Do Catholics worship Idols? Responding to Protestants

Sdílet
Vložit

Komentáře • 8

  • @thegiantbeagle
    @thegiantbeagle Před 5 měsíci +2

    Cool, could you do a video on praying to/with saints like a Hail Mary or Dear Saint Anthony.

  • @BeHappy-fn8yv
    @BeHappy-fn8yv Před 5 měsíci +3

    well explained

  • @Marie-sn7ci
    @Marie-sn7ci Před 5 měsíci +1

    Great video 😂 protestants love trying "to 1 up" Catholics

  • @pokedev8215
    @pokedev8215 Před 5 měsíci +3

    Thankfully, we had the Second Council of Nicaea

  • @luciusgodbold5122
    @luciusgodbold5122 Před 5 měsíci

    But you never explained how you are not worshiping images. You only stated that having them wasn't a sin, but never said how you weren't worshipping them. Using an image of Jesus on the cross or the Holy Trinity as "an aid to worship" is nothing like the use of the Cherubium in the Old Testament and is certainly idolatry. Also you never said how the church in Galatia was "using" the image of Christ(hint: it wasn't for worship, check verse 2). In addition ascribing the power to hear more the 900000 prayers at once to Mary, and giving the atributes of the trinity to the pope("ex cathedra" or the ability to infailibly interpert scripture) is absolutely unbiblical and ungodly. In Mark 7:7 you can find the comments of Jesus himself on your traditions.

    • @BrennaButcher
      @BrennaButcher  Před 5 měsíci

      “Worship” has to do with intent. I can love cake, but that’s not idolatry. I could even go so far as to love cake so much that I kiss it, but that’s still not idolatry. But if I love cake to the extent that I believe it to be a god, then that is worship.
      You keep saying that using images as an aid to worship is idolatry. Back up your claims, since you are so confident about it.
      Galatians 3:2 doesn’t speak of how the Galatians used images of Jesus.
      In Mark 7:7, Jesus was speaking to the Pharisees, not Christians. Scripture makes it clear that the church has the authority to determine doctrine outside the Scriptures, see acts 15, and 2 Thessalonians 2:15
      You’re twisting of the scriptures to fit your own twisted agenda is gross.

    • @luciusgodbold5122
      @luciusgodbold5122 Před 5 měsíci

      @@BrennaButcher Galatians 3:2 was talking about salvation being by grace not works, my bad on that one. What was being said in Mark 7:7 applies to everyone, scripture has more authority than tradition, and if you follow church tradition more than it the wrath of God is upon you. Also while the Church can interpert scripture, it is not infailible like the catholic church claims("Tradition is greater than the word of the Bible" Father DuBois, O Biblismi), and if the catholic church is "the one true church" then the popes sure are lousy soulwinners, they have total acess to the media and spend more time talking about political humanistic nonsense than giving the plan of salvation. And make sure you check with the Synod of Tarragona of 1234 about that Bible you have, I'd hate for you to be burned at the stake as a heretic. Also don't you guys teach that the church replaced Israel? If thats so Mark 7:7 would especialy apply to "christians".