What if General Grievous DEFEATED Obi Wan on Utapau?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 11. 2023
  • In this Star Wars Fan Fiction let’s explore what would’ve happened if Obi Wan was defeated by General Grievous in Revenge of the Sith….
    (Also, this fan fiction will also slightly tackle what if Anakin and Mace Windu fought Grievous)
    Music Used -- • When life ends, anothe...
    Wanna support the channel on Patreon?
    / starwarsquill
    Here are the Benefits;
    • Early access to FanFictions
    • Very early access to Star Wars Lore videos that won’t be uploaded to the main channel for AT LEAST a month :)
    • Shoutout in every video I make :)
    • As for Pricing, it’s set the minimum amount Patreon allows and all tiers have the same benefits :)
    #starwarswhatif
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 70

  • @patrickd2853
    @patrickd2853 Před 7 měsíci +76

    What if Anakin, Palpatine, and Yoda went to Mortis?

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +14

      That would be interesting!

    • @patrickd2853
      @patrickd2853 Před 7 měsíci +17

      @@starwarsquill thanks. I thought it may be interesting to see such dynamics and if Sidious would work alongside the son or if his selfish desires would lead to an internal battle in the dark side. Personally, I believe it would lead to a battle in the world between worlds, Palpatine freeing Abaloth and trying to use Sith alchemy to make her his humble servant, or Palpatine drinking water from the fountain of knowledge and becoming a creature like abaloth, the different sides of the force having to unite one last time to stop him.

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +11

      @@patrickd2853 those are awesome ideas, man! I really appreciate the suggestion:)

    • @Reclaimation
      @Reclaimation Před 6 měsíci +2

      I'm shook!

    • @toomanygrenades
      @toomanygrenades Před měsícem

      Really good idea

  • @electropyro1899
    @electropyro1899 Před 7 měsíci +16

    Grievously injured is crazy

  • @sagittariusa7662
    @sagittariusa7662 Před 3 měsíci +5

    So they brought back the 2003 Grievous, because there is no way Obi-wan could beat the 2003 Grievous. Mace Windu did using a Dark Side technique called Force Crush. That is because Grievous had no data concerning Windu's ability to use Dark side abilities especially since he is a Jedi and Jedi are supposed to only use light sided techniques. Also if Grievous was built to be immune to dark side techniques then there is no way in hell Dooku or Sidious could stop him.

  • @maskdude6914
    @maskdude6914 Před 6 měsíci +6

    Most well explained video I’ve seen I could see this all playing out exactly like this

  • @sheevhernandez3869
    @sheevhernandez3869 Před 2 měsíci +2

    0:15 idk why but that made me laugh 😭🤣

  • @ZenithTech35
    @ZenithTech35 Před 7 měsíci +20

    First video I've seen from your channel, and I'm already greatly impressed! You have a real knack for storytelling! Keep this level of quality up and you'll go far in the Star Wars What If community. Subscribed with Notifications on! :)

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +4

      Thanks a lot, man :) Really means a lot to me :)

  • @fowreeeeeeeel
    @fowreeeeeeeel Před 7 měsíci +13

    Man this is interesting, really looking forward to part 2. You are good at storytelling.

  • @J1drz
    @J1drz Před 6 měsíci +4

    Good video. You should do What if Obi-Wan went to fight Palpatine and Yoda went to fight Lord Vader on Mustufar next

  • @RandomBlackGuyisrandom
    @RandomBlackGuyisrandom Před 7 měsíci +5

    Dang man. You really left me on a cliffhanger. I can't wait for part 2

  • @Godzilla_kotm_
    @Godzilla_kotm_ Před 6 měsíci +4

    If mace fought grievous he'd learn maces unique style which would easily be able to kill Anakin

  • @PugOverboard
    @PugOverboard Před 6 měsíci +3

    Two twists on ideas that people have already done.
    1. What if after Anakin saved Luke at the end of ROTJ it was Luke who died from his injuries while Anakin survived. I’ve often seen Anakin survival stories done before but he was always has Luke as a support system. What does Anakin do in a post ROTJ world if he doesn’t have Luke to help him?
    2. What if Palpatine managed to also corrupt Padme during ROTS and not just Anakin? I’ve seen a million what if Padme was a sith storeia but this wouldn’t be that. It’s still the standard non force sensitive Padme. It’s just what if he managed to corrupt Padme into seeing things his way? Maybe it’s his sweet words, maybe he warps her mind with the force. Either way I think it would be interesting if Palpatine had the support of Vader AND his wife during the fall of the republic.
    What do you think?

  • @warsawpactmapping83
    @warsawpactmapping83 Před 7 měsíci +3

    These long videos are always wonderful!!

  • @mannyperalta1064
    @mannyperalta1064 Před 6 měsíci +5

    Grievously injured good one

  • @benjaminparker671
    @benjaminparker671 Před 7 měsíci +9

    What If Obi-Wan trained Barriss during the time of The Clone Wars (assuming Luminara died in Attack Of The Clones)

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +5

      Ahsoka might’ve ended up staying with the Order messing up Sidious’ plans! I should make that one at some point . Thanks:)

    • @wozn7195
      @wozn7195 Před 6 měsíci +2

      ​@@starwarsquillWell one little thing already did mess up the plan - And thats Obi going to Mustafar and making cuts to his planned personell...
      And I guess having someone to care for - And who you would very likely regret to bring with you -
      Might have changed the only thing that really pulled down the planning long-term.
      Imagine a peak performance Vader, No surviving siblings for the rebellion and yoda dying alone in the swamp without teaching anything to anyone..

  • @radioactiveassassin5218
    @radioactiveassassin5218 Před 7 měsíci +2

    3:27 Oh veeeeeery funny.

  • @elw8742
    @elw8742 Před 4 měsíci +2

    I think you forgot that anakin went to palatines office because they got word that obi wan had defeated grievous so anakin would not have gone to palatines office but otherwise great story

  • @Kvempita
    @Kvempita Před 5 měsíci +2

    What if emergency powers were not given to palpatine

  • @darknessbobulus
    @darknessbobulus Před 2 měsíci

    Please release a part 2.

  • @arthurmorgan8529
    @arthurmorgan8529 Před 6 měsíci +2

    Then palpatine would've sent anakin to deal with him

  • @HumanitarianTeam
    @HumanitarianTeam Před 6 měsíci

    Great Video!

  • @johnpittsii7524
    @johnpittsii7524 Před 7 měsíci +3

    Great video ❤

  • @edwardsolomon1951
    @edwardsolomon1951 Před 6 měsíci +11

    Palpatine just plays the nice guy and agrees the war is over, and masterminds another conflict years into the future, while killing Anakin's loved ones from the shadows (Padme, his children and Ahsoka).

  • @Jnigo
    @Jnigo Před 7 měsíci +1

    Part 2 please

  • @eminaslanozbek4639
    @eminaslanozbek4639 Před 6 měsíci

    amazing, truly

  • @nathansebolt7219
    @nathansebolt7219 Před 3 měsíci

    He would've taken Obi Wan's lightsaber and made it a fine addition to his collection

  • @mohammadhosseini6675
    @mohammadhosseini6675 Před 4 měsíci

    I have to share something that’s just happened at 2:03 a ad of KFC showed up and said shut up and take my money just as Sidous was about to talk hilarious ain’t it.

  • @silasgs9257
    @silasgs9257 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Sidious would have definitely been talking to a then-enraged Anakin after Obi-wans near death experience vs Grevious. Anakin in his rage begs the council for permission to go after Grevious. Windu decides his emotions are to dangerous to be involved and that he would kill Grevious for revenge rather than justice. He takes it upon himself to go after Grevious and the council agrees. Anakin remains silent and storms off to Palpatine's quarters. Seeking guidance and friendship in his moment of grief. Seizing the opportunity to tell Anakin that he is 100% right to want to avenge his master. It's only natural to desire vengeance, he is human afterall, Sidious would imply. It would go like this:
    Palpatine: It is only natural to want glory and to secure ones high ranking position such as Master Windu's. Imagine... the man who brought an end to the clone war... now that is a title a man, jedi or otherwise... could only dream of. He would go down in the Archives a Hero after he slays Grevious and brings an end to all this madness.
    Anakin: But he fled... no one knows his current location.
    Palpatine rising from his chair, a comforting touch upon Anakins shoulder as he motions him to the window. Overlooking a busy Coruscant. Anakin feels a strange comfort in this moment, as if Palpatine was the only one who truly understood him and the weight of his thirst for revenge. As if he had no reason to feel guilty.
    Palpatine: That.. may not be entirely true.
    Anakin: What do you mean?
    Palpatine with a convincing look of concern etched on his face begins to pace around his quarters, Anakin keeping a close distance to him. Eager to hear more he hangs on his every word.
    'It's not something I want to do Anakin, but in uncertain times like these... you never know who you can trust." Palpatine turns to look at Anakin, now standing beside his desk he looks at him with conviction as he continues to speak. "Even the Jedi council..."
    Anakin: Chancellor I--
    Palpatine abruptly continues speaking. "They're holding you back Anakin... you know it to be true. They think themselves above the law, above the courts and the senate... that is why I am sending you on a private mission to assassinate Grevious."
    Anakin overcome with emotions of relief... his eyes brighten but his expression almost fades as quickly as it came. "But the council already doesn't trust me I want to kill Grevious but I know I shouldn't...no.. I can't"
    Palpatine reaching under his desk turning on a hologram revealing a planet with a small red area marked with exact coordinates listed. Anakin looks to it.. excitement rumbles just beneath his surface his thirst is almost re-ignited knowing now where Grevious hides.
    Palpatine: "We intercepted his coordinates as he left utapau... Anakin I trust you and only you with this sensitive mission. I suspect the council is using the war as a means to seize power and military control. It is why a Jedi master Sifo Dyas orchestrated the creation of the clone army all those years ago. I fear if they curry anymore favor with the people and the systems we will have civil war on our hands.”
    Anakins view not fully alligning with Palpatines on the matter. He proceeds to be inquisitive. “You think the Jedi are prolonging the war”
    Palpatine speaks softly but sternly. “If the Jedi publicly end the war and march into the senste with a battalion of clones. Who they fought with, who they saved, who they bleed with. Who do they turn their blasters towards?”
    Palpatine continues, “Anakin remember what I told you about power. They fear to lose it.”
    Anakin: you’re the chancellor…the most powerful man in the galaxy.
    Palpatine. I wish it were true sometimes… imagine the lives I could of saved… the pain I could of prevented if the wheels of justice didnt turn so slowly in the senate. What does true power come from Anakin?
    Anakin: The jedi would teach it comes from within ones self
    Palpatine responds swiftly: Armies… and the Jedi created their own.
    Anakin visibly taking everything Palpatine is saying into considerstion. The smallest smirk appears on palpatines face.
    “Go now, help me save the republic and create an era of peace”

    • @silasgs9257
      @silasgs9257 Před 7 měsíci +3

      This would be with Sidious knowing full well that the clones follow his orders.
      But manipulating Anakin to poke holes in his trust of the jedi and to fear for palpatines safety

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +1

      This is insanely good!

  • @nathans9208
    @nathans9208 Před 6 měsíci

    I wanna see a general grevious become a bounty hunter

  • @bluntslt8023
    @bluntslt8023 Před 6 měsíci

    Part 2 please!!

  • @jamesplunkett8912
    @jamesplunkett8912 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Make a story What if General Grievous was defeated on Mustafar by the Jedi hunting him? I picture a lava river fight taking part against Grievous and the powerful Jedi council members like Yoda, Mace, Anakin, Obi-Wan, Ahsoka, Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, Eeth Keth, and Plo Koon.
    The death of Grievous would have to be done after Palpatine was arrested or killed by Anakin and he'll be made a Jedi Master for helping take down the Jedi hunting cyborg shortly once he killed the last of the Sith. And Ahsoka Tano would become a Jedi Knight as her master is officially granted the rank of Master.
    This would make Master Skywalker the Jedi who ended the Clone Wars, fillfulled the prochecy of bringing balance to the force, and brought forth a new era of peace to the Galaxy with the Sith gone and vanquished. 😊

  • @zc16_
    @zc16_ Před 6 měsíci

    i need that part 2 ASAP!!!

  • @the.unhappy.mechanic
    @the.unhappy.mechanic Před 6 měsíci

    Great story 😊

  • @dollarsignmexican
    @dollarsignmexican Před 7 měsíci +12

    My favorite part was when General Grievous says: "It's Grievousing time!" and Grievoused all over those guys.

  • @yolo4592
    @yolo4592 Před 7 měsíci +1

    What if plo fought palatine instead of mace

  • @carnage0685
    @carnage0685 Před 6 měsíci +2

    omfg yes

  • @Banana_boat
    @Banana_boat Před 5 měsíci

    Do you ever do part 2s? Where is part 2?

  • @EmperorFawful
    @EmperorFawful Před měsícem

    After listening to the whole thing
    (++ Spoilers alert for everyone still watching the video while reading the comment section! ++)
    I would disagree on the note of Palpatine's reasoning at the end - rather I'd say he'd go full Order 66 mode at the point when Mace broadcasts the capturing of the Separatist leaders.
    The inhibitor chips will still force the clones to do as said and while Order 66 wouldn't reach the full potential it had during the actual timeline, it would still cause enough confusion to kill enough Jedi.
    With the Jedi now suddenly locked into fighting the Clones, Sidious would utilize Grievous further, given that despite his failure he had regretably more uses than ever, informing him that the Separatist Council has shut down the droid armies across the majority of the galaxy from Mustafar, meaning that he has to find ways of re-activating these forces. So all Grievous has to do is to transmit the order to re-activate the droid forces manually, claiming that the Jedis are trying to decieve their movement, thus prolonging further the conflict on fronts, as suddenly admidst all the Order 66 chaos, deactivated droids begin to activate and continiue on again as by protocol.
    So in the end it could lead into all directions now, as while Order 66 unfolds, more Jedi might survive the sudden betrayal, as there was a brief fire pause from deactivating the droids galaxy-wide, making it more of a challenge for Palpatine to actually achieve his original plans.
    In the guise of Sidious though, he would further utilize chaos by going to the Jedi temple and releasing Maul from the prison, offering him 'a last chance to proof himself as a loyal apprentice'.
    Maul might not like Sidious, perhaps even refuse the offer and attacking Sidious straight in hopes that he would die that way quicker, but once again Sidious would just toy with Maul and perhaps even leave the fight ealier, only to let Maul be confronted by the entirety of the Jedi within the temple, that are now attempting to get rid of both the clones that breached through and the Sith, that invaded their halls. Wheras Maul would probably consider to just fight his way out, killing also various Jedi on his way out, making it on the holo videos later even seem like Sidious and Maul are still allied with eachother.
    How it will conclude?
    Perhaps the remaining Jedi gather and confront Palpatine directly, perhaps it even comes to a duel that they win, but at the cost of a shattered Republic admidst chip-crazed Clones and a rebooting Separatist army, that seeks to finish the job they started.
    Or Palpatine actually goes along with what the Jedi claimed, fakes his own death at the hands of the Jedi by leaving a last obscured transmission and enough coverup, only to actually allow the Separatists this time to win the war, leading now Grievous directly on his leash, just as Dooku did prior. It might end up in both remnants of the Republic and various Separatist commanders, who have grown desillusioned by the war to actually fight this new threat under Grievous, but it might still make for an interesting scenario, given that with each re-activated Droid army and production facility, Sidious will now pump out the full potential of the Separatist armies.
    Heck, I could even imagine Palpatine giving Tarkin in response to Order 66 the order to fly with a Venator fleet directly to Kamino in order to shatter the clone facilities, just to ensure that the Republic and the Jedi could not weaponize their own assets against him.
    And Maul... who knows, maybe he'll ally up with the remaining Jedi and potentially even become the key in killing Sidious once and for all in a last dramatic standoff. Or he just vanishes into the shadows, as he did prior, knowing that Sidious can't be stopped. A threat for the Jedi Order at another time.
    These would at least be my thoughts of how it could continiue on realistically, as I doubt there's at this point hardly anything that could stop a lethal Order 66, even if the Republic manages to quickly recover from this betrayal with a new Chancellor being elected and cancelling the given orders. Just the chance that more Jedi survive the moment because of an earlier droid shutdown could at least make it less bitter in the end and also give the Jedi a chance for a sort-of good ending.
    It might end in a Grievous-led Separatist regime, that might only be held together by Sidious puppeteering remaining commanders and corrupt corporate leaders on the Separatist side after a long war of attrittion against a severely damaged Republic, who can't continiue creating new clones to replace their fallen soldiers,
    but the chances of a Shattered Republic with a semi-intact Jedi Order coming out of this scenario is higher.
    And on a plus note: Even if Anakin doesn't turn or dies in this scenario by whatever factor, chances are higher as well, that Luke and Leia can grow up on Naboo peacefully.

  • @joecool2501
    @joecool2501 Před 4 měsíci

    When will part 2 made?

  • @MatthewJamesKalasky
    @MatthewJamesKalasky Před 6 měsíci

    23:16 Wasn't Obi Wan's transmitter damaged, limiting its range?

  • @chasetopsecret2018
    @chasetopsecret2018 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Of course he will still execute it and cause damage to the jedi he could still kill a lot maybe even all the jedi

    • @TheUncivilizedNation
      @TheUncivilizedNation Před 7 měsíci +2

      Yeah with Ahsoka making it back the entire 501st legion is on planet. Doubling the force they had in the movie canonically. And there’s also 3 Star Destroyer’s in orbit

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +2

      My thinking was that if he were to execute it, the Jedi would be killed but since they haven’t committed any treason here and with the war over, Palpatine won’t be able to create the Empire so smoothly like in the original timeline. I could be wrong tho…I’ll go over it in part 2 :)

  • @miguelalves5514
    @miguelalves5514 Před 6 měsíci +3

    I believe in this scenario, Sidious still can make the Empire.
    But it will be a fractured one. But with a lot of suport from the corrupt senators and millitary.
    The empire is created for "maitain the galaxy secure form the jedi" sidious can create something simmilar, only to protect the civilization form the sith.

  • @CrysVamp
    @CrysVamp Před 7 měsíci +2

    I have one for you. What If Sidious, Grievous and Tyranus, all died when the Malevolence had a critical failure due to droid repairing the wrong damaged area of a ship. Or if during the fight, one of the B2 battledroid blasted killed the chained chancellor lmao.

    • @starwarsquill
      @starwarsquill  Před 7 měsíci +2

      I’ll definitely do that at one point! Thanks :)

    • @debutriah2854
      @debutriah2854 Před 7 měsíci +1

      Malevolence? Sidious was never on that ship

    • @debutriah2854
      @debutriah2854 Před 7 měsíci +1

      You mean the invisible hand?

    • @CrysVamp
      @CrysVamp Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@debutriah2854 Yesh! my bad. I wasn't sure of the name. Been two years since i last watched the prequels.

  • @masscreationbroadcasts
    @masscreationbroadcasts Před měsícem

    31:40 Please stop lying. I'll need to keep track of when else have you done it, but you have released a "What if Order 66 Failed", but on another premise, you never made this part 2.

  • @cecilarthurton3795
    @cecilarthurton3795 Před 2 měsíci

    what if anankin was born female