EP-145 | Union Home Minister Amit Shah Clears All 'Myths' Around CAA
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2024
- Just ahead of the mega 2024 Lok Sabha Polls, the Centre has notified the rules for the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), which was passed by Parliament four years ago. Union Home Minister Amit Shah asserts that Prime Minister Narendra Modi has fulfilled another commitment after Article 370 and Triple Talaq. The opposition labels the CAA as 'anti-Muslim' and 'unconstitutional'.
The CAA facilitates the process for Hindu, Sikh, Jain, Buddhist, Christian, and Parsi immigrants from Afghanistan, Bangladesh, and Pakistan, who entered India legally or illegally before Dec 31, 2014, and have resided in the country for at least five years, to obtain Indian citizenship.
In the latest episode of the ANI Podcast with Smita Prakash, Union Home Minister Amit Shah dispels all 'confusion' and 'misconceptions' surrounding the CAA. Home minister asserts that CAA seeks to offer refuge to persecuted religious minorities from neighboring countries and does not impact the citizenship status of Indian Muslims.
HM Shah also explains why the CAA excludes Muslims, arguing that this move is a gesture to protect those fleeing religious persecution, while highlighting that Muslims from neighboring countries can still pursue Indian citizenship through other legal avenues.
HM Shah explains why the implementation of CAA does not extend to tribal areas in the Northeast, stating that the tribal composition will remain unaffected by the CAA. Additionally, he clarifies all confusion surrounding the relationship between CAA and NRC.
#ANIPodcastwithSmitaPrakash #AmitShah #CAA #NRC
Timestamps:
00:00 - Introduction
02:36 - Motive behind CAA implementation before 2024 elections
05:49 - Opposition's Allegations & Misinformation Campaign
07:40 - Clarification on CAA not being an 'Anti-Muslim law'
14:07 - Allegations by Delhi CM Kejriwal
17:02 - Communal unrest in West Bengal & Illegal migration in North Eastern states
21:40 - CAA's link with NRC & State government's role in verification process
25:32 - INDI Alliance & Opposition to CAA
31:55 - Can CAA be 'repealed'?
33:47 - Rahul Gandhi & Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra
36:07 - Foreign Media & PM's 25-year roadmap
Subscribe now and press the bell icon 🔔 to get new video updates: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
Join ANI's CZcams membership to get access to perks:
/ @aninewsindia
--------------------------------------
ANI is South Asia's leading Multimedia News Agency providing content for every information platform, including TV, Internet, broadband, newspapers, and mobiles.
Subscribe now! Enjoy and stay connected with us!!
☛ Subscribe to ANI News CZcams channel: bit.ly/2UV4ygi
☛ Visit our Official website: www.aninews.in/
☛ Follow ANI: / ani
☛ Like us: / aninews.in
☛ Email to: anicontent@aniin.com, internetani@aniin.com
☛ Copyrights © All Rights Reserved ANI Media Pvt Ltd.
A Hindu living anywhere in the world has a natural home here in India.
Yes this should be the provision
Nahi bhai, kuchh Dhruv rathi libralindu ko b reject krna chahiye.
We dont want negative people. Even jo Inside india hain negative thinker unko kala pani bhej dena chahiye
@@WildEagle-cf6ws libranduo ko germany aur khalistaniyo ko canada bhej do baaki saare hindu aur sikhs ka india natural home hai 😅😅
@@WildEagle-cf6ws right brother they are like "Sher ke khaal me gidar" they act like they are Hindu but when it comes to speak in the betterment and development of Hindus they will reject it and say no this is against of secularism.
Yes this should be. Implemented in our country
Promises from BJP gov..
Article 370 ✅
Triple talaq ✅
Surgical strike ✅
Economy ✅
Infrastructure ✅
Technology ✅
Ram mandir ✅
CAA ✅
And others are coming soon (let's see)
As a youth I'll say great work bjp gov. Best wishes 🙌🏻
Edit: I have the ability to decide "What is Wrong and Right" so, those Kids in my comment section kindly do not fight and go to your class room! I do believe Every government has its own ups and downs. I'm not a BJP person, but again, if you think so, then give me a better reason and option than PM Modi right now. Table thoook kr keh rha hu usko hi vote dunga.
BJP is anti india saar - librandus
Anti muslim party
@@razak9729 razak, agar terrorist muslim hi hota hai toh haan
@@razak9729 that's why I vote BJP 🇮🇳🕉️💪⚔️❤️
@@razak9729 hutiye sun
Bro they will give sirect citizenships to all religion people who have comed from
Bangladesh
Afghanistan
Pakistan
But before 31 dec 2014
But not to muslims
Because india is alredy divided to 3 parts to give muslims diffrent nation
Now whats the point of them coming back??
And them some uneducated are saying this is anti-muslim 🤡
Do not worry 90% of the Real Indians supports BJP on CAA...and do not worry about the rest
Who is this 90%
Wrestler protest ?
Real Indians will never support these blunders.
@@ami1498 Explain me how it is a blunder. Please stop believing what ever you hear . I am not at all saying that the current government doesn't have any flaws but please atleast appreciate for the good things they are doing.
Wow. The level of clarity this man has is much better than all congress leaders combined
That's totally your call. No one is forcing you.
He is Not India's Home Minister, He is India's Deputy Prime Minister...💥💥✌️✌️
Wrestler protest ??
Really ? I did not see his title as Deputy PM.
@arnabaďhikary5485 The current government does not have a deputy prime minister and the post has been vacant since 23 May 2004. Pls check your facts right.
There were 23% Non-Muslim in Pakistan, now less than 3% remaining there 😮. Where did they go? Why didn't 23% grown while the population of Pakistan grown so fast?
Vo to maar rahe hai but hum unke jaise nahi hai, hum secular hai - librandu
Correct 💯
@@kajupataak should you not be proud of that ?
@@naraharilakshminarayana8493 secularism is a disease, I believe in pluralism
@@naraharilakshminarayana8493
give your women to a m.ulla, after that talk about this nonsense
The way he replied all the tricky questions, it seems "बंदे में दम तो है"👏👏
"Koi possiblity chhorna nahi chahta. Ek bhi hai to nagrikta denge." Goosebumps. This guy means business
बहुत अच्छा फैसला, अगले टर्म में NRC होना चाहिए।
agar koi religion change karke agaya toh india citizen banne ke liye.....phir apna religion india aake change kr liya toh.....???🤔
@@buffy9038 itna asan nahi hai, citizenship ke liye apply karne ke baad sare documents ke sath one to one interview hota hai
We need UCC, CAA, and NRC and Jihadis Mukt Bharat so that Bharat can progress and prosper.
Sabse bade jihadi to opposition wale hai
If you stop giving them their rights and stop them from practicing their religion surely they will become Jihadis to protect their religion and their people.
Thankyou Indian Govt for taking this issue seriously. No one can stop Bharat and its progress.
We support CAA and NRC from Bengal ❤️
Pakistan also should implement CAA in their country so that who think India is not safe country for them will go there immediately.
Amit Bhai Shah is a very strong minded nationalist politician in the path of Sh Sardar patel. Country was on antibiotics for 7 decades but cancer can't be cured without surgery (bills) like removal of 370,CAA,NRC,UCC,ONE NATION ONE ELECTION .
Indian Muslims must watch this video...I don't know how many educated muslims are there in india.. We don't need enemy when opposition leaders oppose CAA, Article 370, Asking proof to Indian army.. These opposition leaders are best friends with pakistan.. All patriotic indians are with PM Modi and Amit Shah 🔥🔥🔥.. India is secular because majority is hindu..We respect everyone.. Jai Hind.
Educated in islamic studies (madrasa) 😅
Musalman and education are opposites of each other bro. You cannot be a Muslim without being Dimagi Paralysed
kitnaa v education dedo... rahega saab dimagi aapnag nd haad jihadi
@PrinceSingh-js5yc right brother.. This is the problem for India.. Now they will again block roads in Shaheenbagh..
Why is muslim community against good education? And then they try to play victim card.
Amit Shah ended the podcast like a King🔥🔥🔥🔥
He is the King ❤🔥🔥
I want to say thanks Mr Amit Shah and Narendra Modi government for the guys to implement the CAA ❤. I am from West Bengal resident and I am a spectator who directly saw the entry of Bangladeshi Rahingas and many of them still living in West Bengal and try to create incergencies according to their faith .
If Muslims of Pakistan want to come to Bharat then what is the necessity of creating an Islamic state like Pakistan.
Caa is only for Hindu, Sikh, Jain , Buddhist and Cristian
Those who oppose CAA are the one whose DP have Palestine flag. They will raise raise for Muslims but not for Minority Hindus
whose daughters get raped by their Pakistani and Bangladeshi brothers. Unlike India Since they have Muslim govt. they are not taking proper steps.
They are raising for muslims and you are for hindus what's the problem?
Salutations to Honorable Home Minister for providing absolute clarity about CAA...Jai Bharat...!!!
CAA done ✅
NRC - NPR coming soon 🔜
Amit Shah ji ek ek शब्द सही और सत्य है,,,विश्व में किसी भी देश से हिंदू अगर भारत आता है या आना चाहता है ,,,सभी का हृदय से स्वागत है,,,100 करोड़ हिंदू 5/10 रुपया चंदा देकर अपने भाई,बहन,का रक्षा करेगा,उनके रहने खाने तरक्की करने का साधन उपलब्ध कराएगा
As long they get 272,it don't matter,what a legend Amit Shah
36:15 Nice to see how sharp and to the point our HM is.
They are given questions already before interview to prepare
@@kritarthsharma2544If thats true even then it doesn't change the fact that he is to the point and very clear about his thoughts.
01. Waqf property Act
02. Pleces Of worship Act
Remove the Act
Wait and Watch ⌚
Bro India will be fre
Yes 1000% support
Why this natak for CAA. It's implemented and a done deal.. If anyone has any issues, they are free to leave Bharat.
Yes right
agar koi religion change karke agaya toh india citizen banne ke liye.....phir apna religion india aake change kr liya toh.....???🤔
Basically he is saying that India is accepting refugees who are being subjected to Ethnic genocide.
Exactly
Amit shah is a true gangster. He controlled the interview on his terms , but was classy about it.
She went easy
This man is highly underrated in terms of brain, capability and patriotism.
NRC should definitely come after CAA.
Which is why people are protesting
@@sorryminati4719they protested against 370 abrogation.
Protested against triple talaq.
Protested against UCC in Uttrakhand.
All things are implemented
We Fully support CAA 🔥
Best decision by BJP and rest of the Hindu's who are opposing this decision are the one's who should be ashamed of themselves, Amit Shah rock's 🔥🔥
Love the clarity with which Amit Shahji says about CAA. We all support him and CAA, each one of us!
18:24 Heartiest respect 🙏 and thanks to our HM for CAA.
M a indian muslim..and totally support the govt regarding the caa....its not anti muslim...india has the rigjt to protect its borders.....for sure will vote for bjp...
You literally have said as a Hindu in another comment :3
WE WANT NRC AS SOON AS POSSIBLE 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
JAI SHREE RAM 🕉️🧡🚩
Mota Bhai bolte fire 🔥
Mr. Amit Shah to my mind, is one of the best Parliamentarian of Independent India.The preparation and thoroughness is unparalleled. Every single Parliament speech/interview is flawless and complete.👏🤗😍🍺
NRC should be implemented as soon as possible. It is more necessary and urgent than CAA 🔥
Saw what happened in Assam with nrc. Idiots like you would not know that
I stand with Amit shah on this. He is speaking reality. Muslims in EU, US are now creating havoc. We dont want nuisance creators in our home. Its our home and we must protect it and our hindu civilization.
Yes you are right. You should not delay. You should immediately migrate to any of the available Hindu nations. Hope you settle well in Nepal.
@@GoodThought-cj9ztIndia is a natural homeland of Hindus since thousands of years. Nepal is a hindu rashtra?? No one should ever respect invaders/converters. Period.
@@GoodThought-cj9ztnepal is hilly state with low population, i think 1.2 billion hindus can settle in macca and recover our makkeshwar temple😂
Actually indians muslims are converted one & there forefathers were hindus so the time has change and indian muslims must realise it and reconvert to their origin dharm that is sanatan dharma
@@Ashish__11
What I say might seem absurd but this is the raw fact. Even if you claim that Indian Muslims were originally Hindus then I think both of them should remember that majority of the two belongs to the Aryan race. Aryans came from outside... So doesn't matter who belongs to which religion, all who came from outside should go back to where they came from...
What a great interview . A TRUE leadership skills, great clarity and conviction for the county
It's Not a anti-muslim Law, its pro Hindu Law. aur ham hamare Bharat me Pro Hindu law nahin laenge to kahan laenge Turkey mein😂😂...🇮🇳❤️My Country My Culture My Rule🇮🇳❤️ Hum kisi v bahar wale ko jawabdahi nahin karenge.
Baat toh sahi hai dost ❤
Opposition should come up with logical points and analysis instead of fear mongering which cannot be always accepted. I used to be against CAA but i see today a sense of justice in words of Amit shah so i should support him.
Request All indian media to please take up matter with Pak govt to please start and implement their version of PakCAA to take in all Muslims who feel threatened in India and also include rohingiyas and some Hindus as well
😂😂😂well said
excellent defense and great argument by Amit Shah!
Amit Shah is the sharpest & shrudest politician out there. The opposition can’t beat a smart & ideologically driven man like him. Abki baar 400 paar 🇮🇳
He needs to be more strict.
Gujaratis patriotism unmatched real sanatanis need to learn from them
This was needed. A slap of truth on their face who spread rumours around this.
Please bring : NRC & Population Control Laws as well.
Just don't breed
It will not happen mostly. Bcz NRC and CAA are contradictory. And talking about population control; that's gonna be controversial. India already in stage 3 and imposing laws means it'll be like taking reproductive rights of people. Rather govt can stop encouraging people having more kids.
And it's quite irony how you are adding up more population by allowing others to settle here but on the other hand you're taking about snatching reproductive rights of your own people. Lol... this can happen only in this country.
Our Bharat is very lucky that we have the golden period of Modiji led BJP in power, else out county will have gone....as of now including so many pending issues since our independence Modiji is taking ineciative and taken bold decisions which must need of the hour and most importantly he is securing national safety and defense power which is never before in our history......Jai Ho Modiji
Dil se bataun to kuchh saal pahle Tak main Amit Shah ko bilkul bhi pasand nahi karta tha.... Par last 4-5 years me as a home minister inhone jo kam kiya hai uske base par main ab inka bahut bada supporter ban chuka hu.... Proud of you Amit jee ❤
There are too many advocates for Muslims, but none for Hindus except BJP and Modiji.
Amit Shah has pretty compulsive case on implementation of CAA. We support CAA for the sake of minority refugee.
What are you talking about they are entire new channels dedicated to praise modi and he's action ex Ani news, republic TV news18 abvp ajtak Zee news many youtubers too
@@gadgettv4472
talking about a lobby, that opens court at 2 am in the morning to rescue their fellow t.errorist
BJP will not going for muslim appeasement like previous congress government,so if muslim don't want to vote BJP its their thought process no one care.😂
Frist Read the caa act carefully and then ask question... 🙏🙏🙏
CAA done ✔
Now another main important things to do are:
1) Free temples from the state government .
2) abolish places of wordship act, 1993.
3) Kashi and mathura.
4) POK
5) Illegalise waqf board and promote equality.
6) UCC.
No Pok, only Gilgit Baltistan
Despite Ms. Smita Prakash being rude (unlike of her normal self...or may be that's how a journalist is supposed to be), in her questioning Sri AmitShah regarding CAA and other relevant subjects, the Home Minister kept his cool answering her questions, clarifying the basic doubts one might have. It's a tough fight for BJP against the entire opposition parties absolutely playing to vote bank politics......not a healthy trend 🙄😨
Except bjp is the one playing vote bank politics. The lot started the vote bank politics culture in this election, with the Mandir laye he, unko layenge slogan. That was the starting of the trigger
Are you blind or what bjp has many big businesmen and entire media behind them like abvp ajtak Zee news republic TV news18 Ani news too
Anchor was indeed rude, guest also spoke in a language which achor understands... Loud and clear..
@gadgettv4472....It's quite evident you are BLIND, as being oblivion to the presence of, forget about the channels, but supposedly game changers like the (Billionaire) George soros, SamPitroda ( with a crucked mind) & the mighty (rotten minded) President of China Xi Jinping....all omni present behind the Indi bloc and cong. with their dirty politics and money to wreck Indian Government, politics, Economy and especially BJP. Any true Indian should be bothered with this equation ......may be you and some are not.@@gadgettv4472
The ending was epic 👍😊🙏 with the hon HM Amit Shah ji himself concluding the podcast and thanking the host before she could even react to thank him for the interview. Third term for NDA inevitable and PM Modiji resurging ahead with a bigger margin will be the foregone conclusion. jai hind 🇮🇳.
Yes
Why Smita Prakash don't ask from Kejru that how the lakhs of Bangladeshi and Rohingyas intruders have got the Aadhar card in the last 7 years tenure of Kejru govt. in Delhi.
Amit ko puchhna bhi chahiye. Kitna rohingya ko flat diya hai😂
Kiska power he centre meh ??? Kiski galtai Karan illegal migrants aaya ???
Aadhar card comes under Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology
Ms.Smita Prakash's candid interview with the Home Minister Of India Sri. Amit Shah Ji, has been well appreciated. I believe that the Home Minister Amit Shah Ji answered and made every doubt clear on CAA, in this insightful interview. Thank you Smita Ji for having Amit Shah Ji on your show.
Support CAA ...and even NRC
CAA is a step forward for Humanity.👍 🇮🇳🇮🇳
What a Bold Man Amit Shah ji is 😎😎🔥🔥
Amit shah is a true patriot n a big strength strong spine of modi....without him modi can't succeed....n never seen amit bhai seeking for his footage in media coverage.....only come on media when needed by bjp or constitution....vry respected personality of Indian politics....all applaud modi but d real mind n Fairplay n sigma man is amit bhai.
We need more people like our honourable H.M Amit Shah ji as our leaders in the country, who have an iron hand and can take bold decisions without worrying about the vote bank politics or what will the world say and respond. He is a fearless leader who is not working for one specific political party or community but for the whole country which will benefit us in the future.Sure no policy or process is perfect as first and there will be core issues, but you don't know the result until you begin! kudos sir.
सही कहा लाईसेंस जनता देती है और वापस भी ले लेती है। भारतीय जनता पार्टी को देश के हित के लिए हम सब समर्थन देंगे
हम भारतीय नागरिक आप पर गर्व करते से.जय हिंद जय भारत 🧡🫡🇮🇳
I usually don't comment in CZcams but the way people are trolling Smita ma'am is unbelievable. She did an excellent job by asking all those questions to doze off the fears and rumours that the opposition is circulating for political gains. Please understand she is a reporter and the job of a reporter is to ask tough question not sit around and have a chit chat over chai. @ Smita ma'am you did a fantastic job as you always do. Keep shining 💖💖
If people understood this, they wouldn't comment in the first place
I support CAA & NRC 💪🏼
CAA - Muslims say why difference between Hindus and Muslims law should be same.
UCC- Muslims say why Hindu and Muslims should be under one law it should be different for Muslim as per Muslim personal law.
True
Yup they are just hypocrite 😂 no need to take them seriously
First time I saw Smita Prakash speechless on more than one ocassion. Well done Amit Shah..!
Always a pleasure to hear Amit Shah ji! Wish BJP lots of success in the Lok Sabha 2024 elections.
This person has exposed all the opposition parties. Everything was talking point to point. That's the reason why I like the BJP. ❤💯
What a clarity on the subject..he is most rememberable HM of the India
Amit Shah's interview will be useful for understanding basic information of C.A.A. .....
No more Shaheen baag movement. Only bjp government can solve problems and consequences of Hindu minorities in our neighboring countries.
Support from Jammu and Kashmir to home minister
What an interview. Such clarity and no sugar coating with words 🙏
Support CAA for west Bengal 💕💕💕🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️
800 years or Mughal rule
200 years of British
70 years of काले अंग्रेज
But I don't blame them. They had an opportunity, they grabbed it
Problem is with
1. Intellectual Hindus
2. Ostrich Hindus
3. All is well type Hindus
4. Secular Hindu
5. Convent educated Hindus
💯💯💯💯💯 right 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
I fully agreed 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Very true bro. ❤
Whole heartedly welcome CAA, my lifetime vote is now dedicated to BJP
Waqf board ki illegal property par action lo
Amit shah ji should be given at least 1 term as prime minister...
But Yogi will be pm after modi
@@himanshuchuphal1305 That's true
Modi will remain till 2034.
@@deadlyninja8391😂 bhai yeh sunke mulle gharwaapsi na karle😂😂
@@deadlyninja83912029 I think 🤔
Waiting for the day when the Indian Govt starts talking about WAQF Board and let the world know how bad the situation is in India. Jai Hind. Jai Bharat. Jai Shree Ram.
For that we have to elect bjp again in 2024 ...
@@smritisharma2797We will👍🏻
Life me humko Self Confidence bas humare Honorable Home Minister Amit Shah Sir ke trah chahiye...What a great leader 👏👏🙏
Excellent. Keep it up to both ANI and Shri Amit Shah!
Mam, please keep subtitles for this episode. Because the whole nation needs to understand it. Many are parroting false claims about CAA on social media.
Wow this man gives right reasons
That's the level of clarity BJP brings in its vision. Why would someone not vote for this vision?
Those who are opposing CAA have only one intention is persecuted people should not get citizenship. If they get, their agenda is unfinished.
Amit Shah is very right. The opposotion is trying appeasement politics. The entire indians are aware of the appeasement politics played by the opposition. CAA is a very serious issue. It is in the election manifesto of BJP. People have voted them and they have fulfilled it.
Amit saha allowed people of other nations have citizenship here. It means they will have right to vote also. If they were really persecuted there, they could have lived here as non citizen residents. Now you should tell who is playing appeasement politics.
Best gov india could ever get!!
sari khudai ek taraf(all opposition parties) aur Hon'ble H.M. Amit bhai ek taraf.....ek akela sab par bhari....
We want NRC now
Amit Shah ji - Chanakya of our nation-Bharat
Narendra Modi ji - Father+Visionary of our Bharat
🤣😅😂🤣
Actually, CAA has nothing to do with Indian people, it is about citizenship of minorities from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan. How the hell are Indian Muslims getting convinced that their citizenship will be lost.
Those who are protesting against it are not Indian Muslims in the first place. They ran away from Pakistan and Bangladesh as their economic conditions are not good and are now afraid of CAA and NRC combination as they when asked for proof of being Indian, will not be able to provide any. That's all. Specially in Assam.
They are convinced that a pdf file is the last and ultimate prophat, what else do you expect from these fools
madrasachap education and vot bank politics
Because of the chronology espoused by Shah himself on NRC following CAA. Also look at the implementation and we will see the issues
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351the pdf file was a horrible person
But not everyone believing that pedo is horrible
Mota bhai rocked opposition shocked
36:15 mic drop moment
25:46 he is so clear in his thoughts
Clear vision Clear thoughts ❤❤
Mota Bhai full swing mode Mein Hain. Don't dare to mess with him.
Amit shah ji aap pehle CAA implement kijiye uske baad NRC .. Uske baad lets review Muslims schoold (aka madrassas). There first prayer in the school has to be Bharat Maata Ki Jai and their last sentence before school ends it has to be Bharat Mata ki Jai. Anybody who has a problem they should be sent on their way to Pakistan/B'desh ASAP. We need to set the house straight - no more traitors within..
No CAA
Remove the deadline of December 31, 2014. The minorities of the neighboring countries must not be ambiguous about the act concerning its deadline. We can normally give citizenship to those refugees who came to India before December 31, 2014, without this act since they had already been here for 10 years and falls under general rules. The current act must accommodate the incoming refugees instead of those refugees who are already here.
After this we want:
1. UCC
2. Population Control Bill
Strongly.
3. NRC
Police reforms
Judiciary reforms
One nation, one election
Hindu rashtra
Third largest economy
@@divyesh97judiciary reforms like?
What idiocy
Yes PCB in UP is necessary
Population Control bill nhi, Bill honaa chahiye DEMOGRAPHY RESTORATION BILL, means 1947 ke baad jiss samudae ke Population des me 1.5 times se Jada ho gaya Hai vo sirf 2 hi bachya le sakte Hai, 3 bachya liya to puri family ka voting right permanently canceled ho jaaega!