How to find a balance between welcoming visitors and respecting residents? | DW News
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 04. 2024
- Places in Europe have started to make efforts to regulate tourism. Venice has already banned giant cruise-ships from docking and unloading thousands of day-trippers in its historic centre.
Spain's Canary Island has been planning to tighten rules on short-term vacation rentals. Spain welcomed a record 85 million international visitors last year, and tourism accounts for over 12 percent of the economy.
But many locals say the booming apartment rental business is making their neighborhoods too expensive to live in.
Subscribe: czcams.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#tourism #spain #italy
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
The horrible truth is that locals can't even find housing thanks to the temporal rentals for Tourists. In Mallorca and Canary Islands health workers, teachers and police can't find where to live so the population and even the tourists will have a problem if they need the services of people who can't afford to be there to take care of them. They just opt to live somewhere else.
I support bans on cruise ships
5€ fee? Yea that’s really going to
Stop them.
Lolz ... That's politics ... Tbh, can't think of a better solution in the moment, without hurting the economy.
@@karatsurba4791 Hurting the economy when that city is full of tourists? If they are seeing a large number of tourists that instead of benefiting the city and its residents, they make more harm, then they should limit the number of people a day in that city. More like a theme park. $5 euros won't do anything, those tourists paid thousands of dollars to get there, that fee will just fill Politicians' pockets.
@@sak_5 Firstly, they are tourists, not vandals. They are here to have a good time n if they break the law, they shld be prosecuted accordingly.
Next, if the politicians are unscrupulous, they shld raise they voices louder or tolerate the injustice. That's democracy.
DW: When is tourism too much?
Answer: When they start to take selfie with the laundry you try to hang dry in your very own garden.
❤️
my friend had someone in her kitchen lifting the lid on the pot, they wanted to know what people was eating in that place...
i have also tried having someone standing in my living room telling me how cool he thought it all was..
the last i saw of him was he was running down the street with my dogs after him
Very apt .
?
>DW: When is tourism too much?
When you have about zero money income besides tourism.
I used to shop in Stratford-upon-Avon. They seemed to have got the balance right. The main streets were a mixture of tourist tat (inevitable) and local shops with a sprinkling of national chains. It was a lively, bustling place and a pleasure to visit.
Slowly, it changed. A soulless shopping centre was built on the edge of town, including one of the large supermarkets. The small supermarket in town couldn't compete with prices, and closed. This was part of the council's plan to eradicate anything but tourism from the centre of town, though, of course, this was denied. Independent shops near the former supermarket found their leases terminated to allow redevelopment of the site. They never returned. National chains either closed their stores or moved out of town. Consequently, the everyday independent shops slowly disappeared.
I last went to Stratford-upon-Avon some years ago. I had no reason to because all the shops that I used had disappeared. So few non-tourist shops remained that there was no reason to go. The soulless out of town centre thrived because the locals had nowhere else to shop. I didn't go because my own town had its own look-alike centre.
My answer to "how many tourists is too many" is that it's the number at which those in charge become greedy for more tourist $£€¥ at the expense of the locals. There is nothing wrong with tourism. Stratford-upon-Avon was a great place to visit either as a tourist or local. Tourists got a good Shakespearience, the locals benefitted from shops that would not have been there but for the tourist revenue. The place had a buzz that made each visit a pleasure. Then the greed set in and the locals were pushed out because the locals couldn't, or wouldn't be a cash cow on the same scale as tourists.
La dolce vita is ONLY FOR TOURISTS in Italy. We who live here in Italy suffer greatly from it!!! Tourists are so IN their touristy dreamy state as they wander our streets, they are NOT aware of them blocking daily life!! How can my elder parents and elderly grandparents walk through throngs of people with bags who dont make way for them and bump them in the streets. They make the super markets impossible, the lines too long, and take up all the seats on buses and trains, and in the cafes... how can we live like this!???
Don't you have apps for elderly people?
But how could you live without tourism? More than 10% of Italian GDP is from tourism and even expected to raise to 12% in the near future. Without that govermnent budget would fall appart
For each town there are solutions that will work for that town. It's a matter of limiting tourism, not getting rid of it. Of course people want to come as tourists. Find ways to reduce crowding, protect limited resources like clean water, and have the foresight to protect special places from overuse. It can be done!
@@gyulakocsis1269 So due to GPD of a country, we should compromise the daily life of its citizens?
The same is the case of the big Italians group travelling abroad. Let s not put the Italian in the good shape as themselves are doing the same whenever they go abroad. |There is needed a clear tourist education and better solutions by the local governments.
I lived in Amsterdam and decided eventually to leave, it's difficult to make a sustainable life there. Places I always dreamed of going I've decided against due to overtourism: Machu Pichu, Borneo, Patagonia... just sad that local governments don't do more to manage this
People are overly obsessed with experiencing something special outside of their daily routine. Because they can show it off to anyone with SNS. If photography is restricted, the number of tourists may be cut in half
I know the internet caused it, our little seaside town was never overrun until this new generation became obsessed with "experiences". Now they are even moving here because they can work remotely, and the real estate is skyrocketing.
7 billion people? Where has this guy been? Try 8.1 billion.
7 billion is the limit Venice can handle 8.1 bil is too much
😂😂😂😂 I guess I am amongst those not going, have zero interest in Venice.
Fully sympathize. The Trampling Mass Tourism...
I do not even go to certain parts of my own city anymore.
All of my friends have left over the years. Not just the cost of housing but the quality of life has forced them out.
It is not just Places it is also the People. The places still exist but the people that were part of the place have long left.
The places are now just the remaining shells...
To keep these places thriving, you need to invite someone either to stay or to spend money, ensuring economic viability.
My wife and I have taken over 30 cruises, but the increasingly larger ships are contributing to diminishing tge experience at many destinations.
Ban CZcamsrs from posting travel logs😂😂😢😢😮😮😅😅
That mayor guy's logic is hilarious😂
I like the fact that italy allows 1000s of illegal immigrants to disembark every day without having a clue about who they are but then wants to know exactly who are the norwegian pensioners that are renting an airbnb for 4 days in Siena or Venice. Consistency and common sense are, as usual, unknown in italy.
Less immigrants you register and more easily they can reach north europe, and well you cannot really trust norwegian pensioners, so they have to be registered
“7 billion people cannot be in Venice at the same time” 🤔🤔🤔
😂
“challenge accepted “-Barney Stinson
Jk😂😅
People are overly obsessed with experiencing something special outside of their daily routine. Because they can show it off to anyone with sns. If photography is restricted, the number of tourists may be cut in half👇
Tourism is meant to be fun ; this is more of a punishment at cost . Hopefully home is where there are no tourists.
Perhaps such tourism is more economically suitable than doing nothing or relying on free money from the govt/social department?
Hotels want to spoil it for everybody, nobody can afford a hotel as it is. These taxes mean only rich people can holiday
Hotels charge the prices that their customers are willing to pay. If the prices were too high then they would have no customers and eventually go out of business. So the statement that on one can afford the hotels is incorrect. You have to understand that there is a large market of international and domestic travelers that have deep pockets and are willing to pay prices that you may not be able to afford.
As if Airbnbs were that cheap...
@@cboy0394 I don't need to understand that, I just need these political groups to leave tourists alone so that everyone has an option
I was just there loved Tenerife pretty affordable prices for food and shopping
Like the Gringos that want to ban the Mexican Banda Music because they don't like it in Mazatlán.😂😂😂
We dislike the fentanyl that comes through Mexico via China, even more
❤️
@@danielmartin7838 >We dislike the fentanyl that comes through Mexico via China, even more
Oh so THAT's why US' head of DEA in Mexico have worked for cartels? 😆
Child, you can't haul tons of drugs over border and spread it until border patrol, police, DEA, FBI etc worked with you.
Locals want it banned too
@@danielmartin7838 >We dislike the fentanyl that comes through Mexico via China, even more
That's why head of US DEA in Mexico was working for cartel?
@2:02 Countries and location can stop ppl from traveling...remember Covid travel bans? Also, countries have Visas and other legal aspects to who can travel there and for how long. I don't understand her logic.
Love this host!
maybe 7 billion -1 because i dont think of going to venice
I’m sure billions on this planet haven’t even heard of Venice’s existence 🤣🤣
I have no plan to visit Venice
Tourism is an issue but immigration from peacful nations is great.
What we need is a way to track everyone's movements all the time to know when there are too many people in one place. Then, if they're naughty while visiting that place, they can get a negative score, and if they're good they get a positive score. Then when they get home, use that score to decide whether their choices align with your government and whether can take loans or get a mortgage and.... Oh wait I just described China.
85 million that's a lot 😂😂😂
Further.. if only people in large numbers did decide not to travel to Venice you would quite quickly see "Venice" trying to attract visitors again
The real issue is that many of these countries NEED tourism. I'm sure most of Italy's GDP is dependent on tourism.
The country as a whole does need tourism to balance the budget, but not everyone and every town is suffering to provide the funds the country needs. Ad campaigns aimed at visits to lesser known places combined with efforts to limit places where excessive tourism is harming the residents and endangering the special places that attract tourists can spread tourism to places it would help, while relieving the pressure on tourist "hot spots".
10% of gdp
I would think that any town or city, like any country, has the right to limit entry! And I don't believe it should be done on the basis of wealth, like charging a daily tax on day-trippers. The people who live in a city or town own it, and have the right to say, "X number of non-residents can enter per day, because of overcrowding, problems with trash and sewage disposal, and wear and tear on precious places." Finding ways to limit entry may be a problem, but the alternatives are bleak for native born and other permanent residents.
oh you can stop people from entering
I have literally sunken in at least $7,500 into the Italian economy by staying with host families, riding the rail lines, and studying Italian at their language institute. How absurd.
Thanks to capable politicians, Europe has no choice but to rely on tourism. There is enough information about which countries in the EU currently have the highest growth and which have the lowest. Only thanks to its past, tourism is and will be the most important economic branch in Europe.😂🤣😥😢
What the heck are you talking about
Only if it actually wanted to preserve its environment, it can limit the number of visitor instead of collecting the fee. $5-10 for once in a life time experience, tourist has no problem paying it. It just want more money from visitor and nothing more.
You can’t bite the hand that feeds you
The question I always ask myself is why people even go to a location just to trample on everything and take a photo and walk along the same path others in guides did. You can literally travel the whole world in 360° without leaving the house these days and mindlessly walking around won't enhance that in any way. Travel without interacting with locals seems like such a waste.
He did the math and 7 Billion people can't be in Venice at the same time. Really? Oh man I'm so distraught. I'd love to see his "math" though.
Canary/ Guanche Islands are in North África, near Morocco!🇮🇨🇲🇦
Always wondered why it doesnt belong to northh africa.
@@anom3897 because they're part of Spain? Same as Hawaii islands are part of the US. It's not that deep.
@@hellomycatingAnd "french" Polinésia is Europe, too???Even Russia is in Europe, but Sibéria is not!
@@suevialania and so is Azores and Madeira.
@@hellomycating Tell me! Azores and Madeira Islands are part of Portugal! They NEVER had native population, and are Next to the European Continent! Guanche/ Canary Island is near of Morocco! Sibéria was colonized and anexed by Rússia! And yet, Rússia is Europe and Sibéria is in Ásia! And I'm pro democracy and freedom! I'm pro Ukraine as well pro Catalonia, etc Putin's Rússia and Zpain are a problem! No more Imperialism and more respect for all Nations!!!
Solution: Tourist 5E to enter, Residents 5E leave.
2 millones de canarios
18 millones de turistas
11 Billones de Euros....💶
@@bobhope9317 los ves? Repercute en tu vida o en la de tu comunidad?
Te respondo: NO
Solo más pobreza, precariedad, servílisno y mala vida.
Hay quien se conformaria con eso.
LOS CANARIOS NO
Money money money...........................💵💵💵💵💵💵
I never want to go to venice.
Tourists obviously don't get when they aren't welcome.
This Mayor forgot that the tourists are the ones who pay his salary.
Visit Costa Rica 🇨🇷
Definitely
Too far away and only jungle to see. Southern Europe got EVERYTHING and more.
@@Just_another_Euro_dude more racism in Europe than Costa Rica
Why is the guy out of breath?
collecting a tax is not a solution to "over-tourism". Were the tax collected actually used on the city's infrastructure and the locals living there? I try not to go to the hot spots of tourism and at the "peak time". I feel sad that if my present in a place were being viewed as a problem. I can only be self-conscious about not being a nuisance and not behave like an entitled tourist blocking the path just for a photo and not insist on talking to the locals in English when it is clear that they don't speak English as a second language. The world is big, I think I can skip many of these hot spots
If they dont want my money, ill glady spend it somewhere else
The main problem is the people they want to visit spain are the people who now go to America and look down on Spain as for yobs.
Avoid Venice. Gotcha.
🪦
Stay in your country.
It is more like avoid dumb tourists stay at home.
@@lifeinaustralia6415 ?
😂
The question could be extended to mass immigration, as well!
I hate tourists I don't ever want to travel to a place polluted by tourism. When i travel I choose to respect the local culture if there is any left which has not been destroyed by tourism.
😅stop lying
I hate tourists
When I travel
🤡
It’s so contradictory, because when you visited a place not polluted by tourist, the moment you be there, it became polluted. But I get your point.
visit North Korea
@@Silks-😂😂
that guy has lost his mind saying that 7 billion people want to visit venice,oooh the arrogance lol
If it wasn't for tourists the few residents left would be in poverty, those places have nothing else.
That doesn't give them the right to change the countries' culture and traditions because of 🤮🤮🤮 💰
Not the right but the power to do so, unfortunately @@timmy-wj2hc
The residents will be living in poverty if they can’t afford the cost of living due to the extreme levels of tourism and short-term rentals.
@@timmy-wj2hc those places have subsisted on tourism since before any of the residents were born, in other words their culture and traditions are based on fleecing tourists.
@@timmy-wj2hc mama mia!
7 billion people dream about Venice? Um wait, who u are?😂😂 u need to calm down
Grasshopers=tourists
The arrogance of this mayor is staggering, perhaps he should compensate all the travelers who are told at the last moment that they can’t visit the city.
Remind me what exactly does Venice produce?
Why would anyone want to waste their hard earned money visiting a place where they aren’t welcome?
I will volunteer to help by avoiding this place.
Everyonemustseemunnarinkeralabeforeonediesitisabsolutelybrilliantandthehikingtrailsarespectakular
To be honest our planet is a beautiful place but humans ourselves were the ones destroying it. Big advice: Don't just travel on very popular destinations/countries at least try visit lesser known destinations and countries that has been lesser known globally. 😊❤
hello
Tax, tax, tax tourists. They have the money to travel they have the money to pay a tax. A tax for the environmental impact they have through their travel, and the garbage they chuck everywhere. A tax for the negative impact they have for the locals and a tax for their huge insatiable demand on food. Half the time it doesn't even help locals with employment because the tourist spots are all manned by other foreigners. Most tourists aren't even that interested in the culture it is just so they can say they have been there and then bore their friends, facebook/instagram follows with their photos of them standing at some well known tourist site.
Do yourself a favour, and do not go to Venice!
They have to worry more about illegal immigrants who empty their budget than the tourist who actually contribute to their economy. 😂
Both
howdy
Ban tourists!!!!
World. Wide. The. Eath. Carpet. Is now. In the. Toiletof. 8 billion. 👨🏾🍼🤱🏻💀🧟♀️👩🏿🍼👩🏿🍼. 🦘🦋🦘. 💰🇸🇦💰. 🎫
comment test.
But not the illegals?!
When are people too many?
There are already so many people, going anywhere sucks for everyone. Unless we address the ever growing human overpopulation problem things will continue to get worse for everyone in a myriad of ways. If you think tourists, and being a tourist, sucks now, just wait.
Isn’t Spain also having a lot of economic issues? I guess they won’t mind higher unemployment and 50 year mortgages next
Don't flatter yourself I have never thought of going to Venice. 🙄
This won't stop overcrowding, just a money grab... That said there are better places to visit, avoid the usual suspects and have a better time
If the tourists are Japanese, it never too much. However,?if they are from a big nation next to Japan, one is already too much
Better raise those birth rates while declining the tourism industry or Europe’s economy will be effected heavily
I forget… European nations are a lot more nationalistic than Americans. But perhaps I take my cosmopolitan experience of Southern California for granted.
You cant blame us. The world needs both
@@CommentinoCommentoni no. It’s just that democrats in America are always saying “we (Americans) should be more like Europe”…
I’ve never understood their argument because Americans and Europeans have distinct cultures and values.
But democrats don’t make a lot of sense most of the time.
Spain could always give the Canary Islands back to Morocco to solve the problem.
They never belonged to Morocco, so how could they give it back?
Or hear me out, keep it where it belongs, they don't even want to be part of an African country, just thigten the rules will should work out just fine.
the ignorance... they never belonged to Morocco in the first place
The Islands belong to me by divine right. You don't want to upset god :P
👍🇮🇨🇲🇦The zpanish genocide/ holocaust of Guanche/ Berberic people in North África! Double standards.....in Zpain...😢
The worst kind of people can be found on cruise ships.
U mean yourself
@@user-xp7nk9dw8d Why so mad??Guess I found the regular cruise user 😂.
@@EyFmS dude u described yourself
@@EyFmS why so racist
@@user-xp7nk9dw8d LOL, racist? Being a cruise ship user is a race now 🤣??
People are overly obsessed with experiencing something special outside of their daily routine. Because they can show it off to anyone with SNS. If photography is restricted, the number of tourists may be cut in half
Angry Canadians’ sentiment on the recent rising 14 cents per litre carbon tax hike regarding high inflation and high Interest rates, many Canadians can not afford to pay their bills!
They oppose raising taxes under any name such as 'Carbon tax' or 'Beer tax' or 'climate change'.
- The Canadian government now spends more ($54.1 billion) on debt interest while the health-care budget is $52.1 billion!
- Canadians are using credit cards more, as there was a 10% increase in their debt in 2023 compared to the last year!
- Instead of rising taxes and gas prices, export clean Canadian natural gas to the EU and prevent China and India and Eu and Iran's regime from burning Mazut and coal.
Stop arsonists from burning the forests. Last Year Canada got %20 of global forest fires!
People are overly obsessed with experiencing something special outside of their daily routine. Because they can show it off to anyone with SNS. If photography is restricted, the number of tourists may be cut in half
Limiting the number of photos people take would be even harder that limiting people! Reduce the number of non-residents allowed in town on any given day. Raise the taxes on air-b-n-bs and other short-term housing, and recommend areas around your hometown as interesting destinations. Make up your mind to do it, and it will happen.
re:普丁歷史性訪華前西方分裂中俄 經濟學人發表北大學者馮玉軍文章 普丁俄烏戰爭注定失敗 中國有意利用西方反俄情緒完成中國戰略目標 普丁訪華中俄將簽署突破性文件
中國有大量美國間諜賣國賊漢奸，台灣也是各黨都有。這些人大部份國民黨在唱衰俄羅斯要失敗菩京老了，中國跟美國正在合作打擊洗錢。民進黨以色列取得戰爭勝利，蔡英文老鴇母斯基滿意度超過五成民調。中共台獨中獨一家親，只要不統一！根本來說，各方各懷鬼胎，中共沒有做到支持統一的事，更多是在搞台獨中獨。美國只支持所有國家對抗，只要沒一個人統一。中共至今不能統一，在於獨派情結只要不統一維持獨立就是戰略定力。中共至今沒有拉攏統一，更多是在搞中獨台獨。沒有政策輿論支持統一派也是中共一大敗筆，更多是在支持中獨台獨。中共把按奈台獨間諜賣國賊漢奸當作是兩獨交流，一波人事換完不是位置變了，就是換個日獨美獨上來，沒有可比性!中共自以為周公反哺天下歸心，充其量也只是左手交右手跟台獨趙娘娘演一齣NTR，說來說去還是那一套中獨劇本，跟蔡英文老鴇姆斯基無差別，唯一差別台灣公司、中國公司還沒合併或是換成美國公司，中共這樣子搞下去還有誰要相信統一，不就是和平中獨?中共還是沒能放棄獨立思維，不獨不武不統戒急用忍的中獨理念，反對其他國家統一、支持其他國家獨立中獨思想!
re:中国-中东关系突变！阿联酋G42与微软签署AI合作剔除华为一切产品！同时从TIkTok撤资！美国商务部长促成合作明确全球合作者:要么选择中国，要么美国没有中间地带！伊朗干以色列，让海湾阿拉伯国家很不爽
阿拉伯國家科技、經濟、文化、歷史都用美國西方那一套閹割版，自然整個國家被美國西方掌控，而想去挑戰美國西方就是對主子造反，所以蔡英文老鴇姆斯基拋出疑美論、反美論就是中共對獨綠牛蛆蛙洗腦。奴隸不能反抗主子!美國西方科技、經濟、文化、歷史才是主子，所以日本、韓國、台灣、菲律賓、阿拉伯國家沒有自己科技、經濟、文化、歷史，就是當奴隸的下場!中共自稱不要別人桌上的菜單也不要別人做餐桌上的菜單，但卻在幫美國西方抓奴隸做成餐桌上的菜單!中共實際上只是在做只要我不是餐桌上的菜單，別人就是餐桌上的菜單!實際上中共就是在吃人牲，而並非統一讓其他人不成為美國西方成為人牲!中共所謂的不讓個別勢力成為獨大，也並非保障其他國家不成為人牲。中共除了吃人牲也向美國西方送人牲，所以美國西方、阿拉伯撤資也是同樣如中共所說不要讓其他國家成為別人的人牲!
中共的對內對外政策攏統、模擬兩可!自以為是世界獨立大國、世界中心!所作所為都是為了中獨台獨美獨共同體，以身做則就是要獨立!在中國領土不搞統一卻在搞獨立的中共，離經叛道、胡作非為!一心想做憤世嫉俗的聖公放飛自我!說一套做一套、說法跟政策往往兩回事，說這套做那套經常有的事!中國政權政策就是統一擴張，而中共走相反方向獨立自閉，把只要不統一獨立時間越久當做中獨共識，人民表率就是要獨立!中國歷朝歷代的國策都是要統一擴張，中共一會當周公、一會當宋公、一會當唐公精神錯亂不知道生活在哪一個朝代?公汁、磚加、學赭一個一個比誰更傻逼。政協一個一個比誰更灑脫，支那賤畜不是來看你傻逼、灑脫!這種程度也難怪中共跟台獨都一個檔次，民不聊生就同一個模子翻出來一模一樣!
re:一件讓亞洲國家都害怕的事終於來了，會引發怎樣的連鎖反應？（文昭談古論今20240417第1400期）
中國一堆電用不完，還能賣電，沒有後端是舊，那是西方造不出來太陽能、電池、核電才是舊的!你還以為西方領先中國?錯了!而太陽能15%-30發電把他比喻成供電不足也是錯的，太陽能15%-30是儲能，就算不發電也有15%-30%自給率!說法不應該以偏概全、用蔡英文老鴇姆斯基思維去理解這一個世界!
A Wumaodang 😂😂😂😂😂 50c for this for your social credit 🤡🤣😅🤣🤡🤣
Obviously, the person gets paid per character for being out of character.