Reaction to Our Latest Street Interview in China
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 07. 2024
- ► WHY we make these videos: • 👉 Hope You Get This Me...
► Watch extended version of this video: asianboss.io/programs/reactio...
► Watch our exclusive membership videos for FREE: asianboss.io/yt/123-exclusive...
► Join our exclusive membership for exclusive content and community: asianboss.io/
Follow us on social media:
TikTok ► / asianbossmedia
Instagram ► / asianbossmedia
Facebook ► / asianboss
X ► x.com/asianbossmedia
Want to see more videos like this and stay informed about the latest developments in Asia and local perspectives?
Check out AsianBoss.io for the most authentic insights from Asia that you won't find in mainstream media.
@@thinkabout602 I knew you were an American before I even finished reading your comment 😂
you guys really have to stop obsessing over the minority of your viewers that doubts everything they see. You will never please them. Just do your thing and cater to the actual viewers that enjoy your content...
Yeah feels like beating a dead horse. Please stop feeding the trolls. Nobody here really cares about what anonymous trolls say. Literally everyone online experiences negative comments. I mean this in the nicest way possible
I agree but I still want to watch this.
@@LeachingJack you're misunderstanding what I'm saying. They keep mentioning those that accuse them of fake interviews and they have to stop addressing them...I'm not talking about the actual video reaction....
@@Vendrix86 I disagree, the issue need to be addressed. As the saying goes, if a lie is told a thousand times, it will eventually become the truth.
@@riser7795 they've addressed it multiple times and it still happens. Constantly making these videos is just annoying the fanbase that actually cares. At this point they're prioritizing their detractors over their core audience and this isn't cool.
I notice how the Chinese interviewees preface their answers with "I've never been to the US... I think..." Whereas Westerners simply jump to conclusions and think they know everything about a country they've never visited. The Chinese are more balanced.
Thats how the complacent and egoistical moralists always do. They thing they know better without any experiences, only with what they had heard and read.
Same difference. Maybe just only slightly better in a more self-conscious admission that they're giving an opinion they don't have experience or facts on. Well, others may argue that it's worse that they're consciously choosing to make up something on the spot, than not.
That reflects how propagandized the Americans are . . . jumping to conclusion over a country they'd never been to meaning that they have been heavily brainwashed by their media while it showed us that Chinese still have their own opinions (which is ironic since the west likes to claim that Chinese are brainwashed, which by now the whole world knows is a LIE) and do not jump to conclusion.
The United States has the world's most advanced technology and education, which is very enviable. There is no doubt that from this point of view, the United States is respectable. But he is evil when he orders and destroys the world with arrogance, constantly waging war to achieve his own ends. What I hope is that China and the United States can work together to solve the challenges facing mankind and create a better tomorrow for mankind. However, hope is being destroyed by the U.S. government. They use national power to suppress a Chinese technology company through a series of restrictions and sanctions. Company Huawei, this is immoral, I still hope that the United States can return to the era of openness and tolerance, that's all, from China
It's because of the American mindset that they are the center of the world and the moral authority of the universe. Most Americans have never traveled overseas, much less hold a passport.
Freedom in US? Let's talk about what happened in Gaza freely, please!
In private discussions about the government in China, whether you think the government or a leader thinks they are good or bad is not under anyone's control, and the same on the internet. 20 years ago, on my way home from school, I heard a lot of firecrackers and saw fireworks. I don't understand why. It's just an ordinary workday, not a holiday, and not someone holding a wedding. I only found out when I watched the news at night that a former leader in our city had died, so the citizens were very happy and set off firecrackers and fireworks to celebrate. Almost every Tianjin resident hates him, believing that he has hindered the development of Tianjin.
不光放花，还吃捞面呢
@@amarnasia 是的！
是哪个领导人？
@@arsenaleric1 张立昌，天津有句顺口溜，“张立昌真能干，要把天津干成县”。
把为党服务放在第一位
I live in China for many years and I will tell you on the overall they are very levelheaded people. Very very rarely did I ever hear people in China go on a ridden tirade against the United States or any country. They usually are very calm and decent with their opinions. I miss being over there, but the key to happiness is to appreciate where you are in the present.
....which is the direct opposite of what Eurocentric Americans will say.
Well, actually you can curse Xi in front of your family or friends, but don't do it in public. If you do it in public and draw a lot of attention, the worst case is that you may be put behind the bars for a couple of days, and that's it. Fun fact: If you curse the king of Thailand in his country, you may face worse concequence.
I agree. I think criticizing individual leaders including Xi is totally okay, however the redline lays on the party. If you would ask me, the party is like the Jews in the west. If that makes sense
@@ramenfit5983the “party” is just the national government. If you want to call them names, in China you need an actual grievance.
If you don’t have a grievance, then it makes no sense to “criticise.”
@@canto_v12 exactly
About chairman Xi，I recognize he is a strong powerful leader，but this is a kind of personal prestige power. I mean not every chairman has his power, and the reason why he has strong power is he can get most of the party members' support, thus he can control the National People's Congress
As for why Xi enjoys a lot of support, it is because he has beaten other opponents in the political competition. You see, China lacks a tradition of political compromise. The Chinese believe in winning the king and losing the enemy. The strong are respected. So the actual power of each Chairman is different, depending on the extent to which he or she has the support of the party.
Steve, you should evolve from street interviews and do discussion forums to make for a more intimate and genuine conversations about contemporary issues facing Asia and Asian people.
I 100% agree. However, I think that the street interviews get more clicks than reports on more critical issues. I’m assuming the clicks are an important factor to generate some sort of revenue stream. Therefore, we get a mix of trivial “what is considered tall” videos with serious issues such as aging/declining population.
AB is definitely missing out on major topics such as NK/Russia alliance, Philippine/China, etc.
I often say jokingly, that the average Indian taxi driver, or the average Chinese guy tinkering with used electronics for a living, is better politically versed than any top diplomat from the imperial core. Of course it's hyperbole, but every joke has some truth to it ;)
Chinese taxi drivers are like this too lol
Talk to taxi drivers in Beijing and see what you find😂
I think Chinese people have an Kantian(Immanuel Kant) understanding of freedom and inalienable rights of being human, which I believe is the right path for China moving forward. According to Immanuel Kant, real freedom is not just do whatever you like with no interference from others. Real freedom is not to be enslaved by your lust, impulse and self-indulgent. And your pursuit this Kantian version of freedom with social manners, your own sense of morality, justice and humanity.
It's very much in line with Confucian values which place manners as an important "ritual" to maintain for social harmony
Indeed, I am Chinese, and this is what I think. I think freedom has a price, and freedom should also have limits. There should not be unlimited freedom.
Bruh those kids were more articulate and politically versed than like 98% of Americans 😂😂😂😂
Good job on the China interviews and very interesting to hear this little behind-the-scene about it!
Thank you for such informative content Asian Boss.
Thanks for your work.
Do one in Shnaghai, another in Beijing, then Guangzhou, Hong Kong, Xin Jiang and rural. Then a collective video. People love to watch this.
"Only your hatred can destroy me"--Darth Vader, the guy who was defeated by love alone
China is a socialist country, not a communist country. Communism requires great material enrichment and a huge increase in productivity, and the current conditions are not yet mature.
China is a communist country like russia, vietnam, cuba etc. Its principles are based with the description of the flag/banner of sickle/hammer. Its made bad by capitalist countries with their agendas. Today's China is more ebullient with its following trend and living.
Dude, communism cannot be realized if it is not global and that means abolishment of the governments and the monetary system and it requires to declare all earth resources common heritage for all humanity and btw good luck convincing all countries to do that.
We will go extinct in the next 100 years so good luck and if you ask what my credentials are, I am declaring myself a universalist I have knowledge from about at least 10 scientific domains.
Matter of fact, China is the biggest capitalist country under the disguise of communism or the so called “Chinese characteristics”😂
@@yongzhu8454 China is a communist country with its principles. The sickle and hammer flag/banner depicts its system of idealogy. In recent years it has become more ebullient in trend and living.
china is NATIONAL socialist, they get their theory from karl Schmitt and gregor strasser, not karl marx or lenin
In fact, many people don't know that China really has an election system.
China's election system starts with the lowest level of institutions, that is, the so-called neighborhood committee leaders or village heads in rural areas. This election is the voting right that ordinary citizens can use. This is the first level of election.
Then, these people who are elected from the first level will be called representatives (you can understand them as city councilors) and are eligible to enter the city-level parliament (AKA City People's Congress), that is, they have the right to vote and elect. From this time on, the right of ordinary citizens to vote is used by these people.
The city-level parliament elects the provincial parliament, the provincial parliament elects the National People's Congress, and finally, the National People's Congress elects various important national positions. This is the election process stipulated in the Constitution of the People's Republic of China.
However, the difference between this election and the Western election is that you cannot conduct election speeches or raise funds. This is the general process and method of China's election.
At the same time, although China is a one-party dictatorship, you must understand a fact, that is, even the so-called one party actually has many factions. These factions also have their own power and interests, and the positions of the President and the General Secretary of the Party are actually the result of discussions and compromises among the factions. There is an institution called the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, which is the core of the entire Chinese leadership.
So, in fact, from a certain perspective, China and the United States are essentially the same. In the United States, you seem to be able to choose between two parties, but in fact, the basic national policies of the United States implemented by these two parties are similar, and there may be some differences in the details. In China, one party implements China's national policies, and then handles the details within the party.
我笑了，你何必呢
@@doflamingodonquixote4740 这就是咱们的政治制度，没啥可笑的。任何政治制度都是有长处有短处的，而在达成共产主义之前，所有的政治制度都只是一种表象，内核都是差不多的。我说的共产主义是资本论里生产力已经达到一定高度，从而形成的分配模式，而不是西方人谈虎色变的阉割版共产主义。全世界国家的管理模式，都是一群精英去制订规则，然后一群人就跟着这个规则去做。西方所谓的选举，从某种意义上来说也是只能影响到他们村里的福利怎么分配，可是到全国性的金融政策、军事政策、外交政策这一块，你觉得普通选民有能力去改变么？
@@horaceleung8646 兄弟，玩政治的都是流氓，他们背后都是资本，资本国家是，共产国家也是，什么狗屁民主都是在利益主导下的粉饰，我们看到的这些所有的信息、采访都是为了洗脑罢了，目的让我们相信这个世界还有正义可言，给我们画一个美好蓝图，然后努力为这些资本工作，仅此而已
You guys are so cool to explain these questions to end the arguments. And I like your open mind without any bias. Good job!
Respect for seemingly pushing minimal personal or political agendas through your street interview and instead just trying to present the people's voices as honestly as possible.
This is a great reminder of how little we know about what it takes to do another person’s job. I assumed you literally stood on the street and stopped people as they walked by to ask if they would answer a few questions. Clearly not! Thank you for all your hard work. Your videos are always interesting and informative.
Policy is discussed by the collective wisdom, and to speak ill of a person alone is to make rumors. You can say that you have done a bad job, and you can go to the government email address to raise your opinions. Simply complaining on the Internet will not solve the problem
The funny thing is, despite you conducting the interviews in Shanghai, which is the most libbed up city (i.e. most perceptible to being "pro-west") the furthest right interviewees are still further to the left than the furthest left option in any place in the west.
I'm totally unsatisfied with the answer to the question "why Shanghai and not another area?" It could have been any provincial capital, even Nanjing or Hangzhou would have been more representative. As diverse as Shanghai is, there's a reason why people come to Shanghai and why they stay there, which influences their mentality and way of thinking.
Counterfeit representation in government is all the rage these days. Also, that globe in the background looks awesome.
It was a great interview！I think the interviewees represent the majority of Chinese people, in terms of sino-us relations and freedom of speech. from Hangzhou.
Meh, this is just a talk about superficial trends, issues and societal prestige. Merely skin deep, not even an actual discussion. Brushing on surface topics will not help understand the roots.
That feeling when you realize you didn't get the full video but was getting into it....😕
I think your videos are invaluable and extremely important for an entire generation.
Classifying China as developing country is just a technical term. Speaking from a SEA perspective, at the GDP level this is valid but the industry and scientific capabilities would China at the top 2 position in the world as advanced developed nations.
If only it was just a technical term. China still enjoys preferential treatments by many countries due to its status as developing country. Go more rural and you'll see why it has that status. It certainly isn't undeserved. And that's the way the CCP likes it they like to have their own cake and eat it too. They'll keep milking their developing status as long as possible having poor people actually just benefits the CCP
So they should stop getting preferential treatment like poor countries do.
@@EbuzzNYC the usa gets the most preferential treatment due to their hold on the dollar, they are the only country that is able to generate wealth from nothing by stealing from the rest of the world through inflation
@@EbuzzNYC This preferential treatment from the US is long gone and replaced by punitive treatment since Trump. The US has long since treat China as an adversary. Even the EU has gone the other way, the only thing preventing more negative policies is reciprocal policies by China.
@@olderchin1558 The reason is China doesn't have a FREE market economy but wants to take advantage of countries that are open with cheap government subsidized goods below market value to overtake the local U.S. business. America needs to protect their own economy unless they want garbage IP theft copy products to overtake the market!
Yeah, you can talk about the general situations, but cannot be specific, it's reasonalble because the specific ones needs to be proved, fair enough.
if you interview u.s public, they won't even know general situations are
Nowadays people's brains can't differentiate real news and tabloid news. 😅
要想谈论中国的事情，至少找个了解中国的人来聊吧。。找个对中国体制和政治制度一无所知的ABC在这侃侃而谈！有啥意义呢？你们这个组织收中国政府的钱是不可能的，我看收美国NGO的钱还差不多
男主持一直引导女的去认为习是独裁领导！
China is the bright light of humanity. Best of wishes.
I always thought chinese was against america. but the common folk totally gave me a different perspective.
They cherry picked.
I hate US, as an engineer in the PV industry. The US affects my salary
中国普通人基本上都是喜欢美国，只是中国还有9000万共产党员，他们才是美国的反对者。😂
@@MaximSupernov Seems like you are cherry picking to confirm your bias. Your hate for China is apparent in your comments on this channel. I wish you well. Hating on me or my countrymen won't make your life better. Hope you find love and success.
@antihypocrisy8978 My opinion was only that the answers were cherry-picked. Did I say I hate China or Chinese? Do you have a victim mindset? 🤣
It doesn't matter what your system of government is - east or west. One man transgresses, entire nation gets knocked down. And he has transgressed.
Thanks for keeping us updated! I feel sympathy
and empathy for our country. low income people
are suffering to survive, and I appreciate Deborah.
You've helped my family with your advice. imagine
investing $30,000 and receiving $95,460 after 28
days of trading.
I began investing in stocks and Def earlier
this year, and it is the best choice l've ever
made. My portfolio is rounding up to almost
a million, and I have realized that when a
stock makes it to the news. Chances are
you're quite late to the party, the idea is to
get in early on blue chips before it becomes
public. There are lots of life changing
opportunities in the market, and maximize
it.
What opportunities are there in the market,
and how do 1 profit from it?
You can make a lot of money from the
market regardless of whether it strengthens
or crashes. The key is to be well positioned.
I would really like to know how this actually
works.
All you need is a good capital, and the
service of a professional broker, with those
your investment will most certainly produce
high yields.
I love that the Chinese can criticize their government as freely as they want to while having that boundary which is to NOT malign any leader. What a great way to train their citizens on how to be rational and objective. How I wish it is like that in my country. Here, most people are quick to call our leaders bad names, direspecting them even to the point of posting fake news about them. And it obviously has a negative impact not just to the leaders but to our society as well. It shows more of the people's priorities in a way that the majority can't even post a valid complaint about their local government unit because they simply don't care other than tearing the politicians they hate.
which country?
Criticise my ass. Show me who can criticise Xi publicly. Show me who can criticise the Chinese government and the communist party online without consequences. Yes, they are free to criticise America, Japan, and Europe.
@@changliu8430Philippines
Then you should go live in China.
In many Asian families, try say something bad about your father anywhere you please and guess what it would happen to you… either your mom would immediately do something (bad) to you or your dad would destroy your face, literally, because you make him look bad ;) ya know. It is just the way it is
you're born and live with your family name not about yourself..
11:00 This is the most interesting thing in this video.
it's sad that most people don't know there aren't any true communist countries in the world.
@@Vendrix86 China is a socialist country, not a communist country. Communism requires great material enrichment and a huge increase in productivity, and the current conditions are not yet mature.
@@yongzhu8454 go tell him that, not me. I didn't need this video to know that.
@@yongzhu8454China is a communist country, just like russia, vietnam, cuba and others. Its principles are based with the description on its flag/banner of the sickle/hammer. But today's China is more ebullient following the current trend and living. But then again communism is just like any system, only painted bad by the capitalists countries, which have its agenda.
Yes, complete nonsense from her, that's not democratic, to suggest that Xi Jinping is not a dictator is preposterous, he often gets no votes against him like when he decided to run for a 3rd term.
"The endorsement of Xi’s appointment by the ceremonial National People’s Congress was a foregone conclusion for a leader who has sidelined potential rivals and filled the top ranks of the ruling Communist Party with his supporters since taking power in 2012.
The vote for Xi was 2,952 to 0 by the NPC, members of which are appointed by the ruling party.
Xi, 69, had himself named to a third five-year term as party general secretary in October, breaking with a tradition under which Chinese leaders handed over power once a decade"
This was given in Shanghai,not quite a common place. You might like to try to give the interview in different places like towns, counties, where the majority of Chinese people live, to have a more common and typical feedback of those questions, after all, the samples here were far away from enough.
But that's not super productive is it. If you went to the American or Italian countryside and asked people for their opinions, it would also be conservative and uneducated
The outcome won't differ much from Shanghai, for Chinese are all connected to same domestic social platforms where same values/views are shared. Yes, we Chinese are already heavily tech bonded... Feels quite like black mirror... I don't have cash, wallet, any kinds of keys (fingerprint for door, bluetooth phone for EV) for years now...And I am in Zhejiang.
Tell me why Sherry is working at Asianboss without visa?
5:10 Comment on "leaders" or any other persons are bound to become biased and personal. Those are good for jokes and chit/chat in private, but lead to nowhere in open discussion.
Chinese are more practical and want to focus on facts, and make suggestions that can hopefully help to solve some issues or improve the situation.
I believe this is more an "eastern" way of communication vs "western" culture.
What a way to gaslight people for expressing their opinions in the market of ideas.
Simple question you will know:
How do you think the historian in the future depicts the China history for the past 40years?
Levee your answer below.
How about people and countries stop comparing themselves to each other.. it doesn't always have to be a competition..
I would say China has the closest regime to the Geniocracy which is likely the most effective ruling system possible to create
Not sure what is this video about?
Good knowledge drop. The only way to learn something different is to open your eyes, ears, and mind
Its actually true you can criticize the chinese govt and the chinese has a lot of freedom compared to how Americans think
Sherry can speak Korean. She has a CZcams channel too
people's minds are so warped by mainstream, when they see a different opinion they think it must be a paid actor (not that it doesn't exist) - they just can't wrap their minds around non-group think
There's a simple explaination for the majority of the representatives won't vote no: those topics ready for a vote are widely discussed and concluded. For controversial topics, they just won't get the chance for a vote. It's more like collective signing by voting.
nonsense, a democracy is having an open forum to discuss.
@@EbuzzNYC When did I mention the term democracy?
@@EbuzzNYC China is not democracy, and the female staff in the video in no way meant to convey that idea. What she was referring to was the fact that it's not a dictatorship (although it is a form of dictatorship as Steve mentioned in practicality as there is really no opposition to Xi).
this is a GREAT interview and approach you guys are doing. But the female guest here was not quite familiar with the Chinese political system as far as I could tell. And it actually brought out an interesting fact that her being a Chinese can not have a good understanding of how Chinese politics work, imagine ppl from out side of China criticizing it.
give you some hot topics. How do chinese children think of US? How do Chinese rural people think of ccp? How do Chinese think of the future of china? ... 100% hot topics.
vpn is not broadly used in china, but many chinese self-medias transport western information for chinese viewers, so it's quite easy for chinese to know western opinions. But very few westerners transport information on chinese websites for westerners. Firewall instead does cause a information gap to westerners.
do some interviews in north korea
Why? What a waste of resources and time.
你的这几个问题对普通中国人来说根本 就不是问题。中国孩子更关心学习，兴趣班（例如钢琴，足球，篮球）。普通中国 人也只关心工作，挣钱，你不问关于CCP的问题，他们从来不会主动想到CCP，只会想到居住地的政府，CCP只是执政党而已. 普通中国人很少 关心中国的未来，只关心自己的未来。 这大概就是大部分中国人的看法。
Can we talk about Gaza in the US? Can we not smell marijuana all the time in the street? Can tiktok not be banned?
Misinformation only hurts the misinformed group !!!!!
Allow blurred faces.
Great and very common sense people in China!
Sherry is so cute!!!
Once one knows that all is propaganda, one should change their views....
They are obsessed with US.
美国科技发达😂 这俩孩子还真是没去过美国😂 美国老百姓都他吗生活在90年代，而中国的应用科技满街都是😂
前沿科技确实发达！
中国满街有什么科技？手机支付吗？那也算科技？
@@zhangsian519 高铁，基建用了很多专利技术，马上开通20个主要城市的无人驾驶限制。当然主要落后的是芯片行业，AI，也是因为芯片行业的制裁受阻，还有很多行业的科技还没有给你看到，
@@zhangsian519 手機支付與美國購物相比根本不算什麼。美國人甚至不用付錢購物。
@@Self-funded50Cents 中国有钱买科技但是始终没法研发出来高科技，离美国高科技还有很长时间。chatgpt是个好例子，咱们国内版大不如chatgpt
I haven't seen many street interview reactions. Great job. I think I definitely prefer your sit down discussion/ interview videos. Like when you helped the Korean grandma renovate her house, the North Korean detector video, and the single dad adopting the boys videos are some notable ones . I hope you can do more interviews like that. I liked learning unique things about people. I'd definitely be interested in female soldiers, ex- convicts. Even a few catch up cases to see how some people are doing now would be great . I know I'd love to hear more about people who get deported back to their country after spending so much/majority of their life abroad. Just a few interesting topics I'd be interested in watching.
Asian Boss does not address any topic regarding the genocide in Gaza. It is a pity that you remain oblivious to this problem. What do Asians think about that?
China is a socialist country, not a communist country.
😅S'pore also a socialist country, but wrap with "democracy" .
We dont care what 🪱🦂🦗🐞🐍🪲🐜🐛🦋🐌🐈🐉🐖🐇🐵🐸 eaters say 😂😂😂
well, clearly those people interviewed in the video have a way better understanding of China than these two...
Thanks for the answer here. 2:50
😆Just tell us your real agenda
Are Chinese fearful that the government will harrass them over answers they may provide in interviews?
NO
in general, only if you are on government payroll, but that happens in any other country. You could lose your job by criticizing where you work publicly. Common sense. The fear is actually not towards the CCP government. More fear about taking an interview from foreign media, because a lot of well known foreign media will twist or cut what you said to meet their propaganda, and that was not what you meant at all. You could be a target because whoever saw that interview would think that was what you said. Suprise ah?
@@sibaraku2023 Interesting. I would not want to speak to many news outlets in the USA myself for the same reason, and I am American. I would be OK with Fox because I am conservative, though. CNN and MSNBC are the worst networks. Associated Press (AP) is bad too. And ABC, NBC, CBS and PBS are not much better.
Nope, unless you are spreading disinformation and telling fake stories.
the answer probably is what u think ~ even I type here
China is the future 🇨🇳☝️
I think some people tend to write long comments because they want to express their thoughts and opinions in detail. However, it’s also perfectly fine to keep your comments short and simple, like saying “wow, amazing!” or “wow, nice!” and giving it a like. I understand that typing long comments can be tiring and time-consuming. It’s better to share our thoughts on other posts or statuses as well, so we can give everyone a fair amount of attention. That’s why it’s okay to keep your comments brief too, because there are many other posts that you might find interesting and entertaining, and you can like and comment on those as well. It would be a waste of time if you spend too much time typing long comments. You might not have enough time to take care of household chores like cleaning or washing dishes because your time is being wasted. So my advice to you is to keep your comments short to save time. Just like me, I prefer to keep my comments concise.
oh, playing ads in reactions and not in the street interview. Smart!
Hmm所以她是美国人公民还是中国公民?不知道装傻还是真不知道，朝鲜和中国怎么不一样嘛😂中国只是有钱的朝鲜而已，我不信她在中国见过朝鲜人，这句话，真见了的话很可能在韩国见的吧，不然怎么能大胆地说金正恩是独裁者呢? 哎无聊，在这个视频里唯一欣赏点就是她的语言能力好，中英韩都会。
Bravo! 🎉 Oh I went back and watched the actual interviews on another video, pretty interesting!
- Explain what is noted as “communist” versus “dictatorship” comment on this video.
-Americans are shown that the Republic of China government is silenced the average citizens. Chinese people are not allowed to talk freely, do you feel this the case??
You can watch the full street interview in another video, it is up on their channel.
1. Among the basic concepts of communism you cannot have a dictator no more than you can have one in a democracy. It goes against the ideals. With or without a dictator like Xi, the fact that China's economy is very capitalist disqualifies it right from the beginning as a true communist country anyway.
2. As she alluded to in the video, just on certain topics. It's not like us Americans can freely speak about ANYTHING and EVERYTHING. I hope you didn't miss the ruling on what is considered "anti-semitism" a few months ago. We are no better than China on many areas.
@@Vendrix86 i think the main difference is that the American government cant persecute you for the stuff you said cuz of freedom of speech but the Chinese government can if you say something they don't like. The fact that there is fear that the government can do something to you for the things you said in of itself is very scary. In that regard, American are really the freest since the government cant touch them for anything they say. Now, i see the government moving more into facist-like for a lack of better word as many people think, but nowhere serious but maybe I'm not that informed.
Just want to clarify that the Republic of China (ROC) is the government currently ruling Taiwan. And the government ruling the mainland China is called the People's Republic of China (PRC). Both claim to be the real governor of China (both mainland and Taiwan, at least by law), but now PRC is mostly recognized internationally as the legitimate Chinese government.
@@Vendrix86anything and everything? Tell that to Snowden who only spoke the truth and got banned from ever coming back to the US or else he gets jailed
Based on this conversation I have a feeling both of you understand little about China nor have an accurate present view. It feels like an outdated view of China 15 years ago.
Why mention rural area if not Shanghai or Beijing as if everything else are rural beside them. Shenzhen, the most technologically advanced city in the World. Guangzhou, Chengdu such an amazing laid back vibed city with its citizens living a more leisurely, Chongqing the largest populated city with insane infrastructure, Hangzhou the most beautiful scenic views I have seen, to name a few all are amazing top tier cities.
China for a while now is both the no. 1 developed country, plus it still is continuing being the no. 1 developing country.
There is no country that is able to catch up at present.
The US is in decay for a while now and they are doing little about it. I hear nothing about how the situation is in the US, for fair comparison you should done a recent street interview in the US and ask random citizens (plus the homeless in CA) what they think about living in the US what they think about their government. If you would have combined this for analysis and review that would have been interesting.
need to fulfill the agenda 😆
WOW, you couldn’t find 1 real Chinese people to talk about Chinese issues?
U obviously don’t know what real Chinese people are😂
@@lwmtx6156 PLEASE enlighten me!
china is a developing country
这个女的一点都不了解中国政治体制
You guys did have 'planned actors' in some episodes not to manipulate or influence the audiences but to represent different opinions. in one of Taiwanese interview, I am for sure there is at least one planned actors in there because I know who they are and they are controversial and active on the Taiwanese social media. But still keep up the good works
If the guy happens to randomly show up, it's not planned. There's always one guy who thinks everything is rigged.
I asume you are talking about Sean Li. He did got accused, but he explained in his facebook group and I believed it was not what you think.
@@JonathonLi Sean is an honest guy, i
believeb him
@@JonathonLi I am not sure the name of the guy but I watched quite a few his video. he is on the pro-China side. If its Sean Li, then its him. I did not dig deep enough for this matter.
@@kalekainxx I dont think he randomly get interviewed about Chinese government in Taiwan since hes quite famous and open about supporting China in Taiwan. thats why I said "not manipulate, but present different view"
Ok sorry but this video isn't helping to add any credibility to the original video. Especially in regards to voting in China. Take the Hong Kong security law for example the vote ended up (2878 in favour -1 against - 6 abstained). Yes it's not North Korea but with results like this you might as well not vote at all. It's hard to take those results seriously. These type of votes say a lot about freedom of speech as well yes you can talk as much as you want as long as it's what the government likes to hear. Yes you can criticise the government as long the overall criticism is skewed more to other countries being worse. They like to create an illusion to give the idea that there's some sense of freedom but sorry Asian boss you have dig a little bit deeper here if you honestly think that's all there is to it.
Also let's be real you can't expect to put people in front of a camera and expect genuine answers that are against the government that might get them into trouble. Ask them about the lying flat movement, three child policy, evergrande scandals, treatment of minorities. The interviewer as well as the interviewees would put themselves in hot water that no one wants to be in. I would say at this point at it's almost decency to not ask the people those type of hard questions but at the same time it's not really giving you a honest take when certain topics are better left undiscussed....
So Hong kong should not have a security law but you in the west all have security laws ? Hypocrite much 😂
You are hating so much on China that you think chinese people can’t give a real and free answer lmao 😂 Dude in case you don’t know China is not the bad guy but you from the west with your enless list of lies, wars and resources thieveries 😂😂😂
@@ploplmao2655 I never said anything about Hong Kong shouldn't have a NSL I nearly remarked on the vote results
Couple more, CCP gaining more control:
China's parliament on Monday revised a law to effectively grant the Communist Party more executive control over China's cabinet, the State Council, after cancelling the premier's post-parliament news conference for the first time in three decades.
The amended State Council Organic Law passed by 2,883 delegate votes, with eight opposing and nine abstaining, during the closing day of the National People's Congress in Beijing.
Xi gaining a 3rd term:
The vote for Xi was 2,952 to 0 by the NPC, members of which are appointed by the ruling party.
I'm not hating on anything these are the simple facts. If that sounds like freedom to you then enjoy it all you like. The list of these type of "democratic" votes can go ond and on....
@@bgk84 So when humanity is gone and killing and committing genocide is ok, do you really think democratic mean anything at all? When the whole western world thinks that committing war crimes and genocide is ok, is democracy really important now when your life is worthless in their eyes?
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
2个主持是韩国人？很多事情采访嘴上说跟行动是不一样，比如汽车，10年前很多中国人都会买韩国车，比较现在韩国车在中国的销量，就是行动说明一切
They don’t sound like Korean to me
Sounds like Americans
女的谈话内容明显是中国人啊, 比如08:27
"Most Asian people are camera shy".
Indians: Am I a joke to you?
Brother, we are not Asians, we are Indians, just as the people of the Middle East are called Arabs, similarly the people living in the Indian subcontinent are called Indians. but not asian🌏
I thought Indians were Asians
@@vikas-Chauhan-c7p That's dumb. We are Asians. Maybe you are a Native American Indian or something. Lol. Also there are ethnic groups other than Arabs in the Middle East/ West Asia like Kurds, Persians, Jews, Assyrians, Armenians etc.
@@vikas-Chauhan-c7p That's dumb. We are Asians. Maybe you are an Native American aka Red Indian or something. Lol. Also there are ethnic groups other than Arabs in the Middle East/ West Asia like Kurds, Persians, Jews, Assyrians, Armenians etc.
@@vikas-Chauhan-c7p That's dumb. We are Asians. Maybe you are an Native American aka Red Indian or something. Lol. Also there are ethnic groups other than Arabs in the Middle East/ West Asia like Kurds, Persians, Jews, Assyrians, Armenians etc.
why no reaction about those Zombies all over the street in america ???!
| Like Zombie City on Kensington Ave Philadelphia |
' What happened to this Neighborhood? '
' I've never seen anything like it': Inside the center of the tranq drug crisis '
' Streets of Philadelphia, Kensington Ave Documentary, October 25-26 2023 ' - youtube
If they don't want to be on camera in China you should consider blurring their face and voices.
Many don't want to speak out against the anti-west propaganda or be candid and risk the displeasure of their local government official so perhaps you should do more to protect them.
And go to small and rural areas too not just big cities to get more feedback.
Absurd comment. Why should everything be about China be negative or positive.
@banarama4144 I wouldn't say negative or positive, but honest or dishonest.
The culture is about preserving social harmony so people would hold back what they really think.
I thought you were bankrupt 🤔
You have done interviews about Ukraine, is it maybe time to make one about Palestine? 🍉
Tf. A paywall? Bye
The female journalist is spilling truth demystifying lies!
随便找了两个人两个小孩，就能代表中国人了？这个数据样本量真的太小了吧？
那个街头采访视频里找了有七八组人， 老中青幼都有，这个视频只是一个对创作者的采访视频。你搞清楚再说吧
Can we stop with the “China is a developing country” narrative? I’m sure there are poor rural areas, but I’ve been fortunate enough to speak with hundreds of people from all Provences and their quality of life is not worse than America, Canada, Japan etc
Because it is not yet a stable middle-class society, at least there are still hundreds of millions of people whose salaries are not high, and the per capita disposable income is not very much. There are still many industries that are still in the stage of development and exploration, but the fact is that the per capita cannot reach the level of transformation. We We are Chinese, and facts are facts.
@Menion98 Their average salary is less than $15k USD. And their GDP growth rate is still more than double of developed countries. Its considered developing by every economic metric.
On a ppp standpoint, average Chinese people are not living a worse life than the US, that may be true. But since globalization is here, Chinese have to spend more of their income for the same products, like a Honda or iPhone, Chinese is relatively in a weak position.
我知道不能只看人均GDP，但看看中国人的工作时长...，如此高的工作时间然而人均GDP仍然与最穷的发达国家差很多，这可以说没问题，巨大的工作压力是破坏生活质量的非常重要的因素。
@@fruit4423 发展中国家，想跟发达国家比，首先，现在还是在靠加工来赚钱，而不是靠高附加值的产业赚钱，你说是技术值钱还是加工赚钱?其次，我们还在转型阶段，而不是转型成功阶段，那么首先要保证的是高技术人才的培养和留住人才，才能继续做产品迭代和研发，而且有一些也是在摸着石头过河，并不是行行都很赚钱，为什么现在这么着急着要拿下新能源和电动车市场，这就是转型的成果，靠劳动力其实根本就赚不到几个钱，你信不信，很多行业现在已经能做到车间不用工人了？ 制衣，电子，制鞋，等等行业，都可以做到无人产线？比请人便宜得多，那为什么很多行业没有用低成本的模式呢? 因为中国要养的人实在是太多了，必须要有几个超级赚钱得产业，才能实现给底层的人加福利的空间， 现在转型在做的就是这个事情，因为所谓的世界工厂，现阶段还要付很多专利费给西方，所以就导致分配不到这么多钱，高科技人才要留住，产业要升级，底层的福利，你选一个吧，不产业升级，你再也没有机会了。希望你能看懂
Can you please do us a favor..by going to the Philippines to interview the common citizens there about the views on current political heat up because their government has chosen to side up with america to go against China?
So you're ok with having China take your territory? Isn't that what cowards do?
Now the Chinese government vigorously promotes Confucian culture, and my children spend much more time reciting ancient poems than when I was in school. The advantage is that the next generation will be more patriotic and recognize Chinese culture, while the disadvantage is that the Confucian culture, which is based on obedience, is far behind the United States in innovation.
中國古代絕大部分時代用的是儒家思想 我們在古代落後於西方嗎？近些年才這麼短時間，你如何得出這樣的結論？
Chinese have been innovating for 5000 years long before the US existed. Innovation is not a Western concept.
The Chinese citizens are 100% correct in their assessment.
❤❤❤❤
#jinandhattie
Asian Boss, if you haven’t caught on there is not a united Asia. You’ve picked your side. Good luck with that.
so naive, threat and so on...
W
Asian boss hope another interview (Filipino people) in Philippines about tension in south china sea/west Philippine sea,. Interview about Filipinos about going with war in china. Are Filipinos ready? I'm Filipino by the way!
Interesting topic! I'm Chinese and I hope that the frictions can be resolved without a war regardless of whether the two sides feel ready 🙏
@@clara4338 yeah, it's sad. Many of mainstream media fueling the fire about the tensions between two countries, and now Russia,.They're not thinking about solving the problem.
What percentage of viewers think that you are in cahoots with the government, and what percentage think there are actors?
I for sure don't, but I still had some criticism on the previous interview.. no interview is perfect, so you have to accept that you may need to try a few angles.
上海和北京从来决定不了中国的政治😂，你去其他城市采访下看看吧。
1 where are you from? 2 Where do you live? 3 What would those people respond? Greetings from a distance..
Their is dictatorship right
这个ASIAN关于中国的采访，取样都是上海，根本没有代表性。
If you want to, you can donate to help financially support their channel, so they can make more street interviews.
@@OmarPadillaa less pro-west view generally speaking.
Shanghai is the most pro-western city in China.