Israeli Historian Ilan Pappé on Interrogation at U.S. Airport and “Collapse of the Zionist Project”

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 05. 2024
  • Support our work: www.democracynow.org/donate?c...
    We speak with renowned Israeli historian Ilan Pappé about his recent trip to the United States, when he was interrogated for two hours by federal agents upon arrival at Detroit airport about his political views on Gaza, Hamas and Israel, as well as demanding to know whom he knew in U.S. Muslim, Arab and Palestinian communities. Pappé was only allowed to enter the country after agents copied the contents of his phone. “They refused to tell me why they stopped me,” he says. Pappé, author of The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, also discusses the Nakba, growing support for Palestinian rights, and why he believes “the collapse of the Zionist project” is imminent.
    Transcript: www.democracynow.org/2024/5/2...
    Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs on over 1,500 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream at democracynow.org Mondays to Fridays 8-9 a.m. ET.
    Subscribe to our Daily Email Digest: democracynow.org/subscribe

Komentáře • 2,5K

  • @darrak4851
    @darrak4851 Před 10 dny +239

    "When exposing a crime is treated as committing a crime, you are being ruled by criminals.”
    ― Edward Snowden

    • @alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723
      @alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723 Před 7 dny

      Yes but selling yourself out to another dictator is retarded move, your now a gambling chip, as your wife and child

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 7 dny +3

      I'm a Snowden fan. His situation is in no way analogous to either side in the conflict. Just lying about something is not "exposing a crime". Nor is giving your opinion about some action BEING a crime. Sorry for Snowden's name to be used like that.

    • @huwpatt3817
      @huwpatt3817 Před 7 dny +5

      @@ms-jf1iz ur a bit of a confuser

    • @naweedock
      @naweedock Před 7 dny

      Just like David McBride got over a 5yr prison sentence for exposing australian warcrimes in afghanistan, while the war criminal Ben Roberts-Smith has gotten away scot free and is seen as a hero. The west is totally corrupt and America is the leader.

    • @mollymuch2808
      @mollymuch2808 Před 7 dny +5

      Well said

  • @coronato7988
    @coronato7988 Před 12 dny +864

    straightforward police state intimidation, unbelievable…

  • @svemory
    @svemory Před 11 dny +92

    This is terrifying; he's a world-class historian and academic and our government interrogated him like a suspect. Insane.

    • @tiktokviral6218
      @tiktokviral6218 Před 7 dny

      Your don’t have a government it was bought by Israel like the capitalist pro the US is..

    • @mkbijnaam8713
      @mkbijnaam8713 Před 5 dny

      Thats why i dont trust our history or science anymore the goverment strong arms or pays of everyone they want

  • @shameela7975
    @shameela7975 Před 12 dny +158

    Thank you Ilan Pappe for being honest and standing with humanity.

    • @theblackdog2399
      @theblackdog2399 Před 6 dny

      He morally equates Muslims with non-Muslims. Hence, he is not only incredibly stupid, he is juridical as well..

  • @maherhamdan2649
    @maherhamdan2649 Před 12 dny +503

    As a palestinian, I'am proud of Ilan Pappe whom I consider as a real brother , more than many Saudis or Emiratis !

  • @theredboneking
    @theredboneking Před 12 dny +467

    That’s exactly why Tic Toc was targeted. Young people were learning too much truth.

    • @MaryLou5239
      @MaryLou5239 Před 12 dny +17

      Yes

    • @sonyjoseph5426
      @sonyjoseph5426 Před 12 dny +16

      These young people are not letting education get in the way of their education

    • @marcomoreno6748
      @marcomoreno6748 Před 12 dny +13

      ​@@sonyjoseph5426the saying is "don't let your schooling get in the way of your education."

    • @marcomoreno6748
      @marcomoreno6748 Před 12 dny

      ​@@ms-jf1iz buzz off, disinfo agent. That's the obvious reason to anyone with a working brain.

    • @BM-ir1dr
      @BM-ir1dr Před 12 dny

      ​@@ms-jf1iz tik tok is not great for some young people. My son is one of them! But if you think the US want to ban it for the wellbeing of children you're kidding yourself. They want to squash dissent. And there is much dissent from the youth. So they target university protests and tik tok.

  • @danoneall4013
    @danoneall4013 Před 8 dny +44

    I'm American
    I've been a Muslim since 2010
    I reside in Egypt with my Egyptian wife.
    Every single time I come back to America, I am detained from any where from 2 to 9 hours.
    It is the same BS questions.

    • @ibrahimtoom9085
      @ibrahimtoom9085 Před 7 dny +1

      its not only you most muslim american went and will go through this bs

    • @nand3576
      @nand3576 Před 4 dny

      Shout ‘alllahoooo akkubar’ they will let you go! On 4 pairs of legs!

    • @bassam5714
      @bassam5714 Před 4 dny +2

      I am sorry you are treated this way, and wish you and your family good luck.

    • @danoneall4013
      @danoneall4013 Před 4 dny

      @nand3576 - my brother said I should hold a Qur'an & Bible & start preaching from both at US Customs & Border Patrol.
      His wife said, you want your brother to disappear
      Hahahahhaa

  • @shahidejaz-hb8vu
    @shahidejaz-hb8vu Před 12 dny +108

    Professor Pappe you give hope to humanity,God Bless You

  • @adinahaun6001
    @adinahaun6001 Před 12 dny +1458

    I’m ashamed of my government with its shameful behavior!

  • @user-wd6ni4xu4n
    @user-wd6ni4xu4n Před 12 dny +707

    That’s disgraceful this man is a professor and renounced for his values. To detain him because of he’s criticism of the actions of Israel is just disgraceful.

    • @theredboneking
      @theredboneking Před 12 dny +18

      Renounced - formally declare one's abandonment of (a claim, right, or possession)
      Renowned- known or talked about by many people; famous.

    • @CowboyConan
      @CowboyConan Před 12 dny +12

      It proves the tropes are true

    • @rickbenjamin6134
      @rickbenjamin6134 Před 12 dny +5

      renounced is the correct word.....

    • @hayleylorenzo6709
      @hayleylorenzo6709 Před 12 dny +6

      When you consort with terrorists expect to be detained. End of story.

    • @hayleylorenzo6709
      @hayleylorenzo6709 Před 12 dny +7

      @@shovanbijoy7136 I do not live in a basement I studied law. What else do you have? Always insults when you can not defend your position. Typical.

  • @notobigotry
    @notobigotry Před 10 dny +31

    What a wonderful man. Ilan Pape you are a model for the human race with your big heart and humanity.

  • @jamiemiloud3557
    @jamiemiloud3557 Před 12 dny +73

    Thank you Mr. For telling the truth
    Blessings ❤❤❤
    Justice will prevail
    Free Palestine!

    • @huizhechen3779
      @huizhechen3779 Před 9 dny +1

      Justice is subjective & relative. Only the victims of injustice get to say when they feel that justice has prevailed. The rest of us--those who are interested in whether a government, a society, or a socio-governmental institution & its employees are committed to the idea of justice--want to know that justice might be possible for those seeking redress from their govt for injustice.

    • @Thinking858
      @Thinking858 Před 9 dny

      Just has been prevailing for 100 years... They always ask for it and received it..

  • @36repulse
    @36repulse Před 12 dny +667

    Disgusting treatment by US of this respectable man

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      Not respectable/. A world-class anti-Semite. One of the big three.

    • @tonydalton459
      @tonydalton459 Před 12 dny

      Yes, a disgrace. It’s pure McCarthyism. “Are you now or have you ever been........”

    • @hayleylorenzo6709
      @hayleylorenzo6709 Před 12 dny

      Actually, he is not respected except for terrorists sympathesizers. What will you do when another 9/11 happens? Will you cry? Or will you be smart and realize radical Islam is a threat to all of us?

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny +3

      Not in my view.

    • @hayleylorenzo6709
      @hayleylorenzo6709 Před 12 dny

      9/11

  • @gs123
    @gs123 Před 12 dny +728

    Shameful! Dr. Pappe is a treasure

    • @MaryLou5239
      @MaryLou5239 Před 12 dny +17

      Agree💯

    • @rickbenjamin6134
      @rickbenjamin6134 Před 12 dny

      only if you believe in revisionist history and brainwashing

    • @asielmundo
      @asielmundo Před 12 dny +19

      Chomsky is a huge treasure and he's american, I mean is one of the few american philosophers.

    • @IsakHashani
      @IsakHashani Před 12 dny +27

      Israel Shahak, Norman Finkelstein, Avi Shlaim, Miko Peled, Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro, Nurit Peled-Elhanan, Shlomo Sand, Shulamit Aloni, Evelin Hecht-Galinski, Jill Stein…..

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      A treasure to haters? Tell me what has he done besides trash Jews? Can you list his accomplishments?

  • @madrasmail20
    @madrasmail20 Před 12 dny +28

    The British need to be made accountable for the horrendous atrocities they helped perpetuate on the palestinians for the last 100 years

    • @TheSpoovy
      @TheSpoovy Před 7 dny

      Er, what? The Palestinian mandate was an obligation created by the League of Nations. Britain has sold arms to Israel since which is not good but no different than lots of other countries. Why pick on Britain?

    • @johnleaver7745
      @johnleaver7745 Před 6 dny +1

      The UK..What about U.S.??

    • @Kffern
      @Kffern Před 4 dny

      @@TheSpoovy The mandate was just Britain, France and the US dividing up the spoils of WW2 which was a european war fought in the middle east and all over Africa and Asia. giving it a fancy name doesn't change anything.

  • @user-im4ps3zv8u
    @user-im4ps3zv8u Před 10 dny +11

    Thanks Democracy Now for bringing Ilan Páppe to your show. Do not let the evil silence us ! ❤🇵🇸

  • @geetanauth6491
    @geetanauth6491 Před 12 dny +486

    How desperate to go after this polite soft-spoken historian

    • @samsammyyy
      @samsammyyy Před 12 dny +7

      Historian 😂😂😂 He freely admits that, in his view, facts are irrelevant when it comes to history

    • @faniarethas2716
      @faniarethas2716 Před 12 dny +7

      @@samsammyyy
      Said the historian Herodotus. 😂😂

    • @ahmed4100
      @ahmed4100 Před 12 dny +12

      @@samsammyyyhe is literally a historian what are you disputing lil man

    • @samsammyyy
      @samsammyyy Před 12 dny +2

      @@ahmed4100 Ilan Pappe is a historian like Mahmoud Abbas is a Holocaust researcher

    • @samsammyyy
      @samsammyyy Před 12 dny

      @@faniarethas2716 Well, he is a proven fraud who also defended literal medieval blood libels of child sacrifices

  • @gtd65
    @gtd65 Před 9 dny +16

    I was interrogated for 4 hours at Detroit airport and denied entry and ultimately, deported, the following evening.
    What did I do?
    Nothing, other than come over to the USA, to visit my 2 US Citizen children.
    That was 8 years ago now and I've been denied a visa to visit the USA ever since.
    No criminal record, no breach of US immigration rules/laws/regulation, no intent other than coming over on holiday/vacation.
    No humans rights for me....

    • @michaelmullins3396
      @michaelmullins3396 Před 8 dny +3

      It should be considered a badge of honor to be denied entry to America until there is a fundamental regime change .

    • @gtd65
      @gtd65 Před 8 dny +1

      @@michaelmullins3396 I'd rather have been able to visit my kids, than any potential badge to be fair. Been three changes during that time, Obama, Trump & Biden.

    • @Hxtice
      @Hxtice Před 7 dny +2

      I feel for you. I wish they would give clear reasons for their rejection so that you could at least try to do something about it. Very unfortunate situation. I hope your kids are able to visit you at least.

    • @gtd65
      @gtd65 Před 7 dny

      @@Hxtice the real problem, is never getting any opportunity to state your case or provide evidence showing strong ties to your home nation. This is contrary to what is advised when trying to apply for a visa.
      It's a really strange predicament to end up in.
      I've only seen my kids, twice in 8 years, so far.
      I'll never get that time back.
      I'm just a guy, on the other side of the Atlantic now.

    • @Animal.CUT...
      @Animal.CUT... Před 7 dny +1

      @@gtd65 If u don't mind and forgive me if I dare ... Just ask u two questions . 1.The mother of your children she's an (born)US citizen ? 2. Do u come from a country which doesn't share the same views and policies of uncle Sammy ?

  • @FaiezCader
    @FaiezCader Před 12 dny +11

    Heard so much of Illan Pape .What a well-spoken man and historian

  • @taherabunama4559
    @taherabunama4559 Před 12 dny +403

    From Gaza, thank you Prof.

    • @ananda111
      @ananda111 Před 12 dny +25

      🇧🇷 with 🇵🇸 forever!

    • @Emanon...
      @Emanon... Před 12 dny +33

      You will have justice, brother and sisters

    • @davidk2471
      @davidk2471 Před 12 dny

      Thank you for supporting rape and murder you mean

    • @faberkoster9725
      @faberkoster9725 Před 12 dny +23

      Stand strong and alive, you will be free.

    • @dijanadevries2643
      @dijanadevries2643 Před 12 dny +19

      ❤ from the Netherlands 🌷

  • @conniedean3787
    @conniedean3787 Před 12 dny +568

    Wow that is shocking, I am ashamed of the US

    • @PauloAdriano-zo2ng
      @PauloAdriano-zo2ng Před 12 dny +11

      Feeling shame is pointless if you don't do anything about it.

    • @conniedean3787
      @conniedean3787 Před 12 dny +9

      @@PauloAdriano-zo2ng I have no control over what the leaders of the U.S. does.

    • @PauloAdriano-zo2ng
      @PauloAdriano-zo2ng Před 12 dny +9

      @@conniedean3787
      Connie, you aren't entirely helpless, use your voting power. Organize others in your community.

    • @gailhitson7340
      @gailhitson7340 Před 12 dny +10

      ​@@ms-jf1iz If you condemn Hamas terrorists in Gaza, then by the same measuring stick you must condemn others who behave the same or worse..... Including Israel and Netanyahu. Exactly how many gallons of Palestinian blood do you demand in revenge for Hamas' actions? Help us understand.

    • @hitreset0291
      @hitreset0291 Před 12 dny +4

      ​@@gailhitson7340 This is already and currently a 1-state (but not a 1-state solution) for both jews and palestinians. It is an israeli apartheid state >> which everyone can see plainly.
      The next 1-state (and a true 1-state solution) will be based on equal rights (no exceptions) for both the israelis and the palestinians.

  • @CY-ye5dz
    @CY-ye5dz Před 10 dny +19

    Prof Ilan Pappe has my highest respect and admiration. He's the sound of reason, wisdom and justice.. Thank you, Professor. You're an inspiration

  • @houcine0739
    @houcine0739 Před 11 dny +10

    Thank you professor Ilan Pappé.

  • @joebondo2422
    @joebondo2422 Před 12 dny +248

    Apparently we here in the US don’t actually live in the US but rather an extension of the state of Israel. Yet millions of our sheep will flock in November to vote for a candidate from the 2 party dictatorship that supports this. 🙏🇵🇸😔

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny +2

      Massive ignorance. Feel good?

    • @theredboneking
      @theredboneking Před 12 dny +21

      Who controls the media, controls the minds.

    • @dc741
      @dc741 Před 12 dny

      @@ms-jf1izthe only ignorant people are the supporters of Israel

    • @fayekalantzis4523
      @fayekalantzis4523 Před 12 dny

      Politicians get paid off by the aid money meant for food

    • @timmoore3188
      @timmoore3188 Před 12 dny

      I think it extends beyond Israel to many countries, Arabs, Asians what have you, those who buy and sell Zionist arms and surveilance tech. It's a world mafia class who only cares about amassing wealth and power.

  • @bayzidahammed8614
    @bayzidahammed8614 Před 12 dny +1146

    I thought the Naz!s no longer existed until I realized that they are rebranding themselves as the NAtional Zlonism of Israel.

    • @optimistx4187
      @optimistx4187 Před 12 dny +43

      What about the White House?

    • @MootTwo
      @MootTwo Před 12 dny +71

      @@optimistx4187 NAtional Zionism of USrael

    • @killiancohara
      @killiancohara Před 12 dny +84

      Zionism came before the Nazis. And they collaborated closely.

    • @hayleylorenzo6709
      @hayleylorenzo6709 Před 12 dny

      And who is killing their own people? I will wait for your answer. Here is a hint...Radical Islam.

    • @KlausRiede
      @KlausRiede Před 12 dny +11

      Nazis would have arrested him...

  • @Lady_Ima2
    @Lady_Ima2 Před 12 dny +11

    Solidarity with you dear Ilan Pappé

  • @SW_aka_Gandalf
    @SW_aka_Gandalf Před 12 dny +8

    Professor Pappé is a good man

  • @cherieestbien1902
    @cherieestbien1902 Před 12 dny +280

    Since when is it illegal to stand against genocide? Wasn't the reason we fought in WWII to stop genocide? Airport security in the US has no legal authority to question anyone about their beliefs on genocide.

    • @oliveoil5789
      @oliveoil5789 Před 12 dny +15

      It wasn’t airport security, it was a couple of federal agents.

    • @marcinbenedek789
      @marcinbenedek789 Před 12 dny

      No, you fought in WWII to protect allies against Nazi Germany and stop Hitler. The genocide was continuing unimpeded. Allies did not bomb the railway to Death camps, while they clearly could, as they flew over them, with knowledge already of what is happening there. So US involvement in War was not to stop the genocide. Also US did annhilated 215 000 people in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, so they committed a huge crime themselves. BUT, I hope that this time US will actually do stop the genocide, instead of arming the killers.

    • @molliestanton2869
      @molliestanton2869 Před 12 dny

      The US government is criminal in funding and enabling the genocide, so they don't want anyone to shed light on their ( the government's )abhorrent role in it.

    • @jo-annerichardson34
      @jo-annerichardson34 Před 12 dny +15

      ​@@oliveoil5789which is worse.

    • @xhorxheetxeberria-td1hu
      @xhorxheetxeberria-td1hu Před 12 dny +9

      Unfortunately we don't have any rights at airports. Those are the things we should pressure our government representatives to change.

  • @docholiday8029
    @docholiday8029 Před 12 dny +717

    It gives me hope that so many people are against genocide.
    It disgusts me that Biden and others aren't.

    • @ingehanson
      @ingehanson Před 12 dny +49

      That's why neither Biden nor Trump deserve to be president again.

    • @rlud304
      @rlud304 Před 12 dny

      Yeah so out of character for Biden to be a war monger🙄 except for his ENTIRE career

    • @hitreset0291
      @hitreset0291 Před 12 dny

      ​@@stevendale7301 YES zionist israel has NO desire to live alongside any other people. Happy to steal their lands but NO to living alongside them in peace.

    • @fawzilaza9545
      @fawzilaza9545 Před 12 dny +28

      They are complicit

    • @hitreset0291
      @hitreset0291 Před 12 dny +26

      @@stevendale7301 are you more content with the term "ethnic cleansing of Gazans" to cover up your guilt?

  • @pmcamacho6447
    @pmcamacho6447 Před 12 dny +8

    Thanks Amy and Juan, always great, informed analysis. Where would genuine journalism be without you?

  • @SarahtheSoldier
    @SarahtheSoldier Před 10 dny +5

    Protect this precious gentleman at all costs. He's one extremely worthy of respect!

  • @user-wd6ni4xu4n
    @user-wd6ni4xu4n Před 12 dny +223

    I have said the same thing many many times. The kindness is in this man’s face.

    • @rickbenjamin6134
      @rickbenjamin6134 Před 12 dny

      but he won't condemn Hamas. Real kind fellow. On 10/7/2024 1200 Israelis were murdered by Hamas, the government of Gaza and the massacre, the rapes, the tortures and the taking of hostages including children and the elderly of whom many have since been murdered, is and was cheered by 70% of "civilian" Palestinians in the region. By the way, there have been no Israelis in Gaza since 2005. The seed was sown and now Rafah reaps the whirlwind. Hamas and only Hamas is responsible for 10/7 and for the deaths and misery of this war repeatedly refusing to release the hostages while continuing to bombard Israel with rockets and whining for humanitarian aid while attacking the crossing used to deliver the aid. Crazy eh?

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      I guess you think Himmler had a kind face too.

    • @coronato7988
      @coronato7988 Před 12 dny

      @@ms-jf1iz sometimes I wonder if you people even have the tiniest bit of self awareness to help you realize how insane you sound

    • @marymatthews678
      @marymatthews678 Před 12 dny +1

      A beautiful face.

    • @UK-Conscience
      @UK-Conscience Před 12 dny +4

      @ms-jf1iz it's also about his lifelong actions. Clearly education in history is a luxury beyond your means

  • @9211goat
    @9211goat Před 12 dny +229

    Thank you, Ilan Pappé, for teaching the world the truth of the plight of the Palestinian people.

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      A known racist tells the truth preaching to the choir. What else has he told the truth about aside from his anti-semitic babble?

    • @user-sk7tm5kp8w
      @user-sk7tm5kp8w Před 10 dny +2

      "He is being paid by Qatar."

    • @Not1MoreWar
      @Not1MoreWar Před 10 dny +1

      A warning to the world: "Albert Einstein Letter to the New York Times."

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 10 dny

      @@Not1MoreWar Seeing a potential problem and preventing it from occurring are two different things. Difficult to do that; even for a genius. I'm afraid it's the human condition. With 8 billion people inn the world, there are going to be some bad guys. The ratio between bad and good isn't the determining factor. How long did it take to bring down the world trade center? How long to build it? Doing harm is that much easier than doing good.
      What's your solution?

    • @Not1MoreWar
      @Not1MoreWar Před 10 dny

      @@ms-jf1iz "This is the unmistakable stamp of a f@scist Party, for whom terr0rism (against Jews, Arabs, and British alike), and misrepresentation are means, and a "Leader State" is the goal." - Albert Einstein, Hannah Arendt, et al. - December 4, 1948

  • @Shaikha-qtr
    @Shaikha-qtr Před 10 dny +14

    Mr. Pappe deserves our utmost respect for his bravery in denouncing apartheid, racism, violence, and hostility towards the Palestinian people. His honesty and integrity set an example for all of us to follow.

  • @uknowamsaying
    @uknowamsaying Před 9 dny +5

    BBC would not report this.
    But if it was China that did, it would be headline for 3 days.

  • @mfa8086
    @mfa8086 Před 12 dny +238

    The fact that the police don’t refuse these orders shows who they work for

    • @skontheroad
      @skontheroad Před 12 dny +5

      The people who pay them??

    • @mfa8086
      @mfa8086 Před 12 dny +14

      @@skontheroad we pay them

    • @skontheroad
      @skontheroad Před 12 dny +5

      @@mfa8086 Exactly!

    • @donnavorce8856
      @donnavorce8856 Před 12 dny +6

      It was two federal agents. Not police

    • @71suns
      @71suns Před 12 dny

      They were FEDERAL GOVERNMENT agents. Think about that for a minute. Apparently we've ALREADY passed the Rubicon in the US.

  • @IbnSaifi
    @IbnSaifi Před 12 dny +143

    We’re very grateful for Prof Ilan Pappe choosing to call the UK home and teaching here

  • @mildredmartinez8843
    @mildredmartinez8843 Před 11 dny +4

    Dr. Pappé's statements are a moral clarion for humanity. Everyone who values justice and humanity is beholden to this great teacher for standing on the right side of history.

  • @mohammadrazaq405
    @mohammadrazaq405 Před 11 dny +5

    Mr. Pappe you’re my hero who tells the truth. Brave gentleman

  • @georgeantonopoulos545
    @georgeantonopoulos545 Před 12 dny +241

    NO COMMENT FOR the WEST dictatorships! How can be to interrogate such precious human being !!Imagine what they can do with an ordinary man?

    • @theredboneking
      @theredboneking Před 12 dny

      Strapped down, blindfolded, held in diapers: Israeli whistleblowers detail abuse of Palestinians in shadowy detention center.
      “We were told they were not allowed to move. They should sit upright. They’re not allowed to talk. Not allowed to peek under their blindfold.”
      Guards were instructed “to scream uskot” - shut up in Arabic - and told to “pick people out that were problematic and punish them,” the source added.

    • @user-dp1bt9ql2m
      @user-dp1bt9ql2m Před 12 dny +6

      oh he's so special!

    • @rickbenjamin6134
      @rickbenjamin6134 Před 12 dny +4

      precious human being. What a load of crap

    • @georgeantonopoulos545
      @georgeantonopoulos545 Před 12 dny

      @@rickbenjamin6134 every human is a precious ..even you ,,,shit! AND YES, LOOK AT HIS HISTORY AND COMPARE HIM WITH YOU ,AS HUMAN!

    • @Stigmaballs
      @Stigmaballs Před 12 dny

      ​@@rickbenjamin6134 cool it with the antisemitic remarks

  • @ananda111
    @ananda111 Před 12 dny +137

    Essential interview for the world. All respect to the great humanist and professor Ilan Pappé! Freedom for Palestine and all oppressed peoples.

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      "oppressed people"? The Jews are the poster child for "oppressed". Or have you never opened a book? Oh wait - in your view WHITE people can never be oppressed. Just oppressors. What a racist bigot idea.

    • @bridgetsaenz2774
      @bridgetsaenz2774 Před 12 dny

      Amén 🙏

  • @BeverlyBurnette-ll2gl
    @BeverlyBurnette-ll2gl Před 11 dny +7

    Excellent commentary this is an Israeli that studies History so moving❤

  • @frankens7632
    @frankens7632 Před 12 dny +130

    Shame on USA complicit in this genocide

    • @brianjacob8728
      @brianjacob8728 Před 11 dny

      Well, the us was complicit w supporting nazigermany. Just ask Ford motors, brown Brothers Harriman and the bush family.

    • @AprilWatters
      @AprilWatters Před 10 dny +1

      SHAME on Ameikans for funding it!

  • @SheBytes2
    @SheBytes2 Před 11 dny +5

    Ilan Pappe is a universal treasure ❤️

  • @SadaK-tr6dm
    @SadaK-tr6dm Před 12 dny +153

    Free US and UK from AIPAC.

    • @janmortimer1758
      @janmortimer1758 Před 12 dny +3

      Vote Jill stein 💚✌️

    • @SadaK-tr6dm
      @SadaK-tr6dm Před 11 dny +1

      @@janmortimer1758 👍

    • @user-io1oj7rm9w
      @user-io1oj7rm9w Před 10 dny +7

      Free all the world from them ❤

    • @ednorton47
      @ednorton47 Před 10 dny

      @@janmortimer1758 Oy vey!

    • @julienl.3327
      @julienl.3327 Před 9 dny

      They don't need aipac to support Israel, it's about being same minded colonialists and genocidal.

  • @mfox1999
    @mfox1999 Před 12 dny +152

    greatly appreciate you Ilan! from a third generation of Nakba ‘48

    • @user-dp1bt9ql2m
      @user-dp1bt9ql2m Před 12 dny +1

      ISR third generation winners!

    • @rickbenjamin6134
      @rickbenjamin6134 Před 12 dny +2

      aw shucks, maybe, your family shouldn't have believed the Arab armies in 1948 that told them to clear the area while they kill all the Jews and throw them into the sea. Then they could return and not only get their land back, but they would get the farms and orchards of the Jews as well....how did that work out for them and you?

    • @Stigmaballs
      @Stigmaballs Před 12 dny

      ​@@rickbenjamin6134 Imagine lying about easily verified facts lol
      It's all you seem to know

    • @dc741
      @dc741 Před 12 dny

      @@rickbenjamin6134from river to the sea Israel is a thief

    • @pambacchus5421
      @pambacchus5421 Před 12 dny

      @@user-dp1bt9ql2mNot as much as the Israelis milk the holocaust for everything. They are the biggest whiners. It’s always but the holocaust. Granted, it was terrible but not the only terrible thing to happen in the history of the world.

  • @lancejohnson127
    @lancejohnson127 Před 7 dny +2

    The fact that they were polite actually makes it even more sinister. The banality of evil.

  • @abootwallysohomow7086
    @abootwallysohomow7086 Před 11 dny +4

    Congrats gentleman for calling a spade a spade !!!
    Good answers to the questions asked !!!

  • @anthonyfx100
    @anthonyfx100 Před 12 dny +160

    If it isn’t a police state, what is it!!!

    • @nopt1118
      @nopt1118 Před 12 dny +1

      It's Democracy laced with Western values

    • @TessTearoe-zp5xv
      @TessTearoe-zp5xv Před 11 dny +2

      You are really becoming what you say Russia is but then you have always been

    • @s-code-b
      @s-code-b Před 10 dny +2

      It's the 'democracy' that we have been so brash about & have insidiously (also violently) forced on other countries.

    • @thicccorgi6187
      @thicccorgi6187 Před 10 dny

      ​@@nopt1118 What democracy? Are the Palestinians free to vote in Israeli elections? Are they free to vote in their own??

    • @Not1MoreWar
      @Not1MoreWar Před 10 dny +3

      Occupied. Einstein warned us.
      "Albert Einstein Letter to the New York Times."

  • @nodiraa2303
    @nodiraa2303 Před 12 dny +53

    It's the honesty and the courage of people like Ilan Pappe that brings humanity hope. Thank you!

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      The guy is a card carrying anti-semite. So much for the education system.

  • @timothykassisieh9701
    @timothykassisieh9701 Před 12 dny +5

    Dr. Pappe's words bring me hope that one day Historic Palestine will be free and everyone can live in peace and cherish each other.

  • @guevaramarwan
    @guevaramarwan Před 11 dny +5

    What a brave man ...Respect ❤

  • @basfinnis
    @basfinnis Před 12 dny +127

    Don't know why the US authorities just dispense with their own offices and just take their orders directly from Tel Aviv!

    • @theredboneking
      @theredboneking Před 12 dny +1

      Revelation 17:18 -
      And the woman which thou sawest is that great city, which reigns over the kings of the earth.

    • @71suns
      @71suns Před 12 dny +2

      ​@@theredbonekingRevelation chapter 2:9

  • @margaretwenham9915
    @margaretwenham9915 Před 12 dny +117

    Monstrous behavior by the US towards this esteemed intellectual

    • @Thinking858
      @Thinking858 Před 9 dny

      He has the same esteemed Intellect as you... And that's not a compliment, but you can accept it as one...

    • @margaretwenham9915
      @margaretwenham9915 Před 9 dny

      I doubt you’d recognise intellect if bit you on your arse.

    • @minshew2039
      @minshew2039 Před 8 dny

      ​@@Thinking858Good goyim, maybe I'll lower your rent.

  • @melisadirilish6466
    @melisadirilish6466 Před 11 dny +4

    A really beautiful human being, our Ilan Pappe, always a pleasure listening to him. There is hope and there is place for everyone on this God's earth, no matter person's religious affiliation, so long as they are human beings.

  • @senscommun1792
    @senscommun1792 Před 12 dny +3

    Reading these days “The ethnic cleansing of Palestine.” Great book exposing the whole tragedy at its origin. I highly recommend.❤❤❤❤❤.

  • @laracroft8420
    @laracroft8420 Před 12 dny +57

    The brilliant author Dr. Pappe❤ We love his books in Germany!!! Free palestine 🇵🇸

    • @ms-jf1iz
      @ms-jf1iz Před 12 dny

      Hate can tke you far. Look what it did for Hiller. Undoubtedly he's another one of your heroes. Miss the good old days?

  • @l23918
    @l23918 Před 12 dny +87

    I look forward to the days when people between the river to the sea will all live in peace and harmony.❤

  • @ISMAEL-ul5eb
    @ISMAEL-ul5eb Před 12 dny +5

    Thank you Dr for speaking the truth.

  • @lilliankeane5731
    @lilliankeane5731 Před 10 dny +3

    Thank you mr Pappe. It was a pleasure listening to you.

  • @rul4522
    @rul4522 Před 12 dny +101

    Ilan Pappé, you’re so right!

    • @rickbenjamin6134
      @rickbenjamin6134 Před 12 dny

      he's a fool. There are about 9,000,000 people living in Israel of which there are about 2,000,000 Muslims, many Christians and sundry other religious sects. People of all colors live, bank, study at Hebrew University and basically live peacefully side by side in Israel. Interestingly, Muslim citizens comprise about 30% of Israeli medical providers. Where is the "apartheid" he refers to?

  • @MakeLoveNotWar865
    @MakeLoveNotWar865 Před 12 dny +245

    From Palestine, thank you so much for standing with humanity, Professor.

    • @helenakolar
      @helenakolar Před 12 dny +8

      ❤💕🩷 Stay strong

    • @anthonydavis9382
      @anthonydavis9382 Před 11 dny +2

      lol you're not from Palestine.

    • @Not1MoreWar
      @Not1MoreWar Před 10 dny +2

      ​@@anthonydavis9382and you know this, how, exactly??

    • @habmann
      @habmann Před 10 dny +2

      ​@anthonydavis9382 and how did you come up with this?

    • @Luv7Bella
      @Luv7Bella Před 10 dny +2

      @@anthonydavis9382 let me guess you are not American

  • @hamnalodhi8946
    @hamnalodhi8946 Před 11 dny +2

    So sorry to hear that. I have immense respect for the gentleman. I feel someone misbehaved with my father and it hurts the same

  • @DrXtoph
    @DrXtoph Před 12 dny +2

    Thanks for this very important coverage! Love your content!

  • @luisdavidllense2293
    @luisdavidllense2293 Před 12 dny +66

    I have MAD respect for this professor! As brave as he is a source of knowledge. Thank you for having him on, Democracy Now!

  • @lulusp1023
    @lulusp1023 Před 12 dny +51

    Freedom for Palestine...

  • @andros1000
    @andros1000 Před 7 dny +2

    I can’t believe how badly I needed to hear those last words of optimism from professor and historian Ilan Pappe. Let us hope that they come to fruition with as little pain as possible for all involved.

  • @realistavelicanstveni9698

    Professor Ilan Pappe you are on the right side of History!

  • @user-nw1fw3nu3y
    @user-nw1fw3nu3y Před 12 dny +107

    What a great historian, scholar and human being.

  • @alicerose9140
    @alicerose9140 Před 12 dny +88

    Shameful behavior by US authorities. I believe the tide has turned too.

  • @amaryllislady8795
    @amaryllislady8795 Před 11 dny +3

    Thank you Professor.

  • @ulugbeknur
    @ulugbeknur Před 11 dny +1

    Thank you for the interview 🙏🇺🇿🇺🇸And thanks for Dr. Pappe for enlightening us with his knowledge.

  • @mariab4660
    @mariab4660 Před 12 dny +76

    Professor Pappé is really a great man

  • @abbyvirji9592
    @abbyvirji9592 Před 12 dny +32

    Prof. Ilan Pappe, you’re a true voice of reason amidst a cacophony of murderous madness. 🙏🏽

  • @bertrandjuan3101
    @bertrandjuan3101 Před 6 dny +2

    Always enlightening to hear Prof.... Thank you Sir

  • @Techworld-us4cs
    @Techworld-us4cs Před 9 dny +5

    Thanks Israeli historian

  • @Pea857
    @Pea857 Před 12 dny +76

    From RAFA Palestine thank you professor go for Palestine free free FREE free free Palestine

    • @janmortimer1758
      @janmortimer1758 Před 12 dny +6

      Stay safe ❤️❣️Australian

    • @user-sk7tm5kp8w
      @user-sk7tm5kp8w Před 10 dny

      You are getting free water and free electricity from Israel

    • @LubnaLuai-rl2vd
      @LubnaLuai-rl2vd Před 10 dny +1

      It’s their land and Israel stole it 🙄🙄🙄

    • @LubnaLuai-rl2vd
      @LubnaLuai-rl2vd Před 10 dny

      How generous they are🙄🙄
      They can leave Palestine and Palestinians can manage as they have always done for thousands of years!

    • @user-sk7tm5kp8w
      @user-sk7tm5kp8w Před 9 dny

      @@khaledhammood5879 Thank you for your reply, you are not in a small room in the Gaza area is fairly large and you are free to move the beach area is a nice place you have your own so system that is controlled by corrupt leaders that become very rich on your account, how can you make peace with an organization that in their charter is aiming to destroy and kill you, which they prove it recently.
      incidentally, some of the individuals they took hostages and killed were from the left and were very much pro-peace helping Gazen with medical issues.
      That said it is not my view, I am more conservative and ultra-Zionist and have another perspective on the issues !!

  • @PapiElric
    @PapiElric Před 12 dny +106

    I thank you and your team for your essential work.
    A French citizen who is ashamed of his government and the majority of journalists in his country.

    • @sikiyahomarmoussa8191
      @sikiyahomarmoussa8191 Před 12 dny +5

      Avec vous!

    • @molliestanton2869
      @molliestanton2869 Před 12 dny +4

      At least your government is supportive of the ICC, and has wised up to its best interests economically. Maybe more of the EU will, too. Vive la France!

    • @PapiElric
      @PapiElric Před 11 dny +1

      @@sikiyahomarmoussa8191 You are welcome.

    • @PapiElric
      @PapiElric Před 11 dny +5

      @@molliestanton2869 Thanks, but right now, I am more proud of Ireland.

    • @PapiElric
      @PapiElric Před 11 dny +1

      @@sikiyahomarmoussa8191 Thank you.

  • @jonlaban4272
    @jonlaban4272 Před 5 dny +2

    Thanks for the interview

  • @hassanmusse7700
    @hassanmusse7700 Před 12 dny +46

    Prof. thanks for your HUMANITY

  • @alexanderconnell6270
    @alexanderconnell6270 Před 12 dny +79

    Go on Amy we love you and thank you for your reporting!!!

  • @gonzalesfrederic6213
    @gonzalesfrederic6213 Před 7 dny +1

    I am French, 45.
    I like that this journalist looks like normal people do.

  • @user-jp4jv4sm1v
    @user-jp4jv4sm1v Před 7 dny +2

    Thank you guys for the amazing job you are doing

  • @moea8818
    @moea8818 Před 12 dny +103

    Grandfather Ethnically cleansed at 1948. Wish he was alive to see this global support. His last words were about his longing for his childhood home in Palestine.

    • @serif392
      @serif392 Před 10 dny

      Mufti Amin al-Hussieni visited with Hitler in 1941 to say they are natural friends..they both wanted to genocide the Jews.

    • @clairezet3182
      @clairezet3182 Před 9 dny

      Everybody has a longing for his/her place of birth, which imprints itself on our psyche and every fibre of our body. This is NOT, however, a legitimate claim to a land or a national sovereignty. Muslims born in America or England will be forever affected by the landscape and culture of their place of birth. But these lands cannot be claimed by them as their own, although Caradawi's plan does precisely that.
      Palestinians = descendants of 7th century AD brutal invaders and COLONISERS of the historic land of the Jewish nation, who in their GREED AND RELIGIOUS ZEAL reached China to the east, Spain to the west and USURPED vast swaths of Africa, plundering physical and cultural riches of the invaded lands as well as converting by the SWORD INDIGENOUS populations,
      AND - descendants of😮
      late 19th early 20th century economic migrant newcomers from:
      Algeria,
      Afghanistan
      Armenia
      Albenia
      Bosnia
      Chechnia
      Circassia
      Egypt
      Greece
      Italy
      Iraq
      Iran
      Lybia
      Lebanon
      Syria
      Turkey
      Yemen, etc, not to mention
      Nomadic Beduins.
      Approximate ratio of 1st group to second is 50:50.
      Palestinians = descendants of colonisers and economic MIGRANTS. Never a nation, never a state, never an identity. Islamists whom nobody wants, not even their co-religionists over the Egyptian border.

    • @Tesla_Death_Ray
      @Tesla_Death_Ray Před 9 dny +1

      Where did he flee?

    • @moea8818
      @moea8818 Před 7 dny +1

      @@Tesla_Death_Ray Lebanon. Ain al-Hilweh was established near the city of Sidon in 1948 by the International Committee of the Red Cross to accommodate refugees from Amqa, Saffuriya, Sha'ab, Taitaba, Manshieh, al-Simireh, al-Nahr, Safsaf, Hittin, al-Ras al-Ahmar, al-Tira and Tarshiha in northern Palestine.

  • @hekma6641
    @hekma6641 Před 12 dny +34

    Great people like ILan pape’ are always on the right side of history

  • @L98fiero
    @L98fiero Před 12 dny +9

    Ilan Pappé is a good, honest man.

  • @z23729
    @z23729 Před 5 dny +2

    US is scared of a professor now! What a shame. Ilan Pappe is an honourable, kind and compassionate human being and someone to be treasured. Shame on the US

  • @SRRMCS
    @SRRMCS Před 12 dny +26

    lawsuit must be filed against this detainment.

  • @user-ub5zu5yh9e
    @user-ub5zu5yh9e Před 12 dny +34

    Ireland stands with Palestine and all its Beautiful Brave People and Their little CHILDREN Bless them 🙏🇵🇸🙏🇵🇸🙏🇵🇸🙏

  • @kawzer8690
    @kawzer8690 Před 6 dny +2

    He wrote one of the best books these last years ✌️🇵🇸🔻

  • @kreyvegas1
    @kreyvegas1 Před 5 dny +1

    Brave Ilan Pappé, the world needs many more like you !!!

  • @sophs8548
    @sophs8548 Před 12 dny +40

    Shameful actions from a country that prides itself on seemingly "free speech" values.

  • @morninboy
    @morninboy Před 12 dny +111

    This is further proof that the United States of Israel needs to become an independent country. Maybe y'all could have a Boston Bagel party and throw all the bagels into the sea

    • @basfinnis
      @basfinnis Před 12 dny +8

      😂

    • @theredboneking
      @theredboneking Před 12 dny +2

      Revelation 17:18 -
      And the woman which thou sawest is that great city, which reigns over the kings of the earth.

    • @theredboneking
      @theredboneking Před 12 dny

      Woman, her or whore, refers to Babylon in the Bible.

    • @YvonneKennedy-lu2uc
      @YvonneKennedy-lu2uc Před 12 dny +9

      🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 American democracy..got to be an oxymoron...

    • @71suns
      @71suns Před 12 dny +3

      ​@@theredbonekingRevelation chapter 2:9

  • @CaptainSnackbar
    @CaptainSnackbar Před 10 dny +3

    Ilan Pappé is a national treasure

  • @doaamath1738
    @doaamath1738 Před 9 dny +5

    We shouldn't forget your brave standing with justice, Professor Pappe.

  • @sikandar9381
    @sikandar9381 Před 12 dny +49

    Long live pappe

  • @Antifa_Gini
    @Antifa_Gini Před 12 dny +234

    Free Palestine

    • @Method9
      @Method9 Před 12 dny +9

      🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉

    • @lalodaniels1388
      @lalodaniels1388 Před 12 dny +21

      Free America from Israel too. My country isn't suffering nearly as much as Palestine, but we are also tired of being under the Israeli thumb. We also want to be free from these corrupt criminals.

    • @Method9
      @Method9 Před 12 dny

      Canada, same. "BDS" has been "hate speech" since 2015.

    • @Method9
      @Method9 Před 12 dny

      Same for Canada. The Boycott, Divest, Sanction movement was classified as hate speech by our former PM in 2015.

    • @CowboyConan
      @CowboyConan Před 12 dny

      @@lalodaniels1388
      Yes! We are not as materially oppressed, but we are MORE PSYCHOLOGICALLY OPPRESSED than Palestinians. America is Israel 1984.

  • @r00mq1
    @r00mq1 Před 11 dny +1

    I respect this man, he is such a great person, his books reveal the truth about Palestine and the Zionists.

  • @TheShootnStar
    @TheShootnStar Před 12 dny

    Thank you Pr Pappé for all the work you still do and your courage. Thank you Amy !

  • @moodygirl609
    @moodygirl609 Před 12 dny +17

    Israel has become a pariah state. Palestinians need to have the ability to return to and/or live safely in the territories of Israel and Palestine. The world must support these demands.