The History of Manchuria: Every Year
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- If you enjoyed this video, please consider supporting me on Patreon!
/ thedragonhistorian
This video presents the history of Manchuria from 10,000 BCE to 2021 CE. It showcases historical cultures and tribes as well as states and their leaders, classified according to language family.
Non-state societies which had their own ethnic identity or were prescribed one by outside actors are classified as tribal societies, while others are classified as cultures.
Major minority groups within the territories of premodern states and nomadic empires are shown. In such cases, boundaries of the dominant state are marked by thick outlines.
Entities are labeled on the map with their most well-known name, but shown on the key by their official names, with reconstructed contemporary pronunciation where possible. The reconstructed names of those who left no records of their own are based on Chinese records.
00:00 Intro
00:04 Information
00:46 Prehistoric Manchuria
01:57 Ancient Manchuria
03:42 Classical Manchuria
06:43 Early Medieval Manchuria
07:43 Late Medieval Manchuria
09:31 Early Modern Manchuria
11:34 Modern Manchuria
12:04 End credits
Note: this periodization is purely for viewing convenience and is not endorsed by mainstream academia. I divided up the eras as follows:
Prehistoric Manchuria (10000 BCE to 701 BCE): the era before state formation in Manchuria.
Ancient Manchuria (700 BCE to 109 BCE): begins and ends with the rise and fall of Gojoseon, the first known state in Manchuria.
Classical Manchuria (108 BCE to 668 CE): begins with the fall of Gojoseon and ends with the fall of Goguryeo, marking the end of singular Koreanic dominance in Manchuria.
Early Medieval Manchuria (669 to 925): corresponds to the time of Balhae, the Goguryeo successor state that also had a significant Tungusic component.
Late Medieval Manchuria (926 to 1386): an era characterized by the dominance of nomadic peoples, namely the Khitans, Jurchens, and Mongols.
Early Modern Manchuria (1387 to 1911): the era in which Manchuria was inhabited by a number of diverse peoples.
Modern Manchuria (1912 to present): Manchuria since the Xinhai Revolution.
-Music information-
🎵Music provided by BGM President
🎵Track : Wind leaves, yet the Moon stays - • [Royalty Free Music] W...
Finding Movement by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
Artist: incompetech.com/
곡정보 : 박세임-설화
출처및저작권표시 - 공유마당, CC BY
링크: • Video
Music from purple-planet.com
"Mechanolith"
Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Really well made my friend, I honestly liked it.
What a nice job, love your maps!
In genetic, manchurian is more similar to Korean or Mongolian but not han Chinese
Manchurian is a artificial ethinc group, precisely, Manchurian is a military group consisted of Nuzhen, Mongolian, and Chinese.
I guess you want to express that Korean are more close to Nuzhen and Mongolian, because they had conquered the Korean peninsula.
But in fact, China is consisted of many ethnics, Mongolian is one of them, what you called "Han Chinese"is not from an single origin.
@@jieyiblue6469Mongolian aren't Native Chinese originally.
The correct definition of a Pre-Modern Native Chinese is : The Sinitic Han ( Huaxia ) people, the Sinitic Non-Han ( Non-Huaxia ) people, the Non-Sinitic people who got conquered and gradually became Sinicized and are inside the Great Wall under direct bureaucratic/commandery control of Native Chinese dynasties in China Proper and the Non-Sinitic legal migrants who gradually became Sinicized and who are settled inside the Great Wall under direct bureaucratic/commandery control of Native Chinese dynasties in China proper.
Korean, Vietnamese, Turk, Uyghur, Manchu, Mongol, Tibetan and Aboriginals from Taiwan aren't Native Chinese at all.
Korean girls ain’t got nothing to do with us. Wtf u on dude
Yeah.But today almost of manchu people can only speak Chinese.
@@joerogue231no
Love the music in this video. Very serene, I have subscribed
Very very good documentary, commendable!
Thank you for this video
Excellent video
best history mapping channel ever at details
Geographically, this is looks so accurate. I'm learning many things from you. Thanks for your amazing videos always!
안녕하세요
@@geoneop1124 안녕하세요.
Excellent video! I do have some issues, you fail to show the Mongol-Jurchen War in the 1620s and 1630s, show Li Zicheng as having controlled the entirety of Shanxi from 1636-1649 (which is extremely innacurate), and failed to show the Sixty-Four Villages east of the Heilongjiang River. During the warlord era, you also misplace the southern border of Fengtian province, fail to show the Guominjun control of Zhangjiakou and western Zhili at the end of 1924, show Chahar and Suiyuan as controlled by Shanxi at the end of 1927 even though at that point during the Northern Expedition they were occupied by Fengtian, misplace the Rehe-Fengtian border again in 1932, show Hebei as controlled by the Shanxi clique in 1935 despite the fact that its governor was KMT, erroneously show the Shanxi clique as having been disbanded in 1938, fail to show Communist Chinese control in northern Hebei and Chahar in 1945. And in general, most of the provincial borders during the warlord era seem poorly drawn. And you failed to show how the coastline has changed over the course of the past several thousand years.
Thanks for the feedback! I was under pressure to finish the video as quickly as possible by the end of it, as it was already a week overdue, so I had no time to do new research to update the information I'd collected for previous videos. Therefore everything from the Ming dynasty onwards was probably not as tightly produced as what came before. My depictions of the Warlord Era especially have never been very good and unfortunately I wasn't able to gather new research.
@@TheDragonHistorian Please do history of India
How do research all this
Thank you. Looking at this and wondering where my ancestors might have come from on my grandma's side. My dad had some Mongolian come up. And it has to come from his mom's side, since his y group is very distinct to only Mesopotamia. Can't look at it like, oh, well there's a small % of Mongolian ... I see it as there were alot of people behind that 1 ancestor. It's cool to fancy where my ancestors were. Even if someone traveled into that region, and another traveled out. Thank you, for your extended knowledge of this. ❤
amazing, I m half Manchu people and feel appreciate your video!
Nice
Love Manchus
Uighur Khaganate do u know seven Uyghur girl jump off the mountain？
so you are one of the real descendants of the true Qing dynasty that once ruled China, damn your ancestors is cool
Is Machuria a country or its part of China already ever since?
Awesome video! Although this might be only a little trivia, you have however forgotten about Jaxa which was a country founded on the Russian-Chinese border by Polish nobleman Nicefor Czernihowski and existed in years 1665-1685
OMG hi
You're always underwhelming. Nobody cares about your Polish hypernationalism.
Good job.
Great video
Northern Tungusic People: "Aight Imma head out"
I’m loving this music!
Awsome video !
Maek tribe who lived in Cháoyáng believe in bear totem and Ye tribe who lived liaoyang belive in tiger totem. After that Ye-maek tribe unite to build a country of Gojoseon.
Well made history of East Asia. Interested to learn more about the Ainu people and culture.
Awesome video. But I have some facts and questions about the representation of the video:
-Since Gwanggaeto the Great's reign the Goguryeo monarchs were known as Taewangs (Emperors);
-I didn't even know that a state named Zubu exists. How did this state managed to bring to submission mongolic and turkic tribes under their rule?;
-And until 1293, Kublai Khan was tje last true Great Khan of the Mongol Empire (1206-1293)? And after his death the Yuan Dynasty became it's own in China and Mongolia after his death?;
- Why didn't put the Khitans as vassals of Goguryeo since Gwanggaeto the Great ruled the new fresh Empire? The youtuber GleamKim showed that it controlled the khitan tribe west of the Liao river.;
Zubu is a common Chinese name for Mongolian tribes from 10th to 12th centuries
좋은 자료 감사합니다!
I am certainly going to be on time for this.
@@ictoan5966 yes, I was.
당신은 좋은 사람입니다. 제게 이런 좋은 영상을 보여주셨기 때문이죠. 감사합니다.
Great video! I have 2 questions.
1. Why did you show Zubu as existing after 924 when book of Liao says it stopped existing in 924?
2. To what extent were all those Qing vassals in Manchuria autononous? Do you have any useful sources on them in particular?
Glad you enjoyed the video! To answer your questions:
It was my understanding that Zubu began paying tribute to the Khitans in 924 but were not placed under their rule until 1003. I did not bother with marking tributary relations because the entire map would have been the same color as China for most of the video.
The Qing "vassals" in Manchuria were not actually vassals but just significant minority groups under direct rule. Such minority groups are distinguished from vassals by having a thick outline around them.
@@TheDragonHistorian Where is the link to the qing anthem you used
Amazing
Your channel is amazing, do about guarani and tupi leanguages, they are cool ok? OH, SEE THE LINGUA GERAL AND NHENGATU
I love this music
Very good and detailed animation! But the republic of Zeleny Klyn existed in these parts, I hope you know about its existence🤗
I am Haixi Jurchen and i think the Haixi Jurchens would be placed slightly more north, but apart from that, it's all accurate. The Haixi Jurchens were most heavily influenced by Mongolia, their leaders naming themselves Khan and language, clothing and combat was very Mongolian. They were Semi-Nomadic as well, so Mongolian traditions fitted their lifestyle. But unfortunately, there Semi-Nomadic ways was the reason they were described as 'Barbarian Jurchens' by the Jianzhou Jurchens, who had settled and mostly assimilated into Chinese and Korean Cultures, they later named themselves 'Manju (Manchu)' to separate them between the Haixi Mongolic Jurchens and the Ye'ren (Wild) Jurchen hunter-nomads. Even after the Jurchen were united by the Manchus (Jianzhou Jurchens), the Haixi Jurchens still had bad relationships with the Manchu Qing emperors.
Amazing geograpic next sir
the koreans had that chunk of manchuria for a long time. Goguryeo disappearing :'0(
The common language of Goguryeo may be more like Japanese, a race similar to Japanese widely distributed along Northeast Asia and the coasts of the Korean Peninsula.
@@herosio270it is old and fault theory. alexander vovin is refutated that theory and build new and more logical theory. find his thesis. he proved goguryeo language is ancester of modern korean
항상 영상 잘 보고있습니다.
Cool
Is there a link for the music of cup of solid gold that you used
대단하다 영상 퀄리티가ㄷㄷ합니다
What app do you use
Fantastic video, though I think you placed the Shiwei far too south.
Cool
1912: shit went from 0-100 real fucking quick
Thank you for making the history of great land Manchuria.Hope Manchuria great again.
Not with 80% han chinese
@@charlesk4831 No Han Chinese, all people born and grow up here are Manchurian.
@Welcome to Mars Chinese always tell lies and steal land of others, fine make your Chinese dream.
Manchurians are Chinese, but that does not mean there can’t be Manchurian nationalism
@@charlesk4831blud us han people literally built Manchuria into what it is today☠️
I can now understand the historical context of season 2 of Golden Kamuy anime from this
I like the music when the Qing dynasty showed up. This music played too in the Tungusic video when the Qing appeared.
This was the National Anthem of Qing Dynasty, which is called Gong Jin Ou(巩金瓯/"Cup of Solid Gold").
Fun fact: The lyrics of the song are about how the empire is solid and it would never fall. Yet 7 days after the adoption of the anthem, XinHai revolution broke out and ended Qing Empire.
tungusic peoples and northern fareast asian peoples sure do love Gold. even in golden kamuy anime, the ainu are for some reason depicted to have some sort of liking for gold. it must be the gold in the amur river and the gold mine industries around manchuria
@@ShibalotonSeattle Oh nice, I just looked it up, it's pretty interesting and sad at the same time
@@xXxSkyViperxXx Never seen that anime before, it seems to be one of the very few anime that features the Ainu culture so it is a must watch. The only other Ainu anime or video game characters I could think of are Nakoruru and Rimururu from Samurai Shodown and Horohoro from Shaman King. Maybe the northerners like to get gold to trade with their more agricultural southern neighbours? They say that the Manchu traditionally were semi-agricultural so I guess they didn't farm as much.
@@JcDizon yeah golden kamuy is mostly about some soldier characters from the imperial japanese army during after russo-japanese war time and the ainu in hokkaido and later on in season 2 or 3, they also get to sakhalin/karafuto and also show a little bit about the other fareast north asian minority peoples there like the nivkhs, uilta/oroks, and some brief mentions about the nanais, yakuts, and evenks in the russian fareast. the anime also likes to showcase ainu food, cooking, and hunting practices. there might soon be a season 4 next time too since season 3 just ended last year
Northern tungusic peoples: just passing by
What version is this anthem of qing dynasty
1:15 I can't read the place marked next to the Hongshan Culture. Could you put it here?
It says Dong'gwan-jin (동관진). It's a Paleolithic site in what is now North Korea.
정말 위대합니다, 선생!!!!!
Goguryeo, balhae = Korean history
there are tungusic history 😅
@@Xiaoxinhistory goguryeo is not
Poor Koreans, you can only output their non-existent history using equations, Korean=false history creator
Nanyue is vietnamese history too !!! Chinese stealing everything
@@ChinaVirus0604yeah but why still same name ?
The tribal people on Sakhalin Island lasted a really long time before being taken over by a state.
Спасибо за Ваш колоссальный труд! Живу в Благовещенске. Очень интересно проследить историю этих мест!
10:58 where you find this version of manchu anthem?
Sad what has happened to Manchuria... But this video is really awesome!
Why do you sad? You think that should be Korean?
@@JOE-ft3gq no
@@retf8977 I see what you mean the this land is not belong to them anymore
@@JOE-ft3gq Manchu was an independent group of people with their own language and culture, until they conquered China and became Chinese themselves.
@@kryndude with respect China also influenced them, the rivers over there were called Jiang because of interaction with Southern China. And they’re able to conquer China not only by force but also they adopted Chinese custom.
Those Mongols knew how to party.
Northern Tungustic Peoples: ight imma head out
He went to get some milk.
according to google early modern start at the 1500s
I ship Manchuria with Poland.
I think Russia should have just annexed Manchuria to have a non freezing seaport.
They used to have one but returned to China in 1955. Russia wants Busan. But not win the Korean war.
It's risky. If they kept Manchuria after WW2 it would destroy relations with China. But if Korea were to unite under North Korea in 1950s, they might be given access to an ice-free port on the peninsula. But we all know Korea is still divided and it didn't happen
Watching while herding Deers and Mooses in Far East
1:42 bad apple
If anyone is still in the comment section here, I would really like a source on the Dong'gwan-jin paleolithic culture/people, as I cannot find anything on it.
Hey can someone help me with this question
What happened to the ethnic manchurians in outer manchuria after russia took it because modern day ethnic maps show there no longer there and its really hard to find any information about it
I think the Russians kill many Chinese, Korean and Japanese living in outer Manchuria.
They were probably forcefully moved out of there.
I think they were forcefully exiled to central Asia.
Nothing, although there were ethnic Manchus in these territories, Trans-Amur was predominantly inhabited by Chinese settlers, the colony of haishenwai was the largest in the region.
They probably got genocided by Russians
10:31 Congratulations! It is First Time when you gave Informations about The Slavs! Congratulations!
manchurian is not chinese, they are just manchurian
@杨波涛 In your China, there seems to be a perception like "Koreans claim everything is theirs". But don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that Manchurians are Korean. But the Manchus were a completely different group from the Chinese Han Chinese before the Qing Dynasty, they are not Koreans, not Chinese
@tianli yu Eng plz
@tianli yu Only the Chinese know the Chinese language The Internet is not China I don't know what you are saying
@tianli yu I'm not talking about nationality. The Manchu people are historically separate from the Han people
China promotes all peoples and former nations of modern Chinese territory as historically part of China
Jinkis Khan is Chinese? Goguryeo is China? Are you kidding China?
@tianli yu Although the current Manchurian nationality may be Chinese, they are clearly not Chinese before the Qing Dynasty took over China. Did you understand what I mean?
охуенно! спасибо авторам!
Manchu Aisingioro family paternally belong to the same haplogroup as ChingisKhan and maternally in the beginning they took only Mongolian princess as their wives. So it could be considered also as Mongolian state. Also there is one correction about the map. Instead of different Mongolian tribes in the 16th century it’s more correct to show different khanates who in their turn consisted of different tribes. Such khanates like AltanKhan khanate, Sain Noion, Jassaktu and Tushetu.
Societies are Patriarchy, so they follow the culture of the Father side. So it's still Tungusic states, besides it's evident in history that the Qing basically controlled Mongol tribes and incorporated them into the 8 Banner Military system.
Are you delusional .
English and French have the same haplogroup, so is England French? Mongol and Manchu are still separate but related groups
Basing ethnic makeup on genetics is some dumb eugenics nonsense. Ethnicity is a complicated mix of language, ancestry, politics, cultural practices, and history, all wrapped up with self-identification. A white guy who finds out his great great grandma was a black woman isn’t suddenly black.
@@cassidyjones2730 exactly you are right in case there were only one ancestor but if it’s happened on prolonged way and you have more ancestry from another ethnicity, like if your grand grandmas, grandmas from both sides and mom would be black, it’s questionable if you could call yourself white, isn’t it ?
Was the music changed?
Yeah, I had to replace some of the music due to a copyright claim.
아래에서 부들부들대는 중뽕들 있네요.
제1만주국 : 청나라
제2만주국 : 우리가 아는 그 만주국
청나라는 중국으로 보는게 맞다
@@ZHONGHUAMINGUOWANSUI_HANGUOREN 그럼 청나라 시절 서구열강들한테 빚진것도 갚아야겠네? 중국이라매 ㅋㅋ
@@user-jf8ky5wn2s갚아야지 ㄹㅇㅋㅋ
청나라는 여진족이세운나라잖아 근데 중국애들은 왜 지들역사에넣음?
@@user-uz6yo6vi2r지들역사가 전부 지배당해 만들어진 역사인데 안넣으면 즈그 국사에 뭘넣겠음 안그라도 문화대혁명으로 싹다 뒤졌는데 ㅋㅋㅋ
the music is very eastern,and there is Great Qing national anthem
I have a question.
Why didn't you show conquered Han Chinese while showing nomadic tribes even if they were conquered?
Because those conquering states ended up becoming Sinicized anyway and were shown as such in the key, I didn't feel the need to mark Han Chinese on the map.
The Bulhae and Goguryeo are simply defined as Korean, Just like the Germanic people of the Holy Roman Empire being regarded as the Mediterranean Roman Empire, it is outrageous.
@@herosio270 이 뭔 멍청한소리야 do you know that korea means goryeo ? As goguryeo means old goryeo ? 古goryeo how stupid
Probably u r chinese right ?
Where is the Kyrgyz Khaganate?
and fuyu kyrgyz
Seni niye her videoda görüyorum...
The korea goryeo ang joseon
Chertovy Vorota Cave
So are the Koreans more related to the Tungusic, Mongols, Yayoi, or Han漢??
Well going from most related to least related it would be Yayoi, Han, Tungusic, Mongol. Koreans are most related to Yayoi.
Linguistically, Korean has no connection with Sinitic language. Korean is structurally similar with Japonic, Mongolia, Tungusic, Turkic
Not related of those who you wrote. You need to find the missing link in part of siberia, not east asia, if you mentioned about a link to the Proto Korean language. Vovin once said that Korean language is probably the descendant of the yeniseian languages(or Pumpokolic you can say), which is not related to any other east asian heritage.
@@xe5309 No, no. Koreans are more related to Northeastern Chinese than Yayoi, Tungusic, and Mongol. Koreans have very little Tungusic. Mongols are more distant.
I’m proud to be a Chinese of Manchurian descent. I also love my neighbors in Japan, Korea, Russia and especially Mongolia.
If you are really descent of manchurian, genetically you are brother of korean.
Genetically most closest country to korean is manchurian.
Manchuria is not a part of China
Manchuria is belong to Manchus
And Manchus are not Chinese
Manchus are Manchus
@@seoul_louis9584Manchus are literally sinified tungusic of mongolian origin, the term 'Manchu' is japanese(Manshū), they never was a majority within Manchuria itself and the name 'Manchuria' was only mentioned for the first time in the 19th century.
Also, the idea of a Manchu nation arose to associate them with the rest of China through a political maneuver by Emperor Hong Taiji. Lol.
Contemporary Manchus are genetically closer to the Koreans and Chinese themselves than to the actual Tungusic tribes that still exist.
@@ninds437 oh yeah? Then is "Uyghurstan" fake too because somebody made that name? Whatever you say, the name what they have is not a matter. The fact that China didn't rule Manchuria is really important. And in Manchuria, Manchu people lived.
And Manchus are not Mongols lol
@@ninds437 there was no Chinese in Manchuria before the 19th century.
Thats a lot of countries where everybody looks the same
Manju tumen se !!
11:41 bad ending. 11:44 cursed ending
Turkic: fuck this shit im out
It's funny seeing all these people who don't even live in this land saying things like Manchuria belongs to Manchus/Koreans/Russians
while at the same time Manchu people in China is basically identical to Han Chinese.
The Manchu language has gone extinct, even. Assimilation has happened.
It’s common, many, many ethnic groups which existed in the past have disappeared, not because they were genocided but simply because they assimilated into other groups.
The first unified dynasty of the Manchrians was 金(Jin). Records from the Song Dynasty or Manchu history books published by the Qing Dynasty indicate that the descendants of the Silla royal family(their last name 金) built 金(Jin). The Song dynasty called the 金dynasty Silla, which had been destroyed on the Korean Peninsula 200 years before. Historically, the Manchrians were a mixture of various northern ethnic groups (Mongols, Turks, Korea, etc.), and their royal family called themselves descendants of Silla, but Joseon ruling class who liked Ming called them babarian. During the Japanese Invasion of Korea, Nurhachi wanted to send troops to help his brother country Joseon, but the king of Joseon refused his proposal and asked Ming for help. After 後金(post Jin) conquered the Ming and established Qing, the Manchrians were assimilated into the Han Chinese, and now they are a minority ethnic group in northeast China. Nevertheless the Manchrians and Koreans were closely intertwined in ancient history.
• Japanese colonial rule (1910-1945) was a contradictory experience for Koreans.
• Nurhaci died of his wounds two days later in Aijipu (靉雞堡; present-day Da'aijinpu Village, Dijia Township, Yuhong District, Shenyang) on 30 September 1626, at the age of 67.
“Records from the Song Dynasty or Manchu history books”，which books? Koreans always like to make up fake historical materials.The 金 comes from Jurchen：amba-an ant?u-un，there's nothing to do with Silla slaves.
와 기대되네요
400년대에 있던 북연은 고구려계 왕국이었으니 풍씨가 집권하기 전 고씨가 집권하던 시기는 연홍색으로 칠해도 되지않을까요??
고구려에 직접적으로 복속된 적은 없어서 색은 따로 칠했으나 고운이 고구려인 정체성을 유지했다는 확실한 근거가 있는 관계로 우측 범례에서는 Koreanic (한국어족)으로 분류했습니다.
@@TheDragonHistorian 就知道是韩国人整理的地图，韩国人的色彩太浓厚，还特意弄出个韩国系出来？不觉得搞笑吗？历史上一直是卑微的民族。
首先扶余族和肃慎族对朝鲜半岛曾经有过深远的影响，主要是朝鲜半岛北部地区，而你们韩国的主体是土著三韩部落：马韩、辰韩和牟韩。只能怪你们的祖先没有什么出彩的历史，所以你们只好借用肃慎族和扶余族的历史了，但请不要冠以"Koreanic"这样的字眼，因为你们koreanic是被征服的。
你们是三韩民族，而扶余族混血的高句丽和肃慎族的渤海国不是你们的！你们最多不过是被这些民族殖民过的而已！
基本上所有历史都只能基于中国的正史24史记载的内容，因为也只有中文的汉字才记载那些历史，但是你们却活生生的把高句丽和渤海国等算做你们韩国系的实在是搞笑！
@pd yt 극단적 민족주의는 심각한 분쟁을 불러옵니다. 예의를 지켜주세요.
@@pdyt843 말갈족,여진족,만주족은 언어,유전적으로 중국의 한족이랑은 거리가 멀다
송막기문과 금나라 역사서에서 금나라 사람은 자신들이 고려의 말갈에서 분리됐다고 기록돼있다
너희들 종족이랑은 거리가 멀다는 뜻이다
그리고 청나라가 중국의 역사인가? 아니다. 중국인이 만주족에게 정복 당했던 것이다
신해혁명 직후에 너희 중국인들이 어째서 만주족에 증오를 품었고 학살했는지 말해봐라
그리고 문화대혁명에서 홍위병들이 명나라의 무능한 왕의 무덤을 부쉈던 이유를 말해봐라
지금 중국은 50개 이상의 민족들로 구성돼있다
중국공산당은 많은 민족들이 각자의 독립의식을 가질까봐 두렵기 때문에 중국 영토에 존재하는 모든 민족이 중국의 역사인 것 처럼 거짓말을한다
그리고 넌 아무런 비판도 없이 그것을 믿는다
@@pdyt843what this concept ?you think it is funny ?
So does the Qing originate from Manchuria or what?
Yes they do
10:30 as the Manchus conquer China.
Meanwhile in russia…
잘 보고 갑니다
what are the kilis people?
Theres no manchuria there
That is not a sea of Japan, Korean sea, or east sea.
It is just stupid figthing for a fucking sea name
@@caracal2011 ikr
쓰시마와 부산 사이의 해협은 대한 해협(korea strait)으로 국제적으로 통용되는데 마찬가지로 국제적으로 통용되는 일본해(japan sea)를 동해로 바꾸고 싶다고 바꿀 수 있는지 모르겠습니다. 영토가 아닌 영해, 그것도 영해만이 아니라 공해를 포함한 지리 용어에 꼭 한국의 시각이 반영된 용어가 쓰여야 할 필요도 딱히 없고요. 사실 방위만으로 이뤄진 지리용어는 구체성이 부족해서 큰 의미가 없는 것 같습니다. 황해(yellow sea)처럼 고유성이 있어야 하는데 동해는 좀 아쉽죠.
@@user-zk4ng1zo7p 그냥 국제적으로 청해 blue sea 라고 하고
한국은 동해 일본은 일본해 이렇게 부르면..
Manchuria is korea
Manchurians are Chinese but Koreans are Koreans
@@josephlee8665 why u say Manchuria is China..manchuria is jurchen..or Tungusic..or Mongolia.people..they are Mongolia.Jengis Khan is ancestors they all..haplogrup.same with Mongolia..
@@indrabayu8381 Because after the Qing Dynasty was overthrown by the Republic of China, all five ethnic groups were Chinese, including the Han, Manchu, Mongolian, Hui, and Tibetan. And if you follow your logic, the Ryukyu people in Okinawa and the Aynu in Hokkaido are not Japanese.
@@josephlee8665 japan people according history ancient time ago.they ancestors is from China mainlad is Yayoi..is from China thousand years ago..so Kanji word alphabet is same with hanyu pinyin China word alphabet..except hiragana & katakana they make hiragana & katakana so different with kanji. .and yayoi or japan people ..have Monolid eyes..not double eyelid..
@@josephlee8665 takuya kimura he is a JOMMON.PEOPLE..NOT YAYOI...or he is origin genuine man from jommon / hokkaido people...because a lot japan are mixed except the imperial family ..they are still origin and genuine yayoi people..
Can you also do India's history plssss???
There was Jomon culture on Sakhalin too
Not Jomon but Ainu.
@@mitonaarea5856 ainus had jomon culture
@@tsheringdolkar9 Ainu are not Jomon. They are a seperate group. Jomon were ancient EA. Ainu are mixed.
What u waiting for China if that was russia they would not hesitate in this situation!
why so many Koreans here say so many aggressive words here?
중국인이 하는 짓을보세요 재네들이 먼저 댓글테러하고 한국인이 공격적인거라고요
Wow
Where did that version of the Qing anthem come from?
even the qing anthem wow haha
Manchuria must be restored as an independent nation. I pray it will happen
I also pray United States will be part of People Republic of China too.
@bensontam Keep joking, you know Manchuria will gain independence, it is inevitable
@SouthCarolinaMonarchist you're joking.no one in manchuria gonna gain independence.it's 99% han now.
@潘越 So what if its 99% Han? With enough convincing, we can make them believe they are Manchu, as they believe anything the CCP says anyways
manchus are literally sinified tungusic of mongolian origin, the term 'Manchu' is japanese(Manshū), they never was a majority within Manchuria itself and the name 'Manchuria' was only mentioned for the first time in the 19th century.
Also, the idea of a Manchu nation arose to associate them with the rest of China through a political maneuver by Emperor Hong Taiji. Lol.
Contemporary Manchus are genetically closer to the Koreans and Chinese themselves than to the actual Tungusic tribes that still exist.
漢字がないと何も分からん
I can’t understand contents because this video has no hanzi
I would be grateful if you would add hanzi
why don't you just learn Alphabet name for those countries?
@@user-nc5yc9es6j You've got a good point.
but that is that we needs to study hanji reading way for chinese japanese and Korean.
It is very difficult because we don't usually use .
Of couse, I also know that this is my selfishness.
@@cosycatastrophe4727
Yeah it would be more conprehensible for east asians if it's in Chinese characters.
But if you know history a lot, you can know which country it is despite being written in Latin script.
@@user-nc5yc9es6j when you use han zi/hanja/khanji for asian mames it becomes clearly
좋은영상입니다. 아주 흥미로워요
그런데 왜 sea pf japan 인가요?
일본의 2차전쟁 영향력 이후 그렇게 부르게 됌
Throughout history, it has been called the Sea of Japan
ADBC