SABATON - Christmas Truce | METAL MUSIC VIDEO PRODUCERS REACT

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 76

  • @coldnorthcreative
    @coldnorthcreative  Před rokem +10

    Sabaton truly didn't disappoint, this was an epic video! Which Sabaton video should we watch next?

    • @alancarter41
      @alancarter41 Před rokem +5

      If you want to continue to analyze the art of making videos, I suggest either "Race to the Sea" which was filmed in a mine lake (you might discuss the difficulties of filming and how some of the effects were created) or Steel Commanders, which was made in cooperation with World of Tanks (similar to yuor reaction of "Bismark"). If you want something where they had a little fun with the story, try "The Unkillable Soldier." Or you might want to delve into some of the animated story videos made in cooperation with Yarnhub.

    • @ondrejhajek4094
      @ondrejhajek4094 Před rokem

      Great real-life story is in animated video No Bullets Fly czcams.com/video/dslO-3GgenY/video.html
      The way of combat of soviet woman pilots is in animated video Night Witches czcams.com/video/5YPo8zDkvy4/video.html
      These videos are story telling - a tot of speech.

    • @baakeeju
      @baakeeju Před rokem +1

      None. So disrespectful. Never watching another one of your videos. Bye bye.

    • @blekic25
      @blekic25 Před rokem +2

      En Livstid I Krig (Live - The Great Tour - Gothenburg)

    • @tanin5
      @tanin5 Před rokem +1

      You could also give a chance to the Seven Pillars of Wisdom video... they filmed it in Tunesia in the desert

  • @alancarter41
    @alancarter41 Před rokem +51

    There are actually hundreds of firsthand accounts of this amazing event. It was widely reported in the English news media, and several survivors on both sides wrote accounts during and after the war. On their channel, Sabaton has a short video of the making of "Christmas Truce." (which BTW is a structured as a waltz according to Joakim Broden). The cross at the end represents a real memorial to the truce outside Ypres. The band members all said how hard acting was and that they had a new appreciation of the craft after this. Great reaction.

    • @coldnorthcreative
      @coldnorthcreative  Před rokem +7

      Cool man! Thanks for clearing that out, appreciated!

    • @crunchybro123
      @crunchybro123 Před rokem +3

      @@coldnorthcreative simply put, the soldiers were tired of fighting and spent Christmas nights in many places of trenches celebrating and having fun with eachother. Sadly, the officers made them come back (and if you don’t know you would back then be killed if you didn’t) and they had to fight again

  • @Vendetta_s
    @Vendetta_s Před rokem +19

    Some Germans knew English, the British knew some Germans too . Each unit had different experiences on Christmas. Not all had a truce, few did. Some had small handmade Christmas trees to place atop of the trenches. This one though talks about the first encounter I believe. However, it was a German officer who yelled out in broken English as everything was quiet “you not shoot and we won’t. Merry Christmas”. A 16 year old British soldier decided to venture out with hands up and met in the middle of no man’s land with a also young German soldier, they shook hands and greeted . Officers weren’t too happy but agreed to a short truce. But it’s why it never happened again. All that propaganda and hate on both sides depicting the other as a monster and evil was gone, both sides realise they were brainwashed and they were just… brothers, just normal humans. Many were students, some were train conductors, barbers, etc
    They gave gifts of cigarettes, chocolate, food, alcohol if any. They showed each other’s photos of loved ones, talked about their lives, some even gave their home address to visit after the war(don’t know If any survived to do that ) .. they buried the dead together no matter who and prayed p together as well. There was no enemy. They all had to be moved elsewhere afterwards. Both sides refused to kill their opposing team that were their new friends

  • @larsjson1476
    @larsjson1476 Před rokem +83

    You lost me at start with not taking it serious. Then not watching it til the end doesnt make anything better.

  • @MikaelKarlsson-vq8wz
    @MikaelKarlsson-vq8wz Před rokem +42

    Disrespectful attitude and review, regarding the historical event and the video. Sorry guys, will not watch you again.

  • @greensky3152
    @greensky3152 Před rokem +19

    You'll notice the trench builders in the credits. They built their own trenches. The video was filmed in the Czech Republic.
    Notice also that the solo during the end credits was by Floor Jansen.

  • @najroe
    @najroe Před rokem +6

    there are pictures of grand pianos in the trences, another instance is a case in military court for looting, the case includes description of a piano being "liberated" from a mansion in nomans land over several nights (hauling in stages from cover to cover...) everything is fairly accurate historically

  • @fenrisulfur842
    @fenrisulfur842 Před rokem +12

    look to the credits, they actually digged the trenches for the video :P

    • @coldnorthcreative
      @coldnorthcreative  Před rokem +3

      Haha what, sick! We totally missed that

    • @BerraLJ
      @BerraLJ Před rokem

      @@coldnorthcreative And as a trucker i like that even the drivers was in the credits :)

  • @henrikvidin
    @henrikvidin Před rokem +10

    It´s a pity, while you are supposed to be metal music video producers, to not taking the video seriously.
    I think you killed this reaction right from the start.
    This is truly an epic music video. If you reacted to it, as the producers you say you are, you may have noticed all the details in this video. But you did not take that chance.
    I will give you and your channel a second chance but if you laugh your way through it (just because power metal isn't your cup of tea) I will not.
    As someone mentioned, if you hade the energy to watch the end credits much of your movie making questions would be answered.
    I do not often make bad recensions on a reaction video but take my advice and react as music video producers and don not making a joke out of it.
    The brilliance of this music video just past over your heads.

    • @coldnorthcreative
      @coldnorthcreative  Před rokem +1

      If you listened to what we said, you would hear us praising the video, but seems like you're too busy crying 😭

    • @henrikvidin
      @henrikvidin Před rokem +5

      @Cold North Creative I'm not crying at all!
      grow up and accept the criticism.
      You can see that there are some more people reacting in the same way as me. It is your loss, not mine.

    • @merryrose6788
      @merryrose6788 Před rokem +4

      @@henrikvidin You wrote some thoughtful comments, as did others. Yes, good start to the reaction, but it tanked fast, no pun intended. If they don't like power metal, then why react to it? And I think the lead singer actually doesn't consider Sabaton power metal (dragons, drinking ,etc., not that there's anything wrong with it).

  • @Nem01
    @Nem01 Před 11 dny

    Nice reaction to a true story including the soccer game.

  • @TheFreddehalmstad
    @TheFreddehalmstad Před rokem +29

    I wish CZcams would create a “Block-Button” I sure as hell would block you first. Can’t watch this nonsense.
    I actually gave you a thumbs up 👍🏻 before I started watching the video, o took it away 1 minute in the song.
    And as far as subscription goes, no way in hell!

  • @greensky3152
    @greensky3152 Před rokem +5

    Could you react to the official music video of Uprising? It's listed on CZcams as SABATON - Uprising (Official Music Video). Be sure subtitles are on.

  • @BerraLJ
    @BerraLJ Před rokem

    The people that made the video is used to do big Hollywood production and it shows.

  • @ragulper
    @ragulper Před rokem +1

    The Pope had called for a Christmas truce and many Germans were catholics and took it very seriously. This wasn't just one place, it was independently negotiated peaces all along the border. Some never worked, some lasted but hours, some lasted even weeks after Christmas. This despite threats of arresting soldiers for treason.
    It didn't start at Christmas really. Trenches were so close that they had started to shout greetings to each other over the border. Over the weeks they started so share sporting results, singing together. Without this growing cameradie, the truces couldn't have been made.
    After this, command started with much higher troop rotations as to hinder any growth of friendships.
    I had a friend once who was a soldier in Wehrmacht and who experienced this himself in WW2 with american soldiers who became friends with the Germans, and they played cards together instead of fighting over what ever the mission object was supposed to be.

  • @ingmariohman8242
    @ingmariohman8242 Před rokem +2

    If you had paid attention to the credits, you would have seen 5 trench diggers mentioned!

  • @amygoodson-catlady
    @amygoodson-catlady Před rokem +2

    Omg...you are my people. If you're gonna hate, at least subscribe so you can hate next time, too. I'm in! But I don't have any hate. Just suggest you head over to The Sabaton History Channel and learn all about the Christmas Truce...you can even react to the lesson.
    Did y'all music pros pick up that this song has The Carol Of The Bells, played backwards on the piano? Or that the song is a waltz...?
    Maybe steer clear of the killing stats until your country hands you a rifle and sends you to *actual* war.

  • @kingofshit303
    @kingofshit303 Před rokem

    The story of the "Unkillable Soldier" is just insane and the video is worth a look.

  • @danielaliewald8340
    @danielaliewald8340 Před rokem +1

    I was prepared for the worst after reading some comments....but actually it was a good and pretty entertaining reaction. ❤ I subscribed....but definitely not to hate 😂

  • @fenrisulfur842
    @fenrisulfur842 Před rokem +1

    actually, there are several pictures taken at this time, showing both sides playing football

  • @generichardson4771
    @generichardson4771 Před rokem

    sabaton history is their history channel

  • @Odlarn2
    @Odlarn2 Před rokem +2

    You really like your own voices that's for sure.....

  • @Aniol363
    @Aniol363 Před rokem +9

    your reaction is so embarrassing that it's just not worth words. no respect and these laughs .... drama

  • @tordbladin8974
    @tordbladin8974 Před rokem +1

    😂😂😂😂😂 Beavis and Butt-head in real life!!!

  • @Bonovin
    @Bonovin Před rokem +6

    Outro of Floor Jansen of Nightwish ... and you cut out !

    • @alancarter41
      @alancarter41 Před rokem +2

      Oh dear, we have angered the NW army. These men react to the video production, not the music per say. her outro was not part of the actual song or production.

    • @larsjson1476
      @larsjson1476 Před rokem +9

      @@alancarter41 forget about Floor then, but role the list of people in the production and pay them respect 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @Monscent
    @Monscent Před rokem +3

    Its kinda ridicilous seeing two grown men giggle because they dont like some lyrics. I too think its kinda cheesy but I can still control myself.

  • @PetterVessel
    @PetterVessel Před rokem

    Don't worry about being sent to war. You two wouldn't be awake to experience Denmark surrender. 😉 Fjellape subscribed just because of this shot fire. 😆

  • @StevenMRA
    @StevenMRA Před rokem +1

    The audio when you two speak is a bit low - just trying to help, as I wanted to hear your commentary.

    • @coldnorthcreative
      @coldnorthcreative  Před rokem +1

      Well try and make it clearer next time, thanks for letting us know! Much appreciated

  • @UTube-gi1ct
    @UTube-gi1ct Před rokem

    I would like to know what you 2 think of the one take Videos of Ren? I know he actually is really hyped, but it’s worth it. Take a look … would love your Reaction 😊 btw like your Channel 👍

  • @fransnilsson7333
    @fransnilsson7333 Před rokem

    Didnt a scientific research show that all Danes are Swedes..Thats why you rock :D

  • @kimeklund8880
    @kimeklund8880 Před rokem

    🤘👊🏼🔥

  • @uMe_underground
    @uMe_underground Před rokem

    React to Ghost their videos is top notch. He Is, Square hammer,Rats , Cirice, Hunters moon...

  • @sundelldennis
    @sundelldennis Před rokem +3

    Next time- Do better resarch berfoce you react to it.. this just pissed me of, and i stop.. good luck...and i will try you agan as reactors 🙂

    • @coldnorthcreative
      @coldnorthcreative  Před rokem

      The premise is that we don't do research before, so you get a our first reaction. If we knew everything about the video, there wouldn't be much to react to.

    • @coupdegrace2767
      @coupdegrace2767 Před rokem +2

      @@coldnorthcreative yes, but it is a common knowledge that all of Sabaton works are based on the true historic events. Reacting to events, that actually transpired, as if it was some cheap blockbuster can obviously be considered disrespectful.

    • @sundelldennis
      @sundelldennis Před rokem

      ​@@coldnorthcreative
      Some bands play songs and some play themes, find out if the band plays themes and if so what the song is about! then you can react. It works for several others who do what you do. WITHOUT hearing the song first. And Sabaton in particular make songs about historical events that touch many people and some in recent history. It is about respect for those countries and among living relatives. But i get, my tip is to do a little resarch to every song before (with out listening to it) Good luck!! :-) Pease and Love!!😘

  • @jonpalsson4755
    @jonpalsson4755 Před rokem

    I understand you guys are reacting to the videos and not really the songs and there's no need to like it (I've seen you guys like some of Sabaton's songs in the past).
    I do like your guys' videos because it's fun to see people looking at the videos and not the songs. The sort of mocking comments early on though, i understand why they may rub some people the wrong way and i think you may have cost yourselves a huge audience from some Sabaton hardcore fans as well as people who think the subject matter itself is a highly senstive one, one which honestly, no band or historian in the world does a better job to pay homage to than this band.
    Do what you wish with this comment, or not, i will continue to watch and enjoy your videos in the future regardless.

  • @meamachne
    @meamachne Před rokem

    will ramos hypnosis vocal cover

  • @marietaandreeva304
    @marietaandreeva304 Před rokem +1

    Do you make sense of the lyrics or are you just giggling?

  • @RealityDysfunction85
    @RealityDysfunction85 Před rokem +4

    Your negative approach to this ruined it.

  • @swenartmann1670
    @swenartmann1670 Před rokem +2

    Bad reaction. U have lost me.