The Future of Israel | President Jimmy Carter
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 03. 2023
- President Carter said the Israel existence was a primary issue for him and his presidency. He frequently expressed the elements necessary for Israel’s future and a Palestinian state.
- Zábava
The Israel Lobby was not yet quite as powerful when he was in office, and that is why he can call Israel an apartheid state, which is stunning coming from an American president. Today, such words could never be uttered by a President, nor a congressman, nor a senator. Such a person would be professionally destroyed today.
Not even a lowly intern has the right to question what is happening today in Gaza !
...despite it's truth and yet existing politicians justify much worse :(
Good point, 60 minutes did a program 10 plus years ago. " stories about Israel and Palestine from the archives ". Proves your comment, as prior to airing their episode. Former Israely ambassador to the US, Michael B Oren called the CEO of CBS. When asked about his call, his reply " there is a first time for everything BOB. The late Bob Simon.
The episode is still out there, worth a watch.
you didn't actually pay attention and listen. He was very clear that there is nothing even remotely like apartheid in Israel. The apartheid is in the occupied territories of Palestine, not in Israel. And plenty of US Politicians and Zionists admit that, and say it's a problem. What else beloved Jimmy said, which you probably just skimmed over, was that the "right of return" cannot be granted. That little bit right there is the most profoundly zionist statement that anyone can make.
@@taylorbarrett384 There's no such thing as Palestine today. Before the creation of the state of Israel, the region was called Palestine, and it had a flag with a Jewish star. The Arabs had a chance to have a homeland next to Israel, but they rejected the Jewish homeland. Five Arab armies attacked Israel, and Israel won the war. Jews have been living in Palestine longer than the Arabs have. Whether the idea of a Jewish homeland came from atheists or not. they knew that the Jewish people had been living there. Islam existed in the sixth century in Saudi Arabia, where Arabs came from. There is no apartheid, Jimmy wrote, Israel: Peace Not Apartheid, suggesting Israel was an apartheid state. Benny Morris changed his view on the history of Israel. There is no such thing as the Palestinian territories.
If I ever grow up. This is the type of man I would like to be.
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
Jimmy Carter, a very accomplished person in every sense of the Word, below are some of his known accomplishments:
* Nuclear physicist
* Framer
* Submarine lieutenant commander.
* Governor of Georgia
* Author
* President of the U.S.
* Home Builder
* International observer
* Habitat for humanity contributor
He was a incredible statesman & a great President. He was so ahead of his time . How sad that the USA has gone from the carters of the world to trump 😮
@@EM-lz9kg One of the worst presidents we ever had. Inflation was 20% and some issues we still paying for today.
@@vitolazlo5767 he was the very best US president in modern history. The only president with morals and principles. If he'd been given a second term, the world today would be a better place. If only because he tried to combat climate change on time. Not to mention the long term impact and cultural impact of Reagans presidency that would have been prevented.
He is also, an elder Statesman, diplomat and human rights advocate. It's too bad that he and President Eisenhower couldn't accomplish the one thing they knew the world needed most. They where the only two presidents in my lifetime that wanted to denuclearize weapons globally. Caring more about humanity as a whole than military and economic power. It's rare to have leaders like them. We were blessed that they've been some influence in our world.
Oddly similar to Trump's resume. They're essentially the same guy.
He was so under appreciated.
He seems very appreciated.
The Americans made a mistake, they voted for someone half decent
The worst president ever. Its because of him that Iran has become an enemy of the US.
In my opinion the best US president in modern history. I know it sounds extreme, but the world would look completely different if he'd been given a second term. In particular, no reaganomics or trickle down economics, no expansion of the war on drugs, a stronger EPA and an earlier start at preventing climate change and breaking up the status quo of the fossil fuel industry, no consolidation of power in the presidency, less regime change, no al qaeda, less corruption, less unemployment, a stronger social security budget. Not to mention all the other negative policies later presidents did due to the cultural impact of Reagan's tenure.
Appreciated, intelligent, but definitely not the right material to be a (great) President.
It's quite obvious.
President Carter was a true leader.
He is a man of highest level of morals within his unique intellectual capacity
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
And a hypocrite. Why didn’t he do anything about it when he was president! Smh
He did what he could do!
@@egtaha He tried his best to broker a peaceful solution. A solution that would please both parties involved. Remember. Israel is considered to be a sovereign state. Any reasonable external entity would refuse temptation to impose its will on that state.
Highest level of morals yet he wouldn't let the Palestinian refugees to come back to their land.. yeah, really moral from.him
Probably the last decent president of the United States ❤
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
why so?
@@jerrysegal2903 whyso was Chinese, not an American president.
@@jerrysegal2903 I don't think Carter was a great president but he wasn't a horrible one either. Most of the ones after him range from mid to downright awful. Bush Sr was good but that's about it. Reagan had some of the worst policies ever creating massive gap in wealth inequality and Iran Contra. Clinton and Obama were mid but Clinton did a lot of degenerate stuff in his personal life and Obama killed loads of people with his drones. Bush Jr is responsible for a million dead Iraqi's and Patriot act. Trump caused thousands and thousands of Americans deaths because he botched response to Covid. And Biden is supporting Genocide atm.
@@NobleBoss Bush Sr was the one who said "I will not apologize ever, I don't care what the facts are"
He is the President who wrote the Book ** Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid ** in 2006.
"...In the occupied territories there is a profoundly disturbing proof of a apartheid in its worse form" Jimmy Carter
President Carter was one of the best respected Presidents of the United States.
Anyone whether a president or regular person who calls Israel an Apartheid state is either willfully lying or extremely ignorant. Carter is in a high position to know better...he's willfully lying.
@sugerhitman1295 but the west bank is occupied and the people there don't have equal rights as arab israeli citizens
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 That's because they Aren't Israeli citizens....these people were governed by Jordan and now a terrorist organization the PLO. And how many times have they rejected a state simply due to the obligation to recognize Israel and end their war against her?
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 You are absolutely right they have been occupied for 75 years, this is exactly why it is apartheid. One rule for citizen, another rule for occupied. segregation and separation for occupied people, total freedom for citizens under the same ruler.
@@George_K1 thanks. U seem to be one of the few sensible persons online
I guess he deleted his comment
Last great living 🇺🇸 President.
Brilliant! So honestly direct. I remember how he was perceived as a weak president with his fire side sweater State of the Unions. No suit. No bravado. Just his speech. IMO, the best US President of the 20th century. So easy to see now. Bless you Sir!
It has been a blessing to see these video"s. Would you vote for him now?
@@everettnicely1937 I definitely would. Can’t speak for other folks though. Seems like everyone wants drama.
The smartest and wisest US President of the 20th and 21st Century!
Respect to Jimmy Carter for this advice that brings calm and confidence to me during this conflict between Israel and its neighbors today.
I am a sixty years old Egyptian and great full for president Carter who mediated and pierce between egypt and Israel some half a century ago. God bless this great president
Jimmy Carter: Once in a lifetime, One of a kind, very wise, exceptional Statesman... Bless him 🙏🏽
"Every time anyone says that Israel is our only friend in the Middle East, I can't help but think that before Israel, we had no enemies in the Middle East."--------Father John Sheehan
good point. @@jimreilly6933
🤡
Terrible President.
Amen that! I voted for him once only because his name wasn't Ford. Then I voted his lame butt out. Adios!@@ilanklinger2573
Does anyone else notice the level of conversation in this interview is light years above that which is undertaken today? Can you imagine Trump talking with the same level of understanding and clarity?
“I’m gonna come!”
They are all the same.
Could you imagine Biden speaking a complete sentence anymore?
@@uwishuknewnunya7845 Still better than Trump speaking a full sentence.
I can't imagine Trump or genocide joe.
Thank you deeply dear President Carter. Such hard work and noble attempt. Shame on us for allowing the killing and apartheid to continue. We need to live Together, all of us, and you showed us how that could happen. We lost two leaders, and too many thousands of innocents who believe military response somehow solves conflicts. gratitude to all who work toward living together.
Let’s take a chance in peace
Free the oppressed. Everyone lived in peace in Palestine before the z1onists came and built a country on top of it by mssmrdering and mssmrdering the natives
The opening comments of Jimmy Carter are so revealing and resonate to this day and time in the midst of self created conflicts
In my many years of voting, James Earl Carter was the best President.
The documentary Jimmy Carter, the Man from Plains, is great! He speaks out about his book. It's worth watching! He is a great man of honor & integrity. It sure beats what we're hearing from crazy trump.
and beats what we're hearing from corrupt biden
Well, the military of the United States has been a great source of leadership. We have to say this country is full of great candidates for president role. Many people in America are better than 🎺 Trump. 😊 When you think about it. Putin will die to be close to these great leaders. Mr. Carter was one of the most respected people in the world, when president must have been demonstrated the integrity, was a strong man from the army.
Wish we could have a great leader like him in the near future 🔮
And the puppet Biden
@@musfazahosein7463 my exact same comment of a couple days ago
removed by ? ?
A.I.drone bots make commenting futile
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
Such a good man. I hope his prayers are answered. Peace ☮️ in the Middle East.🙏🏻
ACTIONS by human beings produce solutions. NOT wishful thinking.
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
Jimmy Carter was underrated. too bad he didn't get a second term.
It's too bad? He was voted out of office for a reason.
@@MrAschiff indeed ; the M.I.C. had to get rid of him w/o pulling a kennedy like coup
Nonsense. Carter was a spineless loser in Iran.@@gaylandbarney2231
@@meetontheledge1380 LOL. Actually, I have an MA in history and have proven my point of view during my interaction with Middle East politics and that Jimmy hates Israel.
@@meetontheledge1380 Feel free to make a complete jackass of yourself and present your side of the story.
A pastor that becomes a president to a country under the control of war mongers and becomes a blessed peacemaker. What a challenge and what a tough job. By far the most Godly president I’ve ever heard of. Do you know there are kids born in Egypt after camp David, their mothers named them Carter !!
What a great soul.
So much cheap shot aggression against Carter from people. They say things like "Jimmy Carter that peanut farmer " I say "You mean Jimmy Carter the nuclear physicist " I believe his degree from Annapolis was in nuclear physics. His intelligence articulation and clarity at 80+ years of age at the time of this video stands in such contrast to the current and former president.
He may be a nuclear physicist, but he knew nothing about running a country. And he blamed the Jews for his loss to Reagan. Hence his hatred for Israel.
Brilliant! So well spoken. He did more for the cause of peace in the region than any other US President.
Mr Carter is a fool
One of the few US presidents with a set of balls.
He was god awful President, 1term loser.
I love President Carter, he is for peace for everybody
He's for war and is a big supporter of Hamas, whom the United States and the rest of the world view as a terrorist entity.
Carter is a born-again Jew-hater.
You are right he made khomeiny , IRGC,Hizbullah, hamas Taliban
No no look what he did to iran
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
A president with knowledge, intellect, elloquent, rational all in all mr. Carter had every personal quality to be admired and respected as president of the US. Maybe the last true president worthy of the title!!
The days when US Presidents actually spoke about policies and answered questions. Good old days.
A true & amazing statesman! It’s a shame that the world didn’t listen or cooperate to usher in peace in Israel & Middle East.
The Zionists have turned the Holy Land in to the Horror land in only seventy five years !
Exactly, they didn't listen, and they do not want to listen now 👂
الله محبه ❤️ 🌹 ☮️ 🤗 الحمد والشكر لله يا كريتر على التكرير وعفوا من التأخير
مرحبا 👋 ❤️ 🌹 ☮️ فلسطين 🇵🇸 عربيه للأبد 🌟 نجمها عالي حجاره التحرير
اعز الناس كريتر يا بترول 🐻 🇾🇪 كلها 🤲 💌 🌿 سلااااام. من قلب ♥ لا تفجير
لا وهابيه ولا اخونجي. ولا جاسوس إيران 🇮🇷 والشقيقه الكبرى والإماراتي الصهيوني تفكير
أثنى عشر مليون مواطن عربي يمني يتضوررن جوعا في اليمن 🇾🇪 قبيلي التحرير
لو بيسمع الكلام ربنا يصبر قلبي ♥️ المحارب معكم على الجراثيم والرواتب الله تكبير
تكبيرات العيد بصوت عالي جدا جدا جدا ♥️ 🌹 🎙️ ☮️ السلام عليكم ورحمة وتفسير
مستقبل باهر. إذا سمعو الكلام. 😊 🙏 جميلك يا جيمي الله أكبر ❤️ تكبير
مستقبل السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته ✌️ 😊 يلعن الشيطان الرجيم ويبدأ التغيير ✒
ما حد يقبل منا ومنكم الارهاب مرفوض. والقرصنه و الصومله الإيرانيه التعبير
محطة 🚉 كريتر تصفي النفط والغاز الطبيعي اليمني يا 📿 مسلمين خافو الله يا البعير
العيب اسود في 🇵🇭 الفلبين. والله اكبر. هو دين 🌿 ☮️ الإسلام دين رحم ورحمه لا غير
بلغو 🍇 عننا 🌻 ♥️ العظمى ستظل عظيمه بفضل الله ثم بفضل الشعب السعودي كن أمير المؤمنين والمؤمنات والمسلمين اجمعين يارب العالمين 🌼 🤲 🇸🇦 والمسرات لها نسير
This guy enabled the Islamic revolution in Iran! Iran now is the main backer of Hamas! He sounds peaceful but deep down his motives are devilish.
He definately lived a decent moral life.
The truth is here ❤
Thank you, Mr. Carter! I wish we had a President in office right now who was able to speak with such integrity and moral clarity as you did.
A great President of America.
Excellent interview
Jimmy Carter was one of our best Presidents. I agree with his ideas on the Israeli/Palestinian issue.
how did this america slip away under our nose?? This is america to the core. Discussions over the table but strong leadership and call it out for what it is. Carter touched me when he answered, I did more for israel and helped them more than anything, then he said he support isarael within the "legal border of israel" wow! The talking point and even with this type of specific detailed part it literally sounds like it was yesterday. I was dumfounded when I realized in todays information world how is it possible that I just found out about palestine and this was going on for the last 75 years. I really want to know what else is hidden from us, and what is really history, and what are we?? this is so troubling.
Good old times... when america was ruled by americans.
One of kind. Mr. President ❤️🕊️
Once again we are seeing a true American HERO!
The last great president!
Thank you for speaking out! What seems to be an obvious horrific mistake continues.
A sane American
I'm praying for the two leaders to come today.
Guys you have about 11 months left. President Carter will turn 100 on October 1st 2024, and I sure hope and pray that he lives that long to see his 100th birthday! And to see the fruits of his labor on this matter fulfilled so that when he departs this life he would know that he had done a good deed towards Mankind! I love this man, I think of him as the best role model to aspire to be… and I wish him well!
Hacer viral esto
thank yu so much exPresident Carter
More people need to watch this video in current times.
And decades later thinks are worse......shame on us
One of the most incredible Presidents that the USA ever had .
The most underappreciated President of Our Era.
A very sensible and righteous man. God bless Mr. Carter.
President Jimmy Carter is one of the extremely rarest morally upright human breed that exist on this earth today. Long live great President. I am sure that God has a very nice place setup in Paradise for you & your late wife.
Peace comes through the love of the others.
Carter was a real hope for peace in the middle east. Let's hope our current leaders can see their way to a peaceful resolution.
To late
Nonsense. He made things worse.
If you think that a US president can make peace in middle East - you are part of the problem
@JeffShacter it's funny how the same bigots who today would make the case that Israel doesn't have the right to the legitimate self-defense of its people against unprovoked rocket attacks still praise the bigot from plains Georgia for essentially having made the same argument.
@@JeffShacter
Carter made things worse ? How come ?
He's got a point that it's up to the mothers to bring peace in the land.
I hope and pray that he is NOT AWARE of what is happening now. He always held great hope for them to find a way to live in peace 😢
Your not to old ,ever , to be president. You have had your turn but I wish you were running now. ♥️
I wish he is the current president
Carter is a great humanitarian, but my memories of him as president aren't all that happy.
He’s 99 years old
@@user-pr8zn6iw5t may I ask what those memories are?
He's a 99 year old failure.@@BigWilt2000
With my respects, Sir.
Carter president is great 👍 👌 😂❤
When it comes the character one of our best presidents . Just think if we had been successful in rescuing just some of the Iranian hostages back in 79 this guy would have won by a Landslide! About the most important thing to remember about the 1980 election is that even though both Carter and Reagan had very different views on things, just like the majority of people that have run for office in this country, they had character and they were good men we're good men. I never felt like everything's going to hell. Until 2016
Morality is what the society lost.
Israel tell world I am higher than you. None you can stop me. Even America which help him.
We need this man’s spirit and compassion today. Unfortunately, that ain’t gonna happen.😢
An American president
Borders have to be firmly defined and then segregation of who wants to be where Israel going ones there and Palestinians to their territory, where is the question of conflict when borders are clearly defined, legal like rest of world is. then what they do in their nations is further to be seen, such tiny nano nations exist in Europe why not in middle east.. where is the problem ?, problem is boundaries, just for sake of small pieces of lands you are killing the innocent public caught in it.
🗽.
#OnlyAccountability.
#TwoStateSolutionREALITY.
#WarCrimesareWarCrimes.
The world loves President Carter.
look at the vast contrast in Carter's bright pleasant demeanor compared to the leaders in Israel like Netanyahu, Ghant and Smotrich, who all snear, growl and emit pure hatred when talking.
LOl. The American citizens don't. That's why he was voted out of office. A weak president who blamed his loss to Reagan on the Jews.
The one place where money has no sway is where we all end up. St Peter at the Golden Gate - He's got a special place for Benjamin Netanyahu, and I've heard its hot....
Great humanitarian, did so much good work in his life. Respect for him and his presidency❤❤
The only honest president ever !
Love this man ❤
Real bone of contention
She’s was the best president of America and how was so kind man l respect him so much good pleas him president jimmy carter
PRESIDENT KARTER IS THE MAN OF PEACE❤
He finished by, "I pray God"
What a Soul.
A perfect oposite of a Zionist.
He definately lived a decent moral life.
And ignorant people will say that the dispute started on October 7???
It’s amazing that you can critique Israel without having to clarify that you don’t support Hamas every other sentence.
Like Jimmy Carter said:
APAC is not dedicated to peace in the holy land
Yes, they are. Israel has made numerous peace offers to the Palestinians. AIPAC supports a two-state solution, except that the Palestinians have rejected every offer that's been made to them. Just ask Bill Clinton, who said he broke his back to create a Palestinian state, only for Yassir Arafat to turn him down. This rejection of peace by the Arabs has been going on since the 1930s. In 1948, the Jews and the Arabs were offered a state side-by-side, Israel accepted, but the Palestinian Arabs rejected a Jewish state next to them. Five Arab armies attacked the nascent Jewish country, and Israel won. It's the Palestinians who've rejected peace.
When Anwar Sadat signed a peace treaty with Israel in 1979, Arafat’s PLO called for Egypt to be boycotted. The Arab states adopted that boycott and prevented Cairo from participating in the Arab League from 1977 until 1989. Most Arab ambassadors in Egypt were recalled and Arabs visiting Egypt were considered either traitors or spies.
Jimmy Carter was dedicated to war in the Middle East, Sparky.
Learn how to speak and communicate well! Jimmy Carter, blessings to him!
"In the occupied territories there is a profoundly disturbing proof of apartheid in its worst form, and I would say it is much more damaging, in some ways, to the Palestinians under the subjection and domination of Israel, even than the black people suffered in South Africa"
No wonder AIPAC took this man down after the first term.
Mr Carter you are a fellow brother in Christ. The days of Noah are here.
He just SOUNDS more sympathetic to the Palestinian side, Charlie, because almost 80% of Americans, and especially Orthodox Jews, are always screaming about ANYONE who dares to be neutral and NOT take sides--something America does NOT understand although most of the rest of the world does. Carter is right here and deserves much praise for his guts by using Apartheid, which is exactly what it is! A great American here.
He is the only one so sincere to solve the disputes between Palestine and Israel.
Are you trying to be put on a watch-list lol? Im not pro-Israel btw.@@jalissatorres2607
The jewish lobby does not allow todays politicians to take any side but theirs ! some say that it is greed which drives todays congressmen, but I think it more to do with fear. Fear of losing their political positions and power.
@@susandeleon4702
While China has done much and in gigantic proportions to save lives in the middle east, America has gone the opposite route. Unless the US refrains from further blocking China's efforts in the UN Security Council to resolve the fighting in Gaza Israeli war crimes there would continue unabated!
For starters. Israel is not an Apartheid state. The Palestinians do not live in Israel, and they are not citizens. There are two million Arabs that live in Israel, and they vote and serve in the Knesset and in the Judicial system. They are not required to serve in the military. How many Jews live in Muslim countries. There are roughly twenty-five Muslim countries that surround Israel, which is the size of New Jersey. Where's your complaint about Iran, which is being run by Mullahs thanks to Jimmy's weakness. These Mullahs kill gays and women who seek their rights. Same with the men who want a secular state. Libya imports Africans for slavery. Saudi Arabia, like Iran, has strict Sharia Law. Israel has made peace with 6 Arab countries, four of which came in the Abraham Accords. Obviously, they see Israel, which has made great contributions to the world in its 75 years of existence, then the Muslims have in the last 1,000 years.
Jimmy Carter was very different from most USA's politicians. He was decent and morally healthy. RIP
And rightly a Nobel laureate
Very mixed feelings seeing this today. I see a lot of good will and idealism in Jimmy Carter. But looking back it seems like it failed terribly. The US should have handled this tougher from the beginning. It was obvious that apartheid on the one side and terrorism on the other would be a ticking timebomb.
What is currently happening is just making it worse. The US should take its role seriously and bring order in this terrible mess. Which unevitably means being tough towards both sides.
يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا إِن جَاءَكُمْ فَاسِقٌ بِنَبَإٍ فَتَبَيَّنُوا أَن تُصِيبُوا قَوْمًا بِجَهَالَةٍ فَتُصْبِحُوا عَلَىٰ مَا فَعَلْتُمْ نَادِمِينَ (6) وَاعْلَمُوا أَنَّ فِيكُمْ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ ۚ لَوْ يُطِيعُكُمْ فِي كَثِيرٍ مِّنَ الْأَمْرِ لَعَنِتُّمْ وَلَٰكِنَّ اللَّهَ حَبَّبَ إِلَيْكُمُ الْإِيمَانَ وَزَيَّنَهُ فِي قُلُوبِكُمْ وَكَرَّهَ إِلَيْكُمُ الْكُفْرَ وَالْفُسُوقَ وَالْعِصْيَانَ ۚ أُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الرَّاشِدُونَ (7)
Great !
Impossible. As long as one side has an arrogant "Super power" acting as its pimp.
Adequate and fair compensation.❤
Only rational politicians.
❤
What about President Carters part in the Indonesian Invasin of the Island of Timor ????
If only Biden had Carter’s faith and intellect, so many lives could have been saved.
How can one talk of peace if land has been stolen?? Restore that & all other injustices, restore Internstional law & Human rights & there you are!! Why appease & gice Any rights to the Perpetrator..????
exactly ! wtf did the Israelis lose ? absolutely nothing ! they didnt go thru a quarter of what the palestinians have been thru for the past 75 years . its sickening when we talk about this issue as if the land was empty and it was a best man wins situation . it was colonized and ethnically cleansed, end of story
Brilliant man
😂l I would personally say that that’s the smartest president we’ve ever had
If only Biden would learn from Carter and stop promoting violence as a solution.
Charlie Rose's body language is atrocious. He comes across as such an arrogant person. Carter was amazing, as usual
Giving others rights to others
He talk the truth❤👑