None of this is that complicated. It's only intellectual laziness (often as great is not greater a vice as physical laziness) that has hindered the vast majority of people in the west from understanding what is going on.
Daniel Carter Most people are starting to understand what's going on here in the U.S. but they're too scared to do anything about it. Sadly, we no longer have the liberty that our founding fathers fought so nobly for.
furballbear Agreed. I'm not sure how many people are understanding what's going on here in the UK, so much attention has been focused on the NSA that a lot of people aren't aware of the things GCHQ are doing. Unfortunately our political/legal system is completely ad-hoc and way out of date yet most people don't have the willpower or even comprehend the situation well enough to make serious beneficial changes.
@@CallousCarter people are log. We need meaning and its embedded in what we are used to seeing. Government is becoming absolete with the tech we want to use, yet we still look up to thr government to do "their job", and their job jas changed.
Snowden leaks was the product of a deep state war between NSA and CIA. They were on behalf of the CIA to shift spying associations onto NSA. Worked well. Snowden and familiy have military history and Snowden worked with Lockheed and close associates of Bush family crime unit. He would never have been allowed to make it to Hong Kong and then Russia without consent of CIA. Only recently has he become a genuine benefit to people like you and me. He is cooprating with President Trump to bring down the deep state. Globally
Looks like Isreal controls both sides. We've been killing for Israel nonstop since I've been alive starting with the Clintons continuing until now with trump.
Metadata analysts like Binney and George Webb are important sources for truthful and fullest information available. Watch “The Good American” movie and Truth Leaks on Utube.
Don't forget these brats are children of the rich and Elite they are tomorrow's Primeministers senator's and maybe President, these brats don't give a flying f....k about the sheepole.
I so admire Binney. As a retired USG diplomat, I can testify how impossible it is to get information harmful to political interests out of an Embassy. And we were above-board.
When I see some of the comments here it becomes clear that we do live in a world of show business and people seek a "show" in whatever is being presented. People wake up please! Binney's message is way too serious to be brushed up with rhetorical mastery and vivid colours. Try to focus on "what" he says. Even our poor comments here are currently tapped stored and analysed just because his name is mentioned. While we are joking around about "oh no he delivered a boring speech and I couldn't laugh" we and a thousands of our social associates are potentially scanned! Probably the phones and mails of our families being run through some codes right at this very moment! Still looking for funny speech delivery?!
the significant element of these comments, is the ignorance and passivity of common humanity. government is so far away from them that society can be called 'feudal' or even 'slave society.'
You can bet that there's a lot more to NSA spying and information collection activities than what's expressed in this video, and 'one' of those bigger concerns has to do with mental telepathy.
He's very right but we all know this and yet we use their devices... This says a lot about us actually. Don't blame them blame us? At the same time it's forced in a way that we actually HAVE TO use devices. Imagine working and telling ur boss I don't have an email send me a letter 😂 it's really hard to go against all this when it's litteraly forced in a way.
I was on the phone with AT&T talking to an older woman about my account. It was 2020, and I was moving. I told her that I had called them on, xx-xx-xxxx, and told them of my new address. She said no, I did not call them on that date. She then started to pick out call dates, and times, from 1987-2020, telling me the number I called, and from where I made the call, even if I was on a pay phone!!! Some of the people I called were dead!!! She said the phone company started recording all calls in about 1980, and by 1985, all calls were being recorded and stored to one master computer. She knew every call I had made, or received, after that date,, and could print them out if necessary. Brother James Kendall Moore OSB OFS OSC.
I don’t think they will A lot of them will give away their freedoms so that they feel safe.. it won’t matter what the stakes are, They can’t see the whole picture and are convinced that they are too smart and the government in the US would never do what other governments do
I takes real genuineity of mind to stand up and tell that spying is wrong. Normal average everyday spirit is to have pride on being above ordinary citizens and being in the capacity to spy on them.
If this is what lectures were I'd be there every day. We're supposed to share with each other to make everyone better not play secret games like the Ashley's from "Recess"
What's with all the disinterested looking kids in the place who appear as though they were required to be there to listen to "some old guy" against their preference?
Longer than 9 years . The victims of these abuses are called “targeted individuals “ . you know it’s true because you’ll find misinformation and disinformation if you Google it. These are people on a watchlist.
God damn, I am pretty informed on this topic and I can't understand what his points are. Just big words that don't mean anything. I bet when he was at the NSA, he walked facing the wall away from people passing by. why would the government not keep records so they can make the links when they need to? What's wrong with the collection when they don't analyze the data until they have probable cause. what this guys does not say is what government did with the collected data. What does government need, i.e. court order? to analyze the data? If a court order is necessary, what's wrong with the collection? So a bad guys metadata is identified, then you want the government to start collecting? From what source? you want private companies to maintain the data forever? who is going to pay for that? Is that timely to stop an attack if we need to? just gibberish chatter from someone who is as informed as him..... waste of time.
Cheney laying down the rules on how to spy on terrorist suspects, plus Norman Mineta's testimony of Cheney on 9/11/2001, excluded from the 9/11 cOmission Report ! What do we have here ? A Terrorist So large that he's like "Environmental" - invisible. The Room is inside The Elephant. Cheney's "stand down" order, at the Pentagon. Norman Mineta, Minister of Transport ".. and when the young man came in for the 4?th time and asked - "The plane is 10 miles out sir? does the order still stand ?" Cheney quips his neck around and snaps at the kid -"Of course it still stands ! - have you heard anything to the contrary !".
thats why i always advise people to take time & listen to david icke, rauni kilde, jordan maxwell, & docm as thrive....this info can open up peoples awareness....to see the dots connection to eachother whats going on for so long
Yes he does unfortunately there isn't anything that he can do about it. The "deep state" Trump and his supporters talk about is far deeper and more entrenched then he realized. I think Trump is in over his head. They'll constantly keep bringing up new "investigations" and impeachments, etc because as long as he's on the defense it makes it hard for him to go on the offense without facing accusations of retaliation, obstruction, abuse of power, etc.
MD’s specializing in. Phrenology also Which is included under the aspects. Of the. Practice of. medicine. Would Benefit from. Studying his. Expertises which, although he is not. A medicine. Practcioner, he. Truly understands how to be compassionate. And. Loving and Has patients with his followers And is not swayed by popular notions in vogue at. The time.
William Binney is a brilliant man who can make complex concepts easy to understand.
None of this is that complicated. It's only intellectual laziness (often as great is not greater a vice as physical laziness) that has hindered the vast majority of people in the west from understanding what is going on.
Daniel Carter Most people are starting to understand what's going on here in the U.S. but they're too scared to do anything about it. Sadly, we no longer have the liberty that our founding fathers fought so nobly for.
furballbear Agreed. I'm not sure how many people are understanding what's going on here in the UK, so much attention has been focused on the NSA that a lot of people aren't aware of the things GCHQ are doing. Unfortunately our political/legal system is completely ad-hoc and way out of date yet most people don't have the willpower or even comprehend the situation well enough to make serious beneficial changes.
I wish bill binney have classes on how to identify complex problens and start solving them.
So we can live.
@@CallousCarter people are log. We need meaning and its embedded in what we are used to seeing. Government is becoming absolete with the tech we want to use, yet we still look up to thr government to do "their job", and their job jas changed.
We need to get rid of the Patriot Act.
That's a start.
The "Patriot" Act is anything but.
You are Correct
It violates over half the original bill of rights. Idk why we the people accept that blatant corruption from our government and their ABC agencies
then act patriotic
Dick Cheny, public enemy number 1.
Enlightening. Thank you William.
Helpful!!
What a speaker. Now THIS is what truth is , and how truth is spoken.
Pay attention crooked politicians.
I'd like to see the Snowden haters go up against this guy. Hedges has the broad strokes, this guy has the details. Truth is a powerful thing.
Snowden leaks was the product of a deep state war between NSA and CIA. They were on behalf of the CIA to shift spying associations onto NSA. Worked well. Snowden and familiy have military history and Snowden worked with Lockheed and close associates of Bush family crime unit. He would never have been allowed to make it to Hong Kong and then Russia without consent of CIA.
Only recently has he become a genuine benefit to people like you and me. He is cooprating with President Trump to bring down the deep state. Globally
Looks like Isreal controls both sides. We've been killing for Israel nonstop since I've been alive starting with the Clintons continuing until now with trump.
@@CaLMCee -- Pfffftthahahaha!
Metadata analysts like Binney and George Webb are important sources for truthful and fullest information available. Watch “The Good American” movie and Truth Leaks on Utube.
@@CaLMCee this work will help to fight and expose Perpertrators in Paedophilia and child trafficking...
I feel concerned about the young hopes of our future at Oxford when I see the bored vain expressions on their faces as this brilliant man speaks.
maybe they are burnt out/tired
It’s a UK university. The students should be interested but it’s not their government being spoken about
Don't forget these brats are children of the rich and Elite they are tomorrow's Primeministers senator's and maybe President, these brats don't give a flying f....k about the sheepole.
@@christianschwalbach7561 Oh yes it is, that's where you are wrong, which part of international you don't understand?
They are concentraded listens carefully
I so admire Binney. As a retired USG diplomat, I can testify how impossible it is to get information harmful to political interests out of an Embassy. And we were above-board.
Bill is a signatory at AE911truth. Thankfully!
Excellent presentation by William Binney... thank you for the platform OxfordUnion!
#SmotheredDataMatters.
This is chilling stuff. The tactics of Stalin era Soviet Union is being installed into the USA.
Except Stalin could not get the data in milliseconds.
@@operalover59 thank GOD !!
NOT "is being" . . . HAS BEEN installed . . .
@@pounamubts7802
Go to the top of the Politburo !
All others - freeze and starve in one of his "hotels" up North.
All the main stream media has been complicit in his treatment over the past 8 years. Horrible
Yo his tie is awesome! This man is a Patriot not a 'whistleblower'
Anyone remember a TV series called "Person of Interest"? This is reminiscent of that.
When I see some of the comments here it becomes clear that we do live in a world of show business and people seek a "show" in whatever is being presented. People wake up please! Binney's message is way too serious to be brushed up with rhetorical mastery and vivid colours. Try to focus on "what" he says. Even our poor comments here are currently tapped stored and analysed just because his name is mentioned. While we are joking around about "oh no he delivered a boring speech and I couldn't laugh" we and a thousands of our social associates are potentially scanned! Probably the phones and mails of our families being run through some codes right at this very moment! Still looking for funny speech delivery?!
the significant element of these comments, is the ignorance and passivity of common humanity. government is so far away from them that society can be called 'feudal' or even 'slave society.'
EXACTLY !!!!!!! ~ so many spineless people, and gossips/voyeurs....doing Nothing !!! Be strong! Stand up!
@@alloomis1635 big brain moment.
It's not too late anymore; what they wanted to do they did...we have to stop them.
You can bet that there's a lot more to NSA spying and information collection activities than what's expressed in this video, and 'one' of those bigger concerns has to do with mental telepathy.
He's very right but we all know this and yet we use their devices... This says a lot about us actually. Don't blame them blame us? At the same time it's forced in a way that we actually HAVE TO use devices. Imagine working and telling ur boss I don't have an email send me a letter 😂 it's really hard to go against all this when it's litteraly forced in a way.
Keep posting-Thank you
Excellent piece, but who is he debating? I'd like to see the entire debate
Thank you, great!
I was on the phone with AT&T talking to an older woman about my account. It was 2020, and I was moving. I told her that I had called them on, xx-xx-xxxx, and told them of my new address. She said no, I did not call them on that date. She then started to pick out call dates, and times, from 1987-2020, telling me the number I called, and from where I made the call, even if I was on a pay phone!!! Some of the people I called were dead!!! She said the phone company started recording all calls in about 1980, and by 1985, all calls were being recorded and stored to one master computer. She knew every call I had made, or received, after that date,, and could print them out if necessary. Brother James Kendall Moore OSB OFS OSC.
incredible
Truth is scarier than fiction.
A truly great man.
….and guess what ? no one cares. That's what amazes me , one day , these sheep will wonder what the hell happened .
Some ppl do CARE !!
I don’t think they will A lot of them will give away their freedoms so that they feel safe.. it won’t matter what the stakes are, They can’t see the whole picture and are convinced that they are too smart and the government in the US would never do what other governments do
@@ddstanfield9259 Wow , I said that two years ago , you're clearly right my friend , I take it all back! lol
@@madhaze3670 things come around when we don’t expect them But it’s current events still
Mr. Binney is a courageous person for speaking truth.
I need to retain a lawyer to sue the us gov for moral turpitude. Help.
Incredible!
What was the ringing of the bell about? Happened twice during his talk....
It's a british tradition within the debate
to wake you up ! .....lol
Omg Sad part is that its public knowledge and they dont care we know... Or we dont care Enough😣
Hello, how are you doing
Thanks
WORD‼️
Democracy or demoncrazy
HERO!!!!!!
Curveball.
Legend
I takes real genuineity of mind to stand up and tell that spying is wrong. Normal average everyday spirit is to have pride on being above ordinary citizens and being in the capacity to spy on them.
Parallel Construction is the means Govt uses to prosecute targeted persons starting from the end result of unauthorized investigations!
If this is what lectures were I'd be there every day. We're supposed to share with each other to make everyone better not play secret games like the Ashley's from "Recess"
rooting!!!
What's with all the disinterested looking kids in the place who appear as though they were required to be there to listen to "some old guy" against their preference?
Newhart for prez
Programs to investigate: stellarwind, EDGEHILL, BULLRUN, blackpearl, boundless informant, dropmire, DRTBOX, WHITEBOX, flatliquid, evening easel...just to start:)
Is that Jeffrey Toobin sitting there looking like he’s daydreaming of being alone with his tube???
So ok, the program was created. Can’t someone create a counter intuitive program to subvert the original program?
9 years ago... great, so they have that now..
Longer than 9 years . The victims of these abuses are called “targeted individuals “ . you know it’s true because you’ll find misinformation and disinformation if you Google it. These are people on a watchlist.
Amazing this has .0001% of a cute kitty video!
Yes if you took a towel from a hotel they are telling all hotels you stay at to watch you
is that cnn's jeffery stuben in the audience?
Dat Combover.
The HAMR?
Hello, how are you doing
God damn, I am pretty informed on this topic and I can't understand what his points are. Just big words that don't mean anything. I bet when he was at the NSA, he walked facing the wall away from people passing by.
why would the government not keep records so they can make the links when they need to? What's wrong with the collection when they don't analyze the data until they have probable cause.
what this guys does not say is what government did with the collected data. What does government need, i.e. court order? to analyze the data? If a court order is necessary, what's wrong with the collection?
So a bad guys metadata is identified, then you want the government to start collecting? From what source? you want private companies to maintain the data forever? who is going to pay for that? Is that timely to stop an attack if we need to?
just gibberish chatter from someone who is as informed as him.....
waste of time.
Controlled demolitions brought us this mess. Think of that.
Not terrifying at all is it.
Privacy is a myth, like bigfoot and Paul Bunion.
Cheney laying down the rules on how to spy on terrorist suspects, plus Norman Mineta's testimony of Cheney on 9/11/2001, excluded from the 9/11 cOmission Report !
What do we have here ?
A Terrorist So large that he's like "Environmental" - invisible.
The Room is inside The Elephant.
Cheney's "stand down" order, at the Pentagon. Norman Mineta, Minister of Transport
".. and when the young man came in for the 4?th time and asked - "The plane is 10 miles out sir? does the order still stand ?" Cheney quips his neck around and snaps at the kid -"Of course it still stands ! - have you heard anything to the contrary !".
Not true
thats why i always advise people to take time & listen to david icke, rauni kilde, jordan maxwell, & docm as thrive....this info can open up peoples awareness....to see the dots connection to eachother whats going on for so long
Does Trump know this?
Gary Thomas Trump is one of them. Isreal and Corporations first, we're just slaves. Look at Trumps administration. No one is going to jail brother.
Trump can barely tie his own shoelaces.
Yes he does unfortunately there isn't anything that he can do about it. The "deep state" Trump and his supporters talk about is far deeper and more entrenched then he realized. I think Trump is in over his head. They'll constantly keep bringing up new "investigations" and impeachments, etc because as long as he's on the defense it makes it hard for him to go on the offense without facing accusations of retaliation, obstruction, abuse of power, etc.
@@bretroberts950 And expect more releases of COVID until we all obey and the ballots have been mailed.
MD’s specializing in. Phrenology also Which is included under the
aspects. Of the. Practice of. medicine. Would Benefit from. Studying his. Expertises which, although he is not. A medicine. Practcioner, he. Truly understands how to be compassionate. And. Loving and Has patients with his followers And is not swayed by popular notions in vogue at. The time.
#Shadowgate #FreeMillie
I did not see one African American in that room.
Ok Not even sure why you looked but did you hear the speech
They should be sprinkled about in there. Affirmative action guarantees they go to Oxford colleges too!
Why does everything have to be about race? Embarrassing.