The Life of Giordano Bruno
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- Vacillating, intriguing, and tragic; if I were to ascribe three words to the life of Giordano Bruno it would undoubtedly be these. I suspect many know of this stories fiery denouement, but if you are interesting in discovering how Giordano Bruno, searching and wondering, transformed from priest to philosophical martyr for free speech and tolerance of differences then give me 10 minutes of your time.
If you enjoyed this video and are interesting in learning more about history’s greatest philosophic minds and ideas consider subscribing to the channel. Here my goal is to bring philosophy to whoever may be seeking it by illuminating the individuals who, by the prestidigitation of their thought, changed the world.
Music:
"Solstice" - Scott Buckley
"Breathing Planet" - Doug Maxwell
Sources:
www.britannica.com/biography/...
The Story of Civilization VII - The Age of Reason Begins (Will and Ariel Durant)
CC Attributions:
Head of inquisition - it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giulio_...
Sorbonne - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89c...
Martin Luther University - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_...
Aviceena - www.flickr.com/photos/blondin...
Bruno Monument - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordan...
Bruno Monument 2 - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordan...
Bruno Monument 3 - upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...
Bruno Monument 4 - upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...
Dominican Monastery - upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...
#GiordanoBruno #philosophy #westernphilosophy
Hero that should be an inspiration to all free thinking people.
I am very fortunate that I have been able to read so deeply into his incredibly fascinating life!
We will be fine for we will find out what he called bull shit from the start
He just became mine
The greatest hero and true patron of truth.
"Perchance you who pronounce my sentence are in greater fear than I am." -- Giordano Bruno
Bruno's joke about Solomon was to use the church's own logic against them. It was demonstration of questioning authority with authority's own logic. In doing so, he highlighted authority's own hypocrisy. Authority's reaction to his proof of it's hypocrisy demonstrates their desire for power and not the truth.
Wonderful, thank you for the insight!
I always wondered about Solomon and his 800 wives, whether or not he was commanded to do that by G_d, because it sure doesn't seem like the actions of a sane person, much less a wise person.
🌻🌻🌻❤️🌻🌻🌻
Not quite that simple. Solomon was an extremely wealthy king, also the Bible is critical of having multiple wives (New Testament stipulates just one). Many events recorded are not endorsements, but to give the full picture
@@MrWholphin That's a cop-out
Just imagine the intense amount of love and strength this man had for the Divine
Every time I'm in Rome I stop in Campo de Fiori to pay homage to the man.
I have not been myself, though I do hope to be in Rome in the near future and will surly stop by to give this man his due!
When I went to Rome Campo de Fiori was one of the first places I visited.
@@giordanobruno7593 he believed that there was intelligent humanlike beings & life out there in the universe & I feel this was one of the most offensive so-called herisies of not just the Cathlocs but also the Lutherans & Calvanists!! How many Cathloc, Lutheran & Calvanist ministers in the 1500s, 1600s believed in e.t. life & ufos?? Saying 'almost none would be a high number back then & even today, this subject is still taboo in many churches!! Try talking about it on a Sunday morning before and/or after service & see if the pastor & congregation??
Please note he said the Universe as planets like ours perhaps populated with gods creature.this differ from your statement
Absolute savage dedication to his own truth. Have to admire that.
Admirable indeed!
Indeed, a true martyr of freethought. We ought not take for granted the freedom that we have!
I am a Catholic, I studied personally ancient religion, philosophy, hermetic occult, and when I watch the life of Giordano Bruno I felt goosebumps his ideology of seeking of the truth through spiritual to science means.
Before Voltaire and Descartes, there was Bruno ...the often forgotten philosopher and methematician
Wha... what a guy! Kudos to Giordano Bruno and thank you Mr. Philosophy for taking the time to come up with this sort of content. I actually learned something today.
Thank you for taking the time to watch, I am happy you were able to find value in what I create!
Just got back that this guy is one of my great ancestors, can’t wait to learn about him!
Interesting, I would be very interested to see about my own lineage! I hardly know anyone past my grandparents haha.
Nice!
Grazie a te 🌿🤝🌿per questo
prezioso documento ✨☀️✨
Giordano Bruno è il mio eroe
per il suo contributo all’evoluzione umana
opponendosi alla crudele e cruenta
ottusità dello strapotere clericale.
Inspiring that a brilliant person with such natural intelligence and curiosity would come to understand the cosmos. Depressing that he would be killed by the dullest and most dogmatic amongst us.
He was a great mind and I too regret the end that befell him. In 10 years he produced some 40 works of prose and poetry, imagine the great works we may have gotten if he would have continued on! Thank you for taking the time to watch.
A courageous man not afraid to speak his truth and not blindly follow the catholic churches fear and damnation ideology. I am from Australia and found out about him while reading about what happened to the Adyar Bookshop in Sydney which was opened by The Theosophical Society and..they also started Sydney's radio station 2GB and the GB came from his name Giordano Bruno..fascinating! The bookstore closed in 2012. It was a favourite of mine.
They thought that they" couldn't talk about Bruno "but here we are speaking about him today just saying
What a great life of adventure 😊 Sad how church religion manages to execute any free thinker. But now the tide has turned and churches are being shown up for what they truly are. Thanks to the wayshowers like Mr Bruno.
Very good video, you stuck to the known historical facts and resisted the myths that surround Giordano Brunos life and death - being the martyr for science.
Thank you! At times it can be difficult to discern what may be fact and fiction when it comes to history and I am deeply indebted to those who have come before me that have provided an accurate and thoughtful description to the lives of these incredibly interesting and influential men and women. Glad you took the time to watch my video, cheers friend!
He was a genuine intellectual and died because of it. He may have not been a scientist but the "myth" isn't far off. He also supported copernicus ' theory and made claims like there being explanets and a center in the universe. You are right tho he was mainly a philosopher and died because he supported hermeticism.
I admittedly haven’t seen a ton of them, but that’s gotta be a top ten statue. It’s awesome.
I have seen my fair share and Bruno's is certainly one of my favorites. Those who erected it did a fine job.
What a man ! xxxxxxx
No doubt about that!
They were truly barbaric in those times. One wouldn't even persecute a monster like this. And he was a brilliant mind😡😭
actually,He was an ancient Albert Einstein but No-one could recognise him at that point of view at that time
Yeah cause humans where always blind to the truth
interesting that he did no science, proposed no theories, and no scientific experiment was done - yet he is so often remembered as a 'martyr to science' along with Galileo
I think the confusion comes because he was indeed a martyr for free thought which, incidentally, during that age aided in convincing those who had theories contrary to popular dogmas to not be afraid, to stand fast to what they thought to be true, even if it means your life. Though there are a few ways of interpreting what he stood for. Cheers for taking the time to watch the entire video, I hope it was helpful and or informative!
I don’t know what you mean here. Giordano Bruno’s cosmological theories are a branch of physics and metaphysics. He proposed the existence of exoplanets (the stars were distant suns surrounded by their own planets) and the ‘infinite’ universe theory. Despite this, it’s his religious views and not his cosmological views that got him in trouble.
I thank you for your comment, but he had no empirical basis for his proposed exoplanets or infinite universe, it was pure speculation - along the lines of Democritus' speculation about 'atoms' in 400BC @@thenablade858
Scholar Frances Yates has written extensively about Bruno. Her books are brilliant. I especially liked The Art of Memory and Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition.
Still Yates did not comprehend trough meaning of of Bruno work very few people did
Beautiful edition and content, you will grow up with time!
Thank you for the kind words!
Bruno is also very talented in mnemonic techniques.
Indeed he is, part of the reason he returned to teach the young noble, the same one who eventually sold him out to the authorities.
thoroughly appreciate this video. By chance I've been to Italy and stayed IN the exact square where he was murdered. but i didnt kno who he was- my mom chose the area because it was hip! and yet i'm an angsty atheist who is tiredof the church . he's become a hero to me and i appreciate the upload and thorough information
I hope to visit when I get to venture to Italy. When that will be, who can say! You are welcome for the video and I am happy you found it to be helpful, cheers friend!
My father Giuseppe Giovanni BRUNO's birthday was Feb 8! Interesting! Grazie, I really enjoyed.
Happy belated birthday to him! Thanks for taking the time to watch and support the channel!
You are so wise to be so young! I really miss our conversations Brett. You are one of the brightest, if not the brightest, person I have ever met. Hope our paths cross again one day. Wish I had your email to write you.
Thank you, many times through out the course of a day, especially in healthcare, you encounter individuals who are in a difficult spot in their lives, and because of that it can make a difficult person even more difficult. However, those who are kind, generous, and thankful far outweigh the former which I spoke of. I would be thrilled to be able to converse with one of those people through email; go to my profile page and click on the about section, there should be an area where you can see one of my emails. I typically do not link them in the comment section since for some odd reason the bots can get a hold of it easier and spam it with innumerable emails. You can reach me at that email just the same as any of my personal ones. Look forward to hearing from you soon!
Thank you for this gem 💎
Thank you, I am glad that you enjoyed it!
I love Bruno.
An admirable man indeed!
Great content brother. Looks like we got some fruitful overlap going on ;)
Thank you! Any outlet to explore the lives, minds, and ideas of these individuals is a plus for humanity in my book!
awesome reporting. hope you would do a part 2 if theres more information about him
Thank you! I will likely do a video in the future on "The Philosophy of Giordano Bruno" I want to get a kind of double aspect of each philosopher, so that my viewers can not only learn about the individual's philosophy, but also about the kind of person they were and vice versa.
Oh man it makes sense why avenged sevenfold used a quote similar to his on the song Roman Sky.
Interesting, I am familiar with the band, but not their music. I will have to take a listen, thanks for taking the time to watch the video! Let me know any improvements that I could make regarding the quality of the video, thanks again!
Here before this blows up
Thank you!
Very interesting. Thanks
Glad you found it so, cheers!
Wonderful animations/compositions. I love them! Never seen something like that. How did you do that?
Thank you for the kind words Sandro! I have taken much inspiration from a few channels in regards to editing my videos; from there I simply try to add what I enjoy or what I think will draw the viewer to continue watching. It can be difficult with virtually no budget to work with, but I am always trying to improve and adapt my videos to make each better than the last. Sometimes it works, other times it backfires; but I always learn something. This channel is the first time I've ever done any video editing. As for the narration I do the research and put together what I feel to be a comprehensive, but easily understandable guide to whichever individual or idea I am presenting. Thanks for taking the time to watch; it does mean a lot!
I really enjoyed this thank you
I am very happy to hear that, thank you for taking the time to watch the video!
Thank you so much; this helped make it easier for me to write my essay 😁💖
Glad to hear that, thanks for watching!
Thank you for making this video.
Of course, thank you for the support. I hope to continue making videos for as long as I can!
My hero
He was the first to call the dogmas for what it was psychologically Bearing to keep
Us from understanding science which is all around us: he said they are afraid because he can accept what they can’t and that’s why he is being killed
Indeed, join our side, keep quite, or die seemed to be his only choices.
Excellent video
Thank you for the kind words and I am glad you enjoyed it!
I came here after listening to avenged sevenfold - Roman sky. Great video dude enjoy it a lot
Thank you! I believe I was told a while back that someone else came here from listening to that particular song. I have not listened to it myself, but I appreciate them bringing attention to our friend!
He was a Hero!
I concur!
Tanks for you work on Bruno people like you that make Bruno to be relevant today i read many literary work of Bruno to me hi was a genius whith many aspects
Just had this man’s statue tattooed on my back. Forgotten hero or free thought
Great minds, Korzybski.
It appears that you omitted Giordano Bruno's alleged indication that he believed that intelligent creatures might exist around the stars. Several sources I have accessed do so indicate; in fact. you are the first person who, either deliberately or accidentally, failed to disclose this significant section of his "crimes."
If that is the case, my apologies. I certainly did not include much of his life; the video may have been 30 minutes in that case. Thanks for contributing!
“AS THEY SPOKE YOUR FATE A FEARLESS MAN REPLIED. AS YOU WILL SENTENCE ME YOUR FEAR IS BEYOND MINE”
#LetsTalkPhilosophy, Giordano Bruno was not persecuted for his scientific or religious ideas, but rather for something else.
Hmm, what do you have in mind?
Well? We're waiting!
A beautifully made video essay. Thank you. Do you know Gordon White's work?
Thank you for the kind words and unfortunately, I am not familiar with Gordon White.
Salvador Freixedo was a recent similar person . worth to read Freixedo's books.
Thanks for the recommendation, cheers!
Thank you so much for this simplified intro. He has been my hero for years, from the little I read....especially his Heroic Frenzies. Now Ive discovered your second video on him and helps me so much.
Your are most welcome, I am very happy you found it to be helpful!
Santos bonacci talks about Bruno all the time
When I hear people getting upset about reclassifying Pluto, I like to refer them to Giordano Bruno, who was sentenced to death in part for declaring that our sun was a star, like the thousands of other stars in the sky, but closer. Unlike religious dogma, science is and must be willing to shift its perspective. It's not meant to insult anyone or anything; it is merely an attempt to reveal truth. Science that is unable to change inevitably becomes dogma.
salute and prayers for such a big man and hero i must say,kept the fire of trismegistus alive
So, Disney movie Bruno was based on him🤯🤯🤯
Yes , yes yes . I had no idea about him . But I have a question . Knowing what we know from the Catholic church .What makes you think that they have changed their evil ways ? If their power has increased tenfold ? Can anybody have a sensible answer ?
Your guess would be as good as mine. I believe that it is part of human nature to skew toward tribalism whatever form that may take in whatever era. You may get 10 different answers to your question if you asked any 10 people. I suppose it is up to us as individuals to make the final judgement. Cheers for the taking the time to write a comment and ask a question!
It looks like he anticipated Descartes, who doubted EVERYTHING (purely as a philosopher, of course!) while being carefully orthodox in his religion) Hmmmm. Anyway, thanks for helping me clarify my own venturesome mind.
Found out about this guy watching pawn stars where rick bought his first edition book for 100k
Haha, I have seen the show, though did not see this clip. I will have to look it up!
What a man
🌻🌻🌻❤️🌻🌻🌻
The map in this documentary about the 16th century is inaccurate for the 16th century, as Belgium did not exist till 1830.
Thanks for pointing that out, good eye.
So I clicked on this video thinking it would also explain his philosophical views that were so controversial but instead it’s just about where he went and what happened to him there.
Apologies Shirley, I do hope to get to making a video on his philosophical beliefs one of these days!
I have a book about him💜💜💜💜💜
Which book?
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy I have a collection of books about the life and the works of the philosophers, and about these books, I have one of Giordano Bruno
As much as I liked this video, it was really just his personal history. If we’re talking philosophy, there should’ve been so much more about what he believed and why he believed it.
Indeed, it was only meant to be the life of Bruno, not his philosophy. I have been working on a video to address his philosophy.
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy Awesome, glad to hear it. Looking forward to it!
Is it true that he got the vision of cosmos, direce perception of the highest truth??
He may be the only one who could answer your question. I think any other would be just speculation.
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy Maybe he can answer it - maybe he is incarnate in our time. Maybe he's planning on updating his work and giving it to the world in the near future. He was a visual "right brain" (R-mode) visionary scientist, and he's still over 423 years ahead of his time!
Have you done a video on when the Inquisition actually ended verses when the Catholic Church claimed that it ended?
This is a beautifully made video visually.
I think to make it the best most perfect video you should seek out over the internet a very good voice actor with gravitas to do the voiceover. This is my view would launch the video into the stratosphere (not for profit or material gain of course but for prosperity and universal knowledge)
Only my view mind you.
Thank you for the kind words and suggestion! Though I couldn't let the British have all the voice acting gigs! Perhaps one day If I am fortunate enough to run into someone who would fit the part it would be a great opportunity.
👌 amazing presentation
Thank you for the kind words, I am happy that you found it enjoyable and hopefully helpful!
give us more they remind me of my political science class, eras of rousseau, john locke, aristotle and many more
are there parallels between him 'n spinoza?
Many indeed, Spinoza took aspects of his philosophy from Bruno.
Watched all of it 10:15
Giordano Bruno believed that there was life out there in the universe & that the stars were suns & they had planets orbiting them & there were earth like planets with life including intelligent humanlike life!!
Indeed, I am working on a video on his philosophy currently and it has been interesting, but also difficult to fit so much matter into a video. Unfortunately I have probably made the thing to long, but there is just so much information that even when summarized it remains probably a 30 minute video. Cheers and hope to see you in the video coving his philoosophy!
What were the 20 errors he corrected, and what lecture was it? (I don't think I need to ask what Calvinist theologian it was, think I already know. :P)
I'm a born-again Christian, but I found Bruno interesting.
That's awesome Anneigh, I am glad you were able to find the video (and man) interesting!
A lot of these people thinking him some freethought martyr would have branded him a superstitious cultist for his spiritual views.
There is certain to be at least some who fall into that category.
I don’t know what you mean here. You can see someone as a superstitious cultist and still not support their death. I see a lot of the astrology girls on TikTok as insane but burning? Even more insane.
for me Giordano Bruno " he's so special at all " is in HighLevel even with Jesus Christ and Joseph from Egypt i mean about being great examples for all people On Earth .. " i saw about him On Cosmos the Possible Worlds . " also Kobe Bryant and Terry Fox .. the greaters On Earth ..!! i did one videogame called Genius vs AntiChrist 1 .. has alittlebit Giordano Bruno's History . "!!
Cheers friend, that was quite the paragraph haha. I hope you enjoyed the video and can honestly say I have never heard Bruno's name be placed beside Kobe and Terry Fox's!
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy Is pretty cool man !!! parabens i'm a brazilian guy i mean living in Brazil .. well greater stories at all ..!!!
Vijayvaratharaj anna soli yaru vanthinga ??
I am sorry Venkatesh, I was unable to translate your text. Feel free to respond to this in your native characters if possible; I would be able to google translate them at that time. Thanks for taking the time to watch!
@venkatesh venkat I know vijayvaratharaj, but I randomly saw it
Heyy, PEPs!
Thanks for taking the time to watch the video, but I am unsure what you mean to convey with your comment. Perhaps I have overlooked something, but I have no clue what PEPs means.
He also Bruno of Nola
I was in Toulouse in 2017 with my mum and dad my mum passed away a year a few months later now completely distraught
I am sorry to hear of your parents, it sounds like you had a great relationship with them. I hope that you are able to take solace in that and can move forward. Thank you for taking the time to watch, you support is very much appreciated!
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy I can’t make sense of it at all
It is a surprise to learn that Giordano Bruno did not believe that the Eucharist was the literal body of Christ. That certainly would have brought him before the Inquisition. Q: Do you believe the sacred host is actually Jesus? And that you eat him at Communion?
Thanks for watching the video! To answer your question, no, that is not my personal belief.
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy Among Catholics that can be the decisive factor whether you are in or out.
The second Socrates.
Why are some humans do not human compared to the masses?
Haha, just in the first 2 minutes, you're kinda saying that he was a sociopath.
In the video, you said that Bruno was "tongue bound". Does that mean that they nailed his tongue to the cross. And was he not crucified upside-down and then burnt to death? How cruel.
By tongue bound I simply meant he was not able to speak, so gagged in some way. Also I am not exactly sure whether he was upside down or right side up during the execution. Thanks for watching!
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy - According to Paul Wallis, an Anglican Minister, Bruno suffered a lot and was tortured. He discusses Bruno in this video starting at time = 7:36 if you are interested. He says that he was in prison for 7 years, in hardship, then had his tongue nailed to the cross, then had his tongue cut off, then turned upside down and burnt to death. There was a cover up and even his death by the Catholics was denied until more recently.
czcams.com/video/VYTSk_r91Xk/video.html
Interesting, thanks for the resource!
08:20 Just like the Jan. 6 political hostages. Imprisoned for years with no set trial date.
Is there a version of this without the background music?
Jojo reference.
If you don't change your beliefs your life will be like this forever. Is this good news?
If you believe the person giving you the advice then I'd say it would be helpful, and I think most things that prove to be helpful are good.
Not one word about how Bruno said that each star is in fact a Sun with planets orbiting them and that they may well have life on them also. He also insisted that the Universe is infinite and that it has no center. He didn’t believe in the Divinity of Christ or that Mary was a virgin. In other words he was highly intelligent, not naive and stupid. It’s always been my understanding that this is what got him killed. It went against the teachings of the catholic church. Galileo was in the crowd and witnessed Bruno being burned alive and this is why he recanted. He didn’t want to die like that. Surprising that you make no mention of this.
Hey John, I understand your concerns, but this video, as was stated in the title, was about the life of Bruno. I am making a separate video on his beliefs regarding philosophy, cosmology, the occult, and religion which I hope to be releasing after my next video on Thales. Thanks for taking the time to watch and I hope to get your critic on my next video aimed at what today's critique was directed toward.
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy Okay…, Many say that Bruno was indeed burned at the stake for his thoughts on Cosmology, science, which totally contracted catholic doctrine. Denying the Divinity of Christ didn’t help his case either.
Nell'essere umano, il cui sistema è l'amore per il prossimo in negazione dell'istinto affettivo carnale, da cui non attingere per non perire (Genesi 2.17), diversamente dal regno animale il cui sistema guida è invece l'istinto affettivo, la veglia (lo spirito) in assenza di sonno, che emerge nel lobo frontale umano (in cui è identificabile il Tempio di Dio), realizzando, collegandosi alla nascita alla Coscienza non locale (Padre della veglia umana), la vita in spirito (eterna), è separata magneticamente presso la Pineale (nella scissura di Silvio e di Rolando) dal resto cerebrale animale immerso a vari livelli nel sonno/veglia anche quando il soggetto è desto. Ne consegue che ogni bene per l'essere umano deriva dalla veglia (in assenza di sonno), mentre il male malessere procede dal sonno soprattutto quando nelle ore diurne sconfina nel lobo frontale.
I attempted to translate this into English, this is what I got:
(In the human being, whose system is love for one's neighbor in negation of the carnal affective instinct, from which one should not draw in order not to perish (Genesis 2.17), unlike the animal kingdom whose guiding system is instead the affective instinct, the vigil (the spirit) in the absence of sleep, which emerges in the human frontal lobe (in which the Temple of God is identifiable), realizing life in spirit (eternal ), is magnetically separated at the Pineal (in the fissure of Silvio and Rolando) from the rest of the animal brain immersed at various levels in sleep/wakefulness even when the subject is awake. It follows that every good for the human being derives from wakefulness (in the absence of sleep), while the bad malaise proceeds from sleep especially when in the daytime hours it encroaches on the frontal lobe)
Let me know if this is what you meant to say, if so I am very confused without context.
La veglia umana
Diversamente da quella animale, è in duplex. Una parte della veglia, la vita in spirito sentimentale, EMERGE, collegandosi alla Coscienza non locale alla nascita, in assenza di sonno da sveglio nel lobo frontale, evolutiva della Funzioni organiche superiori umane (nei primi 12 anni), il cui sistema guida è l'amore per il prossimo indistinto per chiunque (in negazione della cultura affettiva da cui l'inversione evolutiva umana) e da cui procede la felicità dei fanciulli, la libertà, il senso e l'avventura della vita, mentre la restante parte della veglia, quella animale istintiva-affettiva, schermata nella scissura di Silvio e di Rolando presso la Pineale, resta perennemente immersa nel sonno/veglia del resto cerebrale. Ebbene allorché l'adolescente persegue l'istinto affettivo carnale progressivamente o repentinamente smagnetizza la Pineale che si calcifica, da cui le varie psicopatologie a partire dalla nevrosi di massa, in base alla sensibilità genetica di ciascuno.
He was a real Christian
He certainly embodied much more Christian ethics than his persecutors!
@@LetsTalkPhilosophy - He was a real Christian. Brave, logical and loved God with all his heart respect from a Muslim
We need to get rid of the religion !!! as above so below #ahuramazda vs #ahriman
I think, perhaps, to get rid of superstition would be more obtainable. In my opinion I think there is a reason that religion has been and still remains prevalent. I think the best we can ask for is the thorough education of humanity, whichever an individual chooses to believe after that point is outside of our control. From my personal experience and from witnessing humanity in a larger perspective, religion will remain an integral part of our races heritage, no matter where we go in the future, for better or for worse. Cheers friend, thank you for taking the time to watch the video; I hope you enjoyed it!
Why can't Americans pronounce Naples? It's na-pe-lee
Why indeed.
That's why religion is terrible thing..