Why You Can Legally Steal From a Sinking Ship

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 04. 2023
  • Get Nebula using my link for 40% off an annual subscription: go.nebula.tv/halfasinteresting
    Half as Interesting’s Crime Spree: nebula.tv/haicrimespree
    Get a Half as Interesting t-shirt: standard.tv/collections/half-...
    Suggest a video: halfasinteresting.com/suggest
    Follow Sam from Half as Interesting on Instagram: / sam.from.wendover
    Follow Half as Interesting on Twitter: / halfinteresting
    Discuss this video on Reddit: / halfasinteresting
    Video written by Ben Doyle
    Check out our other channels: / wendoverproductions
    / jetlagthegame

Komentáře • 788

  • @samyakjainjss
    @samyakjainjss Před rokem +5046

    Now, I just need to find a place where sinking a ship is legal.

    • @chilledtea.
      @chilledtea. Před rokem +312

      Probably somalia is your best bet

    • @ryshow9118
      @ryshow9118 Před rokem +272

      Everything is legal if you don't get caught 😅

    • @bobbyfeet2240
      @bobbyfeet2240 Před rokem +179

      It's legal everywhere as long as you make it look like an accident.

    • @E1craZ4life
      @E1craZ4life Před rokem +57

      Anything is legal for you if you can make it look like someone else did it.

    • @cnordegren
      @cnordegren Před rokem +63

      Russia
      Somalia
      Venezuela
      North Korea
      Eritrea
      Iran

  • @fpnbrian
    @fpnbrian Před rokem +2472

    ~10 years ago while sailing in the Caribbean early one morning we came across a 32ft center console power boat drifting straight towards a bunch of rocks with no one onboard. We boarded the vessel and towed it to a nearby port where we were requested by the police to tow it to the next harbor. During that transit time the police had tracked down the owner and confirmed that someone had attempted to steal the boat overnight and when they couldn't start the engines they left it drifting. The police asked us if we intended to file a pure salvage claim as it would be 100% in our rights to do so, but informed us that to collect on it would require going to court and may take months or years before the money was awarded. Given the good weather and minimal risk and cost to ourselves (only cost us half a day of vacation), we estimated that we would not get much more than $3-4k in the end. The owner offered to put up a $500 tab at the bar and restaurant we were planning to go to that evening which worked out to a $100 tab for each of us and we happily accepted feeling it was a good enough value on top of the great story and fun memories of the event.
    When we got to the restaurant that afternoon the staff were very curious why a local had given a bunch of sailors on vacation from the US a $500 tab, when we told them the story and told them that whatever was left on the tab that night they could keep as the tip, they declared that we were eating and drinking for free the whole night and gave us anything we wanted (and pocketed a nice $500 tip for themselves in the process). Needless to say the next morning was "rough", and I heard that someone had a security camera that allowed them to catch whomever tried to steal the boat, so it worked out well for everyone.

    • @MesaperProductions
      @MesaperProductions Před rokem +223

      Now that sounds like a helluva vacation!

    • @petergerdes1094
      @petergerdes1094 Před rokem +75

      Except the thief.

    • @wraithcadmus
      @wraithcadmus Před rokem +292

      You got a good night out, the owner got their boat back, the bar got a good tip, and the thief got caught. In the words of the poet O'Shea Jackson Sr, it was a good day.

    • @noneofyourbizness
      @noneofyourbizness Před rokem +24

      great addition to the vid. cheers !

    • @fpnbrian
      @fpnbrian Před rokem +32

      @@petergerdes1094 he got caught, so it worked out well! (ok maybe he thinks differently, but everyone else is happy with the outcome)...

  • @Wolfy8668
    @Wolfy8668 Před rokem +1657

    As a mariner this is fairly well explained. In fact most ships carry on the bridge a template contract for "pure salvage" called Lloyds Open Form, which has massive letters on the front cover "NO CURE, NO PAY". Lloyds Open Form is so standard that even oral agreement to terms and conditions of LOF is enough to stand in court as legal agreement.

    • @Speedster___
      @Speedster___ Před rokem +9

      What is no cure no pay?

    • @sjcodan
      @sjcodan Před rokem +227

      @@Speedster___ Something covered in this very video.

    • @Wolfy8668
      @Wolfy8668 Před rokem +144

      @@Speedster___ it means salvor get paid based on results and not efforts

    • @cvbattum
      @cvbattum Před rokem +38

      Damn, maritime law is such a rabbit hole of interesting facts...

    • @wraithcadmus
      @wraithcadmus Před rokem +96

      Lloyds, so old and essential to shipping there is literally a flag code for "Please report my location to Lloyd's of London" (ZD2).

  • @frederiknielsen6038
    @frederiknielsen6038 Před rokem +304

    Just wanted to clarify that the criteria of "voulentary" applies to both parties. You cannot just tow a random ship into port during a storm and claim salvage, if the ship didn't agree to it. Even if the ship was in actual peril, and you succeded in doing it.

    • @InventorZahran
      @InventorZahran Před rokem +31

      The ship must provide informed, uncoerced consent.

    • @maymeksykanin27
      @maymeksykanin27 Před 3 měsíci

      - Hey guys, u look like u are sinking, maybe u need help?
      - U just want to claim our cargo, f*** off

    • @maymeksykanin27
      @maymeksykanin27 Před 3 měsíci

      - Hey guys, u look like u are sinking, maybe u need help?
      - U just want to claim our cargo, f*** off

    • @maymeksykanin27
      @maymeksykanin27 Před 3 měsíci

      - Hey guys, u look like u are sinking, maybe u need help?
      - U just want to claim our cargo, f*** off

    • @maymeksykanin27
      @maymeksykanin27 Před 3 měsíci

      - Hey guys, u look like u are sinking, maybe u need help?
      - U just want to claim our cargo, f*** off

  • @Distantshoreman
    @Distantshoreman Před rokem +341

    you missed some of the more fun elements. Rules for shares of the prize can apply. The owner of the ship is entitled to the bulk of the money, but the captain gets the most shares of the remaining amount on down do the lowest sailor who gets a single share. The captain can award additional shares for gallantry if a crew member did something above and beyond that put their life at risk to cause the rescue to succeed. There was a supertanker in the mid Atlantic that caught fire and a Canadian supply ship came to its rescue. It pick up the crew in the water and then used its helicopter to land firefighting crews put out the blaze and then attached a tow line. They started taking it back to Ireland. Along the way they they were ordered back to Canada so they signed a contract with a tugboat company to transport their prize back to Ireland. They ended up being screwed by the tugboat and the vessel owner who cut a sidebar deal at a lower rate and the Canadian government didn't pursue it. They gave the sailors a bit of cash and said it was done. The Captain quit the navy and sued. His settlement was covered by an NDA...

    • @rkan2
      @rkan2 Před rokem +16

      Right on ! :D Seems like that is one of the most binding international laws lol. Even above rules of war !

    • @yuki-sakurakawa
      @yuki-sakurakawa Před 10 měsíci +4

      I just make my crew walk the plank if they question their share of the booty. 🦜

    • @Laotzu.Goldbug
      @Laotzu.Goldbug Před 3 měsíci

      Do you know the name of either vessel involved?

    • @Distantshoreman
      @Distantshoreman Před 2 měsíci

      @@Laotzu.Goldbug is was either HMCS Preserver, Provider or Protector. Not sure which one. I do not know the name of the tanker.

  • @gjvnq
    @gjvnq Před rokem +464

    In Brazil we have a similar rule about lost property. If you come across some valuable thing you cannot just take it for yourself but you can return it the original owner in which case you would be entitled to a fraction of the value of the thing and the costs of preserving the thing until the owner picks it up.
    I don't recall any headlines of this being an issue probably because most lost stuff is either too cheap for a lawsuit to be worth it or the owner just offers to pay out of gratitude (this seems to be more common with emotional stuff like heirlooms and pets).

    • @user-xb9yv2ci4c
      @user-xb9yv2ci4c Před rokem +56

      In Germany, we also have this and call it "Finderlohn" which means "finders wage". It is 5% for goods under 500€ and 3% for everything above.

    • @jbird4478
      @jbird4478 Před rokem +95

      We have a similar system here called "Your wallet was empty when I found it. But hey, at least you have your cards back."

    • @iandavidvillaloboswong5180
      @iandavidvillaloboswong5180 Před rokem +21

      I found your dog, can you give me one of its ears?

    • @thelegend8570
      @thelegend8570 Před rokem +7

      We have this in Switzerland as well.

    • @blessedafricarains6429
      @blessedafricarains6429 Před rokem +13

      I am entitled to a percentage of your dog ! *Chops off two limbs from the puppy*

  • @captainevenslower4400
    @captainevenslower4400 Před rokem +130

    A few years ago we broke down with our crappy little 25hp outboard engine on an inflatable boat maybe 1 mile off the coast of croatia. So we yelled at some other guy nearby with a similar setup if he could drag us home which he ofc did. So yeah pretty similar story, but I'm grateful he didn't demand our toolbox and 2 sandwiches afterwards.

    • @dylanherrera5395
      @dylanherrera5395 Před 3 měsíci +2

      Damn! I'd be sad if I lost such a fortune like that too!

    • @miproduction6196
      @miproduction6196 Před 22 dny

      You better knock on wood, because there’s no expiration date! Hell be at your door in a couple weeks here! Hell he’ll take that too!

  • @Seed
    @Seed Před rokem +886

    Now I need to figure out how to sink ships…

  • @Croz89
    @Croz89 Před rokem +157

    There was an incident several years ago in the UK where a lot of cargo containers fell off a ship and washed up on a beach. Locals then "salvaged" the contents of many of these containers. In the end I do believe under UK maritime law it was considered "pure salvage" and those who had taken goods from these containers were entitled to a salvage fee of around 10% of the value of the goods. Which was a nice little bonus for a few lucky beachcombers who had managed to get something valuable out of a container.

    • @spookydirt
      @spookydirt Před rokem +19

      was that the one with people driving away on the BMW motorbikes they'd salvaged?

    • @Croz89
      @Croz89 Před rokem +13

      @@spookydirt Someone managed to get some quad bikes I believe.

    • @somethinglikethat2176
      @somethinglikethat2176 Před rokem +12

      Important to remember that you need to register your claim with the insurance company of the ship.

    • @laratheplanespotter
      @laratheplanespotter Před rokem +1

      I remember that!

    • @Croz89
      @Croz89 Před rokem +5

      @@trollolol705 With salvage contracts you'd price in the cost of recovery, with pure salvage if it's not worth recovering it doesn't get recovered. In this case since the costs were only the time of a few beachcombers, the salvage fee is generally worth it.

  • @HenryGK
    @HenryGK Před rokem +193

    Now you just need to do a video explaining the legal differences between flotsam, jetsam, lagan and derelict cargo.

    • @40below1000
      @40below1000 Před rokem +37

      Flotsam = cargo washed overboard "floats" away.
      Jetsam = Cargo intentionally thrown overboard (jettisoned) by the crew to lighten the boat

    • @ferretyluv
      @ferretyluv Před rokem +18

      Not sure about derelict cargo, but I know the other three. Flotsam fell off the boat, jetsam was thrown off the boat, and lagan is stuff thrown or fallen off the boat that’s on the sea floor.

    • @zrspangle
      @zrspangle Před rokem +11

      ​@@ferretyluv derelict is cargo where there's no reasonable expectation of being able to recover it.

  • @bobbyfeet2240
    @bobbyfeet2240 Před rokem +1568

    As an Italian American, I endorse the boat-driving joke. I'd note that Christopher Columbus was an Italian, but that really only helps your case.

    • @rincwind666
      @rincwind666 Před rokem +40

      Maybe he had the good sense to not actually do the driving at least

    • @dgpsf
      @dgpsf Před rokem +81

      Check it out, guys! It's-a India!

    • @zaphod4245
      @zaphod4245 Před rokem +77

      "As an Italian American", so... an American

    • @michaelvick2872
      @michaelvick2872 Před rokem +28

      @@zaphod4245 you don’t understand how immigration works?

    • @marsovac
      @marsovac Před rokem +31

      @@michaelvick2872 it is not that, the joke was on "italian american" something that an american has on OCD on specifying both countries. italians would just say italian or american.

  • @jobsteigstra2885
    @jobsteigstra2885 Před rokem +69

    It also works for airplanes. In 1983 a fighter jet from the RAF got lost and landed on a container vessel. The crew of the vessel was awarded 570 000 British pounds.

    • @ferretyluv
      @ferretyluv Před rokem +7

      That must have been a long container ship if a fighter jet could use it as a landing strip.

    • @johnadler6987
      @johnadler6987 Před rokem +9

      @@ferretyluv Could've been a Harrier.

    • @ferretyluv
      @ferretyluv Před rokem +1

      @@johnadler6987 I was thinking of that as I was writing, but were those out in 83?

    • @JustAnotherRandomPersonOnline
      @JustAnotherRandomPersonOnline Před rokem +5

      @@ferretyluv I believe so, yes. (at least a quick google search seems to say yes?)

    • @mistertagnan
      @mistertagnan Před 11 měsíci +3

      @@ferretyluv yes, they were introduced in the late 60s and continued serving until the early 2000s (in some cases)

  • @Lyarrah
    @Lyarrah Před rokem +143

    Ah, I see Ben's working through the list of rejected Crime Spree laws again.
    Edit: in my defense, I said this before I finished watching it, and did not expect the Crime Spree reference at the end.

    • @Speedster___
      @Speedster___ Před rokem

      Nah that’s Adam

    • @unidentifiedperson1357
      @unidentifiedperson1357 Před rokem +1

      hey i remember you from hermitcraft recap

    • @soundscape26
      @soundscape26 Před rokem

      @@romangiertych5198 Admittedly I never watch the credits but does Sam ever write anything?

    • @soundscape26
      @soundscape26 Před rokem

      @@romangiertych5198 Yes, I know he should be the main (sole?) scriptwriter at Wendover but I curious if he ever wrote any episodes for HAI. Maybe at the very beginning.

  • @SebAnders
    @SebAnders Před rokem +55

    "It's legitimate salvage!" is the maritime version of "I'm a legitimate businessman!"

    • @SuprSBG
      @SuprSBG Před rokem +10

      Accidental “The Expanse” reference?

    • @SebAnders
      @SebAnders Před rokem +6

      @@SuprSBG Not intended but fully endorsed, The Expanse is a great series

  • @thejudges1267
    @thejudges1267 Před rokem +46

    Sam I loved the video! rarely does admiralty law get enough love. Two things I wanted to add. First marine peril does not have to be actual. Marine peril can just be the apprehension of peril, like in Markakis v. SS Volendam. This cases had a disabled cruise ship being towed in reasonably calm water to avoid shallow water and the Cuban navy. Second, the 6.4 million was not the final number. That was what the trial court ruled, later that number got reduced on appeal to 4.125 due to a whole re-evaluation of the rocket. see Margate Shipping Co. v. MV J.A. Orgeron. Keep making great videos!

    • @mnxs
      @mnxs Před rokem +6

      Correction, it is _Volendam,_ not _Voldendam_ (which, on a side note, is not not be confused with the Dutch ocean liner from the 1920s of the same name).
      How do I know? Because I googled the case to find out what it was about with the Cuban Navy. And congratulations, you just casually referenced a case that seems so obscure, the only results that came back are the Google Scholar reproductions of the actual court documents. I'm impressed.

  • @emborg3145
    @emborg3145 Před rokem +127

    me on my way to be a legal pirate

  • @cassiemyersconcertvids
    @cassiemyersconcertvids Před rokem +199

    This is very cool, Sam. Thank you for the legal advice.

  • @jakerydont
    @jakerydont Před rokem +40

    “At sea there is no such thing as weird behavior”

  • @ThorRuneHansen
    @ThorRuneHansen Před rokem +13

    My dad and my uncle did this many years ago. A pleasure craft had torn the moorings in a heavy wind, and they went out in a boat and towed it in. They got a certain percentage of the pleasure crafts value. The owner was quite angry to have to pay that, but otherwise the boat might have ended up in some rocks somewhere so that's real peril.

  • @jakesmith9089
    @jakesmith9089 Před rokem +5

    States in the great lakes area have similar laws for salvaging. Usually someone drives their vehicle over an ice covered body of water. The vehicle, shanty, falls through and the owner has 3 days to get the item out and face fines for pollution depending on what fell through the ice. Usually after 3 days the item is available for anyone to salvage and keep as their own even without a title.

  • @EpicgamerwinXD6669
    @EpicgamerwinXD6669 Před rokem +86

    But as long as you’re not the one that caused said ship to sink, right?

    • @notaplic8158
      @notaplic8158 Před rokem +3

      Yes chief

    • @sirel33
      @sirel33 Před rokem +18

      _Right?_

    • @chwriter7138
      @chwriter7138 Před rokem +51

      as long as they can't PROVE you're the one who caused said ship to sink

    • @prim16
      @prim16 Před rokem +18

      @@chwriter7138 *Hey Ferb, I know what we're gonna do today*

    • @sephikong8323
      @sephikong8323 Před rokem +1

      The law only apply if they're fast enough to witness you do it

  • @gargoyle7863
    @gargoyle7863 Před rokem +8

    It triggered me that it was referred to as a weird old law because we have a similar rule in the law here in Germany: Anyone who conducts the business of another without authorization to protect their rights has a claim against them.
    Through this video, I did some research and found out that such a law exists only in some legal systems.

  • @Canniba11er
    @Canniba11er Před rokem +8

    “At sea, there’s no such thing as weird behavior” sums up a ton of maritime traditions, laws and outfits.

  • @JorneDeSmedt
    @JorneDeSmedt Před rokem +13

    An answer to the question "What would happen if we let an Italian drive a boat?"
    Cue flashback to the first Punic War.

    • @TheCheck999
      @TheCheck999 Před rokem +1

      A man of culture I see.

    • @wraithcadmus
      @wraithcadmus Před rokem +2

      Even the more Romaboo channels I follow all go "yeah the Romans couldn't sail for shit"

    • @scythal
      @scythal Před rokem +1

      Remember that one Italian guy who landed on the wrong continent thinking it was India... who was it...?

  • @diante50
    @diante50 Před rokem +4

    When I was studying marine engineer, we were taugh some maritime law and case history too. One in particular involved a crew abandoning ship due to some issue (I think a storm?) And once the storm subsided they saw the ship was still okay. So they went back on and claimed it as salvage.

  • @bradlevantis913
    @bradlevantis913 Před rokem +6

    This it well explained. I occasionally have to go over this with smaller boats and paid salvage/tow boats. The in danger part is always the sticking point. Someone broken down is not in danger-but some “salvage” boats will try to tell them that darkness automatically means danger.

  • @jaquigreenlees
    @jaquigreenlees Před rokem +2

    Some jurisdictions have a restriction on open salvage of derelict vessels. In Canadian waters if you get an abandoned vessel into safety so it is not a hazard to the environment or navigation you are limited to getting your costs incurred back. The "derelict fleets" dotting many waterways would be easy to clear out with this, drag them to a shipyard and get them hauled out and stored on the yard, the fuel costs for the tow, the haulout cost and storage costs ( ever increasing storage costs so it needs to be resolved quickly ) are the recoverables. If it sits on the yard long enough complete title is granted as it's value is the same or less than your expenses.
    Check your local laws for things like that, you can get rid of those falling apart boats anchored in a lot of areas if they have similar regs.

  • @lolicantthinkofabettername3437

    I haven't been following it, but I read a while ago that the firm that unblocked the Seuez canal after the ever given famously blocked it also did so without a contract and it seemed they were going to claim part of the value of the cargo. Don't know whether they ended up doing so tho.

  • @AmaraJordanMusic
    @AmaraJordanMusic Před rokem +11

    My husband is big on history and piracy in general. He has a Jolly Roger tattoo for crying out loud. Any time I think he’s underhanded in a game or something he just smiles and goes, “Pirate.”
    This video is going to make his day. 😂

    • @bullzebub
      @bullzebub Před rokem +1

      has he heard ye banished privateers?

    • @bullzebub
      @bullzebub Před rokem

      czcams.com/video/AnVKiWE2ka8/video.html

  • @dannypipewrench533
    @dannypipewrench533 Před rokem +3

    1:39 Wonderful.

  • @dougerrohmer
    @dougerrohmer Před rokem +11

    There's another weird maritime law: Back in the early 2000's, there was a ship anchored in Table Bay off Cape Town South Africa. A heavy wind came up, and Port Control radioed the ship to warn them that they are dragging their anchors. The captain of the ship's response was "Don't tell me my job, I'm far too clever!" And so it came to pass that the massive ship beached itself and the captain packed his back and got a cab to the airport and sayonara'ed outta there. So now there was a massive containership on the beach, and nobody wanted to foot the bill to yank it off. The owners were some US corporation, and I'm not sure what the story with the insurers was. There was hazardous cargo which included explosives, low-pressure gas and corrosive acids, antimony and uranium ore. And so the ball was kicked around between various government departments, and authorities and nothing happened. At this point, the cargo was still on it, and since it was a huge ship there were a lot of people who had cargo on the ship and they were all begging anybody who would listen to please tow the ship off the beach. Eventually some of the cargo was magic'ed off the ship (not an easy job due to location or whatever) and the fuel oil was pumped out. So there was a huge bill for cleanup and unloading the cargo and cutting up the ship because it was on that beach where everybody takes the pics of Table Mountain from when they need to prove to Facebook that they were in Cape Town. So who's gonna pay? So high powered lawyers get involved, probably funded by the insurers, and they dredge up an ancient maritime law that says everybody who owns cargo on the ship is responsible. Say what? So a whole bunch of Capetonians and companies and such got a bill and had to pay. How about flogging the victims? I can't find confirmation that the cargo owners were stuck with the bill, but that was definitely what I remember. Check it out - Sealand Express.

    • @kaimuller169
      @kaimuller169 Před rokem +4

      pretty sure that everyone got had stuff on the evergiven also had to pay part of the cost of that desaster as well due to some kind of similiar law

    • @dougerrohmer
      @dougerrohmer Před rokem +3

      @@kaimuller169 Yeah, it's nuts. The captain was warned, he screwed up and hit the airport so fast it made your head spin.

  • @yobaafett
    @yobaafett Před rokem

    Your videos have so much more personality, great content as always :)

  • @lauraketteridge324
    @lauraketteridge324 Před rokem +17

    Please write out 100 times, "Salvage is not theft."

  • @3rdalbum
    @3rdalbum Před rokem +3

    It seems like maritime salvage laws fulfil the same function as squatter's rights laws - it encourages messy situations to be cleaned up. Salvage provides an incentive to rid the ocean of abandoned ships, squatter's rights provides an incentive to rid the land of abandoned dwellings.

  • @magnemoe1
    @magnemoe1 Před rokem +5

    Friend of mine got salvage money after a group of kids rescuing an sailboat who was adrift and was close to running aground.
    They towed it to an marina. Some there called insurance companies. Think he got around $3K back in the 80's so serious money for an kid.

  • @danieltelemiare8747
    @danieltelemiare8747 Před rokem +3

    1:45 "We do not endorse the previous joke. Half as Interesting supports all Italians"

  • @idevoru
    @idevoru Před rokem +6

    Surprisingly concise and well written. Just finish my law report on salvage. Maybe you can talk about maritime lien as well

  • @leighsowers5099
    @leighsowers5099 Před rokem +1

    Lloyd’s Open Form hasn’t been no cure no pay since like the 80s. Every LOF has the SCOPIC added since then. It’s not a “it sometimes happens”. Now every contract has the SCOPIC for pollution remediation. You can also have a Wreck Hire, Wreck Fixed, lumpsum, daily hire, time & materials, and other contract types.

  • @Mephitinae
    @Mephitinae Před rokem +2

    Actually the helmsman of Costa Concordia was a an Indonesian migrant who had lied about his qualifications. The Italian Captain was not at the wheel.

  • @yeti4269
    @yeti4269 Před rokem +2

    2:40 Byzantine playing some Civ 5 I see

  • @jabber1990
    @jabber1990 Před rokem +7

    "we just let the pirate steal it since they were going to anyways"

  • @Virtrial
    @Virtrial Před rokem +3

    The fake brick advertisement at 5:57 is why I keep watching this show. Long live the bricks!

  • @79adventures
    @79adventures Před 10 měsíci +1

    Philippines had close to 2000 cargo ships beached during the Odette typhoon. more than 900 spilled oil within a week. was one of the biggest maritime oil spills in South East Asia last Dec 2022

  • @InsaneSoloClutch
    @InsaneSoloClutch Před rokem +3

    “Ferb, I know what we’re gonna do today!”

  • @jackiecs8190
    @jackiecs8190 Před 9 měsíci +1

    I've done this! We were sailing in the caribbean and found a dinghy floating at sea. I grabbed the painter, tied it on, and we let local SAR and the owners know. At the next port we met up with the owner's representative, who called the cops on us, claiming that we were stealing their dinghy and/or trying to extort them. The cops didn't believe them, we returned the dinghy, and I believe the salvage case is still working through the courts

  • @ianbelletti6241
    @ianbelletti6241 Před 3 měsíci +1

    This is a complex issue. It depends on the maritime area it sinks. In the US, we have local state waters, federal waters, and international waters. You have to be certain of which salvage lawset you are under when you salvage the ship.

  • @jaridkeen123
    @jaridkeen123 Před 4 měsíci +1

    Did the crew get the money or the owner if the ship?

  • @clandestin011
    @clandestin011 Před rokem +4

    Here's one for the annual "mistakes we've made" episodes, and yeah I'm gonna be that guy :
    0:11 is that really how you spell "Posiedon"?

  • @Raphael-pt7rx
    @Raphael-pt7rx Před 9 měsíci +1

    imagine you save a ship and they say gj buddy, but you were also on our ship that was about to kill you too, so because you saved yourself we wont reward you

  • @TS_Mind_Swept
    @TS_Mind_Swept Před rokem +1

    I love how you went from a video about pillaging straight in to "half as interestings crime spree" 😂😂😂

  • @ajayluhach007
    @ajayluhach007 Před 9 měsíci +2

    So i just need to legally sink a sheep now, hmmm that's a little too easy

  • @valdermaar
    @valdermaar Před rokem +23

    Hehe. PosIEdon. Time to update that mistake list
    EDIT: 0:12

    • @samiraperi467
      @samiraperi467 Před rokem +9

      Also: 0:12 J. A. Oregeron, 3:04 J. A. Orgeron
      Dunno which is correct but at least one of them is wrong.

  • @grogery1570
    @grogery1570 Před 3 měsíci

    The most unusual salvage claim I know of was in WWII when a merchant vessel was attacked and a fire got out of control, so the captain gave the order to abandon ship. After a few days in life boats some of the crew sighted the ship which was still afloat and the fires had burned themselves out. They eventually were able to claim salvage as the captain was not part of the salvage efforts, there was a legitimate reason to abandon ship and they had obeyed orders when abandoning ship.

  • @jareddavies1699
    @jareddavies1699 Před rokem +1

    Does the money go to the company that owns the ship involved in the salvage, or does it go to the captain and the crew involved?

  • @heidirabenau511
    @heidirabenau511 Před rokem +17

    Where's Legal Eagle when we need him?

    • @SpeedBird6780
      @SpeedBird6780 Před rokem +1

      I don't think he specializes in maritime law.

    • @mfmageiwatch
      @mfmageiwatch Před rokem

      No one ever needs Legal Eagle, he's a hack.

  • @jvwMUSIC
    @jvwMUSIC Před rokem

    does that sum go to the operating company or split between the actual individuals which undertook the risk

  • @finscreenname
    @finscreenname Před rokem

    This not only applies to ocean going vessels but if Sea Tow or the others get your boat hooked up for any reason you are paying them and it can be up to 800 bucks.

  • @peterhoulihan9766
    @peterhoulihan9766 Před rokem +3

    It's hardly obscure, it's been the mainstream rule of abandoned stuff floating at sea since forever. Enshrining it in law was just recognising that very little could stop fishermen stealing abandoned stuff in the mdidle of nowhere with no witnesses and finding a way to tax it.

    • @fakiirification
      @fakiirification Před 4 měsíci

      yeah, this law simply encourages people to report their findings rather than stripping them for everything of value and scuttling the rest that cant be resold without documentation like hull resgestration, etc.

  • @prim16
    @prim16 Před rokem +5

    Time to become a superhero who sinks ships and then rescues them right afterwards

    • @kpolitis6958
      @kpolitis6958 Před rokem +2

      I have the perfect place for you...go to ukraine

  • @TheFallingFlamingo
    @TheFallingFlamingo Před rokem +1

    -Purposefully sink ship containing Arizona Green Teas
    -Loot all the Arizona Green Teas
    -???
    -Drink the sweet nectar of the gods until diabeetus has it's way with you

  • @JeffreyAllanBackowski

    So, if I was on one of those casinos they float on the Mississippi river to get around gambling laws and somehow it mysteriously catches on fire or starts to sink, would I be able to grab whatever I wanted, bounce, then keep whatever I grabbed once I'm off?

  • @watashiandroid8314
    @watashiandroid8314 Před rokem

    So, whats a cargo ship if it is not a bulk carrier, a container ship, or a barge, since those are separate items on that chart?
    And what's a Ro-ro ship??

  • @SalMinella
    @SalMinella Před rokem +2

    🎶 Yourrrrr’e a crook Captain Hook
    Judge won’t you throw the book
    At the Piiiirate... 🎶

  • @13thravenpurple94
    @13thravenpurple94 Před rokem

    Great video THank you

  • @thefareplayer2254
    @thefareplayer2254 Před rokem

    1:42 There goes the Italy season of JetLag 🤣

  • @Trusty_Shellback
    @Trusty_Shellback Před rokem +2

    Lol I wouldnt call it too obscure, at least within the maritime field. I had test questions about pure salvage on my Chief Mate exams I took last week. I also know a guy who is captain of a salvage ship, that industry is very much alive today.

  • @Ze-hy9gw
    @Ze-hy9gw Před rokem +1

    well time to try this now

  • @nahuelma97
    @nahuelma97 Před rokem

    Question: was the amount awarded to the boat that helped the other boats by a court given to the company that owned the boat or to the employees who worked at the boat to help the boat in danger? Like, in those cases, is the sum awarded to the people who literally helped, or to the company that employs the people who literally helped?

  • @Pwn3dbyth3n00b
    @Pwn3dbyth3n00b Před rokem +2

    In the future you might be able to salvage a Martian Naval ship as legitimate salvage.

  • @seniorbob2180
    @seniorbob2180 Před rokem

    @0:50 StarSector Admirals represent!

  • @TheWebstaff
    @TheWebstaff Před rokem +1

    Now I need a video on how the crew didn't get any of the payout on how the form that owned the tanker got all the money.
    Because you know that's what happened.

  • @ONEMoneyONE
    @ONEMoneyONE Před 3 měsíci +1

    Now I just need to figure out how to legally sink a ship

  • @andrewrockwell1282
    @andrewrockwell1282 Před rokem +1

    Random thing to learn on a Friday morning, but kinda interesting. Like not fully interesting like a video about bricks would be, maybe.. half as interesting. 😊

  • @KaranLopez
    @KaranLopez Před rokem +3

    Finally a new career prospect

  • @pepsicle4725
    @pepsicle4725 Před rokem

    hi sam!! love ur vids!!!

  • @KlaxontheImpailr
    @KlaxontheImpailr Před 10 měsíci

    3:51 I want to see this as an scp now 🤣

  • @N3UROTOXIN2505
    @N3UROTOXIN2505 Před 3 měsíci +1

    That Italian joke fell flat because…well Venice. Now if you said let an Italian drive a ship without using a stick

  • @eroc1970
    @eroc1970 Před 7 měsíci +1

    "O the lovely Athens queen"

  • @AmaraJordanMusic
    @AmaraJordanMusic Před rokem +1

    I fully expected a comment about the average flight speed of an unladen swallow at some point, but despite that disappointment (such is life), full marks. Well done.

  • @bandi10xx31
    @bandi10xx31 Před 3 měsíci +1

    SAM YOU DIDNT DESERVE THE SEASON 8 WIN

  • @thewyj
    @thewyj Před rokem

    Is the money awarded to the crew as private individuals, or the company they work for, or the company that owns the ship they're on?

  • @akidshistoryandaviation
    @akidshistoryandaviation Před rokem +1

    I’d heard of this but never knew all the details. Somebody called it “pirate law” but didn’t know all the details

  • @artielikesthings
    @artielikesthings Před rokem

    "no such thing as weird behaviour" at sea really explains ben and adam's cream trip...

  • @djaceofpentacles
    @djaceofpentacles Před rokem +1

    This is so reminiscent of South Park's
    "It was coming right for us!"
    Justification.

  • @quillmaurer6563
    @quillmaurer6563 Před rokem

    A worthy point about the Costa Concordia is that it's salvage was an economic loss. Nobody would have voluntarily salvaged it in exchange for even 100% of the value, as the salvage costs were greater than the damaged ship was worth. Would have been cheaper to just leave it there. But the Italian government ordered the owners to pay up to get it removed, and stipulated that it had to be re-floated and dragged off in one piece rather than scrapped in situ.

  • @NoSlaying
    @NoSlaying Před rokem

    really funny story behind that Costa Concordia, i really recommend watching Internet Historian's video on it

  • @bes03c
    @bes03c Před rokem +1

    I want a reddit AMA with the folks on the oil tanker who got the salvage money.

  • @glen1555
    @glen1555 Před rokem

    In one of the books that make up the Swallows and Amazons series. The children meet a man who had been a boat owner and lost his boat because of salvagers claiming his boat was adrift. Don't ever let anyone on to your boat with a tow rope no matter how friendly they appear when they offer to help you. He offered them some money as a thank you, but they said no, we want one third of the value of your boat. He had to sell his boat to pay them

  • @EinfachFredhaftGaming
    @EinfachFredhaftGaming Před rokem +2

    Main thing keeping me off nebula is the lack of a TV app. Hate watching content while sitting on my desk

    • @petergerdes1094
      @petergerdes1094 Před rokem

      I hate the lack of ability to create playlists and the fact that I can't just listen to audio without the miniplayer on iOS (and everytime I close phone to just listen I have to hit play again)

  • @Hawkathon
    @Hawkathon Před rokem

    Doesn’t the law of salvage have 2 additional elements: 1) the vessel must be on the high seas and 2) it must be abandoned by its crew? I’m not sure if both of those elements were also present. There is a duty an every mariner to assist those in peril to the best of their abilities dating back to the Rolls of Oléron of the 13th Century. I’m not saying that the assisting vessel didn’t otherwise meet the criteria for salvage but they would’ve had to assist the tugboat in peril.

  • @doggonemess1
    @doggonemess1 Před rokem

    3:00 There wouldn't be any space ship juice on board. The tanks were fueled just before launch - therefore the tanks were empty.

  • @mahbriggs
    @mahbriggs Před rokem

    Anybody who is even slightly aware of marine commerce knows about this!
    The salvor, in this case risked his ship to save the barge and tug.
    And by the way, saved NASA the cost of a replacement fuel tank!
    This is the Law of the Sea, and the idea is not to keep the cargo and ship from pirates, but to prevent a total loss of said ship and cargo!

  • @pervocracy
    @pervocracy Před rokem

    There was a fun salvage case in the 60s when a USAF B-52 carrying nuclear weapons crashed off the coast of Spain. A local fisherman found one of the bombs and asked for a modest 1% finder's fee--on a $2 billion value. (They settled out of court for probably a lot less and supposedly never paid up. I don't know for certain, but I wonder if one of the counterarguments was "you know what, keep it, it's yours... which makes you a nuclear armed non-state actor. best of luck with that.")

  • @johnwang9914
    @johnwang9914 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Well a sociopathy diagnosis not a psychopathy diagnosis, at least till direct harm to others are considered.

  • @noneofyourbizness
    @noneofyourbizness Před rokem

    1:19
    Wow! those numbers are terrifying. All those losses in just 10 'modern' years. 72 passenger ships ..WTF?

  • @JaykPuten
    @JaykPuten Před rokem +2

    The salvage tanker crew started a casino in international waters...
    Or so I'd like to think...
    Or found a small island nation, bought out the politicians and made it a utopia

  • @feritperliare2890
    @feritperliare2890 Před 3 měsíci +1

    I suggest we don't give people that already seem detached from existence some assumptions that someone can sink a ship and plunder it

  • @2200stiffy
    @2200stiffy Před rokem +1

    Pelican Soup. I'm dieing 😂😂

  • @Maik_Grnto
    @Maik_Grnto Před rokem +1

    Guess Sam read the book “In Peril” and it gave him the idea to make this video about the situation lol

  • @TheHylianBatman
    @TheHylianBatman Před rokem +5

    Wow, very cool.
    Maritime law is so weird, and so interesting.

    • @apveening
      @apveening Před rokem

      Maritime law is so weird because it evolved over centuries with lots of legal systems involved.