Andrew Neil - 'This is not a good time for Western leadership' | SpectatorTV

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 07. 2024
  • The second round of France’s election did not prove so successful for Marine Le Pen, whose party fell to third place with the leftist New Popular Front (NFP) emerging as the dominant force. Andrew Neil Chairman of the Spectator speaks to Freddy Gray about who the key characters on the left are, and why, despite losing in this round of elections, this could mean Marine Le Pen goes on to win the Presidential election in 2027.
    // SUBSCRIBE TO THE SPECTATOR
    Get 12 issues for £12, plus a free £20 John Lewis/Waitrose voucher
    www.spectator.co.uk/tvoffer
    // FREE PODCASTS FROM THE SPECTATOR
    Hear more from The Spectator's journalists on their podcasts, covering everything from the politics of the UK, US and China, to religion, literature, lifestyle and more.
    www.spectator.co.uk/podcasts/
    // FOLLOW US
    spectator
    OfficialSpectator
    www.linkedin.com/company/the-spectator
    spectator1828
    www.tiktok.com/@thespectatormagazine

Komentáře • 1,1K

  • @realitykicksin8755
    @realitykicksin8755 Před 12 dny +419

    Europe has a strong right wing undercurrent. Not just radical but also centered. Europe is sick of the immigration crimes.

    • @Likeaworm
      @Likeaworm Před 12 dny +40

      These polices that breed this undercut will keep being pursued. The establishment and left doesn’t realize that they are creating a monster.

    • @BraveInstance
      @BraveInstance Před 12 dny +36

      Toni Kross commented on mass immigration the other day. Auslander Raus is a popular song over there. Even the Germans with all their WW2 guilt are starting to have enough.

    • @gusgone4527
      @gusgone4527 Před 12 dny

      More right minded than "wing."
      Like London, Paris has been infested with immigrants and has many no-go-areas.

    • @debbiedion5731
      @debbiedion5731 Před 12 dny

      The eu demon bred this and happily took billions to do it😡

    • @unwokeneuropean3590
      @unwokeneuropean3590 Před 12 dny

      The modern left will create the ultimate darth vader right. If they don't take care of the conservatives sooner or later they will suffer by the real ultra right... With a tiny moustache leader at it again. When it happens, we could all blame the left.

  • @theringmaster886
    @theringmaster886 Před 12 dny +142

    Eastern Europe seems to be the only place standing up for "Western" values and people.

    • @ciaronsmith4995
      @ciaronsmith4995 Před 12 dny

      Serbia's biggest ally is Iran. Look it up.

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny +3

      Precisely. The West forgot what is a value of freedom.

    • @ciaronsmith4995
      @ciaronsmith4995 Před 12 dny +2

      Serbia's biggest ally.....is Iran.

    • @alen2773
      @alen2773 Před 11 dny

      eastern europe does not even hold western values

    • @user-zc2ve6bb6r
      @user-zc2ve6bb6r Před 10 dny

      @@ciaronsmith4995 Serbia is not Eastern Europe.

  • @michaelpeacock6360
    @michaelpeacock6360 Před 12 dny +387

    France- NR got 37% of vote...not enough for Government...UK-Labour got 33% of vote...landslide...
    Democracy - what is good for?

    • @nigelevans6873
      @nigelevans6873 Před 12 dny +22

      @@peterholden3672 do you seriously feel there’s no value to comparing different electoral systems? Presumably then comparing what we’ve got to what we’ve got is the way forward? Ingenious!

    • @Bailiol
      @Bailiol Před 12 dny +25

      @@peterholden3672 It's called comparative politics. It's one of the most common and well established traditions for studying politics.

    • @andrewkinghorn5786
      @andrewkinghorn5786 Před 12 dny +18

      Absolutely nothing. I'll say it again.

    • @gusgone4527
      @gusgone4527 Před 12 dny +14

      @@peterholden3672 Because they both claim to be democracies!!!

    • @proselytizingorthodoxpente8304
      @proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Před 12 dny +4

      @@gusgone4527 Thats because they both are

  • @LW-no9sm
    @LW-no9sm Před 11 dny +59

    In France and in England the problem is the Far Left.

  • @SuperHeadman1
    @SuperHeadman1 Před 12 dny +281

    Young people celebrating by setting fires and clashing with the police, they did the same last week when they lost the first round.

    • @pulsey2001
      @pulsey2001 Před 12 dny

      Israelites… They will learn the same lesson.

    • @Candolad
      @Candolad Před 12 dny +19

      Spoiled brats who can't accept losing.

    • @zviszwarc9185
      @zviszwarc9185 Před 12 dny +27

      @@pulsey2001, what Israel has to do with it?

    • @mrmanontherock
      @mrmanontherock Před 12 dny

      Did you see one video on CZcams?

    • @mrmanontherock
      @mrmanontherock Před 12 dny +1

      ​@@Candoladthey won

  • @Joao-id4dn
    @Joao-id4dn Před 12 dny +95

    the failure of the center parties in Europe to address the immigration problem will fuel both far left and far right political forces

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny +2

      They wanted to please everyone but it didn´t work. I blame their greed to get as many votes as possible. 😁

    • @_Stroda
      @_Stroda Před 12 dny

      Is it the right or the left that tends to have an issue with immigration?
      Clearly, it's the right.
      It's also the policies of 'the right' that have contributed most to declining birth rates in Europe. Policies in countries like the UK that have focused on older generations, that have pushed the costs down to younger generations.
      And aging populations are costly.
      So, what is it that the right wants? Massive increases in government spending to support younger citizens (with regards to housing, education, the 'cost of living', etc.), to make parenting children more affordable, or.... High levels of immigration?
      Because the reality is that many countries in Europe, if they wish to remain in any way prosperous, need one of the above.
      People on the right need to either get over what is, in many cases, blatant xenophobia/racism, or accept that policies most would deem 'left wing' are necessary.
      They won't, though, will they? Because most right wing voters aren't all that well off, but they've bought into the lies and propaganda of actual elites (elites whose wealth and power is far beyond the 'elites' that the right often demonize, i.e. hard working professional types), and so they vote against their own interests. They vote against the interests of their countries.

    • @inamoratog
      @inamoratog Před 11 dny

      ​@@_Stroda "many countries in Europe, if they wish to remain in any way prosperous, need one of the above."
      No, they don't. They need to destroy the managerial class that actually runs the country, that hides corruption behind a bloated welfare state. The same people who are importing millions more dependents for that welfare state every year so they can line their own pockets.
      Or I guess we could try importing even more people. Yes, mass movement of foreign peoples has resulted in genocide every other time we tried it, but let's give it another go! What's another continent reduced to poverty and another hundred million corpses in the face of 'progress', after all?

    • @willx9352
      @willx9352 Před 11 dny +1

      ​@@_StrodaThere is a difference between legal, controlled immigration and illegal immigration.

    • @jenniferlawrence2701
      @jenniferlawrence2701 Před 11 dny

      @@_Stroda Left-Wing policies are even worse for birth rates. See the rapid decline of birthrates in the USSR and Eastern Bloc countries. Immigration from outside the EU is an economic negative. Your argument is based on a series of incorrect premises.

  • @steecofarn
    @steecofarn Před 12 dny +251

    Radical left, you mean extreme far left surely?

    • @upthebracket26
      @upthebracket26 Před 12 dny +15

      whats extreme about wanting to put workers & eldery people before rich people & russia?

    • @Gericho572
      @Gericho572 Před 12 dny +14

      @@upthebracket26 Then do it civilised.

    • @orlandomontfort5101
      @orlandomontfort5101 Před 12 dny

      @@upthebracket26 Are you that naive or just stupid?

    • @wiseonwords
      @wiseonwords Před 12 dny +24

      @@upthebracket26 - That's what they claim to care about. I see you believe their propaganda.

    • @NorskInjustis
      @NorskInjustis Před 12 dny +1

      He quoted Peter Sellers, so clearly we live in the 1960s, lol

  • @sn4831
    @sn4831 Před 12 dny +178

    "It's time to punish the unvaccinated." - Andrew Neil.
    The true fascist

    • @ianmedford4855
      @ianmedford4855 Před 12 dny

      @@sn4831 100%. Pepperidge Farms remembers.
      This guy is a total scumbag.

    • @glynreed1
      @glynreed1 Před 12 dny +28

      Our new PM said the same and offered to work with the Tories to draw up enforcement legislation.

    • @gerhard7323
      @gerhard7323 Před 12 dny +12

      Great recent Short showing Starmer being shown the pub door in Bath for this very reason.
      Utter humiliation.

    • @jcal258
      @jcal258 Před 12 dny

      Andrew Neil is a boob

    • @Thermopylae2007
      @Thermopylae2007 Před 12 dny +7

      If that's who you've got calling themselves conservative, that is really sad.

  • @michaelpower7326
    @michaelpower7326 Před 12 dny +125

    Far Left (Communism)

    • @noodleppoodle
      @noodleppoodle Před 12 dny +3

      Do you know what communism even means??? Actually a bit of communism would not be bad right now when most of the assets are in the hands of a tiny few and untaxed

    • @dorseyjack3206
      @dorseyjack3206 Před 12 dny +6

      @@noodleppoodle
      Do you need the air fair to N Korea?
      Get a job and buy one

    • @campbell4show
      @campbell4show Před 12 dny +3

      Marxist Communism*

    • @LordFunzo
      @LordFunzo Před 12 dny

      @@noodleppoodle communal ownership? Who owns something when nobody does? Those with the authority to distribute assets own everything. 'Democratically elected' I hear you cry, maybe I wont distribute food to you unless you vote for me. 'Unjust' you say? 'Treason' I say, off to the goulag with you.

    • @snakeplissken7671
      @snakeplissken7671 Před 12 dny

      @@noodleppoodle Under communism, all assets are in the hands of a tiny few and they are untaxed. The government owns everything and pays no taxes. The people own nothing.
      It seems you are the one who does not understand what communism is. You need LESS communism to fix the problem you are talking about.
      The actual problem with western economies is that leftists have discovered you can print money to steal money from the people covertly through money printing (inflation). They then redistribute this money to their cronies and donors, which then gets funneled back to them to fuel their campaigns or pay insane salaries for nebulous "think tank" or board jobs which are just titles. A portion of that printed money is doled out to greedy voters who have their votes for sale to whomever gives them the most goodies; the whole time not knowing they are being paid with their own money.
      So it's a rampant theft/embezzlement/bribery scheme by people who are mostly leftists and commies. That's why you don't own anything and rich people own everything. It has nothing to do with a "failure of capitalism", it has to do with commies getting political power then looting everyone blind and seizing control of all of the assets. . .then they use that stolen asset power to assert their dominance even further for corporate communism/feudalism. A system we're all suffering under now.
      So yeah, your problem is that we have too much communism. Poisoning ourselves even further is not going to make the poison go away.

  • @nickgood8166
    @nickgood8166 Před 12 dny +25

    Emily Matlis isn't a journalist, she's an activist.

    • @Bungadin2845
      @Bungadin2845 Před 12 dny +1

      Yes…….but she did do a great interview with Prince Andrew

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny +5

      @@Bungadin2845 And even better in a famous interview with the Hungarian foreign minister Péter Szijjártó. She just fumed with rage pushing her multiculti point of view. 😂

    • @georgethompson453
      @georgethompson453 Před 11 dny +3

      A rather stupid one too!

  • @Magicspark2366
    @Magicspark2366 Před 12 dny +95

    I seriously think Europe is gong to hell in a hand basket. Any attempt to backtrack on the Brexit vote despite the smokescreen of `we want to re negotiate` will undoubtedly create chaos in the UK...our major cities are a tinderbox and sparks will fly!

    • @abvmoose87
      @abvmoose87 Před 12 dny

      Thats what female voting rights get you

    • @j.umh1687
      @j.umh1687 Před 12 dny

      Why would negotiating cause chaos?

    • @Madoldcatlady
      @Madoldcatlady Před 12 dny +12

      @@j.umh1687 why negotiate? That’s not what the referendum was for and that’s not what the majority voted for. So to renegotiate rejoining, is a stab in the back, not to mention insanity, particularly considering the election results in France just now and the sorry state of Germany, both the two main EU countries, yet their economies tanking. You really think it’s a good idea to climb back onboard a sinking ship?

    • @joce11
      @joce11 Před 12 dny

      ​@@MadoldcatladyAgree but I've no doubt New Labour will try its hardest to get onboard the sinking ship to save globalisation. The EU doesn't exist for its people. It exists for globalists.

    • @nickgood8166
      @nickgood8166 Před 12 dny

      Delete the first 3 words!

  • @Madoldcatlady
    @Madoldcatlady Před 12 dny +108

    I live in France and it’s been astonishing to hear the ridiculous fear-mongering coming from young socialists. They actually believed music concerts would be prohibited. Art too. We’d have pogroms and the like. One of my daughters acquaintances, is the child of a pair of teachers, one for history, the other English, and the things he’s been claiming should LePen win are the most far-fetched, conspiratorial bunkum I’ve ever heard. I can only imagine his parents have helped him come to these conclusions about RN, which also makes me wonder just how much of their own factually incorrect opinions overflow into their classes.
    Also, when the voting prospectus was posted, the quantity of candidates in left-wing parties, that were teachers or held positions in teaching faculties, was tremendous. Subtle and not so subtle left-wing brainwashing goes on all the time in schools.

    • @MrBannystar
      @MrBannystar Před 12 dny +18

      A lot of leftists come out with the same stupid hyperbole for a lot of things. It's always societally more acceptable to be an ignorant lefty than an informed righty.

    • @drlobomalo
      @drlobomalo Před 12 dny +11

      It's amazing (?) how exactly the same phenomenon is occurring in the US with respect to Trump.

    • @dogwklr
      @dogwklr Před 12 dny

      21st century teachers are a poison to human advancement

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 11 dny

      We know that wealthy African students attended Western Universities, soaked with marxism, they came back home to Africa, made a revolution and killed half of their own nation.

    • @sheridanpayne5347
      @sheridanpayne5347 Před 11 dny

      Yes, and the same scare-mongering is happening in America. Biden's crooked and corrupt administration is more evil than Al Capone, and yet they have the brass neck to say that, if Trump won, he would destroy democracy! Really, they are deranged!!

  • @andrewhotston983
    @andrewhotston983 Před 12 dny +232

    Mélenchon is FAR LEFT. Have the courage to say so, Mr Neill.

    • @philipbrackpool-bk1bm
      @philipbrackpool-bk1bm Před 12 dny +24

      Apparently he makes Corbyn look like a Thatcherite.

    • @springwood1331
      @springwood1331 Před 12 dny +8

      Quite so

    • @simonmc7875
      @simonmc7875 Před 12 dny

      @@andrewhotston983 Hard Far Left... their manifesto is unbelievable. They are mental, if you read what they want to enact.

    • @chrisohanlon69
      @chrisohanlon69 Před 12 dny +18

      He did say that.

    • @pepegalego
      @pepegalego Před 12 dny

      Far left doesn't exist...didn't you know? There is only far-right, right, centre, left and more left...Keep up.
      Oh, and remember the left is everything you believe in, everybody else is far right.

  • @williammunny4679
    @williammunny4679 Před 12 dny +51

    Stop referring to the RN as ‘far right’

    • @jake751
      @jake751 Před 12 dny +2

      OK. Faciasts

    • @Madoldcatlady
      @Madoldcatlady Před 12 dny +11

      @@jake751 ooh… that was clever of you! Wow! I wonder how you came up with that retort. 🙄

    • @tonywilliams7152
      @tonywilliams7152 Před 12 dny

      It's their job

    • @tomjc147
      @tomjc147 Před 11 dny

      @@jake751 ??? Google translate doesn’t work on this.

    • @afterlate8866
      @afterlate8866 Před 11 dny

      Le Pen’s economic policies - if you care to check - are actually Socialist.

  • @simonaveline5542
    @simonaveline5542 Před 12 dny +55

    As if making the rich very rich and the rest of the people poor! whilst importing cheap labour so there children can't find a home or raise a family would have a backlash...

    • @januarysson5633
      @januarysson5633 Před 12 dny +5

      Politicians never think of consequences past the next election.

  • @ReaLityBlue
    @ReaLityBlue Před 11 dny +17

    Western leadership is gone. People tired of endless wars triggering migration.

    • @tombergins8215
      @tombergins8215 Před 7 dny

      The West , USA in particular reminds me of the USSR (Soviet Union) 8 years before the collapse of Communism & the USSR itself.
      Senile Biden being American Leonid Brezhnev for starters.

  • @Stoddardian
    @Stoddardian Před 12 dny +193

    RN literally got 3 million votes more than NFP.

    • @unrealharry
      @unrealharry Před 12 dny +9

      Every country needs PR - it’s simple and fair.

    • @mralireza931
      @mralireza931 Před 12 dny +6

      So what? Do you even know how parliamentary elections work?

    • @John.Doe.272
      @John.Doe.272 Před 12 dny

      And now the far left will run the country into the ground, and eventually the "right" will be voted in to fix the problem.

    • @kanglongshankz3313
      @kanglongshankz3313 Před 12 dny

      @@mralireza931 I imagine they are implying the electoral system is flawed and not accurately representative of voters.

    • @teriekwilliams2828
      @teriekwilliams2828 Před 12 dny +7

      @@unrealharry if elections that cannot produce clear outright majorities and can only form governments via backroom deals is your form of simple and fair go at it. PR in the UK will simply make 2010 to 2024 permanent. But again go at it.

  • @anonnemo2504
    @anonnemo2504 Před 12 dny +68

    The likes of Maitlis and Campbell welcoming this result in France reveals them for the intellectual lightweights that they are, and that goes for much of the rest of the "chattering classes" in the UK too.

    • @proselytizingorthodoxpente8304
      @proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Před 12 dny +9

      Despite their love of all things EU, they clearly have no interest in their politics

    • @gerhard7323
      @gerhard7323 Před 12 dny

      I'm amazed that these two have ANY credibility left at all.
      On the plus side, at least Maitlis doesn't have the blood of hundreds of thousands of dead Iraqis on her hands.
      I would say 'conscience', but Campbell obviously hasn't got one.

    • @gerhard7323
      @gerhard7323 Před 11 dny

      @mikesmith1485 Glad your similar comment to mine got through. Mine didn't.

  • @brigitpimm8488
    @brigitpimm8488 Před 12 dny +79

    So radical left not far left. I see.

    • @januarysson5633
      @januarysson5633 Před 12 dny +1

      What’s the difference?

    • @richardenders6606
      @richardenders6606 Před 12 dny +1

      @brigitpimm8488 - hard radical populist far left, try to keep up

    • @brigitpimm8488
      @brigitpimm8488 Před 12 dny +2

      @@januarysson5633 well it's always far right never radical right. Right?

    • @januarysson5633
      @januarysson5633 Před 12 dny

      @@brigitpimm8488 Is it? Umm…Okay.

    • @PoliticalBetting-x6c
      @PoliticalBetting-x6c Před 12 dny

      @@richardenders6606 You are silly because you don't understand the words I made up...

  • @alie.m.1474
    @alie.m.1474 Před 12 dny +30

    Could someone explain to me how blindly following US foreign policy, which Andrew Neil sees as problematic, has benefited the UK recently? The US pushed for NATO expansion to Ukraine from 2008, Merkel and Sarkozy warned against this as they knew how Russia would react, but US interests reigned supreme. Does Andrew think all the immigrants from Middle East fleeing US wars are beneficial? Hardly any end up in US compared to EU/UK for obvious geographical reasons. Germany committed economic suicide when it stopped purchasing cheap Russian gas, the AFD are as against this war as much as they are immigration. EU put tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles the day after the US. These cars go further than Tesla’s, are great build and are cheaper…And the list goes on.
    Post WWII the idea was EU foreign policy would be aligned with US interests in exchange for US military defence, preventing both extra-European actors and intra-European conflict. Has this really been necessary? I don’t recall needing US troops during the Falklands..instead here we are today as US empire vows to stay hegemonic following blindly a nation who is going to be led by a clearly mentally-incapable octogenarian or Trump who I actually think overall is the better candidate. Perhaps we should reopen the books and see how the world wars started and ask if we
    Really want to join the US in provoking the Russian bear into Nuclear Armageddon….

    • @nellymoo635
      @nellymoo635 Před 11 dny +1

      Quality of Chinese ev is questionable.

    • @user-vu1xn9by6e
      @user-vu1xn9by6e Před 11 dny +1

      Fully agree, but does our insane world agree?

    • @christophernunn943
      @christophernunn943 Před 11 dny

      @@nellymoo635 Totally agree. It's on record their lower standards like everything else they make are well know for cars spontaneously combusting. Most of the Chinese industrial output is sub standard and cheap and the West is hooked on their junk. This has made China incredibly rich and powerful, ironically they are our enemies not our friends.

  • @jcal258
    @jcal258 Před 12 dny +52

    “It’s time to punish Britains 5 million vaccine refuseniks.” - Andrew Neil

    • @nmpolo
      @nmpolo Před 12 dny +3

      When did he say this? As in was that a recent thing or back during the lockdowns etc?

    • @marshallh9
      @marshallh9 Před 12 dny +1

      @@jcal258 The flabby jabber 😂😂

    • @brendancorrigan
      @brendancorrigan Před 12 dny

      ​@@nmpoloYes, I wasn't aware of this. If it's true, I can't respect the man at all,
      czcams.com/video/rJSFd2SPe9I/video.htmlsi=1oHxFEubnsIhPmvt

    • @Lord_Saruman
      @Lord_Saruman Před 11 dny

      Jabba the Jab w/o Leia lol

    • @user-vu1xn9by6e
      @user-vu1xn9by6e Před 11 dny

      Andrew Neil the Boomersaurus Rex

  • @Tsukonin
    @Tsukonin Před 12 dny +14

    The National Rally is not "far-right", it's a fairly centrist or even leftist party compared to the more economically liberal anglosphere countries. It's not too different from Jacques Chirac's line pre-1980s.

  • @Alert64
    @Alert64 Před 12 dny +24

    It was a stitch up between the far left and macrons party and the result defied democratic principles

  • @gerhard7323
    @gerhard7323 Před 12 dny +18

    Macron is about to embody the phrase, 'be careful what you wish for'.

  • @iaindennis3321
    @iaindennis3321 Před 12 dny +12

    1 in 7 people in the UK voted Reform and they got 5 MP’s out of 650 - Democracy?

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny +2

      Exactly. The Labour party got 1 seat by 30 thousand votes while Reform needed 800 thousand for 1 seat.

    • @nellymoo635
      @nellymoo635 Před 11 dny

      @@marysmik9812 🙃

    • @rodthewelder3360
      @rodthewelder3360 Před 7 dny

      As a reform voter I totally agree with you but proportional representation rarely works to get a mojority Goverment. Then you get a hung Parliament.

  • @IMAC1776
    @IMAC1776 Před 12 dny +15

    The NR are significantly more popular in France than Starmer’s Labour Party is in Britain.

  • @DavidRobinson-rj2sp
    @DavidRobinson-rj2sp Před 12 dny +21

    FRANCE HAS FALLEN.

  • @templarmalta9946
    @templarmalta9946 Před 12 dny +30

    Sharia and the religious right of islam will sort out the French left. It's only a matter of time.

    • @Solidude4
      @Solidude4 Před 12 dny

      @@templarmalta9946 Nope. Muslims still tend to vote left wing because the racism of the right is just worse.

    • @ciaronsmith4995
      @ciaronsmith4995 Před 12 dny

      Not really. Iranians in particular are awesome.

    • @bronwenewens1198
      @bronwenewens1198 Před 12 dny

      They are. Those in the West are foes of Islamism

  • @gerhard7323
    @gerhard7323 Před 12 dny +16

    Le Pen probably dodged a bullet here, but maybe doesn't quite yet feel she has in the moment.

  • @ciaronsmith4995
    @ciaronsmith4995 Před 12 dny +7

    Just a fun fact.
    The logo on his shirt is of someone playing "Polo".
    That game was invented in Iran, by the Persians.
    Cheers!

  • @janpetersen7440
    @janpetersen7440 Před 12 dny +31

    France is in a little more chaos today than yesterday - nothing new in that.

    • @randybackgammon890
      @randybackgammon890 Před 12 dny +5

      French 'chaos' has worked pretty well for the common man in my expierence

    • @PopularesVox
      @PopularesVox Před 12 dny

      Not really, it's the end of Macron's reforms to restructure the French economy by instigating cut backs in public expenditure. The French public finance is essentially controlled by the EU and any row back now will place severe strains on the EU budget which is already feeling the effects from a faltering German economy. By facilitating greater influence by the extreme Left within government, the effect will not only harm the French economy which is looking very weak, it will have serious repercussions throughout the European Union. If you think things are bad now, they are about to get a whole lot worse.

  • @BrandyHeng007
    @BrandyHeng007 Před 12 dny +51

    A nation can only be ruled by Fools if the Fools voted in the Fools.
    🤡

    • @richardenders6606
      @richardenders6606 Před 12 dny +1

      @BrandyHeng007 - do people who wished to vote for le Pen last week and then changed their minds because some of the opposition withdrew meet your definition of Fools?

    • @KJ-db7pt
      @KJ-db7pt Před 12 dny +1

      Absolutely correct stated relating to fools

    • @aclark903
      @aclark903 Před 12 dny

      @@richardenders6606 Fools say there is no God. That’s the Bible definition. And that is the problem with Europe- secularism. It’s inadequate to face Islam because the secular left continually underestimate the power of religion.

    • @g3523jaen
      @g3523jaen Před 12 dny +5

      We are winning. We need more time. Le Pen RN party and allies got in 2022 16% and in 2024 37%. It takes time. We will win.

    • @koala6016
      @koala6016 Před 12 dny +1

      Ah yes, democracy is so annoying when you don't like the result.

  • @juliancoulden1753
    @juliancoulden1753 Před 12 dny +20

    The uk……,was ahead of the curve when we voted for Brexit

  • @jacktanner7738
    @jacktanner7738 Před 11 dny +4

    France rushing headlong into oblivion. You can't blame LePen; she tried.

  • @shelleyscloud3651
    @shelleyscloud3651 Před 12 dny +22

    The only sensible & informed comment on Sunday’s results I’ve heard yet.

    • @sye601
      @sye601 Před 12 dny

      The problem with AN is that he talks a good game....then gets proven to be on the wrong side of reality.

    • @richardenders6606
      @richardenders6606 Před 11 dny

      @@sye601 - agreed, strange isn't it?
      His boosting the proposed opening of GBNEWS for months and then flouncing off as soon as it actually did open never did make sense

  • @maxnewson5704
    @maxnewson5704 Před 12 dny +8

    Thank the gods for Andrew Neil's historical knowledge of France. Compare and contrast with almost every other UK commentator's profound ignorance on the subject.

  • @dannycbe949
    @dannycbe949 Před 12 dny +6

    "Western leadership"...? Any actual examples of such a person?

  • @peterjmcc1953
    @peterjmcc1953 Před 12 dny +10

    This is a very wise overview by someone who really understands the situation. This is indeed a very difficult time for the Western nations. They are being shaken.

  • @davidcole8268
    @davidcole8268 Před 12 dny +65

    Poor Andrew Neil - if they slap a wealth tax on him he’ll have to leave France and return to the UK😢!

    • @user-iz9co4qf6z
      @user-iz9co4qf6z Před 12 dny +14

      And you think Labour aren't thinking about a wealth tax?...

    • @DonBean-ej4ou
      @DonBean-ej4ou Před 12 dny +5

      He might lose some weight.

    • @Beach_comber
      @Beach_comber Před 12 dny +8

      He could move to Belgium. That's what loads of rich French did when the French government introduced a punitive 75% top rate of tax in 2014.

    • @Diamondmine212
      @Diamondmine212 Před 12 dny

      No chance SIR Keir and cronies will slab a super tax on folk. AFTER of course the left have made sure their fortunes are safely tucked up in off shore accounts. 👍👍👍👍

    • @stephenwood2172
      @stephenwood2172 Před 12 dny

      ​@@user-iz9co4qf6zStarmer is bought and paid for by billionaires. Wouldnt worry about that!

  • @19squidgy75
    @19squidgy75 Před 12 dny +46

    The French, always arguing with themselves , nothing has changed.

    • @Isclachau
      @Isclachau Před 12 dny +5

      Yes but this time it’s bad. Very bad

    • @19squidgy75
      @19squidgy75 Před 12 dny +2

      @@Isclachau Too many chiefs, not enough Indians, they will sought it out. Maybe if they concentrate more on France 🇫🇷 as opposed to foreign adventures, that could be a good start. End complicity in unnecessary foreign wars, at the behest of the USA 🇺🇸 make peace with former colonies, just be more French in France 🇫🇷

    • @Isclachau
      @Isclachau Před 12 dny +1

      @@19squidgy75 Well I agree but as Mr Neil says that time is not going to be now. Like him I fear for France for the first time in my life and I suspect Le Pen may be sitting pretty in the coming years.

    • @jean-pascalheynemand3271
      @jean-pascalheynemand3271 Před 12 dny

      They worship status quo.

    • @19squidgy75
      @19squidgy75 Před 12 dny

      @@Isclachau She will eventually become the leader, I don’t think that she will be as bad as the corporate media portray her to be. The incumbents will do and say anything to maintain their power, even if it is to create short term havoc. Once they taste the elixir of the public purse 👛 they find it hard to give up. A good government is one that is stable, and firming lose coalitions to prevent true democratic processes from occurring, is polar opposite to democracy. At the end of the day, if Le Pen makes a mistake, you vote her out.

  • @Kiwiboy1929
    @Kiwiboy1929 Před 12 dny +14

    And Starmer wants to bring us back into the EU

  • @cnrspiller3549
    @cnrspiller3549 Před 12 dny +7

    We had better prepare ourselves for thousands of asylum seekers fleeing France... oh, wait.

  • @isabelledetaillefer2726
    @isabelledetaillefer2726 Před 12 dny +10

    The Olympics will be a mess.

  • @davetalbot8256
    @davetalbot8256 Před 12 dny +4

    We don't get this with the BBC, ITV, SKY etc

  • @shelleyscloud3651
    @shelleyscloud3651 Před 12 dny +14

    Sow the wind, reap the whirlwind…..

  • @ronharris7335
    @ronharris7335 Před 12 dny +11

    Why do you call those that are not socialist far right

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny +5

      Because the EU is far left so everything else is on the right with this curved left optics.

  • @Dabhach1
    @Dabhach1 Před 12 dny +8

    Am I the only one who thinks Andrew has had a pleasant lunch?

  • @oscarvi3232
    @oscarvi3232 Před 12 dny +4

    Don't have a lot of time for Andrew Neil, but I think he is on the money for this event. Freddie Grey, as ever, proves himself to be a consummate interviewer.

  • @alphabetaxenonzzzcat
    @alphabetaxenonzzzcat Před 12 dny +3

    Don't worry Andrew - you won't get kicked out of France.

  • @donaldthomson9411
    @donaldthomson9411 Před 12 dny +5

    I always enjoy listening to Mr Neil’s analysis and feel incredibly knowledgable and wise afterwards.

  • @nathanielgordon5659
    @nathanielgordon5659 Před 12 dny +11

    France has been going south for a decade

    • @atkinsjoe5754
      @atkinsjoe5754 Před 12 dny +3

      @@nathanielgordon5659
      Since Mitterrand in the 1980s

    • @foppo101
      @foppo101 Před 12 dny

      France won't allow Fascist to take over.

  • @harryhill-es5jk
    @harryhill-es5jk Před 12 dny +7

    Labour are going to do the same with nigel and the reform party labour wont stop the boat or mass illegal immigration and that what happpen in france

  • @joewalsh4685
    @joewalsh4685 Před 12 dny +7

    French politics is like an ice hockey game, fighting more than playing.

  • @MattieGorman
    @MattieGorman Před 12 dny +4

    Andrew Neil says this could be the end of the EU within a year or two? I have to say I was gutted when marine le pens national rally was clearly stitched up yesterday! But this analysis from Andrew neil has cheered me up no end👏

  • @tonywilliams7152
    @tonywilliams7152 Před 12 dny +2

    Europe will look very very different by the end of this century. One way or another.

  • @SworBeyE16
    @SworBeyE16 Před 11 dny +2

    Alastair Campbell celebrating the apparent victory of French eurocommunism shouldn't come as a surprise whatsoever

  • @glenncrookes9775
    @glenncrookes9775 Před 12 dny +4

    The Right Is Rising 🇬🇧🗽🇫🇷

  • @alancooper9632
    @alancooper9632 Před 12 dny +4

    What a fascinating interview on French politics . I can't believe I've listened to it being an Englishman, absolutely top hole.

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny +1

      My favourite commentator is Gavin Mortimer of The Spectator who lives in France. This morning he spoke with Mike Graham on TalkTV.

  • @xxczerxx
    @xxczerxx Před 12 dny +2

    I hate to say it but it feels like the ship has sailed to bring back any sense of the nation state or conservatism in any real sense in Europe.
    The current trajectory is going to further widen the wealth gap, kill all sense of culture and national pride in these nations, and further create festering tension between increasingly disparate communities.
    All the while, more people shift further right in desparation...my question is why did it have to come to this? Why could we never have reasonable discussions about this over the last decade?

  • @daviddorward7684
    @daviddorward7684 Před 12 dny +2

    Very clear and informed discussion. I particularly liked, as a historically minded Canadian, the references to the 4th. Republic and the disastrous governments/decisions which gave France and the world The Battle of Algiers and Dien Bien Phu.

  • @stephaniesurface8761
    @stephaniesurface8761 Před 12 dny +7

    Thanks Andrew Neil for an excellent comment. Wonder if you are going to move to Tuscany soon. Seems Italy with Meloni is the only stable place in Europe for the next few years. Germany also will have a rocky road in front of it next year…

    • @davidcole8268
      @davidcole8268 Před 12 dny +2

      @@stephaniesurface8761 Meloni a class act. The only western European leader with balls.

  • @wayneyd2
    @wayneyd2 Před 12 dny +4

    Biden have brought that same craps here in the United States also.

  • @Candolad
    @Candolad Před 12 dny +5

    At 21:15 Andrew Neil daid that to change the Constitution France would "need someone with authority". The only person who fits that description in my opinion is Marine Le Pen.

  • @williamtyndale1402
    @williamtyndale1402 Před 12 dny +3

    Andrew please circle back and debate your belief on the rights of"refusenicks"

  • @presterjohn4123
    @presterjohn4123 Před 12 dny +6

    I wonder if Freddy does Dudley Moore impressions

  • @justinf1343
    @justinf1343 Před 12 dny +4

    Please stop using 'far right'.

  • @user-ru4ks1rb6s
    @user-ru4ks1rb6s Před 11 dny +2

    Capital is already fleeing France. Voters do not understand the consequences of their choice. That is the sad thing.

  • @zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz161
    @zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz161 Před 12 dny +4

    Cheers to you sir, your knowledge of french politics is impressive 👍
    Macron has been more destructive to France than all the former presidents of the Fifth French Republic combined. France is on a very bad course...

    • @marysmik9812
      @marysmik9812 Před 12 dny

      Globalists like Macron don´t bother France because they feel as the world leaders.

  • @DeeClarke-lg1hp
    @DeeClarke-lg1hp Před 12 dny +9

    Loving the 2005 Ashes print.

    • @Steve-xl1en
      @Steve-xl1en Před 10 dny +1

      lol that was the first thing that got my attention

  • @Polemicist0
    @Polemicist0 Před 12 dny +4

    Well, what a truly amazing surprise that the staunch Conservative Party supporting journalist / broadcaster, Mr Andrew Neil, said it was a "good thing" that the leader of Marine Le Pen's National Rally Party was unable to actually form a French coalition government.

  • @chris.fyourman2648
    @chris.fyourman2648 Před 12 dny +2

    Andrew Neil knows his onions. Other journalists should take note

  • @larrydugan1441
    @larrydugan1441 Před 12 dny +2

    "How can you govern a country which has two hundred and forty-six varieties of cheese"…?

  • @snorry84
    @snorry84 Před 11 dny +3

    Apart from the tripe pro-EU propaganda, this was an interesting interview.

  • @phyllisbiram5163
    @phyllisbiram5163 Před 12 dny +2

    A simply wonderful analysis from Neil, as politically astute as ever.

  • @S41GON
    @S41GON Před 12 dny +2

    Globalist bros, I don't feel so good...

  • @colingourley1222
    @colingourley1222 Před 11 dny +1

    I am an admirer of Andrew Neil. I have no idea why his This Week programme was axed by the BBC late on Thursday night. His insight is illuminating.

  • @gameram6382
    @gameram6382 Před 12 dny +13

    This will be the uk in 3 years.

  • @Jules-Is-a-Guy
    @Jules-Is-a-Guy Před 12 dny +3

    Outstanding discussion, thanks very much.

  • @johnkingston1337
    @johnkingston1337 Před 12 dny +2

    Guess we’ll see how long this far left coalition will last and whether the lack of a functioning government won’t just breed greater support for Le Pen in the upcoming presidential elections..

  • @AbcDino843
    @AbcDino843 Před 12 dny +2

    This is all too delightful to watch, including the Labour's "landslide" in Britain. Europe is decomposing itself.

  • @Stoddardian
    @Stoddardian Před 12 dny +28

    The French right needs to start thinking about going full revolutionary.

    • @Oxnaforda
      @Oxnaforda Před 12 dny

      Well unlike the revolution of 18th century the majority of the people dont support the " revolutionaries" they are a minority and will remain so, as the fascists for the most part always have been. They cant win democratically

    • @dpstrial
      @dpstrial Před 12 dny +3

      As in the UK and maybe the USA, it's gone beyond the ballet box.

    • @stephenwood2172
      @stephenwood2172 Před 12 dny +4

      You realise this can only mean Nazism?!

    • @willmcgeady4618
      @willmcgeady4618 Před 12 dny +4

      No, that is simply fascism. Do u even hear urself??

    • @Stoddardian
      @Stoddardian Před 12 dny +1

      @@stephenwood2172 Yes, and?

  • @bazrax7932
    @bazrax7932 Před 12 dny +3

    Watch The Day of the Jackal. A great film about the time Andrew is talking about the De Gaulle. It still holds up to this day.

  • @DonPedroTheDude
    @DonPedroTheDude Před 12 dny +2

    Arguably, the likely two years chaos could be worse than simply having cohabitation between RN and Macron.

  • @stevev238
    @stevev238 Před 8 dny

    Andrew's breadth and depth of knowledge in political history is second to none, and results in more depth of analysis than we find elsewhere. Arguably the best British editor in my lifetime.

  • @Nnomadd
    @Nnomadd Před 12 dny +4

    I guess chaos is a low threshold for reporters

  • @lastshelter5550
    @lastshelter5550 Před 12 dny +13

    Can we really call France a democracy? Or even Britain? We both have millions of people not represented in their leadership

    • @WallaseyanTube
      @WallaseyanTube Před 12 dny +1

      In the UK all the constituents are represented by their MP.

    • @thegoodpimps
      @thegoodpimps Před 12 dny

      You can’t be so toxic in a democracy that people vote against you. If there’s and in group and an out group the election ends up lost because the more votes you get the more votes the opponent gets.

  • @HMASJervisBay
    @HMASJervisBay Před 11 dny +1

    Why do they have trees along the Champs-Élysées? So the Germans can march in the shade.

  • @michaelgilday
    @michaelgilday Před 12 dny +38

    Andrew Neil "If France goes south so does Europe." let's hope that happens then.

    • @gusgone4527
      @gusgone4527 Před 12 dny +10

      @@peterholden3672 Sadly, before things get better they must get worse.

    • @ianmedford4855
      @ianmedford4855 Před 12 dny

      Andrew Neil has fully participated in the destruction of western society. He's been on board with all of it, from the Trump bad, to "safe and effective", to Ukrainian flags, to disarming western populations, and all the rest. This dude is a clown.

    • @mikepost8965
      @mikepost8965 Před 12 dny

      Holden3672 still brits wishing harm on nations in the EU.

    • @simony2801
      @simony2801 Před 12 dny +4

      @@gusgone4527 that makes no sense, a strong and stable eu is Europe’s future.

    • @mrbaker7443
      @mrbaker7443 Před 12 dny

      @@peterholden3672If the continental neighbours literally went south the English Channel would be too wide for the refugee dinghies…
      😂
      Bit you have a serious point.

  • @ChrisVaughan-gj7ve
    @ChrisVaughan-gj7ve Před 12 dny +3

    Always heartbreaking when the French get themselves in a right old pickle

  • @edwinlemus8530
    @edwinlemus8530 Před 12 dny +1

    "No able to government" the pain of democracy. Live with it.

  • @jonathanayres6005
    @jonathanayres6005 Před 12 dny +2

    Was 1999 peak strength of the West? Russia was dissolved as a power, China was not the industrial powerhouse, work force age was on average younger, the state was less authoritarian, mass migration was still relatively low and there was minimal threat of Islamic terrorism in the West.

  • @hugedongster
    @hugedongster Před 12 dny +6

    I want to buy the same shirt as Andrew, but I'm struggling to make out the logo. Can anyone help me identify it, please?

    • @Dude0000
      @Dude0000 Před 12 dny +3

      Yeah, I like the subtlety of it, too.

    • @paulross225
      @paulross225 Před 12 dny +2

      I think it's a Fred Perry shirt.

    • @hugedongster
      @hugedongster Před 12 dny +1

      @paulross225 thanks a million been searching all over

    • @dcukprof
      @dcukprof Před 12 dny

      Polo. Ralph Lauren usually just a small picture

    • @paulross225
      @paulross225 Před 12 dny +1

      @dcukprof Only girls wear Ralph Lauren!
      Just sayin!

  • @derekspitz9225
    @derekspitz9225 Před 12 dny +3

    'The new popular front' or 'the popular new front' or the 'people's popular front'? They're all spliters. Ocelot's spleen anyone?

  • @harrygmattin
    @harrygmattin Před 6 dny

    Best political video I’ve watched in a long time. What a fabulous understanding Andrew has and as far as I’m concerned, the BBC has never been the same since Andrew stopped doing This Week.

  • @ansc6472
    @ansc6472 Před 12 dny +2

    The Islamic republic of France 🇫🇷

  • @Vangough792
    @Vangough792 Před 12 dny +8

    How are they gonna sustain retirement age at 60?

  • @Insaanich1
    @Insaanich1 Před 12 dny +4

    Wow. Good explanation 👏👏👍💕🙏 thank you 🙏

  • @evolassunglasses4673
    @evolassunglasses4673 Před 11 dny +2

    Capitalism and Socialism working together to keep Nationalism out.

  • @Ghost-airlines
    @Ghost-airlines Před 11 dny +1

    The British Labour- londoner- green classes were in ecstasy over the prospect of Melenchon winning, Andrew is correct 🤣🤦‍♂️

  • @akashpaul6891
    @akashpaul6891 Před 12 dny +3

    add on top the fiscal situation in the western countries, the fall of an empire beckons