Putin's army destroyed by his own 'Maskirovka' | Philip Ingram
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 07. 2023
- "Those that were charged with designing the new Russian tanks, making sure that the stocks in storage were maintained...were using their own Maskirovka as they pocket the money."
Putin's Maskirovka deception tactics have made his own army decompose, former intelligence officer Philip Ingram tells #timesradio
---
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times Times.Radio/Subscribe
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Tune in to Times.Radio for free today 📻
All these propaganda doesn't help to hide the truth.
And the truth is that after one and a half year, the damn Ruskkies are still there...
So, why keep lying and covering up the truth?
I agree with him. The mutiny is a massive charade. They want a pinscher movement from Belarus in the north and crimea in the south
@@1966bluemax wet thingking and wishful dreams. 😳😁😂
@@1966bluemaxIf that’s the case why didn’t they just secretly move the Wagner Group quietly at night? I guess it’s possible that the Russians are playing 5D chess but Occam’s Razor suggests otherwise.
@@crimfan We've seen plenty of the ruslik 5d chess the past few years. For example the glorious idea of packing parade uniforms with the hordes that were supposed to take Kyiv. Occlom's Razor says: "Never attribute to 5d chess that which is adequately explained by stupidity"
.This is a great interview. Allowing Ingram to give a broad detailed account without interruptions. Ingram is a complex resource. Thank you
Fabulous interview brilliant man! Thank you so much
Wow, so refreshing to hear guests with such an in-depth knowledge. Time Radio keeps delivering. Thank you.
A very worthwhile and insightful interview. Thank you both. 👍
Excellent interviewer and excellent guest in Philip Ingram. An absorbing interview.
@kirsch-qj9bga fresh 3 month old baby Kremlin Gremlin account seen in it's natural environment, able to spread vranyo hours after being born
a disgusting little public schoolboy without the ability to think for himself
Western media narratives. No facts just complete bs. HOPE YOU ENJOYED COME BACK TOMORROW FOR SOME MORE. THE UKRAINIAN NAZIS ARMY ARE USELESS AGAINST THE RUSSIAN ARMY. WHY DOES THE COKEHEAD JEWISH COMIC ACTOR KEEP WANTING MORE WEAPONS???
One of THE MOST intelligent and sensible discussions I have heard in a long time. Absolute pleasure and privilege listening to this man.
Jackanory total western media narratives been spoken so we can send more money and try to look good for potato Joe for the NATO members next week. The Russian are destroying the UKRAINIAN NAZIS ARMY
Ukraine has "probed" 2,500 vehicles and 20,000 soldiers to death ....
citation needed.
Another high quality imformative interview, many thanks please keep them coming
Col. Douglas MacGregor's interviews are great, too.
Excellent questions and fascinating, sometimes tantalizing answers. Thank you.
Maskarova is just another way saying they lie about everything.
It's "Maskirovka". But yeah, you're basically right 😂
Maskirovka means “camouflaging to avoid detection”
Goes hand in hand with Vranyo. Everyone lies, everyone knows they’re lying, everyone knows they know they are lying!
Russian leaders seem to be pathological liars. Is it part of their culture?
@@gerristaples3595 “vranyo” means just “blatant lies”. Practiced by Putin all the time
Love this guys script reading abilities, bravo you sir one government bot right there!
One of the best interviews I have heard.👍👍👍👍👍
I''m getting the feeling that russia is realizing they've lost the war. Putin's "Kyiv in 3 days" bit didn't work out for them haha.
@saratov1 yes, he screamed it
I have got the exact opposite feeling!
@@nadimabdelaal6494 Oh lordy I still remember putin screaming his "Kyiv in 3 days", what fools they have made of themselves. Russia is nothing more than the world's joke at this point lol
@@dpelpal Come on, they still hold 20%, of Ukraine!
@@nadimabdelaal6494 I think they only hold 12%, and russia's currency collapsed today. Not good for russia, very bad day. I bet putin wishes he could take back his "Kyiv in 3 days" speech lol
Thanks for a great interview. I have become fan of the channel!
This one of the best dialogues on the Ukrainian/Russian War I've had the opportunity to watch.
Excellent interview.
Thank you!
Perhaps the best description and insight of this conflict I've heard so far.
War is NOT "Call of Duty", you don't get free respawns, they should take their time and get it right first time and keep their forces alive Slava Ukraine
Ruble is crashing today, I think russia is starting to realize they've lost
@@dpelpal its not crashing today... it been steadily declining against the $ since oct 2022..
That's exactly what he said they were doing.
I love Russian ppls, unfortunately the only way to hurt the leaders is to punish the ppl who let him run things, their complacency gives him power, this makes him their fault by default
Well thanks for pointing out the bleeding obvious.
theyve been saying this since the war started, yet it still rolls on.
Really enjoyed this informative interview…hope you bring the guest back for a part 2 analysis
The difference of listening to a genuine specialist.
Such a great guest!!! I'm much more informed about the war thanks to your interview.
I just discovered this channel and I'm very glad I did:)
Thanks for helping to understand the difficulties the Ukrainians have to contend with ...
From "Kyiv in 3 days" to "St. Petersburg in an hour."
I'll never forget putin screaming his "Kyiv in 3 days" lol. Most hilarious clip EVER.
@@dpelpal please tell me where I can find this clip. I genuinely would like to find it so that I can save it to my hard drive and then publish it when Ukraine wins this fight. 🙂
Ukraine is doing the right thing. Their policy is "Slowly but surely". They will not risk men and equipment by seeking big gains quickly, and that's the mistake the Russians have being making since day one.
@@neilbadger4262 Find it yourself.
@@stuartx7865 I have actually tried. The difficulty is in knowing which words to use in the search. I remember Lukashenko publishing the original war plan, but was simply asking on where to find the 3 day quote.
This is a great interview, Philip Ingram is top shelf!
Putin not going to take "Kyiv in 3 days" no matter how many times he screams it
😂😁😳😀
In the propaganda department! Sigh
@@sallymarvin5981 up your sallyport
@@sallymarvin5981😂yes that's exactly what I was going to say. Top shelf propaganda expert 🎉
👍👍👍 A very interesting in depth explanation of the key importance of intelligence and deception in the Ukrainian conflict and beyond.
Bravo 👏
incredibly intelligent and informative commentary 😎
One of the most intelligent and interesting conversation of politics and deception on the art of war
really? he doesnt even know whats going on... putin is thinning out the herd. so is zelensky
The west is "deception", 'cos there is no truth to it at all!
Yes 2 soft lads in a studio that have never had a fight everything they know can from a book. Is called western media narratives nothing to do with reality.
@@savetheoligarchs they all are. This guy is miskroviaing.
Times are the best news on Ukraine. Great questions professional people
They need to have Ben Hodges and Michael Clarke on more
DW news
Kait Borsay and John Pienaar are the best interviewers on this channel.
Also they get the best real experts and allow them to answer without interruption.
DW and 1420 also do the latter.
@@dpelpal
Ben literally does 15 interviews a day. You can find him on every channel. Same old thing
Very clear and relevant explanation of current situation
So absorbing - thank you hugely..for sharing the sum of all those years of intelligence experience. It is helping those of us trying to catch up on the historical perspective.
Check out what J Baud has to say. He actually worked in Ukraine for years for NATO as a senior Swiss intel officer. It's important to hear all sides. Also look into Western propaganda and its history. The way the media just posts the lies without question and from the MIC funded think tanks without even saying their bias/funding.
@@andrewnorris5415there are no two sides, there's the Russian invasion of an independent country, and there's an independent country being invaded, we wash our behind with your Russian propaganda. Greetings from Europe
The thumbnail shouldn’t be overlooked. Putin’s Army literally is rotting in their trenches. Their motto is “Every man left behind”.
You sound like a complete fool,
Russia may be good at maskirovka, but this time it seems they have been so good at it that they have been maskirovka themselves. They believed they could take Kyiv in three days.
Actually just what Phillip Ingram is describing 😊
I can't stop laughing at that clip of putin screaming "Kyiv in 3 dayyyyyyys!" 😂😂
Retired General Khoderanok "lets not take information sedatives" on Russian TV 60 minutes.
@@sands7779 - Ruskies lie so much and so often, AND THEN they drink to blackout proportions. After that, they cannot tell which is truth and which is lie. Must be horribly confusing the next day when you can’t remember what the heck actually happened, no?
@@dpelpalfunny given he never said that ..
It was US general milley who said this
I spoke about maskirovka already when the Wagner Group marched against Moscow. And now Times Radio is using it as well... well done, guys!
Excellent commentary and insight.
These Times interviews are always first class. So glad I found them.
First class western media narratives bs it is. Not the truth just a story
this series of reports on Ukraine has been consistently among the very best reporting anywhere. Hats off to you...
How many times have they been wrong? Remember a week or so back when the same outlet told you Putin was finished and Wagner was going to march on Moscow. how did that turn out?
Terrific interview. Thank you.
You get very good guests on this broadcast who know what they are talking about. I have started coming to you for real news. What we get in the US is often nonsense from self-appointed experts. You have the real thing.
That was the most informative interview I’ve seen with regards to this war ..
The third front. All the attacks inside Russia? Is an extremely effective strategy. Recruiting anti-Putin Russian partisans, and providing them with the means to sabotage the Russian war machine, truly delights me. Slava Ukraini!
There are no such
@@JohnCSmith-lp1qr Roger that Vlad. They don't exist, Got it. 👍
its just meaningless publicity stunts. I doubt those guys will be back in Belgorod now the Chechens are there.
@@bobeyes3284 The Russians love Putin ! Hope you got that too 😊. Dont know about some Imaginary rebels 🤣 Thats your sphere of Expertise Bob
@@JohnCSmith-lp1qryou are right.. those are "little green men" inside terroRuzziaNazi" causing chaos just like what pootin said in 2014 😂😂 you can buy those weapons/ vehicles in any military store 😂😂😂😂
This reporter is amazing, very thoughtful interview and an excellent guest. 🌺🙏🌺
What a great conversation.
Wow! Great interview Kate, you are my favorite interviewer with Phillip Ingram, brilliant man. Mr Ingram shares my respect and awe of another highly intelligent person, General Kryllo Budanov. This was an action packed piece and certainly perked up my morning cup of tea. Today is already feeling much more optimistic. 🇺🇦🇺🇸🇬🇧🇦🇺
Keep sending them money and weapons, the UKRAINIAN NAZIS ARMY are being fooked properly fooked. You won't find the truth here.
Really enjoyed listening to this guy’s insights. He’s obviously intel based and his curated position is evidence based.
Intel based = giving out propoganda which you have swallowed
@@robsurname4054 Like putin screaming his whole "KYIV IN 3 DAYS" bit lol, putn just throwin' out the propaganda
@@robsurname4054 Interesting that you see his views as propoganda (sic). How do you see the situation?
@@dpelpal That statement, about getting to Kiev in 3 days, was created in the West .. It's called a straw man's argument.
W
Really good conversation. Thanks
Really interesting interview. Thank you
The goal is to create doubt, even among a small part of the population…you want your opponent to have significant percentage people say ‘we don’t know what to believe/what is true’
Yup... the Russian influenced Trump campaign, with Russian Troll farms generating anti Democrat stuff and accusations and distractions... on Facebook, Twitter, and others !
Bingo ! and Trump aided and abetted them... and he knew it.
Wow - fascinating stuff - wonderful to listen to Mr Ingram’s views .. intelligent man & straight shooter 🙇♀️👍👍✌️
One of the best guests you’ve ever had. He’s Brilliant.
Yes, he's a brilliant liar. UN inspectors are on site at Zaporizhizhia Nuclear Power Plant and send back reports daily. They report that no Russian explosives are being planted. A disaster at the ZNPP would spew radioactive material all over the Russian controlled parts of Ukraine, so it would make no sense for them to sabotage the ZNPP. Russians get better info than Westerners are getting from their miserable lying media and governments.
He's putting a good spin on Ukraine's failed offensive
Fantastic interview. Great questions and illuminating answers. thank you!
Spot on assessment. Best yet. 👌
A brilliant interview and explanation from Mr. Philip Ingram
Fascinating interview - thanks!
An intelligent and erudite insight. Thank you.
Really enjoying this analysis. One of the best. Thank you
😂😂😂. Clown show.
I learned a lot! Thank you
great discussion, thanks.
I appreciate these interviews with knowledgeable guests, thanks!
Slava Ukraine…Glory to all the Heroes of Ukraine….💙💛💙
This is pure propaganda you sheep
@@mike4480 lol yeah right baaaaaa
@@ganndeber1621 - Lots of Ruskies becoming fertilizer, just not enough.
It is always pleasurable to hear people say what we want them to say even if it isn't true, isn't it?
The longer Ukraine holds out the more frayed Russia becomes
It is exact the other way round, time is a factor helping putin!
@n: Can‘t you Russiabots do anything else besides project and whataboutism?
Russia's currency has collapsed today
@@nadimabdelaal6494 is it now? only last week the country almost came to civil war due to his shambolic army performance and unsustainable losses... that doesnt sound like time is on Putins side.. the Russia economy is far too small to weather this for long term, where does all the money come from to sustain a war like this?
But unfortunately the more destruction carried out by Russia. Putin is making sure there is no Ukraine left …….shameful……..
Phil is brilliant. Was warching while somewhat distracted, but he kept making solid points. I will set aside some time that I can devote full attention to this interview as I watch again. Kate was, as always, the best.
A solid point. The leader is a cokehead Jewish comic actor and the army he is incharge of are Nazis. The reason the Jew is begging everyday is because Russia is destroying everything. Russia are killing the UKRAINIAN NAZIS ARMY at ratio of 10.1. there's is some solid points that are all true but you won't of heard them on this site.
brilliant analysis, great interview
Maskirovka, like all bluffs, works until it is called. Russia has been bluffing hard and now it's been called they are crumbling.
Is Russia crumbling?
Big time
@@joshuaalistair3193 I think it very much depends on perspective.
If you take the idea that Russia initially planned to invade and take over the whole of Ukraine, yet now they are focused on trying to defend about half of Zaporizhzhia and half of the Donbas, one may speculate that Russia is not doing very well when compared to their ambition.
In terms of Russia crumbling, it is difficult to get accurate figures and then persuade pro Russians the truth behind those figures. Like the sanctions, the economic stability in Russia, the drop in oil and gas sales. It all adds up to Russia digging itself into an ever deepening hole.
@@joshuaalistair3193 Very much so, or what do you think's happened over the past 10 days?
The only thing crumbling is the money and weapons the collective west has sent. The UKRAINIAN NAZIS ARMY are useless against the Russian army
It is good to see how smart and experienced this guy is. He knows these stuff deeply!
Unlike putin and his "kyiv in 3 days" lol
He's a Scot. They are Pragmatic People.
@@AnthonyOMulligan-yv9cgActually he’s Irish. Not that it matters. There are canny, intelligent, strategically adept people living within most cultures.
the big question is, does anyone listen to him. I hope so.... nothing like the right guy analyzing what's happening and some politician not listening to a real professional
@@EasyTiger.01343 I'm Irish myself, he sounds more Scots to me ......He must be Northern
Good questioning - relevant, smart, sequential, short; prompting Ingram, then staying out of his way.
I like this interview. Very good interviewer, but absolutely brilliant guest
Check out Col. Douglas MacGregor interviews.
This man is really informative and insightful. I could listen to him for hours. Great interview.
perhaps you could, but he is lying
@@widows-sun-369 - Why aren't you on the frontlines?
@@ColdRunnerGWN why would i give my life for an illegitimate cause. you are a fooooool!
@@widows-sun-369 Putin Troll
Agree 💯... wouldn't mind hearing from him again!
"Everything is going according to plan."
-Saddam Putsein
"We've destroyed 200 leopards..." Bakhmut Bob
@@toromontana8290 Muscovite 🇷🇺 Ruble has crashed, touching 91 Rubles to 1 Dollar 💲 😁
@@drfill9210 Muscovite 🇷🇺 Ruble has crashed, touching 91 Rubles to 1 Dollar 💲 😁
Saddam is a fool compared to Putin, Putin got the power to realize his goals, he got nukes!
Not really a good comparison as the US actually invaded Iraq.
It's more like
"My wunderwaffe will win us the war!"
-Vladolf Putler
General: What is our wunderwaffe?
Putin: Meatwaves.
Great Interview with Philip Ingram. Very interesting and informative. More of him please 🇬🇧🇺🇦
Excellent. Thank you.
Good morning thank you so much for your support 🙏🙏
I dunno, I'm starting to get the feeling russia knows they've lost.
Very interesting! Thanks to Mr. Ingram.
Great channel. I wish for labeled chapter links.
My heart goes out to the wonderful citizens of the Ukraine. May God be with you all.
British tells lies in favor Ukraine
God will never be with them as Zelensky closed half of their churches.
@@freemenofengland2880NO he didn't stop lying
I don't know if they are so wonderful, probably they are as average as you and me.
On the other hand: they need help as they are getting slaughtered and occupied.
The Russian army "maskirovkaing" Putin himself all this time.
Excellent insights, intelligence from the Intelligent time served Military officer
Brilliant interview. An absolute wealth of information.
Excellent reporting..aThx😮😮
What a enjoyable interview. Such a intelligent and knowledgeable man 🙋♀️
Yes he is very good at propaganda and misinformation
Thank you (Ret) LTC Ingram,
Hoping this interview it explains the difficulties that the AFU are overcoming and performing at their own pace and without air superiority and also not having the best of the best weapon platforms that most if not all western armies have at their disposal. The AFU are truly awesome and amazing forces.
“The price of freedom is eternal vigilance.”
Thomas Jefferson
“It is impossible to conquer a nation determined to be free!”
Thomas Paine, Letter to the People of France, 1792
Slava Ukraine - Slava Warriors - Heroyam Slava🇺🇦🔱🇺🇦🔱❤️❤️❤️
Suggest you google Ukraine cnn 2014. This is when the reported the news
Yes, the former intel officer does a fine job of putting lipstick on that pig. But at the end of the day... it's still a pig. In other words he is as the Bible says, tickling your ears telling you want you want to here. Yet at the end of the day Russia is winning the war not only against Ukraine, but against NATO as well.
@@elizabethpiper8846 Your comment is meaningless; what news - that Putin planned, armed, financed & initiated an entirely fake "separatist revolt".
Heck, the FSB even paid Ukrainian organised crime groups linked to the Russian mafia to carry out false flag attacks on pro Ukraine ethnic Russians as part of the _casus belli_
Give he Ukrainians cluster bombs, for goodness sakes. Who at this point cares about geopolitics? Even the biggest fool knows what is going on at the front and what Ukraine faces. End it. Give them cluster bombs to clear out the trenches and F16s to support infantry.
What freedom . Zelenskyy is leading an American NATO coup country. They have spent so many lives NATO will have to use robots to to do the fighting and borrow the money to build them from Blackrock.
Most intelligent man I've ever heard talking on these subjects
One of the best interviews on this channel that I’ve watched. I mentioned Philip Ingram to a friend of mine who does something in the military, they won’t say what for obvious reasons, but said Philip is a really great guy. More please.
I did something in the military but won't say what for obvious reasons, but I'm saying Philip is a "yes man" liar.
@@joshuaalistair3193 You forgot to mention that you were in the russian military.
@@stuartx7865 Not at all, I was in the US army.
Now listen to Douglas Macgregor and Alistair crook for the real story.
You can definitely trust a ‘former’ mi5 officer to tell the truth, because he would never die any disinformation or perform any deception, especially not in wartime
What happened to the idea of effective economic sanctions? Over 1000 western large corporations are still doing business in Russia!
Boycott UNILEVER.
Economic and other sanctions do have a significant effect, but they cannot stop a war. Besides, if a Western company is still running a factory there or running a chain of shops, this doesn't make any difference for the war. If that company left Russia, then the factory would just be taken over by Russia, then restarted, and they would still make the exact same products. Same logic is true for the shops. McDonalds leaving Russia makes ZERO difference for the war and is only symbolic. The real sanctions are about blocking foreign funds, blocking access to money, not buying their gas and oil, blocking access to advanced electronics and technology,... Corporations still doing business inside Russia makes no difference, as long as they are not making weapons or bringing in "illegal" resources.
@@janickpauwels3792
That’s only partially true. Any non-Russian Co doing business in Russia maintains financial connections with a Western fin institution which can be used for laundering money, etc. Making ANY financial connections illegal would close the still existing 1K+ avenues.
My comment is about inadequacy of our, Western leaders to use economic sanctions in coordinated way. For ex, say the West says to China & India that unless they stop doing ANY business with Russia tomorrow at noon THE WHOLE WEST will stop buying stuff from them tomorrow at noon as well. The reason this [obviously exaggerated] scenario is not considered boils down to the inadequacy I am alluding here. It also indirectly boils down to a conclusion that the West ‘prefers’ wars to peaceful solutions. This inadequacy costs lives and literally endangers peace for the rest of us.
I used to have a colleague from russia using this maskeroska technique. He would say everything and the opposite of everything, going round and round endlessly in every argument. He was the reason why I left because it is a cultural trait very sickening to having to deal with.
i know it well
Orwell's Doublethink
whereas all the evening news broadcasts in the UK about the rebels winning the war in Syria and the Taliban losing in Afghanistan turned out to be what? The truth?
@@ClubofInfo-Circulation "Sun Tzu best expressed the martial role of deception in saying "All warfare is based on deception." Deceptions can involve false maneuvers, feigned attacks, misleading orders of battle, and creation of deceiving indications of strength or weakness in attempts to influence an enemy's actions."
Now imagine the Russian culture. It's marinated in this stuff.
As Winston Churchill said, "In wartime, truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies."
Famine or no famine, Indians will always breed like rabbits." - Winston Churchill, on the 1943 Bengal famine
Ooops! Some ruzzi-Bots were detected by YT and removed.
This woman regularly brings on British military 'experts'. By now I am convinced that UK military must be the most incompetent in the world.
Unfortunately their incompetence is matched, or exceeded, by their politicians.
That conclusion comes just from the fact she brings on military experts on ? Amazing. Do any of them say that British military is incompetent.
@@Bruintjebeer6 except the person you've replied to said the opposite of what you're suggesting. They said 'REGULARLY' brings on experts. You've written 'doesn't bring military experts that often'. How have you managed to get so passive aggressive when you haven't even read what they've written correctly?
Is arguing online the best thing you can think of doing? If so, do it properly, and read what you're replying to.
Pretty sure the Russians take the crown for incompetence. Britain specialises in getting second place (this is a running gag regarding sports before anyone reads too deeply into this)
@@standarduck5860 Changed it. I misread. That is what you get when you try to do 3 things at the same time
I don't understand the issue you're having. LtC(ret) Ingram is widely known to be an insightful and experienced military analyst, a combat veteran, and nothing he said is unreasonable in terms of estimations, or untrue in terms of factual content.
Sure, politicians are untrustworthy, but Radio Times are not politicians. They're journalists. I feel like this is more a case of "Anything I Don't Like is Propaganda" than any legitimate complaint against Radio Times, the journalist, or LtC Ingram.
Excellent commentary and such a easily understood overview of the current situation
Haha pity that not a word he said is true.
@@rickydee5863 ohhhh go play with your crayons....like YOU'D actually have a clue. Silly kid.
@@rickydee5863Enlighten us? 🙄🤡 Yea, we’ll wait! 🤦🏼♂️
Excellent interview. Both on the part of the interviewer, who tee'd up the Colonel nicely and especially on the part of the interviewee, who was succinct, informative and illustrated that very entertaining Ulster dry wit perfectly.
Best analysis I've yet to see.
This is a very great discussion.
Phillip Ingram, fascinating interviewee, unique knowledge and a great way with words, thank you!
Yes he can read a good story for sure. The facts are totally different than the western media narratives he spoke. The truth is out there just not on here.
These companies still doing business with these terrorists need to be named, shamed, and boycotted.
Unilever is amongst the worst
You can send letters or emails to their head offices. If enough people write, they may start to feel a twinge of conscience.
Germany was 1 of them until the world terrorist America decided to blow up Nord stream pipeline.
Business doesn’t care about borders unless forbidden to do so by some political entity.
Like the people who tried to make everyone get the clot shot?
Excellent!
Really good interview
Well said by a brilliant man
Putin is rekt. It's just a matter of time.
Ruble is rekt, and keeps getting rekt-er by the minute.
@@dpelpal that too
Great comment, Ukraine stay strong ❤❤❤❤❤❤our hearts are with you ALL
😂😂😂 to the last Ukrainian.
What will happen after?
Your Generals will replace them?
Good luck.
Excellent Phillip Ingram a well honed mind