Honestly, it depends. Sometimes, I really like the quality that heavy autotune can give a song. You know the type you can tell is there as an artistic choice to add an unnatraul effect to the vocals. It can sound really good if done right, but I also like acoustic with literally no after-effects at all, and I like everything in between, too. It's all a matter of what I want to hear at that moment.
@@CatEater--ImeanLover as long as you only using it as a tool it conects to the saying; if it was comepletely ai then thats called plagerism. So yes and no.
She's 17, can play 40 different instruments, composes, sings, produces, WHO are WE to demand and complain what she does, when she can do so much compared to people twice her age (like me).
When I vocalise I use my smoother higher voice. When I rap I use my raspy lower voice. When a song has both rap and vocals I do both. As a singer I love experimenting with my voice and pushing myself to the limit. I remember in grade 7 I auditioned for my school talent show thingy. I sang "Titanium" for the audition and used my smoother higher voice. I even hit D7. I got to the second round which was also my last round. I sang to "Living Life In The Night" with my lower raspy voice. I got disqualified for lip singing, even though I wasn't. I was so upset, I thought if I showed the judges everything I was capable of, I could win. So after that occasion I stoped rapping, singing in a low tone and singing in a raspy voice. Up until a couple months ago I missed singing lower tone and rap songs so I started doing it again. I'm still getting use to it again but I love how your voice sounds so beautiful in each state. ❤
Then AI art is still art. Because art has no rules. And every artist has influence of someone else, same with AI. Therefore AI art is still genuine art I guess
You've got the raw skill and natural talent, the practice and discipline, the creativity and willingness to explore. People don't realize autotune was also revolutionary to the art. "Music is art, and art has no rules." I love that.
The people commenting that she has auto-tuned voices have clearly never used any audio software. I once had someone ask me to belt quieter, most people don't realize how loud you actually have to sing to achieve certain notes. Part of EQing is adjusting the volume so the instruments are not louder than the singer or vice versa depending on what you're going for.
Thisis why education is important... There are a lot of vocal techniques out there in the world like polyphonic Tuvan vocal techniques. One particular infamous technique that she is fond of using (the one they call a ccheap auto-tuned vocals) is "Khoomei", a biphonic vocal technique which is commonly heard and learnt among Mongolian indigenous. This is a diffiult skill and this artist is hella awesome for learning this and learning how to incorporate it in modern music styles.
Thank you so much for addressing this. These days, so many people who don't understand music production treat any form of noticeable audio processing on vocals as "autotune". This helps to clear up some of the misunderstandings people have. I also learned quite a bit from this video about vocalisation! I was worried for quite a while that the raspy singing technique would damage your voice, but I didn't know that that rasp was present in proper techniques like Mongolian throat singing! This was very eye-opening
Belle, you have a great voice. Some people just aren’t used to change and plus your vocal skills are great no matter what techniques you use. Many people aren’t used to great talent and new ideas for music. Either way, the ones who really care will support no matter what. Using your “normal voice” and changing up your style isn’t a problem at all. The real ones will understand, and you’re right. Art has NO RULES. People love you, some just can’t handle change
i wouldnt have thought to mix edm and throat signing to pump out a banger. Used to hearing The Hu but i picked up on what you were doing when i heard Hold On. Keep it up fam
Just discovered you tonight and had wondered about this, though w/o judgment because of the range of your vocal techniques. Thanks for clarifying. Your talent and mind are unfettered. Glad you're out there. Just 18 with so much ahead--please make sure you look both ways before crossing any streets.
Malaysian fan right here before I knew you were Malaysian. Just wanna say we love your vocals and we love seeing your experiment with your voice. You're really talented and you're one of my musical idols !!
Great explanation. The process and progression you make because as a creative artist is not bound within the digitisation of what you can create. Music is not dying but the person creating it from within is.
Your singing voice is unique and is what caught my attention. Can't wait to hear your new upcoming work for the next few years.. keep up the amazing work!
I don't understand why people are so against auto tune.... auto tune just gives more clean and smooth sound and kinda mix two different keys effortlessly.... You are really talented ...Please don't pay heed to these comments and use auto tune when required 😉😉
Autotune removes the meaning behind talent Because everyone could use it, btw most of the famous users mistake it as their own talent and get BIG egos when all they did was the most basic stuff, and the whole purpose of gifted people dimineshes and makes way more talented people irrelevant and lose their worth in music industry
@@0remy0 Yeah but in some cases, like her, she used autotune to enhance her voice making it sound better and fit to her music. While other artist like Sub Urban doesn't really have good sing but he makes great music and his songs don't really heavily focus on the voice. Some people listen to the singing, some people listen to the lyrics and some people vibing to the music.
I’m glad she made this clear. I was like “that’s some lit throat singing right there!” And searched the comments and then I wondered what was going on or if she was actually using it… but I’m glad we got a woman singi in a raspy voice, using growl, whistle, and throat singing techniques! AMAZING JOB AS ALWAYS!
You have such a variety of techniques! I love that you play with your voice and your skill is obvious. I'm impressed that you're always challenging yourself. Raw or processed, your voice is a hell of an instrument. I find people's processing choices really interesting. I happen to have a bias toward imperfect vocals - I like actual live singing a lot, cracks and all - but I can still appreciate a polished sound. What's weird to me is that I never thought you sounded super compressed or tuned. You highlight your vocal texture in the production and you have a *very* good ear so I'm assuming your raw pitch is pretty solid. I guess people hear a sound that's unusual to them and assume it's "autotune" and bad. Thanks for taking the time to demonstrate and explain. Maybe some folks will listen. 😁
@@bonkdonk297 it's all governor by resonance and harmonics, it doesn't mater if you use Western semitone or Arabic Maqam, the physics of resonance and harmonics governs the mathematical rules set and it all begets from there. The same physics governs timbre. Pitch, Scales, Harmony, Melody, Rhythm, Tempo, Dynamics, Form, Texture, Cadence, Ornamentation, Counterpoint, Tension and Release are all rules that are mathematically calculated from the physics of resonance and harmonics.
@@bonkdonk297 on the flip side... art often relies on descriptions, analysis, and subjective interpretation rather than a notation, be it standardized to the tuning system, or abstract. music is almost entirely quantifiable in a relatively small amount of storage space.
Nah, you are wrong. Colors are also ruled by mathematics, color theory, metrials, etc. Any form of art will inevitably have some grounding in math, because physics is Math and we live in a physical world ruled by math. You just have a boring take on music and art in general. But if that is what you like, good for you, everyone enjoys art in their own way. That is the magic.
@@RicardoAum none of those rules allow other artists to reproduce visual art from less than the full visual art. sound is mechanical. light is electromagnetic. one vibrates quite literally, the other does not. it's not just touching to the soul... music literally touches your body. light might borrow aesthetic metaphors from the mechanical world, but it's just not mechanical. Music is mechanical. but thanks for the ad hominem, conceding the debate.
Auto tune or not! You are amazingly talented, I recently saw your CZcams shorts and immediately subscribed!! I wish I could create 10% of music what you create! God Bless You Belle 😊
Nowadays everyone is an expert on every topic and every field which exists... only a few have real knowledge and I've come across VERY FEW artists who have real knowledge AND musical talent, one of them is you, Belle. You're unique and we really wish to hear more from you!😊💕
These People trying to catch you using auto tune, when in reality you just have such amazing control over your voice. To be able to develop all these different vocal techniques is so impressive
My favourite is your head and chest voice but i am literally amazed that how you can you sound like this beautiful with your nasal , throat and diaphragm voice technique And I aslo wanna listen pasoori song in your head and chest voice but only if you have time for it and if you are willing to do it ❤
i agree! as an aspiring music producer, I really began to learn music has no boundaries or rules. Everyone uses Autotune and the general public doesn't understand that it's a part of the art. Some styles of music even emphasise on the autotune as the style or genre. Autotune can't save a tone-deaf person. If you can't sing well, even autotune can't help you, therefore making it impossible to use autotune to *"lie"* about your voice.
This is exactly it. As a mix engineer/producer for the last 16 years, it always bugs the shit out of me when people whine that "they used AutoTune bc they're bad singers" because even though I've owned a copy of AutoTune all these years, I still had to learn how to sing and put in all the hours to practice. AutoTune is there to analyze and react to incoming pitch drift. When you're a little flat, AT will sharpen your pitch drift a bit closer to centre pitch. When you're a little sharp, it'll lightly flatten your drift to bring it closer. But at no point is it replacing any of your skill - it only works with a total of 40-50 cents to the next true semitone, giving the vocalist only 20 to 25 cents of leeway sharp or flat off centre pitch. You need to be a pretty damn good singer to consistently stay in the range of 20 cents of centre pitch, and that only comes after a decade or more of experience in vocal control. Plus, we've always cheated in audio. Microphones change the sound they capture, preamps add harmonic distortion that further changes the signal, EQs and compressors have been used as frontend colouration and level control since they were first introduced (so 50s for compressors and 30s for EQs) and they used to absolutely drench vocals in reverb and delay and comp takes have also been performed since the 50s but I don't hear a single music listener complaining about that 😅
@@pc_buildyb0i935 yeah exactly! it's only because they don't understand the behind the scenes processing, and honestly it's okay. It just still is funny to me how people think there is absolutely no autotune on "natural sounding vocals"- there always is, even a little bit 😭
Honestly I think out of any musician, auto tune would fit in with her style the best. She already edits her music so heavily that auto tune isn't even a detriment to her skill, it's just one of many tools under her belt. I wouldn't care either way if she used it or not, her greatest talent is her versatility
Yep I agree with it `art has no rule'.....no matter the process if end thing is beautiful people will acknowledge it.....There are people who are God gifted but those who are working hard they will surely receive their gifts....and most importantly if people enjoy it or not.....and girl I really enjoy your song every time😁
I didn't think it was auto tuned at all, but I've been listening to this kind of music for a while. I do personally prefer the first vocal technique, but I would never comment that unprompted. Like this is your art, I wouldn't dare try to tell you how to create. You're clearly an experienced vocal artist and everything you create sounds amazing
at the end of the day, autotune is a tool. people are so used to the idea of using autotune as a 'crutch' but really, autotune can be used as a way to enhance a song. autotune or little to no autotune, it really depends on what you want to go for as an artist. I personally really like how autotune is used in rap nowadays, makes me really go with the melody of the song.
I love the she actually uses her natutal voice but is also not against autotune, hating on autotune is overrated now, y'all can stop now we know everyone uses autotune you're not exposing any secret.
Dont pay attention to these people who have no musical appreciation. Most of us could tell what you were doing and love that style. Actually, some people love to cry “autotune” and they have no clue, so don’t pay any attention to them. You have the skills!!!!
People don't seem to understand what auto tune is so lemme oversimplify it Basically every song has a key (set of notes that you can use that sound good in the song) An auto tune sets it so if you sing a note that is not one of the notes in the key, it will change the note so that it is one of the notes in the key
even if there was heavy autotune its not like every other artist hasnt done that. harry styles uses it, ariana grande, rihanna, literally everyone. its not a sin and its there for a reason
I don’t usually comment but you have my respect in your art form. Eff the haters and keep going. Nothing but love in your endeavors and thank you for bringing us along.
Woowwwwwww 😳 u r really doing this with your real voice 👍🏻 amazing 🤩 you are really awesome 😍😍 your voice 🤌🏻 like waoooo. 🤗Just looking like a waooooo 🥰
It's so cool how she uses many vocal techniques to make her AMAZING voice change based on the song.I would never be able to do that...She's fr so ✨TALENTED✨
artist need this such etitude, responding hate comments and critics with calm, positive and giving educational things instead of mad, denial, or doing anything worse
Indonesian here!🎉 when I heard you, I was amazed haha. you use a lot of musical talents. and unlike other music, it sounds like many genres in one piece of music in one. unique is your specialty. don't mind that person, he/she just protesting out of envy. ❤
When someone doesn’t know what they are talking about, they tend to want to insult people! Your response was classy, informative and you took them all to school with grace! You are amazing
You have an amazing voice and even different techniques to make your voice sound different and good. Your voice is amazing 🤩 ❤ I love your music soooo sooooo much.🎉🎉🎉🎉😊
I think this girl is absolutely brilliant. She's one of the new geniuses in the world and she should be celebrated. I absolutely adore everything about her art. She's amazing, and I can't get enough of listening to her. Thank you so much, dear. You keep going, you're absolutely brilliant.
Any vocal artist has my full respect. I've never been able to fully explore my own vocal range in a musical connotation, so to hear such a huge difference in style from one artist is really amazing. I don't think the people who are claiming you use autotune truly or can truly appreciate the work you've put in.
Here’s why using Autotune doesn’t make you less of an artist!
Autotune VS no autotune: Comment which do you prefer? 👀
Your voice is really a magic I love all your videos ❤️
I have no problem with autotune when it used right
Belle you are god gifted 😮 you are great
*I prefer you belle* ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Honestly, it depends. Sometimes, I really like the quality that heavy autotune can give a song. You know the type you can tell is there as an artistic choice to add an unnatraul effect to the vocals. It can sound really good if done right, but I also like acoustic with literally no after-effects at all, and I like everything in between, too. It's all a matter of what I want to hear at that moment.
She's so confident and kind. She explained it all with so much grace
wtf 8.6k likes and no replies lemme fix dat
What only one useless replie let meh fix dat
Just joking😂
Cant agree more
Let me be a part to live up those comments then 😅😅😅❤❤😂😂😂
lol
"Music is art, and art has no rules"
Wise words.
*AI art be like*
@@CatEater--ImeanLover as long as you only using it as a tool it conects to the saying; if it was comepletely ai then thats called plagerism. So yes and no.
Wise person
art does have one rule, dont copy or get a lawsuit.
@@piggold5175 Very wise indeed
The most kindest "stfu" i have ever hear
FR
FR bud
Fr
She's 17, can play 40 different instruments, composes, sings, produces, WHO are WE to demand and complain what she does, when she can do so much compared to people twice her age (like me).
nooooo she is 17???
@@thestraltheundead4093 she just turned 18 I believe, I found her at 16/17 love her style of music
😳😳😳😳😳😳😳17.......???!!!!!! . The heck.. I was a baby when I was seventeen😱😱😱😱
She's 17???? Here me can't solve my maths problems... 😭😭
17!?!?!?
She called the haters dumb in 7 million languages 💀
2,2k likes and no comment, let me fix it
2.4k likes and 1 comment? Let me fix that
@@emiiriinsecond9732please stop with the reply chains
2.7k likes and 2 comments? Let me fix that.
😂😂😂
If "talent" is a person, it's her🎉
I agree ☆
And hard work
Omg... You're amazing ❤
YES FR
no seriously!! 🩷🩷
Hearing her belt out those lines as an example was pretty mind blowing. What a strong and beautiful voice!
When I vocalise I use my smoother higher voice. When I rap I use my raspy lower voice. When a song has both rap and vocals I do both. As a singer I love experimenting with my voice and pushing myself to the limit. I remember in grade 7 I auditioned for my school talent show thingy. I sang "Titanium" for the audition and used my smoother higher voice. I even hit D7. I got to the second round which was also my last round. I sang to "Living Life In The Night" with my lower raspy voice. I got disqualified for lip singing, even though I wasn't. I was so upset, I thought if I showed the judges everything I was capable of, I could win. So after that occasion I stoped rapping, singing in a low tone and singing in a raspy voice. Up until a couple months ago I missed singing lower tone and rap songs so I started doing it again. I'm still getting use to it again but I love how your voice sounds so beautiful in each state. ❤
I'm glad ur rapping and I hope its making you happy❤
@@user-gi1en5dv4n ♥
*Music is art and art has no rules* -best line ever✨
Edit: OMG!!! Tysm for 2.5K likes❤️❤️
fr
Tell that to some art snobs... Lol 🙄
Then AI art is still art. Because art has no rules. And every artist has influence of someone else, same with AI. Therefore AI art is still genuine art I guess
it has one rule, must not plagiarize.
❤
You've got the raw skill and natural talent, the practice and discipline, the creativity and willingness to explore. People don't realize autotune was also revolutionary to the art. "Music is art, and art has no rules." I love that.
The people commenting that she has auto-tuned voices have clearly never used any audio software. I once had someone ask me to belt quieter, most people don't realize how loud you actually have to sing to achieve certain notes. Part of EQing is adjusting the volume so the instruments are not louder than the singer or vice versa depending on what you're going for.
I'm always amazed by your music knowledge. Also crazy awareness and control of your voice.
Thisis why education is important... There are a lot of vocal techniques out there in the world like polyphonic Tuvan vocal techniques.
One particular infamous technique that she is fond of using (the one they call a ccheap auto-tuned vocals) is "Khoomei", a biphonic vocal technique which is commonly heard and learnt among Mongolian indigenous.
This is a diffiult skill and this artist is hella awesome for learning this and learning how to incorporate it in modern music styles.
her telling "I use my chest and brain " me still trying to find out how should I use my brain voice
I love your Tuvan throat technique. It’s got an eerie mystical feel !
Thank you so much for addressing this. These days, so many people who don't understand music production treat any form of noticeable audio processing on vocals as "autotune". This helps to clear up some of the misunderstandings people have.
I also learned quite a bit from this video about vocalisation! I was worried for quite a while that the raspy singing technique would damage your voice, but I didn't know that that rasp was present in proper techniques like Mongolian throat singing! This was very eye-opening
Rasp/distortion is also present in Jazz, gospel, soul, metal, rock, and so many more genres. Distortion is completely healthy when done correctly.
say me what are the subjects you selected for the A/L exam?
your voice like a magic. I like it.
"Music is an art and art have no rules"..... This just got me girl ❤
She is SO skilled! To be able to do whistle notes and throat techniques!! Too incredible. How have I just found out about her?
Belle, you have a great voice. Some people just aren’t used to change and plus your vocal skills are great no matter what techniques you use. Many people aren’t used to great talent and new ideas for music. Either way, the ones who really care will support no matter what. Using your “normal voice” and changing up your style isn’t a problem at all. The real ones will understand, and you’re right. Art has NO RULES. People love you, some just can’t handle change
i wouldnt have thought to mix edm and throat signing to pump out a banger. Used to hearing The Hu but i picked up on what you were doing when i heard Hold On. Keep it up fam
Just discovered you tonight and had wondered about this, though w/o judgment because of the range of your vocal techniques. Thanks for clarifying. Your talent and mind are unfettered. Glad you're out there. Just 18 with so much ahead--please make sure you look both ways before crossing any streets.
Girl you are nailing it , those peoples are just jealous
Or just plain judgmental.
They just want attention to show off how “perfect “ they are!
@@CabrialYno need to be judgemental well😌people
Malaysian fan right here before I knew you were Malaysian. Just wanna say we love your vocals and we love seeing your experiment with your voice. You're really talented and you're one of my musical idols !!
Siyes ah dia ni asal malaysia?
I'm a beatboxer so I can understand what she is doing, we beatboxer often use these vocals techniques in our beatbox routines 😊
Great explanation. The process and progression you make because as a creative artist is not bound within the digitisation of what you can create.
Music is not dying but the person creating it from within is.
Your singing voice is unique and is what caught my attention. Can't wait to hear your new upcoming work for the next few years.. keep up the amazing work!
Same
The voice range is extremely impressive! Amazing detailed explanation as well!!!
I love your "cheap autotune" vocals. It's pure perfection, so catchy and usually gives me goosebumps
Tbh I love both Ur techniques, could you plz do a video on how to make your raspier voice
Gurl is shutting down all those haters 😌🔥
I don't understand why people are so against auto tune.... auto tune just gives more clean and smooth sound and kinda mix two different keys effortlessly....
You are really talented ...Please don't pay heed to these comments and use auto tune when required 😉😉
I think it's when people totally abuse it and rely on it. At least that's when I think it's cheap 😅
Autotune removes the meaning behind talent
Because everyone could use it, btw most of the famous users mistake it as their own talent and get BIG egos when all they did was the most basic stuff, and the whole purpose of gifted people dimineshes and makes way more talented people irrelevant and lose their worth in music industry
@@0remy0 Yeah but in some cases, like her, she used autotune to enhance her voice making it sound better and fit to her music. While other artist like Sub Urban doesn't really have good sing but he makes great music and his songs don't really heavily focus on the voice.
Some people listen to the singing, some people listen to the lyrics and some people vibing to the music.
@@0remy0 Good singing isn't the only talent but making music and lyrics too.
Her: knows how to sing
Me:sounding like a dead horse trying it😂
I’m glad she made this clear. I was like “that’s some lit throat singing right there!” And searched the comments and then I wondered what was going on or if she was actually using it… but I’m glad we got a woman singi in a raspy voice, using growl, whistle, and throat singing techniques! AMAZING JOB AS ALWAYS!
"Music is Art and Art has no rules"
You have such a variety of techniques! I love that you play with your voice and your skill is obvious. I'm impressed that you're always challenging yourself.
Raw or processed, your voice is a hell of an instrument. I find people's processing choices really interesting. I happen to have a bias toward imperfect vocals - I like actual live singing a lot, cracks and all - but I can still appreciate a polished sound.
What's weird to me is that I never thought you sounded super compressed or tuned. You highlight your vocal texture in the production and you have a *very* good ear so I'm assuming your raw pitch is pretty solid. I guess people hear a sound that's unusual to them and assume it's "autotune" and bad.
Thanks for taking the time to demonstrate and explain. Maybe some folks will listen. 😁
music is math... and it follows a set of rules and principles that govern its operations and relationships.
Can you list some of these rules?
@@bonkdonk297 it's all governor by resonance and harmonics, it doesn't mater if you use Western semitone or Arabic Maqam, the physics of resonance and harmonics governs the mathematical rules set and it all begets from there. The same physics governs timbre. Pitch, Scales, Harmony, Melody, Rhythm, Tempo, Dynamics, Form, Texture, Cadence, Ornamentation, Counterpoint, Tension and Release are all rules that are mathematically calculated from the physics of resonance and harmonics.
@@bonkdonk297 on the flip side... art often relies on descriptions, analysis, and subjective interpretation rather than a notation, be it standardized to the tuning system, or abstract. music is almost entirely quantifiable in a relatively small amount of storage space.
Nah, you are wrong. Colors are also ruled by mathematics, color theory, metrials, etc. Any form of art will inevitably have some grounding in math, because physics is Math and we live in a physical world ruled by math. You just have a boring take on music and art in general. But if that is what you like, good for you, everyone enjoys art in their own way. That is the magic.
@@RicardoAum none of those rules allow other artists to reproduce visual art from less than the full visual art.
sound is mechanical.
light is electromagnetic.
one vibrates quite literally, the other does not.
it's not just touching to the soul... music literally touches your body. light might borrow aesthetic metaphors from the mechanical world, but it's just not mechanical. Music is mechanical.
but thanks for the ad hominem, conceding the debate.
Auto tune or not! You are amazingly talented, I recently saw your CZcams shorts and immediately subscribed!! I wish I could create 10% of music what you create! God Bless You Belle 😊
Nowadays everyone is an expert on every topic and every field which exists... only a few have real knowledge and I've come across VERY FEW artists who have real knowledge AND musical talent, one of them is you, Belle. You're unique and we really wish to hear more from you!😊💕
Girl! I don't know about music but I adore you a lot. You are such an incredible person. Keep going>>> Haters gonna hate player's gonna play.
These People trying to catch you using auto tune, when in reality you just have such amazing control over your voice. To be able to develop all these different vocal techniques is so impressive
Eyooo your whistle voice is clean as fk
“At the end of the day Music is art,and art has NO rules”
There’s one rule. Don’t copy other artist without giving them credit.
Wow 😳😳 your vocals and your voice is just slayyyy 🗿
"Arts has no RULES "👍🔥🤞😌
Eidi ngaore ngda i luv u so much
My favourite is your head and chest voice but i am literally amazed that how you can you sound like this beautiful with your nasal , throat and diaphragm voice technique
And I aslo wanna listen pasoori song in your head and chest voice but only if you have time for it and if you are willing to do it ❤
i agree! as an aspiring music producer, I really began to learn music has no boundaries or rules. Everyone uses Autotune and the general public doesn't understand that it's a part of the art. Some styles of music even emphasise on the autotune as the style or genre. Autotune can't save a tone-deaf person. If you can't sing well, even autotune can't help you, therefore making it impossible to use autotune to *"lie"* about your voice.
This is exactly it. As a mix engineer/producer for the last 16 years, it always bugs the shit out of me when people whine that "they used AutoTune bc they're bad singers" because even though I've owned a copy of AutoTune all these years, I still had to learn how to sing and put in all the hours to practice.
AutoTune is there to analyze and react to incoming pitch drift. When you're a little flat, AT will sharpen your pitch drift a bit closer to centre pitch. When you're a little sharp, it'll lightly flatten your drift to bring it closer. But at no point is it replacing any of your skill - it only works with a total of 40-50 cents to the next true semitone, giving the vocalist only 20 to 25 cents of leeway sharp or flat off centre pitch.
You need to be a pretty damn good singer to consistently stay in the range of 20 cents of centre pitch, and that only comes after a decade or more of experience in vocal control.
Plus, we've always cheated in audio. Microphones change the sound they capture, preamps add harmonic distortion that further changes the signal, EQs and compressors have been used as frontend colouration and level control since they were first introduced (so 50s for compressors and 30s for EQs) and they used to absolutely drench vocals in reverb and delay and comp takes have also been performed since the 50s but I don't hear a single music listener complaining about that 😅
@@pc_buildyb0i935 yeah exactly!
it's only because they don't understand the behind the scenes processing, and honestly it's okay. It just still is funny to me how people think there is absolutely no autotune on "natural sounding vocals"- there always is, even a little bit 😭
Internet bots think "yo, you use autotune 😂" is like some sort of gotcha.
Honestly I think out of any musician, auto tune would fit in with her style the best. She already edits her music so heavily that auto tune isn't even a detriment to her skill, it's just one of many tools under her belt. I wouldn't care either way if she used it or not, her greatest talent is her versatility
Girl you fr?? sooo much technique I am almost shocked by your high notes
Yep I agree with it `art has no rule'.....no matter the process if end thing is beautiful people will acknowledge it.....There are people who are God gifted but those who are working hard they will surely receive their gifts....and most importantly if people enjoy it or not.....and girl I really enjoy your song every time😁
I didn't think it was auto tuned at all, but I've been listening to this kind of music for a while. I do personally prefer the first vocal technique, but I would never comment that unprompted. Like this is your art, I wouldn't dare try to tell you how to create. You're clearly an experienced vocal artist and everything you create sounds amazing
Just discovered this lovely Belle! I am in awe and amazed by her talent, I hope she goes far! ❤❤🎉
You have a wonderful voice!
at the end of the day, autotune is a tool. people are so used to the idea of using autotune as a 'crutch' but really, autotune can be used as a way to enhance a song. autotune or little to no autotune, it really depends on what you want to go for as an artist. I personally really like how autotune is used in rap nowadays, makes me really go with the melody of the song.
His voice really gives me goosebumps!🥹🫢
Hell. YES. You are so talented Belle. Looking forward to seeing your art in the future 💯👏
You're a superb artist. I Love your style and your talent. I have no words to explain my interest on you.
Simply... You are stunning sis ❤
I like your natural voice❤❤🎶💪🎧
Totes magoats she's adorable 🥰
I love the she actually uses her natutal voice but is also not against autotune, hating on autotune is overrated now, y'all can stop now we know everyone uses autotune you're not exposing any secret.
Dont pay attention to these people who have no musical appreciation. Most of us could tell what you were doing and love that style. Actually, some people love to cry “autotune” and they have no clue, so don’t pay any attention to them. You have the skills!!!!
People don't seem to understand what auto tune is so lemme oversimplify it
Basically every song has a key (set of notes that you can use that sound good in the song)
An auto tune sets it so if you sing a note that is not one of the notes in the key, it will change the note so that it is one of the notes in the key
even if there was heavy autotune its not like every other artist hasnt done that. harry styles uses it, ariana grande, rihanna, literally everyone. its not a sin and its there for a reason
You see this ppl, this is the definition of an artist
U don't have to listen them...they just don't know abt the true talent ❤
You don't need to explain girl , we know you best❤
As someone who really enjoys "Viking/Nordic" Music and Metal I really like your new style!
I don’t usually comment but you have my respect in your art form. Eff the haters and keep going. Nothing but love in your endeavors and thank you for bringing us along.
Music is art & art has no rules that hits differently & thats true 100% true
Woowwwwwww 😳 u r really doing this with your real voice 👍🏻 amazing 🤩 you are really awesome 😍😍 your voice 🤌🏻 like waoooo. 🤗Just looking like a waooooo 🥰
this is the most subtle way to say “stfu you don’t know anything”
“Whistle noises” oh the tea is ready
Whatever anyone says I'm proud of u😍
Those who said she used autotune doesn't have their own work and criticized her. Shame on them
It's so cool how she uses many vocal techniques to make her AMAZING voice change based on the song.I would never be able to do that...She's fr so ✨TALENTED✨
I ADORE your vocal sound, it scratches a part of my brain that’s been itching for far too long
Well explained, seeing your character in this breakdown and how you hold yourself is beautiful
You're awesome and amazing as always!! ❤
Whenever you smirks they always seems mysterious to me but when you smiles they seems cute to me
Those whistle notes made my soul jump outta my body💀💀💀
artist need this such etitude, responding hate comments and critics with calm, positive and giving educational things instead of mad, denial, or doing anything worse
Indonesian here!🎉
when I heard you, I was amazed haha.
you use a lot of musical talents. and unlike other music, it sounds like many genres in one piece of music in one. unique is your specialty.
don't mind that person, he/she just protesting out of envy.
❤
When moffos never heard about Metal Growl or Mongolian throat singing...
I love her last word
"Art has no rules..."
When someone doesn’t know what they are talking about, they tend to want to insult people! Your response was classy, informative and you took them all to school with grace! You are amazing
You have an amazing voice and even different techniques to make your voice sound different and good. Your voice is amazing 🤩 ❤ I love your music soooo sooooo much.🎉🎉🎉🎉😊
She looks like suga and I love it
Belle you're absolutely amazing at what you do! Thank you for explaining everything so kindly.
Amen you go girl! I absolutely love your vocals! Your artwork is always fire! ❤❤
Haters gonna hate
Your voice is a gift
Please just do a whole short of just war cries idk why I love them sm
You're just straight up talented
The "cheap sounding voice" reminds me of the Vocaloid 'growls' of the later models and characters, so I think it's a cool talent that you have!!
I think this girl is absolutely brilliant. She's one of the new geniuses in the world and she should be celebrated. I absolutely adore everything about her art. She's amazing, and I can't get enough of listening to her. Thank you so much, dear. You keep going, you're absolutely brilliant.
Any vocal artist has my full respect. I've never been able to fully explore my own vocal range in a musical connotation, so to hear such a huge difference in style from one artist is really amazing. I don't think the people who are claiming you use autotune truly or can truly appreciate the work you've put in.
It sounds like Chester Bennington with the raspy vocals lol!! Love it!
I discovered you by luck a couple days algo and i've been obsesed with your music since then! Love your job ❤