Editorial With Sujit Nair | Are Politicians Deceiving India? | Freebies | Maharashtra | Karnataka

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 09. 2024
  • In this episode of ‘Editorial’, Mr. Sujit Nair discusses how ‘Freebies’ are now being used as a poll strategy in Indian elections. Mr. Nair discusses the recently launched ‘Majhi Ladki Bahin Scheme’ launched by the BJP-led Mahayuti in Maharashtra which promises Rs. 1500 monthly to women between the age of 21-60 age group. Many state governments like Punjab, Delhi, Madhya Pradesh, Karnataka have launched such social schemes. But these schemes come with a toll on the state budget.
    #Maharashtra #MajhiLadkiBahin #Mahayuti #DevendraFadnavis #EknathShinde #AjitPawar #BJP #ShivSena #NCP #Siddharamaiah #Karnataka #MadhyaPradesh #ShivrajSinghChouhan #Punjab #BhagwantMann #Delhi #ArvindKejriwal #Freebies #HWNews
    To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
    Support independent journalism by subscribing to HW News English Premium Newsletter: hwnews.in/subs...
    To Join CZcams Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
    SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscrib...
    Connect With Us On:
    → Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
    → Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
    → Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
    → Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/c...
    → Dailymotion : www.dailymotio...
    For More Videos Visit Here:
    hwnews.in/

Komentáře • 126

  • @antoniodiniz8024
    @antoniodiniz8024 Před měsícem +16

    Very sensible and pragmatic arguments to awaken the mindset of the voters not fall prey for offers of freebies at the time of election.

  • @sureshbhasker5408
    @sureshbhasker5408 Před měsícem +12

    I agree hundred percent with you sujith

    • @siddhartha5875
      @siddhartha5875 Před měsícem

      he never talks about keralites bombarding to bengaluru 😡

    • @jayanthlaxman9188
      @jayanthlaxman9188 Před měsícem

      Why dont you go to kerala ? They need labour there. Lots of guys are thronging to kerala from UP and Bihar !

  • @mariapetma
    @mariapetma Před měsícem +6

    Very interesting editorial Mr Sudhir Nair.
    Teaching fishing is always more important than just giving fish.

  • @neildcosta5932
    @neildcosta5932 Před měsícem +3

    You're absolutely right Sujith. Freebies are a nuisance for the upper middle class which gets nothing free, but pays for the freebies. This class of people is under the highest pressure of taxation with no returns.

  • @marlondsouza2582
    @marlondsouza2582 Před měsícem +4

    There was a time when individuals were moved by the desire to serve, but that was then.....Today self service and self preservation is trending. This is where democracy has fallen short. If man is compromised, how far will a country go?

  • @amritpalsingh3293
    @amritpalsingh3293 Před měsícem +11

    The freebie culture started by AAP.
    Comgress is now following the same.
    BJP used to call it Freebies, now following the same footsteps

    • @ashnaagarwal4825
      @ashnaagarwal4825 Před měsícem

      Aap has still given only education,healthcare and electricity free and still the fdi ratio of Delhi is the lowest in the country if the leader is smart and educated he can manage both freebies and fdi ratio

    • @amritpalsingh3293
      @amritpalsingh3293 Před měsícem +1

      @@ashnaagarwal4825 Also free bus rides to half of Dellhi. well, they ignored infra that is why no new water processing plants were completed. We could see the first floods in Delhi last year. This year, a large population of Delhi suffered from water supply. You need money to develop infra. Now don't get into politics by blaming neighbouring state govts for water floods or water supply in Delhi. I am blaming all the parties here.
      If you give freebies, you cannot develop infra. This disease of freebies have to be rooted out.
      The revadi culture used by Mr. Nair was first used Modi.
      But if people for the time being vote for freebie the parties like congress and BJP cannot be left behind till the time the reality hits people that freebies is not sustainable.
      There used be a subsidy culture in India till late 80s and that almost brought us to economic collapse by early 90s

    • @aleyammarenjiv7978
      @aleyammarenjiv7978 Před měsícem +1

      It is started by AIDMK, Ms. Jayalalitha

    • @aleyammarenjiv7978
      @aleyammarenjiv7978 Před měsícem +1

      Education and health care should be free. We pay income tax and doesn't get any benefits. In Kerala even Govt aided schools also Education is free

    • @amritpalsingh3293
      @amritpalsingh3293 Před měsícem

      @@aleyammarenjiv7978 Basic health care is negligible if you go to civil hospital. Bit atleast there is some agreement between people that freebies be banned

  • @noorjahanrahamathulla2461
    @noorjahanrahamathulla2461 Před měsícem +1

    Sujit ji, your messages to the public is always an eye opener and this editorial is not different from that. It is a mind awakening and people need to think about the freebies. People in poverty will remain in the same state and the middle class will be loaded with taxes. In this only middle and upper middle class are the sufferers. In next election let people think about this and vote.

  • @krishnamurtisharma4507
    @krishnamurtisharma4507 Před měsícem +1

    Valid point . Govt . must review the impact of Freebees on economy .

  • @SSKS_22
    @SSKS_22 Před měsícem +7

    Freebies to people and NPA’s to some corporates is not at all good for the economy of any country.

  • @raghavendravishwas5929
    @raghavendravishwas5929 Před měsícem +13

    Sir Karnataka Government s doing great works..Don't blame Mr Sidhu unnecessarily

    • @jonron3805
      @jonron3805 Před měsícem +1

      Yeh thats why he is encouraging Karnataka people to work under north-indians. He thinks Karnataka people are incapable as Managers so lower reservation there.

    • @raghavendraraob6373
      @raghavendraraob6373 Před měsícem

      Yes great work indeed ! We ate given petrol diesel to smell and beet Brandi and milk to drink.And he us enjoying with votes at the cost of middle class. You people appreciate Good joke is it not ?

  • @wilfredalexandercoelho8003
    @wilfredalexandercoelho8003 Před měsícem

    absolutely correct what has been said by Sujit Nair in the above video.

  • @kyns3946
    @kyns3946 Před měsícem

    Yes, Sir. I have always had the same thought as yours about this issue. Glad you had made this presentation. The crux if the matter is how will the people of India understand this and rejects such politics.

  • @anslemslove5215
    @anslemslove5215 Před měsícem +6

    Politicians are representative of the people ... they are not from another country or planet.

  • @higdcvh
    @higdcvh Před měsícem +2

    I was waiting for this show. Thank you Mr. Nair.

  • @rashtragauravasamarakshana9029

    Jayalalita was the pioneer of FREEBIES

  • @RkR2001
    @RkR2001 Před měsícem +1

    Good comment --These people keep Inventing Innovating 😮

  • @DISABLED950
    @DISABLED950 Před měsícem +2

    Great tuition sir

  • @aleyammarenjiv7978
    @aleyammarenjiv7978 Před měsícem +1

    Yesterday Telengana waved off farmers loan and people were quick to apply for the next loan

  • @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
    @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 Před měsícem +2

    Politicians generally do the right thing when all other options are exhausted Daniel J Mitchell

  • @prasadrao4906
    @prasadrao4906 Před měsícem +1

    In Odisha the BJP offered ₹3000 pension to the elderly, ₹50000 as Subhadra Yojana to all the women, 300 units of free electricity and sending 6 lakh people to Ayodhya etc and won the elections.

  • @venkataramakrishnapulavart3823

    Yes, none of the politicians are worthy to be called leaders. We are being deceived.

  • @tonlihwangsa8982
    @tonlihwangsa8982 Před měsícem +1

    the problem with us Indians are that we want things for free And why not if the govt is giving something free they are happy without knowing where that free stuff is coming from.

  • @troffieribeiro-jo7el
    @troffieribeiro-jo7el Před měsícem +1

    Sujjit sir yes absolutely right.
    But one thing is sure that FREEBIES will not work in Maharashtra.

  • @prasan8825
    @prasan8825 Před měsícem +2

    Thr is nothing called freebies... Its the responsibility of govt to be with people. If thr govt is not giving proper share to revenue generating states, only option avlb to extract it's fair share is to offer freebies and become sick state like UP & Bihar... 🤷🏼‍♀️ Divide equal share to all states, cut special treatment to UP, MP, Rajasthan, Bihar 40% of country problem will be solved.. 🤷🏼‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️ If govt cannot provide Roti, Kapada, Makaan thn for what we need govt. 🤷🏼‍♀️

  • @janurao8308
    @janurao8308 Před měsícem

    Dear Sujit Nair Jee... Thank you so very much for 'Staying On Course' despite all the adversities and also, the adversaries, that you have faced over the last few years.
    I am so happy that you mentioned the Chinese saying that has been so often used and I do not want to repeat, "If a man gives you a fish............... And if a man teaches how to fish.."

    • @janurao8308
      @janurao8308 Před měsícem

      Sorry, apologies for the ignorance on how to manage my message. But basically, I was saying that the reality of life is a lot more complex than just teaching someone how to fish! I am a humanitarian and development worker doing exactly the things you are saying here for the past 30 plus years, 8 of them in India and then overseas. Please understand that skill development is not enough.
      Continuing with the same logic of teaching a man (and yes a woman too), would not necessarily solve that person;s/ families/ communities' food security issues.

  • @hameedshahul6191
    @hameedshahul6191 Před měsícem +1

    It's Jayalaltha AIDMK TN Don who Inaugurated this freebies cultures and became highly successful 😢

  • @ajithkumark6084
    @ajithkumark6084 Před měsícem +2

    You are right Sir, welfare scheam like reasonable old age pension and can be supportive, Farmers and students education needed a interest free or lower interest loans

  • @rajarammanyam4860
    @rajarammanyam4860 Před měsícem +1

    Exactly.

  • @aniljacob72
    @aniljacob72 Před měsícem +2

    Yes they are.

  • @sudeshbandu8852
    @sudeshbandu8852 Před měsícem

    If one is offering freebies and winning elections what others will do, they have to follow their footsteps for their existence.. Kejriwal is the father of freebies culture.

  • @pardeeptandon
    @pardeeptandon Před měsícem +1

    AAP started with free quality education and free medical facilities which is the responsibility of the government.
    200 free electricity was given to the poor by subsidies from enhanced electricity bills of the rich. This cross subsidising be virtually every government in the world

  • @inezdsouza203
    @inezdsouza203 Před měsícem +1

    Good question!! I don't trust anyone of them unfortunately . They all just may money on our cost..

  • @shyam_n
    @shyam_n Před měsícem +2

    state govt increases tax and giving to poor.... the other element who increase the cess and give it to rich are you ok with it...?

  • @japanmesmerises1384
    @japanmesmerises1384 Před měsícem +1

    Sir, giving freebies to people who don't get preferred for any employment. Then it's social welfare. Those who worked,earned and used money judiciously will use it wisely
    Free money to young unemployment will work damage. The youth will always be not willing to work . Free money will be expected.
    Sir, I have always felt exactly this topic. They are going to face fiery karma

  • @rjansounder231
    @rjansounder231 Před měsícem +1

    Government has a social responsibility unlike Corporates.Upliftment of the poor is enshrined in the Constitution.Same opposition should be echoed by the Editor for Corporate loan waiver.

  • @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
    @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 Před měsícem +1

    You have to admit it -Freebies will rule our politics- One state starts it and others follow - Look at the free bus travel for women -All states will go for it and try to recover the amount from other travelers - They dont care whether the state will fall into debts -

    • @aleyammarenjiv7978
      @aleyammarenjiv7978 Před měsícem

      True. Telengana started free travel for women. Nowadays most the women using public transport and people are traveling to native places too often putting employers in trouble. For maids we give two paid leaves, then partial leaves, sick leave etc all paid . Hardly they 1.5 hrs perday

  • @SureshKumar-xc8up
    @SureshKumar-xc8up Před měsícem +2

    Yes

  • @lourdumary5915
    @lourdumary5915 Před měsícem +1

    Politicians are too smart, and what, they call freebies, are in fact not free. Money needs to be invested whether in goods or services, or both. That money in fact comes from the citizens of this country, whether in the form of taxes or GST, or on every commodity and services bought on a daily basis. All, what governments call freebies, are in fact paid by the people. But the politicians misappropriate this credit to themselves, and that is nothing less than cheating/deceiving.

  • @zafaralamansari6776
    @zafaralamansari6776 Před měsícem

    Great knowledge share by Sujit Nair sir

  • @belezadsouza1744
    @belezadsouza1744 Před měsícem

    🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉excellent video

  • @nagarajado
    @nagarajado Před měsícem +1

    Haha very nice and very interesting. What Delhi government is doing 100% right now. No 1 reason aap government is not corrupt. Instead writing off capitalist s . Elected people are getting free transportation, phone bill , discounted food, free accommodation. Then why not common man. And Delhi government is mounting their debt. I have lot of things to discuss. I can better debate on this. I can’t write everything on this

  • @sandeepdhanote5008
    @sandeepdhanote5008 Před měsícem +1

    Do IMC employees need salary? It's peanuts compared to the "tax free salary" they get directly from public.

  • @johnwisdom651
    @johnwisdom651 Před měsícem +1

    Most politicians dont have a vision or the righ knowledge on Governance and how Govt functions

  • @ManojBaishya-ep3wz
    @ManojBaishya-ep3wz Před měsícem +1

    True

  • @Hes12378
    @Hes12378 Před měsícem +2

    This channel is worth watching.

  • @jkm3215
    @jkm3215 Před měsícem +1

    Common man get peanuts as freebies, the real beneficiaries are corporates whose loans are waived by banks.

  • @rockingmudassir
    @rockingmudassir Před měsícem +1

    Reduce taxes no need freebies

  • @marypinto3069
    @marypinto3069 Před měsícem +1

    I am a congress person. But I strongly object Rahul Gandhi’s offering of Rs one lakh to women. It will ruin our country. Secondly those women working will stop working. Let him explain from where the hell he will bring the money What’s the effect on the economy. If he is not paying then it is like Modijis RS: 15 lakhs. Life bar tane Sunte raho

  • @glenalanshillong770
    @glenalanshillong770 Před měsícem +1

    Politicians have been deceiving India from time immemorial nothing new thats why the richest country in the world is still a third world country...Indians should be the happiest people in the world but we aren't..... ???

  • @virendra4995
    @virendra4995 Před měsícem

    Yes this is the topic

  • @rosyjohn7019
    @rosyjohn7019 Před měsícem

    Sujit ever I make a point to any party I always tell them to check the heart beat of the economy.
    Instead of freebies help women to start self help groups and give emoyment to the youth so that they can live an respectable life instead of anyone saying that they feed 80 crores people.Mary John

  • @pacman1437
    @pacman1437 Před měsícem

    The title should be "HOW POLITICIANS ARE LOOTING US AFTER INDEPENDENCE"😅

  • @sudhakarjain1299
    @sudhakarjain1299 Před měsícem +2

    Are newschnnel deceiving india? Because such headlines nit seen about ₹16 lak crores given to corporate

  • @vinodphilips3121
    @vinodphilips3121 Před měsícem

    How can there be idealism in politics, who is to be blamed.... politicians or people themselves

  • @MrDLVORA
    @MrDLVORA Před měsícem

    Start freebees is very easy but which government will have courage to stop same scheme .

  • @Anarchist_syndicalist
    @Anarchist_syndicalist Před měsícem +3

    Tax the rich

  • @dr.santoshb.r.2534
    @dr.santoshb.r.2534 Před měsícem

    Yessssss 100000000% & there's no any doubt it ....🤔🤔👎👎👎👎

  • @rosemicmeriba9334
    @rosemicmeriba9334 Před měsícem

    🎉🎉

  • @dr.madanmohan6700
    @dr.madanmohan6700 Před měsícem

    Yes any doubt 🙋‍♀️ 🙌 😉 😌 😄 😀 🙋‍♂️ 🙌 😉 😌 😄 😀

  • @valentinethebestandthevery1807

    It's a fact they are

  • @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
    @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 Před měsícem

    Maharashtra will have a recurring expanding expenditure -

  • @stevencolaco4931
    @stevencolaco4931 Před měsícem

    So True...but try telling this to the recipient of the free money..they are all so excited at the idea of getting it... so sad this is making us into a handout nation.

  • @santoshoak1921
    @santoshoak1921 Před měsícem +1

    This channel was praising Congress manifesto before general Elections. Khata khat garibi hatao.

  • @rathinbanerjee7136
    @rathinbanerjee7136 Před měsícem

    "Are politicians deceiving India"? And so are you by placing the facts as a question.

  • @rukmanimanay6607
    @rukmanimanay6607 Před měsícem

    The Govt. must not only stop freebies but also all reservations except for the economically backward- wake up citizens before you vote. Nothing is given free!!

  • @chetan9811106355
    @chetan9811106355 Před měsícem +1

    Sujit Ji, What you think, The Indians (for whom before 2014:- 75 Rs/L Petrol, 55 Rs/L Diesal. 450 Rs LPG Cylinder, 85 Rs/Kg Arhar Dal was expensive and 60+ INR vs $ was Shame) after giving 3rd term to Modi Ji, WILL HAVE ANY CONCERN ABOUT FREEBIES AND PAYING MORE TAXES??????

  • @TheGreatVivek7
    @TheGreatVivek7 Před měsícem

    Do the right thing and make a video on reservation and the reason why it should be scrapped.

  • @jaysinghpawarjaysinghpawar3243

    Yes no dougt

  • @RkR2001
    @RkR2001 Před měsícem

    What about recent Karnataka Reservations in private sector bill ?

  • @sandhyamahesh3082
    @sandhyamahesh3082 Před měsícem +1

    Mr. Sujit I really disappointed for your cover pic as you included Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah pic with deceivers its not fair to keep his pic with such faces.. Here Karnataka CM's intentions are very pure not political where all political for their political gain they are doing all..

  • @premkumarnayak1162
    @premkumarnayak1162 Před měsícem

    Koi koi Jad tak cleanliness karaane men laga hua hai.
    Environment aur mother Earth ka sapoot.

  • @SureshBhasker-u1j
    @SureshBhasker-u1j Před měsícem +1

    You can verify all over India. Biharis and Bengalis are all over India. Maybe you are not well informed.

  • @rktiger1
    @rktiger1 Před měsícem

    Hello Naya.. Please lecture Pappu with his khata khat scheme

  • @marthaudom6543
    @marthaudom6543 Před měsícem +1

    It’s very sad! Modi has ruined the country and infested the political system for the people of India pain anxiety depression and anger and pain and suffering and life is draining and so insecure for the people of India

  • @indianambassador
    @indianambassador Před měsícem

    Sujitji..BJP shift their ideology for votes during elections e.g. ladli behna, modi guarantees etc. 😂 but with this editorial, it's funny to see your ideological shift towards utopian russian oligarch based capitalist narrative.Freebies are given in developed countries as well.Pls release an editorial to propose best ideology case for India e.g. socialist/capitalist/communist

  • @shyam_n
    @shyam_n Před měsícem

    okie we will teach you ... by ignoring you and condemning you... i hope u agree

  • @marthaudom6543
    @marthaudom6543 Před měsícem

    Tell modi to open food banks free for all the people of India so need to buy food because food banks are available

  • @shyam_n
    @shyam_n Před měsícem

    kelri and modi came only after 2012....

  • @johnmarja323
    @johnmarja323 Před měsícem

    I

  • @AnthonyMathews-fp3zk
    @AnthonyMathews-fp3zk Před měsícem

    Paying 3000 and charging 6000 is Bulshit. Please don't give false informations. Nonsense argument.

  • @swaminathank2727
    @swaminathank2727 Před měsícem

    Don't talk the foolish language of bjp. I may stop viewing this channel Mr. Nair.

  • @loka120
    @loka120 Před měsícem

    Jaishankar case must also be probed. His father was an IAS officer and chamcha of Indira Gandhi. He was given USA posting on his first assignment which is abnormal. Normally IFS gets USA posting after many years of experience. His wife is Japanese and may be leaking sensitive IFS information to Japan and USA.

  • @RizwanSeikh
    @RizwanSeikh Před měsícem

    try to make videos in all regional languages of India , Hindi, Urdu, Tamil, Telugu, oriya, Nepali and all