I do think she is holding back to save her voice from this long and tightly scheduled tour. Her vocal condition is excellent, she can easily hit that Eb5 in the climax imo.
@@huhyoucantstealmyjoy7420Holding back to save for what? She will not randomly sing this song or whatever else live towards the end of the tour. What you see here is what it will be on the last date. People say she is preserving her voice all the time, but she has been lipping most climaxes for the last 20 years, her voice should be in pristine condition cause she hasn’t actually sang anything taxing for years. People are confusing resting with laziness and I am saying that as a fan. If she was resting, and then sings every song live. Then the vocal routines and not speaking all day etc warrants the results. She isn’t preserving her voice, she just knows her instrument and knows that it is not consistent enough to even attempt the majority of songs live anymore.
@@SilentAssassin01234 who u comparing her to. She has nodules since day 1. You can’t compare her with those singers that don’t have nodules. Her voice kept changing during her absolute prime. I don’t sense anything wrong with her lipping most of the climaxes. They are much much harder than those in other people’s songs. It’s unrealistic for her to replicate climax in live performances.
@@huhyoucantstealmyjoy7420 I am comparing her to herself? Yes I know she has nodules, I legit know everything about her and I don’t expect her to replicate climaxes. But singers can improvise new melodies and dodges like she has done before. My point was more about how lambs say she is lipping to preserve her voice, but she isn’t preserving it for anything. She should have been preserving it for these shows, and maybe she has but what’s the point in doing that to sing one or two verses live every few songs. She has preserving her voice for 10 years lipping hard vocals, and it has no effect. The damage is done, rest won’t save it or improve it now. I am angry with fans who say she is saving her voice for the tour, that is just a bs excuse. The tour is now, she should be delivering. And she hasn’t had nodules from day one, you cannot be born with nodules. She developed them later in her childhood as a lot of children do. Mariah hasn’t sang anything vocally taxing live for 15 years. So these lambs that say her voice needs rest and to be saved for later shows are delusional.
the first half sounded soooo good! best in years. THE FLUIDITY?! that’s why i don’t get why she needs to pre-record the 2nd half. tho she seems happier than the first night
@@axeltimotheo2942 and she's back into her 2017's mode which is less movement and effortless for making the playback part look real🥺not like the previous Christmas show which is she's lipsinging like she's really mean it
It’s a big dilemma. She’s kinda forced to perform songs that she was able to sing effortlessly in her prime, 20-30 years ago. Obviously we can’t expect her to do it the same way. I guess if she performed it completely live and it were kinda crap, people would complain. She lip syncs some parts, which also make people complain. If she stopped performing the old, vocally demanding songs…. guess what, people would complain.
My criticism is that at this point there really aren't any songs in her shows that are completely 100% live. She relies on playback and live mixture in every song. If there is a fully live song its probably either shortened, a duet, an improv, or at high risk of being dropped from setlist.
@ngminphin8818 you also didn't need to leave the initial reply to my comment, acknowledging you read it, but didn't like it. Who tf even does that while being as closed-minded to discussion as you? It's obvious she's amped her lipping up more, and with less instances of switching between live and playback then back to live etc it overall makes for a cleaner sound.
Gli anni passano per tutti, ma ASCOLTARE IL SUO CUORE E IL SUO ANIMO, UN TALENTO SIMILE NON HA ETA'. E', SARA' PER SEMPRE MONDIALE MERAVIGLIOSA UNICA !
Please Mariah Carey Be My Hero. I Want Have Another childhood from the 1990s and Go back To 2000 And Relive my make It better Not Waste Opportunities! I do not want to feel Unhappy or old or misery or stuck. I Want to Be Very Young And Be My Own hero and have Friends and Have my parents and Friends From the past Very Young Really Think and speak Up and listen. I want to in High school again and Do Talent Shows and Have a Better 11 and 10 grade and have a Happy Graduation. I Want Almighty God To say Yes To my heart and Prayers and Turn back Decades ago, and Have a Stop myself from thinking negativly and Live in a Better time and Be A Singer and Dancer.
This was clearly live and it was a fair performance of Hero. What's weird are these people in the comments whom I suspect are really just one or two haters operating multiple fake troll accounts. It's bizarre really.
@@pvm3926 Exactly. There's a lot of copium in these reactions. She sounded okay during the first half, when she was actually singing, but it was wobbly in places. Then all of the sudden, at the bridge, she sounds like she went back in time 20 years and the rest of the song is perfect. Mariah should do what all other aging singers do - lower the key and use more head voice. Miming is a sad look and nobody is paying good money to hear that.
The playback starts at 2:54 and lasts through the end of the song. If you can't hear the abrupt change in vocal quality, you might want to get your ears checked.
She sounds so nice and fluid, but I wish she’d at least go back to attempting the “inside you” belt again. Esp if she’s not gonna do the “lord knows” or “hold on” belt
Mariah parece muito desanimada no palco esse ano, até o palco está menos festivo que nos anos anteriores, o que é estranho, pois ela está linda, o figurino está lindo, as novas bases gravadas estão atualizadas e houve muita venda nos ingressos, tanto que novas datas foram inclusas, da pra ver que está lotado e Mariah nem insegura está, mas está desanimada ..... algo estranho está acontecendo na vida privada, quem é fã sempre percebe que Mariah transcende na música, apresentações, tudo que está vivendo no pessoal, foi assim na época que houve a traição do ex marido e ela fazia a turne do Elusive Chanteuse
@@LeandroR8263 então, eu acho que talvez ela pode estar triste por causa da voz. Li alguns comentários dizendo que ela estava com autotune no microfone, dublando bastante.... Eu não entendo muito, então não posso falar, mas para quem sabe realmente cantar deve ser muito difícil não conseguir realizar as mesmas apresentações que se conseguia. A Whitney ficava bem triste no final da carreira por não conseguir ter a mesma qualidade vocal. Espero de verdade que não seja isso.
@@dss86 acredito que pode ser isso um dos fatores viu… você viu quando ela encerra Fly Like a Bird com aquele Whistle longo nessa apresentação? Link: czcams.com/video/rbAQoqg6iLg/video.htmlsi=qos5kaGITnoXrLdC. Fiquei na dúvida se era ao vivo ou base pré-gravada. Da uma olhada e depois comenta aqui a sua opinião…
she puts out so many shows in short period of time, nobody compliments her passion in music and singing. when couldn’t sing as well as in the 90s, people like you will be first to bully her as a “fan”. now that she sounds good, yall call her lazy. what tf more do yall want?
OMG, 😮Mariah sounds good here, voice is perfect. Compare to few years ago. I don’t know what she’s is went through but her voice, physical appearance (lost weights) are 👍
It's really sad when dynamic powerful singers whose voice is have decreased by 50% or more still try to tour and do live performances. She never has to work again. She really needs to just do an album every now and then for the few people who are diehard fans to buy. With the way technology is now, it doesn't even make any sense for even trying to do that. She is the last generation of a singer who really was singing and making money. The singer industry is over due to AI and when you are as popular as she was and singing night after night, your stamina and vocal range is going to be cut short earlier than somebody like Diana Ross who really was not a strong singer but more of a personality on stage. I saw Diana Ross about 2 years ago and you still never went for her vocal prowess, you went to see her for her. Mariah Carey will never be able to stand on stage at 80 years old and still dazzle and audience because it's hard for her to do it now.
@@ngminphin8818 I understand what you mean and how she feels but Lena Horne stops singing very early because she said her voice was nowhere near what it used to be and a lady knows when to sit down.
I haven't followed her for a long time. Not only the voice, but there is also no energy, her body almost does not move, a clamp in her shoulders and other things, as if it is difficult for her to even walk. It's very sad. What happened to her? Do you know? Maybe she's sick? She was so talented, one jf the best. Oh, i hope God will save her
@@kristinan6517 I agree. This is why I always say, people need to retire before they start deteriorating this badly. She doesn't need the money, she just need the adoration. But that's her cross to bear.
hero was one of the few songs that Mariah sang almost 100% live alonside VOL and now neither of them are live. And she is the worst lipsyncer in the world, like on thing is being a fan and other one is being delusional trying to convince ourselves that MC is singing live
The music is still the same and she still singing it even if not live. She showed up and moved her mouth and knows the lyrics and at least tries to keep people happy even when they disrespectful her by complaining over using an instrument that has done crazy things for thirty plus years
@@christopherturner5507but people come and pay her ticket to see live performance to hear the voice from her own mouth, not only moving her mouth with pre recorded on the background
Hi ..But when she does sing live you can bet people would complain. . Either she doesn't hit the belt properly or her voice cracks and people would say she doesnt sound the same as she did years ago or thar she lost her voice.. I just think people need to remember she is human and frankly what she did in the 1990s isn't possible now. Her voice would naturally and rightly change but the expectation of her still hitting those notes day after day with same power as her younger voice probably scares her because all.her career she has been dubbed as one of the greatest singers so it's a double edged sword. If people could accept that she could sing live but alas she is trapped in her own talent that any mistake is made bigger and colossal as it really needs to be. I would love nothing more to hear all the faults and all but the perfectionism is so ingrained in her that she doesn't want to shatter the illusion. But.thanks for the reply. All ❤ mariah and God bless her.
To me, Mariah is foremost a song writer and recording artist I don’t think she sees herself as a performer Largely, I imagine she tours to give her fans the chance to see her and because the market is lucrative She works with her musical team to give the best shows she can with the skill set she has access to She lips using recent vocals. I think that’s acceptable given the hours of singing she has given to the world, at the cost of parts of her own signing voice
@@christopherturner5507Nobody is saying she has to sound like the 90’s anymore, the lambs just want good live vocals like the years prior to 2022. Mariah is in good voice and she can sound exactly like prerecord vocals so we’re just confused as fans why she’s not attempting as much as she used to. I get that she’s human but Mariah should seek help with her voice bc that is not fair to the fans that pay hundreds of dollars to see her. She’s been having vocal issues for awhile now so I feel that’s irresponsible of her to not confer w a specialist to help improve her vocal state, especially since she’s been laying low and hasn’t been performing as much.
I dont like when she sings hero like this theres no character or color its so boring ...especially the climax part i wish she used at least vibrato for the belted note or else this sounds blah
@@Mommyyriah Lol Mariah has been ‘preserving’ her voice for years, how can she be resting and not speaking all day etc for her to just sing two verses live in a song. I love Mariah and respect her legacy. But she doesn’t care that much anymore I don’t think. People say she is resting her voice for the whole tour, but we all know she will be lipping the whole thing. It isn’t like she will randomly do a song 100% live later on in the show. She hasn’t sung the Hero Bb4 live for years. Mariah has been lipping regularly for 20 years now, her voice should be in it’s best condition because she hasn’t actually sang anything taxing since 2005 live on tour. So everyone saying she is just resting to not damage her voice, the damage is done. She has been resting for years and the voice is not healing.
@@SilentAssassin01234 Mariah needs to A: remove her nodules via surgery or B: start vocal training from 0. She has the muscle memory, but the lack of constant warm up and too much rest is what makes her voice inconcistent
@@SilentAssassin01234she has to because her nodules deteriorate her voice much faster than other artists. Once she damages it like before its difficult to recover.
Entendo perfeitamente ela baixar o tom da música , pelo tempo de voz , já que exige notas agudas .. mas quebrar as notas a todo momento sem uni-las pra um melisma decente .. já é preguiça 😐
She’s playing in our faces now, taking your money to give these boring ass lipsync performances. I could understand if she was dancing and had to lipsync but she’s doing absolutely nothing and still lipsyncing. I wish she would at least re arrange her music in lower keys and sing the entire songs live. I could respect her a lot more.
![Mariah Carey - PT1 Medley Classic Mashup - 2023 Christmas Concert [11.17 @ Hollywood Bowl]](/img/n.gif)
The first half SOUNDS SO GOOD?! she hasnt sounded this fluid since 2017
shes giving us legatooo
It's lipsync
@@odlangaagfits not, only the climax
@@odlangaagf No it's not, only the bridge.
So it is. @@heeheeriah
mariah don't be afraid ! You always is the best!!
I can't believe gow good she sounds in these clips. Amazing Mariah, well done!
Delusion
@@pvm3926whats the point of clicking on the video just to hate lol. Shows u have nothing else to do in life
It's lipsync
You can tell shes giving her all, i love her😢
I do think she is holding back to save her voice from this long and tightly scheduled tour. Her vocal condition is excellent, she can easily hit that Eb5 in the climax imo.
@@huhyoucantstealmyjoy7420Holding back to save for what?
She will not randomly sing this song or whatever else live towards the end of the tour. What you see here is what it will be on the last date.
People say she is preserving her voice all the time, but she has been lipping most climaxes for the last 20 years, her voice should be in pristine condition cause she hasn’t actually sang anything taxing for years. People are confusing resting with laziness and I am saying that as a fan.
If she was resting, and then sings every song live. Then the vocal routines and not speaking all day etc warrants the results. She isn’t preserving her voice, she just knows her instrument and knows that it is not consistent enough to even attempt the majority of songs live anymore.
just shut up i guess? @@SilentAssassin01234
@@SilentAssassin01234 who u comparing her to. She has nodules since day 1. You can’t compare her with those singers that don’t have nodules. Her voice kept changing during her absolute prime. I don’t sense anything wrong with her lipping most of the climaxes. They are much much harder than those in other people’s songs. It’s unrealistic for her to replicate climax in live performances.
@@huhyoucantstealmyjoy7420 I am comparing her to herself?
Yes I know she has nodules, I legit know everything about her and I don’t expect her to replicate climaxes. But singers can improvise new melodies and dodges like she has done before.
My point was more about how lambs say she is lipping to preserve her voice, but she isn’t preserving it for anything. She should have been preserving it for these shows, and maybe she has but what’s the point in doing that to sing one or two verses live every few songs. She has preserving her voice for 10 years lipping hard vocals, and it has no effect. The damage is done, rest won’t save it or improve it now.
I am angry with fans who say she is saving her voice for the tour, that is just a bs excuse. The tour is now, she should be delivering.
And she hasn’t had nodules from day one, you cannot be born with nodules. She developed them later in her childhood as a lot of children do.
Mariah hasn’t sang anything vocally taxing live for 15 years. So these lambs that say her voice needs rest and to be saved for later shows are delusional.
the live parts are the best she's sounded since 2018 for me. more fluid too
Girl they havent sounded this fluid since like 2017
@@butterflyera yea that's why i said *more* fluid
@@instrumentsmrti that's what was implied by @butterflyera daahlin
@@instrumentsmrtiwhos that in your pfp?
@@SinfulCadence lil peep
She sounds so young here! Literally giving me some 1993 vibes at times. Her current tone is bright and beautiful! ❤
It's lipsync
@odlangaagf I'm referring to the first half, which is obviously live 🙄
@@odlangaagfget a life youre 43
@@fernando_alfradique😂😂
her vocals sound soooo much better than last year or even earlier this year, i’m happy for her!
It's lipsync
it's not.@@odlangaagf
She seems to be unable to hit the high pitch as she used to be able to
SHE’S GIVING ME HER BEACON THEATER HERO PERFORMANCE 😭😭😭😭
the first half sounded soooo good! best in years. THE FLUIDITY?! that’s why i don’t get why she needs to pre-record the 2nd half. tho she seems happier than the first night
her LIVE SINGING PART are getting less😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
@@richielee9838i know :( but her voice is in a good shape so i dont get it 😭
@@axeltimotheo2942It is probably a mix of fear, laziness and just her knowing that she can’t sing as consistently as she once could.
@@axeltimotheo2942 and she's back into her 2017's mode which is less movement and effortless for making the playback part look real🥺not like the previous Christmas show which is she's lipsinging like she's really mean it
@@richielee9838her outfits this tour looked extremely uncomfortable on her
I don't care about the high notes, i can feel her emotions. She was smiling in the whole performance.
One of my favorites
I was there. And I was sobbing. This song ALWAYS sends me bawling!
Always THE best MC❤️
So glad God blessed us with your beautiful song❤️
The best always 🙏thank you
Omgggg❤❤❤
Está bem em todos os sentidos. Aparência, voz. Amo! ❤️
Nailed it! Best singer of all time, love you Mimi ❤God bless you
❤love ❤ song
❤เสียงดีตลอดกาลค่ะ🎉
Sounds as good as ever. ❤
“Thank you for those lights.” 🥹♥️✨
Sing Mariah 🎤 ❤️
My song 2 my own personal self. ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mariah carey ❤❤❤
She has her superwoman cape on. Go Mariah 💪💖
Loved that zoom in on that one woman standing on the top towards the end 😂
This song always saves the day.
Singing Is Perfect
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
greatest ever
She sounds better than previous years❤
🥰💖💖👉🙌🙏🏼🙌
❤ Лучшая ❤
I don't think Mariah isn't really feeling it, this year. She seems like she'd rather be doing something else. Or she has something heavy on her mind.
Is this actuall?? 😳😳👂👂!!! So good voice!!
It’s a big dilemma. She’s kinda forced to perform songs that she was able to sing effortlessly in her prime, 20-30 years ago. Obviously we can’t expect her to do it the same way. I guess if she performed it completely live and it were kinda crap, people would complain. She lip syncs some parts, which also make people complain. If she stopped performing the old, vocally demanding songs…. guess what, people would complain.
they all talk as though they are mariah’s vocal coaches. like those comments aren’t even constructive. karma will hit them hard in the future
My criticism is that at this point there really aren't any songs in her shows that are completely 100% live. She relies on playback and live mixture in every song. If there is a fully live song its probably either shortened, a duet, an improv, or at high risk of being dropped from setlist.
@@twc621 no reason to be afraid, karma won’t hit you if you were constructive in your opinion.
@ngminphin8818 tbf i wasn't rude in my comment. Just matter of fact. No reason to sugar coat reality.
@ngminphin8818 you also didn't need to leave the initial reply to my comment, acknowledging you read it, but didn't like it. Who tf even does that while being as closed-minded to discussion as you? It's obvious she's amped her lipping up more, and with less instances of switching between live and playback then back to live etc it overall makes for a cleaner sound.
Gli anni passano per tutti, ma ASCOLTARE IL SUO CUORE E IL SUO ANIMO, UN TALENTO SIMILE NON HA ETA'. E', SARA' PER SEMPRE MONDIALE MERAVIGLIOSA UNICA !
Please Mariah Carey Be My Hero. I Want Have Another childhood from the 1990s and Go back To 2000 And Relive my make It better Not Waste Opportunities! I do not want to feel Unhappy or old or misery or stuck. I Want to Be Very Young And Be My Own hero and have Friends and Have my parents and Friends From the past Very Young Really Think and speak Up and listen. I want to in High school again and Do Talent Shows and Have a Better 11 and 10 grade and have a Happy Graduation. I Want Almighty God To say Yes To my heart and Prayers and Turn back Decades ago, and Have a Stop myself from thinking negativly and Live in a Better time and Be A Singer and Dancer.
This was clearly live and it was a fair performance of Hero. What's weird are these people in the comments whom I suspect are really just one or two haters operating multiple fake troll accounts. It's bizarre really.
Was half lipped. Watch the bridge
@@pvm3926 according to whom though? I don't care about the speculation of some unnamed person on CZcams.
@@pvm3926 Exactly. There's a lot of copium in these reactions. She sounded okay during the first half, when she was actually singing, but it was wobbly in places. Then all of the sudden, at the bridge, she sounds like she went back in time 20 years and the rest of the song is perfect. Mariah should do what all other aging singers do - lower the key and use more head voice. Miming is a sad look and nobody is paying good money to hear that.
Good times are gone!
I wonder what rehearsals were like 😢
A partir del minuto 2:55 es playback 😢
Does she have a vocal coach?
If y’all don’t. Leave. This lady alone 😂 #hero she is our hero. Y’all need. To pay the negativity
The playback starts at 2:54 and lasts through the end of the song. If you can't hear the abrupt change in vocal quality, you might want to get your ears checked.
You are right
1:42 is low key her way of saying "im singing live guys" 😅
She sounds so nice and fluid, but I wish she’d at least go back to attempting the “inside you” belt again. Esp if she’s not gonna do the “lord knows” or “hold on” belt
Mariah parece muito desanimada no palco esse ano, até o palco está menos festivo que nos anos anteriores, o que é estranho, pois ela está linda, o figurino está lindo, as novas bases gravadas estão atualizadas e houve muita venda nos ingressos, tanto que novas datas foram inclusas, da pra ver que está lotado e Mariah nem insegura está, mas está desanimada ..... algo estranho está acontecendo na vida privada, quem é fã sempre percebe que Mariah transcende na música, apresentações, tudo que está vivendo no pessoal, foi assim na época que houve a traição do ex marido e ela fazia a turne do Elusive Chanteuse
Concordo com você! Isso é muito notável quando ela canta o Medley de Hits mais dançantes… está totalmente desanimada.
@@LeandroR8263 pode ser que esteja tentando se concentrar mais, mas realmente ela parece bem desanimada, uma pena
@@dss86 exatamente! Mas na performance de Fly Like a Bird eu senti ela muito mais concentrada mesmo… mas enfim! Eterna demais ❤️
@@LeandroR8263 então, eu acho que talvez ela pode estar triste por causa da voz. Li alguns comentários dizendo que ela estava com autotune no microfone, dublando bastante.... Eu não entendo muito, então não posso falar, mas para quem sabe realmente cantar deve ser muito difícil não conseguir realizar as mesmas apresentações que se conseguia. A Whitney ficava bem triste no final da carreira por não conseguir ter a mesma qualidade vocal. Espero de verdade que não seja isso.
@@dss86 acredito que pode ser isso um dos fatores viu… você viu quando ela encerra Fly Like a Bird com aquele Whistle longo nessa apresentação? Link: czcams.com/video/rbAQoqg6iLg/video.htmlsi=qos5kaGITnoXrLdC. Fiquei na dúvida se era ao vivo ou base pré-gravada. Da uma olhada e depois comenta aqui a sua opinião…
Desiste titia😫😫😫 sua época já passou
she sounded so good she's just lazy she could sing the original arrangement if she wanted to
Shes also 54…. She can’t always sing it the way she used to.
she puts out so many shows in short period of time, nobody compliments her passion in music and singing. when couldn’t sing as well as in the 90s, people like you will be first to bully her as a “fan”. now that she sounds good, yall call her lazy. what tf more do yall want?
Love seeing all the lambs in the comments who know all about the pre-recorded live vocals
OMG, 😮Mariah sounds good here, voice is perfect. Compare to few years ago. I don’t know what she’s is went through but her voice, physical appearance (lost weights) are 👍
😂😂you-all crazy
It's really sad when dynamic powerful singers whose voice is have decreased by 50% or more still try to tour and do live performances. She never has to work again. She really needs to just do an album every now and then for the few people who are diehard fans to buy. With the way technology is now, it doesn't even make any sense for even trying to do that. She is the last generation of a singer who really was singing and making money. The singer industry is over due to AI and when you are as popular as she was and singing night after night, your stamina and vocal range is going to be cut short earlier than somebody like Diana Ross who really was not a strong singer but more of a personality on stage. I saw Diana Ross about 2 years ago and you still never went for her vocal prowess, you went to see her for her. Mariah Carey will never be able to stand on stage at 80 years old and still dazzle and audience because it's hard for her to do it now.
that means mariah loves doing what she’s doing. her goal is to connect with her fans and sing for them. this is her passion.
@@ngminphin8818 I understand what you mean and how she feels but Lena Horne stops singing very early because she said her voice was nowhere near what it used to be and a lady knows when to sit down.
I haven't followed her for a long time. Not only the voice, but there is also no energy, her body almost does not move, a clamp in her shoulders and other things, as if it is difficult for her to even walk. It's very sad. What happened to her? Do you know? Maybe she's sick? She was so talented, one jf the best. Oh, i hope God will save her
@@kristinan6517 I agree. This is why I always say, people need to retire before they start deteriorating this badly. She doesn't need the money, she just need the adoration. But that's her cross to bear.
Je trouve que là elle interprète plus cette chanson comme il se doit
Ummmm why was she so quick to say bye and get off stage??
It's sad to watch her move lips to playback and she keeps looking lost at the screens during this concert. Unfortunately, it's sad to watch :(((
hero was one of the few songs that Mariah sang almost 100% live alonside VOL and now neither of them are live. And she is the worst lipsyncer in the world, like on thing is being a fan and other one is being delusional trying to convince ourselves that MC is singing live
The music is still the same and she still singing it even if not live. She showed up and moved her mouth and knows the lyrics and at least tries to keep people happy even when they disrespectful her by complaining over using an instrument that has done crazy things for thirty plus years
@@christopherturner5507but people come and pay her ticket to see live performance to hear the voice from her own mouth, not only moving her mouth with pre recorded on the background
Hi ..But when she does sing live you can bet people would complain. . Either she doesn't hit the belt properly or her voice cracks and people would say she doesnt sound the same as she did years ago or thar she lost her voice.. I just think people need to remember she is human and frankly what she did in the 1990s isn't possible now. Her voice would naturally and rightly change but the expectation of her still hitting those notes day after day with same power as her younger voice probably scares her because all.her career she has been dubbed as one of the greatest singers so it's a double edged sword. If people could accept that she could sing live but alas she is trapped in her own talent that any mistake is made bigger and colossal as it really needs to be.
I would love nothing more to hear all the faults and all but the perfectionism is so ingrained in her that she doesn't want to shatter the illusion. But.thanks for the reply. All ❤ mariah and God bless her.
To me, Mariah is foremost a song writer and recording artist
I don’t think she sees herself as a performer
Largely, I imagine she tours to give her fans the chance to see her and because the market is lucrative
She works with her musical team to give the best shows she can with the skill set she has access to
She lips using recent vocals. I think that’s acceptable given the hours of singing she has given to the world, at the cost of parts of her own signing voice
@@christopherturner5507Nobody is saying she has to sound like the 90’s anymore, the lambs just want good live vocals like the years prior to 2022. Mariah is in good voice and she can sound exactly like prerecord vocals so we’re just confused as fans why she’s not attempting as much as she used to. I get that she’s human but Mariah should seek help with her voice bc that is not fair to the fans that pay hundreds of dollars to see her. She’s been having vocal issues for awhile now so I feel that’s irresponsible of her to not confer w a specialist to help improve her vocal state, especially since she’s been laying low and hasn’t been performing as much.
Vocal surgery? Sounds so better that I guess it so.
I dont like when she sings hero like this theres no character or color its so boring ...especially the climax part i wish she used at least vibrato for the belted note or else this sounds blah
Poor her, it is painful to watch when the playback goes in. She used to be so good
She can hit the Bb4 live but she doesnt want to over damage her voice this early as she still has many tours left 😢
@@Mommyyriah Lol Mariah has been ‘preserving’ her voice for years, how can she be resting and not speaking all day etc for her to just sing two verses live in a song.
I love Mariah and respect her legacy. But she doesn’t care that much anymore I don’t think.
People say she is resting her voice for the whole tour, but we all know she will be lipping the whole thing. It isn’t like she will randomly do a song 100% live later on in the show. She hasn’t sung the Hero Bb4 live for years.
Mariah has been lipping regularly for 20 years now, her voice should be in it’s best condition because she hasn’t actually sang anything taxing since 2005 live on tour.
So everyone saying she is just resting to not damage her voice, the damage is done. She has been resting for years and the voice is not healing.
@@SilentAssassin01234 Mariah needs to A: remove her nodules via surgery or B: start vocal training from 0. She has the muscle memory, but the lack of constant warm up and too much rest is what makes her voice inconcistent
@@vicktheengine5304 her vopoice is not inconsistent . It is super damaged.
@@SilentAssassin01234she has to because her nodules deteriorate her voice much faster than other artists. Once she damages it like before its difficult to recover.
Maybe she has a cold
Entendo perfeitamente ela baixar o tom da música , pelo tempo de voz , já que exige notas agudas .. mas quebrar as notas a todo momento sem uni-las pra um melisma decente .. já é preguiça 😐
Dur de chanter sans retour de sons dans les oreilles.
Hello i dunn tink tats really affected her after all she used to dated billionaires 😂
Jajajjajajja!!! que cutre!! en las partes agudas cambia a playback! se nota un montón
She’s playing in our faces now, taking your money to give these boring ass lipsync performances. I could understand if she was dancing and had to lipsync but she’s doing absolutely nothing and still lipsyncing. I wish she would at least re arrange her music in lower keys and sing the entire songs live. I could respect her a lot more.
CHILE ☠️😂
She does not enjoy singing 😢
It's like going to eat at a restaurant that used to serve good food in the 90's but not anymore.
Thats so cruel
I’m mad at you because you’re saying this about Mariah, but damn that was generally funny af 😂
Miss Piggy is coming for Christmas again.. 🙄
Why this? She's a good singer, actually we don't have singers like her. Whitney, Aretha, Tina Turner.... it's too sad
❤❤❤ glad to have her around.
She's successful while you and your mom remain useless. Remember that!!