Einat Wilf lashes out over countries’ aim to recognize Palestine
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 05. 2024
- Einat speaks about the diplomatic and political consequences of Norway, Ireland and Spain’s decisions to recognize a Palestinian state.
Join our community now and receive 24/7 of new & original content from the State of Israel.
www.iltv.tv
Follow ILTV Israel News on Facebook - / iltvisraelnews
Follow ILTV Israel News on Instagram - / iltv_israel
Follow ILTV Israel News on Twitter - / iltvnews
ILTV Israel News Website - www.iltv.tv
ILTV is an independent English-language media company based in Tel Aviv that provides daily news and entertainment to its viewers.
Launched in 2015, ILTV is committed to producing high quality content in a broad array of subjects, from reporting news and current events to programming which highlights technology, art and entertainment, sports and culture.
In today’s media, biased reporting and anti-Israel agendas are prevalent, as the State of Israel is under relentless attack.
From the “spinning” of unfolding political events in order to display Israel in a negative light, to the misrepresenting facts, media outlets are providing the fuel which shapes negative public opinion and contributes to the Delegitimization of the State of Israel.
#Israelnews #israel #Iltvisraelnews #newsfromisrael #israeltoday #iltvdailynews #tv7
![Einat Wilf on Anti-Zionism [2019] | Intelligence Squared](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1qGewRDWJGo/mqdefault.jpg)
There's no way Palestine should be given statehood when Hamas is still holding hostages. That's outrageous.
Jewish/Israeli hate is what it is.
Isteal was given statehood when it was holding millions of Palestinians hostage
@@Burrburrcloud most of them left on their own accord, many were promised a Jew-wipeout victory, so they could return. Didn’t happen that way.
@@Burrburrcloud couldn't agree more
@@Burrburrcloud There weren't millions of Palestinians in Israel, and Israel didn't hold anyone hostage.
1882 - about 276,000 Arabs
1918 - about 600,000 Arabs
1936 - 982,614 Arabs
1947 - 1,324,000 Arabs
Surprisingly, AJ made a clip telling the real story of what made the Palestinians leave. Check out an interesting video titled: "LEAVE! - The Origins Of Palestinian Refugees (In Their OWN Words)" on "palwatch" channel. It explains how it was that so many left Israel and the role the Jews/Zionists had in it, as well as the role the Arab leadership had.
I’m an outsider, but what I’ve heard Netanyahu say over the last 7+ months has been really strong and clear. The (willful?) lack of knowledge of the Arab world in the “West” continues to be staggering.
The Palestinian Arabs have wanted to wipe out the Palestinian Jews since about 1920 - decades before any Palestinians displacements. In 1948, the five Arab armies promised the Palestinian Arabs they'd wipe out the Jews, to convince the Palestinian Arabs to leave their homes. Then Israel won. Israel kept that disputed land as a defense measure because of the strong desire of the Arab world to wipe them out. I can't blame them.
Did you start reading world history from Oct7? Because your comment is very Stpd
@@checo8187 because the 1834 massacre was about "occupation" and "Palestine?" Stpdish
@@checo8187lets start from 7th century when mohammed started early islam and nicely asked everyone to switch sides or leave the world.
That's the first time when jew and islam meet.
let the UN find other land for the Palestinian..not Israel land
ridiculous...
Palestinians are the original inhabitants .. you come from europe
@@robsurname4054 Sorry to break it to you, but most of the Jewish people in Israel came from the Middle East.
Also, you might want to check out the work of Adriaan Reland, a Dutch scholar who published "Hadriani Relandi Palaestina ex monumentis veteribus illustrata", in 1714. It's a significant work in the field of historical geography and archaeology, as Reland extensively documented the geography, history, various aspects of the demographics, and archaeology of the region called Palestine based on ancient sources. It's written in Latin. However, you can find some parts of it translated as part of academic research. According to his census of 2500 villages and towns, most of the people in the land were Jewish. We never wholly left, whenever it was allowed, some of us returned. And whenever it was possible, some of us purchased land here.
Very few Arabs/Muslims lived in the area then 1714. The majority were Jews back then.
So no, the Palestinians came mostly around the same time the Jews came back to the land. Around 1880, Jewish people who bought land all over the place started reviving it. They dried up the swamps and boosted the economy in the area. That also brought more Arabs to the area, which at that time was pretty empty. In an area where around 16 million people are living today, with still room to spare, in 1882 you had a population of about 300k.
So no, the Palestinians are not the original inhabitants and Israel is exactly where it should be and where it will stay.
They did ... in 1967 they partitioned the land ... but Israel completely ignores it.
Israeli's aren't Jews. They're American and European tourists.
Perfectly argued! Thank you!!
ICC should issue warrants of arrest to UNRWA LEADER.
and for itself too
In your dreams 😂
There is no Palestinian State! Invaders and Migration from Neighbouring Countries: YES! Israel belongs to Israel and those who want to live and assimilate, be loyal, love Israel, work, live harmoniously, and recognize Israel until the Euphrates River and be Peaceful to all their neighbours! It is joyful to belong 🔥
Palestinians are the indegenous population of Palestine....which Isteal is occupying!
Oh, so IS is Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Jordan. When in history do you have this claim? Outside the bible.
it's not true. I won this land last week in the Israeli Lottery...hmmm
@@Burrburrcloud And before the Palestinians, it was the Jewish people who were living in the land.
Don't take my word for it, go by history. Any archeology dig site in Israel unearths Jewish artifacts. You have ancient Jewish historical sites dating back thousands of years.
Here are just a few examples:
1. In Jerusalem, you have the Kotel / Western Wall / Wailing Wall, part of a Jewish Temple. And you have the City of David, which dates back to the Bronze Age. Also, Mount of Olives, a Jewish cemetery with graves dating back thousands of years, including biblical figures and revered rabbis
2. Masada, from the First Jewish-Roman War
3. The Dead Sea Scrolls, written in ancient Jewish text, were discovered in Qumran, near the Dead Sea.
4. Megiddo is an ancient city located on a hill in the Jezreel Valley. The Hebrew Bible mentions it as the site of several battles.
5. Capernaum is a fishing village on the Sea of Galilee where Jesus lived during his ministry. It has ancient synagogues and other structures. (And yes, Jesus was Jewish)
6. Bet She'arim Necropolis in the Lower Galilee region has catacombs and elaborate Jewish burial chambers dating from the 2nd to 4th centuries CE.
7. Beit Guvrin / Maresha contains numerous Jewish burial caves, some decorated with elaborate frescoes and inscriptions.
8. Safed, a historic city in northern Israel with several ancient Jewish cemeteries, including the Cemetery of the Righteous, where many famous rabbis and scholars are buried.
9. Tiberias has several ancient Jewish burial sites, including the Tomb of Maimonides (Rambam) and the Tomb of Rabbi Akiva.
And there are a lot more.
Some sites also unearth Arab relics, but those are fewer and found only on the top layers. In contrast, the Jewish ones are found on every layer.
And if you go by wars, they won, the Jews were forced out, the Jews came back, they attacked again, the Jews won and stayed ever since (despite being struck several times and from several fronts)
We can also go by modern history, which is a whole story by itself.
Check out the work of Adriaan Reland, a Dutch scholar who published "Hadriani Relandi Palaestina ex monumentis veteribus illustrata", in 1714. It's a significant work in the field of historical geography and archaeology, as Reland extensively documented the geography, history, various aspects of the demographics, and archaeology of the region called Palestine based on ancient sources. It's written in Latin. However, you can find some parts of it translated as part of academic research. According to his census of 2500 villages and towns, most of the people in the land were Jewish. We never wholly left, whenever it was allowed, some of us returned. And whenever it was possible, some of us purchased land here.
Very few Arabs/Muslims lived in the area then 1714. The majority were Jews back then.
Jews were always here. Their numbers changed according to the attitude of the rulers here, but even when expelled, some never left. Everyone who colonized this land, since the first time Jews were forced out, tried to erase our history, destroy the sites, and build over the destroyed religious sites, but the history is still there.
Also, Jews in the diaspora kept their culture, teachings, holidays, and the core of their religion. The land of Zion aka Israel, is a big part of it.
💖👍
Maybe the US should recognize breakaway ethnicities or regions of Ireland(Irish Travelers), Spain(Basque, Galician, Catalan and Castilian regions) and Norway(Kvens, Romani, Tatars), as sovereign states, and recognize them. Let's make our own unilateral announcement for the breakaway ethnicities states.
She has the smartest way to address this issue! Angry responses by Israeli Officials[and non Officials] are a public relation disaster!
Why’s if those countries that’s recognized Palestine as State how come they wouldn’t take them and make States within their countries?
For the same reason countries didn’t take in an create a state when the UN created Isralie
@@checo8187 You are so full of B.S....please stop commenting you are making fool of yourself...lol!
Palestinians would have nothing to do with such a thing. They want Israeli land.
It's Palestine. @@ehcmier
What a joke 🗣️ You may not believe it means anything… But God DEFINITELY knows this IS a big deal… there should not be a parting of the land , that belongs to Israel alone God will avenge this 🙏🏽🙏🏽😡
God didn't give you a land it was uk and uas, looking down on Palestinians butchering and stilling ther land. And playing the victim.
Can you please give us his phone number or address so we can contact him ,
Your GOD is not the only God. How dare you think your God is more important than any other god.
God din not give Israeli any cantry. Let ther ranin a round the world. So europ give you that land ,and zaionist keep on stilling more land and more butchering Palestinians. Is not god here just evil.
She was a MK? Wow Israel has beautiful politicians. 😅
Where exactly is the state they recognized
No 2 state. God gave land to Israel
How on earth can the rest of the world decide whose State is what and when as the "Palestinians" elected Hamas that chants "from the river to the sea" and that they will perpetrate their massacres over and over. Israel's security will always be at risk. Israel has incurred tragic losses. They must be the ones to dictate what should happen, in my view. Rosa Larsen
Israel is the one perpetrating a massacre. And "the rest of the World" created the artificiel Terror State in 1947.
Yet it's OK when Netanyahu says "from the river to the sea" ! The situation was resolved by the UN in 1967 but Israel has ignored it.
The problem that started as an horrific attack first at the music festival and then at the Kibbutzim was nothing short of savagery and barbaric. Any person with a heart and even thinking of their own family i.e. of the perpetrators themselves should such a thing have happened to their mothers and sisters, would surely nullify who said what and when. The fact that Hamas said they would do it again and again forcing Israel to be on the alert fore ever, is a shame and disgraceful. The Palestinians were given Gaza in 2005 (I saw the Jews being dragged out of their homes there to make way for them). They could have transformed the place into a top class land but instead used the world's money to build a myriad of tunnels with which to attack Israel. They voted in Hamas and (The civilians now being collateral casualties of war...I was as well in WW2 when the Allies were justly bombing Genova, Italy when we were the casualties and bodies flying all over), and now these people are having to bear the consequences for voting Hamas in. Rosa Larsen
@@KingBee24 If you are referring to the Six-Day War in 1967, you are misinformed. I'll explain, starting from a bit before, with the Suez Canal.
A few points of the invasion of the Suez Canal a bit and the six-day war.
1. During the 1950~1960, The Palestinian fedayeen groups, supported by Egypt, kept invading Israel, and Israeli forces attacked them back. This caused an *increased tension between Israel and Egypt*
2. Egypt nationalized the Suez Canal on July 26, 1956, seizing control of the Suez Canal Company, which had previously been operated by British and French interests.
3. Following the nationalization, *Egypt closed the Strait of Tiran to Israeli shipping* in late 1956, cutting off Israel's access to the Red Sea.
4. In response to Egypt's actions, *Israel, Britain, and France formulated the plan* outlined in the Protocol of Sèvres to intervene militarily in Egypt.
5. *Israel initiated the military action by invading* the Sinai Peninsula on October 29, 1956.
International pressure, particularly from the United States and the Soviet Union, mounted against the tripartite invasion, leading to diplomatic efforts to resolve the crisis.
6. On November 2, 1956, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 997, calling for an immediate *ceasefire* and the withdrawal of foreign troops from Egypt.
Under pressure from the international community and facing diplomatic and economic consequences, Britain, France, and eventually Israel agreed to a ceasefire and began withdrawing their forces from Egypt.
Now leading to the six-day war:
1. *Syrian forces* stationed in the *Golan Heights* periodically shelled Israeli communities. *Palestinian Fedayeen* guerrilla groups conducted raids and attacks against Israeli civilians, often launching infiltrations from bases in Jordan and the *Gaza* Strip. *Jordanian forces* in the *West Bank* engaged in occasional skirmishes with Israeli troops and carried out artillery bombardments and cross-border raids into Israeli territory. In short, there was constant tension on all fronts.
2. *UN Emergency Force* (UNEF) was deployed in the Sinai Peninsula after the Suez Crisis, UNEF served as a buffer between Egypt and Israel, helping to maintain the ceasefire. However, its presence didn't prevent *Palestinian Fedayeen* attacks.
3. May 1967 *Egypt evicted UNEF* from the Sinai Peninsula,
4. *Egypt, Jordan, and Syria all gathered their forces* near their borders with Israel.
5. *Egypt closed the Strait of Tiran to Israeli shipping again*
6. June 5, 1967 *Preemptive Strike by Israel*
You can't ignore all the threats that were posed. This kind of Preemptive Strike is still considered a defensive move. Israel isn't innocent, but it didn't go looking for war. It was a move to stop the growing obvious threat.
By the way, the Soviet Union took part in this tension build-up by helping to build the Arab armies, running interference in the UN, and providing the Arabs with intel and false intel to suit their needs.
Israel must make it clear what the repercussions will be
None, other than cry for help to the US
Are you threatening again ???? Good luck with that 😂😂😂
@@checo8187 Biden will send them some pocket money...
What a great insight - This needs to be spread on wider media
US SEN. GRAHAM warned the SIN Group - Spain, Ireland, Norway - who are the leaders of #socalledpales? Where are the boundaries?
Israel forever! Stay strong, we Jews around the world always have your back. From Germany
Zionazi 😂
@@ClickPlus-um3qxNo they are successful non Muslim people.
Community-oriented and protect Israel at all costs from Invaders and unlikely entities then let them assimilate with Israel and most all love God🔥
Awesome! Go Doc, go!
Stand strong 💪 Israel 🇮🇱 for The LORD God is with you. 🇳🇬
🙏 🙏 🙏
If it really was genocide, Egypt would open its border, otherwise Egypt would be complict. But it doesn't. Egypt charges a 5000 dollar fee !
Stand your ground Israel! God is upon you! Dont let this palestinian refugees divide your land. Let norway, ireland and spain divide their land and give it to this palestinians.
Bright idea. If they become a state, there is no more need for UNRWA. Lets find out.
Where do these countries think the borders of this 'non' state will be?
So refugee benefits cease?
God bless Israel forever 🙏🇮🇱🙏
❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🦾
Even crow lost interest on brutal occupation flag you boasting
likud policy is to ethnically cleanse the area .. we have read their manifesto.. EVIL
Recognition of Palestine by Spain, Ireland, and Norway: Why It Means They Should Also Recognize Israel
Although I agree with other comments that say Israel should have all the land, at least these 3 countries should try to be consistent as follows:
So here's the deal: Spain, Ireland, and Norway just recognized Palestine, and there's a lot to unpack here. Dr. Einat Wilf, who used to be in the Israeli Knesset, has some pretty solid points on why this means they should also recognize Israel and why UNRWA (the UN agency for Palestinian refugees) needs to be defunded.
First off, if you're saying Palestine is a state, it meets all the statehood criteria. That means Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza aren’t refugees anymore-they’re citizens of their own state. Right now, UNRWA is helping these "refugees," but if Palestine is a legit state, then this doesn’t make sense. So, if these countries recognize Palestine, they should stop funding UNRWA because its mission is basically outdated.
Wilf makes it clear: supporting a two-state solution means backing both a Jewish state (Israel) and an Arab state (Palestine). Funding UNRWA while recognizing Palestine is like saying you support two states but still pushing the idea that Palestinian refugees can return to Israel, which undermines Israel's sovereignty. Defunding UNRWA would show these countries are serious about two states and acknowledge that Palestinians in Palestine don't have a refugee claim to Israel. And recognizing Palestine should naturally come with recognizing Israel to keep things balanced and fair.
Wilf also points out the inconsistency in recognizing Palestine while funding UNRWA. This keeps the “river to the sea” dream alive, where the entire area from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea becomes one Palestinian state, erasing Israel. If you’re all in on the two-state solution, you can’t support this idea.
And just recently, Prime Minister Netanyahu called out Spain, Ireland, and Norway for recognizing Palestine, saying it's like rewarding terrorism. He highlighted how this move could fuel more violence and instability. Finance Minister Smotrich even suggested cutting off financial transfers to the Palestinian Authority to hit back at this unilateral recognition. This shows how controversial and impactful these recognitions are.
So, if these countries are serious about a two-state solution, they should defund UNRWA. This sends a message that they support two separate, sovereign states and reject the idea of one state replacing Israel. It would also push Palestinian leaders to accept the reality of two states and work towards peace. Recognizing Palestine should come with recognizing Israel to show they're committed to a fair and balanced approach.
In short, Dr. Einat Wilf makes a strong case: recognizing Palestine means you should defund UNRWA and recognize Israel too. It’s about consistency and supporting a real, lasting peace in the region. By doing this, countries can show they're all in for a genuine two-state solution.
That’s two more than supposed Israel in 1948 .
more countries will follow...
She's so right. Beautifully said.
There is a change coming. Buckle up Israel you’re in for a wild ride!
Why don't countries that recognized and push for the recognition of Palestinian state don't just welcome and allow Palestinian to be citizen in their countries? With this there will be true peace in the region if they will do so.😊
Einat is right!!!
Judea and Samaria should not be part of a Palestinian state. To all Christians and Christian countries, Bethlehem can NOT be in Palestine but in Israel because of its Christian and biblical importance and Jesus born of a Jewish mother! 🇵🇬😎❤️✝️🙏🇮🇱🇱🇷👍
Sorry but Jesus couldn"t care less about to which states his menorials shall belong. He was about LOVE your enemies rather than " my / our land"
Israel should recognize Basque Country and Catalonia NOW!!!
This is really similar to how Finnish statehood was born under strict oppressive hold of the Russian tsar. Compared to our struggle for independence, Palestinians have more rightfully earned their sovereignty in their intergenerational homeland, I truly believe it 🇫🇮
You're comparing yourself to genocidal Islamic-supremacists?
Theres is still inteligent people.
We glad that Palestine already independence.
EU countries did not learn from pre-WW2 mistakes? Dance with vipers and they'll bite.
If a 2 states solution is impossible, we can make Palestine as an Autonomous Region for Muslim Israel, where they can govern but under the watch of Israel 🇮🇱.
Very Good!!
Now Israel does not have to give them water, electricity, medical care, etc.
Now that they are an independent country, let them take care of themselves.
And on behalf of the Israelis -
GOOD RIDDANCE.
Question is where they are going to put this state they are recognizing. Hopefully in the countries that recognizes them. No way it is going to be in Israel. IT DIED ON OCT7.
Totally shameless!
Free Judea and Samaria, arabs to Arabia!
Shalom
Vejam o que Deus disse a mim:
"Toda semente que é plantada fora do seu tempo, não vingará."
Ea
Shalom
S. Africa and ICC loss no even one cent, lose no army and civilians and lose no land in the hamas-Israel war but then they willing to give the Israeli's land to arab. In my opinion if they give warrant arrest to Israel's leaders why can't Israel's government release warrant arrest to ICC and SA leaders too. If they wanted war to Istael ok no problem let them fight. They have no right to give Israel's land to Israel's enemy. So funny. No headache😂😂😂lol
Sorry there no more Palestine
🇵🇸فلسطين حرة النصر لمسلمين
Dream
Never in your wildest dreams.
انتو احلامو ترجعو اسير واحد حتي تركعو تستلمو الاسرة سوريا القلب مع فلسطين 🇵🇸الروح @@Alextriumph1050
🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱
🇮🇱🇮🇱🙏🏻🙏🏿🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️❤️❤️❤️
Another two European countries to recognise Palestine next month…..France, Japan and Saudi Arabia considering it. That would be 148 countries recognising Palestine, 165 countries recognising Israel. The gap is closing 😂😂😂
Read history , mix blood European 🇪🇺 with a short life span in human history, lady they are not going away You eventually will !
😂😂😂😂😂
Over seventy five years of brutal occupation, oppression atrocities cruel systematic torture crimes, suffering Palestinian deserves their right to freedom, denial over seventy five years.
The only oppression comes from Hamas. You need to do some research.
@@Alextriumph1050 yuppie! You think world as dumb as Biden Blinken, they read the tags that you put on Hamas! World ain't that stupid!! How long you been putting tags on Hamas and Palestinian????
Jordan is Palestine.
Israel your Messiah Jesus Christ is waiting for you to repent and believe in Him.❤
No thanks. Putting your faith in a man is idol worship.
It's like watching the female version of Beavis and Butthead.
Go back to watching Al Jizzeera if this content doesnt jive with your terrorist supporting sensibilities
Free Palestinian no more accupy
How dare those countries care about anyone but Israel. Don't they know we are God's "chosen">
Sorry, wasn't my fault. Israel made me not support them many years ago. They made me do it, not me. Honest I, I mean they did.
What your concern,it was Palestine in the first place before the English gave to the jews immigrant.Before 1948 there was Palestine currency,stamp.you purposely have memory lapse.
Have you seen the pictures of the Palestine currency before 1948 ? Banknotes and coins have inscriptions in English, Arabic and Hebrew. Coins have the word "Palestine" written in English, Arabic and Hebrew. In Hebrew it also mentions in the acronym (א״י) for Eretz Yisrael (Land of Israel).
You are spreading untruths.
Palestinian doesn't need israel approval to have their own State.
If they want land that is Israel's they need Israel's approval. And they won't get it when they have not shown themselves to be partners for peace.
Who are Israel to dictate to any nation or decide who has a state ? The irony 😂
neighbors
Free Palestinian stop accupy Palestinian land
Palestine is an area of more than 27 thousand square kilometers and is on the borders of Egypt and Jordan, which historically is part of Palestine and the people of Jordan, more than 70 percent of whom are of Palestinian origin, but Britain made them a state and brought agents to the Jordanian ruling dynasty in order to rule Jordan and protect the occupation from the Jordanian-Palestinian people Palestine Its capital, Jerusalem, is the land of the Palestinian people for tens of thousands of years. It is the cradle of Christianity and Judaism, and it is the third holiest place for us Muslims. It is a land where most of God’s prophets lived, were born, and died. It is the holy and blessed land and the land of the Palestinian and Arab people. Muslims, Jews, and Christians lived there for thousands of years as neighbors and brothers before the Zionists occupied our land. Britain brought them in the Balfour Declaration to occupy our land. Those who committed the Holocaust against the Jews were the Germans and the West, not me.💚🇵🇸❤️🇵🇸
There was no Islam before Judea and Samaria were colonized by the Romans. Don't bring the teachings of the devil Muhammad to claim land belonging to the Jewish nation since the Jewish kingdom and even before The Arab nation settled into a caliphate.
Nice propaganda 😅 trying to whitewash alleged war criminals
I say right on to Palestinians have their own sovereign state!
So they can commit more terror on Israel?
Spain, Norway and Ireland have the right to recognise the Palestinian state.
No they don't, it not their land and they are all in Europe, they have no right to say where Jewish people can live, work, pray, go to school and shop. This is supporting Palestinians Jim Crow segregationist apartheid policies against Jewish people.
Yes, you absolutely have the right to invite your own doom. Can’t argue with that.
Much in the same manner that we have the right to drink lighter fluid with grenadine and ice while enjoying a slice of aluminum cake with mercury icing. Yes, we have the right. But...no.
Israel must be held accountable for war crimes against humanity and genocide in Palestine 🇵🇸
I agree, if its true. Start building your case. Dont use statements made by Hamas. Good luck.
@@yitzhakspolter9551 Already convicted by ICC. EU countries will arrest bibi after arrest warrant.
Thousand years they living here not refuge
Inshallah free pillestine ❤