We made a REAL HOLOGRAM Desk like Tony Stark's!
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 04. 2024
- FlexiSpot Brand Day, use code "HS50" to get the best price of the year. Event extended until May 31st! (sponsored)
USA ► E7 (best seller): bit.ly/439exgL
USA ► E5 (best value): bit.ly/3pSdvrk
USA ► E7 (with chair): bit.ly/3WffYIp
CA ► E7 (best seller): bit.ly/3o23RS6
CA ► E5 (best value): bit.ly/3MHRZP1
If you want to own the same desk, join the bidding now at: www.flexispot.com/auction
Bambu Lab Ultra Fast 3D Printer ► shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=228215...
3D Scanner ► www.einscan.com/einscan-hx/
COLLECTIBLES, TOOLS & ACCESSORIES ► www.Hacksmith.store
Become a Hacksmith member and get exclusive perks! ► / @thehacksmith
SOCIAL
Instagram ► / thehacksmith
TikTok ► / thehacksmith
Facebook ► / thehacksmith
Twitter ► / thehacksmith
Discord ► discordapp.com/invite/thehack...
Shop ► www.hacksmith.store
SOFTWARE & Services:
PCB Design ► www.altium.com/asp/hacksmith
Spanish Dubbing ► youtubetranslation.mailchimps...
Video Review / Collaboration ► r.frame.io/pZq3N
Video Editing ► Adobe Premiere
CAD ► bit.ly/Solidworks4makers
3D printing filament + more @ Matterhackers ► www.matterhackers.com?aff=7638
TOOLS / MACHINES:
Our favorite toolkit ► www.ifixit.com/Shop/Hacksmith
Our Favorite Robot Dog & STEM learning platform ► bit.ly/3pMyqMR
Our new high tech laser cutter/engraver ► www.xtool.com/
Our Favorite Robot Dog + STEM learning platform ► droneblocks.io/robot-dogs
Battlebots 3D printing help by Elegoo's SLA machines ► www.elegoo.com/
Laser Engraver ► bit.ly/OMTechLaser - Use code HACKSMITH5OFF
Bambu Lab Ultra Fast 3D Printer ► shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=228215...
CNC Mill - Tormach 1100MX ► hubs.ly/H0B8DWG0
CNC Mill - Tormach PCNC 440 ► hubs.ly/H0B8DYk0
CNC Lathe - Tormach 15L ► hubs.ly/H0B8Gcp0
Autofeed Bandsaw - Tormach AF50 ► hubs.ly/H0B8Gj10
CNC Waterjet Cutter ► www.wazer.com/
CNC Plasma Cutter ► bit.ly/EMTplasma
3D Scanner ► amzn.to/2pwbvTu
Drills, drivers, grinders, saws, etc ► amzn.to/35qqbvy
Mig Welder ► amzn.to/3dxFBzk
Tig Welder ► amzn.to/3gmJclN
Oscilloscope ► bit.ly/38sOzKw
Multimeters ► bit.ly/2WKwPEQ
CAMERA GEAR:
Highspeed Cam - Chronos 2.1 ► www.krontech.ca/
Main shooter - Sony A7siii ► amzn.to/3amVsyN
Insta360 Cameras ► store.insta360.com/product/x3... (free selfie stick with this link!)
4K Webcam ► store.insta360.com/product/li...
Main mic - Rode Go II ► amzn.to/3toLsh3
Gimbal - DJI RS 2 ► amzn.to/3v0DFFs
Tripods - Manfrotto 504X ► amzn.to/2QB1Onh
Studio Lights - Nanlite ► amzn.to/3v6iWQr
Purchases made through some store links may provide some compensation to Hacksmith.
CHAPTERS:
0:00 James Gets Kidnapped
1:11 Charles Makes A Plan
2:55 Holograms?
4:38 Getting Perspective
7:59 Cookie Break
9:05 We Have A Chair Problem
10:09 Assembly
15:10 Phone Call With James
20:15 Bogdan Gets Stressed
21:01 It Works!
MUSIC:
Renegade Drive By Zoze
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Dance Rock Party 2 by James Grant
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Impenetrable Barrier by Moodmode
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Ideas That Spark Inspiration by Media Music Group
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Self Care On Valentines Day by The Turquoise Moon
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Breezy Vibes by The Turquoise Moon
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Thrill of the 80s by Eric Haley
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Say Yes by Sleeping Ghost
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
If I Think I Can Do It by Bzur
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Smooth Operator by Melodies in Motion
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Something is Coming by Leadsquid
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Early Morning by JCSD
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Synthwave Rock Fight by Oleksandr Koltsov
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
Cyberpunk Space by Loops Lab
Licensed from Storyblocks ►
www.storyblocks.com/
WARNING: THESE VIDEOS ARE FOR ENTERTAINMENT PURPOSES ONLY. PERSONAL USE OF VIDEO CONTENT IS AT YOUR OWN RISK. THE HACKSMITH IS A TRAINED PROFESSIONAL WHO KNOWS EXACTLY WHAT HE'S DOING. EXCEPT WHEN HE DOESN'T. DO NOT ATTEMPT TO RECREATE OR RE-ENACT ANYTHING SHOWN IN THESE VIDEOS. - Věda a technologie
Creating a hologram Iron Man table using our legs is pure genius! Huge kudos to this incredible project. Who knows, maybe you'll spot our E7 in the next Marvel movie!
Bruh
well, yeah
otherwise this video wouldn't have a leg to stand on
@@elisha175 Perfect comment.
First invisible PC now this?
Dam, how many CZcamsrs are you sponsoring? Linus Tech Tips now Hacksmith who is next?
The hologram grabbing and tracking tech has to be one of the coolest things I've ever seen
There's is a affordable tech just for the hand with the leaps motion
@Repent and believe in Jesus Christ bro wtf how is my Aunt Theresa finding me in CZcams comments let me be gay bro
Not perfecr if its not projected on free air molecule
@@prasektinanda8824 if it was the case you would burn the air and it would smell awful ( and not really safe)
18:16
*Audio:* "Jarvis, raise the screen."
*English Auto-generated subtitles:* "sharks racist"
XD
I think we all know it firmly by now, the first actual real lightsaber that doesn't rely on wires or anything is going to be made by the Hacksmith and his team. Cannot wait, it will blow the Internet.
if you mean one without a backpack or tether, they made a lightsaber staff that, while huge and having wires etc. on the inside, is completely self sufficient.
@@Atr3yu_lol
one already exists (wireless and made of real plasma, stand alone and everything)
@@Chill_lofi3396that’s because we’re in the future
No saber of light can ever be made or hologram period. How can you stop the light from traveling? Lame
As an engineer, the ease of workflow this could improve is astounding
Yeah, I could see this becoming a trend. They just showed the proof of concept and that it works. Now they either need to sell Bogdan's software or make it open source.
Probably would be much more useful to just use a vr headset like the quest pro
I think it has it's uses for sure, but honestly it seems pretty impractical to actually use for serious time crunched work. Not the hologram itself mind you, that's fine enough but it's the hand controls that make it a gadgetbahn in practice. Of course that's not their fault, they have sponsors and investors and workers to pay, so of course they can't go too in depth on the cons. Cons don't feed people, pros do. Unless your a con-man (badm tsss) /j
In the end I don't actually care how useful it actually is. I am a huge fan of making things especially impractical things, just because it's cool, interesting, and or fun. I'm happy just to see the concept come to life in some way.
@@TerrinX I 100% agree. At best it’s a proof of concept and at worst, it’s a cool party trick. I think it’s in the beginning stage of how the track ball mouse was. Or for that matter paper drafting drawings on boards compared to modern CAD.
I’m more excited to see the future of holographic tech integrated with AI or maybe even a form of telekinetic control. Still years away from either I’m sure but that could drastically lower time/improve designs
as an engineer, a powerful laptop looks infinitely more useful to me.
Ok, let me just say, this is freaking incredible. Seeing how y'all built that table, nothing short of geniousity. From the design, to the testing and modification, everything.
Geniousity? Now we all know how far from being a genius you are
Man, these people need to be part of CZcams top 10. They deserve that spot😊
I love how accurate they are when it comes to their engineering but when wood working is involved it goes to “that’s in the middle of that stud right?”
I laughed at that part. He proceeds to drill before even getting an answer lol
@@briondalion3696 oh these poor linear rails.....
That actually made me feel a little better about myself hahahah
Love how a “simple” desk that is anything but simple seems way more stressfull than any other project you guys have done 😂❤
@@DontReadMyProfilePicture.0ok I won’t
The rich friend's setup:
@@DontReadMyProfilePicture.0fine
I think the most stressful part was the screen
And lying on your back on the floor for hours
The display integration is very slick. Could probably use a counterweight system though. Also, one thing I learned having a Bambu on my main desk is: You shouldn't have a Bambu on your main desk. The vibrations can be felt at every corner. And when the cooling fan kicks on for a high speed print, I end up putting in noise cancelling earbuds.
well technically it's under the desk
this is beyond amazing and i can only hope that it will inspire not only future generations to continue this great work, but also inspire many more great designs and have this tech more openly available!
The table is cool and all but the fact you dropped that linear rail and no ball bearings came out is the real impressive thing
Captive balls 😏
used two weeks of luck 😂
timestamp?
@@jimli5049 8:02
God there's something about brilliant, charismatic, Canadian engineers making cool stuff in their element that just warms the heart like a campfire.
Imho got even better when they dropped all that over the top dramatisations and tests that didn't actually test much. Just some real engineering and problem solving
@@Shilka22 bros mad
yeah some real brilliant, charismatic, atractive, girthy, sweaty, strong canadian engineers will do the trick...
@@aitorleal4676 ayo?
Careful.. we are making too much power technologies and what if.. A1 Robot get hands on those and we are DOOMED! 😅
Great seeing James back but it's also great seeing everyone doing their bit makes everything at Hacksmith interesting and more of a working family love everyone brilliant content and brilliant projects
working with a team like this seems like a dream! seeing projects like this always bring out that excitement of watching something come together, i have always loved your videos, really glad to see that the hacksmith channel is still alive and well
Honestly, not having a real hologram makes this cooler. You have to think about it in a different way, and come up with a creative solution. This is what inspires me to be an engineer
if I had a nickel for every video about making a hologram desk today, I'd have 2 nickels- which isn't a lot, but it's odd it's happened twice
AND THEY'RE SPONSORED BY THE SAME COMPANY-
Lmao sameeee
I just finished with the other one and this popped up
Which is the other one?
@@AtharvaAgarwal1503 its from basicly homless
@@varunv7423 thanks
To me this is the coolest project you guys have done. It's a creators desk. Exactly what Tony Stark would have.
Huge kudos to James for letting his talented staff shine
Some big company need to sponsor these geniuses so we can see what human engineers can really make
Cheeeeeese also this is amazing
They definitely deserve it!
Hmmm
And then everything they do will disappear behind black project secrecy. Better to stay independent and visible.
This might be one of the coolest and most practical projects you guys have built. Absolutely amazing. So excited to see the innovation and talent you guys will bring to your future projects. Keep it up!
window
window
window
window
window
i noticed that the katana in the office on the wall is being displayed upside down, the bend is supposed to face up, that way the blade doesn’t dull in the saya (sheath).
This is one of those builds that's actually super useful in real life! I'm sure this is gonna make other builds a lot easier.
People like them are the reason why we'll probably have holographic display computers in the future. Kudos to to them 👍
I mean, what makes you think we don't already?
@@apex_prey well maybe we don't
@@fbiman9643 I know for sure the military has most likely already developed the tech, found it too hard to implement, and set it aside to come back to it later.
@@TAMAMO-VIRUS Maybe, military stuff has a tendency to go way over budget not because it has to but because the companies producing the stuff can get away with it, to an extent. When it gets to be too expensive and/or takes too long projects often get axed even if they actually had a lot of potential and the real problem was just companies milking Uncle Sam (or any other countries equivalent). We see this with other government run organizations as well such as NASA. The cost of a rocket from traditional manufactures is way higher than one from a private company and tend to have a lot more issues (at least compared to the more established private companies). To be clear and fair to NASA they have to deal with what they're given (an inconsistent budget that's way lower than it used to be) and deal with the whims of politicians. They try their best and have done quite well but the best they can do right now is award contracts to less traditional private companies who are willing and able to take risk to make rockets better using their own money.
Hmmm. They are perhaps going to develop holograms but they would perhaps be not used as often since there could also be smart contact lenses. With smart contact lenses and augmented and extended reality synchronized for multiple users the holographic technology would have some serious competion. I guess the contact lenses would require less energy for it to create visible outcome but could be costly for producing and for software running on it and computing all the augmented and extended reality. Tho perhaps hologram would require comparable producing cost and comparable computing power.
I’ve literally been dreaming of building a desk like this where my PC and printer retract into it for years so I could have a “workbench” and desk in one.
Can’t believe you guys built 95% of exactly what I was thinking. Wild!
@@noname-yy3zy literally just got recommended that video today. Saved it to my watch later list. Thanks for the tip tho!
@@garetht677 my main thing was wanting my PC on the desk cause it’s built as a display piece, but sometimes I’d like the work area too.
My desks now are two conference room desk style tables (on casters) that I have in an L shape. Considering how hard and expensive building an entire desk from scratch would be (and I don’t want to ruin what I have) I was thinking of instead just effectively making a cabinet that would sit in the corner of the L with the two desks against it and level with it, and that would raise / lower the PC.
Not sure if that would really work out better than just doing a whole desk, but I definitely need the space of an L desk if not more. (Basically 1 leg is computing and 1 is printing, but I’d like a work bench area too
"I'm gonna attack it with power tools is until it reveals its secrets" is the type of wordplay I want from engineering videos. It's like that quote about chipping away all the marble that isn't the statue.
That's absolutely incredible. One of the coolest things I've seen in a while.
I was literally thinking about holograms last night like Tony Starks desk, and was wondering if it had been invented yet or even possible. Crazy
Don't forget to check their FlexiSpot E7 standing desk sale at bit.ly/439exgL, and if you want to own the same hologram desk, join the bidding now at: www.flexispot.com/auction
Hello there!
I'm trying to make a super soldier serum
You should make star lords blasters and mask
Do you think you could miniaturise Batman’s grapple?
Joe Biden.
That's pretty amazing! But I can't stop thinking that having an AR HMD would have the same effect for the user and maybe better tracking all in one single package
Okay, lowkey, random thing I found the most impressive: The acceleration and deceleration programmed into the winches for the Screen and Printer before they even had the products on them. Most people don't take account inertia until it fucks them over.
Im just gonna flat out say it, this is one of the coolest projects you guys have done yet. Cant wait to follow along until the entire office becomes an Avengers tower
Edit: Grammer change because we gots ourselves some grammar dragons around here
Edit 2: YES I KNOW IT'S GRAMMAR NOT GRAMMER, in fact im keeping the first grammer just to mess with people.... ha
an*
Coolest*
grammar*
Grammar dragons 😂😂. I’m using that one.
Same this really is the coolest
Hacksmith Industries, you've done the impossible and brought Tony Stark's hologram desk to life! This is beyond incredible! The level of innovation and technical wizardry displayed in this video is mind-blowing. I can't even imagine the amount of effort, skill, and dedication that went into creating this real-life marvel. You've taken inspiration from the movies and turned it into a reality, proving that the future is closer than we think. Keep pushing the boundaries of what's possible, Hacksmith Industries! You're inspiring a new generation of inventors and dreamers. 🙌🔥
When VFX editor seeing real one:
If these guys can pull this off imagine what the pros can do
@@Peter-uo9km idk man i think they are the pros
@ーちゃんひなた no I'm talking about apple or Samsung or some government contractor. These guys are just youtubers so they are not as good as the best out there.
@@user-ql3ev5tb9o but Sony can't do better....teehee
That is really cool!
Now for it to be incredible, try to sync the two screens with the head-tracking thing and have the object 'float' in front of you. Sure there will be a bezel between the screens and the brightness might differ, but I bet it'd be very dope.
That's honestly so cool. They actually have made it real here.
This team has the most brilliant minds all working together to make revolutionary inventions. Love it.
This is honestly one of the coolest real world application projects you guys have done
Incredible! The spinning 3d scanner section is genius! All of it is insane!
I love how everyone works as a team. They have a good sense of cooperation and camaraderie. And I find it very very entertaining to watch all your videos and I love the dedication you put into your projects. After finishing my university degree I would love to help you with your projects and work with you.
*sees notification*
*frantically grabs snacks and plants my butt in a seat*
The thumbnail already looks so cool, can't wait to see how you all developed this. Also hope you are doing well! Take care. 👌🏽
Seeing this from start to finish really makes you love it even more. The amount of hard work put into it is insane!
honestly at first i thought the screen would be in the middle on something to make it spin so the screen can follow the person, but keep whatever is projected as a 3-D object in the same position all the way around so as it turns to follow you could walk from the front to the back of the object
Wow! Incredible way to apply existing technology to create a working analogue of Stark Tech!
As Somebody who works in the art industry and a Machinist who does constant metalworking fabrication and welding.... This is by far one of the coolest things you guys have ever made
When I watch these videos I also wonder “could this be an actual product?” And this feels like one of the best unions of practicality and sci-fi spectacle y’all have ever made. I’m sure it would cost a small fortune to buy a table like this but gimme 10 years and I will save the money to buy it
Well, to be honest the only thing you need is the transparent oled screen and tracking camera. Everything else is a bonus
That being said, the cost of the oled screen will set you back about 10k
The UI/UX of this is pretty cool by itself, and in itself, it could probably be an actual product.
@@Random_dud31 I mean, if you're gonna actually use this for work, you don't really _need_ the transparent oled, as cool as it is
@@Random_dud31 the biggest thing is the proprietary tracking software and wench system and a super high graphics card to run the rendering.
@ECHO E you're right. Thats actually so obvious. How'd i miss that? Haha
Lol, I’m just a regular dude that knows nothing about any of this but it super dope. 🎉 Congrats on the super awesome tech and design. Can’t wait to see what you guys come up with next!
Outstanding build on a Tony Stark budget. Loving the screen setup, Thanks
This is probably one of the coolest and most useful builds you guys have accomplished so far on this channel! Suddenly, all the future tech I've been seeing in movies is looking a little bit more tangible. :)
Absolutely amazing! this desk is a work of art. I can't wait till the common person has access to this incredible technology!
Hats off for you guys.....most genuine and ahead of it's time lab ❤
This build was so much more complicated than I had imagined!
Okay, I gotta say, I really really like this dude. It was a ton of fun watching him make this build and I hope we get to see more of him in the future!
I'm so glad we live in an era where people like you can generate revenue from things like this. Making it possible for us to see. I mean, this is stuff I always dreamed about as a kid (just doing things for how cool they are) but of course at that age you fail to see the money that has to go into it. It's just awesome to see. Thanks!
This build is amazing! I 100 percent see this being the future
Replace the printed gears with metal and install fairly tight rollers for tv guidance if rope wench doesn't work use liner actuators or screw drive.
It cracks me up how you reframe woodworking as advanced interrogation techniques. "Become a chair!" and the wood is like "Neva!" and then you pull out the chisels "I didn't want to have to use these"
That is such an amazing desk! This is helpful for engineering, but I can also see a use for 3D animation too! Blender animations with AR on a hologram-like screen is now my dream! Great job everyone, you outdid yourselves as always!
This is one of the coolest things I have seen yet. Wish I could build my own.
which means it can only get better and as technology won't ever stop improving. i cant wait to see what they will make 5 plus years from now even better upgrades and inventions
Im so happy to see that this channel is still going after many years of watching. :)
I knew there had to be a gimmick to replace the holograms, what with real ones not being anything like Tony's and all, but tbh I really did not expect it to function and sell so well. Cool as hell.
I wish you could have done a follow up to let us know if its actually useful as you design with it.
You guys deserve lot more than just appreciations
Honestly out of everything that these guys have made this should be an actual product you can buy for 3D modeling, designing, and printing.
This is really cool!
I need 10 of those transparent OLED displays for... reasons...
One of the most innovative things I’ve seen imagine in a couple months and then a couple years with more and more optimized machinery and code what we could actually turn the field of engineering into with something like this
If there was ever a perfect tagline for this channel, "I'm gonna attack it with power tools" is a pretty good one.
the amount of knowledge , skills , creativity , energy in the project is amazing ! good work guyz :D
This is the most practical and beautiful project yall have made. Keep it in this direction, thus has so many applications, it's unreal.
15:25 ayo what was he doing 😧
This desk is so cool and it looks so good. Keep up the good work
surprised you didn't put foam or something on either side of the slot to prevent the TV from wobbling forward and backward quite so much when moving, i'd be so nervous every time it moved considering how expensive it was lol
honestly, i love this thing though. you should iterate and sell it to designers. i want one. my friend wants one. it's the bomb
You guys really nailed it on this one I gotta say. I think this is hands down the coolest practical use project you guys have ever done!
I love these guys because they are just people. They show exactly what I expect it is to build something like that with a crew
Hehehe glad you guys like these chairs. I make the back framework 😊
Okay so these people are just the coolest group of guys on the planet huh? Got it 🤙🏼🤙🏼
Im so happy y’all are doing more high tech engineering stuff instead of the “the biggest…” or “the heaviest” and etc back to the original and I love it
Very cool. It just makes you think how close we are to actually having something at the same level as Tony Stark for his work station.
I have been dreaming of making one of these things for years. You guys did it.
What an amazing team with unbelievable ideas AND follow-through
My god this desk is one of the most amazing things ive honestly ever seen. Truly great build
Just...whoah.....you guys reached an astounding level through these years. Thats what teamwork, enthusiasm and hours of work can do, you really make dreams come true.
Good luck, you brainiacs and warm hearted geniuses
It’s crazy to me that when I was a kid all this stuff was just make believe. Unbelievable work.
Idk what to say. It's just so cute and effective. Casual but methodical. Mindblowing but expected. I'm commenting as I'm near the 15-minute mark so Idk the result of this entire assembly, but I hope I can see Leia's holo asking you guys for help despite this being IronMan's WorkDesk. For some stupid reason.
Nerdgasm, that's how I would describe this with one word. Such a fantastic proof of concept of what's possible, when you combine so many fields of modern technology into one piece of high-tech. Love the collaboration between all the Hacksmith experts to make this real.
So when do you start manufacturing these and accept orders for such a desk?
You guys making something is like watching the universe being built, it’s breathtaking
I actually got to try something out that was somewhat similar on a field trip at school, but more really just the "hologram" stuff, and it was with a laptop, not a transparent TV. It was still really cool though!
You guys are my spirit brothers! When you said we'll design an elevator for the 3d printer I let out a huge f bomb YES!!!
This was one of the most realistic and amazing projects. Awesome Work!
Why is the bid at $1000000000000000.00 💀
Torsion springs on the monitor lift would help take the weight off the motors/gears and give you a more gradual and consistent lift. Look at how garage doors work for comparison. Also, rear projection on a piece of glass might have worked as well.
I HAVE THAT CHAIR. Anyways, I am a sophomore in highschool just started engineering; I appreciate your channel so much and it makes me love engineering even more. It looks so fun and seems to be a worth while experience!
It was really cool to see the unscripted parts of the team working together to finish before the deadline. That thing is sick
i like how the curent bid is 1 quadrilion
The hologram software is next level on the actual screen ! Suddenly feeling the urge to master unity before the end of this summer XD
You all are the reason I am pursuing engineering.
I hope to meet yall one day!
I hope Basically Homeless uses this for his invisible setup. (they had the same sponsor too)
I had an idea about making one like this. You guys actually gave me an even better idea of how to make it.
cant wait to see how you guys progress in the future
A new thing added to my bucket list, meeting Hacksmith and team ♡
Man I’d love to get to the level of knowledge you guys have in designing ideas and making them real, it is so impressive what you guys are capable of.
Just get into it. They have to do research on all the parts, planning, testing and failing just like you do. In the videos stuff like this might look like a fun little weekend project for a smart engineer but in reality it takes weeks and month to get everything planned and set up. Once you break down everything into single pieces and functions and work on it one by one it becomes manageable. You dont need any special knowledge ot skills to build this desk, just time and patience.
@@oO0Xenos0Oo well said