Netflix's Sign In Page Gets A Rating Of...
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 08. 2024
- #webdevelopment #webdesign #netflix
Watch as I show you how I would redesign Netflix's mobile sign in page if I had the chance.
Support the channel: ko-fi.com/hype... (accepts PayPal, card, etc).
Netflix: www.netflix.com
Music Credits:
Red Green Blue - StreamBeats - Lofi - Harris Heller
Like this comment if you agree all websites should remove their sign up buttons so no more accounts can be made ever again.
As someone who makes several accounts a month for random stuff, please no
@@JoaquinBauman it’s very clearly a joke tho
I think the sign up buttons are a legal issue and if they were to remove it, that would make some lawyers day.
Bad video lol
You know what just release them as theme mods 😂
bro literally got rid of the remember me and sign up buttons 💀
I was waiting for 'take a away the username and password cause im probably already signed in and dont need to do it again' but nah this dude is 100% serious lmao
i dont have a account :(
It’s the login page, why would you even need a sign up. And remember me is kinda not needed with Chrome or Apple password saving.
@@hiroshotreplica They have a main page, what he is showing is the login one. Apple and Chrome automatically save or ask to save login info when you first login using an Apple device or the Chrome browser.
@@striderpup1169 yes it is. I watch on my phone. In the app. Leave it. Every site should have a remember me. The only website I know that doesn’t is fucking college board. Well they do. It just doesn’t work.
The "Sign up now" is something that needs to stay, that's literally how I created my account...
This video is a joke
Genius here
@@TheUnderscore_ it’s this guy that doesn’t understand
@@Giopants101 ?
Nah really that’s how u created ur account never would’ve guessed😂. Jk
Man's the type of guy to think the terms and conditions are for decoration.
Man’s the type of guy that reads the terms and conditions
It is
@OwO ok
@@Cow29389 companies are legally required to show them to you
@@fizzcochito yeah but no one reads them
The reCAPTCHA has to be disclosed on websites.
According to the internet police of the world I bet? 💀
@@shawndythomas2683according to the people who made it, as a condition for using it.
@@ebux9885 well i dont think its a dev thing its more of a legal thing
@@nyaa posted that at like 5 am i was too tired lol mb
@@shawndythomas2683 according to the law
Ladies and gentlemen, that's why we don't let designers make business decisions
True
The whole purpose of a designer is to make good calls on designing a screen like that. It should be based on research tho and not just aesthetic preferences as to not guesswork (which i think is the case in this video)That’s why ux designers are needed for jobs like that.
Bro it's a video and obviously a joke don't get your panties in a twist.
I agree with removing the CAPCHA stop making me prove I'm not a bot, it's annoying
@@jarema9999 to bad this "designer" removed key elements of the sign in page. A designer shouldn't just make it look good, but also unique and functional.
Looks great, but actually way worse in my opinion. I think functionality always goes before design. Maybe you can find a way to keep the functionality. Also the reCaptcha text *has* to be on this page as per the terms of use and common data privacy laws. The imprint also has to be on there for compliance reasons in some countries. I think it's an interesting discussion despite the video mostly being a joke. I think it's a typical beginner problem as a designer.
Yep, the way the page is laid out looks like all of the clutter was an afterthought because they realised they needed it for compliance. Their original idea was probably very similar to the one in the video.
I think he should have removed a lot but not the important stuff like sign up and remember me
didn’t get the joke.
@@Roxleton what joke? He does it in every video. He takes a good and easy to memorize layout and makes it modern with Additional cluster that didnt need to be their and wasn't their before.
@@peteressert5172 Eh depends, it certainly is like that for anyone used to them. But it does leave less options for the eyes to go through so you get to where you want quicker.
But this vid is a joke, because clearly, removing the new account button for the sake of aesthetics is just not something anyone would do. Netflix already has a modern aesthetic so there's nothing to be done really. I guess you can clean things up but that's just a waste of effort.
My mans just deleted half of the stuff you need 💀
”Dont need”*
Yes bro, he deleted remember me ☠
Bro delete the log in 💀
@@ZapDaw so watcha gonna do when your account gets hacked and you need a new account
@@ZapDaw ah yes you don't need the button that creates you an account
he: adds grid effect and ripple effect
my phone: *dies brutally*
Also the ripple effect maybe can affect someone with epilepsy
There is a lot of valid criticism in the comments but resource consumption and epileptic risks do not apply to what would probably be a simple APNG
How tf am I supposed to make a Netflix account now.
Edit: so many people took this seriously. I was just making a damn joke, chill out.
good.
On their website.
It's 2022, you should have an account by now /s
@@MarcoSpaceMan276 'twas a joke
FMovies :)
I like the redesign but I do like functionality too. Also I think instead of the red colour coming in when you sign up, the classic Netflix colour ribbons would look awesome! Still a great redesign, love it!
Hear me out, the color ribbons come out of the button and expand like their intros, revealing everything, instead of having just the red background loading :D
Also they most likely need to disclose the CAPTCHA legally, and the other information is helpful. Imagine you need customer service/ something like that but the only button is "SIGN IN"
It already happens on the TV app when you launch a movie so they have it aorted out there. Not a lot of work to implement to login page.
@@AraiDigital That's what I meant to say, thanks!
@@jacob.rausch ah I see, still tho, could've been put there better
One of the MOST irritating things about UI and Web pages these days is if you DO actually need to call the place on the phone it can be like following a cryptic treasure map to find a phone number. If I can't fix my issue online and I decide I need to call, I NEED TO CALL!! Like, calling is a last resort, but just give me the goddamn number to call!
Removes legally required text*
bro the remember me and forgot password are literally the most important parts of that page haha
And sign up
i mean remember me is not needed really, it should always remember you until you log out but yeah
removing forgot password was dumb
@@nomadshiba absolutely not, u realize some people use netflix on other devices, like at a friends house. You wouldnt want it to stay logged in unless you tell it to
Are they, though?
"A loading icon??"
10 secs later: let's add a loading icon 👍
It’s a more interesting loading screen than just the sign in page with a spinning circle.
@@striderpup1169 no. a full screen loading screen still sucks tbh
@@Ruri0120 Yes, what happens when the system checks and finds you didn't give the right password. Then it'd have to go back from the loading screen to the sign in page.
The ReCAPTCHA thing is put automatically by the RECAPTCHA creators, and its not allowed to be removed.
Exactly what I was thinking. You are legally required to show the text if you are using recaptcha
Netflix be digging a hole for themselves if they do this lol
Nonono the phone number thing is AMAZING! I hate waiting for emails and those unhelpful chats. Phone call with a real person is the quickest way to sort out issues.
Exactly, who wants to dig around the About us section to find no number xD.
Yeah a lot of companies already make it so hard to contact customer service let alone talk to an actual person why hide the phone number?
then you can look up the number lol
man is really thinking he is gonna call a support number from a big company and talk directly to a person instead of a bot
@@YuriG03042have u ever called customer support service
Totally agree emails and passwords are annoying but passwords are way more harder to forget
a lot of people dont like your redisigns but i love them all
people who don‘t have an acc: uuuuuhhhhh
edit: damn, so many likes. I didn‘t expect that
It'll auto recognize and boot you to the sign up page
@@owet2184 that's not really how that works
@@owet2184 how is it supposed to recognize it?
@@Vtraxio You put in your details, click sign in, and it recognises that you don’t have an account, and boots up the sign up pages
@@Vtraxio browser cookies
you should’ve posted this video on April Fools so that people would see the joke, lol.
What joke?
@@lachlantrescott5533 *the video*
whats the funny
@@CRT_YT he got rid of disclaimers like the captcha
@@alis9425 that's not a good funny
I feel like this was way more to your opinion than what is really needed. Other people like talking on the phone to ask questions or to sign up.
my man gentrified the sign in page 💀💀💀
I love how after working in software u realize graphic designers are exactly like this. Delete everything and some impossible css animations.
The animations are totally possible in CSS, removing the legal stuff, as well as the stuff clients want on there - impossible.
@@PaulMcCannWebBuilder Possible but should you really?
I hate web animations for loading shit, like I would rather it just instantly show up and not force me to wait through your need to glamorize the trivial.
This is why I'm backend. I can't take working with fancy artsy people thinking they are above all.
If you want to know how to make the fancy rippling grid effect here's a tut: czcams.com/video/bAwEj_mSzOs/video.html
nice
You should do twitter next
These are super entertaining, please do more!!
You managed to make the site worse with every step you took. Immaculate.
yall seriously falling for this, he obviously did it on purpose so we would comment more
Some of the stuff is legal stuff and getting rid of "Sign up" makes it harder for people to get a new account if they don't have one.
Also the "remember me" is also very handy, especially for a streaming service where I don't wanna login every time I use it.
The footer with the extra resources is also very useful for people who aren't as "easy understanding" as you.
Hello! We meet again! lol, anyways I do agree, functionality comes first before designing, it has to be well functional at best and easy to use!
Like for example, if you prioritize designs more than functionality you may run into some problems espellicially with not being usable or easy to use/convenient.
A good example is CZcams's User Interface, and while the design looks nice, but they took away some functionality just to make it look good or more "modern" like, here's some stuff they removed:
-Date added oldest feature
-Dislikes
(Included in list because most social media has no dislikes as that is "modern")
-And video thumbnails edges
(This caused some problems with smoother corners)
But yeah you get the idea.
captcha has to be disclosed
CaptainCHA
The mcdonalds line killed me😂😂
This is straight up satire of your own video format and I love it
The site looks nice now but u completely removed all functionality. U could have put a button on the top right to switch between create and sign into accs. An arrow could have been used as a drop down for all extra info and u could have went from there. A good looking sight should not come at the cost of functionality
its a joke
@@modz7675 form deign is no laughing matter
A lot of people forgot about legality as well you gotta say that u use reCaptcha v3
I'd hate that. How are you supposed to know the arrow switches you to sign in?
This is why u need a product manager
The developer gonna hate making it😂
This is cool and all but it’s terrible imo
You got rid of important things that needed to be on the page, such as the reCAPTCHA text and phone number. Also, I don’t like the ripping red block effect, it doesn’t suit Netflix right (just my opinion)
It’s a joke
This looks well cool, as someone getting kinda into graphic design your channel is really fun to watch and is helping me learn new things, please never stop these shorts.
there are so many books going over graphic design and i beg you to read them, the best advice in an industry is always comes from some of the oldest people in it
@@tobe3349 thanks for the tip I'll definitely keep it in mind.
This one was more of a joke
@@DeathnoteBB Why?
@@striderpup1169 bro he got rid of the sign up option. And all the legally required texts. Its fun to look at but would never fly in the real world.
I see a lot of people getting mad here, so let me step in..
People are saying things like “functionality comes before design” or “this is why we don’t let designers make business decisions”..
First of all, design is where “form” (art) and “function” (engineering/development) come together with a user’s perspective in mind! Without proper design you’re left with ugly things that just about so the job, or art pieces that do absolutely nothing but look pretty (subjectively).
So what do you think a UX Designer, Brand Strategist, or Strategic Design are? They’re for business strategy focused on brand/design first to ensure great user experience, gut impressions, and all encompassing strategic planning in alignment with the target user.
Functionality coming before design = all the trashy websites from the 90’s or a generic logo slapped on a tradesman’s van. No design thinking to this, just “does it work, ok it’ll do”.
That’s an engineers MVP approach.
Or the mindset of a concept prototyper.
Having said all this, I do think removing the sign up button under the argument that McDonald’s says “welcome back” is a bit of a stretch. McDonald’s doesn’t require a sign in, so they don’t need to ask if you have an account or not, so it’s totally ok to assume they’re coming back, because if it’s their first time it doesn’t change the user journey.
Instead of removing it completely, it could be moved to a minimal footer, along with the reCAPTCHA declaration.
That way we retain the clean design while keeping the important functionality.
I think a nicer way to put some of the comments would be “functionality INFORMS good design” or “we don’t let designers ALONE make business decisions”.
The details matter!
Singing in at 3pm = burn ur sleepy eyes
I feel like if you added the stuff you removed back in _(like the sign up reminder. phone number and the footer could probably be accessed by a button on the menu)_ it would be a good improvement, definitely like what I see with the background and the idea of the sign-in, though.
Yeah
Bro is the master of thrashing a design.
I love how everybody is shitting on this design when its satire, is hilarious to me
The recaptcha text is a requirement of the terms of service. Either you have that badge floating down the side of the screen or you display that text.
1. you have to include the reCAPTCHA text according to their policy
2. Where can I create an account now?
3. remember me check box is clutter?
4. Some countries require you to have an impressum on the bottom of every page (this of course includes the sign in page on mobile)
1. nice but did i ask
2. On the sign in page. if you wanted to make an account, you wouldn't go to the sign in page...
3. Yes. Most apps don't even have "Remember me" because why wouldn't you want to stay logged in?
4. _Some countries_ which countries? And why lmao. Also why not just on the homepage. You don't need a phone number to log in loool.
@@BostYT 💀
Enhancing design at the cost of functionality is such a frontend dev moment
when a user asks why logins cant just happen in a splitsecond
Lets remove all functionality to make a simplistic design because that’s fashion right now.
What stupid logic is “I don’t like talking on the phone?” So you’re going to remove the way for people to talk with a live representative. Completely garbage design philosophy.
he is an average modern designer - "I don't use the feature, so you should not be able to have access to it".
Good job all you need is a sign in and a funny text whilst it loads like “connecting the mainframe”
Shut up guys, this redesign is just for having fun and making a video, not to take the sign up button
"get rid of the loading icon"
"and i guess if it needs more time we can put a loading icon"
as you all know, if the code works you never question it 😂😂
Bro removing the sign up shit is like not teaching a kid how to walk cuz "cmon is 2022"
Same vibe as removing the headphone port or home button because it's "more aesthetically pleasing".
That ripple effect in bright red would absolutely blind everyone prepared for a nice movie night. Otherwise good idea
I've been loving these!! Keep up the good work👍
"Lets bloat random pages even more because the internet isnt yet bloated enough "
The fact that you didn't have the sign in button make everything dissappear except for the logo and have the logo center and then have it play the iconic zoom in animation with the sound hurts my soul.
I mean the back-end would be glad to work with this design.
I love these videos so much, I have never found a CZcams short more entertaining. That’s a subscribe from me. Keep it up man! I love these!!!!
You obviously they are entertaining as he make them as an joke worse
What the hell, you speaking english?
ok i didn't have Netflix account yet and now maybe it's too late. society's not gonna accept me anymore...
Me who can’t find where to sign up for Netflix now: 🤔
Every franchise redesigning logos:
Remove a bunch of functionality to make it look slightly prettier
"I don't like the page loading so I deleted it"
"But since the page needs to load I'll add that back in"
That pulsing grid bg needs a css tutorial now lol
Seriously how would i create something like that i need to know
i feel like this is a silent protest against Netflix to not get new customers
Bruh I thought he was just gonna get rid of everything and honestly that would be way better than his actual redesign
The loading/asyn button state is used when making a call to the server to validate the users login credentials. In your example, If an error was to occur they would jump from a splash loading screen back to the login page which would jar the experience.
Using an asyn button indicates that your data is being confirmed and if an error occurs the fields will be marked with a critical state and a notice can be displayed without displacing the users position, this also allows the user to be informed of ways to solve the issues in the form.
This is probably the most common and most user friendly experience for a login page.
You murdered UX designers at 'don't recommend me' 🤺
now that's what I call a call UI UX redesign.
great redesign of the sign in page
The “reCAPTCHA” part is legally required.
What the fuck. Dude removed literally half of the functionality to make it look marginally better. This guy represents what is wrong with design philosophy today.
Well, it sucks, you just recently started making these amazing videos and I cannot binge like 20 of them, but keep up the amazing work.
UNDERRATED AF✨!
This was truly amazing ❤️👏
Nah, their designer knew what they were doing.
1. I don't have Netflix account. Everyone should start from something, you can't just leave only already registered people.
2. You required by law to tell people that your site uses ReCAPTCHA
3. It's important for you to control, whether it's your TV/phone/laptop and you should be remembered or you are logging in at someone else home
He's the type of guy to get rid of ads because they obscure the design
Do the HUB
when i go to the McDonalds drive thru they say “alright what do you want to order?” and then get it wrong because of how terribly designed the communication system is
Netflix should hire this guy
I’m not even paying attention to what he’s saying his voice sounds so good
Bro wanted to sue Netflix for hiding info💀
bro sounded so smug when he said "real original netflix"
I have to say the red wipe effect for entering Netflix is actually a really cool idea
“McDonalds doesn’t say welcome, it says welcome back”
Quote of this century
Never once did a McDonald's employee say welcome back
Dark mode was half the battle and Netflix won that part
The "Sign Up" is just a standard for every sign in page in case you don't have an account yet and just downloaded or got recommended the App.
This just made me realize this person has never worked for a fully operating legally bound company.
He also does not account for accessibility in his designs.
Give this man acess to "custom website design"
😌
It is always frustraiting when i cant find the sign up button for things, personally i would keep it
Dude is only thinking of UI and not at all about UX…
Hyperpleaxed: “Really Netflix, a loading icon? Real original.”
Also Hyperpleaxed: “And if it needed more time to load, we could add a loading icon.”
Netflix is gonna pull a flappy bird real quick
This reminds me of the time when i went to Behance to get some inspiration for UI as a developer and learned that as beautiful as those UIs may be the practicality of them is absolutely negligible lol
“They say welcome back” Man’s got an achievement that employees remember him 😭😭
I think instead of a loading circle Netflix should display a procedurally generated 2-bit fake movie poster
Everything that is legally required should stay, along with “forgot password?” and “sign up” options. Those are the basics of any website and are more useful than you think.
The reason he removed the sign up button is because he's telling you to not make an Netflix account in 2023, because Netflix got too greedy.
bro gets angry at his phone for having a startup animation
Every video I've seen of yours turns the apps worse than they were.
I wish *every* support page had a phone line listed as plainly as this does. Wouldn’t have removed that.