the fact that yg said all of this and now lee sooman's first ever work outside of sm was with loona...... and the fact that hyunjin nominated yg for the ice bucket challenge...
He definitely did. After she responded to his harsh comment with confidence and positivity, he said “this is frustrating”. Literally mad because he wasn’t able to hurt them
He is always like this, even with his wife, he destroyed her career to have her. He bullied 2NE1, constantly mocking their appearance. It's partly a entertainment business strategy - break your employees confidence so they don't know their self worth and stay at the company, working for less. He is honestly an awful, awful man. Many of them are but at least he got what he deserved.
Just saying but I will never forgive the editors of the show for editing out Haseul's singing audition to make her seem like she didn't do enough/didn't have talent at all
Bro i cried because of how yg was mean to all of them but especially to haseul, now she lacks confidence and is on hiatus because of anxiety and that made me cry even more :( she's the best
Think of it this way (and now she's back yay) Haseul was in front of one of the most powerful men in her industry, who was openly bullying her and her beloved members. AND SHE STOOD UP TO HIM in such a mature and kind way. She is an absolute boss and to me? She completely owned him and made him look like a f u c wit
@@selty i really respect Haseul for standing up well to that idiotic man, had it been me in her shoes, I would've stood up for myself and the members too, but not that kindly. Harsh criticism exists, but he's downright mocking them. Nobody has the right to downplay someone's effort and determination. Really shows you how YG's management is literal shit, because the man who built it is shit too.
They were biased from the beginning, not once did the camera pan on Haseul, they kept centering in on heejin and HyunJin😤 but anyways Stream Sonatine🥰😘
I don't think you can say they were biased to Heejin and HyunJin since they probably edited a lot of Haseul's parts out since she didn't make it onto the show. It doesn't make sense to give a lot of screen time to someone that the audience only sees once on screen.
@@jo-py4wq I'm not sure if you're talking about the auditions of the 101 trainees (like in ep. 1 and 2 of the seasons) or the auditions of those who didn't make it into the 101. But for mixnine, there were 98 girls who actually made it onto the show (and all the boys too) and they didn't even show all the auditions of those 98 girls. So to me, it wouldn't make sense to show the full auditions of trainees who didn't make it onto the show bc they didn't even have enough time to show the trainees that made it on. Sorry if that's a confusing sentence. Edit: But if it's the second case, I think you're completely right and I would actually love to see those videos!
I hate how some people said that haseul was ‘arrogant’ and that the girls needed a reality check. Yg was laughing at them because they believed in themselves. Y’all saying that they were ‘arrogant’ when they believed that they could become the best girl group, of course it sounds arrogant, but they believed that they could become better and be a great girl group. They knew that they weren’t the best but they knew that had some skill which they could improve. Those people who said haseul was ‘arrogant’ when she literally didn’t praise herself when she knew she danced badly. If you see closely, you know that she was ‘laughing’ during her dance because she knew she didn’t do well. She even gave herself a 2 for skill, she isn’t arrogant, she knows that she isn’t the best and felt that she could practice more. The girls did their best and they are amazing now so if you call them ‘arrogant’ or that they need a ‘reality check’, I’m going to track you down and slap you with my Loona lightstick
Dude even the younger judge is creepy. The way he laughs when they first come in and just his whole demeanour. But of course the bigger sleeze is sitting next to him.
Haseul, you made me proud to stan LOONA the way you spoke so clearly and confidently for your group. You deserve to the leader and I personally think you made LOONA look humble and hard-working. You will only get better as you work harder! Also, if yall watch the web drama they're in, Haseul's acting is the best in my opinion.
HaSeul is a vocalist, she stated so herself. She doesn't dance much - and it's fine. Her vocals are actually really good and it's clear that they edited her singing out to make her look worse. Has YG forgotten that two out of the four 2NE1 members couldn't dance? And that's coming from a person who still answers Blackjack when asked what my fandom is. I'm realistic.
blacKpinKpop well haseul can dance whatever choreo given to her if she practice But dancing in competition like this requires putting their own creativity and uniqueness. If thats what yg requires in haseul knowing well her position is vocal i can only say too bad for haseul, not unexpected
Như Nguyễn not sure if Haseul choreographed this dance herself or if it was given to her, but yes she could dance it but the execution was pretty bad. It doesn't matter that us fans know what these trainees are capable of because the only thing YG is basing his judgement on is what was given to him in this audition. And yes, for this competition YG is definitely looking for creativity and uniqueness. If you've seen other auditions from other trainees, even though they did well YG still slammed them for being boring or choosing the wrong song for this competition.
The fact that he laughed at haseul is so rude but I gained so much more respect for Haseul in seeing her reaction to his criticism. She is a true leader and has the kindest heart.
Most of JYP's criticisms comes with detailed points for them to improve while YG's most of the times will just be whether he likes the performance or not then sprinkle it with either insults or compliments.
YG: "the girls on that bus are prettier than you," Heejin and Hyunjin: win top visuals YG: soLo aLbuMs????!?!?! whAt tYpe oF coNcEpt iS tHat? also YG: every member of blackpink will have a solo (and then never release them smh)
THE AUDACITY. He was so godamn rude to Haseul. She even joked about her own dancing herself, she knows it's not her ace card. She is a Powerhouse singer, a morale boosting leader, and a brilliant, charismatic diplomat. It's so infuriating to see her getting mistreated on a biased reality show like this.
Haseul doesn’t back down when Loona’s being shit on and I just LOVE IT! The girls couldn’t answer YG’s rude ass question so Haseul stepped in and took the heat, as she always does. She’s the best leader with the most confidence, and didn’t back down even when YG was LITERALLY LAUGHING in the middle of her sentence lol. Haseul’s the best.
If Haseul started belting out her Opera voice she would be in the bus within seconds. And the manager looked so proud and worried for them, I hope he's still around in bbc
That guy with hat is YG? ........BBC saw potential and they brought forth 12 powerful girls that work hard 24/7, and still got a long way to go. This man was offensive, and cruel, they surely have proved him wrong. I mean, look at the content and good quality songs these girls produced.
Haseul is a vocalist and she sang as well but they cut that part to make her look worse. They didn’t put forth their best, but they did better than they edited to show. I think their company just made the wrong choice regarding what they auditioned with. Nice to know that BBC ceo is really encouraging and supportive so that when they’re treated like this, he’ll help build their confidence back up and fix what they did wrong.
ssozi 86 No offense but yg doesn’t really have room to speak on that when he’s given Dara a solo. You don’t even need to sing well because studio editing exist. They’ve all released solos though and it showed that they had enough vocal talent. Haseul released “let me in” - a a ballad. Hyunjin also released a ballad. And heejin released a kind of jazzy pop song called “vivid”.
everyone knows that dara had really lacking in vocal skills, even in the philippines, she did release solo album in ph and was a hit. but yg casted her after he saw the documentary abt her when she was famous in the philippines, she did not audition to become idol, she even told yg that she was more fit to be actress. dara has great charms and hardworking. she's always humble, esp in every guesting show in ph, she's a huge kpop star but she's still the same (unlike haseul did even she's not that succesful yet, it was just one album, and they were asked on how they will win over the other girls in the show that can sing and dance well than them? and she answered, that they were told they were good to put on solo albums. after her poor performance, how dumb was to say that? and take note, she did audition for promotion, amen)
If JinSoul, Choery and Kimlip joined them i think theyll be going in the bus for sure and it would be best if Haseul sang one of their song... Haseul dont be discouraged😭😭😭
he/she's not biased if Odd Eye Circle joined them they would've passed, I personally think that OEC are talented enough to be MIXNINE, Don't get me wrong, I'm sure Heejin, Hyunjin and Haseul are as talented as OEC but i think they're not ready to be here, Haseul and Hyunjin need to improve their dancing and Heejin needs to improve her stamina at singing, I think OEC should've auditioned since they're good at dancing and their stamina is good too.
El Pene Negro De Namjoon i think yves, olivia and kim lip would have been the best representation for loona’s dance line. they have the most confidence and skill when performing
Haseul was so hurt when she said "Well, first of all, our company thought we were good enough to debut solo" after YG said that thing about people on the bus being better than them. She wasn't arrogant she was hurt and I felt it for her 😭 So happy that she's back with promotions right now, hope they could erase this from their memory somehow bc this definitely factored in for the anxiety
the show was trash anyway and none of them ended up debuted lmao, YG should’ve just sat there and stick at taking care of Blackpink because that’s the only thing they good at 💅🏿✨
he cant even properly manage blackpink and give them proper songs without the same repetitive formula and has the nerve to come after loona’s solo albums LMAO
Dear Leader Haseul, Thank you for making Stan Loona and thank you for being the greatest leader of all.We,Orbits will cheer and love you all without even a little break.We will always think of you,Loona.So don't give up and keep up! Orbits ❤ To our beloved Loona💕
6:09 YG disses Haseul about dancing, then says that she shouldn't expect to be putting out albums! Guess what... albums contain singing, not dancing! She's a great singer!!
ikr! even a dance trainer like bae yoon jung tells trainees to focus on singing as much as dancing, if not more, because an idol in its core is a singer. yg either doesn't know what he's saying or is too in his head and saying nonsense
Yes, Haseul danced badly, but do not keep her talent down. She works hard at dancing and sings very well (Haseul was a student of opera). Do not be like the YG that belittles the talent of others just because they are not so good at dancing. Dara and Park Bom from 2NE1 are not out to dance, and that is not why YG undervalued their talent. He's a hypocrite for saying that Haseul doesn't have enough talent just because he didn't dance well.
Haseul's fancams dancing in three completely different concepts: favOriTe: czcams.com/video/Ld1lSZrqLIQ/video.html Hi High: czcams.com/video/GmFu7oVZRis/video.html Butterfly: czcams.com/video/N9rli_rEtZA/video.html
Funny how he said Haseul didn’t have the skill to release a solo album when... she literally did release a solo album. Long before she went on mixnine.
Here’s the thing: usually the show is edited so the ones who pass the auditions get more screentime and the others don’t really get it BUT while they were showing the girls’ solos they didn’t show Haseul’s solo WHICH led to people not knowing she can sing VERY well. You can see this was targeted towards Haseul not only by showing the judges’ reaction which is a part of editing a show BUT showing the trainees’ disgusted faces. WHO DOES THAT WITHOUT A REASON? That’s messed up. Look at loona now, more successful than YG’s old ass
they didn’t show haseul in introducing, they showed 2jin and called them pretty and cut haseul out. they didn’t show haseul a mv and cut out her singing and just showed her dance when next to her is loonas main dancer. this is so unfair.
this is just heartbreaking for me i can't imagine how bad she felt after that😭😭😭😭😭😭 at least she has improved a lot and i saw on butterfly era she had so much more confidence on stage💖💖 I LOVE YOU HASEUL
I am not sure whether they are the most talented but I am definitely sure their visuals are standing out in all the female trainees especially Hyunjin, she really looks like Tzuyu + Naeun, I don't think there is anyone can beat her visual tbh.
@@flyingraven8933 No need to tear down the other girls just to make Loona seem superior when they were all talented and pretty/handsome in their own unique ways and the same goes to the first commenter above the 2nd's.
@@fearnotmyinsomniaonce4579 it's not tearing the other girls down, it's merely stating a fact. it's also a jab at yg for saying that the girls in the bus are prettier than all of them when it is super obvious that they're the top visuals there. what yg did to 1/3 is borderline tearing them down and crushing them.
I understand being a detailed criticizer and strict person, as well as having a certain expectation, but YG didn’t have to go that deep. If he wants to be a strict judge, that’s fine as long as it’s not discouraging them. But he could’ve at least gave them a few pointers so they know what’s what next time. But hey. At least Loona’s doing fine these days. Just goes to show that there will always be different opportunities for success.
thats why haseul was like 'i expected to receive some pointers so i could grow but...' the shade LMAO she knows he's a bad judge/instructor. completely unhelpful. mean comments without any kind of guidance
Haseul is so courageous and a born leader of an amazing group. YG is a psycho, he enjoyed stripping away young girls enthusiasm and passion and natural confidence, and she took a breath and stood up to him - one of the most powerful producers in the asian music scene. I am so amazed and inspired by her standing up for them at the end. True born leader.
i hope loona gonna be the best girl group in the future . no wonder they will debut next year and all loonatics still waiting for the new members of loona . 💛💛
This video is honestly so damn haunting because Yg was literally so wrong in everything he said and everything Haseul, Hyunjin and heejin said are all true. But honestly what did we expect from a boss who even stepped down on 2ne1’s confidence and literally hated the idea of women thriving on their own without his help. He only likes women in a really bad way and I don’t even want to say what exact way bc it’s disgusting. Hope he goes to jail for good
Loona better than all girl groups Loona better than all Boy groups Loona better than all kpop groups Loona better than any musician Loona is phenomenal Loona is Life Loona is power Loona is god Loona is the Universe
i freaking hate that guy for saying that there were people who were prettier than them on the bus when the other guy was drooling. like the editing obviously pointed out their sheer beauty, everyone in both buses were utterly and genuinely shocked and taken aback at heejin and hyunjin when their showed their faces, i would say that heejin and hyunjin are arguably the prettiest people to have come onto the show, over girls and boys. they look like "ulzzangs" and everyone knew it
some fans uploaded it, i've seen it earlier. jtbc yt channel only uploads the group perf from each agencies... the solo perf, u may seen it on mixnine channel on vlive... the problem was finding it, coz every title of the vidz were written in korean language.
YG was just mad he didn't think about doing a project like Loona before, he knew they could succeed, so he decided to crush their confidence instead. Little did he know that made the girls stronger
i won’t forgive myself for watching this back in 2017 and not stanning them back then :< i remember seeing them on mixnine and i was like haseul’s my bias but did not listen to any of their tracks until butterfly came out
Our Mom-seul did her best!!! Loona have improved so much and Haseul is a necessity in team. She may not be the strongest in dance but she is an amazing vocalist and looks after the members so well. Every day Loona are becoming more and more successful and skilful and look at where YG is now-sitting in jail 😐
i don't know loona that well but haseul is making me wanna change that... she's so beautiful and cheerful, she really stood up not only for herself but for her team as well! i hate how yg treated her ugh he's disgusting
I've been following LOONA for a while and during their Butterfly promotion, I can say that Haseul really improved and when I say a lot, means A LOT. I know YG is the most strict judge but he's the one being a big disappointment in the show. He despise the fact that the girls are confident enough to answer his questions without stuttering.
And here we are in 2021...Oh how time flies! Balckpink members having their solo and LOONA being one of the greateast and most in sync girl groups ever!
same when i showed the video to my classmates... but it's okay! :) she will eventually be like the other vocal line of the other group. she will slowly be a good dancer in the future!
And look at them now , Dominating the world creating History while Yg failed to serve his artist and now jobless because he quitted trying to play Mr. know it all what a shame and I think all of YG’s artists are ashamed that their boss turned his back on them
@UCvYm6spnj_H_-yI9Xj4mXpg father figure? lol ok, unless their father is rude and disrespectful to them. what father tells their daughters that they're ugly for years? what father leaves a daughter in their dungeon for years?
I do understand where YG is coming from. Considering the fact that LOONA is starting to establish themselves as a "unique" group, we all have our expectations from them. In an industry where idols are overflowing, it would be stupid to coddle aspiring idols, so I don't think that YG was harsh or rude in any way. It was constructive criticism worded in a way to bring the girls back to reality. Furthermore, he was basing his criticism on the performance that they showed and to be honest it wasn't really up to par to what we expect from them, that we have to admit. Lastly, he KNOWS that they are talented, he even said it himself. They just need to refine and polish their skills, which YG could provide. Just support the members as much as you can guys. Let's enjoy and see their improvements :)
+Yeppeun Kpop I would kindly disagree with you. He was really stating facts and by no means was he saying those to knock down their confidence just for the sake of it. He said that to them, because the ladies believe that with their visuals and skills, they could become the best girl group. I think what he wants is for these trainees to feel that "desperation" that he always search for, because he knows that that is the factor that would bring out the best out of them. He sees something in them. He wouldn't pass the two ladies if he didn't. :)
The fact that he laughed at them when they said that their ceo considered them good for having solos, it is rude, I dunno. I think his attitude was not the most appropiate. It is their work how can he laaught at it
Poor Haseul. Shes sooo talented and yet so overlooked. Shes such a queen and diserved a chance as well. It makes my heart broke into peaces. I miss her sm and I hope she is doing well! We miss you Haseul. 💚💚😭😭
wow :( they didn’t even show haseul in the beginning and in the caption when heejin and hyunjin walked in it said “2 pretty girls” and for haseul it said nothing
i can tell they don't like haseul i mean.. like they literally called the other girls pretty and not haseul. and almost none of the filming was focused on haseul. poor girl.. yg didn't deserve them, their loss.
I think they still need time to grow as artists. I expected more from them for their audition, but I think that's what happens when you become attached to them after following them from the beginning. Putting my bias aside, I think they have the potential to be successful in the future if their company keeps doing what they've been doing and if they keep practicing, until then, this show is just for their promotion. I don't know how these shows work, but I'm hoping this is some form of publicity stunt where they improve as they go, and even if it isn't I'm sure they'll improve either way.
ive never liked papa yg but ever time i watch this i just 📈📈📈. jokes on him, loona is a viral success and they achieved that while part a small company with 20 employees that was definitely not of the big 3 (not that i'm hating on the big 3, my ults are from there. i'm just saying)
4:15 She won't be very good at dancing like the others, but she has a beautiful voice, you can see that she worked very hard at dancing. But what I did not like was that they cut where he sang and showed his charms
I feel like YG was judging them so harshly because he knows their group would be going against BP soon and while there is plenty of fans he wants all the money, since he can't seem to make a profit. Edit: He maybe was also jealous of their instant popularity for their unique concept.
There can be genuine harsh criticism from judges in survival shows, that are understandable, but here it feels like he is just being mean to them because he personally did not like them for no particular reason.
Love how he said "This is frustrating" right after Haseul's comment. I bet he's frustrated because he couldn't break or even shake her confidence. YG is a complete hypocrite, and Haseul & LOONA continue to do well despite the crap they get from people like YG. *Long live LOONA!!!*
everyone talking about how rude yg was to haseul, but i'm focused on how she did not get any solo shots. when they were introduced at the beginning, the camera did not focus on her and her solo was not edited in unlike the other two. at the end, the editing cherry picked her "bad dancing." during the group performance, you could see at the corner of your screen haseul's energy matching the other two. ugh the bias.
"There are prettier girls than you all in the bus, girls who can dance better than you all and sing well. How are you going to win over them?" Well, By making the best choreographies in all of kpop and experimenting with genres that have never been used in kpop before P.s. fr tho I can't wait for Loona world domination so yg can choke on his own words
coming back to his video years later. all three made it, all three are currently in a group who are breaking records after records. harsh criticism is needed at times and yeah this performance was underwhelming but there was no constructive criticism here especially towards haseul. i play sport so i understand why he was like this but the way he delivered was rude, mocking and tried to crush those girls dreams. he’s definitely eating his words now. hyunjin, heejin, haseul... you made it and we’re so proud of you
i know this is how yg teach their artist like jennie said they always get throw by all this harsh comment smack at their face almost everyday but i mean its so harsh imma cry if i am them
the fact that yg said all of this and now lee sooman's first ever work outside of sm was with loona...... and the fact that hyunjin nominated yg for the ice bucket challenge...
because SM appreciates talents and see potentials on them 🥰
Yang Hyeon Suk is just a weirdo,no cap☠️
Hyunjin nominated YG for the ice bucket challenge? Iconic, legendary level of shade
@@spy6205 I love her for that.
*I’ve been a SM stan for a long time and was a LOONA stan later and the fact that Lee Sooman worked with LOONA already sent me to heaven-*
I feel like yg despised their confidence for some strange reason and wanted so badly to crush it.
He definitely did. After she responded to his harsh comment with confidence and positivity, he said “this is frustrating”. Literally mad because he wasn’t able to hurt them
He knows Loona would be a threat so naturally he wanted to crush their confidence right there. SOB can rot in jail.
Just like how he crush cl hanbin GD lee hi confidence
He is always like this, even with his wife, he destroyed her career to have her. He bullied 2NE1, constantly mocking their appearance. It's partly a entertainment business strategy - break your employees confidence so they don't know their self worth and stay at the company, working for less. He is honestly an awful, awful man. Many of them are but at least he got what he deserved.
@@selty and look at CL now, she's free, independent and shining without trash g
I know this is competition..but it's so funny when you scolding at haseul but you can't even debut the mixnine winner...
For real😂😂
The winner debut in itzy...lol yg
The fact tho! Hahahaha
@@priyanshu_kun who?
speak yo truth 🥰🥰
Just saying but I will never forgive the editors of the show for editing out Haseul's singing audition to make her seem like she didn't do enough/didn't have talent at all
they edited out the clip of her singing? WOW that's so rude and heartless....
@Hunter Jerica the one who went last/didn't get picked for the show
Uk even in the dance part, they were only showing heejin and hynjin I had to watch the dance closesly to even recognise who the third person was...
Thats because she got eliminated and the editors probably thought it was a waste of time putting her part.
@@yeltrionswitch6918 Not an excuse to make her look like she didn't even try
Haseul isn't a dancer so why would they cut her singing part and make her seems like a talentless person ugh
evil editing ofcourse
LMAO.
Fck this editor,they even made hyunjin seems like a bad girl
Its LOONA, they're all dancers
Ikr it ticks me off ://
Bro i cried because of how yg was mean to all of them but especially to haseul, now she lacks confidence and is on hiatus because of anxiety and that made me cry even more :( she's the best
same bro. i'm still crying cuz she is so talented and fuck yg an blockberry. They still sleeping on Haseul's talent
@@delhia1230 yeah she's still in hiatus, but there's a rumor that she's gonna comeback in their new song
Think of it this way (and now she's back yay) Haseul was in front of one of the most powerful men in her industry, who was openly bullying her and her beloved members. AND SHE STOOD UP TO HIM in such a mature and kind way. She is an absolute boss and to me? She completely owned him and made him look like a f u c wit
@@selty TRUE no matter what yg says haseul remains superior to him because of her maturity and kindness (and she totally OWNED PTT)
@@selty i really respect Haseul for standing up well to that idiotic man, had it been me in her shoes, I would've stood up for myself and the members too, but not that kindly. Harsh criticism exists, but he's downright mocking them. Nobody has the right to downplay someone's effort and determination. Really shows you how YG's management is literal shit, because the man who built it is shit too.
They were biased from the beginning, not once did the camera pan on Haseul, they kept centering in on heejin and HyunJin😤 but anyways Stream Sonatine🥰😘
they didnt even show Let Me In,,,, tragic 💔
I don't think you can say they were biased to Heejin and HyunJin since they probably edited a lot of Haseul's parts out since she didn't make it onto the show. It doesn't make sense to give a lot of screen time to someone that the audience only sees once on screen.
@@jo-py4wq I'm not sure if you're talking about the auditions of the 101 trainees (like in ep. 1 and 2 of the seasons) or the auditions of those who didn't make it into the 101. But for mixnine, there were 98 girls who actually made it onto the show (and all the boys too) and they didn't even show all the auditions of those 98 girls. So to me, it wouldn't make sense to show the full auditions of trainees who didn't make it onto the show bc they didn't even have enough time to show the trainees that made it on. Sorry if that's a confusing sentence.
Edit: But if it's the second case, I think you're completely right and I would actually love to see those videos!
I hate how some people said that haseul was ‘arrogant’ and that the girls needed a reality check. Yg was laughing at them because they believed in themselves. Y’all saying that they were ‘arrogant’ when they believed that they could become the best girl group, of course it sounds arrogant, but they believed that they could become better and be a great girl group. They knew that they weren’t the best but they knew that had some skill which they could improve. Those people who said haseul was ‘arrogant’ when she literally didn’t praise herself when she knew she danced badly. If you see closely, you know that she was ‘laughing’ during her dance because she knew she didn’t do well. She even gave herself a 2 for skill, she isn’t arrogant, she knows that she isn’t the best and felt that she could practice more.
The girls did their best and they are amazing now so if you call them ‘arrogant’ or that they need a ‘reality check’, I’m going to track you down and slap you with my Loona lightstick
Thank you for this comment more people should see it!!
period sis speak on it
YEAHHHH!! say it louder sist!!
Its okay they took yg's words and made him shove it up his ass because loona became successful
Now you can't have confidence in yourself because people call you arrogant lol, anyways the girls are amazing and they are growing and growing
they should have let haseul sing in auditions instead of dance
that's sad
they just aired the reason why she did not pass
she did sing, they cut it to make her look bad
yess
@@xotwod6899 they cut the recording to the worst parts T_
LOONA now are the first non 3 girl group to debut in the billboard
Bet YG Is eating his hat rn
Nah, he’s eating rat food in prison
@@kimnotloona even better
the rats as the main course and some rat poison afterwards 😍
why would he do that? blackpink is the biggest girlgroup in the world rn
@@ysocurious136 bc he's in jail 😜😜
I think i will not forgive this man for making haseul cry
We all will not forgive that man
never.
Dude even the younger judge is creepy. The way he laughs when they first come in and just his whole demeanour. But of course the bigger sleeze is sitting next to him.
i agree, the way he laughed and smiled was creepy
Who is he?
@@abhinavrc171 someone from YG BLACKLABEL
that’s Zion.T
Lol blame the editing😭 I'm sure Zion T is not that creepy as what you stated.
Now look who’s on billboard and who’s on jail
Oop💀💀💀
Plz this sent me 🤡
I love dis comment
YG is on jail???
Shook!
Haseul, you made me proud to stan LOONA the way you spoke so clearly and confidently for your group. You deserve to the leader and I personally think you made LOONA look humble and hard-working. You will only get better as you work harder!
Also, if yall watch the web drama they're in, Haseul's acting is the best in my opinion.
HECK YEAH, SHE DEFENDED THE NAME OF LOONA
What is the web drama?
@@vishakhalade1284 woomanna
HaSeul is a vocalist, she stated so herself. She doesn't dance much - and it's fine. Her vocals are actually really good and it's clear that they edited her singing out to make her look worse.
Has YG forgotten that two out of the four 2NE1 members couldn't dance? And that's coming from a person who still answers Blackjack when asked what my fandom is. I'm realistic.
Multifandom Dreamer bom and dara aren't the best but they can dance whatever choreo they're given for 2ne1. I'm a blackjack too btw!
blacKpinKpop well haseul can dance whatever choreo given to her if she practice
But dancing in competition like this requires putting their own creativity and uniqueness. If thats what yg requires in haseul knowing well her position is vocal i can only say too bad for haseul, not unexpected
Như Nguyễn not sure if Haseul choreographed this dance herself or if it was given to her, but yes she could dance it but the execution was pretty bad. It doesn't matter that us fans know what these trainees are capable of because the only thing YG is basing his judgement on is what was given to him in this audition. And yes, for this competition YG is definitely looking for creativity and uniqueness. If you've seen other auditions from other trainees, even though they did well YG still slammed them for being boring or choosing the wrong song for this competition.
And honestly no one in blackpink can sing...
@@ggstan2439 trueeeee
The fact that he laughed at haseul is so rude but I gained so much more respect for Haseul in seeing her reaction to his criticism. She is a true leader and has the kindest heart.
I love how the girls stay professional and positive
he wanted to make them cry in front of him so badly but he failed miserably
I feel like JYP's criticisms sounds professional even if it is harsh sometimes but YG's is (--_--) just so rude!
Most of JYP's criticisms comes with detailed points for them to improve while YG's most of the times will just be whether he likes the performance or not then sprinkle it with either insults or compliments.
THIS. JYP gives constructive criticism so that way you can "improve", but YG only criticize them w no point apart of insulting.
JYP actually give criticism yg just insults everyone
Well JYP is the person behind 9 usual girls to become an idol in a few months.
dude yg's "criticisms" aren't even criticisms...they're straight-up insults smh.
he made haseul cry, and now he's in jail. coincidenc? don't think so
The haseul curse got in his eyes
@@Random-rv3us LMAO please
@@Random-rv3us PLEASE
he's in jail?
@@horanghae_0826 yup. Burning sun scandal
The fact that Haseul knew she wasn't good enough dancing then but still wanted some pointers and only got harsh criticism just shows how trash YG is
YG: "the girls on that bus are prettier than you,"
Heejin and Hyunjin: win top visuals
YG: soLo aLbuMs????!?!?! whAt tYpe oF coNcEpt iS tHat?
also YG: every member of blackpink will have a solo (and then never release them smh)
Haseul: There's nothing you can't do if you keep working hard!
YG wasn't workig hard to give his artist an album 🤣
At least BBC can manage a girl group properly
New management of YG tho confirmed the solos sooo
@@mayamapit2176 I mean... minus the crappy line distribution sometimes with the same girls :/
Ikr
THE AUDACITY. He was so godamn rude to Haseul. She even joked about her own dancing herself, she knows it's not her ace card.
She is a Powerhouse singer, a morale boosting leader, and a brilliant, charismatic diplomat.
It's so infuriating to see her getting mistreated on a biased reality show like this.
I get really upset when I watch this video as an orbit. But now loona is proving themselfs as a great girl group
Loona the world domination. Yey
@@catmayor3522 I'm with you! LOONATHEWORLD!!
Haseul doesn’t back down when Loona’s being shit on and I just LOVE IT! The girls couldn’t answer YG’s rude ass question so Haseul stepped in and took the heat, as she always does. She’s the best leader with the most confidence, and didn’t back down even when YG was LITERALLY LAUGHING in the middle of her sentence lol. Haseul’s the best.
@@happybirthdayame7334 I agree. It must have been terrifying being degraded on national tv like that. But Haseul did not back down.
If Haseul started belting out her Opera voice she would be in the bus within seconds. And the manager looked so proud and worried for them, I hope he's still around in bbc
this is why yg went to jail
Wait huh???
@@sara-8325 it's because YG sucks And I'm mad because how he talks to them just making me cry tbh
That guy with hat is YG? ........BBC saw potential and they brought forth 12 powerful girls that work hard 24/7, and still got a long way to go. This man was offensive, and cruel, they surely have proved him wrong. I mean, look at the content and good quality songs these girls produced.
@@justnzh yeah but he is profesional in this things
@@ubergamer2010 oop 💀💀💀
Haseul is a vocalist and she sang as well but they cut that part to make her look worse. They didn’t put forth their best, but they did better than they edited to show. I think their company just made the wrong choice regarding what they auditioned with. Nice to know that BBC ceo is really encouraging and supportive so that when they’re treated like this, he’ll help build their confidence back up and fix what they did wrong.
That explains everything.
they just aired the reason why she did not pass, just like they aired some the best solo perf within the group other than they're group performance
but its so damn wrong to tell them that they hv enough talent to release solo album but the fact isnt like that
ssozi 86 No offense but yg doesn’t really have room to speak on that when he’s given Dara a solo. You don’t even need to sing well because studio editing exist. They’ve all released solos though and it showed that they had enough vocal talent. Haseul released “let me in” - a a ballad. Hyunjin also released a ballad. And heejin released a kind of jazzy pop song called “vivid”.
everyone knows that dara had really lacking in vocal skills, even in the philippines, she did release solo album in ph and was a hit. but yg casted her after he saw the documentary abt her when she was famous in the philippines, she did not audition to become idol, she even told yg that she was more fit to be actress. dara has great charms and hardworking. she's always humble, esp in every guesting show in ph, she's a huge kpop star but she's still the same (unlike haseul did even she's not that succesful yet, it was just one album, and they were asked on how they will win over the other girls in the show that can sing and dance well than them? and she answered, that they were told they were good to put on solo albums. after her poor performance, how dumb was to say that? and take note, she did audition for promotion, amen)
If JinSoul, Choery and Kimlip joined them i think theyll be going in the bus for sure and it would be best if Haseul sang one of their song... Haseul dont be discouraged😭😭😭
Yane Yang Yanah ur biased every loona member is talented some more than others for sure but at the end of the day yg is just picky
he/she's not biased if Odd Eye Circle joined them they would've passed, I personally think that OEC are talented enough to be MIXNINE, Don't get me wrong, I'm sure Heejin, Hyunjin and Haseul are as talented as OEC but i think they're not ready to be here, Haseul and Hyunjin need to improve their dancing and Heejin needs to improve her stamina at singing, I think OEC should've auditioned since they're good at dancing and their stamina is good too.
El Pene Negro De Namjoon i think yves, olivia and kim lip would have been the best representation for loona’s dance line. they have the most confidence and skill when performing
@@mari-iw6gj yep I totally agree. we basically have the same "loona dancers list". only diff is id put heejin there too.
@@mari-iw6gj yeah but they haven’t debuted yet by the time the show was aired
When the girls entered the bus the boys look so shook lmao i feel u buddies, i feel sorry for haseul tho...
DONT BE! that snake doesn't deserve any one of them
@@crunchygowon3681 i saw you in a barbie video if I'm not mistaken
@@loonaticseul2365 what is going on
Haseul's curse strike again.. It's raining~ lol
I'm crying because of sadness and laughter at the same time!😂😭
And now look what happened with that ex-ceo
SPREAAD YOUR CUURSSSEE BABY GURL
The fact that they didn't pay attention to Haseul and she is now on hiatus makes me want to cry 😭😭
Lolthis vivi pic again
Haseul was so hurt when she said "Well, first of all, our company thought we were good enough to debut solo" after YG said that thing about people on the bus being better than them. She wasn't arrogant she was hurt and I felt it for her 😭 So happy that she's back with promotions right now, hope they could erase this from their memory somehow bc this definitely factored in for the anxiety
The way the editing Like
Heejin,hyunjin,haseul : *Smile
Yg : 🎩
😠
Heejin,hyunjin,haseul : 🙂😐🙁
Yeah bullshit
It's funny how loona is like the best synchronised group and dancing Group!
the show was trash anyway and none of them ended up debuted lmao, YG should’ve just sat there and stick at taking care of Blackpink because that’s the only thing they good at 💅🏿✨
Yeah but its kinda sad for the group who were used to debut...they were all really talented.
200% but to be fair they’re not good at taking care of bp either
he cant even properly manage blackpink and give them proper songs without the same repetitive formula and has the nerve to come after loona’s solo albums LMAO
@@cho5257 well as i know bp will be back with full album and with song with selen gomez so i think they finnaly got brains
You didnt even know why they didnt debut who won yet you have the audacity to say that🙈😭
Dear Leader Haseul,
Thank you for making Stan Loona and thank you for being the greatest leader of all.We,Orbits will cheer and love you all without even a little break.We will always think of you,Loona.So don't give up and keep up!
Orbits ❤
To our beloved Loona💕
6:09 YG disses Haseul about dancing, then says that she shouldn't expect to be putting out albums! Guess what... albums contain singing, not dancing! She's a great singer!!
ikr! even a dance trainer like bae yoon jung tells trainees to focus on singing as much as dancing, if not more, because an idol in its core is a singer. yg either doesn't know what he's saying or is too in his head and saying nonsense
Yes, Haseul danced badly, but do not keep her talent down. She works hard at dancing and sings very well (Haseul was a student of opera). Do not be like the YG that belittles the talent of others just because they are not so good at dancing.
Dara and Park Bom from 2NE1 are not out to dance, and that is not why YG undervalued their talent. He's a hypocrite for saying that Haseul doesn't have enough talent just because he didn't dance well.
Haseul's fancams dancing in three completely different concepts:
favOriTe:
czcams.com/video/Ld1lSZrqLIQ/video.html
Hi High:
czcams.com/video/GmFu7oVZRis/video.html
Butterfly:
czcams.com/video/N9rli_rEtZA/video.html
Bonus:
Haseul singing ópera:
czcams.com/video/Nlah8hFdXMI/video.html
@@cabecadegelo9475 every concept of loona is different unlike YG ✌️
Funny how he said Haseul didn’t have the skill to release a solo album when... she literally did release a solo album. Long before she went on mixnine.
Here’s the thing:
usually the show is edited so the ones who pass the auditions get more screentime and the others don’t really get it BUT while they were showing the girls’ solos they didn’t show Haseul’s solo WHICH led to people not knowing she can sing VERY well. You can see this was targeted towards Haseul not only by showing the judges’ reaction which is a part of editing a show BUT showing the trainees’ disgusted faces. WHO DOES THAT WITHOUT A REASON? That’s messed up.
Look at loona now, more successful than YG’s old ass
"there are more girls prettier than you inside the bus"
(Few days later)
Heejin most voted visual by contestants and staff in Mixnine
they didn’t show haseul in introducing, they showed 2jin and called them pretty and cut haseul out. they didn’t show haseul a mv and cut out her singing and just showed her dance when next to her is loonas main dancer. this is so unfair.
That’s because she got eliminated
HASEULI DONT CRY BABY, YOU AND LOONA ARE GREAT!
this is just heartbreaking for me i can't imagine how bad she felt after that😭😭😭😭😭😭 at least she has improved a lot and i saw on butterfly era she had so much more confidence on stage💖💖 I LOVE YOU HASEUL
She got the last laugh, that man in jail now
I am not sure whether they are the most talented but I am definitely sure their visuals are standing out in all the female trainees especially Hyunjin, she really looks like Tzuyu + Naeun, I don't think there is anyone can beat her visual tbh.
Ikr, all three of them are prettier than the women on the bus so I'm not sure what YG was on about
@@Luna-ry8lv he probably knew that but his jealous creep annoying ass didn’t want to admit
If you look at a lot of the girls in the bus and compare it too heejin, hasuel or hyunjin theres not much to compare
@@flyingraven8933 No need to tear down the other girls just to make Loona seem superior when they were all talented and pretty/handsome in their own unique ways and the same goes to the first commenter above the 2nd's.
@@fearnotmyinsomniaonce4579 it's not tearing the other girls down, it's merely stating a fact. it's also a jab at yg for saying that the girls in the bus are prettier than all of them when it is super obvious that they're the top visuals there. what yg did to 1/3 is borderline tearing them down and crushing them.
I understand being a detailed criticizer and strict person, as well as having a certain expectation, but YG didn’t have to go that deep. If he wants to be a strict judge, that’s fine as long as it’s not discouraging them. But he could’ve at least gave them a few pointers so they know what’s what next time. But hey. At least Loona’s doing fine these days. Just goes to show that there will always be different opportunities for success.
@@jo-py4wq Exactly what I was thinking as well. If they have the skills and potential, then looks shouldn't matter at all.
@@jo-py4wq yg called 2ne1 ugly throughout their whole career . he doesn't care if he hurts the person's feelings or not
@@jo-py4wq he was probably intimidated at how their visuals are top-tier and kept on denying it lmao
thats why haseul was like 'i expected to receive some pointers so i could grow but...' the shade LMAO she knows he's a bad judge/instructor. completely unhelpful. mean comments without any kind of guidance
please what he did here is 0% judging or giving critiques, he just plain insulted them and mock-laughed in their faces because he wants to
Haseul is so courageous and a born leader of an amazing group. YG is a psycho, he enjoyed stripping away young girls enthusiasm and passion and natural confidence, and she took a breath and stood up to him - one of the most powerful producers in the asian music scene. I am so amazed and inspired by her standing up for them at the end. True born leader.
5:32 miss Hyunjin predicted loona world domination purr
i hope loona gonna be the best girl group in the future . no wonder they will debut next year and all loonatics still waiting for the new members of loona . 💛💛
I love them so much
this reminds me to when we thought the fandom was going to be called loonatic woaah 😭😭 it feels like it was yesterday
@@mac-lc7xo omg yes
looking back on this is happy seeing how insanely successful they've become ^^
miss girl your wish is granted
This video is honestly so damn haunting because Yg was literally so wrong in everything he said and everything Haseul, Hyunjin and heejin said are all true. But honestly what did we expect from a boss who even stepped down on 2ne1’s confidence and literally hated the idea of women thriving on their own without his help. He only likes women in a really bad way and I don’t even want to say what exact way bc it’s disgusting. Hope he goes to jail for good
The way they cropped our haseul and left her out of the image makes me insane
I feel so bad for haseul what if he added to haseuls anxiety? She said she kept thinking if she made loona look bad. 🙁
Loona better than all girl groups
Loona better than all Boy groups
Loona better than all kpop groups
Loona better than any musician
Loona is phenomenal
Loona is Life
Loona is power
Loona is god
Loona is the Universe
i freaking hate that guy for saying that there were people who were prettier than them on the bus when the other guy was drooling. like the editing obviously pointed out their sheer beauty, everyone in both buses were utterly and genuinely shocked and taken aback at heejin and hyunjin when their showed their faces, i would say that heejin and hyunjin are arguably the prettiest people to have come onto the show, over girls and boys. they look like "ulzzangs" and everyone knew it
YG is so rude... all of his comments in mix nine are so uncalled for.
HaSeul should have sung instead of danced in her solo audition tbh
But I'm happy HeeJin and HyunJin got on the bus ^-^
She did but get cut
of course, she sang... that's a must for a solo performance, dance and sing. they just aired the reason why she didnt pass
ohh i see~~ i wish it was like produce 101 where they'd upload videos of the whole audition :P (if they do then pls link me) XD
some fans uploaded it, i've seen it earlier. jtbc yt channel only uploads the group perf from each agencies... the solo perf, u may seen it on mixnine channel on vlive...
the problem was finding it, coz every title of the vidz were written in korean language.
I will only say that now that I am older, it seems disgusting to see how producers or judges smile when there are beautiful girls being minors!
YG was just mad he didn't think about doing a project like Loona before, he knew they could succeed, so he decided to crush their confidence instead. Little did he know that made the girls stronger
no bc i admire these young girls staying so strong and confident after this grown ass ogre insults the hell out of them
Is anyone going to talk about how happy Zion T looked? I've never seen him look so happy. 😂
i won’t forgive myself for watching this back in 2017 and not stanning them back then :< i remember seeing them on mixnine and i was like haseul’s my bias but did not listen to any of their tracks until butterfly came out
Our Mom-seul did her best!!! Loona have improved so much and Haseul is a necessity in team. She may not be the strongest in dance but she is an amazing vocalist and looks after the members so well. Every day Loona are becoming more and more successful and skilful and look at where YG is now-sitting in jail 😐
watching this video is so heartbreaking... but knowing that YG has no career now honestly makes up for this.... PRAYING FOR HASEUL'S COMEBACK
i don't know loona that well but haseul is making me wanna change that... she's so beautiful and cheerful, she really stood up not only for herself but for her team as well! i hate how yg treated her ugh he's disgusting
you should get into loona 😏but sadly hasuel is still on a break due to anxiety ☹️
@@dentedcarrot7464 i've heard :( i hope she feels better soon...
I've been following LOONA for a while and during their Butterfly promotion, I can say that Haseul really improved and when I say a lot, means A LOT. I know YG is the most strict judge but he's the one being a big disappointment in the show. He despise the fact that the girls are confident enough to answer his questions without stuttering.
HASEUL YOU ARE PERFECT IN MY EYES. YOUR DETERMINATION AND HARDWORK WON'T BETRAY YOU. ♡♡♡
LOONA FIGHTING!!
And here we are in 2021...Oh how time flies! Balckpink members having their solo and LOONA being one of the greateast and most in sync girl groups ever!
funny how yg enjoyed to throw everything at them when haseul can literally sing opera and heejin is already seen as one of the best dancers in kpop
Let's be honest on Haseul for a moment.... that performance made me gasp, but because it was terrible.
same but yg didn't need to spat out things not related to the performance, though.
i was legit getting second hand embarrassment
same when i showed the video to my classmates... but it's okay! :) she will eventually be like the other vocal line of the other group. she will slowly be a good dancer in the future!
yea
I LOVE HER BUT ITWAS SO BADDDDD
mixnine cancelled, yg company hit by most controversial scandal in kpop history, yg stepped down as ceo, loonathekarma is real.
And look at them now , Dominating the world creating History while Yg failed to serve his artist and now jobless because he quitted trying to play Mr. know it all what a shame and I think all of YG’s artists are ashamed that their boss turned his back on them
Lol please for yg family he is their father figure. If you can't take a little hard words when how will you in this industry,?
@@lalisathequeenyep2386 what…he was literally rude to haseul…
@UCvYm6spnj_H_-yI9Xj4mXpg father figure? lol ok, unless their father is rude and disrespectful to them. what father tells their daughters that they're ugly for years? what father leaves a daughter in their dungeon for years?
I do understand where YG is coming from. Considering the fact that LOONA is starting to establish themselves as a "unique" group, we all have our expectations from them. In an industry where idols are overflowing, it would be stupid to coddle aspiring idols, so I don't think that YG was harsh or rude in any way. It was constructive criticism worded in a way to bring the girls back to reality. Furthermore, he was basing his criticism on the performance that they showed and to be honest it wasn't really up to par to what we expect from them, that we have to admit. Lastly, he KNOWS that they are talented, he even said it himself. They just need to refine and polish their skills, which YG could provide.
Just support the members as much as you can guys. Let's enjoy and see their improvements :)
Yeeees. 👏
Yes but saying that there are prettier people than them isn’t constructive criticism. That is purely something that will knock down their confidence.
+Yeppeun Kpop I would kindly disagree with you. He was really stating facts and by no means was he saying those to knock down their confidence just for the sake of it. He said that to them, because the ladies believe that with their visuals and skills, they could become the best girl group. I think what he wants is for these trainees to feel that "desperation" that he always search for, because he knows that that is the factor that would bring out the best out of them. He sees something in them. He wouldn't pass the two ladies if he didn't. :)
The fact that he laughed at them when they said that their ceo considered them good for having solos, it is rude, I dunno. I think his attitude was not the most appropiate. It is their work how can he laaught at it
@@plantitasp yes! that part annoyed me and made me mad, how rude🤬
Poor Haseul. Shes sooo talented and yet so overlooked. Shes such a queen and diserved a chance as well. It makes my heart broke into peaces. I miss her sm and I hope she is doing well! We miss you Haseul. 💚💚😭😭
wow :( they didn’t even show haseul in the beginning and in the caption when heejin and hyunjin walked in it said “2 pretty girls” and for haseul it said nothing
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
it's funny how critical he is being of their dancing when one of the members of his current girl group cannot dance at all...
Who?
i can tell they don't like haseul i mean.. like they literally called the other girls pretty and not haseul. and almost none of the filming was focused on haseul. poor girl.. yg didn't deserve them, their loss.
Yg really thought he ate that 😂😂
I think they still need time to grow as artists. I expected more from them for their audition, but I think that's what happens when you become attached to them after following them from the beginning. Putting my bias aside, I think they have the potential to be successful in the future if their company keeps doing what they've been doing and if they keep practicing, until then, this show is just for their promotion. I don't know how these shows work, but I'm hoping this is some form of publicity stunt where they improve as they go, and even if it isn't I'm sure they'll improve either way.
Haseul is one of the best singers in the kpop industry
ive never liked papa yg but ever time i watch this i just 📈📈📈. jokes on him, loona is a viral success and they achieved that while part a small company with 20 employees that was definitely not of the big 3 (not that i'm hating on the big 3, my ults are from there. i'm just saying)
I'm glad that the final debut lineup of Mixnine didn't debut. I'll never forgive what he done to Haseul.
4:15 She won't be very good at dancing like the others, but she has a beautiful voice, you can see that she worked very hard at dancing. But what I did not like was that they cut where he sang and showed his charms
These three dance better than Jisoo (BLACKPINK). But Jisoo belongs to a famous company. It's the famous "son of rich parents" case.
right like jisoo is stiff dancer how did they allow her? it's not like she's a rapper too more like she got there for her visual only.
I feel like YG was judging them so harshly because he knows their group would be going against BP soon and while there is plenty of fans he wants all the money, since he can't seem to make a profit.
Edit: He maybe was also jealous of their instant popularity for their unique concept.
There can be genuine harsh criticism from judges in survival shows, that are understandable, but here it feels like he is just being mean to them because he personally did not like them for no particular reason.
even though miss Haseul WASN'T a great dancer, the fact that she covered a Britney's song is just YAS GURL WHAT A QUEEN
Love how he said "This is frustrating" right after Haseul's comment. I bet he's frustrated because he couldn't break or even shake her confidence. YG is a complete hypocrite, and Haseul & LOONA continue to do well despite the crap they get from people like YG.
*Long live LOONA!!!*
the way haseul's dancing has improved since this... iconic!
everyone talking about how rude yg was to haseul, but i'm focused on how she did not get any solo shots. when they were introduced at the beginning, the camera did not focus on her and her solo was not edited in unlike the other two. at the end, the editing cherry picked her "bad dancing." during the group performance, you could see at the corner of your screen haseul's energy matching the other two. ugh the bias.
"There are prettier girls than you all in the bus, girls who can dance better than you all and sing well. How are you going to win over them?"
Well, By making the best choreographies in all of kpop and experimenting with genres that have never been used in kpop before
P.s. fr tho I can't wait for Loona world domination so yg can choke on his own words
lmao now heejin is a better dancer than lisa
i understand criticism, but this wasn’t it. he was just flat out rude especially to haseul.
So, this the reason why orbits had a beef with yg💀 I'm literally living under the rock, I didn't know this survival show wew
5:30 knowing that this is coming true now makes me feel better watching this and makes my blood pressure go down a little.
if just he wanted to hear haseul singing…you cant do a group with just dancers
Hyunjin covering Britney is just YAS GURL
I can't believe how my heart still aches listening to YG's critiques that happened over 4 years ago..
Wow, why did they edit it so Haseul was dancing so out of time with the song? Is anyone supposed to believe that's what actually happened?
seeing her cry broke my heart man. someone that soft and kind should not have to go through things like this. Love you Haseul 😓💚
coming back to his video years later. all three made it, all three are currently in a group who are breaking records after records. harsh criticism is needed at times and yeah this performance was underwhelming but there was no constructive criticism here especially towards haseul. i play sport so i understand why he was like this but the way he delivered was rude, mocking and tried to crush those girls dreams. he’s definitely eating his words now. hyunjin, heejin, haseul... you made it and we’re so proud of you
poor Haseul she was probably so anxious
i know this is how yg teach their artist like jennie said they always get throw by all this harsh comment smack at their face almost everyday but i mean its so harsh imma cry if i am them