Which Scholars Have Refuted Abu Khadeeja?
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 08. 2024
- Some people say that Shaykh Wasiullah Abbas is wrong in his criticism, however he is 100% correct. He refuted Abu Khadeeja for implementing fatawa on divorce despite having no qualifications, this is something that Abu Khadeeja admitted to doing in this video. Secondly the accusation of causing division amongst the ummah is correct, even Shaykh Saleh Al Suhaymee refuted Abu Khadeeja for the same reason.
With regards to Shaykh Tahir Wyatt, I definitely don’t support his recent move to Yaqeen Institute. However there’s no doubt that Abu Khadeeja oppressed Shaykh Tahir Wyatt when he was in Medina, to the point where scholars came out and defended him.
If anyone has any questions about any doubtful matters, don’t post them here. You could be spreading your doubts to others and also someone in the comments might give you a wrong answer. Ask Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan via the following two emails:
abdulrahman@kalemah.org
questions@amau.org
#spubs
#abukhadijah
#salafi
Some people say that Shaykh Wasiullah Abbas is wrong in his criticism, however he is 100% correct. He refuted Abu Khadeeja for implementing fatawa on divorce despite having no qualifications, this is something that Abu Khadeeja admitted to doing in this video. Secondly the accusation of causing division amongst the ummah is correct, even Shaykh Saleh Al Suhaymee refuted Abu Khadeeja for the same reason.
With regards to Shaykh Tahir Wyatt, I definitely don’t support his recent move to Yaqeen Institute. However there’s no doubt that Abu Khadeeja oppressed Shaykh Tahir Wyatt when he was in Medina, to the point where scholars came out and defended him.
*If anyone has any questions about any doubtful matters, don’t post them here. You could be spreading your doubts to others and also someone in the comments might give you a wrong answer. Ask Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan via the following two emails:*
abdulrahman@kalemah.org
questions@amau.org
Sometimes people go astray after they are oppressed. So we should not oppress anyone even after they make a mistake or two.
How can we call shiekh wasiullah Abbas
In my personal opinion, I believe Tahir Wyatt “Joined” yaqeen to give then dawah. Ive known students of knowledge who’ve done similar in the past, but ppl a quick in their judgement and mistaken then to be amongst those whom they are trying to advise. All these ppl that talk on Tahir Wyatt, how many of them have actually tried to get in contact with him to speak about the issue? To the point some are even calling him an innovator but can’t even point out his innovation. As I said this is my opinion nd , Allah knows best.
Ya akhi ibrahim I hope you see this I saw you interacting with al firqatu an-najiyah on their channel akhi keep up the good work they will be asked on yawn al qiyama for splitting up the people who are upon haqq just carry on doing the good work I'm telling you the stuff they say has had more affect on me to the point I started questioning myself if I was on the haqq, y? Because a sheikh who's upon salafiyya they warn against and this is exactly what abu mussab said. They worry me more than any sufi, ikhwani, tablighi, secularist, atheist, missionary, because a man who is upon salafiyya will in sha Allah never fall for this, but when another man is upon the sunnah warning against people of the sunnah it causes a lot of problems, it is important you warn against them
@@solodolo4235 Bro tahir defended Jalal's paper which said B. Adam can be with non Bani Adam, not good, & a group pushing disbelief, his manhaj or method is wrong. It reminds me of surah Qafeerun, though we don't make takfir of yaqin, the likes of jonathan aid disbelief to say its ok to insult the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him!
This generation is horrible. May Allah deal with anyone and everyone who tries to turn Salafiyah into a cult accordingly. And that goes for everyone. These days no one makes excuses for their brothers, everyone is quick to judge, quick to made tabdee' and slander each other.
May Allah (SWT) protect us.
اللهم آمين
Agreed , May Allah protect us akhi , some says hes deviant some say other scholar is deviant , and scholars are fighting among each other , its a time of confusion , we are living in era of confusion .
@@muhammadtalhanayyar8994It's been that way for a really long time. Learn the history of Islam and you will learn that more often than not various scholars of Islam due to ideological, political, and personal motives would accuse each other of deviant and even did takfeer. Learn history (with open heart)! That's how I saved myself from this confusion and kept my distance from these foolish scholars who bicker all the time. Alhamdulillah!
If you keep listening to them I am afraid you all would lose your iman. Please, save yourself!
I love Sheikh Wasiullah Abbas for the sake of Allah
Where are you from
How ironic that the slogan raised by SPUBS is to be careful whom you take your knowledge from, yet their head Abu Khadeejah has not undergone any formal studying. No basic study of Arabic, no basic study of fiqh or usool ul fiqh or any real basic study of the fundamental disciplines that any student of knowledge MUST have, yet he has put himself forward to give fatawa make tabdiee and that's fine with his club members. Really people need to wake up and stop this despicable partisanship.Allah's help is to be sought
Their actions are beyond cringe-worthy. It is really hard to comprehend their reckless nature. Like, even here in South-India, when we become known amongst our local scholars, we will suddenly become super careful and responsible like never before. We'll be very conscious in our conduct so that our scholars should never ever get bad perception about us. Even when mishaps happen, we would rush to make it straight, and get back to our scholars. And I'm sure that is how it is with students of knowledge who tread the path of the scholars.
These people, in striking contrast, get all the condemnation under the sky from scholars and Tullaabul ilm GLOBALLY, forget the local ones. In fact, our Late Shaykh RK Noor Mohammed رحمه الله too had condemned them in multiple occasions. Allahul Musta'aan. May Allah grant us insight and keep us all sincere and steadfast upon haqq.
I still haven't a clue who is this Abu Khadeeja, what's happening I don't understand
@@syedmohammedhussain799 If you don't know him but know salafi scholars say Alhamdulilah at this point, as someone who used to listen to him, you can focus on ilm and miss alot of unneccessary dishonest drama!
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 but what's this madkhali thing I want to know because one person says don't listen to them and another says do
@@syedmohammedhussain799 Madkhali is the name of a tribe, they have many scholars, but some of their so called students like Abu Khadijah and co. are dishonest & spread lies between them. View : **Abdul Wahid al-Madkhali Lying & Slandering Shaykh Muhammad bin Hadi al-Madkhali** - By Nasir Al Hanbali!
@@syedmohammedhussain799 Hope that helps brother, for now to be honest stick with learning Islam and away from the drama.
Go to channels like people of knowledge or scholarly subtitles or Pure Islaam or Knowledge North or Farid Responds etc.
How did they mix up so much good work with hizbiya? May Allah guide us.
Which good work? I can’t think of a lot. They are marginally better than some sects in aspects of aqeedah because they do not (generally) join partners with Allah. However they are not free from errors in aqeedah - their heads suffer from irjā’ for example.
@@si-5814 When you speak be just. They have tremendous good works. The oppression of fellow Muslims is totally Haraam and problematic. But as Muslims we know that they have a lot of good works, may Allah rectify their mistakes and ours!
@@si-5814 Stop lying and dont speak without knowledge. Abu Khadeejah has numerous major scholars behind him who support him 100%.
@@ReturningBackToAl-HaqqBe just, They have sheikh rabee ibn hadi, Sheikh ubayd al jabiri(rahimahullah), sheikh falah mandakar(rahimahullah) who mentions even abdullah al ghudayan(rahimahullah) praise for them, akhi and this is what i know from my head.
@@ReturningBackToAl-Haqq sheikh abdullah bukhari, sheikh muqbil, sheikh hassan al banna, sheikh ubayd al jabiri, sheikh falah mandakar and so on. who praised you?
Abu Khadeejah is not a student of knowledge, by arab standards, he is primary school standards. But the one eyed is the king in the land of the blind.
His mistake was when he assumed that he is a shaykh and knowledgeable. Self amazement is destructive. May Allah save us from that.
Arab standards? Are you serious?
This is the deen of Allah standards, and the prophet Muhammad pbuh is standards and salf !
Shaikh WasiAllah, who criticised Abu khdejah is knowledge is Indian .
Rightly said lol one eyed man is king
BarakAllahu feekum for your efforts akhi but with all due respect I don't think we need to focus on refuting Abu Khadeejah as his words carry no significance. He should be asked to present his academic qualifications so that we all know who we are taking knowledge from and these qualifications can be presented to any reputable scholar. As shaykh salih al usaymi mentioned it takes approx about 12 -15 years of sitting under scholars to become a competent student of knowledge so let's just request AK to see his credentials
This Western orientalist concept of degrees has given a false narrative! Ilm isn't based on how many degrees (wall receipts) one has! 🤔 Aren't there going to be scholars in the hellfire? I personally will not take my religion from a man that invites politicians into the masjid even if he has 10 PHD's and 5 Double Masters! I would rather benefit from someone who only sat under a scholar of Sunnah for 1 yr. The one that has 1 yr it's possible for him to have been given by Allaah something that wasn't given to the PHD! Kufar have degrees in Islamic studies!!! 🤔
They can simply speak with Sheikh in Urdu. Why pretend to be an arabic fluent?😂😂. Sheikh Wasi ullah understands the urdu language easy.
+Osama Manan2 I would like him to speak with Umar Siddique and put an end to his fitna once n for all.
Yes Sheikh Wasiullah Abbas is from Uttar Pradesh, India my state. Urdu/Hindi is his mother tongue.
@@atravellerindunya4433 what fitna ?
@@sunnahnotes1451 Just some controversy that happened in Pakistan. Its over Alhamdulillah (atleast for now)
@@atravellerindunya4433 Umar siddique doesn't respect scholars, I think you should avoid him. For impressing the rawaafidh and the barelvi, he overdoes his position about Yazeed. The scholars in islamic history have never fought themselves for this reason, therefore Umar Siddique should do Astaghfar and back down.
At the beginning when he talked about Abdul Rahman and his wife, is this referring to Abdul Rahman Hassan?
Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh
For Sunni brothers it is important to know that for a sunni making mistakes is not same as someone who make innovation in deen and call to it.
الله المستعان, These people like Abu Khadeejah have tainted the image of Salafiyyah and because of this Ikhwanis like MH and his friends ridiculously rant about Salafiyyah
@W Brother be just they literally have a channel dedicated to exposing SPUBS, though i'm not in agreement with them in their methodology.
@@a-n3135 They attack salafiyyah akhi.
I don't disagree. However my comment was aimed at the brother who said that they don't attack SPUBS, they clearly do. And if you mean that SPUBS embodies the totality of the salafiyyah dawah and that attacking them means attacking the Salafi manhaj, then that is completely incorrect.
@@a-n3135 You are right, they've dedicated that channel against SPUBS, but in the diguse of attacking SPUBS they also take a swipe at other duaat who're not affiliated with SPUBS like Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan, Abu Mussab, Dawah Man and so on, Like recently Ali "needs" Dawah made a video of "advising" Abu Mussab on that very same channel, Please go and check it out if you don't believe me;
@@_FarisSharif_ I took another look at the channel and I stand corrected. They seem to be lumping some of the brothers that are not affiliated with SPUBS with them in their critiques, attempting to muddy the waters.
it's serious when any of the ulama have thier name in your mouth in regards to warning against you even if it's 1 of them not to mention 3, 4 or 5. shaykh Albani Rahimahullah has a good book on the issue of boycotting and one thing he mentioned is this boycotting done today is harmful because the Muslims are weak so if you boycott everyone who will be left? he mentioned even if your friends with someone doesn't pray. you shouldn't boycott him perhaps this will cause him to go further into his sins. you being someone who prays may be able to guide him back to what's correct and have good influence on him. I personally have dealt with this and giving someone who wasn't praying dawah for 3 years and I walked in the masjid and his face was wet from Wudu. I was extremely happy for him. but in other cases i have left people who didn't pray because they also engaged in other sins openly whereas the other didn't. so one must understand when to do this and usually it doesn't correct person because he may not care as albani mentioned. I advise others to read this book in Sha Allah it's very insightful. I remember a salafi imam told me he's free of me in this life and the next because we had a disagreement treated me like i wss kaffir or rapist what could I have done to warrant this? I have the same aqidah as him but this still didn't stop him from boycotting me along with others who were stuck to his crooked menhaj rather than the menhaj of the prophet Salallahu alayhi wa sallam. not to mention i even tried to be the better one and apologize to make islah and still he kept this stance. as i got older and continued studying I realized im not the problem it's these brothers who put thier feelings and emotions before Allah and His Messenger. now I live ina Muslim country alhumdulillah and this imam who said he is free of me has yet to free himself from living with the non Muslims in America. these people will separate from their brothers but have kuffar as neighbors whom their kids play with and know. we all have a problem with this because we all know it to be contrary to what Allah and His Messenger command us with.
beware of this Cult
is that the only thing he has done wrong? should i not listen to him at all? im a bit confused if someone can help clear this thing up cuz i like shamsi he speaks haqq and he promotes abu kadijah, therefore should i not listen to them? jazak Allah khair
Stay away from spubs, none of them have any formal qualifications. Listen to Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan and the brothers at Salafi Events UK like Ustadh Abul Abbas Naveed.
@@ibmsulaymani i listen to Abdurrahman Hassan he is good but bro why would i stay away from shamsi when he gives clear proofs, even if he doesnt have formal qualifications. this whole thing makes no sense i feel like each side just wants to attack the other... i understand not listening to ikhwanis but ditching shamsi doesnt make sense to me.
@@kingyousif8768 Shamsi is better than those at spubs, but he promotes their distorted understanding unfortunately. I’ve met shamsi in real life and he’s a good brother, I don’t warn against him, but I would recommend you to stick those who are qualified.
@@ibmsulaymani ok thank you for your clarification!
Of course I don’t like this division amongst the brothers, but there’s a reason why scholars have warned against this group. The amount of fitna they’ve been causing has been going on for decades, may Allah rectify our affairs.
please where is sahaba path YT channel
Brother you should make a footnote Tahir has been warned against legitimately for working with yaqin!
He hasn’t. Nice try though
@@kennethtaylor6534 yaqeen institute is evil
@@kennethtaylor6534 Tahir Wyatt works proudly with Yaqeen institute.
@@mirsadgll well from your own logic and how you and your group (spubs) refutes, shouldn’t the ‘Ulema who are staying silent be warned against for not warning against Taahir by name and making his evil known to the people? These major scholars who recognize him as a scholar. Where are the warnings against him like they’ve warned against Yusuf Al qardawi and the likes? Please show me the warnings against him from major scholars. I’ll wait. Thanks.
@@kennethtaylor6534 Name 5 scholars of the ulama who even know who tahir wyatt is. I don’t even think 3 proper scholars know who Tahir Wyatt is. Besides the point. Let’s say the scholars know about him but haven’t made a public refutation, does that immediately mean that the person is upon haqq? Your logic makes no sense at all. The fact that Tahir is with Yaqeen is already a no go.
Baarak Allaahu Feek
SubhanAllah. Their story with sheikh salim al tawil is honestly shocking. I've tried my best to have good thoughts of the brothers in SPUBS. This is just too much. This is straight-up hizbi behaviour. While they may have valid criticisms of some individuals who actually water down the deen, how is it that every time someone talks in another masjid or sits with someone other than spubs he's automatically an innovator or a so called 'mumayi''. WAllahi it's very disappointing. And with all respect to abu khadeejah, what are his qualifications to be making tabdee' left right and centre on individuals.
What jobs do scholars do? Like I want to practice the deen and earn a living. Also what job does ustadhs like abdulrahman hassan do?
I think uah is in finance industry in uae.
@@GMTI178 huh? What’s uah? Yeah
@@MohamedAhmed-rf5bk uah is ustadh abdulRahman Hassan
You do realize being a judge a lawyer, is something you pay for.
@@GMTI178 1017 lol
How are the good people to learn from in regard to the truth of Qura. And sunnah.. aside from of course reading Quran for self and going to the sahih ahadeeth of the prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salaam.. who can I go to , to listen to..to learn from. Becuase I live in the USA. And there's a lot of confusion here. One time someone called me a salafi. As an Insult. I had to go home and look up the term as such , becuase I'm a revert woman who takes her reading seruoisly.. so basically it said that salafi is one who take thier guidance from quran. From the prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salaam and from the righteous predecessors.. then when I went more to look into salafi manhaj all I find was people like abu kahdeeja . I don't know where to turn. So I turn to Allah and the prophet ..can someone give me some good resources that have been translated to English for the benefit of my learning thus amazing deen
Also from what I've heard from abu khadeejah I have benefit from.
Asalamwalikum Warahamatullahi Wabarakatu. I really understand where you are coming from. This things are causing confusion among the Ummah, especially for a revert like you it must make it really hard to deal with. Check out Al-madrastu Al umarriyah. It is fillled with beneficiary knowledge.By the way, there is no doubt you will find beneficiary knowledge in the works of Abu Khadeejah. I actually enjoy watching brother Shamsi(He promotes Abu Khadeejah), but when it comes to refuting one another, it just gets out of hand to the point of tastlesness. Anyhow, may Allahﷻ guide them and us and keep all of us on the straight path. May Allahﷻ make things easy for you in your journey of learning this religion as well.
@@saimaasiya99 oh and also try learning Arabic. You probably thought of it already maybe, but I suggest you make it a priority
جزاك الله خيرا
Is this the imam of hendon masjid in London.? Abu khadeejah
No he's not one of the imam there
He's the imam of wright street masjid in birmingham
Is abu khadeeja good scholar
Not a scholar but a good daee most definitely, has done a lot for salafiyah in the west
NO! Stay away from him! They are manipulating scholars to get them to refute people of their choosing! Everything about him goes against the classical scholars approach to knowledge..and he hasn’t ANY knowledge from any reputable source.
Yes he is. Don't listen to the rumours online. Just listen to his lectures on any book of aqeedah and you'll realise the level of his knowledge.
BarakAllahu feek
@@JimmyJhonny
Look up the hadith of Banu Qurayza mentioned by Bukhari. "Do not pray asr except in Banu Qurayza". The sahaba were split down the middle, half taking it figuratively and the other taking it literally. Both were correct. Look up what Imam Malik said when he was told to compile the Muwatta to be used as the sacred law by the caliph.."Indeed you have restricted something that is vast". Sheikh bin Uthaymeen, the "Salafis" Madhab (Ironic) said this would happen. Learn about Imam Malik's Muwatta, Imam Shafi'i's Risalah, etc to learn your deen ie the first books of Fiqh and Usool al fiqh (the basis of recent scholars). These scholars are taking from their works as their base, and mind you using the "sharh" generations after, where references are lost. Get your knowledge from the source! Follow the sunnah not Salifiyah! Take your knowledge seriously, like a science. READ. READ alot. And you will find the "Salafis" are babies in knowledge, drip fed knowledge, studies on youtube and has never opened a Magnum Opus of any great classical scholar of the past. Use the brain Allah the Sublime gave you, to open a book of ibn Al Qayyim and applying reason to realize the "manhaj of the salafis" have restricted something so vast.
@@JimmyJhonny😂😂😂😂 ya miskeen 😂😂😂 Since when Abu khadeejah become a scholar?? Is he even qualify for student of knowledge??🤷🏽♂️😂 my guy can’t speak Arabic “ لا دخلنا" a middle school student can’t even make such grammatical mistakes, and you call him a scholar smh🤦🏽♂️
How did Spubs become popular or big?
Hard work , teaching people , built Good relationships with some scholars
Because they are upon Haqq and Allah aided them
Because of the tarbiyah they brought into the communities since the time of our shaykh Dawud Burbank Rahimahullaah 30+ years from now..
@@Afif.anNayem.asSalafiYes Shaikh Dawud Burbank was a good scholar.But Abu Khadeejah is deviant he is targetting scholars like Shaikh Sulayman Al Ruhayli.
@@JimmyJhonnyBlind followers of Spubs.What qualifications your Abu Khadeejah has?Nothing.Then he is not a scholar.You should learn from scholars with qualifications and not this CZcams Daee.
Can i send money and support Yaqeen institute?
why would you do something so stupid?
Don't do that