it can be even worse of course there have been locks he was able to open without any tools, those were the truely bad ones the 'worse then nothing' locks
Hahaha yes! I was running down the list in my head before he dropped the rake into the shot... "Will he use a lishi? Single pin with the covert companion? Surely you can't comb it... Oooooooh, it's a rake- RIP."
Holy crap, Smonet took down the web page for this lock! LPL embarrassed them so bad they had to kill the lock - wow! Hopefully this is a good thing, and Smonet is accepting their defeat and coming up with a more secure lock. Can't wait for Round 2 when they release it!
@@AndyTheCornbread I highly doubt it, look back 2 months from now and I bet the page is back up, or they rebrand the same lock as "new and improved" etc. My money is on them protecting their ratings and hoping people will forget this video before the page goes back up.
The optimistic side in me is hoping that someone at Smonet might have known how bad their products are and might have sent the lock to LPL intentionally to force management to make changes that they themselves were unable to initiate.
"Ignore my objections, well they!? 'It doesn't matter,' 'it's too expensive to do it right,' 'no one cares about mechanical lock security!' 'ship it now or the shareholders will be frowny...' I'll give 'em something to be frowny about!" ~ disgruntled engineer shortly before contacting LPL
"Whose brainfart idea was that, Wilsons? Get his ass in here, NOW!" Now there's 4.14M people with an opinion for friends and family about their product.
One of these days LPL is going to have a completely silent video. 5 seconds for the lock, 5 seconds for the Amazon listing showing the price tag, then a hand comes in from off-screen, sets down a wave-rake, "In any case, that's all I have for you today..."
We measure lock fails by how much LPL must pad the video to meet CZcams minimum threshold. 6 seconds gets you 2 extra picks and a story about a monkey.
@@stevie-ray2020 or someone in Marketing who has only seen the positive talking points about how amazing their product is, and actually believed they were providing a secure product. No company shares the cut corners with Marketing, it's easier if those people genuinely believe in the product after all.
If someone at Smonet actually sent him or asked him to review the lock, I'll bet it was a whistle blower that just could not believe what they were shipping.
LPL: "you do know what i do here, right?" CEO: "Any publicity is good publicity. Just review it." LPL fanbase: "We aren't here to see locks succeed, we are here to see them fail. And we are well entertained!"
"This lock is unacceptable at any price point." Is he going to bust out a wave rake from the Genesis set? "I'm going to take a turning tool and wave rake from the Genesis Set..." Nailed it!
In other news the entire marketing team at Smonet was just laid off for "unrelated reasons" and the CMO tendered his resignation, citing the desire to "persue other opportunities."
A half-decent core that would require actual picking is also...still so cheap. Especially in that quantity. Reminds of those $500 medical cabinets with filing cabinet locks.
@@popeter It's the ZNS-Y001, right? The picture on the website and the picture from a review don't exactly match but it does look the same. If so, all the pages I saw returned 200.. non 404 to be seen.
It's amazing how LPL's voice, tone and pitch don't change in his vids which proves his professionalism, but damn if I couldn't hear the disdain dripping from every deadpan word in this particular one.
After watching hundreds of his videos, I feel like we're part of a club - LPL targets us exactly, not even new viewers given the context of his words. No bull, no fluff, just "folks, you know what I do, check out the balls on this vendor daring to call this product a viable security solution". LPL is a major influencer re: shopping (in a good way) that I scrutinize MOST things, not only locks, when making a purchase now. Less garbage purchases. Prioritize quality, always. Research, etc.
you should scrutinize using your full name on the internet and that weird little portrait you have for an avatar. prioritize quality, always. trust your gut
I would like to see a round up comparison of smart locks and all features not just the physical key; wifi/BT protocols, different keypads, fingerprint, any special features like temporary codes, cameras, notifications etc.., general construction and installation methods. He could ignore software side but for setup he could just get basic burner smart phone.
@@Gnordlan I'm not going to lie, part of me wants to take a lockpick kit to one of those demo walls just to see the reaction to me checking pick resistance on a potential purchase... but I'm not going to buy one so it wouldn't be acceptable.
As an 30+ swedish viewer of your work this made me think of a show we had here called "Plus". It was a broad consumption journalism show that included reviews and stories form the real world of people being tricked by companies and in the end of most episode he trashed an item that was really bad. This lock would have gotten such a trashing and been thrown with force in that show.
The USA used to. The predecessor of PBS had a show that would, for example, show the difference between a bottle of Bayer aspirin and a bottle of store brand aspirin. The difference was: a dollar, some cotton, and 150 doses of aspirin. Corporate America shut down that show (and network) _real_ quick.
Oh man, I remember The Lottery, that was probably one of my first exposures to a story that made me set a book down and think "what the actual hell" probably in early middle school.
Even if the mechanical lock was any good I wouldnt want a lock that is reliant on an app to function. The moment that company stops supporting the app Im left with a useless paper weight
Not to mention the fact that apps from these companies generally steal and sell customer data. Plus these apps are generally based on the phones Mac address which can easily be spoofed, as well as a number of other security issues that generally come with this type of lock.
That entirely depends on how the app works. Most likely, the app is only used to configure the lock. Also, I don't think the app relies on cloud services - you probably just connect to the lock via bluetooth. So the app would remain working just fine. There are some security concerns about the app to lock connection, though. It's certainly possible to make this secure, but I'm not sure these guys can be trusted with that...
I am not a fan of "smart locks" in general, but when that smart lock has three modes of entry on the door, and STILL requires a smartphone app to set things up, opening a fourth, and wandering access route, it makes me shiver. People put WAY too much faith in the security of their pocket computer. A computer that can be dropped, broken, lost, stolen, seized by police (with or without legal cause)... And they put access to their home, personal data and bank accounts all in that small slab.
Plus more. Basically the entire life is on that small slab. Taking away the phone is like taking away that dude’s soul. Smart locks without backup would be devastating. But those backups we have seen so far might as well does not exist at all.
@@estellebright2579 Never trust a device to do a job that a key can do, especially as with the use of non secure technology like unencoded bluetooth or NFT someone can snoop and acquire your access codes. LPL has shown how it is done and someone with a little knowledge can do it and be in and out of your place without leaving a trace or a clue as to how they got it.
@@estellebright2579 Even worse it's the possibility of the company behind the app development discontinues the app or drops it off the App/Play Store. You cannot setup your lock anymore if you eventually need.
@@JamisCasusa in a nutshell, smart lock is a stupid idea bought up by dumb people who knows little about security. Leave the lock to be a lock, and improve your home security elsewhere. Sadly, the neighbour just renovated his house with a card swiper at the front door. Sad times.
Electronic devices can also be backed up and password protected (which most people don't care all that much about, unfortunately). Devices get broken or stolen plenty, and the most I typically hear coming from that is moderate inconvenience in having lost some recipes or whatever or having to reset some passwords (although there are certainly more extreme exceptions).
I can picture the board meeting with the CEO saying "since I'm assured by the technical team that our lock is unbreakable what we need is to challenge that Lock Picking Lawyer guy" and the look of horror on the technical director's face as this is going on.
While a nice mental image I doubt is was anything deeper then a quick data analytics search for popular youtube channels that feature locks. Basically this channel gets hella views so we send him product and that's it.
@@TheRyujinLP it is more than likely that someone thought that they would get publicity from it, not realising that since they are selling a product that falls to a rake attack in 2022 that makes it a very insecure product. That particular flaw has been known about and dealt with successfully for 40 years and selling 40,000+ units does not make it successful, it means that the buyers had no idea that the product had little security value and were taken in by the slick marketing about app use, in other words a product designed to appeal to millenials.
The thing is that they design a lock, then have an overseas company make the cores, and probably get shafted and lied to. Once the stuff has shipped, whatever corners that were cut, there are no legal avenues. They probably promised a $10 core and put a $2 core in and pocketed the difference. I bet they are having some terse words with the manufacturer, because the lock looks like it at least made an attempt to do the right thing.
Being a lawyer, he's so careful about how he speaks so as to not give them even an argument of a lawsuit "I think you have a pretty good idea what I think of it" 🤣
Before I saw this comment, I turned to my gf and said something like "oh there's the lawyer in him. He doesn't say it rocks or sucks... Maybe he meant it's a good demo lock for a wave rake" 😂
@@Slothptimal This. I'm pretty sure it can only be considered defamation if you're giving information that you know is false. So him saying its unacceptable at any price point then demonstrating why he thinks its unacceptable at any price point seems very safe from defamation. They would have to prove he intentionally and knowingly changed the lock in some way to make it easier to pick for the sake of the video and then didn't mention his tampering in order to make the product look worse than it is.
A good first step is to find someone who will give you critical feedback. Good on the lock manufacturer. The necessary second step is to use that feedback. I guess we will wait and see on that.
When my wife and I bought our condo a few years ago, it came with a Yale smart lock with a keypad and all that business. Naturally, to use the "smart" features, the app was required. I looked up the permissions the app "requires" to be installed on my Android phone. Sure enough, the permissions list is a mile long, just to unlock my front door with my phone. And, they share just about everything with third parties. So, I immediately removed the wi-fi module from the lock. Now it's just a lock with a keypad.
@@stevie-ray2020 Androids at least - not sure about iphones - have the photos and storage as one permission. In other words if an app needs to store anything on your device then it will also have access to your photos if you let it. It's not any less of a privacy breach of course.
We all want to feel secure in our homes but if your not experienced in locks , it's nice to come to ppl like yourself for ideas. Please share your wisdom 🙏
Reminds me of the time my uncle got a new gun safe and as he was showing it off I picked up a little screwdriver and scrap of wire off the work bench and jimmied the lock in about 8 seconds. He took the thing back to the store that day lol
Caveat - this is NOT a criticism of LPL. Your videos are incredibly interesting, entertaining and educational and I watch every one. We see locks picked that are not mounted on doors on this channel (with a few exceptions - most notably videos on April 1). This seems (from someone who doesn't pick locks) like an easier way to pick than one that it mounted on a door, if for no other reason than it's a "best case scenario" for picking the lock (you can dictate the angle of attack, how you hold it, where you place your tools, etc). It clearly still takes a lot of skill to open the locks. My question is this - How different is it to pick a mounted lock, in a situation where you just come upon a lock that you need to pick (or, if, say, you lock yourself out of your house, need to help a neighbor, etc)? Not for nefarious purposes, but just doing it "in the wild?"
I love the "sponsored" videos most. It's so hilarious when some manufacturer goes "what's the worst that could happen?" because they didn't check the content before hand xD
LPL is the first place I look before buying anything to lock a door or valuable up with. I've saved tons of time using a nail gun to open trailer hitch locks.. 22 cent nail cartridge vs a locksmith trouble call.. lock replacement was cheaper and no waiting. best wishes for the holidays LPL! 🎅
“The Monkeys Paw” was a perfect reference for this. I think they should watch your show because they must have been looking for some free advertising without doing their due diligence. All I can say to how fast that was is WOW! I’m amazed at how easy that was.
Lol. Someone just gave me one of these locks. I remembered this video was in my feed and I'm glad I came back to look at it. Now I'm going to have to decide if the person will give it to me is really a friend! 😆
Regarding privacy: use a burner phone, or even several. Older models of all kinds can be bought for near to nothing and you can wipe them afterwards without losing anything.
That has to be a record for the LPL. The average time to pick the lock four times comes in at probably 4 seconds. That is beyond very good. Congrats LPL!
@@The_Muffin_Man "That story comes to mind whenever I get Emails from makers of questionable locks ..." It was an Email, not a letter. He almost certainly bought it himself to test it.
it really doesn't matter, if they sent it, or if he bought it. The email was the trigger event and I agree, that if the "higher ups" of that genius get wind of it, that the days of their employment are probably numbered.
When the manager has a strong background in used cars, or fast food, and doesn't talk to the engineers (who, to be fair, are probably in China somewhere.).
Sorry I've been absent so long. I've been dealing with homelessness, a venous ulcer with which I graduated to Hugh Glass levels of stoicism (with the help of the local house flies), and a total hip replacement (I have 2) that decided to become completely disassociated from my pelvic bone. Now I am in the Hell Hole called "Skilled Nursing Facility" as I attempt to keep concentration focused on getting my wound healed (they seem to be only occasionally aware that I have this 80 cm^2 gash in my leg) so that my orthopedic surgeon can perform a revision surgery on that same leg's hip. Perhaps four months away, God willing and the creeks don't rise.
From their site .... just for a giggle!!! 💯 'What makes our products unique? SMONET has a R&D team composed of more than 60 senior engineers. The security products have a series of powerful and effective functions to detect and prevent any intruders, vandalism and intruders, and protect the safety of personnel and property.'
Very clever of Smonet. They have you talk about how insecure their current lock is, then release a brand new one "based on feedback from the LPL" and sell another 40k.
The thing about the wave rake is, if you can use a wave rake on a lock you can use other things with similar shapes. I've wiggled open locks with letter openers that have a very similar shape, which means you can use other more everyday-type items to open locks without having an actual tool like a wave rake.
For anyone wondering what that short story is, the major plot point is that a woman wishes for a large amount of money, and is then given that amount by her son's employer after he dies in a workplace accident.
I was subjected to "The Monkey's Paw" in 8th grade via our drama club reading it in a particularly lifeless, monotone reading with many of the "actors struggling with vocabulary they clearly hadn't studied. It certainly made the experience memorable.
If I were a smartlock producer planning on upgrading my device I'd 100% send the old device to you. Then when I throw a couple spools in I could get a second video showing how well I listen to feedback and get all the good pr points.
Just be absolutely sure the locking lug is properly shielded, and make doubly sure the hasp is not shimmable. Finally don't claim a lock body back from pot metal is actually hardened steel. At that point though, you may as well take the step to add security pins from the get go, maybe some variation in spring tension and you'll most likely see the lock opened in under a minute by LPL anyway. but he'll most likely say something like "this lock should resist an unskilled attack" which will attract cheers and plenty of sales from LPL's followers.
Or you could, you know, make a good lock in the first place. You could even engage with the security/picking community during development. Maybe not as glamorous. But just imagine how well loved your product could be if LPL featured it and gave a glowing review.
There are two ways of looking at this axiom, and it's dead wrong either way: 1) Locks exist to make money for the manufacturer and aren't there to keep anyone honest or dishonest. Since most customers are not well informed, this means they can be absolute garbage in most cases. 2) Locks are there to convince a dishonest person that it's easier and less risky to steal somebody else's stuff instead of yours. A good lock (not this trash) can absolutely do this, if it's integrated into a decent security framework overall.
The only reason you'd use an app for what is clearly an RFID tag.. is for data collection. The fingerprint pad can be decoded by torchlight, or even by your own house's security light shining on it, the fingerprint reader by a piece of adhesive tape and your finger... and the lock by a wave rake and some enthusiastic jiggling.
I wish you did these videos more often because not only it shows how not that secure some of these locks are for us but it's also free content for you! Not to mention maybe one of these videos persuades these lock makers to better secure their locks!
Ah, I can fondly remember the time (pre-LPL) when I still believed in mechanical lock mechanisms. Raked open 4 times in less time than it takes to watch a Pepsi commercial.
There were 1 or 2 Pepsi commercials that, back in the day, I didn't fast-forward past. So you'd have even more time to rake the lock open a few more times.
he has! there are oms vids with "a xy lock i would use" or stuff. It boils down to "locks that use a version of security pins and are manufactured in high material quality"
He has featured a number of good locks in the past. the problem is, there's so much crap out there. He is trying to illustrate the sorry state of security in the world today and help people avoid the really bad stuff.
@@Tahngarthor I got some American Locks from pre-Masterlock buyout days, and that's what I use for my shed. As a novice / midlevel sport picker I find them pretty brutal. Apparently they're still alright. Haven't been dumbed down so far as I know.
@@KF1 well i cant even seem to rake a masterlock #3 even though they're supposed to be rakeable. So maybe it's a "low skill attack" but apparently not low enough for me lol
As soon as the wave rake comes out you know the answer, we still watch to the end for the deadpan and well spoken scathing review that didnt need to be said. Keep up the good work LPL, I'll never buy a lock again without checking you havent done a video on it.
Residential door locks without the bare minimum of security pins is an absolute travesty, especially when you consider that several of the $10-$20 locks you can buy even at your local Walmart or hardware store are typically immune to raking
So a while ago there was some research done into industries where reviews by experts are a big thing. The research (done by the New York Review of Books) found something interesting: if you're famous, then a bad review is bad for sales. But if you're not famous, getting a review AT ALL raises your profile. So even bad reviews were beneficial to the company.
![[1453] VERY Clever “Loki” Puzzle Padlock Solved](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OFvTzppfJnA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[1453] VERY Clever “Loki” Puzzle Padlock Solved](/img/tr.png)
![[1422] Did I Cheat On This Challenge? (Tamper-Sealed Abus)](/img/n.gif)
You know a lock is doomed when he takes the waverake
it can be even worse of course there have been locks he was able to open without any tools, those were the truely bad ones the 'worse then nothing' locks
I love when he uses a Red Bull can.
Yeah, I wince when the wave-rake comes out... "Oh, sucks to suck..."
that's exactly what I just told my wife.
Hahaha yes! I was running down the list in my head before he dropped the rake into the shot...
"Will he use a lishi? Single pin with the covert companion? Surely you can't comb it... Oooooooh, it's a rake- RIP."
I liked how he picked the lock 4 times instead of the usual 2 just to show how bad it is
Yeah, and every time it sounds like it's calling for Help...
The fluke was it took too long the first time!
@@davec8921 😂
Well he had to do something to pad for time, otherwise the video would have been under a minute... LOL
New "Defeat Resistance" Rating - "Defeats per Minute" otherwise known as "DPM"
To protect the core from raking attacks you can write the combination on the wall next to the door
It would take longer to open it that way too.
@@averagegatsby We mustn't neglect user factors. Sometimes people have bad days and leave their wave rakes at home.
🤣🤣
Or leave it unlocked. I think that's how they're doing it in San Francisco these days.
There is wisdom in creating easier paths for the things you wish to prevent, in circumstances where they will happen inevitably
Holy crap, Smonet took down the web page for this lock! LPL embarrassed them so bad they had to kill the lock - wow! Hopefully this is a good thing, and Smonet is accepting their defeat and coming up with a more secure lock. Can't wait for Round 2 when they release it!
40,000 units a year at $150 a piece and they just tanked a 6 million dollar a year revenue stream by sending him their lock to be reviewed.
Someone got fired over this.
@@CR3W1SH03S Oh yes indeed.
@@AndyTheCornbread I highly doubt it, look back 2 months from now and I bet the page is back up, or they rebrand the same lock as "new and improved" etc. My money is on them protecting their ratings and hoping people will forget this video before the page goes back up.
😆🤣😂 Smonet did get exactly what they asked for, just not what they expected.
LPL takes professional roasting to a whole new level. Picks it 4 times in a row for advanced disrespect
Haha "Advanced Disrespect"
My feeling is that the first open took uncharacteristically long, so he wanted to drive home the point that it opens much quicker most of the time.
In under 3 minutes, with all the explanation and introduction.
He asserted dominance over it.
And then wish them a nice day.
The optimistic side in me is hoping that someone at Smonet might have known how bad their products are and might have sent the lock to LPL intentionally to force management to make changes that they themselves were unable to initiate.
If this is the true story, that'd be amazing, and also a major risk.
When the engineering CEO is not getting through at the financial manager.
Nope.
That is called testing, and it should be done before releasing the product to the market.
Maybe it was a disgruntled employee who was planning to leave anyway?
"Ignore my objections, well they!? 'It doesn't matter,' 'it's too expensive to do it right,' 'no one cares about mechanical lock security!' 'ship it now or the shareholders will be frowny...' I'll give 'em something to be frowny about!" ~ disgruntled engineer shortly before contacting LPL
"Is there really no such thing as bad publicity? Today on Lock Picking Lawyer we put the theory to the test!" - Smonet, probably
Soon on their website: "Featured on the lockpicking lawyer!"
@@GideonWeissman "You just used that phrase. I do not think it means what you think it means."
@@JosephTomasone Inconceivable!
"Whose brainfart idea was that, Wilsons? Get his ass in here, NOW!"
Now there's 4.14M people with an opinion for friends and family about their product.
There was probably an internal bet between corporate buttwipes and someone had a bone to pick.
One of these days LPL is going to have a completely silent video. 5 seconds for the lock, 5 seconds for the Amazon listing showing the price tag, then a hand comes in from off-screen, sets down a wave-rake, "In any case, that's all I have for you today..."
Oh, be fair. You know he'll unlock it twice, just so we know the first time wasn't a fluke. 😊 Take care
Tiktok you mean?
Actually, he would do well to have short versions of his vid. That would be a great format for those who prefer short vids.
@@TesserId you know, because sub 3 min videos aren't short enough...
And then a 5 second deep sigh.
My thanks go out to the person that contacted LPL to review their product. This just shows it takes one person with a conscience to make a difference.
Maybe it was a disgruntled employee who was planning to leave anyway?
When your marketing intern sinks your whole company in their first week.
I wouldn't get me hopes up, i'm pretty sure it was most likely just "stupidity" than "conscience"....
Conscience _and leverage._
Might have to start an LPL witness protection program or whistleblower support crowdfunding!
"One more time to be sure it wasn't a fluke" is LPL's way of saying "That last pick was rookie-tier, I know I can do it faster"
Smonet gets an extra two “not a fluke” picks for free since they asked for the spotlight. You’re welcome, Smonet! 🤣
They should be paying him
No seriously this falls under both QC and security auditing. Both come at a heavy price
he had to give those 2 extras, otherwise the video is to short, this is one of the easiest picks i've seen so far
We measure lock fails by how much LPL must pad the video to meet CZcams minimum threshold. 6 seconds gets you 2 extra picks and a story about a monkey.
Every time LPL says “wave rake” it makes me smile because I know what’s going to happen.
Wave (goodbye to your business) rake
He’s going to use the wave rake?
The vorpal pick.
Me: "Aw come on, they didn't f*** it up that bad did they?"
He just desecrates the locks when he pulls that Disney villain sword. No respect domination style.
The engineer sent it to prove to his boss why they need to include a different core at an increased cost.
..... or maybe it was a disgruntled employee who was planning to leave anyway?
@@stevie-ray2020 or someone in Marketing who has only seen the positive talking points about how amazing their product is, and actually believed they were providing a secure product. No company shares the cut corners with Marketing, it's easier if those people genuinely believe in the product after all.
@@kh628 They do in engineering where certain physical specs must be met.
If someone at Smonet actually sent him or asked him to review the lock, I'll bet it was a whistle blower that just could not believe what they were shipping.
That's the best case scenario lol.
Maybe they were really hoping he downloaded the app!
LPL: "you do know what i do here, right?"
CEO: "Any publicity is good publicity. Just review it."
LPL fanbase: "We aren't here to see locks succeed, we are here to see them fail. And we are well entertained!"
I'm actually here to see a lock succeed. One of these days it will happen.
@mrfreegman I see a lock on this channel succeed I'm buying stock in the company and buying a bunch of their locks
@@MrFreeGman [636] & [653]
As far as I'm aware, he never managed to pick the Bowley locks.
I actually want to see them succeed. Otherwise what are we going to use? 🤔
@@TheJohnDorn not a good idea, they will only sell one or two and no need for replacement
"This lock is unacceptable at any price point."
Is he going to bust out a wave rake from the Genesis set?
"I'm going to take a turning tool and wave rake from the Genesis Set..."
Nailed it!
He's the Ralph "Unsafe at any speed" Nader of locks.
When the wave take tools appear, it means the lock is already open
"Unacceptable" may be the strongest use of word I have ever heard him say. There's no beating around the bush on this one....
You always know a wave rake or bump is coming at those words lol
@@Serlock4869 you can literally see the locking part sticking out in this one, don't know if that was a joke or not.
In other news the entire marketing team at Smonet was just laid off for "unrelated reasons" and the CMO tendered his resignation, citing the desire to "persue other opportunities."
Be careful what you wish for… sayeth The Monkey’s Paw
just checked their website, link to this specifc lock already 404's, others seem to still load but for how long?
A half-decent core that would require actual picking is also...still so cheap. Especially in that quantity. Reminds of those $500 medical cabinets with filing cabinet locks.
@@popeter It's the ZNS-Y001, right? The picture on the website and the picture from a review don't exactly match but it does look the same. If so, all the pages I saw returned 200.. non 404 to be seen.
@@inflatablewolfie 404 for me presently, although the packages containing that lock are still up.
It's amazing how LPL's voice, tone and pitch don't change in his vids which proves his professionalism, but damn if I couldn't hear the disdain dripping from every deadpan word in this particular one.
Yep - and clearly a warning for other manufacturers eager to prove how good their high-selling, expensive locks are
When the waverake comes out I'm always like "Stop the fight, ref! He's killin em!"
"Today Smonet has asked me to set a new personal record" Now consider how much security their app has.
After watching hundreds of his videos, I feel like we're part of a club - LPL targets us exactly, not even new viewers given the context of his words. No bull, no fluff, just "folks, you know what I do, check out the balls on this vendor daring to call this product a viable security solution". LPL is a major influencer re: shopping (in a good way) that I scrutinize MOST things, not only locks, when making a purchase now. Less garbage purchases. Prioritize quality, always. Research, etc.
When I changed the locks on my home, the 1st thing that I did was pull out my trusty Genesis wave rake to determine if it was an acceptable upgrade.
you should scrutinize using your full name on the internet and that weird little portrait you have for an avatar. prioritize quality, always. trust your gut
I would like to see a round up comparison of smart locks and all features not just the physical key; wifi/BT protocols, different keypads, fingerprint, any special features like temporary codes, cameras, notifications etc.., general construction and installation methods. He could ignore software side but for setup he could just get basic burner smart phone.
@@Gnordlan I'm not going to lie, part of me wants to take a lockpick kit to one of those demo walls just to see the reaction to me checking pick resistance on a potential purchase... but I'm not going to buy one so it wouldn't be acceptable.
Best 'value for money' is rarely the cheapest on offer. (and usually neither is the most expensive.)
Congratulations to each and every one of the 40.000 buyers (a year) of this wonderful lock... 🤣
Nice of them to manufacture it with such a distinctive branded form, too, you can probably recognize it from the sidewalk!
Maybe they couldn't keep up with demand and wanted to do a little seppuku to ease up on the production orders coming in.
@@Nareimooncatt 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
At least they will never be locked out of their house 😅
I love how he rakes it faster than the "beep-beeb" can keep up.
LPL is a pro at angling those shiny locks away from his face. Its amazing.
As an 30+ swedish viewer of your work this made me think of a show we had here called "Plus". It was a broad consumption journalism show that included reviews and stories form the real world of people being tricked by companies and in the end of most episode he trashed an item that was really bad. This lock would have gotten such a trashing and been thrown with force in that show.
I actually miss that show. Every country should have had it's own take of this
The USA used to. The predecessor of PBS had a show that would, for example, show the difference between a bottle of Bayer aspirin and a bottle of store brand aspirin. The difference was: a dollar, some cotton, and 150 doses of aspirin.
Corporate America shut down that show (and network) _real_ quick.
"The Monkey's Paw" and "The Lottery" were probably the two creepiest short stories in my English textbook back in the day.
a lot of that edgar allen poe was really creepy to me - came off as satanic
They probably still are.
Oh man, I remember The Lottery, that was probably one of my first exposures to a story that made me set a book down and think "what the actual hell" probably in early middle school.
It was The Veldt for me.
@@AndrewJhikes Yeah, Shirley Jackson was really good at pulling the rug out from under her readers.
Even if the mechanical lock was any good I wouldnt want a lock that is reliant on an app to function. The moment that company stops supporting the app Im left with a useless paper weight
like Sonos but they were much more expensive than a lock
If that happens then you still have the physical key.
So not a useless paper weight.
Not to mention the fact that apps from these companies generally steal and sell customer data. Plus these apps are generally based on the phones Mac address which can easily be spoofed, as well as a number of other security issues that generally come with this type of lock.
@@Jehty_ and if you lose the key, just buy the wave rake from genesis set and all's set
That entirely depends on how the app works. Most likely, the app is only used to configure the lock.
Also, I don't think the app relies on cloud services - you probably just connect to the lock via bluetooth. So the app would remain working just fine.
There are some security concerns about the app to lock connection, though. It's certainly possible to make this secure, but I'm not sure these guys can be trusted with that...
The LPL talked for over a minute then opened the lock 4 times in less than 30 seconds.
Christmas came early for us fans this year.
I know!
Smonet Employee 1: How'd we do, Steve?
Steve: Three "not a fluke" encores and a parable about a monkey.
I'd really like to see Smonet's reaction to this. I bet they just email every content creator with the criteria "Popular with lock enthusiasts"
I am not a fan of "smart locks" in general, but when that smart lock has three modes of entry on the door, and STILL requires a smartphone app to set things up, opening a fourth, and wandering access route, it makes me shiver.
People put WAY too much faith in the security of their pocket computer. A computer that can be dropped, broken, lost, stolen, seized by police (with or without legal cause)... And they put access to their home, personal data and bank accounts all in that small slab.
Plus more. Basically the entire life is on that small slab. Taking away the phone is like taking away that dude’s soul.
Smart locks without backup would be devastating. But those backups we have seen so far might as well does not exist at all.
@@estellebright2579 Never trust a device to do a job that a key can do, especially as with the use of non secure technology like unencoded bluetooth or NFT someone can snoop and acquire your access codes. LPL has shown how it is done and someone with a little knowledge can do it and be in and out of your place without leaving a trace or a clue as to how they got it.
@@estellebright2579 Even worse it's the possibility of the company behind the app development discontinues the app or drops it off the App/Play Store. You cannot setup your lock anymore if you eventually need.
@@JamisCasusa in a nutshell, smart lock is a stupid idea bought up by dumb people who knows little about security. Leave the lock to be a lock, and improve your home security elsewhere.
Sadly, the neighbour just renovated his house with a card swiper at the front door. Sad times.
Electronic devices can also be backed up and password protected (which most people don't care all that much about, unfortunately).
Devices get broken or stolen plenty, and the most I typically hear coming from that is moderate inconvenience in having lost some recipes or whatever or having to reset some passwords (although there are certainly more extreme exceptions).
I can picture the board meeting with the CEO saying "since I'm assured by the technical team that our lock is unbreakable what we need is to challenge that Lock Picking Lawyer guy" and the look of horror on the technical director's face as this is going on.
While a nice mental image I doubt is was anything deeper then a quick data analytics search for popular youtube channels that feature locks. Basically this channel gets hella views so we send him product and that's it.
@@TheRyujinLP it is more than likely that someone thought that they would get publicity from it, not realising that since they are selling a product that falls to a rake attack in 2022 that makes it a very insecure product.
That particular flaw has been known about and dealt with successfully for 40 years and selling 40,000+ units does not make it successful, it means that the buyers had no idea that the product had little security value and were taken in by the slick marketing about app use, in other words a product designed to appeal to millenials.
The thing is that they design a lock, then have an overseas company make the cores, and probably get shafted and lied to. Once the stuff has shipped, whatever corners that were cut, there are no legal avenues. They probably promised a $10 core and put a $2 core in and pocketed the difference. I bet they are having some terse words with the manufacturer, because the lock looks like it at least made an attempt to do the right thing.
@@plektosgaming When I saw the keyway I expected it would at most take single pin picking for about half a minute. Then LPL pulled out the waverake...
the technical director: "I hear boss music"
Being a lawyer, he's so careful about how he speaks so as to not give them even an argument of a lawsuit "I think you have a pretty good idea what I think of it" 🤣
1:12 "unacceptable at any pricepoint" was kind of a hint though
He said it very clearly earlier. This lock is unacceptable no matter the price.
That is as clear as it gets
An opinion of a product is not defamation. "I think it's bad" isn't capable of a lawsuit.
Before I saw this comment, I turned to my gf and said something like "oh there's the lawyer in him. He doesn't say it rocks or sucks... Maybe he meant it's a good demo lock for a wave rake" 😂
@@Slothptimal This. I'm pretty sure it can only be considered defamation if you're giving information that you know is false. So him saying its unacceptable at any price point then demonstrating why he thinks its unacceptable at any price point seems very safe from defamation. They would have to prove he intentionally and knowingly changed the lock in some way to make it easier to pick for the sake of the video and then didn't mention his tampering in order to make the product look worse than it is.
A good first step is to find someone who will give you critical feedback. Good on the lock manufacturer. The necessary second step is to use that feedback. I guess we will wait and see on that.
Ideally you'd want that critical feedback before selling 40 000 units per year...
@@flipster7285 Pobody's nerfect.
CEO "So I sold all your desks, FTS Im out!"
Those lock companies were probably trying to reveal LPL’s face by sending him locks that are extremely reflective 😂
Your videos are the epitome of infotainment. Thank you for the regular knowledge and laughs.
masterlock is celebrating that they aren't the only company you're shitting on.
I do love it when a smart lock can be opened with a waverake quicker than I could unlock my phone and go to its app.
When my wife and I bought our condo a few years ago, it came with a Yale smart lock with a keypad and all that business. Naturally, to use the "smart" features, the app was required. I looked up the permissions the app "requires" to be installed on my Android phone. Sure enough, the permissions list is a mile long, just to unlock my front door with my phone. And, they share just about everything with third parties. So, I immediately removed the wi-fi module from the lock. Now it's just a lock with a keypad.
Of course the lock need access to your contact list, ability to read messages, and location data. How else will they keep you secure?
@@SephBane I've noticed that many apps also ask for access to your photos when there's absolutely no conceivable reason for needing to!
@@stevie-ray2020 They are just looking out for you.
@@stevie-ray2020 Androids at least - not sure about iphones - have the photos and storage as one permission. In other words if an app needs to store anything on your device then it will also have access to your photos if you let it. It's not any less of a privacy breach of course.
We all want to feel secure in our homes but if your not experienced in locks , it's nice to come to ppl like yourself for ideas. Please share your wisdom 🙏
Reminds me of the time my uncle got a new gun safe and as he was showing it off I picked up a little screwdriver and scrap of wire off the work bench and jimmied the lock in about 8 seconds. He took the thing back to the store that day lol
I like that his lawyerness came out and “I think you all have a pretty good idea what I think about it” 😂
That flat, glossy keypad is going to show all the fingerprints. You'll likely be able to tell which numbers people have pressed.
I gotta feeling that Smonet is gunna have quite a few product returns in their future
Getting a $150 refund is definitely worth a return
The sad part is this probably just sold another 40k units, I have seen it happen many times.
@@amb865 What does this mean?
Caveat - this is NOT a criticism of LPL. Your videos are incredibly interesting, entertaining and educational and I watch every one.
We see locks picked that are not mounted on doors on this channel (with a few exceptions - most notably videos on April 1). This seems (from someone who doesn't pick locks) like an easier way to pick than one that it mounted on a door, if for no other reason than it's a "best case scenario" for picking the lock (you can dictate the angle of attack, how you hold it, where you place your tools, etc). It clearly still takes a lot of skill to open the locks.
My question is this - How different is it to pick a mounted lock, in a situation where you just come upon a lock that you need to pick (or, if, say, you lock yourself out of your house, need to help a neighbor, etc)? Not for nefarious purposes, but just doing it "in the wild?"
When LPL opens a video with a 'wave rake and turning tool' you know this is gonna open fast!
I love the "sponsored" videos most. It's so hilarious when some manufacturer goes "what's the worst that could happen?" because they didn't check the content before hand xD
When LPL doesn't even have to say what he thinks for us all to know what he thinks - he's not mad, he's just disappointed.
It’s also to avoid a lawsuit. He’s very intelligent
Welcome to the LockPickingLawyer channel, Smonet company 🤭
"Welcome to the party, Pal!"
I seriously though about this one just now on Amazon. I'm glad I checked your videos. Thank you!
I'm happy. Just before you pulled out the tools I said "wave rake". And lo-and-behold, that's all you needed.
i think i could hear a chant from the Masterlock side "one of us one of us" o.O
My thought was is Smonet french for Masterlock?
Thankyou for the warning Smonet! (TY LPL for helping them to get the word out!)
😂
LPL is the first place I look before buying anything to lock a door or valuable up with.
I've saved tons of time using a nail gun to open trailer hitch locks.. 22 cent nail cartridge vs a locksmith trouble call.. lock replacement was cheaper and no waiting.
best wishes for the holidays LPL! 🎅
“The Monkeys Paw” was a perfect reference for this. I think they should watch your show because they must have been looking for some free advertising without doing their due diligence. All I can say to how fast that was is WOW! I’m amazed at how easy that was.
For Smonet's sake, I hope they listen and don't just ignore the problem.
Great lock! If you forgot the code and don't have the key, just rake it! Could probably be opened with paperclip and screwdriver as well. Very handy!
This was the master lock of smart locks
Hey, even Master Lock occasionally include a security pin by accident.
Even some master locks have done better.
No i think a master lock smart lock would be better than this. Not by a lot, but better.
"You all have a pretty good idea what I think about it."
Midship, direct hit & sunk! 🤪🤣
Lol. Someone just gave me one of these locks.
I remembered this video was in my feed and I'm glad I came back to look at it. Now I'm going to have to decide if the person will give it to me is really a friend! 😆
Regarding privacy: use a burner phone, or even several. Older models of all kinds can be bought for near to nothing and you can wipe them afterwards without losing anything.
That has to be a record for the LPL. The average time to pick the lock four times comes in at probably 4 seconds. That is beyond very good. Congrats LPL!
He inserts the wave rake for the first time at 1:30 and unlocks it for the final time at 1:55; four successful picks in 25 seconds.
I can't help but wonder if the genius who decided to send this lock to LPL will still be employed by the end of the day...
I don't think they sent LPL the lock. He probably bought it himself.
@@The_Muffin_Man "That story comes to mind whenever I get Emails from makers of questionable locks ..."
It was an Email, not a letter. He almost certainly bought it himself to test it.
it really doesn't matter, if they sent it, or if he bought it. The email was the trigger event and I agree, that if the "higher ups" of that genius get wind of it, that the days of their employment are probably numbered.
Plot Twist: The Email came from the competition.
On the bright side, they can always get a job at MasterLock. 😎
I think that lock makers just never do any of these tests and just go “yep that’s good right here”
They know that Masterlock's prominence has set a low bar in the market. They really don't have to try very hard.
When the manager has a strong background in used cars, or fast food, and doesn't talk to the engineers (who, to be fair, are probably in China somewhere.).
@@TesserId A low bar? It's like one of those hand rails to help you keep balance on stairs instead of an Olympic Pole Vault.
If it looks good and has an app, then it’s good enough - or so the exec thinking goes
I'd guess the feature list is generated by marketing, and the lock cores are sourced from the lowest bidder.
Sorry I've been absent so long. I've been dealing with homelessness, a venous ulcer with which I graduated to Hugh Glass levels of stoicism (with the help of the local house flies), and a total hip replacement (I have 2) that decided to become completely disassociated from my pelvic bone.
Now I am in the Hell Hole called "Skilled Nursing Facility" as I attempt to keep concentration focused on getting my wound healed (they seem to be only occasionally aware that I have this 80 cm^2 gash in my leg) so that my orthopedic surgeon can perform a revision surgery on that same leg's hip. Perhaps four months away, God willing and the creeks don't rise.
From their site .... just for a giggle!!! 💯 'What makes our products unique?
SMONET has a R&D team composed of more than 60 senior engineers. The security products have a series of powerful and effective functions to detect and prevent any intruders, vandalism and intruders, and protect the safety of personnel and property.'
Marketing intern at Smonet: “Any PR is good PR!” LPL: “Hold my beer... 🍺”
And comedian follows up with “Here’s your sign…”
Aww, the beer didn’t have a chance to warm up.
Very clever of Smonet. They have you talk about how insecure their current lock is, then release a brand new one "based on feedback from the LPL" and sell another 40k.
damn. that's a pretty insightful comment..... I reckon you're right!
The Dunning-Kruger effect is strong in this one.
"I can only assume they've never seen one of my videos before" < 100% that is absolute truth.
I love that you are honest of your review and only better the materials offered
When LPL pulls out the wave rake, you know this lock can't hold back too much
The thing about the wave rake is, if you can use a wave rake on a lock you can use other things with similar shapes. I've wiggled open locks with letter openers that have a very similar shape, which means you can use other more everyday-type items to open locks without having an actual tool like a wave rake.
LPL did famously rake a master lock with various items of literal garbage before.
@@Poldovico he used a master lock to pick a master lock?! Amazing! 🤣😂
@@ftniceberg874 I couldn't figure out how to work that joke in, thank you!
I used to open the lock on my bedroom window with a small screwdriver after I lost the key.
The sort you might get in a Christmas cracker.
Years ago, I made a wave rake out of a paper clip before I even knew what a wave rake was. It just made sense to me.
What I love most about LPL is he's always so polite even when he's calling something FOCKING SHITE!
Telling someone to go to hell in such a manner that they actually look forward to the trip is the essence of diplomacy.
For anyone wondering what that short story is, the major plot point is that a woman wishes for a large amount of money, and is then given that amount by her son's employer after he dies in a workplace accident.
I would love to see a video showing locks he approves of and how difficult they would be to pick or how well the lock functions
Someday there may well be such a lock.
Try the bowley lock videos
I’m not sure that such a thing exists
The Bowley warded lock got quite some (positive) attention from him
Soon as the video started: he's gonna rake it, isn't he?
I was subjected to "The Monkey's Paw" in 8th grade via our drama club reading it in a particularly lifeless, monotone reading with many of the "actors struggling with vocabulary they clearly hadn't studied. It certainly made the experience memorable.
The Simpson's Treehouse of Horror Halloween version was more interesting..
Was it what you wished for? ;-]
It's a good example.
Whoever picked it wanted a group of teenagers to perform it, and got exactly what they asked for.
"Now whose idea was it to send our lock to this CZcamsr?"
Maybe it was an underpaid development engineer.
Some disgruntled employee.
The social media manager, of course.
1 minute 30 to discuss. 8 seconds to pick. Priceless.
I feared from the onset that this was going to involve the "wave rake of shame and derision". I was not disappointed.
If I were a smartlock producer planning on upgrading my device I'd 100% send the old device to you. Then when I throw a couple spools in I could get a second video showing how well I listen to feedback and get all the good pr points.
Just be absolutely sure the locking lug is properly shielded, and make doubly sure the hasp is not shimmable. Finally don't claim a lock body back from pot metal is actually hardened steel.
At that point though, you may as well take the step to add security pins from the get go, maybe some variation in spring tension and you'll most likely see the lock opened in under a minute by LPL anyway. but he'll most likely say something like "this lock should resist an unskilled attack" which will attract cheers and plenty of sales from LPL's followers.
Or you could, you know, make a good lock in the first place. You could even engage with the security/picking community during development. Maybe not as glamorous. But just imagine how well loved your product could be if LPL featured it and gave a glowing review.
Whoever said locks are to keep the honest man honest hit the nail on the head 😂
An honest man would not require a lock to be kept from entering somewhere he was not allowed.
There are two ways of looking at this axiom, and it's dead wrong either way:
1) Locks exist to make money for the manufacturer and aren't there to keep anyone honest or dishonest. Since most customers are not well informed, this means they can be absolute garbage in most cases.
2) Locks are there to convince a dishonest person that it's easier and less risky to steal somebody else's stuff instead of yours. A good lock (not this trash) can absolutely do this, if it's integrated into a decent security framework overall.
The only reason you'd use an app for what is clearly an RFID tag.. is for data collection. The fingerprint pad can be decoded by torchlight, or even by your own house's security light shining on it, the fingerprint reader by a piece of adhesive tape and your finger... and the lock by a wave rake and some enthusiastic jiggling.
I wish you did these videos more often because not only it shows how not that secure some of these locks are for us but it's also free content for you! Not to mention maybe one of these videos persuades these lock makers to better secure their locks!
Ah, I can fondly remember the time (pre-LPL) when I still believed in mechanical lock mechanisms. Raked open 4 times in less time than it takes to watch a Pepsi commercial.
There were 1 or 2 Pepsi commercials that, back in the day, I didn't fast-forward past. So you'd have even more time to rake the lock open a few more times.
I love the flex of "Let's do this a FEW more times"
The Lawyer should have a list of locks that he either recommends or says are satisfactory.
Anything with security pins is quite challenging. He makes it look easy, but they're actually tough to crack.
he has! there are oms vids with "a xy lock i would use" or stuff. It boils down to "locks that use a version of security pins and are manufactured in high material quality"
He has featured a number of good locks in the past. the problem is, there's so much crap out there. He is trying to illustrate the sorry state of security in the world today and help people avoid the really bad stuff.
@@Tahngarthor I got some American Locks from pre-Masterlock buyout days, and that's what I use for my shed. As a novice / midlevel sport picker I find them pretty brutal.
Apparently they're still alright. Haven't been dumbed down so far as I know.
@@KF1 well i cant even seem to rake a masterlock #3 even though they're supposed to be rakeable. So maybe it's a "low skill attack" but apparently not low enough for me lol
Yo mad respect for not installing the app. I 100% agree with your privacy concerns regarding random apps.
This is the classiest BURN i've seen in a long time
As soon as the wave rake comes out you know the answer, we still watch to the end for the deadpan and well spoken scathing review that didnt need to be said. Keep up the good work LPL, I'll never buy a lock again without checking you havent done a video on it.
I'm raking all day
I love the part where lpl said "it's raking time" and then raked all over the lock.
The hardest thing about picking this lock was having to change the entry angle due to the core being upside down 😂
i figured rake, comb, or bypass. of course it would be the rake, as that's probably the lowest skill attack.
As soon as you said unacceptable at any price point I was saying "rake it, rake it" that is shocking
Proof that not all publicity is good publicity
They should just include the wave rake and turning tool instead of a key. Much easier to open that way. :)
I lost count when I blinked, was that 4 or 5?
😆
Wow, one of the rare times where the first pick was a fluke, seeing as the following ones were 4x faster!
Residential door locks without the bare minimum of security pins is an absolute travesty, especially when you consider that several of the $10-$20 locks you can buy even at your local Walmart or hardware store are typically immune to raking
So a while ago there was some research done into industries where reviews by experts are a big thing. The research (done by the New York Review of Books) found something interesting: if you're famous, then a bad review is bad for sales. But if you're not famous, getting a review AT ALL raises your profile. So even bad reviews were beneficial to the company.
The lock company mistook sales, for actual usefulness.😂
Au contraire, sales & usefulness are one-and-the-same. They've already made their money, why should they care what happens after you buy?