New report reveals flaws in government's net zero plan
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 06. 2024
- A recent report from the Centre for Independent Studies has revealed flaws in the Albanese government's net zero plan.
Centre for Independent Studies released a report on ‘the six fundamental flaws underpinning the energy transition’ earlier this month, which challenges the claims made from energy reports that painted renewable energy as the cheapest alternative, including fossil fuels, despite any cost of carbon or other policy constraints.
Centre for Independent Studies, Energy Program Director Aidan Morrison joined Sky News host Chris Kenny to discuss some of the flaws underpinning the energy transition.
“One of the flaws we’ve outlined is, I call it match fixing the energy transition, they’ve said they’ve found the cheapest and that gives you the impression they’ve contested it against a few other alternative plans,” Mr Morrison said.
“But they actually don’t have any scenario that doesn’t contemplate us meeting all the renewable energy targets, and also the carbon budgets the very strict carbon budgets that actually see the electricity grid fold to almost zero carbon by 2035, we thought it was a net zero by 2050.
“The electricity grid according to the ISP has to be down by just about 2035 so they haven’t actually presented alternatives, they’ve just pretty much said there’s one horse in the race and this is it and where going to claim it’s the cheapest because it’s the only horse we’ve put in the race.”
.... "Ordinary" Aussies have been saying all this for literal years!
You can only get to true stupidity with heavy education
Net zero = pure fantasy
You don't have flaws in a scam.
Scams embrace flaws they keep out the smart people
A kindergarten level child could find flaws in it
The Flaws are named Albanese, and Bowen, Gallagher, Miles, Etc,, Etc,
He is a handsome boy though
Oh there's no holes in their plans... Create a problem. Invent an industry. monopolise and monetise it. Simple
Greatly degrading the grid to meet some arbitrary target sure makes a lot of sense.
It's very easy to say something is the cheapest option when your choice of options is only one.
Thieves and scammers
BOWEN is a very special little man,,,, he lives in his Canberra bubble and thinks he is an expert in everything he does regardless of what is reality,,,, only Albenese would employ this man 😢
Renewables bs wow what a delusion
It is a popular delusion that mans effects on the earth’s climate are significant and dangerous.
It is a popular delusion that transitioning to non fossil fuel energy sources will be cheap and easy.
We are currently burdened with a large cohort of dishonest duplicitous politicians who are colluding with ridiculous and economically destructive popular delusions.
It is all a scam.
But Gretta thunberg said there's no flaws....
Even if the renewables plan was the best in the world, with passion fingers Bowen at the helm it would still fail.
Bowen has a perfect record of failure over his career …
Why would anything change now ?
A CEO needed a new accountant and started his interviews. He asked each applicant "what is 2 plus 2". Some gave the usual answer while others stormed out in annoyance. Finally he asked the last one, "what is 2 plus 2?", the applicant looked around the room furtively and then replied, "What do you want it to be?".
Such is the value of the study endorsing Albanese government's net zero plan.
Australia can't achieve Net Zero when 1200 coal ships are loaded in Newcastle every year with nearly 150,000,000 tonnes of coal for export. Bowen's Folly.
yeah, its madness.
Someone has to supply coal to China so it can make renewables.
Going to China, the land of most smog.
Can apply the 'safe and effective' mantra to this folly.
They are ultimately the same folly, by the same people, for the same reasons. It's all about power and control.
How come Albo and Casanova don’t declare their Renewable Energy Transition as misinformation… it fits the criteria, although not their agenda.
Go with the US. There should be more research on the construction of huge Solar Panel Farms. These farms can cause more damage than you may think. In the United States, there seems to be growing opposition to the construction of Solar Farms and Wind Turbines. At the beginning of 2023, 60 counties in the US opposed the construction of solar farms. By the end of 2023, it had grown to 116 counties opposing Solar Farms and the list is growing. At the same time, 375 counties have blocked wind farm construction. Also three states in the US, Connecticut, Tennessee, and Vermont, are in the process or have banned the construction of Wind and Solar farms.
Wonder what happened to the incinerators for garbage to produce power. Works well in Singapore. Could power Sydney as garbage is growing problem.
CO2 was higher in six different ice ages? So why is basically plant food and issue when it is 0.04% of the atmosphere. The Australian government is just following Europe and America like little children.
Energy input is required to produce garbage.
The Earth's atmosphere is 190000 kms deep; it extends about halfway to the moon. CO2 concentration is measured in the lowest 25 kms, but who cares anyway? CO2 is irrelevant in climatology.
Because they all are under their masters the WEF 0RGANISATION
Weve only got ourselves to blame cause we , not me voted in this government, i never vote for labour or liberals , Vote 1 Nation
Energy minister , we are not morons like people who pushing this energy stupidity. Definitely. 🤗👍🌎🇺🇸🐖💯❤️🇦🇺 7:34
80 percent renewables by when 2030? Better get a move on since according to AEMO over the last three months coal accounted for more than 65 percent of MWh.
Not Zero
Wow who would have thought…
That’s stating the bleeding obvious
Let’s reduce our 1.2%. Carbon contributions , We can save the world.
Yeah it don't work.
Please don’t tell the truth 😳
No shit Sherlock.
How will renewables go with the current weather in NSW
The govt lied to you regarding the jab .
Same with renewables!
The biggest flaw in Australian supply is the current minster in charge.
What are they proposing for added electricity when petrol diesel and gas are all removed. How much will backup batteries cost. ?Here inuk we estimate £30 trillion.At todays prices. Solar panels being made by fossil fuel industries.
People with electric hot water and other electric heating that run on off peak tariffs should be changed to run during the day rather that at night as there is a glut of renewable energy during the day and we are told that the spot price for our power is close to zero and sometimes in the negative. I guarantee that this will not happen but it should if they are serious about this so called climate change hysteria.
Please don't put Bowens face on anything. It makes me sick.
Surge in powe r price is only beginning -
Definitely, great book, God help us. 🤗👍🌎🇺🇸🐖💯❤️🇦🇺 5:34
Nothing flawed in their plan. They know they are one term and out, so they do some theatrics make it look like they will help with cost of living. Implement further pain for farmers/consumers re food pricing with sustainability goals, increase govt spending on aboriginal titles even though people voted NO, increased welfare, increased tax collection, make a song and dance about energy but then approve nothing that will reduce costs.
Net Zero, a problem worldwide, for sure. Nuclear energy is the only sane option for baseload power but if you're a politician that invested heavily just prior to going green on energy, you're probably wanting to carry on lining your own pockets than using something as reliable as nuclear power.
Nuclear is by far the most expensive option - 437% higher cost per KW than wind or solar.
@@davidwall8954 You're forgetting the massive subsidies to green energy, 5 charges on electricity bills to subsidise the cost of green energy and a lot of government grant support for the most unreliable energy source in existence. Additionally, we continue to pay for these intermittent energy sources when they are not producing energy. You can check this out, they're all facts.
Coal is by far the cheapest, then gas, then nuclear. Green energy is the most costly of all when you add all the free money in.
There is a big change going on with power production now not in 20 -30 years time. So if this is as bad as it gets do not worry about it. The power supply is coming back to state owned and operated. There will be net zero by 2050 and a gross reduction by 2030. Simples.
What is Net-Zero? Does it relate to CO2, a totally irrelevant gas in terms of climatology? If it's a problem, I'd suggest you have a chat to the world's oceans and river systems, because that's where about 96.5% comes from, naturally. Good luck sorting that out, but please let me know when, and if, you achieve anything of substance.
Over 60% of the land in Australia are Desert . Australia should try to sell more coal to China , and buy the Solar Panels
from them in return . Install the Solar Panels in Desert areas only and generate a lot of cheap solar energy so as to enable
Australia to become competitive in other industries .
You're not the brightest crayon in the box are you?
Hey mate stick to the funnies in the newspaper 😂😂😂😂😂
@@robharris6874 Grass will grow rapidly under the shade of the Solar Panels , and Sheep Farms can
be set-up to increase the production of wool & mutton .This is one of the many ways how China brought
its people out of poverty . Australia should try to make better use of its Deserts & stop moaning .
Sorry brightspark if we put the panels in the deserts we just Wi-Fi the power for the consumers.. how to get the power from desert to East Coast population, maybe we 😅 Bluetooth it
@@Jackjack-zl4nt High voltage power transmission and distribution systems are widely used in China
to transfer power from Deserts to Cities . Grass will grow rapidly under the shade of the Solar Panels ,
and Sheep Farms can be set-up to increase the production of wool & mutton . This is one of the many
ways how China brought its people out of poverty . Australia should try to make better use of its
Deserts , by asking Universities to study the China approaches and adopt those suitable for Australia .
Cost of Solar Panels is dropping 10% / year and it is not wise to make cheap Solar Panels locally .
It is easy to find the errors and harder to find a solution. It is a problem for everyone around the world. It is the most complicated problem to solve. Either we do something or nothing. Even if we do meet net zero by 2050 there is the carbon dioxide already in the atmosphere which will impact weather events in the future.
Hahahahahahahahaha!
Hahahahahahahahaha!
Tried to warn you!
Hahahahahahahahahaha
Centre for Independent Studies must be real scientists and engineers ? However it sounds like an oxymoron.
It's a right wing think-tank funded by undisclosed donors.
Does anyone understand how Marxism works? Good video to learn about it.
Thanks to !?
USA!
0:47 0:49 It's an energy *_addition_* (not "transition").
Check this NASA motor run turbine math one kilowatt output turbine requires 850w to run that weighted turbine so ok we get why we don't use but add gear today say 600w on top at full count x4 together gets that one kilowatt output to scales vs wind to a x4 over current 5-35MW turbines in Perth to get that 150MW would obtain that or you can go x4 min on 4days a week 4 hours per day at full rpm to the min wind 28,000 coal full time 120,000mwy at 3mw design by the min not second??? Third was the cores in that turbine I'll show you something new add that high job service vs on the ground to parts replacement com on man ??😃😄😁😆😅 5 Smile's. tired off that family.
How about net zero immigration in Australia
Oh gee, really? 😂❤️🇦🇺🦘