Back than people ship Taemin Krystal and Minho Krystal so hard, But at the end of the day Kai Krystal dating. After they break up, they become awkward each other, because Taemin is Krystal and Kai friend and he is in the middle of the situation 😌
true...it helps though that Taemin, Kai, Krystal and Seulgi were literally best friends as trainees and their early years at SM. so they were actually good friends irl and were comfortable with each other on stage. now idols are awkward af around each other (talking about male/female interactions), one because of not wanting to start rumors and secondly they aren't as close as idols in the 2nd/3rd generation who grew up together.
@@NelleBear too bad.. if only the SR15G debuted we would have seen this kind of interaction especially the MMC members because they are really close and are almost always trained together...
@@NelleBear i think the only bestfriend that you mentioned is taem, kai 😅 i don't know about seulgi as far i know shes close with gong seungyeon. Krystal is close with jonghyun, sulli, amber, suho since her trainee days era, Jong and Suho was mentioned in her thanks to album btw.
and today, Krystal left SM... I'm sad but happy. I'm sad because I miss the old memories of them, but happy for Krystal's future. Wherever you are, whatever you wanna be, I'll always support you guys. Sorry, I just really miss the old SM moments.
F(shinee) is everything. Every interaction was the best. Taestal, Lunew💖, Minstal, Minsull, Ontoria, Jongna, Keyber, Taeber, Dinotwins, Jongtoria, Taesull...all of it
Apparently Krystal left SM once her contract had expired in order to pursue her solo career. It’s so unfortunate too, because pretty much everyone in F(x) left SM because they’re a shitty company who can’t promote artists correctly.
So h.o.t and s.e.s are the grandparents, BoAs the aunty that on vacation, the grace and blackbeat are the family that you never see anymore, and fly to the sky and Shinhwa are the older brothers. Okay I got it
@@jenaj7306 Yup she said that because they trained together but they debuted first than her. But when I watch videos of EXO and RV I think she is only awkward to Kai(thats what I observed hahaha)
Also Krystal was seen at Taemin's concert in Japan year or 2 years ago. SHINee were singing f(x)'s song in one program. They're still friends, I'm sure of it.
f(shinee) is the only thing that matters. They were so close. That's what we really missing now a days in K-pop. Actually in SM too.. They are awkward with each other. Suju, Snsd, SHINee and f(x) are on another level when it comes to their interactions. I really miss those times
exactly. When I was watching SMTOWN til 2015, I felt their closeness, how big family SMTOWN actually is. But now whenever I see Hope on recent SMTOWNs I can't unsee how awkward it seems to be...
i remember my heart fluttered when i saw them holding hands (to bow) at MBC gayo daejeon's ending stage. That fancam was famous. I was thinking, ah these two are so cute.
When did kpop stop being this fun. Its just sad that idols this generation recieve hate no matter what they do. If you truly love and support them then let them live. As a fan, that is what you're supposed to do. Not owned them. Ps: now that none of f(x) are in sm, I wonder if we will ever get a chance to have a f(shinee) interaction again. I miss them so bad
Taemin and Krystal go way back since they were trainees. SM wanted to scout Krystal since she was very young but her parents dissaproved and let SM recruit older sister Jessica instead and asked them to wait until Krystal was old enough. When Krystal wasn't a trainee yet, she would come to SM with Jessica(who was already a trainee at the time), just to hang out during summer breaks where she also made some new friends with the SM trainee kids which include Taemin. Rumor has it that Taemin would be excited and always look forward to meeting Krystal to play with during every summer. Jessica was so overprotective of Krystal, which made Taemin felt intimidated by her. Fast forward to when Krystal was already old enough to be a trainee and debuted as an idol with f(x), Krystal and Taemin became good friends like you see in this video. Taemin never seemed this close and comfortable with other girls except Krystal. Krystal was also close to other SHINee members like Jonghyun, Key and Minho. One thing that's not included in this video is in SHINee's variety show Hello Baby, they were planning to invite a female guest as a "one day mom" to the kid they were taking care of. SHINee members asked Taemin whom he wanted to invite, and he answered "Krystal". This answer made other SHINee members felt dissapointed as they think his answer was boring because all of them were already close with Krystal and stated that they can always meet her at SM since they're in the same company. So other SHINee members except Taemin named their ideal girl/female celebs (not from SM) that they would want to invite. Back then the popular hetero Taemin ships were with Sulli, as well as Naeun because of WGM (he was "rumored" to be dating these girls back then), but somehow the girl he's most comfortable interacting with in front of fans and in fancams was Krystal. Several years after, Krystal was dating Kai. I don't think Taemin was interested in Krystal in that way and nor was he jealous because he's still bffs with Kai until now. A few years before Kai and Krystal were confirmed dating, I remember seeing Taemin teasing Krystal about Kai in one of his old fancams which showed that Kai and Krystal were probably already a thing or interested in each other back then and Taemin was their mutual friend making fun of these lovebirds. However, when Krystal and Kai broke up, that's when things turned differently and since then there's like 0 interaction between Taemin and Krystal anymore unfortunately. Obviously Taemin being Kai's bff, he's on Kai's side and probably felt discouraged to keep in touch with Krystal. So it seems like they grew distant as years passed. The whole Jessica gate and Jessica vs SM/SNSD thing also made things worse as well for everyone who were well acquainted with them. Taemin doesn't seem like he'd choose sides as he's not close with any 0T8 SNSD members nor Jessica (although he's on friendly and respectful hoobae sunbae terms with all the SNSD girls), meanwhile other SHINee members like Key and Minho became closer to SNSD members especially Taeyeon. Krystal eventually left SM after her contract expired and became a full-time actress now. Unfortunately I don't think she kept in touch with anyone from SM except f(x) members.
I agree. People think that when people dont interact anymore, it means their is indeed hatred. Not true. I really doubt their is a hatred among Taemin and Krystal or Krystal and SNSD Members. But out of respect for the parties involved, its best to not interact. Case in point. I had a Cousin who was dating this Girl. I was very close with her Cousin, I really liked her. But we stopped interacting after my Cousin had a nasty breakup with her Cousin. I dont hate them at all, but out of respect for my Cousin, we stopped interacting since, but I wish them well. Human and Societal behavior can be so odd sometimes.
This is so nostalgic. I can remember around 6-8 years ago when I kept watching moments between idols specifically f(x) with other artists. How I miss the old days :((
“When it was normal” it was was never normal for idols to interact with each other. SM, JYP, and YG were the only ones who were exempt from this rule but then even YG got strict. SM and JYP still highly encourage good relationships amongst its artist to continue their family image and promote collaborations! Nothings change these moments still happen just with different artist in the company since fx doesn’t exist it’s red velvet now
No even tho they encourage good relationships, the way the fans will react now is different. The smtown now is never the same as it used to be. The fact is that the atmosphere changed a lot, even with sm artists. F(x) and SHINee were particularly close becos they have a lot of collaboration stage together and attended same variety show or programs. The f(SHINee) thing makes the fans just somehow ships them with each other and not being salty.
@@cakegirl5052 the fans always talked shit. AGAIN there are just some artist that don’t care. SHINee has a beautiful relationship with Red Velvet too. They just don’t care and it depends on who. Bambam and Lisa are widely known as best friends but also often get shipped together however for the most part both fandoms highly support their collaborations. It has always been conditional
I forgot that things used to be like this... I miss male and female idols being able to interact without everyone going mad about it and assuming they're dating. If they are or if they aren't, so what? Guys and girls can be friends too.
i DEFINITELY don't ship them, but they have been in the industry fo so long, i hope they find someone who's gonna take care of them like how taemin & krystal take care of each other
So sweet❤😊🌹 I didn't know that they have a moments like this before. We'll I'm pretty sure I'm not a computer/ social media addict before and before the only thing was I've been waiting is the new mv we'll come it's either on youtube or in myx... 🥰
Actually it was the other way around, the mbc gayo video.. the one their aired on TV was the prerecorded one,, and the one taemin carrying krystal bridal style was the live stage (you could see minho and sulli was not there bcs they attended sbs drama awards that night)
New groups may come and go, but for sure Taemin and Krystal will forever be Maknaes of SM they are the most loved.. And guess what another reason to love SHINee they are the most comfortable around females, and I am lucky to be part of such a fandom, that does not make a fuss about it...
Male and female friendship can become awkward after they find their own girlfriend and boyfriend. It was just a show but Taemin soon got closed to Naeun because of WGM, and then Krystal started to date Kai who is Taemin’s best friend and broke up.
i really wish opposite gender idols could interact more now :( there would be so many more fun moments && i rlly wna see exo and rv be good friends in front of cameras!
Eventho they are maknaes they were quite old when they debuted plus there aren't many interactions of them together other than those times when they were forced to work together 😂 So I would not call them sm babies or sm's maknae duo More like sm's unofficial couple as kyu once said
ALSO WATCH:
KPOP IDOLS ON-STAGE FUNNY MOMENTS/ACCIDENT/MISTAKES THAT I STILL THINK ABOUT
czcams.com/video/4E3vo1nF0NQ/video.html
i miss them together, f(shinee) have the cutest interactions
And now the SM maknaes are RV Yeri and NCT Jisung they're both talented. But I can't help but miss the 2nd gen because of their friendship back then..
same! i miss 2nd gen sooo much 😭😭😭
@@lucyheartfilia2073 no its not jisung is still the youngest
@@shammam4008 i mean in SM😅 because he used to be the youngest in SM but now it's Ningning
@@shammam4008 lmao NOW it’s ningning but yes, jisung used to be the youngest
Jisung and NingNing
Back than people ship Taemin Krystal and Minho Krystal so hard, But at the end of the day Kai Krystal dating.
After they break up, they become awkward each other, because Taemin is Krystal and Kai friend and he is in the middle of the situation 😌
Actually its the fans who made it akward 😞
@@rhythmverma1862 the dating definitely is the main reason lol
How I wish idols in this generation can interact with other idols like this without receiving hates.
true...it helps though that Taemin, Kai, Krystal and Seulgi were literally best friends as trainees and their early years at SM. so they were actually good friends irl and were comfortable with each other on stage. now idols are awkward af around each other (talking about male/female interactions), one because of not wanting to start rumors and secondly they aren't as close as idols in the 2nd/3rd generation who grew up together.
@@NelleBear too bad.. if only the SR15G debuted we would have seen this kind of interaction especially the MMC members because they are really close and are almost always trained together...
@@NelleBear i think the only bestfriend that you mentioned is taem, kai 😅 i don't know about seulgi as far i know shes close with gong seungyeon. Krystal is close with jonghyun, sulli, amber, suho since her trainee days era, Jong and Suho was mentioned in her thanks to album btw.
and today, Krystal left SM... I'm sad but happy. I'm sad because I miss the old memories of them, but happy for Krystal's future. Wherever you are, whatever you wanna be, I'll always support you guys. Sorry, I just really miss the old SM moments.
Same thoughts!
yeah. im happy krystal left sm, it wasnt doing her good.
F(shinee) is the best thing ever. They really are the only twin group that matters
What about 2NE1 and Big Bang *2nd gen memories makin me cry😢
SUJU and SNSD 2PM and Miss A I miss 2nd gen
@@sierral9400 They are not a twin groupe, more like big brother and little sister groupe. But I get what you mean.
You're right. Idols these days could never............
F(Shinee) forever 😭
Their Pure friendship, all of them, 10 of the 10 really close with each other.
I really miss seeing f(x) with shinee and of course all f(x) members performing on stage altogether 😔💖
Miss ot5
I pray the best for all
F(shinee) is everything. Every interaction was the best. Taestal, Lunew💖, Minstal, Minsull, Ontoria, Jongna, Keyber, Taeber, Dinotwins, Jongtoria, Taesull...all of it
I hate the fact that male and girl idols nowadays don't interact that much :(
when we will see them together again :') :') i also miss those times where idols can freely interact with eo
Why can't now? Because of any restriction?
Apparently Krystal left SM once her contract had expired in order to pursue her solo career. It’s so unfortunate too, because pretty much everyone in F(x) left SM because they’re a shitty company who can’t promote artists correctly.
Taemin - Krystal - Kai - Seulgi
They are friend since trainee.
Don't forget Jinri! Sulli with the four of them were good friends.
Sulli was close to them too
Super junior - Father
SNSD - Mother
TVXQ - Uncle
SHINee- Son
F(x) - Daugther
Red Velvet - niece
NCT - nephew
Aespa - grandchild
😎
EXO???
@@ashxoxoerii they’re from other universe 😂😂
@@nanadasal02 ahh i see . Got supernatural powers😌😌😂😂
So h.o.t and s.e.s are the grandparents, BoAs the aunty that on vacation, the grace and blackbeat are the family that you never see anymore, and fly to the sky and Shinhwa are the older brothers. Okay I got it
F(Shinee) and Super Generation were the definition of friendship goals. I really miss these 2nd gen group interactions.
All are so talented vocalists, dancers and rappers.
I love them all.
Sometimes it is not about the ship, I just miss their interactions where they feel free to show how close they are
Interviewer: red velvet or snsd
Jonghyun: f(x)
Me:😭😭😭😢😢😭😭
They really are sibling groups
I don’t think I can express HOW MUCH I MISS these kind of moments in kpop back then...
jWhat I need now is Taemin Krystal Kai and Seulgi being together since they were friends since trainee days
but Seulgi didn't say she felt awkward around EXO and Kai?
@@jenaj7306 Yup she said that because they trained together but they debuted first than her. But when I watch videos of EXO and RV I think she is only awkward to Kai(thats what I observed hahaha)
@@recillenonnot7760 aah, okay. makes sense now ^^ but yeah, they were such a great group of friends. I miss them together
I just love how supportive they are of each other
Shinee and F(x) members are close still now. When Amber left SM key posted like ' go amber' as motivation . There was situations lie that
Also Krystal was seen at Taemin's concert in Japan year or 2 years ago. SHINee were singing f(x)'s song in one program. They're still friends, I'm sure of it.
@@jenaj7306 yeah. 😀
f(shinee) is the only thing that matters. They were so close. That's what we really missing now a days in K-pop. Actually in SM too.. They are awkward with each other. Suju, Snsd, SHINee and f(x) are on another level when it comes to their interactions. I really miss those times
exactly. When I was watching SMTOWN til 2015, I felt their closeness, how big family SMTOWN actually is. But now whenever I see Hope on recent SMTOWNs I can't unsee how awkward it seems to be...
i remember my heart fluttered when i saw them holding hands (to bow) at MBC gayo daejeon's ending stage. That fancam was famous. I was thinking, ah these two are so cute.
The Iconic Maknae lineup was Taemin-Krystal-Sulli-Minho
I miss ot10 f(shinee) so much🥺 The best siblings group ever existed.
f(shinee) always makes my heart warm
they are all so close
When did kpop stop being this fun. Its just sad that idols this generation recieve hate no matter what they do. If you truly love and support them then let them live. As a fan, that is what you're supposed to do. Not owned them.
Ps: now that none of f(x) are in sm, I wonder if we will ever get a chance to have a f(shinee) interaction again. I miss them so bad
That W Photoshot was Kai, Taemin, Krystal 🤣
omgg the rehearsal fancam tho was so cuteee. I feel like taemin had a secret crush on her :>
Taemin and Krystal go way back since they were trainees. SM wanted to scout Krystal since she was very young but her parents dissaproved and let SM recruit older sister Jessica instead and asked them to wait until Krystal was old enough. When Krystal wasn't a trainee yet, she would come to SM with Jessica(who was already a trainee at the time), just to hang out during summer breaks where she also made some new friends with the SM trainee kids which include Taemin. Rumor has it that Taemin would be excited and always look forward to meeting Krystal to play with during every summer. Jessica was so overprotective of Krystal, which made Taemin felt intimidated by her.
Fast forward to when Krystal was already old enough to be a trainee and debuted as an idol with f(x), Krystal and Taemin became good friends like you see in this video. Taemin never seemed this close and comfortable with other girls except Krystal. Krystal was also close to other SHINee members like Jonghyun, Key and Minho. One thing that's not included in this video is in SHINee's variety show Hello Baby, they were planning to invite a female guest as a "one day mom" to the kid they were taking care of. SHINee members asked Taemin whom he wanted to invite, and he answered "Krystal". This answer made other SHINee members felt dissapointed as they think his answer was boring because all of them were already close with Krystal and stated that they can always meet her at SM since they're in the same company. So other SHINee members except Taemin named their ideal girl/female celebs (not from SM) that they would want to invite. Back then the popular hetero Taemin ships were with Sulli, as well as Naeun because of WGM (he was "rumored" to be dating these girls back then), but somehow the girl he's most comfortable interacting with in front of fans and in fancams was Krystal.
Several years after, Krystal was dating Kai. I don't think Taemin was interested in Krystal in that way and nor was he jealous because he's still bffs with Kai until now. A few years before Kai and Krystal were confirmed dating, I remember seeing Taemin teasing Krystal about Kai in one of his old fancams which showed that Kai and Krystal were probably already a thing or interested in each other back then and Taemin was their mutual friend making fun of these lovebirds. However, when Krystal and Kai broke up, that's when things turned differently and since then there's like 0 interaction between Taemin and Krystal anymore unfortunately. Obviously Taemin being Kai's bff, he's on Kai's side and probably felt discouraged to keep in touch with Krystal. So it seems like they grew distant as years passed. The whole Jessica gate and Jessica vs SM/SNSD thing also made things worse as well for everyone who were well acquainted with them. Taemin doesn't seem like he'd choose sides as he's not close with any 0T8 SNSD members nor Jessica (although he's on friendly and respectful hoobae sunbae terms with all the SNSD girls), meanwhile other SHINee members like Key and Minho became closer to SNSD members especially Taeyeon. Krystal eventually left SM after her contract expired and became a full-time actress now. Unfortunately I don't think she kept in touch with anyone from SM except f(x) members.
Hmmm this is so sad and i miss krystal and taemin sooooo much 😭😭😭
@@farahshahira21 Me too. I hope a miracle fated them to reunite and be good friends again. A collab would be great.
I agree. People think that when people dont interact anymore, it means their is indeed hatred. Not true. I really doubt their is a hatred among Taemin and Krystal or Krystal and SNSD Members. But out of respect for the parties involved, its best to not interact. Case in point. I had a Cousin who was dating this Girl. I was very close with her Cousin, I really liked her. But we stopped interacting after my Cousin had a nasty breakup with her Cousin. I dont hate them at all, but out of respect for my Cousin, we stopped interacting since, but I wish them well. Human and Societal behavior can be so odd sometimes.
I MISS SM’S OG MAKNAE LINE 😭😭😭❤️
Idol moments like this is the moments missed of this gen.
Cutest interaction of all time. Miss them so much. Friendship goals 😊
I can't help but smile throughout this video. f(x) and SHINee will always be my bias groups. I really miss their interaction like the old days..T-T
I miss shinee and fx so so much
I missed f(shinee), their interactions were so genuine toward each other. Now.. Both f(x) and shinee lost one of their member..
Taemin and krystal made the power up choreography wow
I know I can't believe people when they said Krystal is ice queen... so adorable
This friendship and interactions is what I miss the most on the old gens. The freedom that new gens cant relate
This is so nostalgic. I can remember around 6-8 years ago when I kept watching moments between idols specifically f(x) with other artists. How I miss the old days :((
“When it was normal” it was was never normal for idols to interact with each other. SM, JYP, and YG were the only ones who were exempt from this rule but then even YG got strict. SM and JYP still highly encourage good relationships amongst its artist to continue their family image and promote collaborations! Nothings change these moments still happen just with different artist in the company since fx doesn’t exist it’s red velvet now
No even tho they encourage good relationships, the way the fans will react now is different. The smtown now is never the same as it used to be. The fact is that the atmosphere changed a lot, even with sm artists. F(x) and SHINee were particularly close becos they have a lot of collaboration stage together and attended same variety show or programs. The f(SHINee) thing makes the fans just somehow ships them with each other and not being salty.
@@cakegirl5052 the fans always talked shit. AGAIN there are just some artist that don’t care. SHINee has a beautiful relationship with Red Velvet too. They just don’t care and it depends on who. Bambam and Lisa are widely known as best friends but also often get shipped together however for the most part both fandoms highly support their collaborations. It has always been conditional
My f(SHINee) heart. I miss them.
the most adorable maknaes ever. my favs.
i wish kpop idols still had friendships like this🥺
I forgot that things used to be like this... I miss male and female idols being able to interact without everyone going mad about it and assuming they're dating. If they are or if they aren't, so what? Guys and girls can be friends too.
Krystal is everyone's PRINCESS but can never be their QUEEN. 😄😍
i DEFINITELY don't ship them, but they have been in the industry fo so long, i hope they find someone who's gonna take care of them like how taemin & krystal take care of each other
Thank you for this video!
I f miss my kpop era ㅠ 2009 - 2015
thanks for making this...i really miss f(shinee) moment 😭🥺🥺😞😞
So cute 😻
now we can't see them interact 😢
This is so so cute...loved it
Ahhh miss this so much ❤️
So sweet❤😊🌹
I didn't know that they have a moments like this before. We'll I'm pretty sure I'm not a computer/ social media addict before and before the only thing was I've been waiting is the new mv we'll come it's either on youtube or in myx... 🥰
Actually it was the other way around, the mbc gayo video.. the one their aired on TV was the prerecorded one,, and the one taemin carrying krystal bridal style was the live stage (you could see minho and sulli was not there bcs they attended sbs drama awards that night)
I Love them all the time 💖💖💖
i love them so much
I do hope their still in contact they're friendship is so precious
I remember shipping them so hardddd because they were so cute together and lunew too lmaooooooooo
New groups may come and go, but for sure Taemin and Krystal will forever be Maknaes of SM they are the most loved..
And guess what another reason to love SHINee they are the most comfortable around females, and I am lucky to be part of such a fandom, that does not make a fuss about it...
Where’s the lie tho 💜💎
I ship Taemin with Krystal . I love to see both of them together.
I miss taestal so much :((
SHINee in generaL really take a good and sweet care to fx I guess. I still can't get bored of watching them fancams . my babies :(
I miss them
Idols right now can never interact like this because of some toxic "fans". I miss the 2nd gen idols
They must be really close ❤
i feel like they are soulmate in a friendly way
Omg so cuteee taemin and krystal😭❤🤧 but now hit different😭😭😭
yes!!!yes!!!
ありがとうございます😊💚💚
Male and female friendship can become awkward after they find their own girlfriend and boyfriend. It was just a show but Taemin soon got closed to Naeun because of WGM, and then Krystal started to date Kai who is Taemin’s best friend and broke up.
Wasn't he already in WGM at this performance? Krystal is the sister he never had.
So sweet
Wow they look all so free, it’s really hard to see such interactions now, I hope they’re still close even though Kai and krystal happened
Seohyun, taemin and Krystal will always be my baby maknaes♥️
Missing idol Krystal terribly🥺
They're so cute
My babies
KYSTRAL Y TAEMIN LOS ETERNOS MAKNAE DE SM .ENCANTADORES ❤❤❤
Aw! Cute
and now ningning is our maknae ❤❤
6:38 OK taemin oppa what did you tell to soojungie?
1:43 가장 귀여운 순간~~ㅎㅎ
Is it just me or how did they do all of that without having a crush or something????😩😩😩
how lovely to see him flirting with a girl she very nice
I Miss 2nd generation. Groups were more Free now New group are watch 24/7 by companies because of social media 😔
Taeyeon at the end she smiled to krys too I guess XD
i really wish opposite gender idols could interact more now :( there would be so many more fun moments && i rlly wna see exo and rv be good friends in front of cameras!
I’m pretty sure Taemin is the one who made Kai and Krystal date.
😂
Or she was the beard, just kidding... but TaeKai...
SM 94liners for next vid please 🧎🏻♀️
💖💖
❤️❤️
Kyuhyun and Seohyun: AM I A JOKE TO YOU???
Eventho they are maknaes they were quite old when they debuted plus there aren't many interactions of them together other than those times when they were forced to work together 😂
So I would not call them sm babies or sm's maknae duo
More like sm's unofficial couple as kyu once said
Taemin ❤️ Krystal together，👍👌👏👍👏👌
What is the title of the variety show of f(x) in this video?
Yup they're siblings and their parents is Luna and onew
They act like twins
What name show 5.40?
Lucky Taemin got to lift Krystal😂