Saw this exact thing on reddit www.reddit.com/r/Whatcouldgowrong/comments/esfx0s/wcgw_if_i_throw_boiling_water_in_the_air_and_its/?st=K5Q3KY93&sh=da389f31
This is a great demonstration of the process by which persistent contrails can spread across the sky, and by which they grow to be visible from the ground, 10km awway from where they are formed. If the air is super-saturated with respect to ice, the exhaust water cannot evaporate and freezes to ice crystals; more Ice sublimates out of the saturated atmosphere onto the nucleation points provided by the ice from the jet exhaust and the other combustion byproducts, increasing the size optical density of the trail. If blown by the wind to other similarly-saturated patches of air, these ice crystals can themselvs act as nucleation points for the deposition of more ice, and so the cycle continues, with ice accumulating more ice, which gets blown by the wind and accumulates more ice elsewhere. If the atmosphere isn't already super-saturated with respect to ice, of course the initial contrail is sublimated into the atmosphere and the contrail disappears at a rate related to the local humidity.
we also blow bubbles when we get below 0 and the bubbles freeze then the kids play catch with them. plus it is so cool to watch the crystals form on the bubbles. I mean really, what else can we do when it is this cold here (tonight we have a wind chill of -15F in Montana)
Most people are wrong. The water is not actually frozen immediately unless it is about -42°F or colder. The falling trails are actually liquid water and the steam that you see is actually a cloud. The cloud is made up of condensed water droplets, just like a natural cloud. The cloud droplets might freeze if they are in the air for long enough, land on the ground, or if the air is below about -42°F.
I feel it’s more to do with the fact that the surface area to volume ratio of the water all of a sudden decreased, the effect your talking about has more than just temperature that goes into it otherwise all hot water would freeze faster.
You got lied to and it was worth it. Right. Ok. That's real smart. Bet you verified this with Wikipedia, too. This is a farce. It doesn't even take any formal scientific education to understand that frozen water does not evaporate; Doesn't steam. Every bit of the water that was trailing steam as it came down was still liquid, and still rather warm even.
That is soooo cool. I wish I could go to where it gets that cold and do it myself. I'd be out there all day. I would put different food coloring in the water🤣.
Hotter the water, the faster it freezes. Your wife's correct, but for that shot I'd let you slide. Thanks. I lived in the CA dessert at the Gateway to Death Valley, we would cook eggs on the sidewalk.
you make it sound like you swam across the ocean “my wife said i’m crazy for doing it” ooh look at me i can walk outside and throw water in the air i’m crazy
This Mpemba effect is probably different than the usual. My guess is that the rapid evaporation makes the droplets smaller, which increases the surface area so the now cold water droplets can freeze quicker. But that's just a hypothesis
No matter the 'effect,' that water wasn't frozen as it came down. It was trailing steam, which is actually proof it was still liquid. Boiling hot water doesn't freeze that quickly. In fact, the only indicator in this video that would suggest that the water had frozen before it hit the ground is the captions: They tell you, you believe it. If it had been >150°F, then there could've been a chance.
*doesnt freeze and gets burned with boiling hot water*
Saw this exact thing on reddit www.reddit.com/r/Whatcouldgowrong/comments/esfx0s/wcgw_if_i_throw_boiling_water_in_the_air_and_its/?st=K5Q3KY93&sh=da389f31
Lol when I did it I was scared that would happen
It looks like it was gonna turn into the moon
what
Vegeta screaming in distance
that's rough buddy
Super wish you could have posted without the annoying music - one of the enjoyable aspects of this is the sound that the water makes as it freezes.
Very true; It's like a hissing sound, correct?
I did that when it dropped down into the -40s
Dude... I am glad u did Retakes!!! Cuz that was the PERFECT SHOT!!! Awesome 👏👍🏽👏
Thanks for this video. The wife might think he’s crazy for trying it but seems like it’s worth it.
That was pretty cool, and it looked like a white firework explosion.
“My wife thinks I’m crazy.”
“BTW my wife is never wrong XD”
Two thumbs up if possible lol best one I've seen on CZcams. Looks absolutely dopetastic with the sun in the background
Looks incredible
Why did i think it was a penguin throwing a snowball at the camera?
This is a great demonstration of the process by which persistent contrails can spread across the sky, and by which they grow to be visible from the ground, 10km awway from where they are formed. If the air is super-saturated with respect to ice, the exhaust water cannot evaporate and freezes to ice crystals; more Ice sublimates out of the saturated atmosphere onto the nucleation points provided by the ice from the jet exhaust and the other combustion byproducts, increasing the size optical density of the trail. If blown by the wind to other similarly-saturated patches of air, these ice crystals can themselvs act as nucleation points for the deposition of more ice, and so the cycle continues, with ice accumulating more ice, which gets blown by the wind and accumulates more ice elsewhere.
If the atmosphere isn't already super-saturated with respect to ice, of course the initial contrail is sublimated into the atmosphere and the contrail disappears at a rate related to the local humidity.
I'm not sure why you gave a figure of '10km', as a condensation trail can be seen from 100's of km's away.
At 60 to 80 degrees below zero fahrenheit in the sky, contrails will always form (hot water to ice phenomenon).
AAAAAHHHH!!!! IT'S THE CHEMTRAILS!!!! NOOOOooooooo!!!!!!
The flatards call those chem-trails.
And yet chemtrails can be spread in any air temperature and aren't even always visible to the naked eye.
awesome!!
alright nerds who can explain to me why tf hot water freezes faster than cold water
Good try Diego!
super video and sound
This is the coolest thing ever!!!!!!!
throw it into +29 degree air then and film that for me
bigmaxy07 why
*woosh*
Sachin Thapa how do u not understand?
I dont get it
It lookes like a cloud floating but then it falls from the air and trys to run away
we also blow bubbles when we get below 0 and the bubbles freeze then the kids play catch with them. plus it is so cool to watch the crystals form on the bubbles. I mean really, what else can we do when it is this cold here (tonight we have a wind chill of -15F in Montana)
Wind chill says nothing about the temperature. What was the temperature?
That's fun as hell, going to do it tonight...
WAUW ! thank you !
awesome
I tried this in Florida and all I got was a bad burn.
Interested in a wonderful experiment.
Thank you for sharing the video.
This would be perfect for daily dose of internet
One of the benefits of living in a cold state!
Awesome
That straight up looked like fireworks
Tried it with cold water once, just came back right in my face
Crazy? Crazy awesome!!
So cool
Wow amazing
Beautiful- Nature is like that.
VERY COOL!!👍👍😎
It was minus 24 here in Chicago today. Why didn't I try this???
because you were too busy sitting inside watching youtube
It’s like u opened a white universe with a huge cloud
Cool!
who thinks it kinda looked like the moon when it was in the air
I thought it's going to create a kind of dome. But i guess the water particles were too small
I’ve never knew that I wanted to know
But now I know that I’ve always wanted to know
youtube recommendation less than 1 min old videos are incredible
Most people are wrong. The water is not actually frozen immediately unless it is about -42°F or colder. The falling trails are actually liquid water and the steam that you see is actually a cloud. The cloud is made up of condensed water droplets, just like a natural cloud. The cloud droplets might freeze if they are in the air for long enough, land on the ground, or if the air is below about -42°F.
*THAT LOOKS LIKE A GIANT CLOUD ABOVE HIS HEAD*
Cool stuff:)
I feel it’s more to do with the fact that the surface area to volume ratio of the water all of a sudden decreased, the effect your talking about has more than just temperature that goes into it otherwise all hot water would freeze faster.
with the cold weather the midwest is getting rn i wanna try this
What's the music, please?
If you can do this, as well as pronounce it, you've accomplished two great things.
You're not crazy....that was easily worth it!
You got lied to and it was worth it. Right. Ok. That's real smart. Bet you verified this with Wikipedia, too.
This is a farce. It doesn't even take any formal scientific education to understand that frozen water does not evaporate; Doesn't steam. Every bit of the water that was trailing steam as it came down was still liquid, and still rather warm even.
Hey guys, what's the music ?
that’s cool ... ❄️
"My wife thinks I'm crazy for trying it"
*Actually she is not wrong*
Nice one
Woah David Fahrenheit attempted this stunt???
What is the music?
What song is that?
It's not science it's logic
What is you throw boiling coffee, would the cloud be black
No, because the freezing point would decrease due to the addition of coffee powder it may not freeze.
He did it
That is soooo cool. I wish I could go to where it gets that cold and do it myself. I'd be out there all day. I would put different food coloring in the water🤣.
it was minus 30 where i live on of the coldest places in the usa today would have loved to have tried that still might , after a few 😁
That's cool
Your neighbors must love you...
What a nice view 😍😍😍
I just tried this here in eastern Oklahoma and I just burned the heck out of myself lol guess 28 degrees is NOT cold enough lol
So it just turned into a big cloud?
cold out there.
What is the temperature
I LOVE IT AND YOU ARE SOME WHAT CRAZY😲🤣😁WELLDONE.
Your wife is actually right! 💯
This is how clouds are made.
He tried it twelve times? Was the first time throwing it in his own face?
Wow...😯
ice works!!!
I tried it in Lake Tahoe California in January like -21 and the water froze
really cool... stay warm my friends
This is cool
And little hot also
Hotter the water, the faster it freezes. Your wife's correct, but for that shot I'd let you slide. Thanks. I lived in the CA dessert at the Gateway to Death Valley, we would cook eggs on the sidewalk.
China can do that too
So this is how clouds are made
his name is actually David Fahrenheit
My roommate and I want to do that here in Minnesota next week when it's -13°F
Kay this comment was 3 years ago and I dont think thats cold enough.
Any updates?
@@jeff4762 I tried it with -22f wind chill in south eastern canada, and it worked.
@@johonanandrewgomes7593 good to know
Viva Frei Montreal litigator turned CZcamsr turned scientist and know you know your David...
Looks like a firework
I didn't know that when water solidifies it could float away.
What you've never seen clouds before?
woah.
He almost burned his face away for throwing that pot overhead
Wow
Make sure the wind current isn’t blowing towards you, took a drop of boiling water to the foot because it caught the wind current 😂
Pretty much every single kid growing up in Duluth, Minnesota has done this.
ayo do you know if this is a physical change or a chemical change
Physical: liquid to solid, it’s still water
We can't do that in Texas it's too hot here
Dooo Foxywatermelon hell yeah 70 in fucking December
its 33 right now
acbulgin2 nothing it's just a funny name
Maybe you can throw ice and make it rain boiling water?
If you still do it then the hot water pour on you instead of Ice, ha haha
you make it sound like you swam across the ocean “my wife said i’m crazy for doing it” ooh look at me i can walk outside and throw water in the air i’m crazy
This Mpemba effect is probably different than the usual. My guess is that the rapid evaporation makes the droplets smaller, which increases the surface area so the now cold water droplets can freeze quicker. But that's just a hypothesis
DANG JOS Not evaporating though.
It turns to steam right away and then freezes in a few seconds
@@braxton7638 if it's not evaporating, then how is there steam?
@@DANGJOS five years crazy is wilddd, idk i think it’s steam maybe?
@@braxton7638steam is evaporation
THATS OS SATISFYING😭
"sometimes" ?
did he just make a cloud????
thanks, i managed to throw boiling water on my face and now i have 3rd degree burn.
He poured it in his face the first time.
No matter the 'effect,' that water wasn't frozen as it came down. It was trailing steam, which is actually proof it was still liquid. Boiling hot water doesn't freeze that quickly. In fact, the only indicator in this video that would suggest that the water had frozen before it hit the ground is the captions: They tell you, you believe it. If it had been >150°F, then there could've been a chance.
From hot water to instant snow storm. Hot water freezes sooner than cold water. The music kinda ruins it.
This isn't science, this is nature
But nature is science