It's difficult to sing better than the original version.Though Aska sings quite well, I prefer shin's more. Anyway, it's two styles of presentation. Both of them are awesome.
I think it's because after Gary sang those songs and everyone gives good comments so he just keep perfoming them...if gary can sing such difficult song like "I want happiness" what else song he can't sing...I think Gary can sing other songs just that people expect to sing those songs because it's really good...besides I think those songs can really show how good Gary's singing skill...
I start to love his voice. I think he is the kind of singer like Gary Chaw, doent has good look, but he has powerful voice! I personally feel that having a great voice is much much important than having a good look only, like those "idol singers" on the market..haiz
This "goryreprisals" has been posting the same text on each of Yang's video. I don't understand why (s)he did this. Yang doesn't own you anything. No need to search for his Video and attack him. It's pointless.
楊宗緯 has a lot of potential to become an excellent singer. he just has to polish up his technique a bit. as for gary, i love him too, but sometimes his performances are a little boring, as if he's missing something...
lol, u gotta agree that this guy isnt so attractive but hes talented and i bet he's hell of a nice guy, so whatever, let the people down there say w/e they want they may not be ugly but they will never be as talented as them
he is so NOT wayyyyyyyyyyyy better than Gary Chaw. maybe it's because you've seen so much of Gary so he's getting boring. Have you seen his performance to wo yao kuai le and zhu wo sheng ri kuai le on 3/8 Black Society?? that is so NOT boring. Gary chaw is still the better singer. He puts me to tears!
No doubt in terms of technical ability Jam is better. However singing isn't just about showing your singing ability...it's also your ability to bring out the emotions of the song. In this area, Aska is way better than Jam. If a singer can bring out the emotions of the songs and get the listeners to laugh or cry with the song, i think he/she is a good singer. It doesn't matter if he/she can sing like pavarotti.
不管是以前的楊宗緯還是現在的楊宗緯 真的他的歌聲沒人可以替代他
好好聽，好喜歡。真的，唱啥都好聽
真的超強
再回来听。杨宗纬.-了百万。唱歌感情一带到底.感动。赞
看來星光的老師最愛楊的是小胖，挺他一路至今，音超比賽也那麼看重他，回首來時路要感謝感恩，加油
還是很懷念楊唱這首歌，獨特的嗓音甚至皺眉頭，非常耐聼，讚！
一聽再聽
一直循環真的太厲害了2018還是常來溫習
很棒! 讓人想一聽再聽得好歌聲!
很磁性的嗓音。杨宗纬还没出道时，我还蛮喜欢李圣杰磁性嗓音。现在唯独杨宗纬 我心中的歌神。
這首！最令我感動！加油！小子！
宗緯其實長得很帥， 臉蛋身材都有， 真是百年難得一見。
風流倜黨~超帥性格超喜歡的型
第二眼帥哥❤
真的是沖滿了感情... 喜歡!!!
小黑， 我就喜歡你， 支持善良的人， 有越突破的人， 我喜歡楊宗緯， 永不放棄 ，而一直堅持做自己 音樂， 唱給我們聽，
楊宗緯總是唱出比原唱更動人的歌聲。
好好聽喔
好好聽!
真係好聽
好聽...
不知道這首歌原來這麼好聽，楊宗緯唱出這首歌的靈魂！
超好聽的
好聽啦
幾年後再看,依然很喜歡
他的声音很感人 T_T
他出我也會買!
楊也很帥，評審老是提他外表如何，難怪他対自己一直沒信心。潘裕文看來斯文，氣質也很好！兩位都加油！
袁乃欣 杨如果没这个外貌，在星光时候不会这么红，很对女性吃他man的外貌
@@user-hj1uh7zd1w 哈哈有趣啊
徐德鳳 真的呀，他好几个动态角度像言承旭，兽化版的
@@user-hj1uh7zd1w 很多其他人的粉絲一直批評他的外表，甚至於在yuto罵他以前的外號直至現在還是有，其實那有醜，不喜歡也不要批評太過，從未喜歡蕭敬騰也從不在視頻上批評他
徐德鳳 不得不说，台湾星光首届那三只都有星象，萧敬腾和林佑威也都长的不错
生命的歌者,太感人了!!
唱得點都不比阿信差!!
宗緯,加油!! 等你出新專輯!!
his voice is very sincere, really touching.
无敌的表现 o.O"""
宗緯我們好想你喔^^
我也聽了很多次。
黑人慧眼識英雄!
楊宗緯在星光時比較少唱這種飆高音的歌,其實他唱這類的歌也是很好聽,那時的唱腔比較外放他可以盡情的飆唱,現在唱得比較內斂再次詮釋不知道會是甚麼感覺,希望有機會可以聽到他再唱這首歌
Ichen Chen
真的，超想在聽到這首
嗯嗯是啊是啊~
@@tvmovers8804 聽說新演唱會要到年底了
因為高音沒特色
Aska Go Go!!
棒棒的
excellent piece! Love Aska!!
So touched!
He has great voice.
wonderful!
快開演唱會
是 "此人不红，天理难容"啦
what a powerful and very touching voice, we are very glad
如果讓楊宗緯在詮釋一次這首歌一定又是不同的感覺了
naterapper Joker
對啊，感覺宗緯唱腔有些轉變
@@Rika-mj8xq 現在更內斂，更好聽，之前用的是天賦，現在融合兩種，用努力和歲月的厲練，再聽會更喜歡
我又回來聽了 哈哈
@@Rika-mj8xq 好棒，我也再回聽，最新的作品是緣也好聽
he is sooo great ^^
還是喜歡星光時的他.
好久沒看到宗緯，還真想他。
我和你一樣很想念他
哈哈最近十五日要推出新劇，曲名是緣，宸汐緣主題曲，好久沒新歌好期待
他有當年王傑的影子__衣服單薄表情苦楚///還有伍思凱的高亢//加ㄧ點現在陶喆的轉音(假音)但是轉的讓華人都喜歡能接受//再加ㄧ點..周董的不善言詞//成就了他的特色吧 ...........個人見解
wow aska rockss so much man-- a one in million talent
赞！
一了百了 is my favorite song and zhong wei present it remarkably well.
老蕭無法唱出宗緯細膩度。染感力無法達到。這是不能比的。因差太遠了。老蕭只會唱而己
王小守 太同意～蕭只是很會飆高音而已，我聽不到感情的味道！
可是在台灣蕭較紅
ten Sun 萧的唱法比较时尚，杨的比较传统
@@user-hj1uh7zd1w 時尚和傳統怎分，我音樂素質低聽不大懂
徐德鳳 就是感觉萧比较洋气点，并不走感情路线，就是一种他自己的唱法，杨是传统的感情路线嘛，所以感觉两者没什么好比的，我个人觉得萧可能更受年轻人喜欢
前面比較緊張，可惜提早進歌，如果再慢一拍，一定更好，而且當時這首也超不好唱，能唱出自己味道真的不簡單。
很享受
嗓音真好，磁性又渾厚，這歌聲誏人愛上像醇酒甜美可口忘不了。加油！
aska yang,u r the best......
eason chan ,jay chou,i gt new idol,is u,aska yang~
小黑真會評，跟我看準蕭敬騰是一樣的道理。
黑人真識貨!!
論唱歌感染力，穿透力，楊宗緯最棒無需與人比啊
+1
Aska can perform a song very well
Mmms, his voice is rare. Nice ;}
苦情歌神!苦情歌神!la
黑人說得很讚~黑人好棒~
i've never believe that singing can touch someone. after hearing this, i finally understand
Yes,me too
一了百了...我也想
此人不紅，天理難容！
his presentation is diff from ah xin...
so totally powerful voice...
one in a million years
ho ho... he better come out with an album!!
It's difficult to sing better than the original version.Though Aska sings quite well, I prefer shin's more.
Anyway, it's two styles of presentation.
Both of them are awesome.
我同意
chung ming Low 過了十年，很難想像吧，時間飛快
Yang Zong Wei is a star in the making. "You all like them but I don't agree."
I think it's because after Gary sang those songs and everyone gives good comments so he just keep perfoming them...if gary can sing such difficult song like "I want happiness" what else song he can't sing...I think Gary can sing other songs just that people expect to sing those songs because it's really good...besides I think those songs can really show how good Gary's singing skill...
鬼迷心竅
aska sentimental
我也是喜歡以前他的歌聲 現在的聲音有點太制式了
同意…還有咬字發音也是 以前聽起來比較自然
其實宗緯一直在進步，唱功一直在精進。更動人。
And Gary's version of zu wo sheng ri kuai le is like 23423452345 times better than Yang's version. Can't even compare!!!!
真的好喜歡以前的楊
現在再唱不知道如何
I start to love his voice. I think he is the kind of singer like Gary Chaw, doent has good look, but he has powerful voice! I personally feel that having a great voice is much much important than having a good look only, like those "idol singers" on the market..haiz
I shred
I agree
This "goryreprisals" has been posting the same text on each of Yang's video. I don't understand why (s)he did this. Yang doesn't own you anything. No need to search for his Video and attack him. It's pointless.
and u must be one of the buyer.
superb
楊宗緯 has a lot of potential to become an excellent singer. he just has to polish up his technique a bit. as for gary, i love him too, but sometimes his performances are a little boring, as if he's missing something...
只可以話信較有power
佢滑音較多 可能因為咁所以聽落感情豐富d
始終鍾意信版
lol, u gotta agree that this guy isnt so attractive
but hes talented and i bet he's hell of a nice guy, so whatever, let the people down there say w/e they want
they may not be ugly but they will never be as talented as them
進歌太早
his selling point is his voice... he has nth to do wit his face... jus sing bro... sing ur ass out!! good voice!!
he is so NOT wayyyyyyyyyyyy better than Gary Chaw. maybe it's because you've seen so much of Gary so he's getting boring. Have you seen his performance to wo yao kuai le and zhu wo sheng ri kuai le on 3/8 Black Society?? that is so NOT boring. Gary chaw is still the better singer. He puts me to tears!
聽起來是降半個或一個音 不太確定
已知用火
我還是覺得曹格的唱歌技巧比他好
不過我也很喜歡楊宗緯
我覺得他的聲音帶點沙啞
唱一了百了很有那種感覺
我覺得他唱這類型帶點滄桑的
情歌比較適合...
和曹格所走的路線是有點分別的=]
ps: 我覺得曹格唱live 超棒的,
但是他唱來唱去都是那幾首歌
不是自己的歌, 就是聽海, 我要快樂
祝我生日快樂..新不了情...etc.
所以可能聽多了會boring吧?
No doubt in terms of technical ability Jam is better. However singing isn't just about showing your singing ability...it's also your ability to bring out the emotions of the song. In this area, Aska is way better than Jam.
If a singer can bring out the emotions of the songs and get the listeners to laugh or cry with the song, i think he/she is a good singer. It doesn't matter if he/she can sing like pavarotti.
為何聲音跟影像有時間差...
你才沒資格說話
請問各位他有降key嗎?降多少?
原KEY
好似李聖杰~~~~
請教各位大神有走音嗎？還是我的問題
Shin did a better job than Aska!!
Aska better, ok?
chao1220
I saw his post all over around too..this is just nonsense
who cares about shit~just leave him alone
應該是"信"= =
黑人出来我有点跳戏
這褲子有點奇怪，不是嗎。
少了信的power,滄桑
個人認為他不適合唱rock如信的歌
WTF472 他很适合唱周华健那些武侠歌
何必让继续在自己困扰
Shin is sing better and better than him
Oh, i don't agree
其實他聲也很厚..
但他的唱腔在每段收尾都在喉嚨發出嗚咽聲
反而聽起來很薄 怪怪的
唱起阿信那些中氣嘹亮的歌十分不適合
還是唱回苦情歌吧
sorry ... but he does not have 肌肉... lol..
but he is a great singer :)
His body is great, ok. You don't know?
JAM is better,lol
Jam是啥
@@user-tb5fk2yr9k
jam 是果醬的意思 塗麵包的
@@sunnyjean9275 哈哈哈哈哈我懂妳的幽默
@@user-tb5fk2yr9k
謝謝您心照不宣的明白 哈哈