Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Pirates of the Caribbean 3 (Inspired by Th3Birdman)
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 11. 2022
- Pirates of the Caribbean is one of my favorite franchises, at least the first three. Th3Birdman has already tackled CinemaSins' video on Dead Man's Chest, and that was back in 2020, so I decided to tackle my favorite of the series, At World's End. They really mucked up all the nitpicks of this movie, and I have pointed most of them out. I don't hate CinemaSins, but it's definitely not a good series of videos. Anyways, enjoy.
Disclaimer: I don't have much ill will towards CinemaSins, I just want to point out the many mistakes they've made in their videos.
All film footage belongs to Walt Disney Studios, and is being used fairly
Original video: • Everything Wrong With ...
Th3Birdman's Dead Man's Chest video: • Everything Wrong With ...
My Letterboxd account: letterboxd.com/captain_vader/ - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Nice of you to give Th3Birdman a day off
So, you label Beckett's ship with CinemaSins' logo, then play the scene of the Flying Dutchman & Black Pearl blasting it into oblivion......
*BRILLIANCE!!!!!!*
Lord Becketts death is incredibly satisfying and anyone who says that Beckett is lame is wrong and forgetting that the entire reason why Beckett is actually a villain that is fun to hate.
For Sin 92...the reason "this guy" was able to say the words correctly was because in the very same scene, it's explained that in addition to burning the nine pieces of eight, you need to say the words "Calypso, I release you from your human bonds," specifically as if you were saying that to a lover. Barbossa said the words incorrectly and this guy did it the correct way.
13:33 - 14:49 * me noticing this incredible understanding of norrington * this is a beutiful sword 🙂😉
Missed SinSins:
2:31 People can be separated from their companions, it doesn't mean they're at a place alone.
3:00 How is this racist or sexist? Race played no factor here, and he's clearly just being a creep. Unless race or gender is involved in a negative way, it's not racist or sexist.
5:55 He was having, or at least starting, a conversation.
6:08 That was a legitimate question.
6:45 Maybe there are other ways souls can come back from the dead. In fact, Davy Jones and his crew likely caused the green flash a lot of times, as we saw at the end of the movie when Will became captain of the Dutchman and went in and out of the living world that this caused a green flash too.
7:18 Sinning this gorgeous scene.
8:42 Yes, because I'm always so eager to admit that I sacrificed a friend, or at least an ally. And she doesn't know Will saw her kiss Jack.
9:28 The REAL Sin here is that in the vastness of the Limbo ocean, they encountered her father at all; those odds are astronomical.
10:32 It was stated that those trapped in Davy Jones' locker go mad. The months of isolation obviously caused Jack to go a little crazy and imagine other versions of himself.
11:38 Again, there may be others ways to return to the living world besides this that also cause the green flash.
11:47 This is a series with ghosts and witches and supernatural beings, maybe someone learned this from one of them. For all we know, a member of Jones' crew told someone about this long ago.
12:43 Jack was only half serious here and was likely putting on a show for his crew. He even later comments to Will how he escaped the brig even quicker than he expected.
13:09 The Dutchman was given specific instructions to go after them. The timing may be convenient but this isn't a deus ex machina.
16:26 Jones was heartbroken back then, he probably acted on emotion and didn't care about the why. On that note, according to Greek lore, Calypso was forbidden to be with those she loved as punishment for siding with the titans in the war against the gods.
17:28 A later scene and even the sequel shows that Jack does NOT have daddy issues. Maybe he's a little intimidated by him or is embarrassed by his own reputation, but there is no evidence that he has daddy issues.
17:43 Many lawless groups have rules. Have you never heard the saying "honor amongst thieves"? They also have hierarchies, from street gang leaders to drug lords to mafia bosses.
18:42 The Pirate Lords were needed because they held the necessary items, and then Barbossa says that someone, not a Pirate Lord, but someone needs to speak to her as if they were her lover.
20:26 This is arguably the most iconic and greatest wedding scene put to film.
21:04 It's pretty much unanimously agreed that the first three PotC movies are great, and lots of people think the 3rd is the best.
21:26 Jones is a supernatural being. For all we know, his tentacle is trying to bring the key back to him, and he's right there, just a few feet from Jack.
22:06 They were just floating there, there was no need for someone at the helm.
22:22 That wasn't an abyss, it was a maelstrom; if you're going to nitpick Sins for literality then I will too. And Calypso created it to allow the Pearl and Duchman to fight one-on-one since the pirates were vastly outnumbered.
3:24 Hoo boy, don't let him watch _The Pirates of Penzance_ - he'll freak out over the presence of a pirate king.
Good job with this video. You made a lot of good points and mentioned all the cliches that CinemaSins is guilty of using. Well done!
These videos remind me why i watch cinemawins over cinemasins.
For Sin 78...no, Will did NOT kill those men. Those were the corpses leftover from the battle on the Black Pearl after Barbossa and the crew fought the East Indian Trading Company off.
This video was very well done 💯
8:29 - 8:41 actually yes I'm pretty certain that is what happended andor is the answer. when they got in the locker or near the shore Tia sent the crabs to get the pearl.
It might not make sense of having a pirates code but they did have one for governing pirates.
The Pirates Code is a factionalized take on the actual ship articles that each crew operated under…basically a series of rules that emphasized things like distribution of shares, how voting works, the process of removing a Captain from his position etc.
As far as I’m aware, there was no unified pirate rules…each crew did what they wanted.
I honestly cannot believe that critics who hate this movie for being too long and over complicated but somehow praise the last Jedi even though that movie is also too long and over complicated.
I wouldn't call Last Jedi "overcomplicated", but yeah, I never found this movie to be that confusing, as I always at least got the gist of what was going on
@@captainvader921 yes the last Jedi is not overly complicated but I guess a better showcase of critics being hypocrites is the fact that they say at world's end sucks because it's dark out nowhere and lacks the fun of the first movie but when the last Jedi dehumanizes Luke Skywalker it's suddenly amazing storytelling even though the movie does the things that the critics hate about at world's end.
That was something Nostalgia Critic pointed out, that the dark tonal shift was apparently too jarring, even though the Harry Potter films did that, and people praised those movies because of that.
@@captainvader921because apparently when you're j.k. Rowling and not Gore verbinski you are terrible at telling a story. I'm not the biggest harry Potter fan, I don't hate the movies I just don't want to watch them because I had to constantly listen or look at the screen of my tv where my mom and sister would watch these and because of that I started to hate those movies.
@@captainvader921Nostalgia critic at least respects his fans and allows them to have a different point of view. Hell even I am someone who loves him as a critic, I acknowledge that he misunderstood this movie and other movies but at least he can take a joke about him and takes the criticism like a champ.
Love the video, will *GLADLY* subscribe to you if it means I get to see more like this, and in sin 74 you missed an opportunity to say: "Jeremy makes a Star Wars reference that isn't a sin of the movie cliché"
Thanks! And I have been considering doing another one, but I'm just not sure what to choose.
@@captainvader921: How about his videos of the Harry Potter movies?? He does this *Really* gross sin in most of those - It's worth at least 550 sins every time
@@JadenMoon1475 sorry, but Th3Birdman already tackled all of them. I'm not sure what else I can say about them.
@@captainvader921: How about CinemaSins' Everything Wrong With Jumanji?
@@captainvader921: You know, just because other CZcamsrs - Yes, others besides Th3birdman - have done something doesn't mean you're forbidden from doing it.
Captain Sveid & Jay Exci also sinned Jeremy's sin vids of the Harry Potter movies
@ 10:07
I mean… we got this information last time, and this is just reiterating it for those that forgot. And considering the four people who this would effect… yeah, I’m surprised Jeremy didn’t point out that this was mentioned in the last Movie, even if it was to a different character.
17:59 - 18:18 cinemasins is idiotically back and forth about what should and should not be explained and it probably depends on (stupidly) how boring whatever that is
17:33 - 17:44 cinemasins is talking about A how Jack seems incredibly shocked or scared that his father comes here and B the part where Jack asks about his mem and even cinemasins sinned this and you skipped it I still don't think this is a sin for the movie but again it's not addressed very much but it's still a thing about how jack seems freaked out by his father and apparently sees his mum's shrunken head
I didn't have anything to say over the shrunken head scene, though I guess you're right about Jack's shock. I just found it weird how he said "daddy issues" as if the movie goes in-depth in their relationship.
I’m back
Can you do The Princess and the Frog?
Birdman already did that one, and I don't like that movie enough. Not that I hate it, but it's just not a personal favorite.
@@captainvader921 All right, then. I just asked because it’s not just one of my favorite movies, but also the first movie that I did a video on (and I did it before Birdman).
And I’d also like to say that while there are a lot of movies that I did after him, there are four that he did after me (The Princess and the Frog, Monsters Inc., Home Alone, and The Lion King).
yeah. I'm fine with that, I'm just trying to just do movies I can't see anybody doing anytime soon, like the Narnia movies for example. And I also want to come up with my own things to say, otherwise, I might end up saying the same things other CZcamsrs have already said.
@@captainvader921 I definitely do that too, because when I cover a video that someone else has covered, I try not to copy them.
@ 18:16
Seriously? There is no line. Or rather the two lines are on the wrong side of each other. Too much is actually less than not enough.
And that’s how Jeremy’s brain works.
Birdman is already doing this why are you copying him
Not this particular movie though. Considering he did Dead Man's Chest, and that movie ended on a big cliffhanger, I felt like he should do At World's End, and then he never did. So this was sort of my way of finishing what he started.
@@captainvader921 thanks
Yeahhh at least don’t copy his exact titles and format maybe ? This is a legit rip off of his videos bro just seems like your trying to ride his videos for views
@@gangaim08 Trust me, I love Th3Birdman but he doesn’t have a monopoly on making fun of CinemaSins, besides this guy even gave him credit in the video, what more do you want him to do? And if the title is such a problem then what kind of title would you have used?
It literally says “Inspired by Th3Birdman” the title 🤦♂️