Vocal Coach Reacts BTS The Truth Untold Live Performance Reaction
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 04. 2020
- Check out this voice teacher reacts to BTS The Truth Untold live performance reaction. This is a LIVE performance! So let's see how they do... good or BAD?! Now let's sing something! La La La!
🎵 ⚠️ Join live MASTER CLASSES, get BONUS VIDEOS, LIVE Q&A with Audrey and hang out in our CREATIVE COMMUNITY:
👉 www.SingWithAudrey.com
❓🤔 WANT TO IMPROVE YOUR VOICE FAST? You need the QUICK FIX course!!
👉www.SongsFromASuitcase.com/Qui...
⚠️ Grab A Free "BREATH SUPPORT" Course Video Here:
👉 www.VocalFreebies.com
❓🤔 WANT TO SING? ...THINK YOU CAN'T?!
Sign up today for private voice lessons exclusively with Audrey:
www.SongsFromaSuitcase.com/one...
🎥 Get my PRIVATE FEEDBACK on a video of you singing:
👉 www.wisio.com/sfas
📸 Get more behind the scenes footage and sneak peeks on my IG:
👉 / songsfromasuitcase
💬 Continue the conversation at DISCORD:
👉 / discord
✅ Check out my website for online singing lessons and DISCOUNTS:
👉 www.SongsFromaSuitcase.com
Songs From A Suitcase - Jak na to + styl
Do you like FREE STUFF?
Me too :)
Get FREE warm ups, song breakdowns & my top singing tips and voice hacks:
www.VocalFreebies.com
I really suggest you to watch ON live by BTS and mostly crystal snow live. We get to see their their true talent
I love your honest reaction
Sad. They have different version of this with different adlib and blending.
This version is better. 💜 czcams.com/video/YSXMp0h-NXs/video.html
Hey! Please if you love amazing vocals react to Dimash SOS, he’s truly a wonder. And also Jim’s epiphany!
I love your honest reaction💖
But i just want to say that there's no backing vocals on the last part💜 there's V and Jin who's singing that part💖 and im happy too because you said that V's voice is good and you think that was a backup vocals🥺💖💜
Thankyou💖💣
I hope you can react again to their songss in the future😅🤔
No hate🤔💖
I just love her facial expressions when V started singing so much that I had to watch it twice
hahahah!
same tho
Same! Ahaha
Same
No it's not backing vocals it's 2 persons singing at the same time,jungkook and jin at the same time
Ikr
*V and Jin in this video
she was right though. in the beginning of jins 2nd verse, that’s when tae lifted his mic to harmonize but you can clearly see when the camera is panned to a wide shot and jin starts there’s only a back up vocal in the first 3-4 words. I don’t believe she’s saying the whole verse had a backing vocal because that would be false.
At the end of Jin's and Jimin's parts, you can hear layers to their voices. The harmonization that V and Jungkook did was live. Please listen again carefully and don't confuse the two. :)
nanamutita army not sure if this comment for me.
Guys, it seems that we’re all talking about different things here. The reactor is talking about the layers of pre recorded voices (back vocals). If you listen closely, you’ll hear that there is another Jin singing with Jin. She’s not talking about TaeTae’s add libs. It’s all about the layers of voices that seems part of the instrumental of the song. If y’all try to listen behind their live voices, you’ll hear it, almost like it’s echoing their voices. She thought it was too loud, almost confusing their live voices. It’s just her opinion.
But me, I think otherwise. For me the additional voices are perfect and bring out all the emotions the song intends. The additional voice makes it really chaotic, just like the feelings of this part the lyrics, where the masked guy realizes he will never be able to show himself to his loved one, because she died.
But she used the "there is only 1 person on camera so obviously only one person is singing logic" If she is gonna stick with that logic (which to me is overly simplistic) She is gonna miss out on a lot
TaeKookies it was both JK and TaeTae that did ad libs there
if only jk's adlibs are jin's background vocals, then it's understandable
oliver wenzel // 🤦🏻♀️ she is not wrong, you can hear the background vocals echoing Jin’s voice even before V starts doing the ad libs. She even said that she noticed the layers in Jin’s voice before V even brought the mic up to start singing so she is clearly aware that Jin wasn’t the only one singing in that part.
@@denzelwenzel uhm but literally that what she pointed out is the layering and there was just Jin singing maybe bcs she stopped it after Tae's ad lip ppl think differently so yeah :) Just wanted to say that
jimin is known for a little drag and flick at the end of his vocals which makes him GREAT at singing sad songs 😭
The moment you said background vocals came in, V (on the far left) also started singing with Jin. However, camera was only focused on Jin so you couldn't see well.
Thanks for reacting again, sorry you felt like you got a lot of hate past video! I swear ARMY (fandom) never means ill, we are all just very protective of the boys since they get a lot of ungrounded hate. We really appreciate honest reactions over fake reactions though, so please don't hold back!
I recommend you listen to House of Cards Live if you want to see another pure vocalline performance or Magic Shop Live Seoul with all of BTS in concert.
Hey Giny Spierings! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
Yess💖😇 there's V on the left🥰
_Army here💣💖
Ouu yesssss house of cards plsss
🤦🏻♀️ you can clearly hear the background vocals come in along with Jin even before V starts doing ad libs. She was not wrong and she even points out that you can hear the layers before V even brings the mic up to start singing as well.
@@SongsFromASuitcase yes plz do one on magic shop!
You're right, Jungkook has a very breathy style. They all have very unique voices (from eachother). As Jungkook is the main vocalist he usually does a lot of the adlibs, harmonizing. On their Make It Right performance at the Stephen Colbert show Suga (rapper) wasn't satisfied with the harmonizing of his rap with the played mix so Jungkook did harmonize with him live instead for example.
6:40 that deeeeeeep voice that only Taehyung has
I looove deep voices!
@@SongsFromASuitcase If you love deep voices, I recommend reacting to Bigbang coz there's TOP.
@@SongsFromASuitcase plss see his other somgs u will be addicted to his voice its deep than ocean
@@japjap7102 Yeah T.O.P is a bass he can go lower than V
To appreciate taehyungs unique tone like u said he has sadly this isnt the song cause he barely has lines in it I suggest u should check out some of his solo songs stigma and singularity in live performances
It's pretty commmon for large groups to have one deep low singer that doesn't have many solos. Often times this is because he needs to sing more of the underlying base notes of the song. Once he stop signing then the music often will feel slightly empty. Idk if that's exactly true for BTS but that's very common for large singing groups
@☽ B T S ☾ But wouldn't giving him more lines, take lines away from someone else? It's not like V dosent get his fair share of lines in genereal.
oliver wenzel IKR Taehyung does get a good amount of lines... the only person who gets the least is jin and even then in the recent years he’s gotten more but it also has to do with who’s the main vocal lead vocal etc.
@@denzelwenzel Hmm I understand your point, but in this song only 4 members are singing. The song lasts 4:03 minutes and he sings only 28 seconds, also the song has no choreography, so he must stand still for the other 3:75 minutes.
It is not like that in general he receives too many lines, normally with jin they are those that have less lines.
I'm actually a casual listener. From the songs I've heard (quite a lot actually because they are good), IF you really analyze it objectively, V SEEMS to have good amount of lines in them. But ultimately this is because his voice IS very distinct. Distinct and memorable. So that's why most ppl THINK that he has a good number of lines, even though that's not true.
One minute in:
You are absolutely right and I am very happy that you still reacted to them regardless of what the comment section looked like! Cause I enjoy reactions like yours so much more than fan reactions and I'm sorry if that offends anyone but I just love reactions like these and I strongly dislike reactions that only include screaming about how good it is
hahah! there's reviews with them screaming?! Sounds funny!
React BTS highnotes and falsettos (Compilations)
By Smile Hoya. 💜
Hey sasuke Uchiha! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
@@SongsFromASuitcase Yes please!
Yes please do a reacting to this video
Okay first off, sorry if you got backlash the Army are very protective of these boys and to be fair in a lot of cases it is needed. What I find is alot of people will choose to react to BTS and for people who genuinely want to give them a listen Army are welcoming and fair, but for the people who are just using BTS for views, clout or just outright meanness then no, Army will defend. My criticism is basically your choice of video to react to. The first one it was as I said in my last comment an aggressive song, heavily rap and dance based performed on a teeny tiny stage on a big American show. They had performed their new single Boy with Luv earlier in the evening and I am not sure why you would not have chose that one to listen to instead. Now for the Truth Untold, I took in your opinions and I can see you had some informative comments and some good advice. I am going to comment on "your paying money so you want to hear them live" comment though as I find it not called for in this case. When BTS does a concert they go all out, it is 2 and a half to 3 hours of intense singing, rapping, dancing and performing. So this song would have come in somewhere near the last quarter. As a fan of these boys if they had background vocals(which is just basically their own voices layered in, as any one who watches a behind the scene knows) on the track I would have still felt I got my money's worth after the first 4 songs because you can guarantee they were going full throttle for all of them. They will do as much as they can live as they never want to disappoint anyone but no one and I mean NO ONE could do the whole concert without some help period! They are incredible people and that is the main reason they have such a following, oh and the music is awesome as well. Thank you for giving this a listen, if you had chosen one with the lyrics you would have been blown away by the beauty of the entire piece.
I'm glad you gave your opinion. Thanks for that!
Linnea Gilbertson. I totally agree with you Very well said💜
@@emilyeddins473 Thank you. 💜
omg u are so dramatic. If u can't take some criticism then leave. I knew it was a mistake for vocal coaches to react to bts because the amount of army that can't handle anyone criticizing bts. Literally it is their job to be able to perform for 3 hours straight and you have to get trained for so many hours to be able to achieve that. Literally every time someone gives professional critique on how bts's vocals were kind of off or not in tune, army always think the person is hating like no. If you can't handle professional criticism then don't watch the video.
TBH I've watched quite a good amount of vocal coaches react to BTS and their many performances. I believe that the more you listen to their songs the easier it is to differentiate their voices like I'm sure many armys can even read into how many members and who are layering the buildup. This is my first video of ma'am and I could see she didn't do much background research, I'm guessing to deliver an authentic reaction. But also she didn't criticize them. She commented on what she observed based on their singing and how much she knew them and so did OP. What op said wasn’t criticizing ma'am either. She just knows them better? We're not saying BTS never use BGV we're saying that we've only seen that in MVs and if they did, that's fine too. I individually found the video leaning more towards the entire "Backup Vocals" and finding slips of them compared to other vocal coaches I've watched who basically describe the technicalities behind the "vocals" so we can catch layers and it's useful for people who're in training. At first, I thought maybe it's my army ears standing because it's about our boys, but wasn't that. Anyway, I'm glad she's back into it even after the backlash which I know would've been brutal. And I just found more videos of her reactions so I'll check that out. It's good she's exploring them further! We need as many people to acknowledge this industry. Especially professionals.
I believe they felt the need to add background vocals in this song (only at the last part, where it picks up) because it used to come at a point of the concert where they'd already been singing and dancing to some pretty hype songs for at least an hour and a half, so I bet it's not only difficult because of the tiredness, but also because it's kind of a big mood change.
One thing I really like in BTS's vocal line is that the four of them have really different voices from one another. Once you start to listen to them more, you can never mistake who's singing what, unless they put some kind of effect in the voice recording for stylistic purposes. Often times in their songs, one of them will sing a section, then when that section comes up again they chose someone else to do it, and so the part always has a different and fresh feeling, not only because each singer approaches the lyrics and melody differently, but also because their voices are just so naturally distinct from each other. This way, their songs are never boring and never feel repetitive, because in all the 3 minutes of a song, there'll always be something new to hear. Though they're not what is considered powerhouse vocalists, I believe this interesting type of quality to their singing is what sets them apart in the vocal department, because I can honestly say I don't hear many voices like theirs in the market right now.
The one you pointed out that has a very different tone is V. His tone really is very different since he is the only baritone in the group, so his deep voice stands out. The other one you found distinguished was Jimin, who is a very light tenor. The tone of his singing voice is very high pitched (he is almost considered a countertenor, though I don't believe he is) so not only he can hit some very very high notes, but he always adds a lot of flavor to the songs, so whatever verse he sings, he makes it his own. The two who have a more middle tone (compared to the others) are Jin and Jungkook. Jungkook is the main singer, he is the best at adlibs and he has the most stable vocals when singing and dancing at the same time, from chest to head voice. His breathy vocals are his signature, and his tone is generally very sweet, as opposed to Jin, who has a very metallic, nasal tone. Like Jimin, Jin is also very good in high notes, and he always nails ballads (though all four of them are very versatile).
To check out more from each of them, I recommend:
- Stigma, Singularity and Winter Bear for V
- Serendipity, Filter and Lie for Jimin
- My Time, Euphoria and Paper Hearts (cover) for Jungkook
- Epiphany, Moon and Awake for Jin
For more vocal based BTS songs to react to, I recommend House of Cards, Zero O'Clock, Louder Than Bombs, Lights, Let Me Know, Blood Sweat & Tears, Hold Me Tight and Crystal Snow.
Hey Luiza Barros! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
and thanks for giving me the details on all their voices
@@SongsFromASuitcase Seriously, BTS is hyped. If you want great voices, listen to Bigbang. They're coming back this 2020 Coachella. You'll see the difference between these 2 groups. Big Bang is on a different level. Seriously, just listen to them especially Taeyang and Daesung's voice. BTS is known to lipsync and autotune (though their fans won't admit it! BTS members are good dancers, just very bad vocals). Thank you!
And the comment from gily mean is exactly why people protect BTS. Love your group without putting down others it's just toxic and sad. BTS are great all around my fave guy group in kpop and check out Mamamoo for a vocal heavy group they are awesome.
#ArmyMoo 💚💜💚💜
@@glymean5467 as a long time VIP, your comment is very disappointing. Real VIPs are not haters and we don't need to bring others down to lift BB up, that's just trashy. Youngbae and Daesung's voices are very different to the BTS vocal line, they're not in competition. I hope as a fan of BB you realize that they wouldn't approve of this type of childish bs. Please be healthy.
What I love most about this is that they have been performing for atleast an hour before this full of choreographed songs and then too still be able to continue like this is amazing
I love hearing people praising jin's voice (the one on the far right)! before joining bts he didn't have any background with singing, and he had to work hard to train his voice!
oh wow!
@@SongsFromASuitcase he really has an incredible voice! I loved seeing you react to them, but it's hard to find live performances of them without any of the backing vocals because majority of their songs include intense choreography and their concerts last about 2-3 hours. They use the backing vocals to give them a little bit of guidance and wiggle room as a result. But if you do decide to do another, please give a listen to the live version of Intro: Epiphany :) It's one of Jin's solo songs and he does really well!
Sorry for the people who say that they don’t use backup vocals, of course they use it. especially with dancing songs but I really love BTS cause they always have their real vocals too and you are right there was some backup vocal while Jin was singing but that was just a tiny bit. And I can’t blame them, their songs are pretty hard + or they are dancing or they are exhausted cause they just danced 💜 thank you for reacting we appreciate it and stay away from Corona
Yea Covid is scary stuff right now. Thanks for your commant and yes you be safe as well sweetie
“They are all probably high tenners”
Tae: Am I a joke to you?
Jkjk I know you haven’t heard the members long enough to know each of them by voice so it’s okay😂
They all sing surprisingly high!
Songs From A Suitcase thanks for your reaction. Jin does this triple high note in the song Crystal Snow. It’s awesome! Jin is probs my fav vocalist of BTS, though I’m an OT7. He’s got a very raw theatrical sound. At a concert last year, his solo song Epiphany went viral in Riyadh bc so many fans were impressed. It topped the iTunes Charts the next day. A bit about the other vocalists: Jungkook is the main vocalist, known for being the most stable while also dancing, and his voice is breathy, emotional, and consistent as heck! Jimin’s voice is a little higher, and really unique. I also hear him doing more...I’m not sure what to call them. He does these cute little growls during live performances sometimes, or throws in runs that you don’t expect - maybe vocally interesting is what you’d call it. Taehyung (stage name V) has the deep voice, with kind of an R&B flavor to it, and the greatest range probably. Anyhow, thanks for taking the time to react to these boys. Let me know if you’re looking for recommendations, I know a lot of their songs and can help in identifying the songs that include more vocals. I’ve seen other voice coaches on CZcams even comment on the rappers before (usually just stuff about how they’re producing diff noises, and how much tension RM has in his neck sometimes while rapping 😂). Side note: the rappers all pretend they’re horrible singers. They joke about being bad. But they’re filthy liars - I have heard all three rappers start singing for whatever reason (either just messing around, as part of a live performance, or even in some songs). All 3 sound good to me (admittedly I’ve zero knowledge of objective ‘good’ when it comes to singing, but they seem to be hitting the correct notes using a tone that sounds really nice to me as a consumer). So listening to the rappers sing might be entertaining to react to. Thanks again!
💜💜💜
Vocal coaches always love Jimin's voice. I am sad that many fans underestimate him so much.
Rain Cloud💜🎶🎶💜
The dude in the pink shirt was sick during this performance yet still put his all into this and that's one of the man many reasons i love him lmao
Kim Taehyung is one of the BTS vocalist. Baritone. Best vocalist and performer.
I LOVE deep voices!
Most of us are actually quite nice but there are some of us who are just immature or can't take it when someone says that they are doing something wrong. Like It's completely normal to make mistakes because from mistakes you learn and do better next time. No one is absolutely perfect. Yeah It's kind of sad that you had to experience this backlash but some of us can be a little too overprotective of them. But we are not bad people just some of us don't know how to respect an opinion and except that they are humans just like us and make mistakes just like us.Most of the times them being out of breath has to do with they're hard choreography. I ha e tried they're dancing and I don't know how they can sing at all while doing those dances like at the end of the song I just couldn't even stand anymore so I just welcomed the nice cold floor.
Multifandom Bitch hahaha! I hope floor was clean! 🧼
Thanks for reaching out with your understanding comment. I had a feeling that was the reason behind most fans. I just wanted to take a minute to make sure that I was still making videos that were supportive of what I want my channel to be about. Making a welcoming music community ❤️
@@SongsFromASuitcase BTS r the best kpop group live just saying
@@deanjbwinchester2995 nope.... I love BTS but it's clear that lot of other groups that have better live singing. BTOB EXO SHINEE SUJU etc....
@@rizataufiqurrohman3850 cringe
@@rizataufiqurrohman3850 None of that is "clear" It's all opinion based
Yes, please keep reacting to BTS live performances and/or compilations of live vocals. There are a lot of mature fans that genuinely love these type of reactions. I will definitely watch every single reaction you do to them. I just might not comment all the time cause I'm usually a quiet subscriber and I almost never comment
Awesome!! Feel free to be quiet if needed. I know i like to just watch sometimes :)
@@SongsFromASuitcase yeah exactly, thats why I almost always watch reactions twice, once to (when needed) answer questions asked or to generally give information on the video and once to just watch all the way through without pausing👍
Just FYI, when you are at their concert you can hear them loud and clear over the back up vocals. It's very different from on screen mainly because of how these live performances are filmed/recorded
Yea could be true for sure
Ok so obviously all singers use backup vocals sometimes but when you say “clearly there is more than one person singing therefore it is backing vocals” .........I just want to say that CLEARLY there is more than one person on stage. I don’t understand how you can’t tell that the other singers are singing with him. I can CLEARLY hear each individual voice as they come in. Sometimes it’s hard to tell if there are backing vocals but not on this one. Each member’s voice is very clear.
Check the first five syllables. That's where it should be only one person singing. :)
She did state that at the time the backing vocals came in only one person was singing. Tae was lifting his mic up to be able to sing, otherwise no one would hear him you know, but at that time only Jin was singing, JK had already put down his mic so he couldn't have been singing. Unless Hobi Yoongi or Namjoon was singing under the stage or something which is doubtful, unless of course you believe that more than them having backing vocals
I AGREE SOO MUCH
@@SongsFromASuitcase why criticizes use of backup tapes to help with volume at concerts? Makes no sense. All artists do it or else they lip sync. We know BTS are horrible at lip syncing. In fact it's a joke in the fandom.
But I never heard any coach ever criticize artists for using backup tapes of their own vocals for stage/concert settings.
In S Korea on their televised shows its a requirement by broadcast show that all use them. Artists are not allowed not to.
I would like to know what concert you have been to where backup tapes not used. By the way I am a 65 year old music buff who has been to concerts.
Your statement that when going to a concert you expect life vocals throughout a concert I find mind boggling. I couldn't believe my eyes at seeing those words.
Now if an artist did a concert lip syncing I would issue but not using backup tape of their own vocals to give volume & help with the tiredness that occurs.
Donna, you obviously cherry picked the half comments you wanted to respond to. The reviewer clearly stated and talked about how she thinks backups of your own voices have their place particularly in live concerts to build the momentum for the viewer, she also stated as they were standing still while singing that the backups were too loud and not needed to be so loud as to drown out the live vocals. When live vocals are being offered they SHOULD be heard before the backup tracks. Also she stated she is not criticizing, she is giving an oppinion, and yes, when going to a live concert people do expect live singing. Its not mind boggling to expect it at all. Before the technology of backing tracks all concerts were live. Do we expect it today for the duration if the show? No. As the reviewer SAID if you had listened, there is a time for it such as during dance sequences, however they were standing still at this song and as such did they really need them? Her oppinion no, as they are so good and with obvious power at that point in time of the concert. She was complimenting, not criticizing. It seems too many people want to cherry pick instead of comprehend the whole.
That high note was Jimin and his voice is SO amazing and so unique!! His voice makes me so emotional when I hear him 🥺
💜💛 😊
10:58
There were two people singing, V with the mint hair was singing too, you can see him lift his mic and sing
the one with the different tone is taehyung or v 🥺 hes known for having a really soulful voice
you should listen to his solo songs if ur interested 🥺
thanks for clearing that up. I thought those names were two different people.
@@SongsFromASuitcase oh sorry 😅😅😅 ARMYs usually call him Taehyung but his stage name is V
the thing is, they do 2 hour 30 minute - 3 hour long concerts with 24 songs in the setlist of which most are dance numbers (pretty much all of them except for this song and maybe one or two others). and their choreography is insane. this song is not in the beginning of the set either so you have to understand they get extremely tired by that point and need the background vocals to bolster them so they don't sound too breathless or breathy though they still try extremely hard to be stable (which is what you hear when they sing without the background vocals or when they overpower them). they are very capable live singers but their extreme choreography is what makes the background vocals necessary.
sorry about the hate though, some people can be childish and send hate without it being in the form of constructive criticism. here's my two cents on this though.
I like your two cents! :) Very valid points for sure!
Sorry you got hate on your previous videos. I was hoping you would make it to their more vocal songs rather than the hip hop ones. Here are some of my recommendations for more vocal focused songs plus I would recommend color codes lyrics if you are okay with the studio version:
- Louder than Bombs
- We are Bullet Proof the Eternal
Solos from left to right on the screen:
- Singularity & Inner Child (V solos, deep voice, incredible range)
- Serendipity & Filter (Jimin solos)
- My Time & Euphoria (Jungkook Solos)
- Epiphany & Moon (Jin solo)
Fans can be super sensitive but no excuse for hate. I feel like us fans have spent so many years campaigning for them that we don't know how NOT to be stage moms.
KiiKii hahha! I think “stage moms” perfectly explains it! When you get so close to a performer it is hard to hear other people say they don’t like something they’re doing. Thank you for being open minded and also thanks for the suggestions.
I plan on doing a reaction video maybe twice a month as I want to be more about teaching people how to sing and less of a reaction channel. So when the time comes I will be sure to consider your options above. Thanks again!
Please ignore the immature fans! Thanks for understanding how some people can be “stage moms”. If you want a little insight on the overprotectiveness I suggest watching “BTS Hardship” by XCeleste.
KiiKii o
idk i tried to hear what ur saying about the end part with the back up vocals but i still just hear jin singing with v backing him up, that's just me tho. Idk... v had his mic up too..
I think she mixed back up vocals with added music and beats that came at the same moment🤷
Sasha Yakubenko OMG SAMEE 😒🤦♀️
Check out the first five syllables of that section of the song. The camera shows only one person with a mic to their mouth BUT there are several voices singing. That's what I was showing :)
@@SongsFromASuitcase Nah, thanks i am good no need to see first cyllables or whatever) BTS gave us two day BTS marathon of their live shows that is on now! czcams.com/video/KDrb3kckUmU/video.html join! You will have amazing time! They are amazing performers!
@@SongsFromASuitcase Huh?? So becuse the camera wasnt on both singers, you assume that it's only one live voice? I dont really get that logic, but okay....
yAll i think she was right, there WERE backup vocals in this. Im no vocal coach, but there was clearly another subtle layer of vocals during that last vocals, APART from the adlibs that V did.
No it was the echo filter on their mics, I don't think she understands that that echo stayed throughout the whole performance.
@@JinsolLee yo yo this waa from ages ago but pls yall are going against a vocal coach here... most of the people commenting prob know nothing about live performances and shit...
Let's not forget that Truth Untold is an interlude. Just before this song they were basically dancing their butt off, running a marathon and jumping over a cliff.
Ha! Love your comment!
Hello! Fun Fact: Jin (@ 3:21 on your video) started singing at the age of 20 (when he joined BTS, he was an acting major in college). He's now 27. It would be interesting if you followed his singing (solo songs) journey. Starting with his Awake, Epiphany, Tonight, In Front of Post Office in Autumn (cover song) and Moon (latest solo song).
cool info! thanks!
Don't forget Abyss
Whenever i listened V's voice i got goosebumpss😍😍 i really purple his voice💜💜
You didnt need to justify what you said in your last video, thats what reaction videos are, theyre real opinions. I love that you didnt fake anything
thanks!! Yea that's what I thought too
Jimind high note wasnt suppisedly that high 😂 he changes it every performance 😊 u should see them rehearsing this song there is no back up vocals 😅
thank you for the explanation about the vocal, i could learn more about it :). you're right they sometimes add back vocal especially in hard choreo song. For this particular song if they use back vocal (if you said so, cus tbh i cant hear the back up because idk anything about music or singing lol) maybe because they're sing after dancing of 3 or 4 songs before this so the engineer decided to add back vocal. Also BTS really have tight world tour schedule 14 countries 60+ shows they sometimes got injured or sick (flu/ sore throat) in the middle of the concert if one of the vocalist sick they sing with the help of back vocal (also because it stadium) and decided to not hit the high note, we only hear the instrument which is we as fans really appreciate that proof they're not lipsync even at that condition, whether there is back vocal or not we don't mind it they're still give us amazing performance, choreo, firework, the energy, best experience of life :). Anyway thank you for the reaction, excited for another reaction :D
You're totally welcome! Thanks for watching.
Her:There’s only one person singing.
Tae:Am i a joke to u
😂😂😂
I cant believe I just found your vid! Thanks for creating this vid 🙂
I love this reaction so much. Especially how you mentioned why background vocals are needed in that latter part to emphasize that we are now on the climax of the story. And its very beautiful because it gives power to the melody.
Aw thanks! Josef Ree Cusi 🥰
I've noticed overall that they do tend to use a lot of back-up vocals, and they're louder than most, but I think they blend pretty decently. I personally wish they didn't do so much, but still, especially live, you can still hear where it's them singing over the vocals, you can still hear that live difference and I love that. Watching their live videos are my favorite. In this specific song/video, you can still hear backup vocals, but most of the time it is two of them singing. That being said, you were still very impartial about it, giving your own opinion and not in a way that feels negative. You said a ton of good things about them, which you're not required to do when it's an opinion video. I love react videos like this, because I like learning the 'why' to different things.
ARMY can be very protective of the boys, which shows their passion, but sometimes they're a little harsh. Don't let that get to you. When there are millions of fans across the world, there are different opinions, but unfortunately a majority of the time it's the brash ones that are the loudest.
BTS has a t o n of songs, and they seem to sing differently for each one, so there are bound to be ones better than the others.
Keep it up!!
Ali Dayne The beauty in music is that we DON'T all agree. It's often not based on facts but more based on personal preference. I won't always like the sounds that you like and vice versa, but by listening and appreciating other peoples opinions it allows us to become more aware of our own. Welcome to my channel 💜
I agree that most of the time they sing while the song with their recorded voice is play behind but that time at 9:00 when you said that their is background vocal, it’s actually because they are two singing: jin and V but when the camera show them you can only see Jin. But it’s okay you can only hear this if you really know their voice :)
Great reaction! I love to hear professionals analyze the musicians I like.
Glad you enjoyed it! Be sure to sub!
I love your Reaction on this Because your Detail I love it
V is the one who started, said to be one of the most unique voices in K-pop. He has a very deep voice but can also hit extremely high notes.
Solo songs: Stigma, Singularity, Winter Bear etc.
Jimin is the 'previous' one too Jungkook (the breathy one)
Solo songs: Lie, Serendipity, Promise
Jungkook, the breathy one
Solo songs: Begin, Euphoria, My Time etc
Jin, first one to build it up after the 'whispering' (oldest)
Solo songs: Awake, Epiphany
Easier version(from left to right): V, Jimin, Jungkook and Jin
I fixed this comment:
Jimin: Lie, Serendipity, Promise etc.
Jin: Awake, Epiphany, Moon etc.
By the way, this song has a pretty deep like meaning. It's based of off an old story.
So there is this guy who has absolutely nothing accept for his home and his garden of flowers. But then he notices this woman who regularly comes and steal his flowers to sell them. At first he is angry and he wants to confront the woman. But when he finds out she does this solely to survive he creates an unique and beautiful flower specially for her in the hopes of it earning her more money. He never talks to her or shows her his face, afraid to do so. When he finally finds the courage to do so he notices she isn't coming. He then proceeds to find out she passed away
oh wow! That's sad!
@@SongsFromASuitcase yeah and the boys really get in the feeling of the song they've been seen tearing up during this song and just awes me
and i think they do know what they're doing, this guys been training with good vocal coach's
even with training it can be a habit. but thats a whole other discussion.
I love the way you explain their vocals that I could understand even I'm a beginner 😍😍💜
thank you for your honest reaction to this video and all the points you made here make sence cuz this actually worth reacting( because this is vocal lines song) i hope we werent too harsh on you last time.
hahah! You guys are fine. Thanks for reaching out with support.
5:23 Te guy that was singing was our Jimin!!!!!!!!
Love the way you explain! By far the video I’ve enjoyed the most
Awesome, thank you!
i would love watching other bts reactions from you :D please continue, your commentary is very insightful!!
Thank you! Will do!
I love it your pikachu face when Taehyung start sing the second time!
hahaha! Never heard it called that before :)
this is one of the members recording a song , it's actually the way they record the backing vocals for their stages too, this one has eng sub . czcams.com/video/Ednrm-uykm0/video.html
and this is jin, it starts from 1.13 czcams.com/video/s9lMjOc-4HM/video.html
oh thats nice to know. Thanks!
I love this! Thank you to the people who suggested she react/analyze this song.
I agree with you that sometimes the backing vocals are louder than their actual voices. And the way you reacted when V started singing deep (his usual) was perfect. Hahaha thank you~
I love your energy of the reactions 💜
aw thanks!! Much love back to you
Jungkook and jin are singing, it’s not back up vocals☺️ I hope this clears the misconceptions
V has an amazing voice.💜
Anushki Perera💜🎶🎶💜
Jimin was in voice pain while performing this live so his high note at the end is normally more beautiful and clean look at bts jimin hide pain in the truth untold
I love their voices together! :)
And I love your speaking to technical speaking styles - very educational. I love all of their vocals and styles. Appreciate this video!
Super glad you enjoyed it 💜🎶🎶💜
In the truth untold they have BARELY any backup vocals which is why it’s my favourite song and i saw it live and can confirm they sound insanely good!
wait, don't get mad at me. But I think what she was saying is that while they were singing there were some backup vocals. Like, to make their voices more soothing and to support their voices. I think she understood that there was more than one boy singing at the same time, but she didn't mean that. I took singing lessons since I was 7, and it's been 10 years. I can recognize the difference between someone singing with bakeup vocals or with another person on stage. And, since she's a vocal coach, she knows better than me. I know that they were singing live together, and she also knew it. It's just that there were some bakup vocals behind their *single* voices. It's not a bad thing. Anyone does that. It's to support in case something happens or just to make the singer feel more confident in case of high notes. I've been an army since 2017 and I don't feel attacked in any way by her comments, so I don't understand why you would make a fuss over it. It's not a bad thing.
This ^^^^ 🙏🏻
i respect your honest reaction
And you should know that they are doing that after 3 hours of heavily singing and the dancing at the same time on stage like everyday. Even if they are on not on world tour they are doing this anyways too, these guys are so packed that you can’t imagine.
Yea I've been hearing how crazy their schedule is! Insane!
Thank you for doing honest reactions and not pretending that absolutely everything the boys ever do is perfect. It‘s much more interesting and genuine this way! I actually find it quite fascinating to hear what a professional in the field thinks about the talents/techniques in this band.
Also, please don’t be scared of the fandom as a whole. With any group that is comprised of several millions of people, there are bound to be a few bad apples. Those apples may be loud on social media, but they are definitely a minority.
As much as I love BTS, I am willing to admit that they are not the best singers that ever were. I sometimes wonder if all the choreographies they have to learn hold them back from becoming better singers. Ah, but then, the dancing is a big part of what makes them so appealing ...
SHHHHHH!!!! Watch out what you say! They are EVERYWHERE! ;)
Great reaction, I hope you won't take the negativity to heart. As others said, some people tend to be a little immature sometimes. 💜
Favourite voice of mine is the guy with the deep voice, Taehyung (V). Actually, nobody's voice ever touched me like his does but that also probably because he is one of the purest person if you'll get to know him. I literally sleep every night listening to his voice from atleast past 5-6 months. (Excluding some exceptions lol)
He doesn't always have the most lines or just the song type doesn't do justice to his voice so I'll recommend that if you can then please react to Stigma live.
Also, if you don't want to react to solo work then you can react to Bts high notes and falsetto by Smile hoya. It's a good compilation video of the whole vocal line.
Much love. 💜💜💜💜
Hey Divya Mishra! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
I really enjoyed Vs voice. It nice to hear deep voices sing too
@@SongsFromASuitcase Thankyou 💜 I really enjoyed your review so I would be glad if you will check out any of the videos I mentioned. :)
Before I even started listening to your reaction, I felt like I could watch one of my favorite groups perform and also learn a lot from you at the same time. I like watching these videos because I like the songs they sing and I like BTS. At the same time, I like to listen to a professional opinion on what vocals are healthy vs. unhealthy, ways to improve my own vocals, etc.
BEAUTIFUL! Glad i could help 💜🎶💜
I appreciate that you give your true opinion. I don't have to be worried that you're just complementing them to avoid backlash. Haha! Great review! 👍
Okay I just want to say this. The reason why a lot of Army's would argue with you on the back up vocals is this. So many of us Have been in the fandom since they debuted and we can tell each members voice distinct from the others while they talk and while they sing. Listening to their audios I can always tell which member is singing just from a single line. The part where you said Jin had backup vocals. Actually the back up voice was Taeyhungs voice and the only reason why I guess you didn't notice was due to the fact that at that moment the camera was focused on jin Alone. But the voice in the background belongs to Taehyung. To confirm there is about 3 different life performance to this song. There is one with Eng sub in which Jk was the one who sang the back up for jin in that part.
My heart did something when Jin came in. In the beginning. SHIT
omg i love ur video, i learn so many thing ♥️
Oh that's soo good! If you're a singer then i suggest checking out my other videos as well as joining my FB group!
don´t let the backlash stop you :) its those who actually wanna learn and understand critique that are important! You´re amazing
6:31 its BTS V. Your reaction is a representation of "he has few lines, but has great impact"
You should React to his songs too. Like Stigma, Singularity, Sweet night and Winter bear💜
8:58 that back up vocal is V too😁
Yeees the voice of V is unique and different, you should listen to stigma and singularity, he's amazing 💜💜
You know what? She's right. She have to tell her true opinion, not just what others want to hear. I love people that tell the truth. ❤️❤️
Jay 017J The beauty in music is that we DON'T all agree. It's often not based on facts but more based on personal preference. I won't always like the sounds that you like and vice versa, but by listening and appreciating other peoples opinions it allows us to become more aware of our own. Welcome to my channel 💜
There are quite a lot of vocal coaches who reacted to this, but somehow I always learn something new - it's good to have multiple perspectives on something :D
Glad I could bring something new to the table
Not gonna lie I had the same reaction to Vs part when I first heard the song😂
BTS V's Singularity and Stigma
Hey Familia MR! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
Thank you for your honest opinions, i like that 💕
You’re welcome 😊 💜🎶🎶💜
I am new here and this is my first time to watch your video and I loving it how you reacted 👍
Thank you!! 😁
Yes, the very different tone is V
I really like it! It's a great compliment to the group
Watch "BTS hig notes and falsettos complation"
Hey valentina gamez! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
I like your professional opinion and analysis :)
I appreciate that! I always love hearing that! Enjoy my channel
It's not back up vocals. They are singing duets. If you watch more of their videos, you'll see that they do use back up vocals to make the songs fuller, especially in songs where the dance routines are intense. But in this song it's a single person singing or two singing. They don't do that very often.
Pause here at 10:57 (you might need to slow it down) and zoom into Tae. You can see that Tae doesn’t lift his mic until after Jin sings. Clearly backup vocals for a few lines.
V IS UNIQUEEEEEEEE ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
👍😍
That V. he Has that Deep Voice and he sound Great
Thank you!
You're welcome!
I like your honest reaction. Its rare for someone who reacts honestly in Kpop. Just dont mind other Army's they're just protecting there idols.
When you say back up vocals are you talking about other singers off stage or the other members singing at the same time? if its the members singing at the same time is correct and is very obviouse so am confused a lil on what you mean.
it's other singers singing off stage. Back Up singers. You can hear them during the first five syllables of the section I mentioned. It should be only one voice singing there.
@@SongsFromASuitcase
they do not have backup singers backstage singing with them. It was all there voices. Sorry but you are wrong in this. Not sure why you are saying it should be only one person singing when all four have microphones. If you heard anything it would still be their underlying music of the track.
then the underlying music could have had the backups recorded into it. Backups are SUPER common. Either way. It was a mention to the sound guy and not to BTS. Sound engineer should have made the backups quieter in my opinion.
They have "guide" vocals. They recorded it. So essentially sometimes they are backing up themselves.
I’m not a teenage Army by any means but the reaction seems to be based on “gotcha moments” rather than performance. Seems more time spent trying to catch those times.
I don’t mind honest analysis. But, for me, too much time is spent on the “aha” moments.
Thank you for reviewing and reacting to this song. As Army, I appreciate that others are learning more about BTS. And don't worry .. I didn't know their names when I first started listening to them either :)
I'm getting much better hahaha!
Jin always gives me the biggest chills. He has such an incredible voice. Omg
So who's going to tell her that it wasn't background vocals and it was actually the other members singing over them...
You can clearly see taehyungs mic at his mouth when Jin was singing......
Really like ur reaction. Thank you so much for reacting to this video. I hope you will react to more BTS videos soon again :))
Thank you, I will
Kudos for you just for commenting on different opinions in the form of comments ! I do agree that the back up voices are a bit louder than maybe they should be, and again the lights can be ajusted better / all these are remarks about this particular video. Thank you for reacting :)
i like your honest opinions, it’s ok to have different opinions. some react for the views from army and it’s really fake.
more bts plsss
Im working on it. Probably not too soon but it will happen again :)
Could you please react to this next
czcams.com/video/Ednrm-uykm0/video.html
It's Jungkook recording adlibs for his single Euphoria, it has English subs so you can understand what he is doing. Not many people have reacted to this but I'm dying to see vocal coaches react to it cause it's just Jungkook and his vocals without anything else. Which is why I also recommend reacting to a compilation of them singing acapella for the same reasons.
I feel like you could make that a very educational video as it really goes adlib by adlib, everytime something a little different
Hey Christi Cobban! That's a great suggestion! I'm always happy to review any vocal videos that have enough requests. If I get more requests for this video then I'll be sure to review it for ya :)
@@SongsFromASuitcase thank you!
Kudos to you for being one of the very few people in the world brave enough to be honest about BTS. Don't get me wrong, I've been ARMY since 2015 and I adore them, but ARMY can be a little insane sometimes and are not open to any kind of critique towards their boys. I might not always agree with you but respect for standing by your convictions :) This is one of my favorite songs from the vocal line and it ALWAYS makes me cry. It comes from a very old Italian folk story. Think Phantom of the Opera, the Hunchback of Notre Dame or Cyrano de Bergerac. A love lost because of the fear of revealing it and being rejected, of what might have been. BTS is so good at so many things but one of those is emotionally expressing the mood of their songs. Both V and Jimin have very unique tones to their voices. V is deep and rich and Jimin is high and almost child like. They can both blend with each other like no other. "House of Cards" is another good song from the vocal line. Finally, BTS does use backing tracks. They use it instead of having backup singers and they use when when they are doing a particularly difficult dance move. I think most people don't understand that the backing tracks are not used instead of singing live, they are used in harmony with singing live. When you are at their concerts it's very clear to hear the difference between the backing track and the live mic. BTS does that on purpose to shut down the haters that say they lip synch.
I see that others have said this but I feel compelled to say it also...those of us who follow kpop (like myself, 10 years now) are well aware how backtracks are used in the industry. It is true that multiple layering of their voices occurs in recordings (as with their current album, sometimes they even have a gospel choir singing backup). But: just because the camera does not show people singing live simultaneously does NOT mean they are not singing live simultaneously. They are not only talented, they are professional and skilled at their craft. They know how to do this.
Check out the first five syllables of that section of the song. The camera shows only one person with a mic to their mouth BUT there are several voices singing. That's what I was showing :)
@@SongsFromASuitcase with respect, I've already said I understand how backing tracks are used in kpop. I promise, I do. BTS is not my first rodeo, not even my first kpop concert. I'm saying, they deserve credit for the on-stage harmonies of which they are quite capable, and this song has that too.