I'm a big fan of DiRT games, so I want to share with you my POSITIVE opinion on ALL these games: DiRT: This is where all started, now history! This game had excellent graphics at that time. DiRT 2: PURE FUN + PERFECT PHYSICS + PERFECT GRAPHICS = Still my favorite DiRT game! :) DiRT 3: For the first time Split Screen feature on PC + Gymkhana. Personally I loved this game too. DiRT 4: The most realistic rally in a main DiRT game. DiRT 5: SPLIT SCREEN IS BACK! PURE FUN + MotorStorm/ONRUSH feeling. Probably the best DiRT game since DiRT 2 ! :)
Dirt 2 had the best co-driver who would actually react to your crashes with something like 'my head is spinning', 'don't worry, it's just a scratch, keep going'... And campaign was awesome, and that menu with your little trailer and the car parked outside... Just awesome game.
in dirt 3 for me, the graphical image is very seamless, it's peak codemasters on all fronts. It's like looking at a painting, would've blown people's minds when it first came to PC
@@fifteen8850 Dont. None of the ‘newer’ games have half the development the older generation had. You can tell. Everything that’s come out from basically any genre has been half assed and monetized for money. Just stop man.
Today I reinstalled Dirt2. On 4k tv or 144hz gaming monitor... It doesn't look like a 11 years old game! Sure, we have no flying leafs and such things. But Dirt 2 was such a great game. The presentation was awsome. Also the soundtrack. I loved the menu with the camper and the guys (Travis and Dave). They are a part of my childhood 20 years ago like Mat Hoffman and Tony Hawk. Damn time flys. Greetings from Germany
@@cormacbcb I agree loved this game from start to finish I actually repurchased it not long ago for 360 cause my daughter broke my original disk, dont even play my 360 any more just wanted it fro my collection :)
@@MJ-uk6lu what’s weird is that DiRT has very bad optimization because it stutters a lot when I play it on my mid end pc. Even it can run DiRT 3 on medium settings smoothly at 30 fps.
Started playing dirt 5 recently and thought it feels too easy, so I thought I'd go back to dirt 3 and immediately noticed it feels more grounded and realistic. Probably nostalgia but dirt 3 was and still is my favourite one and it still holds up pretty damn strong in 2021.
@@kazzng2087 I very first time to try D5 last couple weeks i was a huge fan in x360 D3 and iam very F.. Ing dissapointed about this shit after past almost 10 years development. Not about the grapich the controlling and AI. Thats why is a smart idea the xbox game pass because you can get free those shit games. Just imagine if you bought that shit almost 60-70usd or eur what ever you want. Same!!!
Hmm based on the calculations of each titles nom I predict that the best DIRT on an average is =(1+2+3+4+5)/5= 3 Thus i come to the conclusion that DIRT 3 is the best until now. 😅
The newer they get, the worse they get. These developers try so hard to make games more realistic and it just makes them worse and worse. Every racing franchise has gone downhill. Dirt 2 will forever be the king and we need a remaster with the old physics
as a fan of rally games i played dirt 3 and dirt 4 and personally i love dirt 4 because is a kind of realism and a arcade together and thats why i liked so much is the perfect balance for me not too arcade but also not too realism to be a simulation game also brings me back to the old colin mcrae games :)
in dirt 3 for me, the graphical image is very seamless, it's peak codemasters on all fronts. It's like looking at a painting, would've blown people's minds when it first came to PC
Is it just me or dirt 5 graphics looks downgraded compared to dirt 4? Also why this 4:39 looks a bit better than this 4:52? It should be the opposite. Sometimes old games looks better than the new ones.
@@pettiwhisker7792 they were barely even randomly generated it was the same 3/4 parts every single time but in a different order like the one hairpin in australia, i saw it in every stage just in different locations, extremely lazy imo
Dirt - Oh okay this is how dirt looked back then Dirt 2 - Wow nice improvements it almost looks like a modern game Dirt 3 - Damn it straight looks like it came out this year! Dirt 4 - Wait what are you doing? this doesn't look as good as before Dirt 5 - : I
@@InternetMouse Yeah. I have played dirt 2 3 and 4. Also dirt rally. Dirt 2 has the best world physics. I mean that the tire-ground contact us by far the most realistic when it comes to mud water and slippery areas. On the other hand, dirt 3 has the best car control and in my opinion looks the best. Except from the water mud physics. Dirt 4 is just... Another type of game. It's too arcade. It's like playing carx rally or rush rally 3 at the phone. Dirt rally, is the most realistic. Not in vehicle damage. If you want realism you will play BeamNG, but here we talk about rally games. So. Dirt 2. Best worldphysics. Dirt 3. Best look and car physics. Dirt 4. Is another game in the arcade category. And dirt 5. Dirt 5 is a new game. It will get patched and many many improvements will be made. It's too early to talk. I can't criticize it. If you compare dirt 5 with cyberpunk 2077, there is almost not difference. Both are early access games, Still on development. So. No complains about the new game
Yeah I flippin love Dirt 3 for how it looks and feels. Dirt 4 looks a bit cartoonish, way too bright and cheerful for this game, and Dirt 5 is just… I mean, I’m digging the water and mud thing but *no*
I think what we need is a bit of a graphics clean up and frame rate boost on dirt 2 and 3 and release it as a bundle (keep the physics and engine as they are )
Nice video, it's what I'm after to help me decide if I should hope for Dirt 5 to be improved or just buy Dirt 4. Suggestion though, please don't add music as it's important to be able to compare sounds also
Dirt 2 looks good due to the realistic damage , mean looking vehicles , the overwhelming dirt effects , and mainly the orangish background light and soft edges of vehicles make it look great.
Fully agree dirt has lost its edge since 2 and 3, I cant explain it but they felt more free back then and more fun, these days they go for like 100% sim which is cool but not always fun and they look depressing all the time like gloomy stages if u get me.
Yes. Cockpit view is perfect in DIRT2. Everything in DIRT2 is nearly perfect. AND NOW! Cockpit is finally perfect in DIRT5!!!!!!!! And the windshield wipers feels just RIGHT! Just as good as Driveclub. Hope water phyics on WIndshield may get upgrade to DC level in next game.
Dirt 1 was like pretending to be in a band Dirt 2 was like finding your favorite unsigned band that melted you face off Dirt 3 was like that band bring polished by a record label, but lost a lot of the angst That you loved.
@@blakecooper669 I own 1-4, 2 being my fav. Yet I hated 4 at first. Bad menus limited content etc. But the unlimited tracks made me stick with it. For dirt 4 For handling between dirt 2 and 3 Select gamer difficulty and turn off everything, traction control, anti lock breaking etc For handling like dirt rally 1 and 2.0 Select simulation and turn on everything to 1, traction control breaking etc For insane select simulation and turn everything off. When your done go buy WRC9😁
@@blakecooper669 I miss the arcade racer. Nobody today can make an arcade racer even half as fun but in dirt 1-dirt 3 era there were so many good ones.
I played Dirt 2, 3 and 4. Dirt 2 was every time my favorite Game. Dirt 3 is OK, the dust looks much better, but the Game play istn so much funny as Dirt 2. It looks that Dirt 4 and 5 is a step Backwards. It isn't so much funny, online you can't see other Players in Rally. The physics doesn't look so good for the fact that there are successors. My fav. is Dirt 2
4 I didn't like because of the penalty system. 2 was great but because it isn't backward compatible I'd play 3 more. If they combined the 2 games together it would be immense
@@cormacbcb Yes in 4 you got an penalty of 10 secons AND get reset back on the road. this is to much, cause you have to restart the speed sometimes in the beginning of a corner. 2 was only fun pure. 3 was a combi of 4 and 2. The style of 4, but more fun like part 2.( I liked the style of pt 2 more) Am I right that you cant play 2 on windows cause GAMES FOR WINDOWS LIFE?
@@SILE141 to be fair the penalty system wasn't the biggest problem. I fucking hated the generated stage thing. I prefer finding courses I like so I can keep improving on them
Dirt 3 PC was the first driving game I purchased, keep hoping a substantial improvement in graphics & physics will be released but I haven't seen it yet!
for me i think dirt 4 is overall better than the others maybe it wanted a click of graphics but in saturation color physics sound behavior driving even details was better than the others
Imo dirt 2 still looks and feels the best, the whole desig of the game was just awesome from start to finish. Have not played 5 yet but not likening all the bright colours looks like forza festival too much for me (I like forza but 2 different games). EDIT: Now own dirt 5, Not anything like any of the previous dirt titles, it's basically Onrush 2, as a Dirt game disappointing, as a new standalone title yes I would have been all for it because it's actually really fun, but it is an entirely new feeling of gameplay and visuals which are sub par to its predecessors. However the fun factor is definitely there in the online level designs.
Bravo for this comparison. Well done. It helped me a lot to decide which I`ll drive. When I saw Dirt 5 for the fist time I thought order I`m getting mad or this game is bullshit. Now, when I see that most of you think the same, now I`m really disappointed. How can it be ? Are the producers blind or strongly drugged !?
I don't know if it's only related to this comparison video but oh man does DiRT 5 look horribly bad. DiRT 3 is quite possibly my favourite title along with DiRT 4. I'm yet to try the first two games.
Dirt 2 and 3 were perfect but dirt 2 style and soundtrack and campaign was more fun with 3x the cars at dirt 3 but dirt 3 was more serious and the multi-player was insane dirt4 was ok and dirt 5 was terrible I hope dirt 6 brings back the feel of dirt 2
Dirt 2 is the best ever.. I bought Dirt 5 cause the style reminded me a lot of Dirt 2 yet the feeling I get remembering Dirt 2 with the Monster vinyl on the Hammer making big jumps and drifting and smashing the others. Graphics like in Dirt 2 will always be good cause they are a bit from both cartoonish and realistic a bit with an arcade feeling yet half a simulator It's just classic. Dirt 3 is good too I just didn't find anything more special in it from dirt 2 except gymkhana maps. Dirt 5 is good but it didn't reach the hype I was looking for from Dirt 2 maybe cause I'm older .. Dunno I'll download Dirt 2 just to find out is it really that good as I remember :D.
Dirt 5 looks the best in most areas (as it should), the frame rate was low but I'd put that down to system performance. Good comparison video either way, nice one.
It's a joke how DiRT got devolved by 2020, in terms of everything. DiRT 5 is the shame of the series. Shame of the new generation/end of the previous generation, especially for a car game.
@@shinobiblade2558 Nice! I don't get the peoples that say D4 Is a graphic downgrade by the way, i think dirt4 graphics it's better and colorful (finally sepia filter removed 😂). But dirt2.0 it's the best rally game i ever played!!
@@shinobiblade2558 i didn't bought dirt5 maybe one day with a huge steam sale i will, but i read and saw a lot of reviews and i agree with the guys that said it's basically motorstorm pacifict rift mixed with forza horizon. Talkin about D5, in the steam library my dirt4 has "become" dirt5: i mean all the pictures and the logos have changed from D4 to D5, but it's only in the steam library that i have this new glich. In game it's still D4 and works as always...
------Plz note------(dirt 1 2 3 4 using ego engine dirt 5 using ONRUSH engine) And yes dirt 5 have better texture better grass better everything except dirt but the way dirt 5 look compare to 1 2 3 it looks flat they are chasing realistic look sometime it is good some time it is bad depends on the weather that's why people will look at this and say it's downgrade
People can find old car and new car, recycle parts and stll the car fueled with old gasoline, but now game industry seems focus on graphic and people will complain or called dev lazy if they didnt make it nextgen or somehow reuse the game assets that can run on "old pc". I believe they can save time and put better content if dirt 5 were made with same dirt 2 or 3 engine
I own 1-4, 2 being my fav. Yet I hated 4 at first. Bad menus limited content etc. But the unlimited tracks made me stick with it. For dirt 4 For handling between dirt 2 and 3 Select gamer difficulty and turn off everything, traction control, anti lock breaking etc For handling like dirt rally 1 and 2.0 Select simulation and turn on everything to 1, traction control breaking etc For insane select simulation and turn everything off. When your done go buy WRC9😁
Dirt 2 is my all time favorite. The driving physics so feel so good. I love rally stages the most. I don't play Dirt rally because it's just boring. Regular Dirt series adds some flare and energy. I'm very disappointed in Dirt 5 rally tracks. They're so wide and unrealistic to me. Like a Sega Rally game. I love technical and narrow stages like how a normal backroad/country road would actually be. Probably will wait yet again for the next Dirt game. I need a Dirt 2 remake with more tracks and cars. My first rally game was Colin McRae Rally 2005. I've yet to see a rally game with stages and car damage as unforgiving as that game. Maybe in Dirt Rally? IDK.
I look at dirt 1 and it still looks amazing. They totally nailed the saturation of colors and the contrast. Dirt 2 is less amazing to me, dirt 3 is too washed out and dirt 4 maybe a tad over-saturated. btw dirt 1 had the best variety in the environment and locations, as I recall the sequels all failed to reach that level. despite it had many imperfections I still kinda prefer that game. Call me a boomer :)
@Wundermax 1 I was really amazed by DiRT 1 too when it's released. Especially how realistic it looks. But for me DiRT2 with it's awesome soundtrack and fun (although a little arcady) driving mechanism really made it to be my favorite of the series! I think you could give DiRT2 a second chance if you haven't already played it for more than a few hours! :)
@@PlayGroundComparisons I played it more than that, but not to completion. I do agree, the driving mechanism and game engine issues from dirt1 were gone in dirt2. It also looks similar in the art direction, though in general this was the part I had issues with, too much in-game super star vibe :) Nevertheless thanks for the advice, I will dig up my wheel and replay both dirt1 and 2, so that I could have fun and compare them. Cheers! Edit: Oh and you made an awesome comparison video!
Concordo. Só joguei o Dirt 3 mas é um ótimo jogo e o melhor(pelo que vejo). Já vi gente reclamar dele por causa do modo gymkhana, e que o controle do carro é ruim porque desliza, o gráfico é apagado mais é tudo questão de aprender a jogar e corrigir a cor pelo driver da placa de vídeo
I'm a big fan of DiRT games, so I want to share with you my POSITIVE opinion on ALL these games:
DiRT: This is where all started, now history! This game had excellent graphics at that time.
DiRT 2: PURE FUN + PERFECT PHYSICS + PERFECT GRAPHICS = Still my favorite DiRT game! :)
DiRT 3: For the first time Split Screen feature on PC + Gymkhana. Personally I loved this game too.
DiRT 4: The most realistic rally in a main DiRT game.
DiRT 5: SPLIT SCREEN IS BACK! PURE FUN + MotorStorm/ONRUSH feeling. Probably the best DiRT game since DiRT 2 ! :)
Same here love DIRT 2, it was my first Dirt game. DIRT 5 is going to be my second.😁
I'm a massive fan of the DiRT games and love them all! Here's my ranking:
1. DiRT 5
2. DiRT 1
3. DiRT 3
4. DiRT 2
5. DiRT 4
@@thezeon5 what about DIRT showdown?
@@sandstinger3454
IMO, DiRT Showdown shoud've been a expansion to DiRT 3, rather a seperate full game.
@@thezeon5 I couldn't enjoy it much tho . I was halway through when my PS3 motherboard burned.
i'm 40 years old, still playing dirt 2 and dirt 3
Dirt 2 had the best co-driver who would actually react to your crashes with something like 'my head is spinning', 'don't worry, it's just a scratch, keep going'... And campaign was awesome, and that menu with your little trailer and the car parked outside... Just awesome game.
Bro dirt 3 co driver has the same replies
Dirt 3: 'I see, you're giving them a head start, how kind of you'
Dirt 4 does that too, the co driver will also alert you if the engine or muffler sounds damaged. Also will mention which tire specifically is damaged
I think Dirt 2 and 3 really got the look and feel nailed down.
same here
in dirt 3 for me, the graphical image is very seamless, it's peak codemasters on all fronts. It's like looking at a painting, would've blown people's minds when it first came to PC
Dirt 3 looks so good 4:46 almost photorealistic
Yeah, Dirt3 also has the best graphics in vegetation and trees (Dirt2 is very close too).
Not lol
@@costa2k1 Yes lol
yes
Right on. I still play D3.
Alternative title:
Watch a 2020 game being destroyed by its 2009 version
Lol it's a shame
Hard disagree
@@fifteen8850 Dont. None of the ‘newer’ games have half the development the older generation had. You can tell. Everything that’s come out from basically any genre has been half assed and monetized for money. Just stop man.
@@fifteen8850 blind
@@porterde08 true
Today I reinstalled Dirt2. On 4k tv or 144hz gaming monitor... It doesn't look like a 11 years old game! Sure, we have no flying leafs and such things. But Dirt 2 was such a great game. The presentation was awsome. Also the soundtrack. I loved the menu with the camper and the guys (Travis and Dave). They are a part of my childhood 20 years ago like Mat Hoffman and Tony Hawk. Damn time flys. Greetings from Germany
dirt 3 also isnt bad, worth a check too
I love Dirt 2! Still holds up to this day!
Dirt 2 is still the Best Dirt Game
@@snitchmojo3717 the Utah and the Morocco courses were amazing
@@cormacbcb I agree loved this game from start to finish I actually repurchased it not long ago for 360 cause my daughter broke my original disk, dont even play my 360 any more just wanted it fro my collection :)
It's better
I had it on ps3 and it was da best
I love Dirt 3. It made my childhood
So basically, DiRT 5 introduced clean dirty driving without a lot of dirt.
DiRT 5 looks like one of those low rated indie games found in the last pages of Steam.
Graphics quality are almost as bad as DiRT 1.
@@MJ-uk6lu what’s weird is that DiRT has very bad optimization because it stutters a lot when I play it on my mid end pc. Even it can run DiRT 3 on medium settings smoothly at 30 fps.
@@Waddle_Dee_With_Internet Well you can't say smoothly at 30 fps. Anyway, your PC isn't exactly mid end either. What are your specs?
@@MJ-uk6lu I got 4GB ram, Intel i3 8th gen, and Intel UHD 620. The problem must be from the cpu.
@@Waddle_Dee_With_Internet Explains everything why DiRT 3 runs poorly for you.
Dirt 3 blows all of them out visually.
Umm DiRT 2 is also the best.
I think dirt 3 took it graphically and dirt 2 was the better game for me
@Colin Hart same
@Colin Hart dirt 3 had a green filter, but also there are mods that remove it. Dirt 2 is still much better in physics.
It's crazy how a game from 2009 is much better looking than it's 2020 successor
Damn Dirt 3 is superb!!!
bdw dirt 5 is such a big disappointment
huge issues in cars physics and engine sounds
Don't forget to mention bugs and game crashes in 5 too
and all the tracks are basically circuits with bollards and stupid arrows. i’m literally taking it back
Started playing dirt 5 recently and thought it feels too easy, so I thought I'd go back to dirt 3 and immediately noticed it feels more grounded and realistic. Probably nostalgia but dirt 3 was and still is my favourite one and it still holds up pretty damn strong in 2021.
@@kazzng2087 I very first time to try D5 last couple weeks i was a huge fan in x360 D3 and iam very F.. Ing dissapointed about this shit after past almost 10 years development. Not about the grapich the controlling and AI. Thats why is a smart idea the xbox game pass because you can get free those shit games. Just imagine if you bought that shit almost 60-70usd or eur what ever you want. Same!!!
Wow dirt 3 has some nice dust follow and throwing effects
1. Dirt 2
2. Dirt 3
3. Dirt 4
4. Dirt
Last place dirt 5 seriously what is that
1. Dirt 2
2. Dirt 1
3. Dirt 4
4. Dirt 3
5. Dirt 5
Hmm based on the calculations of each titles nom I predict that the best DIRT on an average is
=(1+2+3+4+5)/5= 3
Thus i come to the conclusion that DIRT 3 is the best until now.
😅
@@SneakiestDuke68 ah 3 was better than 4
The newer they get, the worse they get. These developers try so hard to make games more realistic and it just makes them worse and worse. Every racing franchise has gone downhill. Dirt 2 will forever be the king and we need a remaster with the old physics
@@travisguyer7451 agreed.
And since dirt 2 is the only dirt game I have played so far it's true what you say.
Why dirt 5 don't have working mirrors in cockpit view?
as a fan of rally games i played dirt 3 and dirt 4 and personally i love dirt 4 because is a kind of realism and a arcade together and thats why i liked so much is the perfect balance for me not too arcade but also not too realism to be a simulation game also brings me back to the old colin mcrae games :)
Heard number 4 is the best lot of people complaing on number5
I started watching this cause I was wondering if I was alone on thinking dirt 3 was one of the most visually pleasing of the franchise
nah the 4 is better visually, especially during the rain
yes dirt 3 for the win
in dirt 3 for me, the graphical image is very seamless, it's peak codemasters on all fronts. It's like looking at a painting, would've blown people's minds when it first came to PC
Is it just me or dirt 5 graphics looks downgraded compared to dirt 4? Also why this 4:39 looks a bit better than this 4:52? It should be the opposite. Sometimes old games looks better than the new ones.
in dirt 5 the cars look like plastic, and the ton of effects makes the game even uglier
Dirt 4 had randomly generated tracks, so they had to degrade in the graphics department a little bit
@@pettiwhisker7792 they were barely even randomly generated it was the same 3/4 parts every single time but in a different order like the one hairpin in australia, i saw it in every stage just in different locations, extremely lazy imo
Remember when Dirt 2 came out on the x360. It looked so good and so far ahead of any other racing game
Dirt - Oh okay this is how dirt looked back then
Dirt 2 - Wow nice improvements it almost looks like a modern game
Dirt 3 - Damn it straight looks like it came out this year!
Dirt 4 - Wait what are you doing? this doesn't look as good as before
Dirt 5 - : I
Yeah. The fckd up at dirt 4. That yellow-green filter dirt 2-3 had was the biggest spot of realism in the game
Dude you summed up my thoughts pretty well.
@@InternetMouse Yeah. I have played dirt 2 3 and 4. Also dirt rally. Dirt 2 has the best world physics. I mean that the tire-ground contact us by far the most realistic when it comes to mud water and slippery areas. On the other hand, dirt 3 has the best car control and in my opinion looks the best. Except from the water mud physics. Dirt 4 is just... Another type of game. It's too arcade. It's like playing carx rally or rush rally 3 at the phone. Dirt rally, is the most realistic. Not in vehicle damage. If you want realism you will play BeamNG, but here we talk about rally games. So. Dirt 2. Best worldphysics. Dirt 3. Best look and car physics. Dirt 4. Is another game in the arcade category. And dirt 5. Dirt 5 is a new game. It will get patched and many many improvements will be made. It's too early to talk. I can't criticize it. If you compare dirt 5 with cyberpunk 2077, there is almost not difference. Both are early access games, Still on development. So. No complains about the new game
@@_.ser._.john_. You know Dirt 3 has blue filter, i hate it because Real life doesn't look blueish
Yeah I flippin love Dirt 3 for how it looks and feels. Dirt 4 looks a bit cartoonish, way too bright and cheerful for this game, and Dirt 5 is just… I mean, I’m digging the water and mud thing but *no*
Wow dirt 5 is a downgrade
Because they made it for money, they don't work hard to make the best for there fans and people to have more fun
Yeah, I feel like it was made to appeal to need for speed fans
Esatto è più "giocoso" o "arcade" sicuramente lo si vede anche da come è impostato con lucine led e tutto... È più per ragazzini
I just don’t like when the dirt barely shows up. Dirt physics mean a lot to me.
I think what we need is a bit of a graphics clean up and frame rate boost on dirt 2 and 3 and release it as a bundle (keep the physics and engine as they are )
If Colin McRae was alive to this day, the later DiRT titles would have his name on it
They still should
And they would have actually decent physics, unlike modern DiRT games.
@@projectmunch1017 no cuz he's dead and to pay respect for the McRae family they never used the Colin McRae title (except for events, cars, ecc.)
Anyone remember DIRT SHOWDOWN?
The best.
Nice video, it's what I'm after to help me decide if I should hope for Dirt 5 to be improved or just buy Dirt 4.
Suggestion though, please don't add music as it's important to be able to compare sounds also
Dirt 4 is far more superior than Dirt 5. If you're looking for a better rally experience, buy Dirt Rally 2.0
Basically dirt 5 is more like a dirt 1.1
Yeah looks like the original Collin mcrae games for pc
Great! Next Video compare damage model ;)
I think dirt 2 is the best because they are a lot of pilots speak during the race !! Just Amazing
Dirt 5 look like ps3 games -- in some things almost like ps2 game
also it has shit physics and look like mobile game
Dirt 1-3 is best
Agree looks so bad dirt 5 and idk what happend... dirt 2 and 3 looks waaay better and that was ps3 so dirt 5 looks like ps.2.5
DiRT 5 is completely crap. The game crashes multiple times and had a lot of missing features compared to its predecessors.
Dirt 2 looks good due to the realistic damage , mean looking vehicles , the overwhelming dirt effects , and mainly the orangish background light and soft edges of vehicles make it look great.
Fully agree dirt has lost its edge since 2 and 3, I cant explain it but they felt more free back then and more fun, these days they go for like 100% sim which is cool but not always fun and they look depressing all the time like gloomy stages if u get me.
Dirt 5 looks amazing on PS5 though...I don't think this comparison had the sliders at max.
I installed Dirt 3 today, finding it difficult without assistance, because I'm more of a NFS and Forza guy 😂
Still playing dirt 3 in 2021
Your video comparison concept is amazing. This video proved your creativity. Awesome video. Btw dirt 2 & 3 best game in the series.
(My opinion)
Thanks! :)
Yes. Cockpit view is perfect in DIRT2. Everything in DIRT2 is nearly perfect. AND NOW! Cockpit is finally perfect in DIRT5!!!!!!!! And the windshield wipers feels just RIGHT! Just as good as Driveclub. Hope water phyics on WIndshield may get upgrade to DC level in next game.
Dirt 2 my favoritt
Dirt 1 was like pretending to be in a band
Dirt 2 was like finding your favorite unsigned band that melted you face off
Dirt 3 was like that band bring polished by a record label, but lost a lot of the angst That you loved.
Tbf. All three Dirt games are better then the modern. Period
@@blakecooper669 I own 1-4, 2 being my fav. Yet I hated 4 at first. Bad menus limited content etc. But the unlimited tracks made me stick with it.
For dirt 4
For handling between dirt 2 and 3
Select gamer difficulty and turn off everything, traction control, anti lock breaking etc
For handling like dirt rally 1 and 2.0
Select simulation and turn on everything to 1, traction control breaking etc
For insane select simulation and turn everything off.
When your done go buy WRC9😁
@@blakecooper669 I miss the arcade racer. Nobody today can make an arcade racer even half as fun but in dirt 1-dirt 3 era there were so many good ones.
I played Dirt 2, 3 and 4.
Dirt 2 was every time my favorite Game.
Dirt 3 is OK, the dust looks much better, but the Game play istn so much funny as Dirt 2.
It looks that Dirt 4 and 5 is a step Backwards. It isn't so much funny, online you can't see other Players in Rally.
The physics doesn't look so good for the fact that there are successors.
My fav. is Dirt 2
4 I didn't like because of the penalty system. 2 was great but because it isn't backward compatible I'd play 3 more. If they combined the 2 games together it would be immense
@@cormacbcb Yes in 4 you got an penalty of 10 secons AND get reset back on the road. this is to much, cause you have to restart the speed sometimes in the beginning of a corner. 2 was only fun pure. 3 was a combi of 4 and 2. The style of 4, but more fun like part 2.( I liked the style of pt 2 more)
Am I right that you cant play 2 on windows cause GAMES FOR WINDOWS LIFE?
@@SILE141 to be fair the penalty system wasn't the biggest problem. I fucking hated the generated stage thing. I prefer finding courses I like so I can keep improving on them
Dirt 2 will forever be the king. I keep my 360 hooked up so I can continue playing it
Same with my ps3
Dirt 3 PC was the first driving game I purchased, keep hoping a substantial improvement in graphics & physics will be released but I haven't seen it yet!
Классно видео снимаешь продолжайте также
Dirt 4 here ! I love it! Im so glad i purchased it. My only gripe is racenet doesnt work!
Codemasters needs to bring back the handling and physics from DiRT 2/3.
trilogy remaster would be cool for current gen consoles
I'm actually diggin' how dirt 1 looks and feels
Dirt 5 should name Mud
I must be going crazy or something, because DiRT 2 looks better to me than all the other ones 😂
my eyes hurt when I saw the first dirt chart
for me i think dirt 4 is overall better than the others maybe it wanted a click of graphics but in saturation color physics sound behavior driving even details was better than the others
Imo dirt 2 still looks and feels the best, the whole desig of the game was just awesome from start to finish. Have not played 5 yet but not likening all the bright colours looks like forza festival too much for me (I like forza but 2 different games).
EDIT:
Now own dirt 5, Not anything like any of the previous dirt titles, it's basically Onrush 2, as a Dirt game disappointing, as a new standalone title yes I would have been all for it because it's actually really fun, but it is an entirely new feeling of gameplay and visuals which are sub par to its predecessors. However the fun factor is definitely there in the online level designs.
Dirt 2,3,4 physics 🗿
Dirt 5 physics 🤡
Dirt 5 isn’t just Dirt anymore
Bravo for this comparison. Well done. It helped me a lot to decide which I`ll drive. When I saw Dirt 5 for the fist time I thought order I`m getting mad or this game is bullshit. Now, when I see that most of you think the same, now I`m really disappointed. How can it be ? Are the producers blind or strongly drugged !?
dirt 5 is like a mobile game called asphalt xtreme
I believe the team of 3D artist making Dirt 1 until Dirt 3 in Codemaster is not the same team on Dirt 4 and Dirt 5...
It`s obvious
Those people who says that dirt 5 looks like a ps2 game should seriously go to a doctor
Absolutely agree!
Newer game comes with new content but Dirt 2 gameplay is still the best
I don't know if it's only related to this comparison video but oh man does DiRT 5 look horribly bad. DiRT 3 is quite possibly my favourite title along with DiRT 4. I'm yet to try the first two games.
Personally I think d2 and d3 are good since in rally stages there are other people racing with u instead of by yourself.
Dirt 2 and 3 were perfect but dirt 2 style and soundtrack and campaign was more fun with 3x the cars at dirt 3 but dirt 3 was more serious and the multi-player was insane dirt4 was ok and dirt 5 was terrible I hope dirt 6 brings back the feel of dirt 2
Dirt5 Side mirror is terrible
Don't work
Fans of dirt 2 here...❤️
No one
@@abhiramveeraiahgari6452 ya but y it is gud game of that time
here!!
❤️
Here I am
Dirt 2 is the best ever.. I bought Dirt 5 cause the style reminded me a lot of Dirt 2 yet the feeling I get remembering Dirt 2 with the Monster vinyl on the Hammer making big jumps and drifting and smashing the others. Graphics like in Dirt 2 will always be good cause they are a bit from both cartoonish and realistic a bit with an arcade feeling yet half a simulator It's just classic. Dirt 3 is good too I just didn't find anything more special in it from dirt 2 except gymkhana maps. Dirt 5 is good but it didn't reach the hype I was looking for from Dirt 2 maybe cause I'm older .. Dunno I'll download Dirt 2 just to find out is it really that good as I remember :D.
Wow Like
Dirt 5 looks the best in most areas (as it should), the frame rate was low but I'd put that down to system performance. Good comparison video either way, nice one.
Dirt 2 and Dirt 3 looks the best in most areas, i think you have mistaken.
It's a joke how DiRT got devolved by 2020, in terms of everything. DiRT 5 is the shame of the series. Shame of the new generation/end of the previous generation, especially for a car game.
I still played dirt 3 in my ps 3 its looks good than i played dirt 5 in pc
I like racing against other racers instead of the clock. Is Dirt 5 for me then? because I heard they took out rally tracks.
yep
Still playin DiRT4 (and rally 2.0 sometimes) in 2021, those are best ones (too much arcade driving on all the others).
Me too!
@@shinobiblade2558 Nice! I don't get the peoples that say D4 Is a graphic downgrade by the way, i think dirt4 graphics it's better and colorful (finally sepia filter removed 😂). But dirt2.0 it's the best rally game i ever played!!
@@Bsc8 yeah I alternate between dirt rally 2.0 and dirt 4. Dirt 5 is really bad to me. It’s just way too Arcady and unrealistic.
@@shinobiblade2558 i didn't bought dirt5 maybe one day with a huge steam sale i will, but i read and saw a lot of reviews and i agree with the guys that said it's basically motorstorm pacifict rift mixed with forza horizon.
Talkin about D5, in the steam library my dirt4 has "become" dirt5: i mean all the pictures and the logos have changed from D4 to D5, but it's only in the steam library that i have this new glich. In game it's still D4 and works as always...
Maybe it's because we prefer the Actual Rally Driving by the legends and don't care about Graphics and shit.
------Plz note------(dirt 1 2 3 4 using ego engine dirt 5 using ONRUSH engine)
And yes dirt 5 have better texture better grass better everything except dirt but the way dirt 5 look compare to 1 2 3 it looks flat they are chasing realistic look sometime it is good some time it is bad depends on the weather that's why people will look at this and say it's downgrade
The uglyness of DiRT 5 puts 4's to shame.
Also should've put DiRT 2's London Rallycross track (at night) at the end.
Dirt 5 seems like a mobile gameplay with graphics mod
Todo mi apoyo 😃 meses descubrí más juego 👍😃
dirth 2 in my opinion is the best of the saga
People Graphics
Dirt 5 > Dirt 4 > Dirt 1 > Dirt 2 > Dirt 3
Grass Graphics
Dirt 5 > Dirt 1 > (Dirt 4 Dirt 3 & 2) Almost the same
Best Water Physics
Dirt 2
We bought a new pc in 2007 for dirt 1. So, there is no more dirt that you would buy pc for
How come, Dirt 2 and Dirt 3 look like a proper 2017-made game and Dirt 5 looks just a bit better but cant even get to 60fps properly most of the time
People can find old car and new car, recycle parts and stll the car fueled with old gasoline, but now game industry seems focus on graphic and people will complain or called dev lazy if they didnt make it nextgen or somehow reuse the game assets that can run on "old pc". I believe they can save time and put better content if dirt 5 were made with same dirt 2 or 3 engine
any recommendations guys for which one should i play first because i never play one of them ?
Basically anyone? 😂 Its not like they have a storyline or smt
@@rami3952 aightttt, i bought dirt 4 already 💩
Work your way up. Play the first. Then 2 and 3. End it there. Simple
i very like rally
I own 1-4, 2 being my fav. Yet I hated 4 at first. Bad menus limited content etc. But the unlimited tracks made me stick with it.
For dirt 4
For handling between dirt 2 and 3
Select gamer difficulty and turn off everything, traction control, anti lock breaking etc
For handling like dirt rally 1 and 2.0
Select simulation and turn on everything to 1, traction control breaking etc
For insane select simulation and turn everything off.
When your done go buy WRC9😁
Wow dirt 5 sucks
dirt rally 2 dirt 4 ditr 3 dirt 1 dirt 5 ditr rally 1 best dirt series
The world in Dirt 5 is much more alive. i like that.
Dirt 2 is my all time favorite. The driving physics so feel so good. I love rally stages the most. I don't play Dirt rally because it's just boring. Regular Dirt series adds some flare and energy. I'm very disappointed in Dirt 5 rally tracks. They're so wide and unrealistic to me. Like a Sega Rally game. I love technical and narrow stages like how a normal backroad/country road would actually be. Probably will wait yet again for the next Dirt game. I need a Dirt 2 remake with more tracks and cars. My first rally game was Colin McRae Rally 2005. I've yet to see a rally game with stages and car damage as unforgiving as that game. Maybe in Dirt Rally? IDK.
I'm still playing cmr 2k5
Dirt 5 is the 1st time I've played a Dirt game and i am hooked.
What the hell happened to DiRT5.
I can’t believe how bad dirt 5 looks. Dirt 2 & Dirt 4 are definitely the best
I look at dirt 1 and it still looks amazing. They totally nailed the saturation of colors and the contrast. Dirt 2 is less amazing to me, dirt 3 is too washed out and dirt 4 maybe a tad over-saturated.
btw dirt 1 had the best variety in the environment and locations, as I recall the sequels all failed to reach that level. despite it had many imperfections I still kinda prefer that game. Call me a boomer :)
@Wundermax 1 I was really amazed by DiRT 1 too when it's released. Especially how realistic it looks. But for me DiRT2 with it's awesome soundtrack and fun (although a little arcady) driving mechanism really made it to be my favorite of the series! I think you could give DiRT2 a second chance if you haven't already played it for more than a few hours! :)
@@PlayGroundComparisons I played it more than that, but not to completion. I do agree, the driving mechanism and game engine issues from dirt1 were gone in dirt2. It also looks similar in the art direction, though in general this was the part I had issues with, too much in-game super star vibe :) Nevertheless thanks for the advice, I will dig up my wheel and replay both dirt1 and 2, so that I could have fun and compare them. Cheers!
Edit: Oh and you made an awesome comparison video!
Dirt 2 forever.. I loved 🥰
i have dirt 3 its amazing
I love dirt dirt 2 dirt 3. Nice games
DIRT 2
Dirt 2 eo Dirt 3 são os melhores pra mim
Concordo. Só joguei o Dirt 3 mas é um ótimo jogo e o melhor(pelo que vejo). Já vi gente reclamar dele por causa do modo gymkhana, e que o controle do carro é ruim porque desliza, o gráfico é apagado mais é tudo questão de aprender a jogar e corrigir a cor pelo driver da placa de vídeo
i think in dirt 5 the developer was putting to much focus in environment,
Dirt 5 looks like ps2 prime
dirt 5 has the best textures but the physics
:(
В 2011 DiRT3 что тогда что сейчас вылядит фотореалестично!
Согласен
I hope EA and Codemasters will make another DiRT game
Never ever, I would rather see Dirt die.
they are making the next WRC game WRC 23 which hopefully will be Dirt rally 3.0 with the WRC title
dirt 3 for me :-)
Dirt 5, the car and driving mechanics are jenky. 3 looks the best. Did they change software devs between 3 and 5?