Real Pilot Story from the Field: No Go-Around - A lesson from the Backcountry
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 08. 2019
- Link to certificate of completion and ASI transcript: bit.ly/RPSNoGoAroundCert
Backcountry flying is mesmerizing and rewarding, but it also presents unique challenges. For example, exploring a remote airstrip-especially a no go-around field surrounded by high terrain-requires that pilots conduct thorough briefings and perform extra planning before committing to the flight. Join the Air Safety Institute’s executive director Richard McSpadden in "No Go-Around" as he speaks with four experienced pilots who discuss lessons learned from a flight that went terribly wrong.
#Backcountry #Flying
Five absolutely wonderful human beings, able to speak truthfully without any fear of feeling foolish, for the betterment of their community. Thank you, Todd, for having the stones to be so honest and forthcoming, and thank you Richard for the respectful and professional way you conducted this interview. I love the way you guys paid it forward: Todd, you had angels looking out for you that day, and by sharing your story, you will certainly save more lives.
I'm not even a pilot, but that was an amazing, educational video. Glad it turned out well and I'm impressed with everyone's professionalism and commitment to helping other pilots.
As a student pilot at the ripe old age of 57, I just want to thank all involved with this accident for their willingness to share and discuss it with us. I have found it extremely valuable to now add the unexpected stall training to my current stall training, again, as a student pilot working on my PPL... Again Thnx...
Nice to know that!
I am 35 and enrolled as SPL...
I can only guess as a non-pilot that stalling must be a bit like falling? Scary while trying to operate machinery. Could even have a natural reaction to put your hands on the frame to stop your fall of some other actions.
A lot of people start their PPL at the age of 59 to 64 , once they are only working part-time, they learn a lot slower than if 24 to 25 years old, but it's still very doable. As with everything with age, balance start to go, try standing on one leg with your arms out and close your eyes and try to stay balance, then open eyes and try to balance on one leg while trying to put a sock on your other free foot. Continue to do balance training at advanced ages. Walk, exercise and balance training along with a diet that doesn't lead you to diabetes and you'll be a better pilot. Get instrument rated too so you can get out of the soup -- balance training even more important.
Theses videos are priceless. Very sobering to hear where it went wrong from experienced pilots. Thank you.
And THIS is why I, an aspiring pilot, binge watch Air Disasters every chance I get.
@@darkdragonfire I would highly recommend watching Probable Cause. These stories are great to listen to but if you really want to learn something go watch Dan. Obviously NOT everyone likes his style or his straight to the point NO bs but it's better than pushing up daisy's. If they are even capable of finding enough of you to be able to.
@@CJE2007.5 thanks for the recommendation! I will go watch that.
One advice for ppl who want to land on no go around strips: Get a glider license, or at least take some glider hours before you go to these strips. This teaches you to fully commit to every landing you do in future, because there is no other option.
So when you aproach a no go around strip, Change your mindset to glider flying, your throttle lever becomes the spoiler Lever, and you will be fine.
I wholeheartedly agree. I got my Glider License first and it's made an enormous impact on how I fly and how I deal with landings and setting up my patterns.
I'm just a truck driver and I can totally understand this. Great advice!
Disclosure: I have flown a simulator once lol
Thanks, I will ask my son about glider. He learned first in TN. He just got his water rating this spring.
SPLASH!
One can learn to commit to a one way strip without glider hours. Just train to nail landings, on every landing. Don’t be lazy on accuracy.
Chelsea "Sully" Sullenberger III, the US Airways pilot who pulled off a safe splashdown in the Hudson River, was a flight instructor, a pilot in the Air Force and, importantly, a certified glider pilot.
Excellent point about not just stall training, but departure/spin training by an instructor who can work you into a stall/spin scenario without your being aware it's going to happen. It didn't feel like a freaking *benefit* at the moment I found myself unexpectedly in a spinning airplane with a laughing instructor - he found stuff like that *thoroughly amusing* - but once I realized fully what had just happened, I laughed too. And it stays with you. Wonderful video. Thank you!
That is why Spin Training for all pilots is so important. Its like simulated Boxing. You can get a false sense of capability by faking it and get into a painful fight due you though, hey I can do this to that tough guy I dont like!! Then oh wait, Ouchhh!!
When I worked at a major electric utility we did a lot of remote site work, so we invited a local SAR organization in to teach us. They introduced us to those GPS emergency alerters and highly recommended them. Now I see why.
This hits close to home. Last month I nearly stalled after a botched go around from a high density altitude mountain strip. Pointing the nose at the ground 50ft away to recover was one of the hardest things I've ever done.
Similarly to this story, I had not adequately prepared myself for such a challenging strip. I also was not proficient at go-arounds as most of my recent flying had been IFR training.
Glad you are A OKAY 😊
Good recovery man , flight 447 could’ve used you .
WOW, that had to be one terrifying moment! Glad you made it out safely. 👍
I was admiring how open and honest this self-criticism was. Then, I looked at the name and realized it was apparently written by a woman. Hate to be sexist, but OF COURSE it was! A guy would have blamed the plane!🤣
Hello, this is very interesting stuff I recently learned about in another video! I don't fly or anything...
So you were at a loss of power at a high density airport and had to overcome ur instinct to push toward the ground to gain speed to climb is what I'm gathering...
Takes my breath away to have experiences like this to learn from going into aviation. My favorite line, "Are pilot and machine ready for this mission?". One that I will hold close for life.
This channel has saved lives. Please keep up the good work.
Thanks to all involved for sharing. We can all learn from each other.
My son had 15000 hours of flying different air craft, his baby is his 152 he built with Dad and Uncle. I bought him a first aid kit with flares and he has never crashed, lost a door but landed fine. This is a video that should go up on ALL Cessna planes such a Cubs and little bugs such as his. He has a piper needing a engine sitting in his hanger, engine hought just taking his time as he works full-time. The piper I will worry I think more. Thanks Todd for hanging in there. Guntersville Airport, Alabama, you can call and connect with him. Leaving message using Foxie Dog. He will know. Thanks again. Fly safe.
I can't begin to tell you how valuable this video is. It's also a relief to see that Todd has recovered and flying again. No doubt this will indirectly save someones life. There are so many valuable lessons in this not quite 30m video.
We are definitely not trained enough on the dreaded stall spin scenario. I have never experienced it but I know I was close back in the mid 80's (it's burned into my memory). I had way too much left rudder in on a left base to final turn, trying to force the aircraft to line up. I still remember the feeling of seeing the ball so far out of where it was supposed to be and realizing and way too much bank. Thankfully I corrected the rudder, rolled wings level, and went around. A few weeks later I signed up for spin training. It showed me how violent and disorienting the entry is. It's on me to fly the aircraft and keep it coordinated.
Pilots today are blessed to have this kind of resource. Kudos and best wishes to everyone that was involved.
The "helmet question", and the inertia reel harness attached to the fuselage STC were extremely interesting.
Another great video from the ASI. Thanks for producing this and thanks guys for sharing the story.
I look back on some of the situations I've experienced in light aircraft in my 50yrs of flying and realise many dangers that I had little awareness of at the time. It's so much easier now to avail yourself of good information. It's one thing to read accident reports, but quite another to see these guys relating their experience. When he described that wing drop my stomach lurched with the aeroplane! Thank you sirs.
1. He is a lucky man. It was not his time to go.
2. The right trio of friends on scene with the right tools, training, communication. Incredibly so!
3. Very proud and grateful of these gents and ASI for creating a useful step by step vlog of events so others can be more prepared. At LEAST take pause. Some times things do not go as planned
4. Know your limits, your airplanes limits and don't exceed them. Your responsibility is to get home safe, not to land your where friends landed (Monday quarterback stuff, sorry)
Thanks fir putting this up. Glad he is alive and seemingly well
What was missing was a pilot briefing about this demanding strip. At the top of the list should have been that this is a NO go-around strip, and a go-around IS NOT an option. If the pilot was uncomfortable with this, DON'T GO! Sometimes less experienced pilots get sucked into doing things they are not qualified to do.
Love watching Ed Harris do these interviews .......
Dude, what's wrong with you? You missed Eugene Levy!
@@jshuffield HA!! I couldn't get over just how much he looked (and even his mannerisms!) just like Eugene! And the host - spot on Ed Harris! 🤣👍
you made me do a double take.
Lol
Funny, I was thinking Dick Cavett, but then I was mainly listening.
I remember my instructor taking me up for spin recovery training, and me thinking "oh no, why?". But when he took the airplane into a first spin, I was so completely disoriented and in some sort of shock, that it made me unable to do anything but stare at the ground in front (!) of me. All he asked me to do was to report the spin direction, and count the revolutions. I wasn't even able to do just that. My conclusion: if I had encountered this situation at a low altitude, unprepared, I would certainly have died.
I recently learned that spin recovery (and even aerobatics) isn't part anymore of commercial pilot training (I personally know a commercial pilot that had his training less than 10 years ago, and he never did this during his training), because of cost arguments. I think this is a giant mistake. Basic flying is an essential part of pilot training. I started with gliders, and as already mentioned here by others, it is such a great experience and preparation for powered flight. It has learned me a lot (the spin recovery training was part of my glider license training, it wasn't in the PPL training later on).
When I had to practice engine out landings later on, I was totally at ease, because I learned to land without an engine before I learned it with an engine. You leanr about energy management before you even know what that means. In fact, glider training should be part of any pilot training.
To finish my story: after I-don't-know-how-many spins, I was able to do them however the instructor wanted, he even flipped the aircraft over to get it into a spin, I was "comfortable" with it. And years later, while demonstrating power-on stalls to an instructor, in some crosswind, when a wing dropped, I still had the reflex of using the rudder to correct (which impressed him).
I dont think mandatory spin training would not increase safety. With powered aircraft fatal stall/spin accidents usually happen at very low altitude where recovery isnt an option anyways (unless you know whats going on immediately and have lightning fast reflexes, which cant be expected when a pilot is too distracted to even watch his airspeed). At altitude where recovery would be a realistic option spins basically never happen in powered aircraft, so therefore i dont really see the point.
In gliders its quite different, as they also occasionally fly low at higher altitude to take advantage of thermals, so there is a realistic chance a glider might get into an involuntary spin at altitude where recovery is definetly a realistic option, spin training makes sense here.
Personally, i think avoidance is the best tool and the evidence seems to support that point as well. Stall/spin accidents are basically unheard of in commercial aviation, not because there is spin training in 737s and A320s, but because they have strict minimas and avoid circumstances that could potentially lead there. If we hold ourselves to similar standards by flying with adequate safety margins we can also avoid these hazardous situations as much as possible, i think Dan Gryders covers this whole topic really well.
The jump in production value is obvious, these are getting better and better. Thanks to the pilots for telling their stories.
Thank you to everybody who was part of making this video. We all need to see this and think about it. Todd, you are lucky to be alive! Terrible situation, ultimately happy ending.
Not a pilot, just an aviation fan. Man, That choked me up. So Glad to see that Todd is okay as can be.
Wow. So glad for this outcome and the lessons learned. Great video, thanks AOPA. I can't imagine the feeling of seeing my brother pancake his plane just out of sight in the backcountry. Then to find him alive but death-gurgling. Props to these guys for getting the right aid in place asap. So glad these brothers can fly together again. Blue skies!
"Airplanes always make it to the ground". Much respect to all of the pilots out there reading this with a little bit of gallows humor in the back of your mind. All of us plebes wouldn't mind making a landing once. Cheers... from a passenger.
I had a Stearman start spitting burning glops of gas out the exhaust on takeoff at ten feet alt. Luckily my copilot was a WW2 Vet and knew exactly what to do. He calmly notified the tower, set back down, shut off the fuel, slowed down, drove off the runway and locked the left brake to slowly go around in circles until the engine quit. We sat there he started laughing. "If you shut off the engine, the aircraft will burn to the ground." "I learned that in basic flight training 1944, and never used it until now." (1994)
Moral: Good training sticks with you. RIP Mike.
UPRT! An absolute must for any pilot. I’m an airline pilot and we have done it in our recurrent training every six months for the last 5 years. I was also an aerobatic pilot and light aircraft pilot in my spare time. Upset recovery training is brilliant! It has made me more aware in all my flying. The way ASI has done this video and how the pilots involved have openly discussed this and shared their experience is absolutely brilliant. Hangar talk definitely increases all pilots knowledge. Single pilot CRM and the psychology of flying is just as important as any other aviation subject. Thank you for this, you have enlightened me and provoked more thought on how I prepare myself for flight. Absolutely brilliant video👌🏻👍🏻
@Donavan Waite. I've been flying for 32 years and I don't think I would land there. I consider myself a good pilot and believe me I'm not laying fault on anyone, I just know my limitations and I wouldn't be comfortable trying to get in there.
@@garywilliam375 I respect you so much for that. It takes a lot for some people to admit shortcomings (although I don't view this as a shortcoming). In many of these GA crash investigation videos it seems pride is at fault at least partially.
Donavan Waite, I'm fascinated by CRM and the value it adds in the cockpit. I am a leader (one of several) in a large consulting firm, and I have used the Sioux Falls example of CRM in some of my larger presentations. Unfortunately I'm not a pilot, but I absolutely love flying and all things aircraft related. I have seen a fair amount of bad decisions with clients made similarly to a bad situation in the cockpit; overconfidence, not looking to others for ideas, and a hierarchical way of thinking (and perhaps maybe a bit of arrogance mixed in as well). I loved your point about single pilot CRM - is that something you introduced, or is that shared in the flight community as well? I really like that concept! Thank you for sharing Donavan. 👍
In the airline world we review and brief each and every approach prior to descent. Even if we've been to the same airport 100 times. We cover the approach, go-around, Terrain, Weather, and other operational considerations (e.g. current fuel state, contingency plans, etc.) Preparation is key. In this case, a clear briefing on sight picture, location of the runway (it's tucked in on the right side of the clearing) approach, landing, and rollout. Also discuss commitment point -- the point where an approach can no longer be aborted, and the pilot is committed to land. Critical details are key! As the hazards increase, so should the preparation to meet those hazards.
There was a bit of stall-spin recovery discussion in the video. Once Todd had stalled, at that altitude, there was no chance to recover. Stall and spin recovery is critically important for pilots, but wouldn't have saved Todd. Stall and spin *avoidance* training would have been more useful.
Also being a glider pilot does help. When you know you only have one chance to land each time you fly, you get really good at mentally preparing for an approach and staying focused throughout the whole approach and landing.
I got the impression from this vid that the pilot that crashed wasn't 'briefed' on what to expect. The "interview" wasn't well done IMO as this issue wasn't addressed.
The last comment on takeaways - "leave yourself an out" should be #1. Doesn't just apply to aviation.
Absolutely, giving yourself an out apply’s 100% in backcountry flying... Unless you go into a strip like Dewey Moore, or some other “no go around” strip, field, ridge etc. There is a point that you’re totally committed and or not. Once your past that point of total commitment you either land without bending metal, or you land and you do bend metal.
I'm a fire training officer who's done a little flying, and i preach that to the younger guys coming up. That mindset saves lives, plain and simple.
Thanks to the gentlemen for sharing this story. Very humbling and learnt a lot.
Glad to see that Todd has recovered from this scary accident.
I don't fly, but i would have anyone of these guys at my back without question. We all make mistakes throughout our lives but critical thinking, which all of these men are using in this situation is admirable.
Appreciate the story and the guys willing to talk about it.
I do aircraft recovery for a living. This guy is lucky to be alive. I’ve seen crashes like this and the pilot was mangled beyond recognition. We give tours to student pilots around the yard and tell them what caused each crash and how that pilot could have avoided the crash. The students leave our facility with their eyes wide open after the tour. They either stall on landing or takeoff or the biggest problem we’ve been seeing is people NOT checking their fuel levels.
Every time I see a video from this channel I can't click it fast enough.
Outstanding video and big, big thanks to the pilots involved for being open and sharing their story. Happy to hear of the pilot's recovery.
I'm a glider pilot, with only a few hundred hours, so have less experience than these guys and I acknowledge it's easy to be wise after the event. It surprised me that a pilot would choose to fly into a challenging strip solo for the first time. The others had been here before: mightn't it have been better to have one of them in the plane? Stall / spin: many GA pilots fly aircraft which will not readily stall and are not universally (I believe) taught spin recovery. You might find it useful to go to a gliding club and ask to do some spinning (not just the early stage of wing drop). Stall / spin is a well-recognised hazard for glider pilots, particularly in out-landings (going into a farmer's field you've only just seen a few minutes before) and spin recovery training is part of the syllabus. Lastly, thanks for sharing. The challenge is to not repeat someone else's mistakes but to go out and make your own new and different ones. Fly safely.
And as glider pilots, all our fields are non-go-around :).
Did Todd really know that this was a one-way strip? To me it sounded like this information hadn't been adequately communicated and the implications (including deer) discussed amongst them all.
Gliding experience is without doubt a plus for all GA pilots, and even more to bush pilots. Being a glider instructor I teach spin recovery for one main purpose : have the student acknowledge that a spin close to the ground can't be recovered (due to fall rate once in spin). I do also teach that no glider pilot should choose a field for possible outlanding only a few minutes before it is needed: always soaring within reach of a landable spot is key to survival.
When I first saw the title of this, related to backcountry flying, I immediately thought "this is what pilots face here in the backcountry in Idaho," and here you are!! His joke about looking for world-class rhubarb isn't far from the truth. Before he let his license laps due to his age, my dad loved to fly into some small backcountry strips here in Idaho and have a burger at the lodges. He called them his "100-dollar hamburgers."
Thank you Todd for putting yourself through this for our benefit. I hope I am never in the same position but, if I am, I hope have the courage that you have shown.
Thank you
Thanks to all of you. I've recently been turned on to the idea of flying(specifically backcountry flying.). This is a well needed awakening from the frequent day dreaming I've been doing as of late. Having close to 30 years of ER experience, I can say you guys handled a very intense situation. There is next level pucker factor when shit happens right in front of you.
I drive lots of miles and have been the first on the scene to quite a few accidents. The adrenaline blast and instant focus of “”what can I do to save this person?” just seems to take you over. I remember running down the hill to the overturned car on one of them and never thinking about if I would trip and fall myself and also the feeling of I hope this isn’t a fatal accident. I did turn off the ignition the minute I smelled gasoline though.
This is an amazing story, but the lessons that were learned are so valuable. Nothing is able to substitute for training, and having a good plan. Always having first aid and survival gear, is also a huge takeaway from this.
For me personally I would only attempt these kind of BC operations until I had received rigorous mountain flying training from professionals. A co-worker of mine worked part time at "McCall Mountain Canyon Flying Seminars" and shared many stories. But even then accidents can happen like these proficient pilots experienced. Thank you for sharing this event.
SpinFast I used to fly with McCall air taxi to cabin creek with Mike Dorris
*as someone who wants to go into back country/bush flying, these stories are priceless and immensely helpful. Thank you so much for agreeing to open up about it!! Back country flying has such big risk but such big reward, thankful everybody survived.* 🙏
Every pilot should see this. Thanks to all of you for candidly sharing all the details.
I totally agree!!
Also being able to commit yourself into a controlled crash as opposed to the alternative which is a nose straight down uncontrolled stall/spin crash.
I'm glad he's okay. The competence of his comrades is remarkable.
Thank you all for sharing your story. I'm not a pilot, but enjoy watching these videos... your story was very educational and scary. I'm so glad it had a happy ending and you are all safe!
If you fly backcountry THIS INTERVIEW SHOULD BE MANDATORY VIEWING!
This is the first video of yours that I'm watching on your channel. I was part of a US Coast Guard / Civil Air Patrol joint effort looking for stranded boaters, downed aircraft and swept out swimmers. We took off from Erie Int'l Airport in PA, flew up to Dunkirk NY, turned, went to Conneaut Ohio, then returned. Whatever we saw, we radioed in for the Coast Guard to go investigate. It was a daily event, code named "Sundown Patrol." Once we were stable in the air, the pilot would give over the controls to us cadets, one by one, so we could experience what it was like piloting a plane.
After my stint as a CAP Cadet Commander, I joined the Air Force, in Security Police (Now called Security Forces) and joined several federal law enforcement associations as a result. After fulfilling many of my life dreams, I am now seeking to rejoin CAP and get my pilots license. This looks like a good place to get great info, and learn. I'm very happy to have found your channel.
This is the flight instructor in me, but why are we labeling this as a "no go around" strip? If the approach is unstable or for any other reason there always has to be an alternative, otherwise why even approach? Here's a suggestion, how about a spiraling climb? Isn't that why we practice chandelles? Constant airspeed, constant bank... pitch for vx and perform a climbing 180... why was this not an option? I'm glad this pilot lived to share the experience; I'm trying to learn something hence my question. I don't understand what a "no go around" strip is as I come from a different school of thought I suppose. The pilot of the accident aircraft is lucky he was in a group; that saved his life. Now I will also say thank you to ASI for facilitating this conversation and posting it on CZcams so the content reaches more people. That's awesome.
Very interesting. Whoever designated the airfield "no go around", did so because a go around was not possible. So a crash was inevitable. This is a very valuable video.
Julian Alcock Are you saying that because any strip that is no “go around”, crashing is inevitable?
@@wallybrown9509 As I understand it, an airstrip which is designated as "no go around" because the terrain blocks all possible paths for a go around. Once the pilot has passed a certain point on the approach, he or she must land or crash. The most famous example of this is the Tenzing-Hilary airport at Lukla in Nepal.
Julian Alcock Yep that’s correct. You’re going to land one way or another. The question is, do I bend metal, or don’t I?
Great recap with a lot of good take aways, glad this pilot is alive and the willing to share the story.
Thank you for sharing this chilling story. I is hard to learn from other peoples mistakes.....Yet all of these "forced landing" discussions help others to reflect on the seriousness of flying in the back country.
I love these videos, starting on my pilots license later this month and am binge watching these again to prepare myself mentally. Sidenote: I also love me some rhubarb
TheCptCoy BE RELENTLESS. DO NOT QUIT. GO ON “AUTOPILOT” MAKE YOURSELF FINISH NO MATER WHAT COMES UP. This is the only way you will do it, only 1 out of 5 +/- students Pilots get there PPL, I did it so can you. ✈️
@@mog882 I am going to a college where my major includes flight school, so luckily I should stay on track. I should have my PPL by the end of the year, and then the next year I'll start working on more ratings.
@@TheCptCoy well, how is everything? Watcha doin now?
Great stuff guys .i tried to remember all the good advices you gave to all of us in this video.
Above all, I am delighted to see the brothers still happy together.
Cheers from the French alps American flyers.
Great video guys glad to hear the outcome was as good as it was.
I’m an ag pilot who topdresses in high altitude country in Australia and regularly operate off short no go round strips.
Conducting up to 80 takeoffs and landings a day .
Great idea to practice on go round strips.
Helmet with this type of flying is I believe a must, a good flight helmet does cost a few dollars,but well worth it.
Another fantastic video!! A great way to spread safety that I'm sure has and will continue to keep folks out of bad situations. Very happy to hear that Todd has made a full recovery. I can only imagine how terrifying that must have been. Good group of fellas together that fateful afternoon - the kind of guys you can trust and know they have your back. 👍
What a lovely group of people. Just the kind that you want around when things are tough. ❤
Excellent videos. Have watched many of these and learned from each. I’m a 2100 hour commercial instrument rated pilot and each time I watch one of these I tense up with understanding how it feels to be so highly stressed.
Just wow! Thank you for this video and thank you to the 4 involved in this incident, to share their experience. So thankful for the recovery!
Outstanding. Its nice to see everything go as 'according to plan' as it can. Getting the power and fuel cut are a good reminder for the next pilot down the line. Sending out the SOS immediately was job #1, well done.
Thanks so much for this video. As someone once said, "Humans learn from their mistakes, not from their successes."
I pilot a canopy as a skydiver, not an airplane but I learned an amazing amount about my own sport from watching this video. All of the flight terms and all aspects of being in the air and landing are the same. No matter how big or small your wing or wings are the aerodynamics of flight don't change.
When I deploy my canopy I am always aware that I could be presented with something unexpected. One the most harrowing of these possibilities is being in a stall spin. Under canopy can easily be deadly. Once the spin takes over it becomes extremely difficult to overpower the centrifugal force. Maintaining clarity during an emergency is challenging but critical. My father was a pilot and I have chosen to take flight to a different level but at the end of the day the principles of that flight are the same and the emergencies are remarkably similar. All of the people in this vid are outstanding and a happy outcome being pulled from an accident was truly miraculous. The most important thing I was taught from my instructor: Remember, whenever you begin a turn you are committing to an altitude loss. Thanks for the reminder. Blue skies, guys!
Solid work all - very much appreciated, and happy this one only had an expensive outcome!
Oh, and rhubarb crumble is worth the effort!
I Love that the Garmin device can send texts without cell phone coverage ! Just brilliant
Great discussion on helmets and old plane cockpit design.
I am absolutely not a pilot, but I was very surprised when the one question I had was not coming up through all of this video: Why did nobody in the group ask everybody else if they have been to this place before while they were all still in the and not in an approach? Why is there not a policy in place, when you go bush flying, that everyone gets a briefing for the place they are going to be landing? I get that the challenge is part of the fun, but I would make it a rule that:
1. everybody who landed there before states as such on the radio.
2. everybody who didn't states as such on the radio.
3. If someone in the group never landed there before, the pilot with the most experience for the landing strip is obliged to give a quick summary of what to expect.
Yes This Is Very Valuable Pre Info' _Yet Many Of The Multi Plane River Rompers Just Let The Terrain Entice The Next Landing' So Ive Noticed?_ Risky? Yes' Yet So Is Bush Flying' Btw? Were Are The After Market AirBags??_ 😶✌🌈
borheimer, I guess it’s a little like Jeep outings. There’s a mixture of sometimes sharing and sometimes just know your buddies have good equipment and can take care of themselves. Sometimes you’re on trail nobody knows about, and you count on pitting your brains and equipment against whatever comes up.
Sometimes that’s exactly what you were looking for, not a guided experience with known results.
I was thinking the same thing. How the hell do you wait until the last minute to ask someone if they have landed here before?
In the electric utility I recently retired from, any job that has hazards requires filling out a pre-job brief. The brief is done as a team if more than one person is involved. Individual responsibilities are clarified, and a comprehensive checklist of hazards - about 30 in all - is completed to identify which of those hazards may be present and how they will be managed.
I understand this was a strictly recreational flight and this procedure would be a bit of a downer, but each was aware there are hazards anytime you depend on the wings to keep you alive. Talking over the whole "no go-around" thing might have prevented the crash.
The older guy had been there before, but I was surprised there was no mention of it being a no-go around situation. Maybe I missed that part.
Experience can mean nothing. Only evaluated experience is valuable. That’s what this channel is all about and I love it! Great show with several great takeaways.
The honesty of these guys demands huge respect from me.
What a GREAT group of guys that, in AS BAD as this situation was..I would want this kind of ‘level-headedness’ and strong people around any accident scene. I WISH we’d heard more about the specific CARE they gave Todd in the initial aftermath of the crash..SO glad he’s alright! Bet this has made them a lot tighter group. AND, you can’t say ENOUGH about that garmin ‘IN-REACH’ tech..saved Todd’s life to be sure.
Thank you very much for making these videos available.
Thank you for sharing the story. Glad it had a happy end amd you were able to male it out!
I agree with others that these videos are invaluable and really make me stop and contemplate all aspects of my experience as an aviator. Well done and please produce more safety oriented content.
Excellent recap of what happened. Lesson learned, thank you!
Thanks for doing these videos. Every time I watch a new one I hold my breath. This time I relaxed, because you guys laughed in the beginning of the video. I am sure it has been a tough journey for Todd, but the other option is far less good. Thanks again.
Really appreciate the story, it will definitely help me. I will be looking at my cockpit for what I could hit in a crash. Thank you.
Glad to hear you mounted back up and are doing good.
OUTSTANDING VIDEO!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SHARING !!!
Thank you for sharing the lessons learned...
Great video! These are the types of videos we can all learn from. Thanks for sharing!
So many things had to go right for this guy to be a live, wow.
Want to practice no go around landings, fly a glider. Every landing in a glider is a no go around landing.
Wyll Surf Air Just get good at landing your airplane. For me I don’t think about if it’s a “no go around” or not. Just land it competently.
anyone understand why this was a no-go around situation? It seems from the map instead of making a 180 turn he could have veered and continued along the river to climb out of trouble. Was there terrain that made that impossible?
That may be true, but it find of misses the point.
A glider is absolutely nothing like a powered aircraft.
If only I could have a super light aircraft with a low stall speed where you can instantly change the drag and glide ratio with one lever while affecting nothing else going into a perfectly flat airstrip with minimal obstacles.
Completely irrelevant.
@@calvinnickel9995 Your comment makes me assume that you must not fly gliders. Many gliders are actually very heavy and carry water on the wings to make them heavier. This they have high stall speeds. Dive breaks do not actually "effect nothing else" they usually increase the stall by a few knots and on some cases also induce a pitch change. Gliders to do not just land on perfectly flat runways. Any good glider pilot will have out landed on all sorts fields, and duster strips that are by no means flat or free of obstacles.
Thank you for sharing your story amazing so glad you came out of that alive
This looks incredibly hard to do. Thank you, so much for your honesty, your story, and for saving countless people in the future
Great video, great quality of the production as well. I loved it and above all thank you for sharing.
Good discussion. Thank you!
A quick story, my commercial check ending was a short field landing. Storms in Fla surrounded the airport and I stated to the FAA inspector
That there is no stall warning system on my 1960 Comanche . I’ll never forget his words” you mean you don’t know how to fly your
Airplane. “ Well I shuttered it to the runway and the inspector smiled told me come in the office n get my ticket. Lesson learned.
All great points made about gliders. I learned to fly on cessnas etc, and then flew gliders, including hang gliders and paragliders for 15 years - as everyone else says, it really focuses your mind when you know you can't go around (like when I landed repeatedly for a photo-reportage project in the super tight canyons of Petra in Jordan, next to the Indiana Jones temple of doom place.
Scary occurrence but thank you all very much sharing. Superbly hosted and produced ASI. I'm currently just 5 hours into a PPL in the UK and making an effort to go through a lot of your content.
I'm so glad I've subscribed to this channel. This is such a great video, and a wonderful reminder to plan and prepare - and to make critical decisions ahead of the point you need to make them.
Wow, cool story. I really enjoy watching these, glad this one turned out well.
One mitigating factor I've noticed in canyon/mountain flying it is very easy to lose your horizon perspective; while turning in a canyon, it is very easy to climb exccesively in the turn- you lose airspeed very quickly. Mentally preparing for this helps me- I scan my artifical horizon in the turn to make sure I'm not inadvertebtly climbing. Also always enter the turn on the downwind side of the canyon if there is a crossbreeze- so you are turning into the wind. This effectively reduces your turn radius relative to the ground especially when your eyes are focused on terrain below. Good video- thx!
An exceedingly well made video. Mr. McSpadden is very enjoyable to follow and listen to. I will be strongly considering Upset Recovery Training to become more familiar with stall regimes. Thank you ASI!
Wow....A really great video. Thank you to all involved.
Thanks for sharing. As a old h/glider pilot, I had a number of close escapes. But still by far the best times of life I ever had.. God's grace is just awesome.
Great story - glad to have all back safe and sound - thank you for sharing.
Great video. Thank you for producing it and to those gentlemen for sharing it.
Thank you guys for the excellent discussion ❤️🤠❤️
This was outstanding. Agree it was a very sobering reminder to plan and stay well ahead of the situation.
Fantastic video. Please do more like this, in this same presentation style!
I think what I appreciate the most about this video is the part about: "what have you added to your cockpit that could potentially hit you in a crash"
we as humans are incredibly good at disregarding these questions because we do not accept that it can happen to us. But especially as a pilot it is vital to know that this stuff can happen ans that you have the same chance to be involved in a crash as the guy next to you. Think ahead, ignoring the possibility of a crash won't make your plane safer.
Great opening up your story for safety. Iam a soaring trike pilot. Flew hang gliders and ga aircraft.
Iam always evaluating safety in flying conditions WX plus make model type . Flying MT ID mountains, I conclude that in flying a soaring trike i have alot of safety built in as far as E/O . Slow stall speeds. Short roll on landing and take off. Soaring trikes are often observed as soooo dangerous. But in truth its the oposite based on good ADM.
But it all relates to all types of aviation safety. Accidents happen to the best of pilots and soo unexspected. My hats off to these cub pilots in opening up there story for the safety of all aviation thank you .