Why we REMOVED the Wheel Pants

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 07. 2024
  • Website: www.aviation101.com/
    Proudly Sponsored by:
    ForeFlight: www.foreflight.com/
    Lightspeed Aviation: www.lightspeedaviation.com/?u...
    Flying Eyes Optics: flyingeyesoptics.com/
    CoFlyt: coflyt.com/
    Email: mail@aviation101.com
    Facebook: / aviation101films
    Twitter: / aviation101film
    Instagram: @aviation101films
    #flying #aviation #airplane

Komentáře • 586

  • @johnopalko5223
    @johnopalko5223 Před 4 lety +71

    According to the Piper Archer III (PA-28-181) manual you lose a whole 3 kts by removing the wheel pants. Frankly, gaining 3 kts isn't worth the extra weight and the loss of access to the tires, brakes, etc. I'm one of those people who think that the aircraft looks better with the wheel pants, but not better enough to outweigh the disadvantages.

  • @Will2FlyHigh
    @Will2FlyHigh Před 4 lety +51

    Another pro and con:
    Pro: Those dings on the front of your wheel pants mean the wheel pants have protected the wheel and brake hardware from getting hit by something... maybe rocks. That means possibly less damage to the more expensive parts of the plane.
    Con: The wheel pants are bigger than wheels alone. I have tripped over them a few times whereas I have never tripped over the wheel on a plane that does not have wheel pants..

    • @DanielF601
      @DanielF601 Před 3 lety

      Agree with your Con, Will. A 152 is awkward enough already. The wheel pants (aren't they called Spats?) are freakin' inconvenient and annoying when moving to and from the aircraft.

  • @randc47
    @randc47 Před 4 lety +74

    More “beer in the hanger” videos please. Love it!

  • @logicreversed18t
    @logicreversed18t Před 4 lety +174

    Me: I've never watched a video from this guy, I wonder if I can watch his videos.
    You: Cracks a beer within the first minute.
    Me: Okay. I guess we're best friends now.

    • @sakumisan
      @sakumisan Před 4 lety +1

      As long as its 8 hours bottle to throttle, but that's just the minimum.

    • @haulperrel2547
      @haulperrel2547 Před 3 lety

      >mfw that was an o'douhls

  • @AKSuperDually
    @AKSuperDually Před 4 lety +2

    You nailed it on the visibility of the landing gear. Small problems become big problems when they go undetected and uncorrected. In order for a wheel pant to be truly effective, it covers several critical systems. Up here in Alaska, we often install mud flaps though, which is a practical solution to dents, dings, and corrosion encouraging mud on the lower wing, flaps, and even the tail. Great video, I always enjoy your videography. I enjoyed your Alaska series immensely, it's my back yard and you flew all around and even over us on your trip. The scenery here never gets old though, and no matter how often I've seen it for myself, I enjoy seeing outsider's perspectives, views, and reactions to our awesome state. Thanks again, good video!

  • @mattmansell3486
    @mattmansell3486 Před 4 lety +19

    Something I recently discovered the hard way is when taking off of a runway that has melting snow or ice, it quickly refreezes inside the pant adding weight and other problems.

    • @kneedeepsnow16
      @kneedeepsnow16 Před 2 lety +1

      Dude‼️ exactly... never dawned me.... Alaska‼️🥶
      Great Point, im so sad I didn’t think of that🥶🍪🍪🍪

  • @chriseinfalt3499
    @chriseinfalt3499 Před 4 lety

    Hey Josh! Been watching your videos since you were "Mr. Aviation" years ago! I finally got my first logged flight hour out at KBAZ earlier this week even though I've had flights in a RV7 and a T38. I'm headed off to Air Force pilot training in the coming month so I'm just trying to get ahead. Your videos are very inspiring and a ton of fun to watch! It's crazy to think that you live not more than an hour away too. Keep up the good work!

  • @michaelb.8953
    @michaelb.8953 Před 4 lety +82

    No matter if it's aviation related or pertains to life in general whenever one wants to have fun it always includes removing the pants.

  • @lg7639
    @lg7639 Před 4 lety +17

    "Potato with butter on top" cracked me up. :)

  • @mattyflying5483
    @mattyflying5483 Před 4 lety +4

    Hey. Thanks for making these videos. You really keep me motivated to get my PPL and go fly! I'm on my 20' hour atm, and are really looking forward to fly with my family/friends.
    Please keep making flying videos, they are really amazing!

  • @warwickkinscher5986
    @warwickkinscher5986 Před 2 lety

    Keep up the good work - from way “down under” at Ballarat in Victoria, Australia. At our Aero Club flying school, we have taken the wheel pants off the ab initio trainers - basically for the reasons you have espoused; teaching new pilots to check brakes, tires, tire pressures; to be able to handle short field landings and take-offs, gravel and grass runways, etc. The Piper Warrior still has its pants - but they are fixed; and we have left them on the C172SP - but it is used for pre PPL navs, PIFR and IFR training and fly-aways. We must agree - according to our measurements, wheel pants are worth at best 5 knots - but for 6kgs = 13 lbs on the smaller aircraft, and 9kgs = 20 lbs on the 4-seaters. Love the “beer o’clock” talk - but gotta keep that MINIMUM 8 hours from bottle to throttle!

  • @FlyingJournalism
    @FlyingJournalism Před 4 lety +126

    "Why did the plane get arrested for indecent exposure?" Because he took off his wheel pants

  • @niklaspilot
    @niklaspilot Před 4 lety +33

    “I can’t say I haven’t thought about it” 😂
    Haven’t we all?

    • @hempelcx
      @hempelcx Před 4 lety +1

      Curious how that would work with the front fork... Bush tires normally go on tail draggers.

    • @niklaspilot
      @niklaspilot Před 4 lety

      i.b. hemp check out Josh’s Alaska series. That 172 has some bush tyres fitted

    • @scalymonster3052
      @scalymonster3052 Před 4 lety +2

      Added 26 inch bushwheels to my 182Q after removing the wheel pants. I love em’. Lost about 2Kts in cruise with the bushwheels, but gravel runways are softer, plane sits up higher a little further away from grass on the runways. Looks cool too 😉

  • @homertalk
    @homertalk Před 4 lety +57

    I save weight and always remove my pants while flying!

    • @MikeBrown-ex9nh
      @MikeBrown-ex9nh Před 4 lety +3

      Hopefully not on the airlines.

    • @inglewoodwhb
      @inglewoodwhb Před 4 lety +4

      @@MikeBrown-ex9nh I recall a captain I once flew with told me that he and his female FO once had an empty repositioning flight and they dared each other to fly it in their undies.

    • @joshstanleymc
      @joshstanleymc Před 4 lety

      ha made me smile ! 😀

    • @e36s50b30
      @e36s50b30 Před 4 lety

      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @trueblueflying
      @trueblueflying Před 4 lety

      homertalk I always take them off to save weight, they are in the baggage compartment if I need them.

  • @kentd4762
    @kentd4762 Před rokem

    Fun, informative video, Josh. Have been flying various Cessnas (both fixed and retractable) since 1981, including instructing for a number of years. The biggest reason I prefer no pants is definitely the (in)ability to fully inspect everything around the wheel/tire. Always feels like I need to take a second or deeper look, but there's not way to do it...
    Fly safe everyone.

  • @redheron
    @redheron Před 4 lety +47

    Nothing like some good brew and simple hanger talk 👍🏼

    • @redheron
      @redheron Před 4 lety +2

      And I’m with you... NO PANTS!

  • @jackstraw7898
    @jackstraw7898 Před 4 lety +1

    I had a 140A back in the 70's and those slippers were nothing but a pain. 1 out of 10 flights were on paved runways. I flew out of our local grass strip airport mostly to other grass/dirt/gravel strips. It was a constant job making sure they were clean internally and a pain inspecting the gear. One year when I was having the annual done by our local field mechanic I asked him to just take the damn things off. He explained to me that wasn't a good idea because the plane had fabric wings and more than looks they worked as debris flaps to keep anything from flying up off the wheels and impacting the wing or any control surfaces, especially because it was a tail dragger and more of the wing surface was exposed to potential debris. That plane was built during the days that most fields were just that fields and was fairly high performance, including flaps, for it's purpose at the time as opposed to something like Cubs or T-Crafts. I wonder if they were originally a safety feature but as time went on became a cosmetic feature, especially to identify with Cessna, that was no longer required but just made the planes look good like nice looking wheels on a new car.

  • @wilzboyz
    @wilzboyz Před 4 lety +22

    Snow and ice in WI -- We remove pants in the winter as to avoid slush and ice accumulating inside the pant causing damage. PA 28-235.

    • @75Seneca2
      @75Seneca2 Před 4 lety

      We do the same in Manitoba. But we like the look so throw them back on in late spring!

    • @gibbeys
      @gibbeys Před 4 lety

      Ditto...177B

    • @monacosfranz4202
      @monacosfranz4202 Před 4 lety

      Same here. C182T

    • @rammstein1903
      @rammstein1903 Před 4 lety

      Was thinking the same thing for 172N

    • @dalgrim
      @dalgrim Před 4 lety

      We do the same on our PA-28-180, mains come off at the first snow and stay off until spring.

  • @chrisc161
    @chrisc161 Před 4 lety +15

    You needed an excuse to have a beer. Good decision lol

  • @waukeshapilot6462
    @waukeshapilot6462 Před 4 lety +4

    Good to see you are Normal and enjoy a beer from time to time, Josh!!!

  • @randyporter3491
    @randyporter3491 Před 4 lety +1

    I can relate to this video ! I had a 172 in the late 80’s, that we wound up removing the pants for a time for repair. After reinstalling them, I always wished I had just just left them off. But, unlike most, I actually like the look of “no wheel pants”, not to mention the pants hide so much, that really needs to be visible. Great video Josh !
    BTW - A friend removed wheel pants from his 152 Areobat and put really nice polished aluminum wheels on all around. Looked great !

  • @RPSchonherr
    @RPSchonherr Před 4 lety +8

    3 mph on full tanks could mean the difference of making your destination non stop or not. Depending on tank size (~39 gal) and fuel burn (~8 gal/hr) you get ~15 extra miles with wheel pants. Multiply that 15 by how ever many stops you need to make for a long flight and it could be significant, especially if you are flying over ocean or other terrain where you wouldn't want to make an unscheduled landing if your fuel ran out.

  • @chrisschreiber5000
    @chrisschreiber5000 Před 4 lety +1

    Great and practical episode! Keep these coming and mixed in with your flights!!!
    I just put pants on my 172M and saw about 3 knots difference in speed in similar conditions. Like you, I do a fair bit of grass ops and am a little concerned, but figure on trying it out and seeing. As I see it, 3 knots on a 4 hour flight is negligible.....on a trip from Texas to Osh and back, maybe that saves you a bit....does it add up in the long run? Probably not.

  • @bobbygraves6564
    @bobbygraves6564 Před 4 lety +3

    I was wonder why you had never put the pants back on after painting 80991. After your explanation, pro's and con's, now I know and I fully agree with your decision! Keep up the great work and fantastic videos!

  • @jessiebullock
    @jessiebullock Před 4 lety

    I love that you set up multiple cameras to talk to just for a simple talking to the camera video. Thanks for your work, Josh!

  • @mattf49006
    @mattf49006 Před 4 lety +3

    In 84 when I had my primary training in 172s at KTOA..i recall the FBO had about 7 skyhawks from a 79..a 84 and the rest 80/81 models...none had pants..my instructor showed me a storage room where boxes of them where stored and said wheel pants on a trainer with the frequency of tire and brake changes..tire pressure checks..students using them as steps etc..made it far easier to leave them off...I've owned a cpl skyhawks and I agree...maybe 3 to (on a good day) 5 knots faster in cruise with pants..

  • @SixStringflyboy
    @SixStringflyboy Před 4 lety

    I took them off my 150M 2 years ago and have zero regrets. For me it was a no-brainer, and for exactly the reasons you highlighted here. On a 150, they add 1-2 knots of airspeed max, at a cost of 18 lbs gross weight with pants, fairings, and mounting brackets. That's 3 gallons of gas I was leaving on the ground just to gain 1-2 knots of speed. The Skyhawk I trained in didn't have them, and I hated not being able to see the brakes & calipers, and especially the condition of the tire treads and sidewalls, like I could on the Skyhawk during preflight.

  • @robertparrott9273
    @robertparrott9273 Před 3 lety

    As director of maintenance for the Oregon State Flying with 3 C-172's, we have removed all of the the wheel pants so that student pilots can learn to see and inspect for tire/brake wear. We also save about 1.5 hours of labor every 100 hours with our A&P's by not having to take them off and putting them back on for inspections. When you have an airplane flying 600 hours a year that savings adds up fast. I can also point out to the CFI's that are allowing their students to brake to hard and making flat spots on new tires, or that they are side loading when landing.

  • @Buzzkilla39
    @Buzzkilla39 Před 4 lety

    Josh I totally agree with you! My 172 currently has wheel pants and they're probably coming off at next annual. It drives me crazy trying to air up a tire and you really don't get a good look at everything during preflight. Nice video!!

  • @Autocross7
    @Autocross7 Před 4 lety +1

    I have a Piper Warrior and keep wheel pants on the mains. They weigh around 3lbs each. Without them I found the underside of the wings just get slapped with crap kicked up by the mains. It has made it a lot easier to keep the underside of the wings clean. Not a problem with high wings to be sure.

  • @benhewy3775
    @benhewy3775 Před 4 lety +1

    Hey! Great video! I am moving down to Texas this summer and thought maybe you could make a video about Texas aviation, the community, and what it means to you. Keep up the great work!

  • @downwinddemon
    @downwinddemon Před 4 lety

    Been waiting for this for a long time. Looks better with them on in my opinion, but I see the perks of leaving off. Thanks Josh!

  • @Demy26
    @Demy26 Před 4 lety +65

    Plane: Where are my pants 😊

    • @RobertForslund
      @RobertForslund Před 4 lety +3

      Or, it might even go "Whee, let us go streaking down the taxiway!" 😁

    • @EdwinCristobal
      @EdwinCristobal Před 4 lety +3

      Everything looks better without pants... wait...

    • @Thaddeus.N
      @Thaddeus.N Před 4 lety +2

      Plane: everyone can see my gear.

    • @flyer16612
      @flyer16612 Před 4 lety

      Tango just made my entire evening 😂

    • @zeppzeus
      @zeppzeus Před 4 lety

      Piper Cherokee: COME HERE BABY

  • @gordonfeliciano4315
    @gordonfeliciano4315 Před 4 lety

    We removed the wheel pants off of our Tiger last year during our annual inspection for the same reasons you did... well, except we didn't have a paint job done. It was a pain in the arse to put air in the tires, do any brake work, etc. And, for some reason, we had a string of flat tires within a six month period thanks to FOD that we had to deal with. So, the decision was made to take them off. And I am glad we did. Our cruise speed is down about 6 knots and we gained about 27 lbs in useful load. She still flies like a champ.

  • @Rodeo32145
    @Rodeo32145 Před 4 lety

    I agree about 3kts. That’s what I see on my M model 172. Correct on work of installing and removing, also the brake fairings. I’m in northern Michigan and I pick what days I use the plane in the winter with the pants on. But I think the plane looks better with a matched paint job on them. Great video.

  • @adrianpetasis8220
    @adrianpetasis8220 Před 4 lety +1

    Great video! Love this format of video from time to time!

  • @FlyingDarkLord
    @FlyingDarkLord Před 4 lety

    Thanks so much for this video, I’m considering buying a new aircraft soon & was wondering whether or not to tick the options box for wheel pants... this helped make up my mind!

  • @alharris185
    @alharris185 Před 4 lety +18

    I spy a Spotted Cow being consumed. There is no finer beer on Earth!

  • @earlmyers9374
    @earlmyers9374 Před 7 měsíci

    thanks for your videos, from an old retired pilot. back when, grass strip and winter (snow), wheel pants became a big slush scoop. The flight school where i taught, the 150s and 172s had the pants removed during the winter so cleaning the brakes would be much easier.

  • @greatlakesflyer6099
    @greatlakesflyer6099 Před 4 lety +2

    Love the videos! Keep up the work josh!

  • @billwatson8181
    @billwatson8181 Před 4 lety +3

    You probably don't worry about this in Texas but farther north, you have to take the pants off in the winter because they can collect snow and slush during taxi, then freeze once airborne. Could make for an exciting landing

  • @IsaacWilke
    @IsaacWilke Před 4 lety +25

    That beer looks like a Spotted Cow if I've ever had one ;) Freshly made in my home state of Wisconsin!

    • @alanrossjohnson
      @alanrossjohnson Před 4 lety +3

      I caught that right away too!

    • @donnieboyette2216
      @donnieboyette2216 Před 4 lety

      One of the reasons I go to Oshkosh from NC!

    • @IsaacGarcia-
      @IsaacGarcia- Před 4 lety

      It’s a lovely drive from Chicago 😊😊.

    • @WiredForFlight
      @WiredForFlight Před 4 lety +2

      Have a few in my fridge now. (Than again I live in WI so it’s the law)

    • @wilzboyz
      @wilzboyz Před 4 lety +2

      Also grab Karben4 Fantasy Factory ! Out of Madison WI (KMSN) with brewery within 0.5mi of the airport.

  • @jasonsauer9555
    @jasonsauer9555 Před 4 lety

    I have a 1967 C-182 Skylane and I took them off because when I bought the plane it only had two. One on each main gear nothing on the nose. I lost about the same on speed that you said about 1 to 2 knots. I am from North Dakota and the wind here will change your speed more than the wheel pants will. Like your videos. Keep up the great work.

  • @landonlasseigne1511
    @landonlasseigne1511 Před 4 lety +1

    You keep me motivated. Keep making videos. Never stop!

  • @rocky_williams
    @rocky_williams Před 4 lety

    Dang Josh. You covered that well. Bonus points for the view of the awesome Texas sky at dusk. Now I suddenly have an urge to grab a cold beer.

  • @tfilter6
    @tfilter6 Před 4 lety

    Last time I had to add air to the tires in my SR22, after fighting for what must have been half an hour to get everything lined up through that little access hole on the first one and still not getting it finished, I just removed the wheel pants to add the air. Hey, 15 screws with a cordless screwdriver, for each, not too bad, took about an hour for all three off and back on. Definitely would be a lot easier without the pants. A 172, fine without pants, but on a Cirrus -- I want the pants installed. BTW, that's a nice paint job on your 172.
    And, another great informative video from a talented pilot and entertaining speaker.

  • @beachside180
    @beachside180 Před 4 lety

    Hi Josh, at least two advantages are they protect the tail from rocks thrown up from the tyres on gravel strips and when operating from wet muddy strips they keep under the wing clean from mud. Two cons are they can fill up with freshly cut grass and you can get debris caught between the Tyre and the scraper which can jam up the wheel. Personally I prefer the panties look over the naked tyres. Nothing like a little mystery and anticipation looking there!

  • @bobvorwald9737
    @bobvorwald9737 Před 4 lety

    Con. Snow I learned to fly in northern Indiana. It was a best practice for the FBO to remove wheel pants in winter. Packed snow from the runway would pack into the wheel pant on the runway. This happened to me when I was about 17 years old and on a solo flight. Shortly after landing the left main locked up and the next thing you know I’m facing another plane on final (they did a go around). As a student I assumed I had done something catastrophic like breaking the gear. I shut down the engine jump out and inspect the gear. No obvious issues I push the plane backwards the wheel skidded a couple inches then pushed out a load of packed snow. Freeing up the wheel immediately. Relieved that I hadn’t rode the plane I taxied back to the FBO. (FYI uncontrolled airport, Valparaiso Indiana and about 40 years ago.

  • @ryanryessir
    @ryanryessir Před 4 lety

    On the Cessna 172S NAV III POH/PIM it states that increase true airspeed about 2 KTS for wheel pants which is completely negligible in the grand scheme of things. In addition I think the practicality like you mentioned is the main reason for removing them. Upkeep on the mains and nose is so much easier, weight reduction even if a few pounds, easier visual preflight inspection, able to "kick the tires", less issue with getting grass and dirt in them etc. Just so many pro's to the 172 not having wheel pants

  • @adamthomas1234
    @adamthomas1234 Před 4 lety

    Loved this video Josh. Can you do a video on performance planning? For example planning and flying a given power percentage based on a given pressure altitude and temperature. Best economy and best power... stuff like that.

  • @markploeger8624
    @markploeger8624 Před 4 lety +2

    Reduced drag from wheel pants is also gonna improve your total flight time (slightly). Reduced drag means you are going to be at a slightly lower throttle/rpm to fly at a given speed, so you get slightly better fuel burn at a given flight condition. That said, if the drag is only enough to barely change your top-end speed, the throttle/rpm/fuel burn rate change will probably be barely noticeable at cruise, if you notice it at all. The faster you fly, the more benefit you'll get.

  • @Organsk8er
    @Organsk8er Před 4 lety

    Good commentary. And big points for using the clip from McClintock!

  • @rikspector
    @rikspector Před 4 lety +1

    While watching the VLOG, I had another question.
    Are there special tires for Bush or gravel/grass runway landings?
    If tes, are they very expensive and are they less efficient?
    Cheers,
    Rik Spector

  • @monacosfranz4202
    @monacosfranz4202 Před 4 lety

    Nice video. I was actually wondering why you’re not putting the wheelpants back on. I agree thought that it’s not worth the money if it comes out of your own pocket 😉
    We operate a C182T out of a grass strip and we have the wheelpants on in the summer and take the mains of in the winter due to the ice and snow. Otherwise the slush freezes in the wheel pants and locks the wheels.
    I would like to have more videos like this. Very interesting to get some insights.

  • @ranjrog
    @ranjrog Před 4 lety

    Excellent discussion of the topic! I’ve often wondered why you didn’t have them on N80991 and have debated the pros and cons of keeping then on my 172M as well. When you removed them, I assume a new weight and balance was required? Did you re-weigh the plane or just do the calculations?

  • @fredtaylor1915
    @fredtaylor1915 Před 4 lety

    Great vid. Answered the wheel pant question. If your fixed plane goes less then 150mph, don't need. Above 150mph, probably helps plus usable load is not a problem.

  • @RobertForslund
    @RobertForslund Před 4 lety +10

    That bottle opener is wicked! Now I wish I had one, or two or fifty! 🤔
    You should totally fit N80991 with bush tires! 😀👍

    • @Newberntrains
      @Newberntrains Před 4 lety

      Unless your always flying into grass or gravel pavement is very unkind to those and chews up the tires and for 1200 for a good bush wheel yeah

    • @james1795
      @james1795 Před 4 lety

      "totally fit with bush tires"? As opposed to maybe one or two tires?

  • @lifeinmsl8650
    @lifeinmsl8650 Před 4 lety

    Heyyy!! Peep that spotted cow at the beginning there! Gotta comeback up to Wisconsin to stock back up! Especially back to oshkosh!

  • @TexTrading
    @TexTrading Před 3 lety

    Really good content! I enjoyed this format.

  • @charlesbrewer6552
    @charlesbrewer6552 Před 4 lety

    The manual for my Jabiru says Wheel Covers on for long grass and off for sand or soft surfaces.
    This makes sense as the covers are open around the wheel and would fill up with sand ect while in the long grass they part the grass and prevent "wrapping" around the wheel/axle /brake gear ect.
    I believe they make about 2-3 kts difference at cruise speed. This is not very significant for short flights by may make a difference on longer ones.
    Mine spats are in good condition so I have left them on as I do not land on sand but do operate from grass strips.
    Looking at the spats in the video, i am surprised that they cannot be repaired. Fiberglass is usually very repairable by cutting out damaged areas and putting back new glass fiber.
    no doubt you have looked at the options, so I guess you know your aircraft better than i would. I guess the labour could be expensive.
    Intersting video though.

  • @christianbiedenharn228

    25 year old pilot just south of you in San Antonio. We took our pants off our 182... living in Texas with dirt strips it just seems to make more sense. Have also thought about increasing tire ply or going full bush tires as well🤷🏻‍♂️ appreciate your channel, hope to see you in the sky!

  • @paulstein7369
    @paulstein7369 Před 4 lety +2

    Agreed! Weight loss, maintenance/safety, less damage.

  • @robertedwards4031
    @robertedwards4031 Před 4 lety

    Another great video .. can ATC ask you to transition from VFR to IFR during a flight ( how do they know if you are rated or not )

  • @triskellian
    @triskellian Před 4 lety

    Terrific bottle opener gift! I wouldn't mind one my self for the hanger.As for wheel pants, it dose help with streamlining the landing gear,especially for slicker air frames (e.g DA 40) . I agree that for accessing the wheels for servicing,it's much easier without them.

  • @benholm5727
    @benholm5727 Před 4 lety

    I’m with you on this one. I have a 152 and weight is everything! It removed 20lbs with the metal plates and bolts. And I like to see the tires! Looks better!!

  • @miksal26
    @miksal26 Před 3 lety

    I took off in a glider with a shrouded mainwheel. As we climbed out behind the tug I could smell burning. That was very puzzling.
    I immediately returned and ,after pulling the aircraft off the field I discovered heavily impacted dead grass jammed in the wheel shroud.
    It took the rest of the day to pull all of this grass out of the shroud because I would have had to pull the aircraft to pieces to remove it
    .
    Back in 1963 I was in an emergency landing in a 172 and the field chosen to land in was extensively waterlogged. If we had wheel pants I’m sure that we would have flipped over because of the depth of the mud.
    Cheers from Downunder👍🇦🇺🇺🇸😷😷😷

  • @wingsrhk
    @wingsrhk Před 4 lety

    You have a beautiful Skyhawk. I love the paint job. My favorite color is blue also. Wheel pants are nice, but you make good arguments for keeping them off.

  • @scarletlightning565
    @scarletlightning565 Před 4 lety +8

    More Hanger Chats with Josh please :D

  • @saltandpepper4u
    @saltandpepper4u Před 4 lety +5

    My C172S POH says to reduce TAS by 2Kts without Speed Fairings in all conditions for what it's worth.

  • @clivejohnston8534
    @clivejohnston8534 Před 4 lety +8

    Wheel fairings collect dirt and muck when operating from dirt airstrips which add more weight to the aircraft.

    • @stunna7807
      @stunna7807 Před 4 lety

      They stop wet runway spray from coating the underside of the wing, strut, nose etc. It’s basically an aerodynamic mud flap

    • @arthurbrumagem3844
      @arthurbrumagem3844 Před 2 lety

      Try washing them once in awhile

  • @ThomasGrillo
    @ThomasGrillo Před 3 lety

    Initially, I thought the Cessna was missing something without the wheel pants, but it actually makes the aircraft look bigger. Very interesting. Thanks for sharing this.

  • @paulr4074
    @paulr4074 Před 4 lety

    Great video as always. Could you do a video with some basic tips, simple maintenance, and "how-tos" for new owners? Stuff you wished you knew before you got 80991 back to the hangar.

  • @americanrambler4972
    @americanrambler4972 Před 4 lety

    Question: Would hubcaps on the mains make any difference in airflow around the wheels? I could see them providing a more finished and cleaner look to the plane. Also, without the pants, do you get “skid marks” on the bottoms of the fuselage and wings along with more splash spatter than you would running with the pants?

  • @tc104x
    @tc104x Před 4 lety

    May I add as a motorcycle enthusiast who has run at Bonneville and other motorcycle racers, we've all ditched the front wheel cover even some of the Busa turbo bikes at over 200mph gs. We all had some gain in speed or performance. The physics suggest less turbulent drag. But, its also not quite the same with in the air with out some surface contact... Im sure you've heard all the arguments. I think it looks better without pants and functionality of inspecting landing gear far out way the aesthetics...my opinion as well.

  • @182driver
    @182driver Před 4 lety

    Great video and informative, especially the pros and cons...

  • @NbenGames
    @NbenGames Před 4 lety

    What would you recommend for a kneeboard?
    would you say a standard metal board with a strap works? or would you say something like a Flyboys kneeboard be a good pick?

  • @flyingfalcon8999
    @flyingfalcon8999 Před 4 lety +1

    For 12 years my father has had a 46' Cessna 140 and after he bough her we found some original wheel pants. At 85-90 knots I really don't think they do anything but it adds to that classic aircraft look.

  • @kneedeepsnow16
    @kneedeepsnow16 Před 2 lety

    Great analysis Sir.
    I totally agree. If the pant is going to protect the aircraft from damage, I would rather spend the money on the repair not the pant. You have the purchase price, any minor repairs before the big damage & the money spent after the big damage.
    I am in your camp I think no pants make it look like an aircraft. Of course you made it clear, top speed also plays into it, if you are flying a 250 kt aero. I would still question what the drag is at that speed. If its 5-7 kts, I am still going with the less wt factor. Not to mention, the whole point of fixed gear and ignoring the 7 to15 KT difference from RG.

  • @chunkyfunkymonkey28
    @chunkyfunkymonkey28 Před 4 lety +25

    Noticed a Spotted Cow beer....only in Wisconsin, must be an Oshkosh souvenir haha

    • @bmgarrity
      @bmgarrity Před 4 lety +2

      Dinger Mike I thought the same thing.

    • @DylanMunce
      @DylanMunce Před 4 lety +1

      Yep. That caught my eye too. Best beer out there

    • @ericsundell9978
      @ericsundell9978 Před 4 lety

      Either that or he lives in WI, or close to. They don't sell outside Wisco.

    • @rammstein1903
      @rammstein1903 Před 4 lety

      Yeah I didn’t think new glarus brewing sold outside of our state

    • @brojaracing
      @brojaracing Před 4 lety

      @@ericsundell9978 he is down in Texas but he and his father come up to AirVenture every year

  • @MichaelLloyd
    @MichaelLloyd Před 4 lety +1

    I can't recall flying any Cessna with wheel pants. Maybe the 182 I did my mountain checkout in. I like being able to see the brakes, bolts, etc. during preflight.

  • @wiplashsmile
    @wiplashsmile Před 10 měsíci

    I have a 172G and am leaning towards taking them off. My only pro for leaving them on and this will sound strange at first, is for grass strips. The nosewheel pant can act as a fender to protect the prop. Piper Tri-Pacers and Colts have a little fender, I wish there was an STC for one on the 172.

  • @markvanherk1425
    @markvanherk1425 Před 4 lety

    I think the wheelpants help keep a bit of debris from hitting the horizontal stabilizer. I don't use them, though I use to have them. Flying into grass strips and gravel often I find more nicks on the stabilizer I believe from gravel chipping up off the back wheels. I don't keep them on because of tire accessibility and because mud and ice can clog them up and make you even heavier.

  • @michaelrice500
    @michaelrice500 Před 4 lety

    I fly a 1946 PA-12 on 31" tires. "Shucks, sodbuster, we don't hardly wear no pants 'round here!"

  • @CyrilDeretz
    @CyrilDeretz Před 4 lety

    I have an SR20 that was missing it's front wheel pant when I bought it. I have replaced it and can attest that I gain a little speed. I can now do 130+kts at LOP where before it was more like 125kfs. The look is also much more balanced for a Cirrus. It is a very aerodynamic design and a missing WP looked very much out of place. For a C72 I can understand your point, especially if you do bush flying.
    I agree with all you points about practicality and safety, this is indeed a big down.
    One last thing I wanted to say is gravel projected on wings and other parts of the plane without WP, that must also be one reason for their existence

  • @joshallman4409
    @joshallman4409 Před 4 lety +1

    when you’ve had one beer and feel like starting a fight...

  • @kencraft2751
    @kencraft2751 Před 4 lety +2

    Got a 182 with britches, love the way it looks but a pain to service tires.

  • @sabetel-masri923
    @sabetel-masri923 Před 2 lety

    Excellent explanation ! I do like it.. Now what about fuel consumption ? Is there any difference between having or not having wheel pants on ?

  • @alananeshansley7170
    @alananeshansley7170 Před 4 lety

    Where in Mena did you have the re-paint done? And are you satisfied? Can I ask what the cost was?

  • @cncelements6531
    @cncelements6531 Před 2 lety

    I use to be in the pro wheel pants club. Had them on my Cherokee and loved them, but was always a bit nervous landing on grass fields, especially here in Florida where grass grows 1 inch a day in the summer. Recently I was renting a Cessna 152 and I had an engine failure on a cross country flight. After making an emergency landing, I discovered a new use for wheels without wheel pants. The left wheel made a perfect seat for me to sit on in the shade of the wing while I was waiting for help to arrive..

  • @watchfordpilot
    @watchfordpilot Před 4 lety

    Do you have tyre creep marks? Despite their obvious function, if you do have wheel pants (spats) its good for lining up the valve with the access panel, mine are in the 6 o'clock position, works every time. Cheers.

  • @joelobryan1212
    @joelobryan1212 Před rokem

    I took my wheel pants off my experimental Rutan Long EZ to help cool the brakes on multiple full stop landings which heat the brakes. The LongEZ differential braking is how the EZ is steered too. Its about 5 mph slower in cruise w/o pants. But way easier to check the tires tread and inflation psi on preflight.

  • @davidrobins4025
    @davidrobins4025 Před 4 lety

    Another informative video. Thank you.

  • @flyingmaniac3827
    @flyingmaniac3827 Před 4 lety

    it,s almost 3 gallon of fuel , and you are spot on 2 to 3 knots on a good day , even if you fly long cross country leg the saving is negligible the useful weight is more valuable in my mined , keep up the good work Josh and thanks for sharing .

  • @alanrossjohnson
    @alanrossjohnson Před 4 lety +3

    Hey. That's a Spotted Cow! Josh, did you smuggle that back from EAA?? 🤣🐄🍻

  • @shermanfree598
    @shermanfree598 Před 4 lety

    Interesting thoughts. I am looking to purchase a C-172 and have been considering if I want wheel pants or not. Thanks for this!

  • @tonymorris7377
    @tonymorris7377 Před 4 lety

    Same pressure altitude. Did you correct for density? TAS?

  • @Ifly96
    @Ifly96 Před 4 lety +1

    According to the POH for the 172 Skyhawks I fly it states:
    "Cruise speeds are shown for an aircraft equipped with speed fairings. Without fairings, decrease speeds shown by 2 knots". So pretty much what Josh experienced when he tried it himself.

  • @georgew.henkel3182
    @georgew.henkel3182 Před 4 lety

    Good Point - in the South you did not mention mud. It will cake and add weight. In the North there is slush and snow. It will lock the wheels and add weight. Wheel pants in winter. You have to do a touch and go. You tap the wheels on the runway to break the ice and check wheel rotation. Then fly a circuit before full stop. Flying schools up here remove the pants.

  • @landonlasseigne1511
    @landonlasseigne1511 Před 4 lety

    I’m liking the tips and topic discussions.

  • @maxwhitmore9558
    @maxwhitmore9558 Před 4 lety

    I have a question. Did you go to flite cadets and would you recommend it?