Top 10 Plot Holes in And Just Like That
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 02. 2022
- And just like that, they threw out all continuity. For this list, we’ll be looking at plot holes and discrepancies from the revival that contradict scenes, moments, or character developments from the earlier parts of the “Sex and the City” franchise. Our countdown includes justice for Samantha, Charlotte's changed her tune, the degradation of Steve Brady, and more! Which "AJLT" inconsistency frustrated YOU the most? Let us know in the comments!
Watch more great "AJLT" videos here:
Top 10 Cringiest And Just Like That Moments - • Top 10 Cringiest And J...
Top 10 Sex and the City References in And Just Like That - • Top 10 Sex and the Cit...
Top 10 Times Samantha Deserved Better on Sex And The City - • Top 10 Times Samantha ...
Test your Trivia Power!
www.watchmojo.com/play/id/51659
Have Your Idea Become A Video!
wmojo.com/msmojo-suggest
Subscribe for more great content!
wmojo.com/msmojo-subscribe
MsMojo is a leading producer of reference online video content of Top 10 Lists, Origins, Biographies, Commentary and more on Pop Culture, Celebrity, Movies, Music, TV, Film, Video Games, Politics, News, Comics, Superheroes. Your trusted authority on ranking Pop Culture.
#AndJustLikeThat #SexAndTheCity #HBOMax #JusticeForSamantha #AJLT - Zábava
What plot inconsistencies did you notice in And Just Like That? Let us know below, and be sure to also watch our video of the Top 10 Cringiest And Just Like That Moments - czcams.com/video/SWUNJeI-gTE/video.html
Everything!!@
Didn't Aiden buy the apartment next door and do renos for Carrie? That might explain why her apartment looks bigger
Miranda is the biggest inconsistency in this show, her cheating with Che after she was cheated on, her not helping Carry, her letting her child have relations with someone in the house and letting that person live with them, the things I could let pass are her exploring her sexuality(even though she already did), now she's a boomer with white savior mentality and alcohol problems and blacks out
Agree with all of this!
Her exploring women seems weird after she made fun of samantha for having a girlfriend
And she not into women. I think that’s a big overlook. It would have made more sense for Samantha to have run off with/ well not Che but a woman
My sister had an ex-girlfriend who had been married with adult children and had previously never been with a woman until she met her in her mid 40s.
It does happen!
@@sarcasticallyrearranged that's why I said it is the only part I believe, I just don't think that she of all people would cheat
I also always got the sense that, at least early on, Samantha served as Carrie's publicist on a pro bono basis. I don't think Carrie could have afforded her when she wrote her first book. Considering that Samantha had global luxury hotels and celebs as clients, I don't think Carrie the driving force of Sam's firm's income.
You’re right, I remember Carrie mentioning right around the time that her book came out how she couldn’t afford Samantha’s services
Exactly!!! They just Samantha SO wrong
Probably why it hasn’t been renewed
Hi
L
@@angelface101ful They threw her under the bus
I seriously noticed a plot hole in a sense with Miranda dropping her internship to move to LA for someone else.. she shamed Carrie so badly for moving to Paris
Hell Yes! When Carrie moved to Paris for Alex and left everything behind, she was judged and criticized by Miranda. But in the revival, She does the same for Che and shifts to LA. This is not fair!!!!!!
She's a completely different character in this, and not a good one.
@@nineteenfortyeight6762 Miranda had a brain transplant without us knowing and it's called bad writing .
I don't think she SHAMED Carrie for moving to Paris. I think she was genuinely concerned that Carrie was giving up her whole life for Alexander. She was right and she was a good enough friend to SAY it.
In terms of Miranda, I feel like the writers tried to push this message that as long as you're exploring your sexuality, than having an affair is okay. It's not okay, cheating is cheating and Miranda seriously pissed me off in almost every scene she was in
The whole scene of her and Che in Carries kitchen when Carrie is laid up in bed on medication for her hip surgery PISSED ME OFF so bad!! Like what a shit friend! Carrie was far too nice to Miranda for that nonsense. Miranda became such a selfish jerk and I can't help but think of how mad she was when she hurt her back and called Carrie who sent Aiden (I think) which was crap of Carrie but Miranda's actions were so much worse
@@seannanana84 facts
Not going to lie Miranda in AJLT was more of a midlife crisis
Not to mention Che doesn’t sound worth it.
I think the writers are more concerned with an "inclusive" story than sticking with the original charm of the series.
And the truth it the original story wasn't inclusive, was never apologetic but remained very human like society. This new mess was all about embracing all this new culture and wokeness hoping to get new fans but offending us old loyal fans.
I remain with Season 6 ending (and I hoped they used the part where Carrie never ended with Big). Then kept her as a the single gal among the four. Even Sam deserved to be with Smith til the end.
I don't mind Miranda being bisexual, but she didn't need to cheat at all, and she could have had a proper conversation with Steve about her sexuality and wanting to explore it.
But instead Anthony would become hetero, everyone would be offended. 😑
@@joaquin224 Because its totally different.
Apparently she wasn't just a closet pansexual, but also a closet a$$hole.
And you just know if she did talk to Steve he would have been so supportive and accommodating
The whole reboot was inconsistent 😭
Miranda is gone, this is just cynthia nixon
Sadly
EXACTLY!!!!!!!
Wait, what’s wrong with Cynthia Nixon? Miranda used to be my favorite character but they’ve butchered her so bad
@@kimberlyhernandez2517the reason it was butchered was because cynthia nixon wanted to make miranda’s storyline a reflection of her own life. that’s why it is a very uncritical look at having an affair because they came out later in life - it’s exactly what happened to cynthia and she felt that she was 100% in the right to have an affair just because she was gay. hence her not aligning with miranda in season 1 with the softball player, or when miranda insulted sam for dating maria (harsher than anyone else might i add), or in the first movie when she talks about how terrible cheating is
If that's how Cynthia Nixon is in real life, she is not a good person
Another one for me is Stanford. I think the writers ruined his character completely, especially after what happened to Willie Garson! He would never just leave to go to Tokyo, especially without saying a proper goodbye to at least Carrie. They could have done something better to honour Willie.
My thoughts exactly. I was absolutely enraged by the way they butchered his character, Stanford would never in a million years do that. They could definitely give him a better farewell, it’s a slap in a face for poor Willie Garson, very disrespectful!
You're so right!!!
Also does anyone else remember how terribly mean Miranda in particular was to Samantha when she started dating Maria, and then she got pissed at Charlotte because she called her out for having an affair for not being supportive? What a hypocrite.
The Samantha and Maria issue is like the controversial episode when Carrie dated a younger but bisexual guy. Miranda, Charlotte and Carrie herself weren't openminded .
Yeah I believe the phrase was, “Poof you’re a lesbian? I forgot to tell you, I’m a fire hydrant.”
Right!? Her words exactly “you go to bed one morning and wake up the next and poof you’re a lesbian” she dragged Samantha for dating a woman so the fact that Miranda is having an affair with a woman now is infuriating
@@carlciulla6546 And Because Che doesn't identify as a woman , Miranda probably thinks in her twisted head that it makes it ok *smh* .
@@gemstar7286 does Che have female parts? Does Che have male parts? I’m a gay man, and I am looking at a FICTIONAL series from an outward perspective. Miranda bluntly made it extremely clear in the original series she was STRAIGHT she even said the words herself and talked about how she liked d!ck. Don’t come at me trying to put words in my mouth. I said what I said as a part of the LGBTQA+ community and also as a SATC fan of over 20+ years who has probably watched every season 20 times over. Miranda made it extremely clear she was a straight woman who loved Cis men, period.
They make being middle aged look like the worst thing ever. And SATC (from my understanding) made your 30s look as fun and exciting as your 20s just in a different way. I get that age has a new set of challenges, but SATC was able to handle tough things about your 30s too while still being generally light hearted. The show was honestly just depressing.
Seriously did the makers of this show not see The Golden Girls. That was a brilliant portrayal of middle aged women enjoying life.
They did make things seem pretty damn bleak but I sorta gave them a break since the pandemic and the world in general are pretty damn bleak right now (they talked about the pandemic, about the problems in the US Senate, and about the racial justice movement). But still - the show is a bit too sad city.
@@uelueluesue I totally get that, but also I want TV to be more about escapism. I feel like they would have been better off not mentioning the pandemic because it is technically still ongoing but they acted as though it was over - I mean in all of SATC they didn’t once bring up 9/11 despite living in NYC during it so it’s not like they haven’t ignored large scale and depressing current events. It just feels like most TV shows that have been coming out recently feel the need to be depressing because the world is and it’s kind of exhausting and I didn’t expect it from this series. They were able to handle things like cancer, infidelity, parents dying, and divorce in SATC without making the show super depressing before but there was nothing in this show that didn’t come off as depressing, cringy, or preachy to me.
@@noel2223 The pandemic stuff was so awkward. "Hey! Remember when everyone was wearing masks. Wow that was a weird time!" -- meanwhile, everyone is STILL wearing masks. They should have just pretended it didn't happen.
@@TomWDW1 literally. Every show I have seen that mentions the pandemic is just off. Like the only show that did it and it was okay was You where Joe made a joke about the wealthy getting early vaccines but even then it probably would have been easier to just ignore the pandemic and make that same point in a different way.
tbh im glad kim didn’t participate in this
Miranda was one of my faves, I’m all for character changing/growth but not in a blink of an eye to the point where idk the character at all
Same! I loved Miranda and I loved Steve for her. This update just didn't work for me.
The biggest shock was her saying she was never happy in her marriage.
@@mayln163 it wasn't really a shock, she was like that the entire series
@@nataluxx7312 I would’ve been fine with a divorce plot line because they fell out of love or whatever or even her discovering her sexuality, but her cheating after her resenting Steve for cheating was her main personality trait of the first movie was dumb and annoying. She made it so her friends couldn’t criticize her having an affair because she came out when that was never the problem anyone had in this series
@@mayln163 Yes, really bad writing, it goes against everything we were previously told about the relationship.
I fully agree with Steve being degraded! Like the actor did a wonderful job but his character isn’t like that at all.
Maybe Carrie reached out to the purse thief and told him her husband is dead and he finally returned the Baguette.
LOL. Maybe!
Lol 🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣
Best comment ever!! Lol
Had no idea he died, did she ever mention it ? 🤔
The biggest fail is how they wrote out Samantha. She was the best and most loyal friend out of all of them. At some point, everyone of them judged her for being sexually liberal. She always had their backs no matter what. A better exit would have been is that she just simply outgrew the friendship. By the second movie, 3 of them were married and 2 of them had children. Samantha was still living the single life. She was no longer in the same place as them. I feel like they didn't deserve Samantha's friendship cause they all looked down on her when she was the most confident and knew exactly who she was and what she wanted.
The guy that stole it was Che's brother or cousin. And then Carrie saw it one time at the podcast and stole it back. And just like that...she got her purse back.
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Just felt as though they had to tick off a massive checklist and formed plots around them. Not great
Yes agree
That’s ABSOLUTELY what they did. And so this is what you get when your motivation is not having artistic integrity but crafting story lines all in the name of “diversity”. So, yes, the checklist tries to desperately cover the racial, gender, and sexual orientation map. It’s obvious the show casting call was: Hispanic, Asian, Middle Eastern, black, gay, trans, self identify. And in addition to that, of course the original cast of white characters all have to look like bumbling idiots apologizing for their whiteness. They even tried to slip in a few “pandemic” references in the show! Come on! People watch television to escape reality, not be reminded of it!
They had plot points, just no way to connect them
The apartment not being decorated anymore drove me NUTS this whole season. They made so much mention in the first movie about her 'paying the fancy decorator' and having the apartment completely redone. No one in their right mind would ever get rid of a redecoration like they did with AJLT. This plot hole was beyond annoying.
There's so much that I can say, but I'll stick with Miranda. BTW, David Eigenburg did the best bit of acting in the whole AJLT series when Miranda told him that she wanted a divorce. IMO, he was very realistic. So, did you notice how offended and angry Miranda was when Carrie challenged Miranda's choice to be with Che? Go back to 2004 to the second to the last episode of SATC series. Miranda give Carrie the same crap about Carrie going to Paris to be with Aleksandr Petrovsky, played by the yummy Mikhail Baryshnikov. Carrie got angry and yelled at Miranda that she wasn't going to stay in NYC to be single for her. That was when all of the women did have husbands/boyfriends. The Manolo Blahnik is on the other foot. I wonder if there has been enough backlash about this poorly written reboot that all cast will just take the millions that they earned and call it a day.
I definitely got flashbacks to the Petrovsky/Paris fiasco and wondered why the show didn’t acknowledge that! Glad other people noticed though!
Biggest inconsistency?
SATC - good.
Ajlt - crap.
🤣🤣🤣Well said
I’m not watching because I knew this reboot would be a mess. Plus my fav character (Samantha) is missing. Not sure why they thought this reboot was a good idea. Kim Cattrall dodged a bullet.
And it feels like LTW & Seema are being forced as a merged copy as the new Samantha .
This reboot is a pathetic, awful mess that I refuse to watch. But these Ms Mojo videos are entertaining and addictive so best believe I am watching every single one of them ☺️😍😂.
Hahaha, thanks Daniel!
@@MsMojo OMG YOU GUYS ARE THE BEST🥰
@@MsMojo do everyone a favor a do more Golden Girls. That'll make things better
@@frankieseward8667 I originally joked with my friend “And Just Like That” was a reboot of “The Golden Girls” but after the third episode I felt awful for saying it. Blanch, Dorthy, Rose & Sofia deserve better than MPK & SJP makeover.
Everything else aside, the butchering of Miranda’s cynical and no BS character was unforgivable and so cringey. And poor Steve! And then they had the audacity to make a meta comment of it all through an “I’m allowed to change” hair-gag in the final episode… 👎🏻
I think we can all agree And just like that, sucks! There was no reason to bring it back. Kim was done after the second movie, which didn't need to be made, and it should have ended there.
Also, we all knew carrie was a crap friend, how she even has friends is mind-boggling.
I only watched because Samantha Irby was attached to the show as a writer. Love Irby but I can't continue with this show.
Wait... People like Samantha Irby? I thought she was hated 🤔
The fact that there even *is* 10... feel like that says plenty about the writing of this show
I don't think it's the fact that there are ten... it's the fact that this is a top ten out of all the other inconsistencies
A lot of this was desperate reaching and attempt to get clicks… well I fell for it, never again 👎🏾
Miranda also said when she kissed a woman I think in season 1, that she definitely wasn’t a lesbian, I know it can happen but it seems too out of character for her suddenly to be with another woman. The cheating when she lambasted Steve for Doing it then does but never says and keeps doing it such a major hypocrite
Miranda was probably the -meanest- when Samantha started dating Maria "What? she just woke up one day and said 'poof, I'm a lesbian'? Okay, fine. Poof, I'm a fire hydrant!"
And she screamed at Steve and didn't talk to him for nearly a year when he cheated once. Meanwhile, she was basically having a relationship with Che before she told him.
Nothing about her character this season made sense.
To be fair Che doesn't identify as a woman they identify as non binary so it's not quite the same but sexualities aren't concrete and I'm bisexual and don't connect with every person I kiss, heck I didn't realize I was bi for a while because I had no chemistry or desire for a few women I kissed. My problem is how love struck and foolish she was after hooking up with Che.
Che can call herself they, or he, or it, or unicorn. But she is a woman.
I think they were trying to queer up Miranda because the actress who plays her is gay.
Well, she could’ve repurchased the bag somehow.
Anyhow, about Steve- my husband said they need to give him a gorgeous girlfriend that deserves him. And I agree.
Do y'all not remember that when she was with Aiden he had bought the apartment next door and was making renovation plans to expand the apartment to double the size. It makes sense that once Carrie marries Big she's stupid rich and she can do whatever she want thus making the apartment bigger would not be a problem.
haha that's what I said. Didn't Aidan knock down a wall?
@@kyleebristow6223 he started but never finished but for all we know she could have knocked it down herself
The wall was just a metaphor for breaking up with Aiden. But after the break up she did get contractors to finish the build out because in the movies her apartment is complete.
Miranda's wig was inconsistent throughout the reboot!
first, what a steaming pile.
and just like that, thats about it.
This show is full of inconsistencies. Its like the writers did not watch Sex and the City 😂
It feels like a bunch of kids wrote AJLT
1. Let's not forget that in the series, Charlotte says she rims Trey. Not even Sam does that.
2. How Miranda got super upset & unsupportive when Carrie moved to Paris w/the Russian but then does the same thing w/Che & LA.
3. On the podcast, Carrie says she wins worst breakup via Big's death but doesn't bring up the Post-it.
4. I guess it was Miranda who bought herself the book?
Thank you!! Factssss! I was coming here to call out 1 & 2 only true fans know.
And also the actor whose name escapes me played 2 different roles in 2 different seasons. He was the writer who Carrie flirted with in the first season to make Big jealous and he came back as Vaughn the short story writer with the inability to last long enough in the bedroom.
@@99kdaniel it's Justin Theroux
I now hate Miranda with a passion. How did the fendi bag get rated higher than what was done to Steve? I’ll tell you what, if the show had been good, no one would care about that bag. It would have simply been regarded as a delightful little Easter egg. But it sucks so it ends up being just one more dumb thing. The biggest inconsistency? Sex in the City was a good show. And Just Like that might be the worst show I’ve ever forced myself to sit through. I had pretty low expectations because of the second movie. But these writers have outdone themselves. Possibly the worlds most remarkable garbage.
Uhhh...the biggest plot inconsistency is Samantha living in London. She would not be living where's it cold and foggy, the men are more uptight, and she has none of her best girlfriends with her, especially at her age. She left the sweetest and hottest guy she ever knew, Smith, because she was bored and lonely in L.A. and wanted to be back with her friends in NY. There's just no way Samantha would be living in London. It's ridiculous.
What they did to Steve Brady is the worse offense, Miranda is outside ready to run off with her Binary and she & her son are only concerned with her new hair color, truly reprehensible.
Spot on about Miranda's character assassination, and how they did her and Steve's relationship dirty...very dirty. It can't really ever be forgiven. As for the bag, there is such a thing as ebay, and Carrie has done well for herself over the years. Not hard to believe that she would have connections, and been able to find a replacement for the bag, shoes...and even the shoes Pete ate in Season 4! So not necessarily a plot hole there. Also, I didn't notice Carrie's apartment being bigger, and I'm usually pretty good at noticing stuff like that. However, the hideous flower wallpaper needs to go.
Idk why people are so concerned with Charlotte saying she didn’t like to do oral then being okay with it with her husband 20+ years later lol. She’s made it clear she loves Harry a lot; I can see that being something she’d be happy to do so long as she loves the person. She’s a “people pleaser” lmao. Plus, it was just *one* scene from the first season over 20 years ago - it wasn’t some reacquiring thing where she always talked about how much she hated oral, lol.
She did pretty wild stuff with Trey too when they were married. I think she's able to compromise on certains things or maybe she enjoys it with him.
Not liking a thing with an ex or a random hookups doesn't mean you'll hate it too with your husband of 20 years. She didn't seemed like she was hating it when she was starting lol.
@@ayeurieleo7650 yeah, didn’t she also say in the original that she ate her husband’s (Trey’s) ass and stuff and had no qualms about it? Like, it even kinda shocked Samantha? I can believe that Charlotte is maybe somewhat a prude if it’s a ~hookup~ lol, *but* if she’s married and in love she will do whatever she and her husband want. So maybe she hated it before, but she and Harry have been together for 20 years…. - I don’t have to suspend my disbelief that hard in order to believe they worked on that together lmao. In fact that seems quite normal.
@@CarlDillynson You are right about the butt stuff.
I agree with you; Charlotte's only a prude for boyfriends and hookups, but she was very open with Trey and even Harry.
Like you said, it's normal. It's actually very nice that they have a good relation together about sexuality.
And let's not forget that it's ok to change opinions and to start liking or disliking things with time. It was a clip from season 1, we are 24 years later! Of course she may have a different opinion.
Exactly I think they just wanted to include something about Charlotte tbh
TMI but I literally hated it with my first serious boyfriend and felt like it was a chore, but with the last guy I dated I was completely ok with it and would initiate it. That change seems realistic to me especially since Charlotte still is very much in love with Harry. I actually thought the breakfast exchange with her and Carrie and Miranda was the one scene that felt like the old show. Also Charlotte was the one character that didn't drive me bonkers in the reboot because even when she was annoying it was still the character I watched in the original series and movies. They made Carries whole personality about Big (again/still which I get it he's dead so she needed to mourn and refind herself) and Miranda is just a mess and nothing like who she was so it's depressing
Besides Samantha, Miranda was the only person in a interracial relationship and then she goes back to school and she’s shocked the professor was black and has braids idk that was super weird to me. Her character is from Philly, lives in Brooklyn and she dated a black doctor for the Knicks in season 5 or 6.
This could of been a top 100
The entire reboot was inconsistent from start thru finish. I could find nothing entertaining or funny about it and kept hoping it might improve, but it never did.
I would love to know what happened to the Black diamond ring Big gave Carrie in the second movie.
I kept my eyes on Carrie's hands for 2 episodes, not z glimpse of that gorgeous ring.
In the book summer in the city Samantha helped Carrie when she was evicted and helped her get a rent controlled apertment.
One thing that has bothered me is that, in OGSATC, Carrie’s apartment was made with an entrance to the bathroom from her bedroom and the front door. So, how did she end up seeing Miranda and Che in the kitchen while she was in bed?
Crushing Steve is really sad, too!
If you're wondering what destroyed the characters and the show...it's political correctness. The original was edgy and provocative. That's why it was fun. 15 years later and we regressed. We can't do that anymore because of the twitter backlash it would cause. They're trying to showcase every possible thing (like race, sexuality, social problems) that nowadays HAS to be included even if it makes no sense for the plot.
Well said xxxxx
I think the change in Miranda was because of Cynthia…
What about Lily’s age? At the end of season 6 set in 2004, Lily has already been born in China, but in And Just Like That, which had to be at least 2021 because the pandemic has already happened, it is stated she is 15!
I heard people say the same about Brady. He should at least be in college based off of the timeline of the original show.
YES!! Lilly and Brady's ages were completely inconsistent with the timelines of when they were born. The only one that was correct was Rock's.
We actually don't have a set timeline in universe in the original series, people just assume it's set as the same year as the seasons come out but we don't know. Season 6 came out in 2004 but in SATC universe the year it's unknown
@@valentinodemilch8935 actually we do have one! In an episode in season 2 where Carrie and Samantha are walking and talking about the old coot, she says “wake up, it’s 2000! The new millennium won’t be about …” (forgetting the exact line but the date sticks with me. They may have not mentioned dates a lot but this one officially sets a timeline. So does Carrie’s age and birthdays.
@@amandadecker6065 Yes she does said that but keep in mind people used that expression to referenced the new era “new millennium” through out the 2ks so it could be 2000-2010 and we don’t know season 6 year let’s say season 2 was exactly 2000 season 3 could be next year or two years later or maybe four months
Wow, Ms Mojo's hate watching of AJLT (just like everyone else)
That's not Miranda Hobbes, it's Cynthia Nixon 😆
I love how Miranda solved her alcohol problem in one afternoon hahaha
The only way I can see how the show justifies Miranda's cheating is by, "well, Steve cheated on Miranda, so it's ok for her to cheat on him. Now they're even." 🙄🤦🏻♀️
This show should have never been made. It is awful.
"More her her than an ATM?". Samantha intially offered her PR services for free and also offered to loan Carrie money when she almost lost her apartment.
That a BS way to explain her absence.
Fendi did rerelease the bag in 2018 or 19 and had SJP star in a commercial for it. So it kinda meta for it to appear
Surely there needs to have been a plot to have holes?
Hahaha. This is the comment of the day.
That man is 80?!?!? Wow he aged great
JUSTICE FOR STEVE!!!!!!
How about that time Miranda was setup with a woman on the baseball court , and later kissed her in the elevator, admitting she was definitely straight …
Regarding Charlotte, she changed her mind long before AJLT, when she was dating her first husband, she often did that
Didn't Aden buy the apartment next door, that's why her place is bigger, it's not beyond possibilities she bought another bag.
Thats what I've been saying! fendi famously re-released the bag and SJP was apart of the launch. It would be pretty obvious that rich carrie would re buy the bag that had been stolen from her.
It would be more realistic they say Samantha is now the PR head of the UK Royal Family than the crap they brought.
Yes, why couldn’t she just get a great job offer? People move without its being an indictment of their friendships all the time.
I may be mistaken but the Fendi baguette was re-released on the Fendi website.
I didn't watch the revival, and by the looks of it I don't think I will.
Yes, it was extremely shameful how they written out Sam's character, couldn't get rid of the bad taste
I Hope SJP, Patrick Richard King and Criss Darren see this, and then try to make a better storyline with the nezxt season of AJLT, if there is any, of course.
Miranda’s parenting is the biggest inconsistency for me. A kind, intelligent, thoughtful woman does not just let her teenager run amok and accept whatever happens like the chaos that is portrayed in the show. I believe she would have boundaries in her parenting that just aren’t there in the show. It felt difficult to reconcile with all we know about her.
This entire show is a plot inconsistency
What about the plot hole with Miranda already experimenting with being gay? She used that Sid/Syd woman in the series to impress her boss and kissed her in the elevator, and nothing. Now magically poof.... shes bisexual. They both agreed that she was definitely not a lesbian. It reeks of desperation on the writers parts to try to create a story for the character. It also strikes me as annoying that this storyline seems to mirror the actresses real life.
One of my friends has a theory about Samantha. The group wasn't her core group of her friends, so that friendship group was easy for her to let go of. I was considering watching the series, it was a show I watched with my mom (far too young, but oh well) but honestly, I don't like Carrie, I never have. Then they did my favorite character dirty (Samantha) and then I heard about the fuckery with Miranda and said absolutely not. I can't. I hate what they did to her character and I hate it even more because Cynthia Nix is defending it. Its bullshit. If she's busexual or pan or hell even a lesbian, then do it without the cheating. It's possible. As for Charlotte, I really just want to think that she matured and I agree that she is just that comfortable with her husband. As for the purse, after she married Big she had lots of money, I don't think it's outside the realm of possibility for her to have tracked one down and bought it.
The apartment was bigger because Aiden brought the apartment next door.
They broke up before he finished renovating it and he sold it after he asked Carrie if she wanted to buy him out. How ironic I just watched that episode Sunday.
@@feliciasmith1910 Maybe the apartment next door came up for sale over the past 20 years and they converted both into one apartment since she had all that Big money at that point $$
Definitely a much bigger place!
@@uelueluesue LMAO, I can only go by what was filmed in the episodes. This is imaginary after all.
7:11 The way I see it, it wasn't Samantha who was the shallow one. It was the other three, and they're just projecting by calling her the shallow one.
This character said something in 1998 and 24 years later said the opposite? What gives? Don’t people just stay the same throughout their entire lives? Come on …
Miranda acting like a lovesick teenager in AJLT was super cringe.
It might surprise some people but, if you really like a handbag and it happens to still be available, you can buy it again 🤦🏻♀️
A list of worst outfits from ‘And Just Like That’
Okay let me just say charlottes plastic surgery looks awful! She literally looks like Mickey Rourke.
Miranda's line is the biggest disappointment. The way their love with Steve was shown, how they were friends, supported each other, gave birth to a child, and after all that they realized how big their love. It was so beautiful. And now Miranda left everything after just saw Che on the stage, one conversation in a bar, and one sex at the kitchen. Seems like she is teenager who fall in love with a celebrity(
I’m just pretending this never happened. I liked the movies didn’t love them but they were ok. But Steve would have never cheated on Miranda. And Carrie would have never kissed Aiden after getting her whale Mr. Big. So this sh&$ never happened
Just throw the whole reboot away or bury it so it doesn’t see the light of day again. So many years invested in knowing the characters of this show to end up with this trash. One of the biggest disappointments since the final season of Game of Thrones.
Totally agree with all these! Well put re: Samantha.
Inconsistencies are probably open items to create more stories. Maybe...? :) love your videos
actually carrie bought the fendi baguette in the fendi commercial sarah jessica appeared in a couple years ago, so it's not really a plot hole.
If I remember correctly, Aiden bought the apartment next to Carrie's and "broke the wall", so basically, it's two apartments in one)
Didn’t they break up after he got close to breaking through that wall? Because she had to buy it back for what he bought hers for, not for both apartments I thought?
I think she had to buy the apartment he bought in order to stay in hers because they were one apartment now, maybe? Like buying out half of a house when you split up.
If I'm not mistaken.. I think Carrie's apartment got bigger since Aiden was able to expand it.
This. Is. Dead on. THANK YOU!!!
Fendi did a reissue of that baguette a couple of years ago to celebrate it’s 20th birthday. Perhaps she just bought it again.
The one thing I assumed from Carrie’s apartment was that she may have bought the place next door after all. I remember Aiden bought the place next door and was planning to combine the two. With the money Carrie now has, and her clear obsession with keeping her apartment, added to the fact she is now financially stable, would it be any surprise she bought the place next door after all? And what’s the big deal about Carrie having the same baguette where she was robbed? She loves that bag, and she’s financially stable enough to track down the exact same version of that baguette. And also, what are they supposed to say about Samantha? She died too?
To me, Miranda dating a non-binary person in her 50s isn’t shocking (I myself didn’t come to terms with my bisexuality until age 35) but it could have been handled so much better. To show no remorse for cheating with Che when Miranda knows how awful it feels to be cheated on, to saw she’s been unhappy in her marriage “since forever,” etc. She showed no compassion for her husband or for the person she was having an affair with.
Well, the Fendi Baguette with violet sequins is still available (currently for 3300 Euros); but it's the new model. So maybe she bought it again. This is not the biggest plot hole for me 🤷🏻♀️.
12:00 I haven't watched the new series but maybe Carrie went through with buying the neighbours apartment to make hers bigger, like she had planned to do with Aiden
This video is everything! I really admire how it concisely distills all of the various observations from CZcamsrs who are recapping the series! It pretty much reflects everything I thought while watching the show. At this point, I’m just going to pretend the reboot never happened. 😂
Also, what’s disappointing is that the cast and writers have been really defensive about any criticism and they really don’t get the legitimate complaints that people have.
You forgot the kids ages. Brady should be 19, Lily 16-17, and Rose 13. This really annoyed me.
Serious plot hole for Miranda also is the fact that she pretended to by in a relationship with a woman in the first season to try and get a promotion. After she comes clean, she attempts to make out with the woman in the elevator and both decide that she is straight. So then, why would she not only cheat on Steve but do it with a woman in the revival? And she called out Samantha for her relationship.
none of these are plotholes... theyre just bad writing.
The Fendi Baguette is not a plot hole. Carrie could have easily replaced that bag the same week it was stolen.. it was hardly a one of kind bespoke piece.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. I'm just Amazed.
Steve WOULD NEVER cheat on Miranda. HE’s been done dirty ever since. 🙄
3:32
When Aidan moved to her house he also bought the neightbour flat so they could be comfortable in the house
After watching the first episode and just like that they destroyed the franchise.
Mirabeau exploring her sexuality is fine. I have no problem with it. But while she's in a relationship not matter what you think you are or realise you are it's never alright to cheat. If I were in her situation I'd have at least have the heart to tell my husband about it. I hate the trope that bisexuals are cheaters. As a bisexual person myself that is far from the truth. It doesn't mean we cheat constantly ffs.
For the purple Fendi purse returning, I just assume she got really lucky and found another one on a designer resale website or store.