It is, but it's hard to prove in court. My friend's ex called CPS on her all the time because he was trying to get custody, but she couldn't prove it was him because it was "anonymous"
I completely agree it happened to me before and they had a 10 year record of it but the people that came the caseworker said there was absolutely no truth to what was being told to them which I knew it was simply just revenge just people being cruel
Thank you! I was looking for this comment. Everyone is talking shite about one or the other... they're BOTH unhinged. Something was slightly humorous about the defendant, but I think because she is young and I hope she matures. The plaintiff is something else.
@@KPbouj Right?! She threw that “wh%re” word around real easy, on something she made up in her head about the defendant. That was a messy but entertaining case. Feel for the kid & the dog.
Yep. Some commenter said it could be they're away on business, or visiting family somewhere. Don't know whether to laugh or cry at how naive and/or stupid some people are.
he wasn't supposed to be in the house at all. the lease she had her agree to said no men in the house. Yet the defendant kept breaking that time and time again in just a short week.
Yes she loves the drama. Calling someone a whore is bound to start a fight. I'm mad the judge didn't call her out for that but went hard for her being called a white lady 🙄. She is white tf sont they ask for a description
he wasn't even supposed to be there, the lease specificially said no men. Which is a thing women who are victims of DV and SA do, yet the defendant broke that stipulation on the daily starting day 1.
@@dragames right but breaking your lease in one way or another is a civil matter. putting your hands on somebody in hopes they put their hands on you back so you have “evidence” for court is criminal. she assaulted him first in order to pretend to be a victim of assault by him. that’s insane 😭
The landlord is trying to play victim when she called his sister a whore several times and tried to tell him he should help care for his nephew to provoke them. She’s a nasty vindictive person herself. She thinks she’s inferior because she’s a stripper
What else would you call someone who sluts around?????? The defendant is renting from her and he has no authority to stay there because he is not on the lease..... don't defend her
I have had 2 separate friends ask if they can move into my house with my son and I in the last month. I very nicely said I'm sorry but no. One of them is very annoyed with me. I would have preferred she hadn't asked, and I wouldn't have had to say no. But I'm with you, don't want anyone renting a room in my house.
The plaintiff doesn't have clean hands in all of this. She was just as aggressive as the defendant and her brother. The ruling was correct...although some of the evidence appears staged.
I believe that the plaintiff was a conniving & scandalous individual but I do believe that the defendant did tell the plaintiff that she was a Dancer, Stripper & Escort because to make such an unsubstantiated statement would clearly leave the plaintiff open to a Libal Suit in a Civil Court & the plaintiff, from what I've seen in this court proceeding,, is not that stupid.
@@AP-uo7sp Yes, there certainly is a difference between being a stripper & a prostitute & I don't think that the plaintiff, whom I'm sure is no stranger to the law, would have made such a reckless accusation had she not been able to substantiate it for fear of being sued by the defendant in a Civil Court for libel. I also don't believe that any woman would smile/giggle, as the defendant did after having such a disrespectful & demeaning statement made about them.
No, that part wasn't the lie, even the brother in the video says "so what" which solidifies they both know she is. plus, when the defendant says she doesn't have paystubs for her other job, that's because it's illicit. In otherwords, she was hookin.
The defendant should’ve counter sued for punitive damages because lady called CPS on her. How dare the plaintiff be judgmental calling the woman a whore when her husband is locked up.
You don't believe that child is at risk having a mother like that who not only moves in with strangers, but then creates the scenario to cause strife by not only refusing to PAY the rent, but bringing in people that was outside the agreed contract?
@@LeeoGoneWild not really. What if she worked over night at a warehouse, would it make any difference? Honestly if the plaintiff didn’t say anything about her being a stripper we wouldn’t have known.
But she didn't touch him first, he slapped at the phone first,(which IS in fact, assault) then advanced on her. She raised her hand up 2 block his advance and he shoved her... Seems like so many of you in the comments see what you want 2 see...If someone just smacked your phone out of your hand and then advanced on YOU, are you REALLY saying that you wouldn't put your hands up 2 defend YOURSELF??? C'mon....That is BULLSHIT!
Plaintiff is definitely an instigator. She has no business saying all that mess to her brother, or about the nephew. So what if he wants to be there for his nephew? How is that a bad thing? But if she asked him to leave he should’ve just left to avoid drama. Even if she’s wrong for trying to start something; which you can’t convince me wasn’t the goal when she’s filming it.
It's bad because the plaintiff's rent requirement was no men. This is common for women who require roommates who were victims of DV or SA. By that, the defendant had 0 right to give her key to another man.
The plaintiff is doing what white women do and start ish then act like they are the victims! Had she called my sister a whore she would have been taken out in a stretcher but its amazing how the judge chastise the black girl for calling the white woman a white woman but is silent when the white woman called her a prostitute and a whore .. I didnt realize that calling a white woman a white woman is now racist but hey society is working hard for white people to feel like a victim .
It's heartbreaking hearing the baby crying in the background of the videos the plaintiff used for evidence. Adults need to stop having arguments in front of children, period. It's extremely traumatizing.
That plaintiff is crazy! Antagonizing complete strangers is dangerous. She seemed to reveal in it. Her mouth was reckless. They could have exed her out in her own home. All over dogs & cigarettes. Smh!
The brother showed more restraint than a lot of people would've been able to her with her screaming and throwing a fit like that saying all that about his sister
@@mollyscot1563No no go back and watch 13:24-13:34 even the judge says it clear as day your hands are on his NECK and he PUSHED you off of him have some accountability
@@namjoonssexybrain1679 He hit her phone and got up to her, she had her hand out, then he hit her again. He had 0 right. He actually had 0 right to be in there when the contract with the person who set them both up told her that there was to be NO MEN in the house, and her brother is *gasp* a man.
@@dragames Your confuse or being emotional. Yes they have no right to be in her space. BUT yes he had the right to shove her because she held his neck. Imagine a dude grabbing a lady neck. Do you expect her to let it happen. No. She touched him first. You can't hit someone and not expect not to be hit. There's a reason why the cops and judge didn't side with that lady for so called getting touched. If someone was choking you, you will not do nothing. You will push them away.
The world has always been like this. The only difference between "Today & Yester Year" is that we now have videos showing/memorializing such events & the worst is yet to come. LOL
@dessean1 No it is worse. People take pride in their bad behaviour. When I grew up you were ashamed to disrespect and abuse people and get into trouble. People have no shame and it's ALL about ME.😢
That lady DEFINITELY damaged her own futon. She seem like the type. From she can be spiteful and lie to have that lady's child taken away, she can be spiteful and lie about a damaged futon.
My mom is mentally ill. She had a lady renting a room once. My mom stabbed furniture and walls with a butcher knife, then was convinced her renter did it. One of the scariest thing i dealt with. This plaintiff is unhinged and crazy. She was screaming and instigating a fight so he would hit her and she could claim it was all their fault. On the flip side, the renter had NO BUSINESS moving a man into the house when she signed a lease stating no men. So theyre both wrong!!! Everyone is the problem.
Some people will damage their own property to go to court and get the person they are mad at to pay for it if you don’t have real proof I don’t think that’s fair
Hi. To be fair, I’m glad people rented to my mom when I was a baby. She was an attentive mother and is great tenant, always left the place better than she found it. Landlords are ALWAYS sad when she says she’s moving. There are many good mothers out there who are young and single. Okay, well, take care & wish you & everyone well & all the best!
And what does the plaintiff comes off as?. I'm pretty sure the video recordings show what a nasty and immature person she was. Slaughter the girl, calling her out of her name and grabbing her brother by the NECK. Quit with the double standards.
Goddamn so many morons here. She had the defendant agree to the lease (yet signed late) to not bringing any men around. This is the type of thing women who are victims of DV and SA do. Which means likely her husband was arrested for DV, and the plaintiff probably suffers PTSD from it and wants no men around, and here we are with the defendant and her trashy ass brother breaking that and refusing to leave, and not only that, hits the plaintiff twice.
She disrespecting that man's sister the way she was doing, can't say had I been in his position, I would not have done the same thing, she was wrong for that!
@@magicworld3242 But here's the thing, it's her house, he was never given permission to enter, and repeatedly asked to leave. By all rights, if a stranger walked into your house and refuse to leave, you can legally hit them if you feel threatened; it's the Castle Doctorine. If he would've left when he was ordered to, he wouldn't have gotten slapped.
Yeah I agree, she should have never called his sister a whore, that's so disrespectful, & then she tried turning the heat onto the siblings relationship when she kept saying he wasn't the father of the child, his sister was taking advantage of him since he was the one taking care of the baby at night, and it wasn't his place to do so. To me, he seemed like a solid guy who loves his nephew. He just was the one who got put in the middle.
@@Fribee83 , But here's the thing. He didn't break into her house. He was there visiting his sister. Just because someone is in your house, doesn't give you permission to assault them. The cops saw the video and that's why, he didn't get arrested. The cops knew, they would have to arrest her too.
I love how the plaintiff acts so scared of the defendant and playing the victim but in the video she has her hand around the brothers neck and calling his sister out of her name, but you allowed her to move into your home (because your psychotic *SS needed the money) smh weirdo!!!
I love how blind you are. The brother wasn't supposed to be there 100%. Was told to leave and he didn't. He would be legally, a trespasser. Second, he hit her first, she put her hand out, and then he hit her again. The first hit, the phone falls to the floor. Second is after she has her hand to push him back after HE rushed up to her, not the other way around. The problem starts with plaintiff's broker who set them both up without disclosing the defendant's occupation and further the defendant refusing to obey any of the rules.
The defendant is not blameless at all but that plaintiff is BONKERS. I 100% believe she burned the futon herself and put that butt print there are on her own.
Tbh no one in this situation has clean hands. The plaintiff was a piece of shit and wanted to trigger the defendant and the defendant was in her emotions. They both need to get help. Only one I feel bad for is the baby.
I don’t why she ignored the part about the plaintiff dragging the defendant calling her a whore and prostitute and calling her brother dirty and yelling in his face to provoke him. And then she acted blind when she saw the video and ignored the fact that the plaintiff grabbed the brother by the neck. If the brother didn’t point it out to her she would’ve let it slide.
Biases are with you all. JM is just often wrong / overlooks many things. It has impacted white people, black people, men, women, Asian people… But the only time it’s “bias” in comments is when it’s a black person. Of course when a black person handily wins y’all are nowhere to be seen crying about how bias JM is… hmm. She can just be wrong without it being racial bias as you’re implying. It wouldn’t be the first time she’s wrong.
The defendant thinks that she can put on this sweet little voice and pretend to be all innocent when everyone can see straight past it. But the plaintiff is beyond a piece of work. The pillow, the video, she’s an instigator. I would never want to rent a place from her.
@@imartinistexactlyyy, I keep seeing that comment but how she was talking on the video to the police was the exact same. Too many inconsistencies with the plaintiff and I don’t understand how people make an oath and still lie in court lol
@@imartinist of course she used her sweet voice on the cops . i want to hear her real ghetto voice , like how she talks to people on the streets where she is hookin .
I'm not condoning the behavior of the defendants but the plaintiff seems to be a very awkward woman. She's acting like the defendants are such horrible people and she herself is a saint who does no wrong. But it's pretty obvious the plaintiff has just as much personal problems and the husband she speaks of is obviously in jail.
Both are crazy but the plaintiff over stepped her boundaries when it came to the baby and she definitely hit the brother so he had a right to shove her back.
@@inukoko2012 I agree with they're all crazy. Just noting he assaulted her first. None of what she said as shitty as it was is illegal, she was baiting him tho
@@inukoko2012 oh yeah, she provoked him and he took the bait. He assaulted her in her home after she withdrew his invitation. Sounds like she was shooting for grounds for restraining order against them to kick them out easier then evicting them. Prime example of why words shouldn't provoke a physical reaction
@@kennethbaker5223 It is quite clear and if you don't see it, that's on you. I don't think I need to explain myself to opinion warriors over the internet 💁♀️.
@@DJLadyRyan33 you must be thinking of only "American history". White Slavic people used to be slaves. Involved in genocides and even more atrocities. Learn a bit more. Racism comes from ALL races and discriminates against ANY race
Idk why the judge is mad about her calling the police to come before she beat the plantiff’s ass. At least she took the right course of action 🤷🏾♀️ if she had beat the plaintiff then it would be another story
The plaintif being so evil and aggresive WHEN SHE WAS RECORDING tells me she is completely unhinged. The defendant really needs to check herself and GROW THE F UP for her and that poor baby.
I think they both have a crazy streak 😂 Also, if the defendant admits to she actually did why would she lie about anything? But she still cray cray...just like the plaintiff.
Why didn't the defendant & her brother just get their own place if he's going to be with the baby at night? Had she explained that ahead of time it probably wouldn't have gotten so crazy between them. Both ladies seem a little out there, but in completely different ways, lol!
I find it very suspicious that she knows exactly what the substance is and exactly how it was put there but didn't see it happen… I'm talking about the cushion situation, but they are both nuts, so I don't put it past either one of them
@@tabwab83 exactly! Then, she tried to come off as innocent and a victim but the way she was talking in that recording.... I was like oh, she was TRYING to rile them up so she could get a negative reaction on video. If she was talking to the girl like that, no wonder she was telling the police "I don't want to have to beat this lady up." 🤣🤣🤣 I would never say no mess like that, but it had to be about more than the money at that time. On the other hand, the way the brother was saying "you're saying WE don't live here and all of OUR stuff is here... the homeowner was frustrated and they definitely overstayed their welcome at that point. She only signed up for 1 roommate.
I feel like her family came over and were extremely sweet in order to get their daughter out of their hair!!! get her binding into a contract so she would definitely have a place to live her brother should have babysit at his parents house. So glad this lady does not have to put up with this dangerous situation.
Something I have learned in my 42 years of being a landlord.....every time you 'help someone out' that needs a break it is very expensive for you the landlord. The reason they are in the pickle they are in is 95% of the time their own irresponsibility then it becomes your problem once they move in.
This was great. Everytime the defendant said "That's a lie." The Plaintiff produced the receipts to prove it was the defendant lying. I haven't laughed this much in ages.
The plaintiff lied too saying she didn't know what a stripper was, gtfoh. Old as she looks there's just no way that's true. The plaintiff just wanted the money that's why she let her move in before verifying income and collecting W-2's.
@@miloperrault2614what she meant was that she didn't know that when the defendant said stripper, what she REALLY meant was an escort...BIG difference...
@@snoopholmab2177you do realize he first hit her when he knocked the phone out of her hand(that's assualt). Her pushing him away is her defending herself at that point. And then he shoves her which is more to his assault. Learn the law
All that evidence was staged. Please if ure there while she is moving out and mind u sge said there with her dog in her right hand and she destroyed the place u just gon let her leave really. If the police kept being called wouldn't she have a police report. She didn't even report ot she just took pictures. Plus that cig butt was short af for someone to have smoked it. I feel like the lady staged ot to get the money. Even the stuff left behind wouldn't take an hr to throw away. Idk what the judge was listening to plus a pears the lady and girl boutthe same size so again the couch def could've been staged plus she had a picture of the baking soda so again she had to have seen it before she left.
The defendants brother is the only normal one out of the three. The plaintiff is terrible liar. The way she setup the brother was despicable. The stripper is cute.
How the fuck is the brother normal? He hit her twice, he refused to leave when he had no right to be there in the first place especially since the lease said "no men in the house" the fact he had KEYS is fucking insane past the initial point and definitely a violation of landlord/roommate rights. You're not allowed to make keys without the landlords permission.
This generation, OMG HAS ZERO REGARD FOR ANYTHING , THE LANDLORD IS A KAREN ,SO THEY ARE BOTH ADDICTED TO DRAMA , THIS WAS DOOMED TO FAIL FROM THE BEGINNING, WHAT DISASTER, SMH 😡
@@kay22100 = Why do you have to spell everything out for certain people in the back, SMH from the very beginning, after she told her she was a a stripper, she began to look down her nose at her, which makes her a judgemental Karen, who is nosier than Judge Milian, if you have reservations about someone's occupation ,just don't rent to them, that simple
I hate when older generations say things like this. Our generation may be bad but y’all just didn’t have cameras to record everything. Let’s not act like the older gens didn’t have slaves, segregation. Or even having to implement the laws of today. Let’s not act like y’all don’t have decades of serial killers and didn’t sweep family molesters or rapist under the rugs. Let’s not act like y’all didn’t need work laws. I just don’t understand it when y’all say this generation is worse. It’s so much more too
This ruling was wrong. I have NO CLUE what yall were watching. You can look at the plaintiff's mannerisms and tell that she is over-the-top and actually crazy. I don't doubt that she damaged her own property. I'm confident her "husband," if he even exists, is in prison because she framed him because she looks like the type. The fact that she was recording and had no problem putting her hands on the defendant's brother speaks VOLUMES. Also, Judge not catching her put hands on the man's neck until he called it out was problematic. Making the defendant pay the month when the host company has a different set of rules regarding breaking lease and charging NOTHING for the suffering after that nutcase called DCF? This ruling was wrong.
The plaintiff was also out of line. She clearly turned a blind eye to some things as a matter of convenience. Stripper $$ pays the rent just like butcher $$. It is probably when the defendant pushed her luck that the plaintiff snapped like Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest. Definitely some displaced anger. And the husband is, "away?" like in out in the garden pushing up daisies?
When the plaintiff said "Her husband is away". That's (code) for, "Her husband is in prison".
Thank you, I thought the same thing 😂
And she probably put him there by her lies. She's trouble
I was waiting for the judge to ask where like she normally would smh
I peeped that 😂
Bingo!!!!
“she told me she was a stripper, at first i didn’t understand what she meant” 😑 girl you knew
Lmfao
It's pretty self-explanatory. 😂😂😂
Right she knew especially since her husband is in jail
If this ain't the most realest comment I've seen on CZcams! 😂😂😂😂
she didnt understand right away that stripper was code for hooker .
Using CPS as a weapon should be illegal.
Judge Judy won’t tolerate it
It is, but it's hard to prove in court. My friend's ex called CPS on her all the time because he was trying to get custody, but she couldn't prove it was him because it was "anonymous"
I completely agree it happened to me before and they had a 10 year record of it but the people that came the caseworker said there was absolutely no truth to what was being told to them which I knew it was simply just revenge just people being cruel
Making false reports is illegal more than 2 times is a 3rd degree felony
You can absolutely press criminal charges for false cps reports. The cops will get the person who called it in
I think both the plaintiff and the defendant are out their damn minds
Thank you! I was looking for this comment. Everyone is talking shite about one or the other... they're BOTH unhinged. Something was slightly humorous about the defendant, but I think because she is young and I hope she matures. The plaintiff is something else.
Even Doug called it out “you are pretty salty yourself” 😂
@@KPbouj Right?! She threw that “wh%re” word around real easy, on something she made up in her head about the defendant. That was a messy but entertaining case. Feel for the kid & the dog.
@ashleycarr4974, I totally agree with you.
I think this is a fake story to be on TV
One thing about judge Milian, she doesn’t appreciate anyone using CPS as revenge.
@@Michael-cp6gr Judge Judy was a judge in family court
No Judge should!!!
There aren't enough people who work there so false calls take away time from real cases. That's why there are so many let downs by CPS workers.
doesnt matter if she also wanted revenge , she was still right to inform cps regarding the unstable situation the child was in .
@@dunkinjunkie586899oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Husband is away…Paternity Court taught me that means he is locked up.
Yep. Some commenter said it could be they're away on business, or visiting family somewhere. Don't know whether to laugh or cry at how naive and/or stupid some people are.
She's probably the reason he's in prison
Yeah normally when they say he is away it means they are locked up...
And?
Exactly!
The plaintiff didn’t know what a stripper was??? PUhlease! 🙄. She’s a total Karen provoking them and playing victim.
She was baiting him she is not innocent
he wasn't supposed to be in the house at all. the lease she had her agree to said no men in the house. Yet the defendant kept breaking that time and time again in just a short week.
She didn't bait her into not paying rent.
And she goes to church....wonder how her God feels about her behavior. I guess she can just go to confession and it's all forgiven
Plaintiff was trying to trigger an emotional response from. The brother you can tell she’s a sneaky one
You can definitely tell she enjoys the drama and provokes it
Yes she loves the drama. Calling someone a whore is bound to start a fight. I'm mad the judge didn't call her out for that but went hard for her being called a white lady 🙄. She is white tf sont they ask for a description
he wasn't even supposed to be there, the lease specificially said no men. Which is a thing women who are victims of DV and SA do, yet the defendant broke that stipulation on the daily starting day 1.
@@dragames right but breaking your lease in one way or another is a civil matter. putting your hands on somebody in hopes they put their hands on you back so you have “evidence” for court is criminal. she assaulted him first in order to pretend to be a victim of assault by him. that’s insane 😭
The landlord is trying to play victim when she called his sister a whore several times and tried to tell him he should help care for his nephew to provoke them. She’s a nasty vindictive person herself. She thinks she’s inferior because she’s a stripper
Exactly
Right?!? And then wants to make herself so innocent by using the word “derrière” in court when talking about the defendants butt.
She was telling him he SHOULDNT help her with his nephew bc he wasn't his child..
the lady really is nuts.
What else would you call someone who sluts around?????? The defendant is renting from her and he has no authority to stay there because he is not on the lease..... don't defend her
@@jaynehogue2459stripping means you slut around?? It’s stripping not having sex you need to get out more
“she said she was a BUTCHer and a STTTRIPPer” The way she said it, was hilarious
Anyone who voluntarily roommates with a stranger (outside of college) is crazy. No way I could ever trust a random person that much.
I don’t care how desperate I am, I would never rent a room out of my home to anyone, especially a complete stranger!
Not a stranger no maybe siblings or parents But that doesn't always work out good either.
Yeah I’ve done it before when I was younger when I had an extra room and rent was super high but it was a horrible experience. I’d never do it again
I have had 2 separate friends ask if they can move into my house with my son and I in the last month. I very nicely said I'm sorry but no. One of them is very annoyed with me. I would have preferred she hadn't asked, and I wouldn't have had to say no. But I'm with you, don't want anyone renting a room in my house.
Pickles you did the right thing!👍
@@kimr5479 thanks :)
The plaintiff doesn't have clean hands in all of this. She was just as aggressive as the defendant and her brother. The ruling was correct...although some of the evidence appears staged.
I agree that they are both unhinged
All the video did was show how awful of a person the plaintiff is.
Definitely appears staged
💯
Both parties wanted 15 minutes of fame....
Plaintiff straight up lied about the "escort" thing to make her case look better😂
I believe that the plaintiff was a conniving & scandalous individual but I do believe that the defendant did tell the plaintiff that she was a Dancer, Stripper & Escort because to make such an unsubstantiated statement would clearly leave the plaintiff open to a Libal Suit in a Civil Court & the plaintiff, from what I've seen in this court proceeding,, is not that stupid.
@@dessean1 there's a difference in stripper and prostitute. Plaintiff lied.
@@AP-uo7sp Yes, there certainly is a difference between being a stripper & a prostitute & I don't think that the plaintiff, whom I'm sure is no stranger to the law, would have made such a reckless accusation had she not been able to substantiate it for fear of being sued by the defendant in a Civil Court for libel. I also don't believe that any woman would smile/giggle, as the defendant did after having such a disrespectful & demeaning statement made about them.
@@AP-uo7spIt is?
No, that part wasn't the lie, even the brother in the video says "so what" which solidifies they both know she is.
plus, when the defendant says she doesn't have paystubs for her other job, that's because it's illicit. In otherwords, she was hookin.
The defendant should’ve counter sued for punitive damages because lady called CPS on her. How dare the plaintiff be judgmental calling the woman a whore when her husband is locked up.
I believe that the plaintiff was being vindictive when she called CPS but the child is at risk & that should be the main concern of everyone.
You don't believe that child is at risk having a mother like that who not only moves in with strangers, but then creates the scenario to cause strife by not only refusing to PAY the rent, but bringing in people that was outside the agreed contract?
@@dragamesI'm with you here.
Huh? Mom is out every single night while her brother watches her, but is out smoking every night while the baby is crying? CPS!!!!
@@LeeoGoneWild not really. What if she worked over night at a warehouse, would it make any difference? Honestly if the plaintiff didn’t say anything about her being a stripper we wouldn’t have known.
Mighty funny Milian didn't see that the plaintiff touched the defendant's brother first in the video until he pointed it out.
But she didn't touch him first, he slapped at the phone first,(which IS in fact, assault) then advanced on her. She raised her hand up 2 block his advance and he shoved her... Seems like so many of you in the comments see what you want 2 see...If someone just smacked your phone out of your hand and then advanced on YOU, are you REALLY saying that you wouldn't put your hands up 2 defend YOURSELF??? C'mon....That is BULLSHIT!
@@giondennis6808 You sound just as unhinged as the plaintiff. 🤪🤪
You and I know why she didn't “see” what the plaintiff did.
I don't think it's a good idea to be renting a room in a house/apartment occupied by other people when you will have children living with you.
Never a great choice. Their just as broke as the renter
That’s the city girl life lol
😅😅
Absolutely not, an emergency situation is one thing, but normal circumstances, definitely not....
Well she’s trash. What do you expect?
Plaintiff is definitely an instigator. She has no business saying all that mess to her brother, or about the nephew. So what if he wants to be there for his nephew? How is that a bad thing?
But if she asked him to leave he should’ve just left to avoid drama. Even if she’s wrong for trying to start something; which you can’t convince me wasn’t the goal when she’s filming it.
Especially because she dropped that she's an aunt herself as a defense when she got called out over the retaliatory CPS call.
It's bad because the plaintiff's rent requirement was no men. This is common for women who require roommates who were victims of DV or SA. By that, the defendant had 0 right to give her key to another man.
@@dragamesagree
Thank you for your contribution to our society 😊
The plaintiff is doing what white women do and start ish then act like they are the victims! Had she called my sister a whore she would have been taken out in a stretcher but its amazing how the judge chastise the black girl for calling the white woman a white woman but is silent when the white woman called her a prostitute and a whore ..
I didnt realize that calling a white woman a white woman is now racist but hey society is working hard for white people to feel like a victim .
“8 month year old” got me 😂
Lololol that’s what the trainer at the child care facility I work at says too
Lol i was looking for this comment i was like huh surprised jm didnt say anything
The comment I was looking for lol😂
I was looking for this comment. Smh the way the judge always lets that slide when people say it, judge Judy would never 😭😂
@crown7637 Judge Judy wouldn't have let half of this stuff happen lol
It's heartbreaking hearing the baby crying in the background of the videos the plaintiff used for evidence. Adults need to stop having arguments in front of children, period. It's extremely traumatizing.
It’s a baby it’s not like it will remember that incident 🤣
My parents argued my whole life, it's not traumatizing 😂 Not every bad thing that happens has to be "trauma"...
He'll probably have a lifetime of this kind of behavior to look forward too
@@joeslinky the trauma stays in the brain. It happened to me.
Exactly, and this coming from a woman (me) who was subjected to fighting adults as a kid.
That plaintiff is crazy! Antagonizing complete strangers is dangerous. She seemed to reveal in it. Her mouth was reckless. They could have exed her out in her own home. All over dogs & cigarettes. Smh!
I think the plaintiff is gross for trying to shame her job.
He had no right to be there once she told him to leave. He's not on the lease
@@jaynehogue2459this comment wasn’t even about the brother
@@jaynehogue2459stick to the topic!!! You don’t have visitors at your house??? Everybody at your house has to be on the lease 😂
It IS a gross immoral job
@@Chichiloveeyet it would not exist but for gross immoral people paying to see stuff like that.
The brother showed more restraint than a lot of people would've been able to her with her screaming and throwing a fit like that saying all that about his sister
Not really. He hit her.
@@mollyscot1563She grabbed his neck. He has every right to hit her.
@@mollyscot1563No no go back and watch 13:24-13:34 even the judge says it clear as day your hands are on his NECK and he PUSHED you off of him have some accountability
@@namjoonssexybrain1679 He hit her phone and got up to her, she had her hand out, then he hit her again. He had 0 right. He actually had 0 right to be in there when the contract with the person who set them both up told her that there was to be NO MEN in the house, and her brother is *gasp* a man.
@@dragames Your confuse or being emotional. Yes they have no right to be in her space. BUT yes he had the right to shove her because she held his neck. Imagine a dude grabbing a lady neck. Do you expect her to let it happen. No.
She touched him first. You can't hit someone and not expect not to be hit. There's a reason why the cops and judge didn't side with that lady for so called getting touched.
If someone was choking you, you will not do nothing. You will push them away.
the plaintiff definitely isn’t innocent but this whole situation just wild 😂 what has the world come to 😩😭
The world has always been like this. The only difference between "Today & Yester Year" is that we now have videos showing/memorializing such events & the worst is yet to come. LOL
@dessean1 No it is worse. People take pride in their bad behaviour. When I grew up you were ashamed to disrespect and abuse people and get into trouble. People have no shame and it's ALL about ME.😢
She is all dressed up for court but her words belie her appearance. Defendant is dodgy as all shite too.
The only person who wasn’t behaving badly in this situation was the baby. Poor little baby.
Thank goodness SOMEONE is thinking ab the baby😭♥️
That lady DEFINITELY damaged her own futon. She seem like the type. From she can be spiteful and lie to have that lady's child taken away, she can be spiteful and lie about a damaged futon.
That scrawny, pathetic print should have been proof that she did it herself.
My mom is mentally ill. She had a lady renting a room once. My mom stabbed furniture and walls with a butcher knife, then was convinced her renter did it. One of the scariest thing i dealt with.
This plaintiff is unhinged and crazy. She was screaming and instigating a fight so he would hit her and she could claim it was all their fault.
On the flip side, the renter had NO BUSINESS moving a man into the house when she signed a lease stating no men.
So theyre both wrong!!! Everyone is the problem.
"Karen" and "Keisha" deserve each other. Both are a trip 😂😂😂
The plaintiff is not any better than the defendants.
Legend has it the husband is still not available 😂😂😂😂 look, the defendant's a doodoo, but this landlord is crraaazzyyyyy.
Not the judge trying to say the plaintiff experienced racism or a racist comment lol 😂
Some people will damage their own property to go to court and get the person they are mad at to pay for it if you don’t have real proof I don’t think that’s fair
JM underestimates crazy sometimes.
Why in the world would you rent a room to someone with a baby?
Trying to help a single mom I guess
Hi. To be fair, I’m glad people rented to my mom when I was a baby. She was an attentive mother and is great tenant, always left the place better than she found it. Landlords are ALWAYS sad when she says she’s moving.
There are many good mothers out there who are young and single.
Okay, well, take care & wish you & everyone well & all the best!
I would
Not all people with a baby can afford a house.
@@JohnnyEnrico Yea or Hispanics, they're probably illegal.
The defendant uses a “sweet voice” but you can tell she’s a real piece of work. The 911 call is bonkers.
it’s really not!!! that white lady was CRAZY!
Exxxactly
@@LifeWithTiaawhat does being white have to do with it?
@@LifeWithTiaa 🙄🙄🙄
@@eph2vv89only1way is she not white? ………. Is she purple ? Oh okay tf😂
Plaintiff: “I got a call on Labor Day, which was a Monday.” really? 😂
JM kills me. She was rendering a physical description of the person she needed assistance with.
The defendant comes off as ditzy and immature
Yeah but the ditzyness is intentional to get away with more crap.
She's a kneegrow, what the hell do you expect !
Absolutely
So does the plaintiff. The realtor put the two of them together, because he knew they were both crazy.
And what does the plaintiff comes off as?. I'm pretty sure the video recordings show what a nasty and immature person she was. Slaughter the girl, calling her out of her name and grabbing her brother by the NECK. Quit with the double standards.
The plaintiff looks old & young at same time. 🤔🫣 ok bye!💅🏾😂
The plaintiff is borderline Karen .
Most DEFINITELY is with a “husband” in jail. 🥴
Not even borderline, she just is! 😂
She IS a Karen.
@@jesssssssssssssssssssssssssright!
more like "borderline personality disordered". fr
This is one of the craziest cases I’ve ever seen😂
Where's her husband? Sounds like he's in prison. I'm sure she's a criminal just like him. This lady is not innocent she's an instigator.
I thought that too, he's maybe in prison. Lol
I was looking for this comment. "He's away" "I can't call him" either hubby isn't real, or he's definitely locked up.
She probably framed her husband and sent him to prison
Goddamn so many morons here.
She had the defendant agree to the lease (yet signed late) to not bringing any men around.
This is the type of thing women who are victims of DV and SA do. Which means likely her husband was arrested for DV, and the plaintiff probably suffers PTSD from it and wants no men around, and here we are with the defendant and her trashy ass brother breaking that and refusing to leave, and not only that, hits the plaintiff twice.
She disrespecting that man's sister the way she was doing, can't say had I been in his position, I would not have done the same thing, she was wrong for that!
It's clear from the video that the plaintiff slapped the brother first. I don't know what the Judge is talking about.
@@magicworld3242 But here's the thing, it's her house, he was never given permission to enter, and repeatedly asked to leave. By all rights, if a stranger walked into your house and refuse to leave, you can legally hit them if you feel threatened; it's the Castle Doctorine. If he would've left when he was ordered to, he wouldn't have gotten slapped.
Yeah I agree, she should have never called his sister a whore, that's so disrespectful, & then she tried turning the heat onto the siblings relationship when she kept saying he wasn't the father of the child, his sister was taking advantage of him since he was the one taking care of the baby at night, and it wasn't his place to do so. To me, he seemed like a solid guy who loves his nephew. He just was the one who got put in the middle.
@@Fribee83 , But here's the thing. He didn't break into her house. He was there visiting his sister. Just because someone is in your house, doesn't give you permission to assault them. The cops saw the video and that's why, he didn't get arrested. The cops knew, they would have to arrest her too.
@@magicworld3242you realize him knocking the phone out of her hand is him assaulting her first.....
The defendant walked in the courtroom with a smile on her face like she thinks it's funny.
I love how the plaintiff acts so scared of the defendant and playing the victim but in the video she has her hand around the brothers neck and calling his sister out of her name, but you allowed her to move into your home (because your psychotic *SS needed the money) smh weirdo!!!
Typical broke entitled karen
I love how blind you are.
The brother wasn't supposed to be there 100%. Was told to leave and he didn't. He would be legally, a trespasser.
Second, he hit her first, she put her hand out, and then he hit her again. The first hit, the phone falls to the floor. Second is after she has her hand to push him back after HE rushed up to her, not the other way around.
The problem starts with plaintiff's broker who set them both up without disclosing the defendant's occupation and further the defendant refusing to obey any of the rules.
@@dragames no that would be your mom 😂🤣✌🏾
@@chonkygato Ah, a lead paint indulger.
Fact's 💯💯
I think the plaintiff sinister smile says it all. The lady seems crazy
The defendant is not blameless at all but that plaintiff is BONKERS. I 100% believe she burned the futon herself and put that butt print there are on her own.
Oh yeah.
She really needed money clearly. So this case seems inflated. The husband must be in prison.
Husband is "away" 😉
Ain't no husband she just said that...and says that so ppl will think she has a man behind her
Tbh no one in this situation has clean hands. The plaintiff was a piece of shit and wanted to trigger the defendant and the defendant was in her emotions. They both need to get help. Only one I feel bad for is the baby.
Exactly
The plaintiff really thought that second video was gonna help her case but jesus christ she was going IN.
That lady ain't got no husband😂
Judge Milian is so messy.. “ Let me see the video” 😂😂but I’m here for it every time.. I love her we are the same 😂😂
But when she literally said that the woman did the same, the judge dismisses it. I find her so biased all the time.
I've always said that
She's a jealous racist
I don’t why she ignored the part about the plaintiff dragging the defendant calling her a whore and prostitute and calling her brother dirty and yelling in his face to provoke him. And then she acted blind when she saw the video and ignored the fact that the plaintiff grabbed the brother by the neck. If the brother didn’t point it out to her she would’ve let it slide.
Sadly, the judge is biased all the time. She needs to address her biases as she doesn’t even realize it.
Biases are with you all. JM is just often wrong / overlooks many things. It has impacted white people, black people, men, women, Asian people…
But the only time it’s “bias” in comments is when it’s a black person. Of course when a black person handily wins y’all are nowhere to be seen crying about how bias JM is… hmm.
She can just be wrong without it being racial bias as you’re implying. It wouldn’t be the first time she’s wrong.
The defendant thinks that she can put on this sweet little voice and pretend to be all innocent when everyone can see straight past it. But the plaintiff is beyond a piece of work. The pillow, the video, she’s an instigator. I would never want to rent a place from her.
Idk she sounded the same on the phone with the police. I don’t hear any inconsistencies with her voice and behavior
@@imartinistexactlyyy, I keep seeing that comment but how she was talking on the video to the police was the exact same. Too many inconsistencies with the plaintiff and I don’t understand how people make an oath and still lie in court lol
Exactly what I thought
@@imartinist of course she used her sweet voice on the cops . i want to hear her real ghetto voice , like how she talks to people on the streets where she is hookin .
I'm not condoning the behavior of the defendants but the plaintiff seems to be a very awkward woman. She's acting like the defendants are such horrible people and she herself is a saint who does no wrong. But it's pretty obvious the plaintiff has just as much personal problems and the husband she speaks of is obviously in jail.
She’s a paranoid judgmental see you next Tuesday
Totally agree
I guess the judge had nothing to say about the woman calling her a whore? Just go through the motions and get the people out!
Both are crazy but the plaintiff over stepped her boundaries when it came to the baby and she definitely hit the brother so he had a right to shove her back.
Him knocking the phone out of her hand is the first hit.......also known as assaulting her
@@hey-you7 they’re all crazy bats if you ask me. 🤣
@@inukoko2012 I agree with they're all crazy. Just noting he assaulted her first. None of what she said as shitty as it was is illegal, she was baiting him tho
@@hey-you7 smh definitely was baiting him and got in his face. Sometimes someone can provoke you if you’re that mad. Lbs.
@@inukoko2012 oh yeah, she provoked him and he took the bait. He assaulted her in her home after she withdrew his invitation. Sounds like she was shooting for grounds for restraining order against them to kick them out easier then evicting them.
Prime example of why words shouldn't provoke a physical reaction
Craziest case I've watched in a long time. The judge was also a little biased as she always is.
The defendant and plaintiff both have agree to have their case settled by this judge. So word to the wise.
@@quiltgalsews Your comment is pointless. The fact still remains that she's biased.
@@LivingforJesusaGodisGood74 How is she "biased"?
@@kennethbaker5223 It is quite clear and if you don't see it, that's on you. I don't think I need to explain myself to opinion warriors over the internet 💁♀️.
She is biased for sure, she typically has little patience for crazy/entitled people.
You know the economy is in bad shape when ppl have to resort to renting out a room to make ends meet
Id agree, but it seems like the plaintiff has a husband in prison “away” that she’s probably fronting money for too.
I would sue the rental agency for not doing their job like a thorough check-up on the tenant (defendant)🚫
Milian is spot on for calling out the defendant for saying "crazy white lady"!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 if it was reversed, it would be such a bigger issue 😂😂😂😂
The reason why it would be a bigger issue is because of the violent history toward Black people in this country. Tiny violin
@@DJLadyRyan33very tiny 😂😂😂😂
@@DJLadyRyan33 you must be thinking of only "American history". White Slavic people used to be slaves. Involved in genocides and even more atrocities. Learn a bit more. Racism comes from ALL races and discriminates against ANY race
@@DJLadyRyan33 Not tiny violin truth history with history to prove it. But you pale-skinned cave beast will never admit the truth
@@DJLadyRyan33which history? White on black? Or black on black? Or black on white?
Idk why the judge is mad about her calling the police to come before she beat the plantiff’s ass. At least she took the right course of action 🤷🏾♀️ if she had beat the plaintiff then it would be another story
😂😂plantif trying to paint herself so clean and naive smh lol
God bless that poor baby under that woman’s care.
Sooo the defendant NEVER told her she was a prostitute….she just assumed she was because she’s a dancer?
No she told her she was a stripper, the plantiff then assumed or tried add extra and call her prostitute
@@PrincessZaire100that’s what the original commenter said lol smh
The plaintif being so evil and aggresive WHEN SHE WAS RECORDING tells me she is completely unhinged. The defendant really needs to check herself and GROW THE F UP for her and that poor baby.
I think they both have a crazy streak 😂 Also, if the defendant admits to she actually did why would she lie about anything? But she still cray cray...just like the plaintiff.
Why didn't the defendant & her brother just get their own place if he's going to be with the baby at night? Had she explained that ahead of time it probably wouldn't have gotten so crazy between them. Both ladies seem a little out there, but in completely different ways, lol!
I find it very suspicious that she knows exactly what the substance is and exactly how it was put there but didn't see it happen… I'm talking about the cushion situation, but they are both nuts, so I don't put it past either one of them
Right! She said she was there the whole time while she was moving out, she recorded everything else. Why wasn't that Recorded.
@@tabwab83 exactly! Then, she tried to come off as innocent and a victim but the way she was talking in that recording.... I was like oh, she was TRYING to rile them up so she could get a negative reaction on video. If she was talking to the girl like that, no wonder she was telling the police "I don't want to have to beat this lady up." 🤣🤣🤣 I would never say no mess like that, but it had to be about more than the money at that time. On the other hand, the way the brother was saying "you're saying WE don't live here and all of OUR stuff is here... the homeowner was frustrated and they definitely overstayed their welcome at that point. She only signed up for 1 roommate.
The defendant was laughing the whole time so I believe she did it
Cant lie i like the defendants energy 😂😂the plantiff is giving cra cra😂 wish them both well
The defendant reminds me of Nia Long….she’s a cutie!
I would never rent out a room to a stranger.
Plaintiff is such a Karen bringing up her welfare documents and all the other petty details.
I feel like her family came over and were extremely sweet in order to get their daughter out of their hair!!! get her binding into a contract so she would definitely have a place to live her brother should have babysit at his parents house. So glad this lady does not have to put up with this dangerous situation.
Something I have learned in my 42 years of being a landlord.....every time you 'help someone out' that needs a break it is very expensive for you the landlord. The reason they are in the pickle they are in is 95% of the time their own irresponsibility then it becomes your problem once they move in.
Very entertaining case! 5/5 stars would watch again!
Plaintive was just as aggressive with her words and trying to bait the brother to be physical..
“Catting around” omg 🤸🏾♀️😂
This was great. Everytime the defendant said "That's a lie." The Plaintiff produced the receipts to prove it was the defendant lying. I haven't laughed this much in ages.
The plaintiff lied too saying she didn't know what a stripper was, gtfoh. Old as she looks there's just no way that's true. The plaintiff just wanted the money that's why she let her move in before verifying income and collecting W-2's.
Plaintiff lied saying the brother hit her after putting her hand around his neck and provoking
@@miloperrault2614what she meant was that she didn't know that when the defendant said stripper, what she REALLY meant was an escort...BIG difference...
@@snoopholmab2177you do realize he first hit her when he knocked the phone out of her hand(that's assualt). Her pushing him away is her defending herself at that point. And then he shoves her which is more to his assault. Learn the law
All that evidence was staged. Please if ure there while she is moving out and mind u sge said there with her dog in her right hand and she destroyed the place u just gon let her leave really. If the police kept being called wouldn't she have a police report. She didn't even report ot she just took pictures. Plus that cig butt was short af for someone to have smoked it. I feel like the lady staged ot to get the money. Even the stuff left behind wouldn't take an hr to throw away.
Idk what the judge was listening to plus a pears the lady and girl boutthe same size so again the couch def could've been staged plus she had a picture of the baking soda so again she had to have seen it before she left.
"I wanted to help her because she was a single mom working 2 jobs" yt survivor complex
Plaintiff def sat on that pillow😂😂😂
The defendants brother is the only normal one out of the three. The plaintiff is terrible liar. The way she setup the brother was despicable. The stripper is cute.
How the fuck is the brother normal? He hit her twice, he refused to leave when he had no right to be there in the first place especially since the lease said "no men in the house" the fact he had KEYS is fucking insane past the initial point and definitely a violation of landlord/roommate rights. You're not allowed to make keys without the landlords permission.
@@dragames are you done reposting this comment nobody cares about under every comment?
This generation, OMG HAS ZERO REGARD FOR ANYTHING , THE LANDLORD IS A KAREN ,SO THEY ARE BOTH ADDICTED TO DRAMA , THIS WAS DOOMED TO FAIL FROM THE BEGINNING, WHAT DISASTER, SMH 😡
How is she a Karen?
@@kay22100 = Why do you have to spell everything out for certain people in the back, SMH from the very beginning, after she told her she was a a stripper, she began to look down her nose at her, which makes her a judgemental Karen, who is nosier than Judge Milian, if you have reservations about someone's occupation ,just don't rent to them, that simple
I hate when older generations say things like this. Our generation may be bad but y’all just didn’t have cameras to record everything. Let’s not act like the older gens didn’t have slaves, segregation. Or even having to implement the laws of today. Let’s not act like y’all don’t have decades of serial killers and didn’t sweep family molesters or rapist under the rugs. Let’s not act like y’all didn’t need work laws. I just don’t understand it when y’all say this generation is worse. It’s so much more too
They’re all crazy lol.
God bless the baby!
Yo, this case went from 0 to 100 real quick smh 😂
This ruling was wrong. I have NO CLUE what yall were watching. You can look at the plaintiff's mannerisms and tell that she is over-the-top and actually crazy. I don't doubt that she damaged her own property. I'm confident her "husband," if he even exists, is in prison because she framed him because she looks like the type. The fact that she was recording and had no problem putting her hands on the defendant's brother speaks VOLUMES. Also, Judge not catching her put hands on the man's neck until he called it out was problematic. Making the defendant pay the month when the host company has a different set of rules regarding breaking lease and charging NOTHING for the suffering after that nutcase called DCF? This ruling was wrong.
💯
Wow, this is one of the weirdest case from the whole series.
I love how judges face lit up when she said he had a video. She loves the tea 😭🤣
This was a joke🙄...there's no way I would have allowed her in my home...
The defendant is so beautiful. I hope she learns to get some class soon. She could be such a beautiful person.
😂
You need new glasses
Like judge judge would say the all made for each other 😂
I don't know who's lying but when the defendant said she did it herself the plaintiff had a smirk!
This case was bonkers 😂😂😂😂 I love it
When crazy people collide
The plaintiff was also out of line. She clearly turned a blind eye to some things as a matter of convenience. Stripper $$ pays the rent just like butcher $$. It is probably when the defendant pushed her luck that the plaintiff snapped like Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest. Definitely some displaced anger. And the husband is, "away?" like in out in the garden pushing up daisies?
Plaintiff trying to sound all innocent in court until you hear the video of her talking trashy and ghetto… 👀👀👀
She has an "8 month year old baby" 😂
WELFARE PAPERS? IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW
Lmao
Wait I don’t get it ? Does welfare papers mean u should be homeless or discriminated against
This is my new favorite episode ever lol
The only person who got "exposed" was the plaintiff. 😂
the plaintiff needs to sue the guy who referred this lady.
How would he know how she is behind closed doors??
Not really. He doesn’t know her personally.
Yea it’s not his fault that the two didn’t get along
The plaintiff is just as crazy as the defendant. I have a gut feeling the plaintiff has problems with everybody.