I like the Arabian, but it’s just kind of small. I think Arthur looks a little goofy riding on it. And it’s too scared of everything for me to keep it around for more than a couple hours.
I said the exact same thing myself. Beautiful horses but too small and they scare easily. My personal favorites are the Dutch Warmblood, Missouri Foxtrotter, and the Turkoman.
I usually go get the white arabian just so I can beat that chick that challenges you in Lemoyne (2X). Afterwards, the speed boost is awarded and I switch horses to something braver, durable and has more stamina. The Arabians are good for speed and selling for money. That's about it.
i like the turkomam but its c tier for me cause i make it go right and bro just runs around in circles because its so fuckin stubborn, i think the thoroughbred is far better but thats just my experience
The only 2 things I hate about the Arabian horses are how tiny they are compared to all the other horses in the game and how often they start freaking out over nothing
Appaloosas are so underrated. The leopard Appaloosa not only have great health and stamina but they can actually reach a max speed of seven when you complete all the race challenges plus the stable upgrades.
The Turkoman is easily one of my favourites, I was actually able to get one for free in chapter 3 and used it for through the rest of the game and I got no regrets. For those you want to no you can get it from the Braithwates when you go to steal there horses, all you gotta is make it your temporary horse before handing it over to the weird twins and then just pick it up after the cut scene (look on CZcams for a tutorial)
Who didn't know you both were going to give the Arabians high marks? The Thoroughbreds are caught throughout the game as are the Arabians. Put em next to one another in game. The Thoroughbreds are better than the small Arabians for mine and most other gamers. (I saw much larger Arabians in real life) Imo, Rockstar added the thoroubred horse so anyone with a little game time could have the best all-around horse. Btw i do not pay for any horse in this game. Theres always a way to either catch or steal them for Arthur. Online would be much better if they were not so tightly wound imo. Dutch was given the Arabian because he does not use it the way Arthur uses horses imo. The Arabians are good for 3 things, though. (imo anyway) they are fun leveling to 4, and they are good to sell for $ ( can be done over and over). 3rd if you like a sorta a very small horse and dont hunt much theyll get ya from a to b in a good time with good handling. So I use them in chapter 2 for some treasure hunts. Very easy to catch them. I agree with your Andalusian roundoff, but I catch the Pearlina at will fairly easily. So, dudes, they are not hard to find. That horse also spooks easier than a thouroghbred even though they are war horses. For a no-nonsense large war horse, I think the Turkoman, but you gotta stick with them for a while like one of you said he did with Big Shire. Btw that's a great horse. Not my long term choice but yaeh, good one. Turkoman...Stats are as good as the best but they are programmed to learn slower imo. Very nice large slender horse. They will let you know when any enemy animal or NPC is near. The differences in the horses are also sensitivity. The Turkoman is almost overstrung but used long term becomes a great horse in this game. Just not a speedster, but fast enough. After using these horses in this game and riding them well past full leveling I always come back to the thouroughbreds and Turkomans. The brindle is the hardest of the Tbeds to find free but well worth price if you decide to buy at Strawberry stable for 450 bucs? She is awesome. I just don't like buying horses even when im on allot of cash. . I did ride the spotted appaloosa for 3 chapters once though. Lol. I enjoyed the horse. I catch them from time to time to haul extra larger pelts for me. i do not bond just break keep close. Toss a rope on if I am headed back to Trapper or Pierson. I do this with others too. If you let them bond, they become your temporary horse which is fine if you dont have a temporary but if you do, you'll lose the temp you have in camp. I keep stables full, then one temp in camp and ride one. Either my favorite or one I'm leveling to sell. Btw you two left a very important horse out of your video. (The American Standardbred.) ( Also mentioning GTA in you RDR vid is sort of a tell why one of you picks the horses that he believes are prettier and faster.) Dudes, I love cool cars but horses are so different than cars.. ima older guy in time on Esrt fir a human lol. Rode horses when I was young. Loved them. It's a bit more than game to say the least. Horses have more minds of there own in general, and, in reality. With that, they can be very similar also. Rockstar really did well with the horses IMHO. I Love cars too. And I don't drive a truck. Lol no I've had American built hot rods since the 70s. cars built from 37 chev to a modern SRT challenger. So many in between. Not a brag dudes. A tell. Back on topic.. American Standardbreds are Pretty close to Thoroughbreds. Maybe, not quite as good. But they are race handling and will bond very well. In (online game) I ride a thoroughbred and a Standardbred. Colors of Standardbreds are cool. The only all black horse in the game i know of is an Americans Standardbred, tall race horse. They have size speed and bond well. (Off topic a bit) If your having a bit of trouble with a horse, you like? Put it in camp as your temp after leveling and past top.. idk but seems to me horses are a little better when left in camp while Arthur rides out on another horse continually. I know, very unlikely in programming... right? Try it..thanks for vid. Overall very cool.. but breaking these horse down like this? Idk dudes, its personal for certain and you take good note of that fact.
I don‘t get why everyone loves the arabians. First of all the coats are pretty boring. They will buck you off as soon as they see any possible danger. They are small as hell which makes them look really goofy. They only have good speed and stats and I think stats only tell half the story. There are so many horses I prefer to an arabian. I only had one in my first playthrough and after that never again.
I would say in my opinion, the Fox Trotter overall is better than the Arabian if you build your saddle right. It Also won’t run off as often as the Arabian.
I really can't rank them all because I have little experience with most of them. In my first playthrough I ran with a Black Tennessee Walker, and when playing with John, I bought the Gold Turkoman and fell on love with this breed. Been using it ever since. You can actually get a Dark Bay Turkoman from the mission where you stole the Braithwait horses in Chapter 3, all you have to do is feed the horse before finishing the mission, until you get level 1 bonding and the temporary horse icon shows up on the map. It is pretty arduous, you must have a lot of horse food on your inventory because takes a little time, but it is totally worth to get a horse you're only supposed to get in the Epilogue, all the way back in Chapter 3.
It’s pretty difficult for me to rank my favorite horses, because a good number of them I didn’t bother using. I’m a bigger horses type of guy: so like the Dutch Warmblood, Ardennes, and Turkoman come to mind. Horses like the Belgian Draft and Shire however, I’ve never really liked the idea of using so they won’t be included. As another note, everyone’s perfect horses is different as some prefer faster horses while others like the bigger bulkier ones better. Oh, and please search up how to pronounce some of the horse names better because that was kind of embarrassing.(just saying) I’ll only rank the horses I’ve used extensively, but again a great deal of others I never used for one reason or another. 2 honorable mentions: The Mustang and Hungarian HalfBred I consider to be underrated. Both Great War/Work horses that served me well, I just haven’t used them that much. 5. Andalusian: When it came time to unlock the stables, I’d often go to brandywine Drop to pick up the Perlino Andalusian. Andalusians in general are great horses for hunting, gun fights and are very brave around predators making it easier to hunt big game. They’re also pretty attractive in their coats. It’s a great early option for a strong war horse and I just have wonderful memories of having it as my main mount. 4. Turkoman: Another fantastic strong war horse. I give it the edge over the Andalusian because of its better speed stats, and I’ll mention they’re both equally great for what their worth. Sometimes however, the Turkoman feels more race than war because there were times were it could easily stand up to a bunch of wolfs until til the next time it couldn’t stand down before bucking me. I guess I’ll say I’m kinda tied with the Andalusian and Turkoman actually, but I like them both. 3. Dutch Warmblood: A solid earlier game option as a giant, tall, versatile work horse. Apparently they can chase off small herds of wolfs because of their sheer size and resilience! These horses have good bravery and all around stats, my favorite coat/variant is the Cremello Gold Dutch Warmblood named Buell from Hamish, then the Chocolate Roan. But yeah, very solid horse with great versatility that never disappoints me. 2. Ardennes: What can I say about it?? It’s so muscular, has a monstrously sounding voice and is a literal tank of a horse!! The hulk of all horses if you ask me. I don’t mind it’s low speed stats because of it’s high stamina and huge health pool, plus they’re perfect in gun fights because they don’t agitate and just about nothing can scare them off.(although the Andalusian and Hungarian Halfbred rival it in bravery) but overall, the Ardennes is my favorite big horse. 1. Missouri Fox Trotter: Quite possibly the greatest horse in the game! Has the highest speed stat, they preform greatly in races, have excellent health and stamina etc. this is the horse I’ve been spending the most time with as of late, as thanks to the Albert Mason MFT glitch I can get the Silver Dapple Pinto as Arthur as early as Chapter 2! It has reasonable bravery even if some horses are better in that category, and that SDP coat is gorgeous! Love this horse, it might be my all time favorite at this point.
My #2 would absolutely be turkoman right behind Arabian. By chapter 4 you’ve done the valentine heist and maybe explored and gotten some gold bars to sell so you definitely could afford 1000 on a horse especially because horses are such a big part of the experience. And I just really like the thing. I remember buying and loving the gold one when I got to Saint Denis it was awesome
super late comment but I pretty much agree with you both on your list based on stats and handling and stuff like that and its a difficult list to do because some horse coats are great even if its a breed that at first seems pretty meh or bad. For example the Adalusian is a solid horse but the Perlino coat is an absolute monster when its at max level I think it has 10 health and 8 stamina while being very stout and not easy to spook also it looks absolutely beautiful. It would be really cool if you both do a ranking of horses breeds in terms of looks and coats excluding stats and temperment etc. If thats the case Ethan's choice of the Shire at 3 is a very very good one.
As someone who hunts more than does bounties or gunfights with gangs, the war horses are amazing. I used the Hungarian Half Bred before switching to the Ardennes and it's an underrated horse (Hungarian). Both HHB and the Ardennes are absolute units and great around big game/predators; was not bucked off once. Other than them, I'm using a Turkoman currently and looking forward to trying Buell towards the end of the game.
You can get the brown Turkoman for free during the Chapter 3 mission “Horse Flesh for Dinner.” Do the mission, but right before meeting the fence, stop and feed, brush, and pet him until he becomes your temporary horse. After the cutscene, you’re back at camp, but still close enough to get to him.
Learning just how little the difference between the bottom speed of an unsaddled Morgan and a 10 speed Thoroughbred...speed doesn't matter. Acceleration and courage are the most important things. That said, in my personal experience, my Turkoman is a bratty coward while the Arabian didn't dump me instantly when spotting a cougar.
Played one time with an Arabian...never again. First place is a toss up between the Fox Trotter and Turkoman for me. Usually have both at my stable at one point. Remaining places go to sturdy horses preferably with great stamina.
Honestly, no, the Arabian is just not the best. It kinda sucks. I mean yeah, it's pretty and fast but that's kinda all it's got going for it. In my game experence, the Arabian is incredibly skittish where the opposite is very essential; you're gonna come across many predators, gunfights and ambushes where you need a horse that can handle that. Taking this horse hunting is not ideal either mainly because of the wild animals but also because it freaks out just after a few gunshots. Stats wise, the Arabian is fantastic, and the sell price is great too, if you snatch the black one from Saint Denis. I have tried to like it and ride it, but I just can't... I absolutely hate how small it is, it feels so unrealistic for Arthur and John to ride. For me, the perfect horse is something like the Missouri Fox Trotter or the Thoroughbred. I value speed and stamina statwise, but I also want a horse that doesn't freak out easily. A huge factor for me is also what I'm gonna be looking at psysically while playing, aka the size of the horse. As mentioned, the Arabian being so small is just an eyesore for me😅 Ironically enough I spent a lot of time with the Appaloosa while playing as Arthur! It's not super fast, but the stamina is great and it was surprisingly brave. The Arabian had a harder time aproaching crocodiles than the Appaloosa.
If I'm looking to do story mode stuff, I'm using the Missouri Fox Trotter. Great horse. If I'm just roaming around the map, hunting, or whatever and I don't care about stats? My favorite horse is the American Standardbred that you can get from Valentine. Beautiful horse.
Dutch Warmblood for me every time. If we're comparing horses to cars, then the DW is an F250 or F350. Not super fast (the one from Valentine Stables tops at 7) but they're meant for work and won't throw you off when next to a snake. A cougar or bear is a different story though.
It's amazing how similar most horses are that it's just up to what you like best. Personally I prefer the larger horses, but not the biggest tanks - Andalusian, Dutch Warmblood, Thoroughbred, Turkoman easily my favorites. Also considering an Arabian beats a Morgan across the map in 1 minute, overall speed really doesn't matter to me.
I wonder what the deal with that is, why did they make the most mid horse breed ever in story mode literally have Rose Grey Bay Arabian level stats in online
Nice video! But I think you guys forgot the American standard, personally I'd put it at #2 because it's one of those horses that you buy in chapter 2 and stick with it until you either find an Arabian or Buell from the veteran missions:)
speed is not rly a thing in this game. Over short distances, the difference is gonna be max 5 seconds between the slowest and the fastest horse. What rly matters is stamina which you need to make long distance trips aswell as health
I like the only horse you cant find in the wild (ofc) its the one deleted Hungarian halfbred. Cant remember the name exactly but its what Boadicea used to be.
I used the brown and white one you can buy from the stable at the start of the game idk if this is just me but in my experience it’s the bravest of the race horses idk if that’s actually the case in game tho
My top picks based on stats are from 5 to 1: 1. Norfolk Roadster 2. Arabian 3. Missouri Fox Trotter or Criollo ( both on same spot lol due to same stats) 4.Mustang (at 4 bonding with Nakodoge Saddle they have full health and Stamina, 9 bars of speed and 7 bars on acceleration) 5. Gypsy Cob (beautiful horse and at 4 bonding with Nakodoge saddle they have full health and stamina with 8 bars on speed and 7 acceleration) note: they are brave against animals.
I only have horses that i find in the wild, steal or get given, ive played the game multiple times and the only horse ive ever bought from a stable is $15 morgan at the beginning of chapter 2
Get high honor and buy any high priced horse for about $450 to $550. Ride the horse to level 4 bonding and sell the horse for about a $1000 dollars. If you're in the epilogue the Blackwater Arabian will make the most money with this method.
I have the black Shire since the beginning chapter 2 and I love this horse he's big handles well and has enough speed for my likeing he'll take alot of punishment so that's why I take him hunting along with a stolen pack horse with a saddle for carrying carcasses. If I get the Ardennes as well I'll be very happy 😊
The Raven Black Shire that you get for free - doesn't even buck you off when around Alligators or Grizzly Bears! It is totally fearless So when you are doing hunting for all Trapper outfits / LOE Satchel etc. It is very helpful - just very slow. Piebald Tobiano Hungarian Halfbred is the same - another absolute beast , even better than the above as it has better stamina and speed starts. It is just hard to get a hold of (you get a free one on the way back from Guarma or get it from Bounty Hunters) Probably my third favourite overall in the game. You can steal Wrobel's horse however if you want a similar horse early (it is the Dapple Dark Grey and a very good looking coat) Chocolate Roan / Sooty Buckskin and Seal Brown Dutch Warmblood is a great all round horse in all stats - plus you can get it early on in the game. Buell is even better - but obviously super late in the game. (2nd best horse overall IMO) Dark Bay Turkoman if you glitch the mission ins Chapter 3 is a brilliant horse (best looking in the entire game apart from maybe the Blood Bay Thoroughbred) but legit - you can only get in the Epilogue. Unless you decide to get the Gold one in Saint Denis for a lot of cash. Brindle Thoroughbred is a great horse, and you can get it early in Chapter 2 from a race / O'Driscoll ambushes. Super fast and unique coat. But if you have the PC version - the Reverse Dapple Thoroughbred is the only horse you will ever need! Plus it's free. Even if it wants to buck you off near any predator most of the time. Overall, the Silver Dapple Pinto Missouri Fox Trotter IMO... is the all round best in the entire game. When you consider looks, speed, getting around the map, stamina , gunfight combat and being around predators for hunting. It will still buck you off if you don't calm it - but mine never bucked me off for Cougar's which was better than basically all the other rivals to it (Turkoman, Arabian, Nokota etc) To me it is just better than the Arabian in every way. Plus you can get it in Chapter 2 from the Arcadia for Amateurs mission and TWO random events.
its funny, how in real life Morgans are considered the breed of horse that built this country if there is such thing, but the Morgan is dead last in terms of the game lol.
The white Arabian is easily my fav horse in the game. After it died in red dead redemption (the mission where Arthur dies) I was really sad, I told myself my new horse would carry her soul with every beat with their heart but it wasn’t making me feel much better. Then after trying to steal some other Arabians after thinking all three wild ones were dead (I had the warped and raspberry in stables) I searched up if the Arabians could respawn if they die, and they can. I was super happy and rode straight to lake Isabella and started looking. On about day three i was looking around in the mist and couldn’t find anything, I used eagle eye and looked into the mist when right near me was a bull moose (one of the rarest animals in the game). As I was looking at it I noticed the white Arabian was right in front of it! It was a beautiful sight indeed Whoever read all the way down here gets a cookie!!!!
I get the silver dapple mft beginning of chapter 2 use it up untill I can get the braithwhites dark bay Turkoman in chap 3 and I’m set. Turk, MFT, choc dutch warm blood and then blood bay Thoroughbred or Ardennes
With the exception of the Turkman, , Mustang, Arabian and Missouri Fox Trotter, all the other horses mentioned on video really sucks on stats. I got prove on this.
Missouri Fox Trotter for me, was my grandpas horse named Socks since he was Brown with white legs that look like socks. And I’m from Missouri so a no brainer.
I like the Arabian, but it’s just kind of small. I think Arthur looks a little goofy riding on it. And it’s too scared of everything for me to keep it around for more than a couple hours.
Yea I'd tamed it for nostalgia's sake (had a white Arabian toy as a kid) and then discovered it was beautiful but too small and skittish.
I like to keep an arabian just not as my main horse its more of a i own a fancy horse i can ride around when im bored as john 😂
I said the exact same thing myself. Beautiful horses but too small and they scare easily.
My personal favorites are the Dutch Warmblood, Missouri Foxtrotter, and the Turkoman.
I usually go get the white arabian just so I can beat that chick that challenges you in Lemoyne (2X). Afterwards, the speed boost is awarded and I switch horses to something braver, durable and has more stamina. The Arabians are good for speed and selling for money. That's about it.
Yeah it's too small, they are smaller horses but in the game they're ridiculous.
The Turkoman being a Race/War horse and having size with speed makes it the most special to me
It’s kinda OP because of that actually, which is why I’m kinda fond of it.
They need to add more coats
i like the turkomam but its c tier for me cause i make it go right and bro just runs around in circles because its so fuckin stubborn, i think the thoroughbred is far better but thats just my experience
its not race/war if i am not wrong its war/work
@@SinghPratyush10 Your wrong.
War horses were always my favorite bc they can get through the swamps without kicking me off and leaving me for the gators, great video
Lost count of how many times you said “StaNima” haha
I thought it was “Stama” 😂
The only 2 things I hate about the Arabian horses are how tiny they are compared to all the other horses in the game and how often they start freaking out over nothing
Appaloosas are so underrated. The leopard Appaloosa not only have great health and stamina but they can actually reach a max speed of seven when you complete all the race challenges plus the stable upgrades.
I got a ad for the local horse races god CZcams knew what they were doing.
stanima is making me so maf
Me too
@@PerkaSet lol
The Turkoman is easily one of my favourites, I was actually able to get one for free in chapter 3 and used it for through the rest of the game and I got no regrets. For those you want to no you can get it from the Braithwates when you go to steal there horses, all you gotta is make it your temporary horse before handing it over to the weird twins and then just pick it up after the cut scene (look on CZcams for a tutorial)
Who didn't know you both were going to give the Arabians high marks? The Thoroughbreds are caught throughout the game as are the Arabians. Put em next to one another in game. The Thoroughbreds are better than the small Arabians for mine and most other gamers. (I saw much larger Arabians in real life) Imo, Rockstar added the thoroubred horse so anyone with a little game time could have the best all-around horse. Btw i do not pay for any horse in this game. Theres always a way to either catch or steal them for Arthur. Online would be much better if they were not so tightly wound imo.
Dutch was given the Arabian because he does not use it the way Arthur uses horses imo. The Arabians are good for 3 things, though. (imo anyway) they are fun leveling to 4, and they are good to sell for $ ( can be done over and over). 3rd if you like a sorta a very small horse and dont hunt much theyll get ya from a to b in a good time with good handling. So I use them in chapter 2 for some treasure hunts.
Very easy to catch them. I agree with your Andalusian roundoff, but I catch the Pearlina at will fairly easily. So, dudes, they are not hard to find. That horse also spooks easier than a thouroghbred even though they are war horses. For a no-nonsense large war horse, I think the Turkoman, but you gotta stick with them for a while like one of you said he did with Big Shire. Btw that's a great horse. Not my long term choice but yaeh, good one. Turkoman...Stats are as good as the best but they are programmed to learn slower imo. Very nice large slender horse. They will let you know when any enemy animal or NPC is near. The differences in the horses are also sensitivity. The Turkoman is almost overstrung but used long term becomes a great horse in this game. Just not a speedster, but fast enough.
After using these horses in this game and riding them well past full leveling I always come back to the thouroughbreds and Turkomans. The brindle is the hardest of the Tbeds to find free but well worth price if you decide to buy at Strawberry stable for 450 bucs? She is awesome. I just don't like buying horses even when im on allot of cash. . I did ride the spotted appaloosa for 3 chapters once though. Lol. I enjoyed the horse. I catch them from time to time to haul extra larger pelts for me. i do not bond just break keep close. Toss a rope on if I am headed back to Trapper or Pierson. I do this with others too. If you let them bond, they become your temporary horse which is fine if you dont have a temporary but if you do, you'll lose the temp you have in camp. I keep stables full, then one temp in camp and ride one. Either my favorite or one I'm leveling to sell. Btw you two left a very important horse out of your video. (The American Standardbred.) ( Also mentioning GTA in you RDR vid is sort of a tell why one of you picks the horses that he believes are prettier and faster.) Dudes, I love cool cars but horses are so different than cars.. ima older guy in time on Esrt fir a human lol. Rode horses when I was young. Loved them. It's a bit more than game to say the least. Horses have more minds of there own in general, and, in reality. With that, they can be very similar also. Rockstar really did well with the horses IMHO. I Love cars too. And I don't drive a truck. Lol no I've had American built hot rods since the 70s. cars built from 37 chev to a modern SRT challenger.
So many in between. Not a brag dudes. A tell. Back on topic..
American Standardbreds are Pretty close to Thoroughbreds. Maybe, not quite as good. But they are race handling and will bond very well. In (online game) I ride a thoroughbred and a Standardbred. Colors of Standardbreds are cool. The only all black horse in the game i know of is an Americans Standardbred, tall race horse. They have size speed and bond well.
(Off topic a bit) If your having a bit of trouble with a horse, you like? Put it in camp as your temp after leveling and past top.. idk but seems to me horses are a little better when left in camp while Arthur rides out on another horse continually. I know, very unlikely in programming... right? Try it..thanks for vid. Overall very cool.. but breaking these horse down like this? Idk dudes, its personal for certain and you take good note of that fact.
I don‘t get why everyone loves the arabians. First of all the coats are pretty boring. They will buck you off as soon as they see any possible danger. They are small as hell which makes them look really goofy. They only have good speed and stats and I think stats only tell half the story. There are so many horses I prefer to an arabian. I only had one in my first playthrough and after that never again.
I would say in my opinion, the Fox Trotter overall is better than the Arabian if you build your saddle right. It Also won’t run off as often as the Arabian.
The St.Enema of the horses is important 😂
Some horses are just too small for Arthur. Morgan, Nokota, Mustang, and Arabian. He just looks silly on them.
I really can't rank them all because I have little experience with most of them.
In my first playthrough I ran with a Black Tennessee Walker, and when playing with John, I bought the Gold Turkoman and fell on love with this breed. Been using it ever since.
You can actually get a Dark Bay Turkoman from the mission where you stole the Braithwait horses in Chapter 3, all you have to do is feed the horse before finishing the mission, until you get level 1 bonding and the temporary horse icon shows up on the map. It is pretty arduous, you must have a lot of horse food on your inventory because takes a little time, but it is totally worth to get a horse you're only supposed to get in the Epilogue, all the way back in Chapter 3.
It’s pretty difficult for me to rank my favorite horses, because a good number of them I didn’t bother using. I’m a bigger horses type of guy: so like the Dutch Warmblood, Ardennes, and Turkoman come to mind.
Horses like the Belgian Draft and Shire however, I’ve never really liked the idea of using so they won’t be included.
As another note, everyone’s perfect horses is different as some prefer faster horses while others like the bigger bulkier ones better.
Oh, and please search up how to pronounce some of the horse names better because that was kind of embarrassing.(just saying)
I’ll only rank the horses I’ve used extensively, but again a great deal of others I never used for one reason or another.
2 honorable mentions: The Mustang and Hungarian HalfBred I consider to be underrated. Both Great War/Work horses that served me well, I just haven’t used them that much.
5. Andalusian: When it came time to unlock the stables, I’d often go to brandywine Drop to pick up the Perlino Andalusian. Andalusians in general are great horses for hunting, gun fights and are very brave around predators making it easier to hunt big game. They’re also pretty attractive in their coats. It’s a great early option for a strong war horse and I just have wonderful memories of having it as my main mount.
4. Turkoman: Another fantastic strong war horse. I give it the edge over the Andalusian because of its better speed stats, and I’ll mention they’re both equally great for what their worth. Sometimes however, the Turkoman feels more race than war because there were times were it could easily stand up to a bunch of wolfs until til the next time it couldn’t stand down before bucking me.
I guess I’ll say I’m kinda tied with the Andalusian and Turkoman actually, but I like them both.
3. Dutch Warmblood: A solid earlier game option as a giant, tall, versatile work horse. Apparently they can chase off small herds of wolfs because of their sheer size and resilience! These horses have good bravery and all around stats, my favorite coat/variant is the Cremello Gold Dutch Warmblood named Buell from Hamish, then the Chocolate Roan.
But yeah, very solid horse with great versatility that never disappoints me.
2. Ardennes: What can I say about it?? It’s so muscular, has a monstrously sounding voice and is a literal tank of a horse!! The hulk of all horses if you ask me. I don’t mind it’s low speed stats because of it’s high stamina and huge health pool, plus they’re perfect in gun fights because they don’t agitate and just about nothing can scare them off.(although the Andalusian and Hungarian Halfbred rival it in bravery) but overall, the Ardennes is my favorite big horse.
1. Missouri Fox Trotter: Quite possibly the greatest horse in the game! Has the highest speed stat, they preform greatly in races, have excellent health and stamina etc. this is the horse I’ve been spending the most time with as of late, as thanks to the Albert Mason MFT glitch I can get the Silver Dapple Pinto as Arthur as early as Chapter 2!
It has reasonable bravery even if some horses are better in that category, and that SDP coat is gorgeous!
Love this horse, it might be my all time favorite at this point.
shire because i like ramming into people
My #2 would absolutely be turkoman right behind Arabian. By chapter 4 you’ve done the valentine heist and maybe explored and gotten some gold bars to sell so you definitely could afford 1000 on a horse especially because horses are such a big part of the experience. And I just really like the thing. I remember buying and loving the gold one when I got to Saint Denis it was awesome
You could just steal it or any horse for that matter from any stable instead of buying it.
super late comment but I pretty much agree with you both on your list based on stats and handling and stuff like that and its a difficult list to do because some horse coats are great even if its a breed that at first seems pretty meh or bad. For example the Adalusian is a solid horse but the Perlino coat is an absolute monster when its at max level I think it has 10 health and 8 stamina while being very stout and not easy to spook also it looks absolutely beautiful. It would be really cool if you both do a ranking of horses breeds in terms of looks and coats excluding stats and temperment etc. If thats the case Ethan's choice of the Shire at 3 is a very very good one.
As someone who hunts more than does bounties or gunfights with gangs, the war horses are amazing. I used the Hungarian Half Bred before switching to the Ardennes and it's an underrated horse (Hungarian). Both HHB and the Ardennes are absolute units and great around big game/predators; was not bucked off once. Other than them, I'm using a Turkoman currently and looking forward to trying Buell towards the end of the game.
You can get the brown Turkoman for free during the Chapter 3 mission “Horse Flesh for Dinner.” Do the mission, but right before meeting the fence, stop and feed, brush, and pet him until he becomes your temporary horse. After the cutscene, you’re back at camp, but still close enough to get to him.
liked the Andalusian and kept it for the whole game because i like hunting and this thing just casually trots near alligators.
Honestly i love ur channel guys ! I wish you the best of luck in ur youtube journey
Thank you we appreciate it so much!
Learning just how little the difference between the bottom speed of an unsaddled Morgan and a 10 speed Thoroughbred...speed doesn't matter. Acceleration and courage are the most important things. That said, in my personal experience, my Turkoman is a bratty coward while the Arabian didn't dump me instantly when spotting a cougar.
It’s cool to see two different play styles
Arabian......absolutely not lol. When I got it my first playthrough at relase, rode it for 5 minutes and sold it. Just mediocre and skittish as hell.
Played one time with an Arabian...never again. First place is a toss up between the Fox Trotter and Turkoman for me. Usually have both at my stable at one point. Remaining places go to sturdy horses preferably with great stamina.
Honestly, no, the Arabian is just not the best. It kinda sucks. I mean yeah, it's pretty and fast but that's kinda all it's got going for it. In my game experence, the Arabian is incredibly skittish where the opposite is very essential; you're gonna come across many predators, gunfights and ambushes where you need a horse that can handle that. Taking this horse hunting is not ideal either mainly because of the wild animals but also because it freaks out just after a few gunshots.
Stats wise, the Arabian is fantastic, and the sell price is great too, if you snatch the black one from Saint Denis. I have tried to like it and ride it, but I just can't... I absolutely hate how small it is, it feels so unrealistic for Arthur and John to ride.
For me, the perfect horse is something like the Missouri Fox Trotter or the Thoroughbred. I value speed and stamina statwise, but I also want a horse that doesn't freak out easily. A huge factor for me is also what I'm gonna be looking at psysically while playing, aka the size of the horse. As mentioned, the Arabian being so small is just an eyesore for me😅
Ironically enough I spent a lot of time with the Appaloosa while playing as Arthur! It's not super fast, but the stamina is great and it was surprisingly brave. The Arabian had a harder time aproaching crocodiles than the Appaloosa.
I got the Belgium Draft bc I didn’t realize how super slow it was bc it had been awhile since I was familiar with the game and I had forgot lol
If I'm looking to do story mode stuff, I'm using the Missouri Fox Trotter. Great horse. If I'm just roaming around the map, hunting, or whatever and I don't care about stats? My favorite horse is the American Standardbred that you can get from Valentine. Beautiful horse.
Tiger striped mustang is hands down my personal favorite which I get in chapter 4. Beast of a horse compared to the rest!
how you get it?
@@batmann3445 there's a guide to get it early chapter 2 using the buggy method here on CZcams. It's hard but possible as I've done it. Best wishes
thanks
Dutch Warmblood for me every time. If we're comparing horses to cars, then the DW is an F250 or F350. Not super fast (the one from Valentine Stables tops at 7) but they're meant for work and won't throw you off when next to a snake. A cougar or bear is a different story though.
Stanima??
The shire is badass!!
It's amazing how similar most horses are that it's just up to what you like best. Personally I prefer the larger horses, but not the biggest tanks - Andalusian, Dutch Warmblood, Thoroughbred, Turkoman easily my favorites. Also considering an Arabian beats a Morgan across the map in 1 minute, overall speed really doesn't matter to me.
A thing is that in story mode the Mustangs are average but in online they’re better than arabians
I wonder what the deal with that is, why did they make the most mid horse breed ever in story mode literally have Rose Grey Bay Arabian level stats in online
I just found a wild Andulusian west of Annesburg. I was previously riding an Appaloosa and it’s like night and day.
Nice video! But I think you guys forgot the American standard, personally I'd put it at #2 because it's one of those horses that you buy in chapter 2 and stick with it until you either find an Arabian or Buell from the veteran missions:)
Glad to see some love for thoroughbred
speed is not rly a thing in this game. Over short distances, the difference is gonna be max 5 seconds between the slowest and the fastest horse. What rly matters is stamina which you need to make long distance trips aswell as health
Nice list! Did you guys forget the American standardbred?
that's my favorite horse bro
For the turkoman you can get the black turkoman for free in the chapter 3 Braithwaite glitch
I like the only horse you cant find in the wild (ofc) its the one deleted Hungarian halfbred. Cant remember the name exactly but its what Boadicea used to be.
Where does the American standardbred rank on the list? I found a black coat with great stats chapter 1
I used the brown and white one you can buy from the stable at the start of the game idk if this is just me but in my experience it’s the bravest of the race horses idk if that’s actually the case in game tho
My top picks based on stats are from 5 to 1:
1. Norfolk Roadster
2. Arabian
3. Missouri Fox Trotter or Criollo ( both on same spot lol due to same stats)
4.Mustang (at 4 bonding with Nakodoge Saddle they have full health and Stamina, 9 bars of speed and 7 bars on acceleration)
5. Gypsy Cob (beautiful horse and at 4 bonding with Nakodoge saddle they have full health and stamina with 8 bars on speed and 7 acceleration) note: they are brave against animals.
I only have horses that i find in the wild, steal or get given, ive played the game multiple times and the only horse ive ever bought from a stable is $15 morgan at the beginning of chapter 2
Get high honor and buy any high priced horse for about $450 to $550. Ride the horse to level 4 bonding and sell the horse for about a $1000 dollars. If you're in the epilogue the Blackwater Arabian will make the most money with this method.
The arabian is just a classic horse I remember I got the one from the couple in saint denis by accident and used it all the game
I have the black Shire since the beginning chapter 2 and I love this horse he's big handles well and has enough speed for my likeing he'll take alot of punishment so that's why I take him hunting along with a stolen pack horse with a saddle for carrying carcasses. If I get the Ardennes as well I'll be very happy 😊
The black arbian has more health and stamina and is the same speed, so it's better than the white one imo
lol I never had to spend a dime for my MFT, you can get the beautiful Silver Dapple Pinto as early as Chapter 2 from the Albert Mason mission.
The Raven Black Shire that you get for free - doesn't even buck you off when around Alligators or Grizzly Bears! It is totally fearless
So when you are doing hunting for all Trapper outfits / LOE Satchel etc. It is very helpful - just very slow.
Piebald Tobiano Hungarian Halfbred is the same - another absolute beast , even better than the above as it has better stamina and speed starts. It is just hard to get a hold of (you get a free one on the way back from Guarma or get it from Bounty Hunters)
Probably my third favourite overall in the game.
You can steal Wrobel's horse however if you want a similar horse early (it is the Dapple Dark Grey and a very good looking coat)
Chocolate Roan / Sooty Buckskin and Seal Brown Dutch Warmblood is a great all round horse in all stats - plus you can get it early on in the game.
Buell is even better - but obviously super late in the game. (2nd best horse overall IMO)
Dark Bay Turkoman if you glitch the mission ins Chapter 3 is a brilliant horse (best looking in the entire game apart from maybe the Blood Bay Thoroughbred) but legit - you can only get in the Epilogue. Unless you decide to get the Gold one in Saint Denis for a lot of cash.
Brindle Thoroughbred is a great horse, and you can get it early in Chapter 2 from a race / O'Driscoll ambushes.
Super fast and unique coat.
But if you have the PC version - the Reverse Dapple Thoroughbred is the only horse you will ever need! Plus it's free.
Even if it wants to buck you off near any predator most of the time.
Overall, the Silver Dapple Pinto Missouri Fox Trotter IMO... is the all round best in the entire game.
When you consider looks, speed, getting around the map, stamina , gunfight combat and being around predators for hunting.
It will still buck you off if you don't calm it - but mine never bucked me off for Cougar's which was better than basically all the other rivals to it (Turkoman, Arabian, Nokota etc)
To me it is just better than the Arabian in every way.
Plus you can get it in Chapter 2 from the Arcadia for Amateurs mission and TWO random events.
You guys made it, Thank you man 🙌❤️
stop saying stanima its STAMINA.
Did you guys mention the American Standardbreed?
Dark Bay Turkoman until I die ✊
Can’t beat it
I usually go for Mustangs in the game as Arthur, but as John, I usually go for buell.
Arabians are way over rated compared to some of the larger, more health and stamina horses.
Silver Dapple Pinto Foxtrotter for the win... hands down.
6:04 what happened there (in the audio)
I love the MFT tho
Buell is the BEST horse in the game
My favorite is the mustang just for the looks.
Why is American Standardbreed not in here
Yup that’s my third favorite horse in the game.
Thanks guys...Stamina...not Stanima...just saying...😅
"Stanima" omg... every time. I hope its bait lol bc that's silly.
i have the black arabian and it’s just a fantastic horse
Bro can’t stop saying staNiMa
U guys didnt even rank the American Standardbred ???? The only all black beauty race horse thats in the game..... Come on now
I honestly like the fox trotter just because of the name as well
its funny, how in real life Morgans are considered the breed of horse that built this country if there is such thing, but the Morgan is dead last in terms of the game lol.
Arabian before fox trotter is insane
I like horses with Stanima 😅
What do u mean it doesn't have a unique coat 5:05
Arabian the best horse breed in the game.
6:02 how do you spin your guns like that?
The white Arabian is easily my fav horse in the game. After it died in red dead redemption (the mission where Arthur dies) I was really sad, I told myself my new horse would carry her soul with every beat with their heart but it wasn’t making me feel much better. Then after trying to steal some other Arabians after thinking all three wild ones were dead (I had the warped and raspberry in stables) I searched up if the Arabians could respawn if they die, and they can. I was super happy and rode straight to lake Isabella and started looking. On about day three i was looking around in the mist and couldn’t find anything, I used eagle eye and looked into the mist when right near me was a bull moose (one of the rarest animals in the game). As I was looking at it I noticed the white Arabian was right in front of it! It was a beautiful sight indeed
Whoever read all the way down here gets a cookie!!!!
Nakota for me Fast and nimble and great…(say it with me) Sta-Mi-Na
I get the silver dapple mft beginning of chapter 2 use it up untill I can get the braithwhites dark bay Turkoman in chap 3 and I’m set. Turk, MFT, choc dutch warm blood and then blood bay Thoroughbred or Ardennes
i like light grey Shire so beautiful and elegant and brave , even better then my black arabian i think
Stanama?
nakota for turkoman? really? Race horse for war + race?
Ardennes is king
Is it me or is this dude saying “stanima”?
As usual the video as nothing to do with the topic at hand but it is rdr2, I’ll give you that…
wdym?
thoroughbred is best
Stanima?
What no American standard
With the exception of the Turkman, , Mustang, Arabian and Missouri Fox Trotter, all the other horses mentioned on video really sucks on stats. I got prove on this.
bro kept saying stanima
Hey
For fucks sake: sta-MINA not
sta-NIMA
Missouri Fox Trotter for me, was my grandpas horse named Socks since he was Brown with white legs that look like socks. And I’m from Missouri so a no brainer.