Che meraviglia il mio compositore preferito cantato da Dimitri con grande passione e bravura sarai sempre nel cuore di chi ti ama ancora perché un uomo così bravo e bello è un tesoro prezioso e non si dimentica
@@marcelpopa8018 Solo loro due?! Caro amico, purtroppo hai dimenticato di nominare più di 50 Baritoni che facevano parte del passato glorioso tutti sono anni luce migliori come Artisti e cantanti di Hvorostovsky . Saluti cordiali Nicola
magnifico controllo dei volumi e colori della voce. incredibilmente fantastico è ciò che si prova con un attento ascolto . meraviglioso Dima. la tua anima è straordinariamente viva nei tuoi canti e non smetterei mai di ascoltarti
I love this guys voice..... and his looks! Wow. stunning.. Everthing is about right.. This is a very difficult aria.. the fact that he does not put an A natural at the end.. is really not to be held against.. him.. He is singing the score!
Estoy entusiasmada de poder oír esa maravillosavoz, fue alguien que supo usarla magistralmente, estoy apenada de no haberlo oído hasta ahora, pero agradezco el poder hacerlo, gracias por haber existido y regalado tus interpretaciones.
I've seen DH in Rigoletto and Simon Boccanegra, and in concert. He is a superb baritone; others may be as good, but no current baritone is better. Solid technique - great Verdian line - and expressive. We are fortunate to have this artist appearing so widely in the states..
DIVINE RUSSIAN VOICE !!! ENDLESS BRAVO Dear Dmitry Hvorostovsky !!! DIVINE MUSICIANS !!! ENDLESS BRAVO !!! DIVINE Maestro !!! ENDLESS BRAVO !!! GOD BLESS You !!! GOD BLESS The Your FANTASTIC TALENTS !!! Always with a lot of love and light Your eternal fan Nadya Mirkova and all my big family, and all my friends from Sofia - Bulgaria - Russia - Europe and all World !!!
He sings this in a very lyrical fashion that I've not heard from a lot of the old singers, it makes him unique in my eyes. Definitely not worse. Please leave great singers of the past in the past, right now we have this man and men like him, and we should cherish them while we still do.
Verdi wrote 27 operas in his lifetime. "Ernani",opera in 4 acts, based on Victor Hugo's drama "Hernani" was written in 1844. It was a lesser known opera. But this aria of King of Castile from "Ernani" is one of my favoured, as sung by Dmitri Hvorostovsky.When Dmitri magnificent voice reverberates on stage, I can hear a voice of eternity.
Yes, Giga, this clip brings thoughts of eternity, particularly when H. sings: ...della virtù com'aquila sui vanni m'alzerò, ah! e vincitor de' secoli il nome mio farò.” (Like an eagle I will raise myself on the wings of my virtù, ah! and I will make my name as the conqueror of centuries.) The lyrics here may be about Charles V’s political conquest of world-wide kingdoms but they bring to mind H’s artistic conquest of world-wide audiences. Maestro, R.I.P.
Solo la encarnación de UN ALMA con esos matices sublimes pudo ser representada por este HERMOSO SER de Luz que reunía todas las condiciones del mejor Barítono con ese MARAVILLOSO color de voz
this is the great human honesty in declaration, the honesty is the most important quality human qualityn and in this is presenting itself and the following scene must understand
Yes, many times, actually. On Heroes and Villains, there are several of them. After all, you can hear it in Valentin's aria at this very concert. More than that, I have a recording where he sings a Bb.
:-) Please remember it's not just about the high notes. I think he just owns Di provenza il mar, Rodrigo's death or Il Balen del suo sorriso, not to mention the Russian repertoire. Please check some of these out, too. My fav Barbiere: watch?v=KE9OWvBRyQ4
Anche se il mio preferito rimane FRANCO CORELLI.....questo GRANDE cantante mi piace tantissimo......e molto bravo e BELLO......Cosa che non guasta mai....
Recordando otros tiempos felices, podría ser el sentido de esta aria, de este interprete fallecido hace poco tiempo, de un mal que nos afecta a una tercera parte de los humanos, pero que el tiempo suele difuminarlos.
Yo! Excellent! This is a fantastic aria, but quite evil to sing as that cello accompaniment is tenuous to say the least, and keeping pitch and timing must be extremely challenging especially in a big house. The Met Live version demonstrates that, as the stage and theatre are so cavernous he is having to watch the conductor like a hawk, and you can hardly hear the thready cello accompaniment. Here he is at his best.
@Baritenore those were all voices with a good deal more weight.. and heft.( and I like that too). .. Dimitri hasa medium weight voice.. and as such is quite flexible and lyrical.. In other words.. while I admire the singers you mention... greatly.. I also like this dude... I see them as different.. not necessarily better/worse.
Really? He's pretty secure up there. He is even heard in some of those "cage matches" on CZcams. If you don't have any of his operatic CDs (too baaaad! :-) ), try here on YT Figaro's & Valentine's arias, Il Prologo from I Pagliacci, I believe.... I can't remember all the performances where he sings a high A, can anybody help?
Great voice, but he gets a little too cute on things the way I hear that Fischer-Deskau did in his last years. Overall really fine, but a tendency to be too affected--portamentos where traditional they would not be placed. I don't mind the lack of the high A. I've heard it both ways and while it is impressive for baritones to hit it, this is one number that sounds better dramatically without it. As opposed to the end of Rigoletto where McNeill tossed it in and it was dynamite.
Maybe it' s just me, but we had Milnes who pretty much imitated Warren. & Now here we have Hvorostovsky imitating Bastianini:( Not a bad imitation @all. He really should sing the way he did when he won Cardiff's Singer of the world contest back in 89! There he sings much more open. It's got nothing 2 do w/him being older. Watch Bastianini's "live" performances her on CZcams & U'll C it's very similar 2 how Dmitri is singing. He's definitely channeling the man. 4 that, great job Dmitri:)
To me a great singer, the looks and the voice! But seriously Dmitri is a absolutely amazing. I can % Kauffman, what a tender voice. Love them both. If I had the money, it attend every
Agree! Dima was imitating Bastianini, but when Bastianini use his own voice, because his bass backgroud, Dima had to darken, and overdone his Tenor like voice to get something like result
На заре 2008 год, в костюме ,который носил ещё при Светлане,такое короткие,и десять лет назад носил, новый костюм сшить ,желание не хватает и настроение нет ,без Светланы,
ESTA ARIA DE DON CARLO REY DE ESPAÑA,QUE SE ESTA PREPARANDO PARA SORPRENDER A LOS REBELDES que se deben reunir en este emplazamiento,de una capilla tras la tumba de Carlo Magno...? Y EL EMPERADOR DA ORDENES A DON. rICARDOpara detener los propósitos de los conjurados.
I don't find his dark colour appealing in Rossini, either, when listening to him *after* a "regular" baritone. I love his Verdi, he was not a bad Don Giovanni, and I love his arie antiche. You asked for a high A... ;-)
¡¡HAY UNA ROSA BLANCA Á LA QUE UN FLORICULTOR PUSO TÚ NOMBRE...MUY BIEN GANADO...TÉ QUIERO **DIMA** Y ES PARA SIEMPRE!! 💖🎵🌺🎤🇷🇺🔔🇷🇺🌻🕊🍀☀️🌹🌼🌷💕🕊⚘⚘⚘17/08/2024 🎼🇦🇷
Ottima tecnica, suoni appoggiati. Interpretazione un po' giovanilistica, aliena dalla "gravitas" del personaggio (quanto meno in quest'atto, non nel primo).
He had to have been mic'd when you saw him. Don't be stupid. Listen to the two youtube clips I said to listen to. There is NO ARGUMENT that there is a difference. And his voice is like the Traviata clip. I saw him MORE than twice and at the Met. Don't comment on things you know nothing about. Your need to believe that he sounds great doesn't change reality.
It's not just about the high notes, true, but aside from that I don't find the basic coloring of his voice to be too appealing. After listening to Macneil sing this beautifully and cap it with a booming A natural this is a wee bit disappointing ;-D He's a good actor and of course, good at Russian.
No, you don't *know* for a fact that he isn't being mic'd. And I wrote that he is being enhanced. And opera houses have admitted to it. Look up the article in the NY Times where they discuss it and admit it. I have heard him also. This is not some unknown thing. Maybe you are unaware of it, but it has been written about and documented.You just have to bother to look it up. I also have posted a video on my channel where the audience erupts in screams because they hear mics. You are in denial.
@@frufruJ Non lo sapevo . Anche i miei amici Baritoni noti da anni sono tutti morti e nessuno tra di voi trova una bella parola per loro di più come Artisti e Baritoni erano anni luce migliori di questo cantante mediocre . no comment
That's funny because I heard him live also many times. At the Met etc. And his voice was ALWAYS very small and hooty. Perhaps you are hearing him enhanced as many of the houses are doing now. And they admit they are doing it. I know many who heard him early on as well and said it was puny in small recital halls. I am sorry, but the audiences are being duped, and your comments are proof of that.
You and your obsessive fantasy about miking. I've heard him live enough times-his voice is not "puny and hooty" He is an elegant, stylish singer, with great breath control-but the truth is, it is not a large voice-but outside of the Met I'd imagine amplitude would be less of an issue. If we are comparing it to the great Verdi baritones of the past he comes up short. The voice really can't soar, and the top doesn't have a real ping. Given the inelegant bellowers around to day-his fame makes sense
This is enhanced. He sounds NOTHING like this in person. The voice is puny and hooty. No squillante. Listen to the 2012 Met recording of Traviata with Dessay. That is what he sounds like, not this mic'd and enhanced crap.
I'm still waiting for your NYT article citation-or any of the many reliable sources you claim exist Strange silence on your end-but I suppose you'll continue your unproved nonsense elsewhere I wonder why I never thought of my great point before-if what you say is true and universal why do so many voices sound so meager when you hear them live-volume wouldn't be a problem according to you really pulled the rug out from your contention
I KNOW he was not being miked-I described his voice honestly. I know when you can you ban people who disagree with you-but provide -prova-instead of coming across like an internet maniac-put together with irrefutable evidence a real investigative piece-if done properly a real publication would love it-otherwise you're tiresome My other point would be-if what you say is universally true-and we're all duped why are the voices so small and inadequate??? size shouldn't be an isssue then-and it is
Look it up yourself. lol It was in 2006. People like you won't listen anyway. It is pointless to engage you in anything. You have a need to believe in something and nothing will change that.
What color! What energy! What beauty!
Dima's voice is a masterpiece of nature ❤❤❤
❤
Forever the one and only, our divine Dmitrii Hvorostovskii...
4:30
❤🇬🇷💙
Sicuro, bello, bravo. Era e resterà un Dio💗
@francescasassu2009
Non dubito , per i dilettanti non ci sono dei limiti …
La Mediocrità è la vostra migliore amica …
il vecchio
❤
@@eleftheriadias5119
❤️
Una Gran Estrella de la Ópera Internacional!!!
Che meraviglia il mio compositore preferito cantato da Dimitri con grande passione e bravura sarai sempre nel cuore di chi ti ama ancora perché un uomo così bravo e bello è un tesoro prezioso e non si dimentica
Who else as Don Carlo? DH was a King!
magnifico sia nell, Opera che nella musica classica! fantastico interprete! spettacolare sentirlo e vederlo! mito e re dei baritoni!
Il re dei baritoni !? Dove sono Titta Ruffo e Ettore Bastianini ?
Jeder hat seinen König,du Bastianini,wir Dmitry.
@@marcelpopa8018У Бастианини нет такой лиричности в голосе, как у Дмитрия, а драмматизм у Дмитрия есть как у Бастианини.
@@marcelpopa8018
Solo loro due?!
Caro amico, purtroppo hai dimenticato di nominare più di 50 Baritoni che facevano parte del passato glorioso tutti sono anni luce migliori come Artisti e cantanti di Hvorostovsky .
Saluti cordiali
Nicola
@@user-xj6nv4px3b
У Хворостовского был маленький голос.
Эго самый любимый друг это был микрофон 🎤…
Старик
In this moment he is one the great verdian baritone! Bravo!
Bravo!
Grande, unico indimenticabile!
Unique and unforgettable. lovely Maestro Hvorostovskyi!!!!
UNIC SI IREPETABIL....REGRETE PROFUNDE...I A PLACUT SI DOMNULUI DIVIN CUM CANTA!!! L A LUAT IN CERURI...
magnificent! what a great lost
magnifico controllo dei volumi e colori della voce. incredibilmente fantastico è ciò che si prova con un attento ascolto . meraviglioso Dima. la tua anima è straordinariamente viva nei tuoi canti e non smetterei mai di ascoltarti
Che meraviglia....chi lo fa meglio del meglio....solo lui dima....forever 🙏👑❤RIPOSA IN PACE MAESTRO 🙏❤
I love this guys voice..... and his looks! Wow. stunning.. Everthing is about right.. This is a very difficult aria.. the fact that he does not put an A natural at the end.. is really not to be held against.. him.. He is singing the score!
Καλλιτέχνης του κόσμου κ των αιωνων
Восхищение и слезы от утраты
Great singing !
Какая красота какая энергия ! Спасибо тебе Дима гордость России ! Ты наш любимый соловей ❤
Igen a csalogányunk😢🥹💦🌞🎼🎹🎼
Dima The Best forever!
Podría escucharlo hasta al infinito, grande, estupendo, DIMA, nunca me canso oír esa maravillosa voz!!!💙
Mi piace molto questa voce! Dispiace che non sia più tra noi. Un bel baritono che potrebbe insegnare ancora a molti. Grazie DMITRI, sempre con noi .
Наш Гений, наш Ангел, наш Друг !!!!!! Любим безмерно !!!!!!!!
i like this video very much:) he is born for singing Verdi:)
Estoy entusiasmada de poder oír esa maravillosavoz, fue alguien que supo usarla magistralmente, estoy apenada de no haberlo oído hasta ahora, pero agradezco el poder hacerlo, gracias por haber existido y regalado tus interpretaciones.
Grande Dima, que pena tu marcha al infinito tan pronto
I've seen DH in Rigoletto and Simon Boccanegra, and in concert. He is a superb baritone; others may be as good, but no current baritone is better. Solid technique - great Verdian line - and expressive. We are fortunate to have this artist appearing so widely in the states..
Çok güçlü ve etkili bir ses . Harika yorum . Onu dinlemek büyük bir zevk ne yazık ki verimli çağında bu dünyadan ayrıldı.
fanatastico!
Dmitri e la sua voce sono sempre fra noi .
Esatto 👍 ♥️
@@francescasassu2009 ciao :)
@@brunaazzurra 👋🧡
DIVINE RUSSIAN VOICE !!! ENDLESS BRAVO Dear Dmitry Hvorostovsky !!! DIVINE MUSICIANS !!! ENDLESS BRAVO !!! DIVINE Maestro !!! ENDLESS BRAVO !!! GOD BLESS You !!! GOD BLESS The Your FANTASTIC TALENTS !!! Always with a lot of love and light Your eternal fan Nadya Mirkova and all my big family, and all my friends from Sofia - Bulgaria - Russia - Europe and all World !!!
Extraordinaire…! Et une diction superbe, aussi
He sings this in a very lyrical fashion that I've not heard from a lot of the old singers, it makes him unique in my eyes. Definitely not worse. Please leave great singers of the past in the past, right now we have this man and men like him, and we should cherish them while we still do.
Hall
Que puedo decir de ese maravilloso baritono buenisssssimo e sentido profundamente su muerte 😢😢😢😢😢👏👏👏👏👏
RECORDANDO UNA EXQUISITA VOZ
MARAVILLOSO
Дивный баритон, такое душевное исполнение, прямо слушаешь и его голос обволакивает тебя. Спасибо, наш Гений, наш Кумир навсегда...
990
Magistral 👏👏👏
una bellissima sala,creata per la voce...
Thanks to Dimitri I have become 'Verdi-fied" ! (Our Maestro looks a bit tired in this clip . Maybe working too hard, bless him ) xx
Verdi wrote 27 operas in his lifetime. "Ernani",opera in 4 acts, based on Victor Hugo's drama "Hernani" was written in 1844. It was a lesser known opera. But this aria of King of Castile from "Ernani" is one of my favoured, as sung by Dmitri Hvorostovsky.When Dmitri magnificent voice reverberates on stage, I can hear a voice of eternity.
Yes, Giga, this clip brings thoughts of eternity, particularly when H. sings:
...della virtù com'aquila
sui vanni m'alzerò,
ah! e vincitor de' secoli
il nome mio farò.”
(Like an eagle I will raise myself
on the wings of my virtù,
ah! and I will make my name
as the conqueror of centuries.)
The lyrics here may be about Charles V’s political conquest of world-wide kingdoms but they bring to mind H’s artistic conquest of world-wide audiences. Maestro, R.I.P.
Susan Pezzino i
Solo la encarnación de UN ALMA con esos matices sublimes pudo ser representada por este HERMOSO SER de Luz que reunía todas las condiciones del mejor Barítono con ese MARAVILLOSO color de voz
this is the great human honesty in declaration, the honesty is the most important quality human qualityn and in this is presenting itself and the following scene must understand
Grande interprete❤
Yes, many times, actually. On Heroes and Villains, there are several of them. After all, you can hear it in Valentin's aria at this very concert. More than that, I have a recording where he sings a Bb.
Поклон!
Υψηλότατη,απλά!!!!!!αξία
:-)
Please remember it's not just about the high notes. I think he just owns Di provenza il mar, Rodrigo's death or Il Balen del suo sorriso, not to mention the Russian repertoire. Please check some of these out, too.
My fav Barbiere: watch?v=KE9OWvBRyQ4
The grestest baritone of all times!
Merrill, Warren, Bastianini, MacNeil, Cappuccilli and Milnes would like to have a word with you.....
😝
beautiful, hope i will be able to see Ernani in the cinema :)))) in February, tickets are already at home :)
Anche se il mio preferito rimane FRANCO CORELLI.....questo GRANDE cantante mi piace tantissimo......e molto bravo e BELLO......Cosa che non guasta mai....
Franco Corelli , tenor
Dmitry Hvorostovsky,baritone
Recordando otros tiempos felices, podría ser el sentido de esta aria, de este interprete fallecido hace poco tiempo, de un mal que nos afecta a una tercera parte de los humanos, pero que el tiempo suele difuminarlos.
Si eso ha pasado con grandes cantantes......que ni conocimos...pero siempre habra alguien que los recuerde por mucho tiempo....
Yo! Excellent! This is a fantastic aria, but quite evil to sing as that cello accompaniment is tenuous to say the least, and keeping pitch and timing must be extremely challenging especially in a big house. The Met Live version demonstrates that, as the stage and theatre are so cavernous he is having to watch the conductor like a hawk, and you can hardly hear the thready cello accompaniment. Here he is at his best.
Wow!!! RIP 🌹
@Baritenore those were all voices with a good deal more weight.. and heft.( and I like that too). .. Dimitri hasa medium weight voice.. and as such is quite flexible and lyrical.. In other words.. while I admire the singers you mention... greatly.. I also like this dude... I see them as different.. not necessarily better/worse.
OK I'll check some of those out. I'm not really a fan of his but I guess he's one of the better current singers. :-)
@frufruJ Dmitri said in an interview i have read that he admires Bastianini :-)
i don´t know why to insult H´s singing, he is great as well.
Saw him live twice, both Verdi, his voice was just like on recordings. Don't make up shit.
Really? He's pretty secure up there. He is even heard in some of those "cage matches" on CZcams.
If you don't have any of his operatic CDs (too baaaad! :-) ), try here on YT Figaro's & Valentine's arias, Il Prologo from I Pagliacci, I believe.... I can't remember all the performances where he sings a high A, can anybody help?
Grande voce, peccato l'orchestra non capisce Verdi!
Great voice, but he gets a little too cute on things the way I hear that Fischer-Deskau did in his last years. Overall really fine, but a tendency to be too affected--portamentos where traditional they would not be placed. I don't mind the lack of the high A. I've heard it both ways and while it is impressive for baritones to hit it, this is one number that sounds better dramatically without it. As opposed to the end of Rigoletto where McNeill tossed it in and it was dynamite.
Maybe it' s just me, but we had Milnes who pretty much imitated Warren. & Now here we have Hvorostovsky imitating Bastianini:( Not a bad imitation @all. He really should sing the way he did when he won Cardiff's Singer of the world contest back in 89! There he sings much more open. It's got nothing 2 do w/him being older. Watch Bastianini's "live" performances her on CZcams & U'll C it's very similar 2 how Dmitri is singing. He's definitely channeling the man. 4 that, great job Dmitri:)
To me a great singer, the looks and the voice! But seriously Dmitri is a absolutely amazing. I can % Kauffman, what a tender voice. Love them both. If I had the money, it attend every
Agree! Dima was imitating Bastianini, but when Bastianini use his own voice, because his bass backgroud, Dima had to darken, and overdone his Tenor like voice to get something like result
OK thanks. Just wondering. I had never heard him do so.
На заре 2008 год, в костюме ,который носил ещё при Светлане,такое короткие,и десять лет назад носил, новый костюм сшить ,желание не хватает и настроение нет ,без Светланы,
Dmitri is the greatest baritone ever born.You guys below can go play with wooden soldiers.
ESTA ARIA DE DON CARLO REY DE ESPAÑA,QUE SE ESTA PREPARANDO PARA SORPRENDER A LOS REBELDES que se deben reunir en este emplazamiento,de una capilla tras la tumba de Carlo Magno...? Y EL EMPERADOR DA ORDENES A DON. rICARDOpara detener los propósitos de los conjurados.
I don't find his dark colour appealing in Rossini, either, when listening to him *after* a "regular" baritone. I love his Verdi, he was not a bad Don Giovanni, and I love his arie antiche.
You asked for a high A... ;-)
¡¡HAY UNA ROSA BLANCA Á LA QUE UN FLORICULTOR PUSO TÚ NOMBRE...MUY BIEN GANADO...TÉ QUIERO **DIMA** Y ES PARA SIEMPRE!! 💖🎵🌺🎤🇷🇺🔔🇷🇺🌻🕊🍀☀️🌹🌼🌷💕🕊⚘⚘⚘17/08/2024 🎼🇦🇷
Ottima tecnica, suoni appoggiati. Interpretazione un po' giovanilistica, aliena dalla "gravitas" del personaggio (quanto meno in quest'atto, non nel primo).
You're welcome. Go listen to the dead ones then, if you know better than us.
❤💖
I guess when you're a "star", you don't have to pay attention to the note values!
Has Hvorostovsky ever sung a high A??
He had to have been mic'd when you saw him. Don't be stupid. Listen to the two youtube clips I said to listen to. There is NO ARGUMENT that there is a difference. And his voice is like the Traviata clip. I saw him MORE than twice and at the Met. Don't comment on things you know nothing about. Your need to believe that he sounds great doesn't change reality.
It's not just about the high notes, true, but aside from that I don't find the basic coloring of his voice to be too appealing. After listening to Macneil sing this beautifully and cap it with a booming A natural this is a wee bit disappointing ;-D
He's a good actor and of course, good at Russian.
what do you mean, "Boo?" explain!!can you sing like this??
Eunegin
HUGE LOSS
Mah... ognuno si fa bastare quel che gli basta.
No, you don't *know* for a fact that he isn't being mic'd. And I wrote that he is being enhanced. And opera houses have admitted to it. Look up the article in the NY Times where they discuss it and admit it. I have heard him also. This is not some unknown thing. Maybe you are unaware of it, but it has been written about and documented.You just have to bother to look it up. I also have posted a video on my channel where the audience erupts in screams because they hear mics. You are in denial.
Chicken. Listen to Macneil.
MacNeil is a god....
Non mi piace affatto .
il vecchio
Wow. He's been dead for seven years, and you still have nothing better to do than commenting on CZcams that you don't like him? Get a life.
@@frufruJ
Non lo sapevo .
Anche i miei amici Baritoni noti da anni sono tutti morti e nessuno tra di voi trova una bella parola per loro di più come Artisti e Baritoni erano anni luce migliori di questo cantante mediocre .
no comment
@@frufruJ
segue
Voi avete sepolto per sempre la vera arte lirica per far regnare la vostra dea - La Mediocrità.
no comment
il vecchio
That's funny because I heard him live also many times. At the Met etc. And his voice was ALWAYS very small and hooty. Perhaps you are hearing him enhanced as many of the houses are doing now. And they admit they are doing it. I know many who heard him early on as well and said it was puny in small recital halls. I am sorry, but the audiences are being duped, and your comments are proof of that.
You and your obsessive fantasy about miking. I've heard him live enough times-his voice is not "puny and hooty" He is an elegant, stylish singer, with great breath control-but the truth is, it is not a large voice-but outside of the Met I'd imagine amplitude would be less of an issue. If we are comparing it to the great Verdi baritones of the past he comes up short. The voice really can't soar, and the top doesn't have a real ping. Given the inelegant bellowers around to day-his fame makes sense
This is enhanced. He sounds NOTHING like this in person. The voice is puny and hooty. No squillante. Listen to the 2012 Met recording of Traviata with Dessay. That is what he sounds like, not this mic'd and enhanced crap.
I'm still waiting for your NYT article citation-or any of the many reliable sources you claim exist
Strange silence on your end-but I suppose you'll continue your unproved nonsense elsewhere
I wonder why I never thought of my great point before-if what you say is true and universal why do so many voices sound so meager when you hear them live-volume wouldn't be a problem according to you really pulled the rug out from your contention
I KNOW he was not being miked-I described his voice honestly. I know when you can you ban people who disagree with you-but provide -prova-instead of coming across like an internet maniac-put together with irrefutable evidence a real investigative piece-if done properly a real publication would love it-otherwise you're tiresome
My other point would be-if what you say is universally true-and we're all duped why are the voices so small and inadequate??? size shouldn't be an isssue then-and it is
Look it up yourself. lol It was in 2006. People like you won't listen anyway. It is pointless to engage you in anything. You have a need to believe in something and nothing will change that.