Thank you Dylan for your contribution and sharing our history, the experience of bi-racial Native people (I am also mixed indigenous) and for the vision going forward. I felt such a good feeling in the way you spoke about truth in history and balance in respecting contributions from the many communities that make up the U.S. Thank you ABC for the coverage, I look forward to more next and coming years, there are so many important contributions from Native people and educating the public on history is enriching for everyone.
Why does celebrating native Americans have to take away from Italian heritage. I am all for a holiday celebrating Native Americans, but not at the cost of robing Italian Americans of their holiday. That’s not right.👎🏿
Message this spiritual man,he has all solution you want to any problem, and his work is done in two to three days, no matter what the problem is I assure you friend, trust me,he will definitely he you out
I am bi racial and in my grandmother's time she was a half breed. Yaqui Native Americans and English; my paternal grandmother's side. Natives on maternal side are San Gabriellano and Chumash/English. Our family is buried in the first rows at the mission in California. 🙏🌈
Rediscovering something that has already been discovered by someone else then telling people you are the first to discover it even though people were already here before you got here🧐
@@WillmobilePlus That’s actually incorrect many Indians had connections to the Polynesians and had boats that could sustain long voyages although they never chose to use their boats.
Hmm.. maybe I'm not as smart you. Can you fill me in on your Dugcun joke? I'm sure it's hilarious. I was actually hoping to get a reply on my other comment from you. Hopefully this is not your best material.
@@pbp1701 Indigenous Native Americans ONLY... Sorry guy... Maybe sometime in the near future People like you will get together and get a (Indigenous Peoples from Somewhere Day) Just not on this day...
@ibreak4pie oh okay so would you be interested in celebrating this day with us? By us I mean the rest of the Americans who work hard and Pau taxes and don't get special treatment. We read about ya in history as well as other countries who lost wars and lost there land. You said your fought for the country guess what you was probably fight some indigenous people somewhere else that will get no special day lol. Being an American allows us to at least think we are free. Any word put in front of American detracts from it and make you less. Alaska is probably the most free place you can be. Maybe Alaskan American people are the only ones better than us so they can just say comments that don't have any actual purpose geared towards the topic.
Okay, ABC seems to be taking this personally. Absolutely no one is trying to eradicate your culture, like what was done (and continues to be done) to us, Indigenous people in the "Americas". Check your bias and realize that Indigenous people have been here since time immemorial, and our perspective is valid and intertwined with the natural aspects of this earth. Our Indigenous ancestors fought with everything they had for our existence in the wake of settler colonialism and forced assimilation. Celebrating Columbus in any form essentially honors violence, genocide and greed. The accounts of this are not only documented but can be physically seen all around us... One should not place any cultural significance/ties to his livelihood, as I am positive that there are thousands of inspiring, good-hearted Italians to commemorate and embody. This one BAD MAN is not it and should not be the face or representative for whole generations of Italian Americans, especially considering he did not even step foot in the USA EVER- he was lost af and ended up in the Carribean... Shortly after his arrival, he set the tone for the next hundreds of years, grandfathering the slave trade, the extraction of precious resources, and the dehumanization others. It's baffling how hard-pressed modern non-Indigenous people are on idealizing his actions. Be proud of who you are but not at the expense of Indigenous folx or this land.
Aug-3-1492 Columbus left Spain. He was sailing with 3 ships ( Santa Maria, Pinta, and Nina ) He was supported by Spain Monarchy. After 36 days, on Oct-12-1492, he set foot on the island of Bahamas. Claiming it for Spain. He encountered Natives people. He went by / passed by, but he did not landing in this land ( today we call USA ). Columbus continued his journey. He completed 4 voyages across the Atlantic Ocean, that opened the NEW WORLD of AMERICAS. Today, We know N. America ( 3 countries ) Central America ( 7 countries ) S. America ( 10 countries ) and the Caribbean ( 13 countries )
@k Maybe you misunderstand me and it's my fault. I understand Indigenous Day very well and better than most people. Although this is a new holiday initiated by Biden it's actually very ancient and in Germany it's called "Heiliger Vatertag" which in English is Holy Father's Day. It's intended to be celebrated by all Indiens specifically Indiens from the Land of Gods known as Nwords. Therefore it's a day for all indigenies to come together for worship and celebration. Not just meant for Native Americans but Kanakas, Kanakes, Afrikan Amerikans, Mexicans, Dutch Indiens.... All Hindian People known best in North Amerika today as Minorities. It's not Indigenous day if they don't invite all indigenies.
It's tha day we rescued a bunch of disease infested flea bags that in return raped murdered n stole there lands n forced them into reservations tha Hitler n his nazi developed in world war 2 which the native Americans won n yet are still disrespect n systematically murdered everyday MMIW
@@fsg356 I actually know the meaning of this holiday but I'm positive Amerikans don't. 2nd Although Native American fought bravely and made great strides during WWII the war was actually won in Stalingrad Russia by the Black Russian Indiens known as Kanaka "Hawaiians". Yet no one thanks them. 3rd. If you recall the Nazi SS were Indiens known as the Indien Legion. Do think think maybe, just maybe Native Amerikan mucked up when they followed the orders of Amerikan Government as if they wouldn't lie to us AGAIN!!!😳 Native Amerikans Indiens were fighting against other Indiens.
@@ibreak4pie990 Indigenous Day literally is the same as saying Negro Day in three different Indo languages. Negro, Aboriginie, Originie, Nation, Indien, Indiër, Nazi, Communists.... Are the same damn words in different Indo languages
it is not about the disrespect of europeans, it is about the truth. america is two continents, north and south. columbus never set foot on these land masses. his - story tells us columbus discovered america, how is that possible when millions of people were already here? there existed the large cities of the great lakes [chicago]. over 550 nations with cities and towns like the cherokee, seminole, piquot, sioux, pueblo, eroquis and cree. the many states and rivers like arizona, ohio, utah, dakota and tennessee. to the long muddy water, they called mississippi, these are a few of the first peoples names. so what was discovered? *do not forget about the mighty gold empires of the mayan, aztec, incas and olmecs of south america. they had hundreds of pyramids and great walled cities dedicated to the earth, the sun and the moon. history must be truthful and not just his - story alone to gratify injustice.
Did you know Columbus Day was made because the largest lynching in US history was against 11 Italian Americans and it was a way to say sorry? Why not pick another day other than to be spiteful?
@@Mr.White10-65 history, 26 ''indians were lynched in 1831, they were wise men, shamans and chiefs, this action brought about the fort laramie treaty, which in turn displaced and placed ''indians on reservations'. in 1891 the italians were lynched so why say sorry politically and create the big lie of america's discovery which became nationalized in 1937.
@@Mr.White10-65 I agree. The Native Indians were known to be cannibals in numerous tribes including the Seminole and Cherokee tribes. We shouldn't celebrate that. Columbus came to America for good.
Different books and different writers / authors do have different views and different assessments. Including the names " America " and " Americas " Research and Read before you speak. 1 book or 1 writer may not be 100% corrected. Unless, it can be proved with evidences. That is applied to everything else too. Such as history books, history of United States, history of the World, ect...
Hey Biden when you gonna get water and electricity to all the residences on the reservations?? Maybe you should have someone look into that!! What do you think???
Um no that's not Thanksgiving. insunjinious people will not be celebrated, no trying to change history because it's not happening. Thanksgiving is Thanksgiving not insunjinious peoples day.
There were Native Americans that were here by some estimates 25,000 years ago. Then other Native Americans came here around 5,000 years ago and are now native of the same land......doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Pretty much anyone who arrived to America before Europeans were "Natives."
Holy Mother of all preprogrammed to think certain thoughts they heard someone else say bro. Don't just open up with your arguments that don't even apply here and think I'm not gonna call it out. Your like the happy birthday at the funeral mistake someone made when buying cheap rubbers.
If everyone is indigenous then the importance of eliminating Columbus day is futile and undermine all atrocities that were committed to the natives of the Americas...shame
Mr Lawrence Hite is the right person to start trading cryptocurrency with.. he knows he's way around the crypto world.. he has been helping me increase my investment every day for over months..
The crypto market is highly profitable with an expert broker just like Mr Lawrence Hite I got recommended to him and since then my financial life has been a success.
Gee that sounds racist, why do you center and focus on skin pigmentation? Is race a motivating factor in your decision making? (hard to tell if you are satirizing or are a true SJW)
Still eating a 🥧pie Tonite. And I'm On Arapahoe UTE Cheyenne Land from Ohlone and I'm a Choctaw Afro-american. 🗿 Happy Thanksgiving 🌃🩸🥰 CANADA ❣️ relatives. HID and Night 🌃🧘🏾♂️ peace ☮️☮️. Salaam
Historically Columbus has his day. By crossing West and having it recorded he let the way to the European's conquest of the Americas. Indigenous people were technology behind and taken advantage. But also benefit from Europeans, bringing horses , metals, and greed.
They didn’t benefit from invasion if Columbus hadn’t discovered the Americas the natives would have plenty of time to progress in technological progress and a lot of lives would have been spared even the triangle slave trade wouldn’t exist
@@kingofgamez_9695 Without written languages Indigenous would be still behind in Columbus' lifetime. In Europe the printing press came shortly after. Someone was going to discover the Americas, but historically Columbus did. Greed and riches brought everyone over. In those days the strong would strive even in the Americas this was the rule. Slaves had exit in every continent all thru history.
@@richardgomez5008 they had a written language fool though it was not alphabetic and not Spanish there was slaves or indentured servants and besides other civilizations had made contact prior to Europeans such as East Asians and Africans so even if Europeans had not come or had not existed at all the Americas would of been better off given time they would have progressed into making guns cannons gas powered vehicles
Written languages can be read to pass informations to others. That is how progress and technologies are increased. Where are the languages written of the Americas if only in Aztec ruins etc? No the Americas were too far behind to ever catch up. Which tribe's technology was past the European's. Show me their writings! For the printing press has European old books in existence.
@@richardgomez5008 they were advanced in argiculture had a better standard of hygiene knew hydraulic engineering had gold and silver and were not in the stone era as some would believe and they had better and organized societies than europe had even with the aid of the moors that aid southern europe, europe was still packing behind in those areas compared to native Americans. The only reason Europe advanced when it came to high tech weapons is because shared knowledge from africa and asia hence a geographical advantage The only reason the Spanish and Portuguese succeeded in colonizing was due to plague and 2 facing other rival tribes also they tried burning down libraries and other sites when they had one. Although a huge number of pure natives exist and have kept their language and written text to this day
America is on stolen land taken by genocide and built by slavery. America according to Native Peoples is the entire continent from Canada to Argentina.
He thought the Earth was shaped like a pear (hence the reason he had to sail under the Spanish crown -- the Italian monarchy laughed at him for believing he could sail to India by going the opposite direction) and was a genocidal maniac. More than anything, he was a straight-up buffoon. Oh, and Leif Erikson was the first European to discover America. Maybe we should have a Vikings Day instead.
Do indigenous people in the U.S not have more than everyone else? Who is discriminating against them? I thought they could have casinos and free college grants and stuff the rest rest of the people in this country don't get. Isn't everyone indigenous to somewhere? This is an ignorant topic. What did Columbus do by the way? How about we focus on the future and stop celebrating failures like Columbus. He thought he landed in India and call the people Indians lol. We still call them that!!! Not sure why lol
Come with me blind one... I'll show you how to Hunt, Fish, build your own home... "Live" Give a person a fish, you feed them for the day. TEACH a person to fish, you feed them for a lifetime.... True Story...
@ibreak4pie "give a person a fish" Wow, that poetry! Did you think that up on your own? "Blind one" interesting how you copy-paste things you heard somewhere but don't have your own thoughts. Makes since why none of what you said seems like a reply to my comment... lack of thoughts. By the way grasshopper, I caught 8 catfish, 2 red fish, 4 bluegill and have the redskin to show for it. Matter fact I'll probably have 2 coons or possum in my traps by the end of the week. I may be a half breed but your best half ran down your mother's crack
@ibreak4pie also I may have this strange hobby of saying A bunch a true things in comments on videos I know will make people mad. They're true things im saying. I'm only saying this to let you know this "I pity the fools" who just let stuff fall out there face when talking to me.
@@pbp1701 I've noticed, quite entertaining, I would like to invite to Alaska for a Hunting Trip. Be worth it... You go on keep thinking some things are true. In YOUR opinion. You do that, I've fought for this country and one of the reason why I fought is the FREEDOM of Speech. I truly hope you take me up on Hunt... Keep your Pity. I'm a grown ass man, I'm sure your Mom Upstairs/Downstairs will need it...
@ibreak4pie well dang that's awful nice of ya to invite me hunting in Alaska. Not exactly the reply I expected. I do feel that it would be an awkward trip given the circumstances and financially not ideal( daughter just turned 16 and the used car market is ridiculous). It had crossed my mind to visit there but only because ive heard most the land is wild and untamed. I been chasing these white tail, turkey, and coyotes most of my life. I have been Colorado and Illinois for some decent hunts so who knows. I'm a little curious to what about the initial comment you disagree with. I think we are all Americans( not everyone obviously in this comment section and ive had discussed this with natives to Canada)and no body gets special treatment. We live in a country where we can at least claim to be free and I've yet to meet the first person who doesn't have their own obstacles to overcome or set backs in life. Seems like some like to blame others for that and pretend there some special human that need other people to care about them differently than the others. Also I have nothing good to say about Columbus. This whole indigenous vs Columbus is obviously media fuel by the news Channel it was posted by. I'm just hoping to state some thoughts and make people think with there brains instead of there emotions. You know like the freedom you fought for. If you just don't like me that's cool but I'm more less looking for people who disagree with me or this isn't much fun.
The indians also wiped out the first three settlements of colonists along the eastern seaboard. The 4th landing the europeans brought rifles and more men than women. What they discovered was some of the previous settlements, the men were killed, the women were raped, and the kids were taken as slaves to help fight tribes they were at war with. There were 67 indian factions at war and slaughtering one another before the europeans landed. They practiced scalping, raping, slavery and cannibalism. READ A BOOK that was written by any one of those tribes sometime and see for yourself. All the europeans and Spainards did was bring CIVILIZATION to these barbaric/savage people. They were still hunting with spears and bows. Meanwhile the colonists had guns, built cities, build galleys, build concert halls, wrote masterpieces of music, and also learned math and the solar system. Plus before the native americans, the Mayans were in North America first before the indians invaded and wiped them out. And before that the Stegosaurus roamed over 3500 miles and was the first dinosaur. So if anything it should be called Stegosauras/Mayans Day.
Thanks for spitting in the face of every Italian American for creating this "woke holiday" on the same day as Columbus Day. 95% of you don't even know why Columbus Day was REALLY made a holiday!
For the 400th anniversary of Christopher Columbus's voyage in 1892, following a lynching in New Orleans, where a mob had murdered 11 Italian immigrants, President Benjamin Harrison declared Columbus Day as a one-time national celebration. The proclamation was part of a wider effort after the lynching incident to placate Italian Americans and ease diplomatic tensions with Italy. During the anniversary in 1892, teachers, preachers, poets, and politicians used rituals to teach ideals of patriotism. These rituals took themes such as citizenship boundaries, the importance of loyalty to the nation, and the celebration of social progress, included among them was the Pledge of Allegiance by Francis Bellamy.
Have a Good One Ohio, Georgia and all the other Columbusses 🚌 🚉 I was still gonna order a Hot Plate from Lou's Special Italian Rest here in the Gentrified Neighborhood I adjust too daily ☕ 📘🙋🏼♂️💙🤍🩸
Not really a fan of indigenous because of that whold burning people alive thing, then there was the holding black people as slaves thing...torture, the list goes on.
I don’t think you have taken any history classes whatsoever because it sounds like you have no knowledge of what Europeans were doing at the time. Please get more educated so you don’t sound so unintelligent.
duh duh duh ...Its NOT called Columbus Day anymore...... MAINLY because Christopher Columbus never set foot on North American soil in his lifetime... duh duh duh.
I don't really know how to thank Dr odiboh, you're sure and a wonderful spiritualist your work amazes me keep it up once again thanks for bringing back my relationship back to me
I have moved from church to church,harbalist to herbalist no cure,but someone directed me to Dr Samuel,a strong herbalist ,who Later help me free from spiritual spouse and bad forces,,he can help you
There is no such thing as Indigenous Peoples Day! The Indians are actually from Asia. They came during the Ice Age ! They are not native to America either! They came they same way other people came so that doesn’t make them native.
Happy Indigenous Peoples Day!
Happy Columbus Day.
Happy Columbus Day, cucked out liberals!
Happy shutthefuckupthebothofyous day
Yes, Best wishes to all of Americans on this day since we are all indigenous to somewhere.
Thank you Dylan for your contribution and sharing our history, the experience of bi-racial Native people (I am also mixed indigenous) and for the vision going forward. I felt such a good feeling in the way you spoke about truth in history and balance in respecting contributions from the many communities that make up the U.S. Thank you ABC for the coverage, I look forward to more next and coming years, there are so many important contributions from Native people and educating the public on history is enriching for everyone.
Why does celebrating native Americans have to take away from Italian heritage. I am all for a holiday celebrating Native Americans, but not at the cost of robing Italian Americans of their holiday. That’s not right.👎🏿
@@mananimal3644 A holiday dedicated to celebrating a horrible man and colonizer? Oh, okay. Carry on. 🙄
I wonder if we will get a show or movie where Columbus is a bad guy
Message this spiritual man,he has all solution you want to any problem, and his work is done in two to three days, no matter what the problem is I assure you friend, trust me,he will definitely he you out
@New Moon No he was not.
That ship, LOL, has sailed. He and other early settlers took land from Native Americans.
@@emperoraxel um, yes he was.
@@emperoraxel Yea he was he had a child tracking ring he committed mass genocide as well as more fun things. Facts don’t care about your feelings.
Why can't we have "Indigenous month" as well?
YAY!!! It's about time!!!
You heard the man - celebrate, dammit!
I am bi racial and in my grandmother's time she was a half breed. Yaqui Native Americans and English; my paternal grandmother's side. Natives on maternal side are San Gabriellano and Chumash/English. Our family is buried in the first rows at the mission in California. 🙏🌈
In the 70s, the local Stoners smoked Columbian Gold. Today, it's called Indigenous Pyrite
Rediscovering something that has already been discovered by someone else then telling people you are the first to discover it even though people were already here before you got here🧐
So? his voyage established permanent cross-ocean contact. Most Indians could barely sail outside of a river.
@@WillmobilePlus Nothing you said invalidates the comment you’re replying to
TRUTH
@@WillmobilePlus That’s actually incorrect many Indians had connections to the Polynesians and had boats that could sustain long voyages although they never chose to use their boats.
@@chandelier6811 Yeah, ok. They didnt.
Pseudo-history sites that unironically talk about "lost continents" and "ancient aliens" are not sources.
Happy Indigenous Peoples Dayyy!!!
Yes, Best wishes all of Americans on this day since we are all indigenous to somewhere.
@@pbp1701 Sorry Mr. Dungcun, not you... All of us Americans but the Dungcun guy
Hmm.. maybe I'm not as smart you. Can you fill me in on your Dugcun joke? I'm sure it's hilarious. I was actually hoping to get a reply on my other comment from you. Hopefully this is not your best material.
@@pbp1701 Indigenous Native Americans ONLY... Sorry guy... Maybe sometime in the near future People like you will get together and get a (Indigenous Peoples from Somewhere Day)
Just not on this day...
@ibreak4pie oh okay so would you be interested in celebrating this day with us? By us I mean the rest of the Americans who work hard and Pau taxes and don't get special treatment. We read about ya in history as well as other countries who lost wars and lost there land. You said your fought for the country guess what you was probably fight some indigenous people somewhere else that will get no special day lol. Being an American allows us to at least think we are free. Any word put in front of American detracts from it and make you less. Alaska is probably the most free place you can be. Maybe Alaskan American people are the only ones better than us so they can just say comments that don't have any actual purpose geared towards the topic.
Do we?
Everyone is Indigenous somewhere!
Okay, ABC seems to be taking this personally. Absolutely no one is trying to eradicate your culture, like what was done (and continues to be done) to us, Indigenous people in the "Americas". Check your bias and realize that Indigenous people have been here since time immemorial, and our perspective is valid and intertwined with the natural aspects of this earth. Our Indigenous ancestors fought with everything they had for our existence in the wake of settler colonialism and forced assimilation. Celebrating Columbus in any form essentially honors violence, genocide and greed. The accounts of this are not only documented but can be physically seen all around us... One should not place any cultural significance/ties to his livelihood, as I am positive that there are thousands of inspiring, good-hearted Italians to commemorate and embody. This one BAD MAN is not it and should not be the face or representative for whole generations of Italian Americans, especially considering he did not even step foot in the USA EVER- he was lost af and ended up in the Carribean... Shortly after his arrival, he set the tone for the next hundreds of years, grandfathering the slave trade, the extraction of precious resources, and the dehumanization others. It's baffling how hard-pressed modern non-Indigenous people are on idealizing his actions. Be proud of who you are but not at the expense of Indigenous folx or this land.
Aug-3-1492 Columbus left Spain. He was sailing with 3 ships ( Santa Maria, Pinta, and Nina ) He was supported by Spain Monarchy.
After 36 days, on Oct-12-1492, he set foot on the island of Bahamas. Claiming it for Spain. He encountered Natives people.
He went by / passed by, but he did not landing in this land ( today we call USA ).
Columbus continued his journey. He completed 4 voyages across the Atlantic Ocean, that opened the NEW WORLD of AMERICAS.
Today, We know N. America ( 3 countries ) Central America ( 7 countries ) S. America ( 10 countries ) and the Caribbean ( 13 countries )
I celebrate Indigenous Peoples Day & Leif Erikson!
Well put !!!
I love this!
1/5 of the whole Native American population are actual full blood. About one million people.
Someone please explain this day to me in detail because it makes absolutely no sense.
@k Maybe you misunderstand me and it's my fault. I understand Indigenous Day very well and better than most people.
Although this is a new holiday initiated by Biden it's actually very ancient and in Germany it's called "Heiliger Vatertag" which in English is Holy Father's Day.
It's intended to be celebrated by all Indiens specifically Indiens from the Land of Gods known as Nwords.
Therefore it's a day for all indigenies to come together for worship and celebration.
Not just meant for Native Americans but Kanakas, Kanakes, Afrikan Amerikans, Mexicans, Dutch Indiens.... All Hindian People known best in North Amerika today as Minorities.
It's not Indigenous day if they don't invite all indigenies.
It's tha day we rescued a bunch of disease infested flea bags that in return raped murdered n stole there lands n forced them into reservations tha Hitler n his nazi developed in world war 2 which the native Americans won n yet are still disrespect n systematically murdered everyday MMIW
@@fsg356 I actually know the meaning of this holiday but I'm positive Amerikans don't.
2nd Although Native American fought bravely and made great strides during WWII the war was actually won in Stalingrad Russia by the Black Russian Indiens known as Kanaka "Hawaiians". Yet no one thanks them.
3rd. If you recall the Nazi SS were Indiens known as the Indien Legion.
Do think think maybe, just maybe Native Amerikan mucked up when they followed the orders of Amerikan Government as if they wouldn't lie to us AGAIN!!!😳
Native Amerikans Indiens were fighting against other Indiens.
@@lordvonmanor6915 Whut???
@@ibreak4pie990 Indigenous Day literally is the same as saying Negro Day in three different Indo languages.
Negro, Aboriginie, Originie, Nation, Indien, Indiër, Nazi, Communists....
Are the same damn words in different Indo languages
list of all the great contributions made by indigenous people :
Potato, cacao, guano etc.
Survival... "nuff said"
@@rajashashankgutta4334tomatoes, corn, many fish species, the list goes on forever
it is not about the disrespect of europeans, it is about the truth. america is two continents, north and south. columbus never set foot on these land masses. his - story tells us columbus discovered america, how is that possible when millions of people were already here? there existed the large cities of the great lakes [chicago]. over 550 nations with cities and towns like the cherokee, seminole, piquot, sioux, pueblo, eroquis and cree. the many states and rivers like arizona, ohio, utah, dakota and tennessee. to the long muddy water, they called mississippi, these are a few of the first peoples names. so what was discovered? *do not forget about the mighty gold empires of the mayan, aztec, incas and olmecs of south america. they had hundreds of pyramids and great walled cities dedicated to the earth, the sun and the moon. history must be truthful and not just his - story alone to gratify injustice.
Did you know Columbus Day was made because the largest lynching in US history was against 11 Italian Americans and it was a way to say sorry? Why not pick another day other than to be spiteful?
He managed to get on some boats and sail across the wide ocean.
Did any Indian do that? No? Well ok, then!
@@Mr.White10-65 history, 26 ''indians were lynched in 1831, they were wise men, shamans and chiefs, this action brought about the fort laramie treaty, which in turn displaced and placed ''indians on reservations'. in 1891 the italians were lynched so why say sorry politically and create the big lie of america's discovery which became nationalized in 1937.
@@Mr.White10-65 I agree. The Native Indians were known to be cannibals in numerous tribes including the Seminole and Cherokee tribes. We shouldn't celebrate that. Columbus came to America for good.
@@WillmobilePlus yes, the tainos and olmecs sailed the pacific and atlantic, they even sailed to the potomac river. they were sailors not conquers
Wow
poetic snow 86
COLUMBUS is now on the naughty word list.
Make a boomer cartoon make a boomer cartoon
Hard dolphin 29
Calm elk 37
Short hunter 47
Black girl 83
Calm hunter 57
Different books and different writers / authors do have different views and different assessments. Including the names " America " and " Americas "
Research and Read before you speak. 1 book or 1 writer may not be 100% corrected. Unless, it can be proved with evidences.
That is applied to everything else too. Such as history books, history of United States, history of the World, ect...
I dont think i need a book to tell me, (a proud native american) that my family and culture was taken from me.
Hey Biden when you gonna get water and electricity to all the residences on the reservations?? Maybe you should have someone look into that!! What do you think???
Um no that's not Thanksgiving. insunjinious people will not be celebrated, no trying to change history because it's not happening. Thanksgiving is Thanksgiving not insunjinious peoples day.
There were Native Americans that were here by some estimates 25,000 years ago. Then other Native Americans came here around 5,000 years ago and are now native of the same land......doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Pretty much anyone who arrived to America before Europeans were "Natives."
uh, no. it's Columbus day.
Indigenous people's day*
Just as we tell southerners waving their Confederate flags, "You lost the war, get over it," Indigenous people need to hear the same message.
The confederacy lasted 5 years. Lmao no comparison
Holy Mother of all preprogrammed to think certain thoughts they heard someone else say bro. Don't just open up with your arguments that don't even apply here and think I'm not gonna call it out. Your like the happy birthday at the funeral mistake someone made when buying cheap rubbers.
аусбомижд
Thanks for the land
Gotta hold these 🥜 1st
Just as long as you live your life working and spending for the system. Congrats! Have fun voting in November hahaha
If everyone is indigenous then the importance of eliminating Columbus day is futile and undermine all atrocities that were committed to the natives of the Americas...shame
Happy indigenous peoples day 💞💗💕😌
That's a mongol
Despite the economic downturn,I'm so happy☺️. I have been earning $ 60,000 returns from my $7,000 investment every 13days.
Mr Lawrence Hite is the right person to start trading cryptocurrency with.. he knows he's way around the crypto world.. he has been helping me increase my investment every day for over months..
How can I get to him please help?
Please how do I reach out to Mr Lawrence Hite? Am from London
@ariana victoria I also needed he's info too I’ll write him thanks.
The crypto market is highly profitable with an expert broker just like Mr Lawrence Hite I got recommended to him and since then my financial life has been a success.
Christopher Columbus never had a passport!🤣
I'm glad they got the most white guy to report on this makes sense to me
Gee that sounds racist, why do you center and focus on skin pigmentation? Is race a motivating factor in your decision making? (hard to tell if you are satirizing or are a true SJW)
Seismic shift
Still eating a 🥧pie Tonite. And I'm On Arapahoe UTE Cheyenne Land from Ohlone and I'm a Choctaw Afro-american. 🗿 Happy Thanksgiving 🌃🩸🥰 CANADA ❣️ relatives. HID and Night 🌃🧘🏾♂️ peace ☮️☮️. Salaam
May your Ancestors slap the sh!t out of you when you meet them... The ones that fought bravely anyways....
no
It's Columbus Day for normal Americans.
US celebrates Columbus Day.
Who cares lol
you probably lol why are you commenting on a news youtube video as if the reporter will read the comments
Historically Columbus has his day. By crossing West and having it recorded he let the way to the European's conquest of the Americas. Indigenous people were technology behind and taken advantage. But also benefit from Europeans, bringing horses , metals, and greed.
They didn’t benefit from invasion if Columbus hadn’t discovered the Americas the natives would have plenty of time to progress in technological progress and a lot of lives would have been spared even the triangle slave trade wouldn’t exist
@@kingofgamez_9695 Without written languages Indigenous would be still behind in Columbus' lifetime. In Europe the printing press came shortly after. Someone was going to discover the Americas, but historically Columbus did.
Greed and riches brought everyone over. In those days the strong would strive even in the Americas this was the rule. Slaves had exit in every continent all thru history.
@@richardgomez5008 they had a written language fool though it was not alphabetic and not Spanish there was slaves or indentured servants and besides other civilizations had made contact prior to Europeans such as East Asians and Africans so even if Europeans had not come or had not existed at all the Americas would of been better off given time they would have progressed into making guns cannons gas powered vehicles
Written languages can be read to pass informations to others. That is how progress and technologies are increased. Where are the languages written of the Americas if only in Aztec ruins etc? No the Americas were too far behind to ever catch up. Which tribe's technology was past the European's. Show me their writings! For the printing press has European old books in existence.
@@richardgomez5008 they were advanced in argiculture had a better standard of hygiene knew hydraulic engineering had gold and silver and were not in the stone era as some would believe and they had better and organized societies than europe had even with the aid of the moors that aid southern europe, europe was still packing behind in those areas compared to native Americans. The only reason Europe advanced when it came to high tech weapons is because shared knowledge from africa and asia hence a geographical advantage
The only reason the Spanish and Portuguese succeeded in colonizing was due to plague and 2 facing other rival tribes also they tried burning down libraries and other sites when they had one. Although a huge number of pure natives exist and have kept their language and written text to this day
Happy Columbus Day
We celebrated Columbus Day!!
i'm sorry to hear that... choke on that corn while your at it...
I love Indians but it is America day! 😉
America is on stolen land taken by genocide and built by slavery. America according to Native Peoples is the entire continent from Canada to Argentina.
They ain’t Indians
You are too confused about indian people. They are literally called native americans
They should have called it 🎶Take An Indian To Lunch🎶 day. 😉
Is that our native American Indians or those from India?
The "Whoo whoo" ones.
God bless Christopher Columbus!! He was a great man
He was indeed
He thought the Earth was shaped like a pear (hence the reason he had to sail under the Spanish crown -- the Italian monarchy laughed at him for believing he could sail to India by going the opposite direction) and was a genocidal maniac. More than anything, he was a straight-up buffoon. Oh, and Leif Erikson was the first European to discover America. Maybe we should have a Vikings Day instead.
He was a great man he just cut off peoples hand started a child s*x trafficking ring committed mass genocide and more
If you find mass genocide and rape against our ancestors and inslaving them is great to you you need help homie
Did you know him? Or read it in a book that was edited by man.
Do indigenous people in the U.S not have more than everyone else? Who is discriminating against them? I thought they could have casinos and free college grants and stuff the rest rest of the people in this country don't get. Isn't everyone indigenous to somewhere? This is an ignorant topic. What did Columbus do by the way? How about we focus on the future and stop celebrating failures like Columbus. He thought he landed in India and call the people Indians lol. We still call them that!!! Not sure why lol
Come with me blind one... I'll show you how to Hunt, Fish, build your own home... "Live"
Give a person a fish, you feed them for the day.
TEACH a person to fish, you feed them for a lifetime....
True Story...
@ibreak4pie "give a person a fish" Wow, that poetry! Did you think that up on your own? "Blind one" interesting how you copy-paste things you heard somewhere but don't have your own thoughts. Makes since why none of what you said seems like a reply to my comment... lack of thoughts. By the way grasshopper, I caught 8 catfish, 2 red fish, 4 bluegill and have the redskin to show for it. Matter fact I'll probably have 2 coons or possum in my traps by the end of the week. I may be a half breed but your best half ran down your mother's crack
@ibreak4pie also I may have this strange hobby of saying A bunch a true things in comments on videos I know will make people mad. They're true things im saying. I'm only saying this to let you know this "I pity the fools" who just let stuff fall out there face when talking to me.
@@pbp1701 I've noticed, quite entertaining, I would like to invite to Alaska for a Hunting Trip. Be worth it...
You go on keep thinking some things are true. In YOUR opinion. You do that, I've fought for this country and one of the reason why I fought is the FREEDOM of Speech.
I truly hope you take me up on Hunt...
Keep your Pity. I'm a grown ass man, I'm sure your Mom Upstairs/Downstairs will need it...
@ibreak4pie well dang that's awful nice of ya to invite me hunting in Alaska. Not exactly the reply I expected. I do feel that it would be an awkward trip given the circumstances and financially not ideal( daughter just turned 16 and the used car market is ridiculous). It had crossed my mind to visit there but only because ive heard most the land is wild and untamed. I been chasing these white tail, turkey, and coyotes most of my life. I have been Colorado and Illinois for some decent hunts so who knows. I'm a little curious to what about the initial comment you disagree with. I think we are all Americans( not everyone obviously in this comment section and ive had discussed this with natives to Canada)and no body gets special treatment. We live in a country where we can at least claim to be free and I've yet to meet the first person who doesn't have their own obstacles to overcome or set backs in life. Seems like some like to blame others for that and pretend there some special human that need other people to care about them differently than the others. Also I have nothing good to say about Columbus. This whole indigenous vs Columbus is obviously media fuel by the news Channel it was posted by. I'm just hoping to state some thoughts and make people think with there brains instead of there emotions. You know like the freedom you fought for. If you just don't like me that's cool but I'm more less looking for people who disagree with me or this isn't much fun.
Idiot's Day,,,,😂😅🤣
Supposed to be " Native American Grassroots Day "
The indians also wiped out the first three settlements of colonists along the eastern seaboard. The 4th landing the europeans brought rifles and more men than women. What they discovered was some of the previous settlements, the men were killed, the women were raped, and the kids were taken as slaves to help fight tribes they were at war with. There were 67 indian factions at war and slaughtering one another before the europeans landed. They practiced scalping, raping, slavery and cannibalism. READ A BOOK that was written by any one of those tribes sometime and see for yourself. All the europeans and Spainards did was bring CIVILIZATION to these barbaric/savage people. They were still hunting with spears and bows. Meanwhile the colonists had guns, built cities, build galleys, build concert halls, wrote masterpieces of music, and also learned math and the solar system.
Plus before the native americans, the Mayans were in North America first before the indians invaded and wiped them out. And before that the Stegosaurus roamed over 3500 miles and was the first dinosaur. So if anything it should be called Stegosauras/Mayans Day.
Who's celebrating? Idont know any. HAPPY COLUMBUS DAY.
It’s not losers of land day it’s Columbus day
Its Columbus Day!
Dude people barley celebrate it
What's up, fascist?
@Jonny Moon Happy Columbus Day, cucked out liberals!
Happy Columbus Day you savages
Thanks for spitting in the face of every Italian American for creating this "woke holiday" on the same day as Columbus Day. 95% of you don't even know why Columbus Day was REALLY made a holiday!
For the 400th anniversary of Christopher Columbus's voyage in 1892, following a lynching in New Orleans, where a mob had murdered 11 Italian immigrants, President Benjamin Harrison declared Columbus Day as a one-time national celebration. The proclamation was part of a wider effort after the lynching incident to placate Italian Americans and ease diplomatic tensions with Italy. During the anniversary in 1892, teachers, preachers, poets, and politicians used rituals to teach ideals of patriotism. These rituals took themes such as citizenship boundaries, the importance of loyalty to the nation, and the celebration of social progress, included among them was the Pledge of Allegiance by Francis Bellamy.
Have a Good One Ohio, Georgia and all the other Columbusses 🚌 🚉 I was still gonna order a Hot Plate from Lou's Special Italian Rest here in the Gentrified Neighborhood I adjust too daily ☕ 📘🙋🏼♂️💙🤍🩸
Aw, bless your heart.
@@amyreynolds3619 Lame.
As an Italian-American (parents from Sicily), I don’t care. Happy Indigenous Peoples day!
No one is completely and fully indigenous in the USA. Everyone's ancestors came from somewhere else to begin with even Indians.
Can't it be both Columbus day and IP day?
Well not really since we don't really celebrate Columbus day
Never heard of indigenous or whatever it is.
Of course not. The whole point is to displace Columbus Day, after all. They could have chosen any other day for this silliness, but they didn't.
Ehhhh no. Majority of us just stayed home and glad we got the day off work. Dont really care about Columbus or Indigenous day.
You've got to get out and live man... SMH...
COLUMBUS DAY
@Jonny Moon In my defense, The natives commonly had cannibal and voodoo rituals.
@@emperoraxel The voodoo rituals came from the africans, not the native americans...
Whats Indigenous people? Sounds like a forgotten race. How absurd that is?
Today Marks Columbus Day.
Acting like it doesnt wont make it not exist.
Happy Columbus Day.
Not really a fan of indigenous because of that whold burning people alive thing, then there was the holding black people as slaves thing...torture, the list goes on.
Wow you sound really educated.. *checks comment history* oh wait you actually don’t care about black people either.
I don’t think you would be a fan of white people either. You know burning witches at the stake. The whole slavery things.
I don’t think you have taken any history classes whatsoever because it sounds like you have no knowledge of what Europeans were doing at the time. Please get more educated so you don’t sound so unintelligent.
@@chandelier6811 Sorry, but truth hurts.. I know.
It is Columbus Day. GET IT RIGHT
Nope, but maybe in your world... 😁😁
Happy Columbus Day everyone!!
happy columbus day to you too as well
Happy holidays to you and your family. I'm Jewish and don't celebrate Christmas. Hope you aren't offended that I do not say Merry Christmas. #woke
@@amyreynolds3619 Merry Christmas to you 👍👍
Choke on that Corn!!! So i can come piss and sh!t on your grave!!! 😁😁
Let me have my Washington Redskins name & mascot back,,,
I okay the trade mark,,,, then maybe I'll give ur holiday back,
"Stumbled Day",,,🏄
How about, let you go back to where your ancestors came from... Take your Redskins and that Silly Mascot with you...
Happy Columbus day you silly performative virtue signalers
Imagine supporting a genocidal maniac ehh typical conservative political position.
Im Native American. I can tell you honestly it doesn't sound right. Columbus wasnt this horrendous genocidal maniac the way you think he is.
To whom this may offend. Happy Columbus Day!!!!
Always fun to see a proud racist openly admit that they are also stupid :D
Happy Columbus Day, cucked out liberals!
Happy Columbus Day, Elizabeth Warren.
It's really called columbus day.. 🤯
duh duh duh ...Its NOT called Columbus Day anymore...... MAINLY because Christopher Columbus never set foot on North American soil in his lifetime... duh duh duh.
I don't really know how to thank Dr odiboh, you're sure and a wonderful spiritualist your work amazes me keep it up once again thanks for bringing back my relationship back to me
I have moved from church to church,harbalist to herbalist no cure,but someone directed me to Dr Samuel,a strong herbalist ,who Later help me free from spiritual spouse and bad forces,,he can help you
Bahamas is in North America. Buy a globe.
There is no such thing as Indigenous Peoples Day! The Indians are actually from Asia. They came during the Ice Age ! They are not native to America either! They came they same way other people came so that doesn’t make them native.
I mean we all originated from Africa, so by your logic people who are from England aren’t English. They’re actually Africans.
Buuuut, to be technical about it... like your comment...
We've been here 10's of thousands of years before you and your ancestors....
That's a mongol
Happy Columbus Day