Natalia Kills and Willy Moon fired from The X Factor NZ following scathing attack on contestant
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 03. 2015
- Twitter: / thetvnews
No copyright infringement intended. Belongs to Mediaworks / FremantleMedia
Fans of X Factor NZ contestant Joe Irvine are rushing to his defence this morning, following a blistering attack on his appearance by judges Willy Moon and Natalia Kills last night.
The husband-and-wife duo ignored his performance entirely, instead focusing on his slick new look - which Kills said was ripped off Moon.
"As an artist who respects creative integrity and intellectual property, I am disgusted at how much you've copied my husband," she began. "From the hair to the suit, do you not have any value or respect for originality?"
And it only got worse from there.
"You're a laughing stock. It's cheesy, it's disgusting. I personally found it absolutely artistically atrocious. I am embarrassed to be sitting here in your presence even having to dignify you with an answer of my opinion."
Her husband continued the attack, saying it was "cheap and absurd".
"It's like [Psycho character] Norman Bates dressing up in his mother's clothing. It's just a little bit creepy, and I feel like you're going to stitch someone's skin to your face and then kill everybody in the audience."
"It's disgusting," added Kills. "You make me sick. It's absolutely disgusting. You have no identity, I can't stand it. I'm ashamed to be here."
Irvine smiled through the grilling, later tweeting a photo giving the thumbs-up and writing, "I survived the Kills!"
But viewers haven't been so gracious, taking to CZcams and social media to let Moon and Kills know what they think.
"Natalia and his husband sound like rich f***s who step all over people for fun," LegitYT wrote on CZcams.
"I just checked Wikipedia and found that her husband did, indeed, invent 'The Suit'. Surprisingly, he was also the first man to ever put product in his hair," added Dan Hildreth.
Former contestant Benny Tipene wrote on Twitter he was "gutted" about going back on the show that kickstarted his career, "especially with someone so heartless. F**k that feedback."
On Reddit, the response was much the same, with one contributor suggesting Moon stole his look off '90s cartoon character Butthead.
"I know the guy, he's an absolute sweet heart. You the man Joe, she's a heartless wanna be bitch," said Redditor Magictonay.
"Who the hell does she think she is?" asked Princess3ply. "What she said wasn't constructive, it was downright vile."
"For me, it's absolute hilarious that two people I have never heard of are ripping apart a man in a suit for all things," said Devilsgotmywhisky. "Perhaps this husband is an unoriginal hypocrite for wearing one of the most common outfits of the century."
Irvina and Kills are both trending on Twitter this morning, with even 3 News presenter Hilary Barry weighing in.
@Hilary_Barry "Shame on you Natalia. Shame on you. #xfactornz"
More than 1300 people retweeted Barry's thoughts.
"If @Hilary_Barry says that it means your f****d up big time," added @Eyesz13.
"Bullying is NEVER acceptable, especially on National TV," wrote @ACeeyShaw, while @Raj_In_Charge kept it simple: "Who is Natalia Kills?"
Others suggested Kills and Moon forgot what kind of show X Factor is supposed to be.
@angewad "Isn't this a singing competition not a fashion competition? #StopBullying #xfactornz"
All Black Israel Dagg weighed in too. @izzy_dagg "Those comments were inappropriate and disgraceful.. #xfactornz"
Some have come to Kills' defence, though they are definitely in the minority.
@MELODEEZE "Saying we're supposed to be nice to em cause they're 17 year olds? Um care bout their age! Their perfomance was boring full stop! #xfactornz"
TV3 posted a statement on its Facebook page last night, following the episode.
"Following tonight’s episode of The X Factor NZ we received a huge amount of feedback about comments made by our judges. The nature of live television can be unpredictable and we appreciate you taking the time to voice your opinion. TV3 does not condone bullying and are currently on-site with Joe who is doing well."
A petition set up on Change.org to have Kills and Moon booted off the show already has more than 22,000 supporters. More than 32,000 have joined a Facebook page with a similar goal.
3 News
So... she thinks her husband invented suits??
+Ryan Denziloe i cant tell if someones playing a joke but it says it in his wiki, search willy moons
+Ryan Denziloe Lol I know. White guy in a suit with a side part, soooo unique!
LOL
+Ryan Denziloe And hair aswell
+space man Suits where invented long before he was born...
When the contestant is more professional than the judges
annyeong jam 100%
true
More mature than the contestant i say,
@@yellowsunday9230 true
Agree
“I’m ashamed to be here” don’t worry Natalia, everyone else is ashamed you’re here too
And that basically sealed her fate. She wasn't popular enough to be this arrogant lol
bc she did what she had to do bc everything was staged?
1:38 respect for this lady ! She raised her voice against bullying !!
💯
She looks disgusted at those two.
But she took waaay too long to stand up for him
bro everything was planned from the show
@@N1rr7maybe not. Natalia kills disgusted expression looks genuine
That’s not even criticism that’s practically verbal abuse. At least the other judges and the audience supported him.
These people are not kiwi, kiwis known for their humbleness.
not even verbal abuse its bullying
@@humblegorilla935 Nice way of putting it... Humbleness
so unprofessional she should have just talked about the performance then moved on
The audience? They literally booed him.
Maybe I'm living under a rock or something but I've never heard of her husband before
Same here
Maria Manea it’s people who’ve been living under a rock are the ones who actually heard of her husband. 😂
I had never heard of her or her husband before this
I haven't either
Neither did I and no do I want to
"Acutually you dress better than her husband" SAVAGE!!!
Wow, my heart actually hurts watching this brutality and bullying. I can’t imagine treating any human like this.. how cruel and heartless. He’s so handsome and I hope he was able to get through this. Unbelievable that it was even aired actually.
The wars going on in the world. I'm sure he'll "get through this" 😂😂 idiot!
This was live
i copied her husband once when i went for a job interview.
FELT ASHAMED OF MYSELF.
Ur disgusting
You're sick and absolutely disgusting.
How dare you still allow yourself to live?
Pyro 😂😂😂😂😂
That's cheesy and disgusting. I'm ashamed to read this.
When you’re insulting someone and don’t realise that you look like Lord Farquard
Haha best comment ever
Looool
Dang.....😂😂tis hits me hard
Armitage Shanks 😂 true
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA THIS COMMENT.
Even though 7 years have passed, I feel so hurt to see this young man being literally insulted and humiliated in front of everyone for NO-THING😑....He didn't deserve that. Hope he moved on from that incident.. 😤
She and her husband were set up!~
Everything she said was totally unnecessary, he didn't copy anyone, he looks like thousands other men in a suit.
Willy Moon invented tuxedo, don't you know? 🤣🤣
@@SigalDa 🤣
Omg she has no respect for originality, she stole this look from dora the explorer
Dora with a thick eyeliner
He said "You've copied Cleopatra."
Who is she ? What does she actually do ?
@@blobfishonflyingunicorns3087 Since being booted out of the show after this episode, she now works as a lunch lady and janitor at some preschool in New Zealand.
link biff she’ll bully the children working in a school. A child will pick some rubbish up off the floor and she’ll end up accusing the child of copying her. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Natalia Kills her career.
lmao
+FistKitso your profile picture just makes that wayyy more funny
+TheCrustyDorito It's the memes
Lmaol 😂 well said!
There´s nothing to kill, because it wasn´t even there in the first place
0:29 "but don't you copy Cleopatra"😂😂
As a human, we don’t claim her.
I mean did her husband invent suits and hair gel?
Nope. She's disgusting. Where is she now
@@mightyobserver12 Banished to the shadow realm.
I think so
Acording to Google he did
@@mightyobserver12 She's in a band called "Cruel Youth." Their music is pretty good.
So all men who dress in a suit are copying her husband?? Crazy lady
*picture of man from 1960 wears a suit*
"YOU COPIED MY HUSBAND!"
John Wick: *Wears a suit*
Natalia: You copied my husband
specialunit 042 😂😂😂😂
Hahaha ❤️❤️❤️
White men who wear suits and comb their hair back 😂😂
Even though Natalia's comments were cruel and bullying Willy's were down right disgusting and vile. To compare him to a real life serial killer, that's just not on. I'm proud that Mel stood up for him 👏
Meanwhile he looks like and sounds like Kmart Patrick Bateman if he was some spoilt English kid.
This makes me want to cry. Like she literally was just bullying him she wasn’t doing her jobs properly. You can see all the pain in his face and I just wish I could give home a hug or something like this is just so annoying to watch
She was actually told by people higher up to be horrible
Did anyone else hear the other man saying "but don't you copy cleopatra?" 😂😂
+Dxkshyaa .L When did he say that?
+gircakes Never mind it's at 0:29
😂😂
Yeah
he should have waited until she finished talking. Would have had a greater impact.
Props to the other female judge for standing up for him.
+VenuSux redditor here
+VenuSux Yep, thank you /r/AskReddit.
+VenuSux you and me both. But I've seen it before aswell
Jenna Parry oh :p she's pretty stupid lol.
+VenuSux as is the husband. How is he gonna sit there and refer to someone as a fictional serial killer on live prime time TV. Absurd
She’s treating him like he’s not even human! She’s literally copying Cleo Patra from head to toe!
I broke down in tears when I first watched this video! The fact that Joe was able to keep his composure throughout this attack was remarkable! Such disgusting and evil hate speech coming from these two figures! Very sad! 💔
remember when natalia ruined her own career? Wait... what career?
Oof
And i oops
miss Grace Jones she *killed* her career
I actually never heard of her
"Actually, you dress better than her husband" My thoughts exactly!
I love when she said that
Did you see the stare he was giving her after she said that? Dude clearly has a fragile ego.
an actual monkey in a suit also dresses better than her husband.
Not only dress even his looks is 70% better than her husband
Episode is too cringe to watch. Glad u pointed out a moment where someone defended the contestant
The way he held himself up is so respectable
She's taking about identity when she's changed her name a million times and has stolen the looks of Dora the Explorer and Cleopatra.
"Akchili Akchili Akchili Akchili, you dress better than her husband!"
lmao
XD
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
+Ɛтнαη "Cookies" is that how "actually" is spelled in NZ?
nope, it's a meme word.
Natalia Kills? The only thing she killed was he nonexistent career.
5yrs later and it's still relevant today
Bruh, I hope these two are cringing every night about how this moment destroyed their pathetic careers for the rest of their lives.
Natalia & Willy: You took everything away from me!
Joe: I don't even know who you are.
Natalia basically Killed her career
Focking bitch
badum tsss
Shut up,bitch
chris georgallis true!
What career ?
It’s a singing competition, not a fashion show.
I know right. I feel bad for him. -~-
True
Acttaly it's a talent show but ok...
@@tams1417 still went there to sing
@@danwhowatches707 but its a talent show idiot shut up dummy fukin hell
As a groom, I apologize for copying your husband. I feel ashamed of myself.
Man if only Simon was here, he would have definitely roast that lady judge!
Nathalia: You are a laughing stock!
*Nathalia gets kicked off show*
Who is the laughing stock now??
Radical Change hey
Well well how the turn tables
*Natalia
HE JUST WANTED TO WEAR A SUIT DAMN
Livi Holliday lol init
I feel so bad for that guy😢.I am so happy that girl stood up for him.
This just randomly made it’s way into my brain after all these years and I had to check back to see if this incident was as awful as I remember it being. It was. I remember thinking how ironic her little tirade about “originality” & “artistic integrity” was when she and her entire career were stuck in Lady Gaga’s Fame Monster era.
I just love how the man just kept smiling at natalia like "girl you know u copied dora"
me too
lol like I'm sure he was routing her much better in his head
Omg I’d have fricking died laughing if he’d come back at her with that! 😂
I’d say he was in shock
😂😂
Ok so every person who has ever wore leggings and a t shirt is just copying me
Every person with eyes are copying me
+Ritu Gupta every person that has ever inhaled oxegen is copying me
Molly Bryceland *Inhales Deeply*
every person that has blinked is copying me
We're all copy cats now
She really thinks her husband popularised suits and slick back hair? 😭 the reach is mental
She talking about how he doesn't respect originality but she pretending to be the owner of the huge chocolate factory.
“You dress better than her husband” burnnnnuu
Facts
She copied willy wonka
he is way handsomeher then her
She must be a big fan of willy wonka because she married someone named willy and dresses like him lel
Leila, BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHhahahah
+Master Of Shadows you know, cursing really makes you sound uneducated. Also, you should have put a comma after "than" and before "dumbshit".
+Master Of Shadows it's because, not bcuz. If you are going to correct some on their spelling and grammar, "then" yours better be perfect.
I love how the other judges just look at her like "lmao what"
“But don’t you copy Cleopatra?” SAVAGEEEE😂😂😂
1:36 actually actually actUaLlY ACtU A LL Y
kid nick 😂😂😂
OMG 😂
MY WHOLE LIFE
a whole ass mood
Actually, Mel needs glasses 👓
That guy deserves major props for complimenting her after what she said. I wouldn't be able to do that at all. I didn't know it was such a crime to wear a suit 😐
poor guy was near tears
Your comment has absolutely no taste. It's disgusting. You have no respect for yourself. I feel embarrassed to be sitting right here commenting the same video xD
totally agree, i don't think people should act like that even if they are celebrities, its not how you treat people, and exactly i would have cried, and maybe even jumped her for humiliating me in public, it is so hard for a person to get on stage and for them to rip his heart out was horrible, i am so happy that moment "kill"ed her and her husbands careers i get that sometimes it ok to be a little harsh but that was the worst piece of criticism i've ever heard on any of these shows, even Simon wasn't that mean. she is evil. cleo patra look alike. lol
Claudio Gonzalez lol i get it. you're so funny. omg
Apparently wearing suits is not allowed any more because we'd copy the originality of her husband,
A man in a suit is dressed as her husband? There are billions of them.
I heard someone said, that she Copied Cleopatra😂😂😂 who said that!? On point! 😂😂😂
Guys i'am ashamed to be here...you are all copying me....you have skin....you disgust meh....
Bruh exactly what I was thing lol 💗💗
lola acalain lol
M4 Gamer 😉😉
This ^^^ is the best comment ever 😂 Thank you!
She's going to be pissed when she finds out Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin copied her husband.
LOLOLOL
That was some funny shit right there dude, hats off for that comment !
Damn🤣🤣🤣
Hahaha!!!!! XD
And the Beatles! 🤣🤣🤣
When you accuse someone of being a doppelgänger yet you are a rip off of Edna from the incredibles
Yes! Natalia and her husband should be ashamed of themselves. Their entitlement is so annoying, can't believe you guys were invited to the show. Good job Mel for the final word.
I absolutely thought I loved her until I saw this. She was flat out obnoxious and rude. He was simply wearing a suit and he got attacked like that. I agree he looked better than her husband. And what her husband said was ignorant.
I hear you. I was about to download one of her songs, but after seeing this, I don't want to download (not even illegally) or listen to anything she has to say or sing anymore!
PS; not that I download things illegally ever, I promise.
Never heard of her
Joel Caswell Lucky you ;)
So what if he is ,, what a big deal that should make her happy that people wants to dress like unknown loser
*plot twist* her husband copied him
Her husband copied england ppl
The contestant is so humble and calm .
And the couple is so rude ...
I am glad the other judge said good words.
Respect to the blonde woman at the end “ actually u dress better than her husband “ pure got me pissing myself laughing 🤣🤣
THE BLONDE WOMAN....QUEEN
That is All Saints singer Melanie 'Mel' Blatt
when he said "but don't you copy Cleopatra" that was such a burn
He looks like he was about to cry so sad the man has a beautiful voice and is also super handsome , That woman should be ashamed of her self
How could she do that?! Instead of marking his singing skills she laughed at him and shouted on him. Who is that stupid person that employed her?! She behaves very unwell. At least she paid for that physical violence (she got fired). #stophating
Dude this was staged
1:52 LOOK! THE HOST IS COPYING HER HUSBAND TOO
Olivia Knowles 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
Olivia Knowles HAHAHAHAH exactly
Lol
I know thats disgusting 😂
Olivia Knowles exactly so...a “suit” is her husband’s original style oh and hair gel....very rare indeed 🙄
she copied Willy Wonka's hairstyle.
The guy who makes fun of little mistakes she copied lord farquad from shrek
And cleopatra horrible style
retweet
Haha yas I was thinking that to
+MyLittleDash and they wondered why her second name is kills and his is moon two illegal things to do in public lol
That dude needed a hug. Though this happened years ago I'll still hug him if I see him now.
My respect to the contestant who was way more dignified than the stupid judges..
god and i thought simon cowell was a little too harsh :(
I actually like Simon idk why lol
but they're going to hell
Simons cool
No no Simon has great common sense of where to react n not. This lady n her fiancé have nothing in head. Simon is way better, his comments r sarcastic n funny.
Yeah i know i like him.
Now i understand her last name though.
+Hayns Hangout Nutella kills is copying dora and nutella
I like Natalia Kills for the fact that she doesn't need anyone to destroy her career, bitch did by herself
looooool
nice one .
I know right
What career
dam that comment tho XD
I like how In 1:58 a random guy just yells 'YOU SEXY!!'
Omg i'm dying😂😂
For somebody who claims 'the producers told me to say this', she went overboard and was completely delusional.
He took it like a champ though, I would have burst into tears.
Rico g I would be crying and at the same time giving that piece of shit a piece of my mind
I would have smirked so hard that I'll have to try to stop. And of course I'll insult back lol.
I would not be so polite. That bitch needed to be told.
And I would yell at the lady and make her shut her disgusting mouth
he actually did cry later on
It's funny how they both try to act like Simon haha
Simon has class, this couple is just trash.
+The Weeknd Simon Cowell does not have class, if that's what you mean; he's a bloody lunatic sometimes. He does at least complain for valid reasons though 😂
+The Weeknd OMG , it's Theweeknd
XO Till We Overdose .
Ndia Liphford
XOTWOD
Nah not at all like Simon, sure he can be mean sometimes but he often have good points.
Says a kindergarten level riposte "actually, Mel needs glasses" and slides back in her chair thinking she's the smartest person in the room.
I'm so happy the last judge defended him. The first two that spoke were clearly unprofessional.
Looks liked she KILLED her career
badumtssss... no? ok :,(
what career?
+david lmao
Yeah, what career? LOL
yah and know she is shit but I'm glad I don't like her she looks like trash and plus it's only gelled hair and a suit her freakin husband wasn't the first to wear that it's been worn by millions of men
He dealt with that really fucking well to be fair to the guy, I doubt I could've bit my tongue like he did
CC DeVille he did the best lmao
CC DeVille lol who hurted u
Sad thing is I don't think he bit his tongue. I think he was just heart broken, and didn't know what to say. Not everyone bites back when getting attacked, some people are just genuinely sweet people.
Scott Gallagher ya
CC DeVille you actually could not have done that but that would be amazing
Years later this still cracks me up. What a lunatic....apparently her husband has intellectual property rights over wearing a jacket and having short hair😂
I dont understand why nobody behind the scenes , step in and says ... thats Enough
I'm cringing at how Willy and Natalie are so self absorbed even though they are Z-Class celebrities
I've never heard of them. I won't remember their names in 3 mins either.
Yea never even heard of them until I saw them on the X factor
They were nobody and now they are nothing, lmfao.
When did willy moon copyright wearing a suit and combing your hair? Vile.
Exactly, I guess a man can't wear a suit to his wedding or prom without "copying" or "stealing" this irrelevant man's "style" and dare I say "artistic originality." Like dude don't kid yourself men had that style way before you were even born. And clearly this irrelevant woman defending her husband is to blind or stupid to realize that this is a singing competition and not a fashion show!
Chrissy Tee I know, right? He looks like just about every pop artist in America during the 1950's.
This was so sad you can see in the end that he was about to cry what the hell is wrong with that woman eww 🤬
How could judges do like that?! OMG..Shameful!
Who else doesn't even know who the husband was a singer😂
wie wait- he has a career other than working in X factor for money? Yes I know that she’s a singer bc I’ve seen a song but... He has a career too?
@@polysinoca3422 I dont know either Who tf are they
Is he famous?
I didn't even know who that woman is, much less her husband.
I didn't even know both of them are human beings
0:29 "But dont you follow cleopatra?" YASSS STAN!! TELL HER!!!
"But didnt you copy cleopatra?"***
No ..he just follow dora the explorer
Stan standing up for him is iconic, what a lovely man
She copied Dora better 😂
With all due respect since when a judge became a insecure and who the hell is her husband thinks he is also they don't deserve to be a judge to any show.
"Thank you Natalia, you're beautiful." is such a classy response, really shames her further.
Oh no he’s wearing a suit LIKE EVERY OTHER MAN ON EARTH 😑
No other people coping him.
bad.... very bad.....
If I was on stage i would say:
I didnt even know you have a husband.
"Actually Mel needs glasses" and leans back like that's the most brilliant comeback anyone has ever heard haha
Lmao Exactly! like stfu that so lame
I find it funny that Natalia said that the contestant looks like Willy and then Willy makes fun of his clothing, basically insulting himself. Like insulting a mirror.
I wonder if she watches back on this with absolute regret knowing that she created the ending of what could have been a fucking amazing career.
It makes me uncomfortable to watch her. Is she serious? How can she be serious? He is wearing a fucking suit!
Willie Moon was the first person to wear a suit.
You👏 will 👏never👏 be👏 Simon 👏Cowell👏
Kim Taeyeon is my everything so basically she's copying simon cowell doesn't he own the name nasty judge 🤣😂
I do not know if those judges are New Zealanders but if they are they deserve to get their citizenship revoked considering how polite and kind New zealanders are.
Basically verbal abuse not criticism
I love how Mel stood up for him and how he tried to stay as positive as he could even calling that Disgusting Mean cow “Beautiful” tbh I thought He looked WAY better than her husband😂💖
“Cow” coz that’s not sexist
Nice One Melanie good always a saint for him
@@reaux3921it’s not sexist. At all.
Kills: ".. I am disgusted at how much you've copied my husband ..."
Moon: ".. It's like Norman Bates dressing up in his mother's clothing "
Well, that says something..
I guess moon just insulted his own style lol
True dat.
lol XD
Will Gravis that Bates motel reference tho
Will Gravis OH MY GOD
"Actually your dress BETTER than her husband" oh my lord i love this line.
I just randomly remembered this and had to look it up omg crazy stuff