Joseph Campbell and the Power of Myth | Ep. 3: 'The First Storytellers'

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 08. 2022
  • Joseph Campbell explains how ancient myths bring humans to understand and accept birth, growth and death.
    Watch Episode 4: • Joseph Campbell and th...
    Buy The Set: www.powerofmyth.net
    #documentary #tv #tvshow #television #mythology #josephcampbell
  • Krátké a kreslené filmy

Komentáře • 154

  • @paulnugent9937
    @paulnugent9937 Před 10 měsíci +26

    This man, Joseph Campbell, is very articulate; and the other man, Bill Moyers, is a very good listener. It makes for a truly excellent and intellectual discourse. Thank you!

  • @ChirpoTunes
    @ChirpoTunes Před rokem +214

    I keep watching this series again and again, just for the moments when I'm most receptive and can actually grasp some of the depth of the content. There are still parts that aren't quite penetrating through my ego yet.

    • @martaescobar7625
      @martaescobar7625 Před rokem +8

      It is difficult to put into words what the soul knows, and returning is simply standing still and allowing yourself to be. Psalm 46:10 KJV
      1"0 Be still, and know that I am God: I will be exalted among the heathen, I will be exalted in the earth." ....just ask an empath.....

    • @danocable
      @danocable Před rokem +1

      Agreed.!!

    • @IceyCharmander
      @IceyCharmander Před rokem +4

      Everytime I watch I discover something new

    • @fongponto
      @fongponto Před rokem +4

      some suggest that will happen when the ego (the illusion of yourself as a being) dissolves

    • @goran.rukljac
      @goran.rukljac Před rokem +2

      You have said IT.

  • @doloresfraijo3803
    @doloresfraijo3803 Před rokem +48

    I love the language that JC uses to describe, to explain, to tell his stories of Mythology. He was a gift to the world. Listening to the series now...20 years ago

    • @bobhope5114
      @bobhope5114 Před 9 měsíci

      Manly P. halls lectures are also a must.

  • @harryschultz6951
    @harryschultz6951 Před rokem +20

    That last statement though 🤯. And there are those moments where he just wells up with joy you can just see his face beaming. It’s so amazing.

    • @Ultra-Luminary
      @Ultra-Luminary Před 4 měsíci

      I noticed that too! Which put a big smile on my face!😅

  • @rajireddy5224
    @rajireddy5224 Před rokem +9

    Centuries of research, learning , knowledge disbursed to younger generation

  • @patriciatewhetu6808
    @patriciatewhetu6808 Před rokem +39

    I have been listening to this series back to back, this is amazing i truely love what im hearing it's so thought provoking. As an indigenous from NZ this is a great reminder of our connection to the spirit of nature and animals. Thank you 😍

  • @Monsternetero
    @Monsternetero Před 10 měsíci +4

    What a beautiful human being. Mr. Campbell has gone through his own hero’s journey and now plays the guide for us through his books and these interviews.

  • @alanrogerson-rogersonart1936

    It's incredible that Joseph Campbell died mere months after this series! A true master!

    • @robert-wr9xt
      @robert-wr9xt Před rokem

      A plan?

    • @04Serena
      @04Serena Před 4 měsíci +1

      I suspect that he was at great peace when he made that transition.

  • @TerlinguaTalkeetna
    @TerlinguaTalkeetna Před rokem +20

    So glad to see that Campbell gave such praise to Niehart's Black Elk Speaks at the end. We would be wise to bring true native understanding and wisdom back into our national soul before it's to late. Bears Ears National Monument co-management plan with 5 tribes is trying to attempt just such a thing. Campbell's life's work wisdom is everlasting

    • @peterparker9286
      @peterparker9286 Před rokem

      Crazy Horse

    • @TerlinguaTalkeetna
      @TerlinguaTalkeetna Před 10 měsíci

      No it was Black Elk@@peterparker9286

    • @doctorcrafts
      @doctorcrafts Před 9 měsíci

      Too late

    • @TerlinguaTalkeetna
      @TerlinguaTalkeetna Před 9 měsíci

      Clearly in the short run most humans I've met in 65 years of living seem to prefer pessimism. Your not alone in you statement for sure.@@doctorcrafts

  • @orlandooracle7008
    @orlandooracle7008 Před rokem +21

    Thank, thank you, thank you!! I just can’t say it enough!!! Thanks!! This show had one of the most profound effect on my life!! Thank you so much and I pray that CZcams never takes these down!!! 🙏🫶💯💯💯🙇‍♀️

  • @thepaulusmaximus
    @thepaulusmaximus Před 9 měsíci +5

    The biggest lesson here I wish the modern world would heed is that myth, ritual, religion are constantly changing, evolving in order to survive. I think the way we treat these things as fixed quantities continues to do great harm.

  • @thegreatawakening7thedimen837

    No one is hated more• than he/she who tells the truth- Plato

  • @Dazbog373
    @Dazbog373 Před rokem +7

    Good to learn Bill Moyers still alive December 2022. RIP Joseph Campbell.

  • @lateonaname
    @lateonaname Před rokem +8

    An invisible plane supporting the visible 🌌🙏🏽 well put

  • @marycamilleri9450
    @marycamilleri9450 Před rokem +6

    In my 💓 👁👁 I Declare U a Saint👣🙋 Saint Joseph 🤓🎓🎩💚🌏💚 Holder of WISDOM💎🎁
    NAMASTE 2 U & All💓🔔

  • @chrislucy3778
    @chrislucy3778 Před rokem +14

    Profound. Keep coming back to these. Meditating right now on these words - ritual and meaning are returning. Thanks for posting 🙏

  • @fonzi7451
    @fonzi7451 Před rokem +23

    Thank you to whomever has put this together Its truly appreciated

  • @educationalramblings6826

    The "respect " for the animal that feeds you....the part of nature that sustains us, I think has been lost as has the respect for nature in general and the understanding that WE ARE IT and IT IS US.
    I came across Joseph over 30 years ago and he was one of many that helped me along my path. The last 2 years I was showing the documentary Finding Joe to my students. If you haven't seen it, it can be found on youtube

    • @BrionyGunson
      @BrionyGunson Před 11 měsíci

      Yes, it's tragic that we've lost that connection to nature and that reverence for how the animal we eat sustain us.
      Here is that documentary, Finding Joe: czcams.com/video/s8nFACrLxr0/video.html

    • @paulward2333
      @paulward2333 Před 7 měsíci

      For another high quality treatment of this same point, I strongly recommend to you (and your students) Daniel Quinn's novel The Story of B.

  • @donovanjones4175
    @donovanjones4175 Před rokem +3

    That last 5 minutes with blackout, such a great moment of learning. That guy was cool af.

  • @a.account8011
    @a.account8011 Před 11 měsíci +2

    This series is magical and full of wisdom.

  • @robbiereilly
    @robbiereilly Před 23 dny

    I'm coming back to this series again, now in 2024. I watched it when it aired and then again in the mid 90s on Japanese public television. I've always gained something from every viewing. I am watching it on my Sunday nights before I go to bed, just like I did when it was on TV so many years ago. Cheers from Tokyo.

  • @silentobserver4425
    @silentobserver4425 Před rokem +5

    Powerful, truly powerful.

  • @diogenesegarden5152
    @diogenesegarden5152 Před rokem +22

    This series has been most enlightening and thought provoking, much ‘food’ for thought. I always try to remember the consciousness of all the food I eat with a prayer of thanks. We look upon the ancient right of ‘blooding’ a Hunter, like we in the west have considered barbaric as seems to have been carried on up until quite recently in the UK, and was a common occurrence in traditional Hunts, by abandoning it, as a ritual ‘rite of passage’, actually goes way back to pre history. By banning this activity in Britain has possibly severed one of our last link to the food giving animal world. When we had the pandemic, we were banned from churches and gatherings such as harvest festivals, so that last vestige of our communal links to the past, and the spirit world of the consciousness we consume, we are breaking the cycle. Could this be the reason that the we are plunging much of the Western world into what may be difficult times ahead food wise? It may seem unconnected, but if we do not respect our land and treat it with its due reverence, nature will in tern withold their sacrifice for our benefit. This will lead to starvation. Only places where the rituals survive in significant number, and not those places reliant on manufactured or adulterated food, they will be led into full slavery and be fully reliant on manufactured produce for their nutrition. By abandoning or phasing out of these spiritual food and fertility rituals over the years, as we become more ‘progressive’, and disconnected with our planet and the way we live and feed ourselves and live selfishly, taking and not giving respect back, then services withdrawn by Mother Earth and we’re on our own. Quite a scarey thought really. Maybe we ought to start bringing back some of these rituals as a matter of some urgency. Maybe we can learn something from our Pagan forebares, where most of these customs and rituals, dances, festivals, feasts and even town carnivals came from prior to Christianity, and were kept on to appease the old memories, to slowly whither away, and then slowly erased from memory by other distractions. Maybe this is why the Native American elders speak, that during trying times, only those that observe the spiritual niceties, will be able to thrive in any meaningful way, notwithstanding external devices. So the ritual carried out when a young huntsman on his first kill is ‘blooded’, goes back to a time when they depended on the animals they killed, they had to introduce the new hunter to the tribe and spirit world possibly, and why they would eat the liver straight away so that they got that first nutrient as a gift from the slaughtered animal to replenish them, also because they would need to be eaten first as they were difficult to preserve. I’m guessing they wouldn’t kill animals for fun, but it would possibly be spiritual bad manners not to get a thrill of the hunt, so long as the sacrifice of the hunted animal is appreciated and utilised to the fullest extent.

    • @spiralsun1
      @spiralsun1 Před rokem +1

      Have you noticed that science is EXACTLY LIKE these rituals, but the name is changed to “theory” instead of god or spirit, and they follow clues to find the eternal principles…? Like tracking a living thing? We also get amazing technology and benefits from this epistemological hunt. We hunt to “eat” with our minds. Spiritual sustenance from knowing empirical truth.
      So I think it was actually understanding the Tao or manitou of the animal. Learn the lesson and partake like with the Christian sacrament. Every organism has a “manitou” or meaning-an eternal intrinsic meaning. With language, human’s greatly amplify this.

  • @trishlane9777
    @trishlane9777 Před rokem +4

    The centre of the world is where stillness and movement are together where movement is time and stillness eternity ⭐️💕

  • @denniscostello3430
    @denniscostello3430 Před rokem +3

    Years ago, in a cultural anthropology class, we studied Campbell. One of the best classes I took.

  • @thedobermans
    @thedobermans Před rokem +6

    Bill Moyers was so freakin cool.

  • @sebastianwrites
    @sebastianwrites Před rokem +4

    I wish people would stop saying that animals don't think about death... when they absolutely do! Elephants will go back to the bones of a beloved member of the group, and other species of shown similar behaviour.

  • @Dolcelux5
    @Dolcelux5 Před 2 měsíci

    These episodes always bring peace over me. Holiday time for soundtracks and reason; they grow up wise and tall when truth and belief can coexist

  • @wumpascott
    @wumpascott Před rokem +2

    this is so surreal. what a gift. thank you for posting.

  • @user-qp2xy5zs7r
    @user-qp2xy5zs7r Před 3 měsíci

    My favorite storyteller Joseph Campbell

  • @patriciajob7829
    @patriciajob7829 Před rokem +4

    Extraordinaire ! Thank you for sharing ! This man is incredible, a good teacher what's he revealed will feed me for decades. Thanks so much to him and everybody that makes it hapened. Namasté

  • @johnnicholas1488
    @johnnicholas1488 Před rokem +6

    Professor Campbell is a very kind and interesting fellow, pleasing to
    listen to and thought provoking.
    As to Mr Moyer, I shall fellow the
    maxim that if your can't say something nice don't say anything at all, to wit:

  • @christopherscotellaro5027

    The power of Joseph Campbell 😊

  • @mariarosamc5393
    @mariarosamc5393 Před rokem +1

    Amazed and infinitely thankful!

  • @jonasvaitiekunas2713
    @jonasvaitiekunas2713 Před rokem +7

    thank you for posting this❤️

  • @wearesouls6783
    @wearesouls6783 Před rokem +2

    Love hanging out with the smart kids. 😁👋

  • @nycgweed
    @nycgweed Před rokem +3

    The thou and it reflects it well even today

  • @wisconsinfarmer4742
    @wisconsinfarmer4742 Před rokem +1

    life is a wonderful experience.
    God loves it when you give your best.
    and so do you.

  • @nilvana7540
    @nilvana7540 Před rokem +2

    For someone so learned of the past, Campbell was wise to point to the future. It's sad to see people here launch into the same old bleating about the "good old days" as if doing a rain dance will cure society's ills. He said as much in the previous part, and he alluded to it in this--we are a new society with new knowledge, a new domain. We need new myths--ones local and relevant to our modern experiences. People end up seeking out stories or meeting like-minded folk and creating their own in the process--but if you never do, or if yours conflicts with what our society demands of you, you get those lost souls.

  • @bradbryant3810
    @bradbryant3810 Před rokem +9

    Campbell is an American treasure and gave us so much to think about more deeply. But I don't agree with some of his conclusions. Our religions kept us believing that we all need an intermediary between us and higher spiritual awareness (Heaven, Enlightenment) In my opinion, we are all responsible for our own advancement to higher levels of awareness. No shaman or Priest can do the work for us. They can be a friend - a supporter, but the work remains ours. Victory or defeat is in our hands.

    • @marcio-duarte
      @marcio-duarte Před rokem +1

      I think he would agree with you, actually. He explicitly said that any true myth should be “transparent to transcendence”, so no set of religious symbols can really save anybody, it has to happen for real inside yourself. The symbols only show the way, but each one of us has to walk there with our own legs, in our own manner.

  • @darkilluminat3976
    @darkilluminat3976 Před rokem +11

    Campbell was indeed wise

    • @SonOfTheDawn515
      @SonOfTheDawn515 Před rokem

      He was just a narrator

    • @marcio-duarte
      @marcio-duarte Před rokem +2

      @@SonOfTheDawn515 Of course. What really matters is the message, not the messenger. Not the finger pointing to the moon, but the moon itself.

  • @michaeljarmstrongjr5569
    @michaeljarmstrongjr5569 Před rokem +3

    Wonderful! Thank U 🙏
    #TOGM #AIO

  • @ftmrivas3043
    @ftmrivas3043 Před rokem +3

    This is so good. Thank you 😊

  • @alexdhoxha
    @alexdhoxha Před rokem

    I can’t get enough of this

  • @areneesouder
    @areneesouder Před rokem +4

    This is some beautiful stuff, I love it.

  • @terrylevine
    @terrylevine Před rokem +1

    So fantastic and inspiring to listen to.

  • @fredricksikay387
    @fredricksikay387 Před rokem +1

    Truly extraordinary! Mind opening perspective

  • @Stereostupid
    @Stereostupid Před 6 měsíci

    This is true awakening to it's highest power possible! Joseph Campbell brings together all human knowledge and truths from time and memorial ❤ the best compilation or library known to man in his research a true walking library for all time !! Josephs own hero's journey was to put This together for mankind! Truly the greatest gift 🎁 a mind could ask for ...a hero wearing eternitys' ever-changing mask of consciousness

  • @nikhilanand7805
    @nikhilanand7805 Před 5 měsíci

    Iam 21 years old as am commenting this comment, many of the things which were discussed in this episode are things I am unaware of, I truly wish, that as time passes on, I want to accumilate enough intellect to grasp each and every detail being discussed in this video. Namaskaram🙏🙏🙏

  • @bealreadyhappy
    @bealreadyhappy Před rokem +1

    8:42 a lovely metaphor. This body isn’t worth dwelling on!!😊

  • @jeanettecarnell8933
    @jeanettecarnell8933 Před 7 měsíci

    Excelent book,great to hear audio version,thanks!😊

  • @secretshaman189
    @secretshaman189 Před 7 měsíci

    Great information-- Bill Moyers is a skillful interviewer and Joseph Campbell a wonderful insightful teacher.

  • @spiralsun1
    @spiralsun1 Před rokem +3

    THIS. 🙏🏻❤️‍🔥

  • @susanharvey2109
    @susanharvey2109 Před rokem +2

    So interesting.

  • @oliviergoethals4137
    @oliviergoethals4137 Před rokem +1

    This is so good🌟

  • @tony11950000
    @tony11950000 Před 10 měsíci

    And each of us is a manifestation of this mystery 🙏.

  • @Ultra-Luminary
    @Ultra-Luminary Před 4 měsíci

    144 comments!😅
    !38:16 A Woman is a vehicle of Life!🤯
    You just inspired me a beautiful poem! Thank you!🙏

  • @andrewhiggins1975
    @andrewhiggins1975 Před rokem

    Thank you

  • @FF-so3su
    @FF-so3su Před rokem +1

    Brilliant

  • @saradiaz7879
    @saradiaz7879 Před rokem +2

    Sería un gran aporte que pusieran subtitulos en español para poder seguir mejor a Joe en sus maravillosas e inspiradoras exposiciones! Gracias por considerarlo! 🙏🏼🤗🇦🇷

  • @VIRGONOMICS
    @VIRGONOMICS Před 3 měsíci

    This book changed my life. It was my first knowledge of him. Everything had new meaning . We have lost our way, and these Myths are being buried in technology . Yuk.

  • @Ultra-Luminary
    @Ultra-Luminary Před 4 měsíci

    25:17 This is giving me the most impressive goose bumps!

  • @solidwindow
    @solidwindow Před 5 měsíci

    It's just so good

  • @mcliloldbigyoung
    @mcliloldbigyoung Před 4 měsíci

    I would just like to add to Bill Moyers statement on thinking animals dont think theres an after death experience, elephants bury their dead, they mourn at the funeral site often for over 24 hours straight, and they return to the burial sites to visit their dead, so at the very minimum and Im sure theres more, elephants believe in something we likely could scarcely even fathom

  • @staciwashington3212
    @staciwashington3212 Před rokem +2

    I gave child of the Sun the Peacock feather and child of the Moon the Turkey feather. They are on their way!

  • @billmartins5545
    @billmartins5545 Před 6 měsíci +1

    The ads are very disruptive.

  • @lorettascutta3629
    @lorettascutta3629 Před 4 měsíci

    Keep going! You will get it as I did!

  • @cheri238
    @cheri238 Před rokem +1

    Kinolober, thank you for all these video's again, with Bill Moyers and the amazing thinker and writer Joseph Campbell. A journey of the consciousness,(subconscious,) a walk of deep insights. All great religions faiths, indigenous cultures for centuries, wars, and religious divisions beginning 3500 years before Christ. It is a journey, and it begins inside of you.
    Krishnamurti ❤ Everyone has their own journey. World histories, philosophy, sciences, religious divisions, books of great writers and literature, poetry, music and creative arts, dance, painters for centuries. Creative arts are the glue that hold our world together.
    "The Master and His Emissary," The Divided Brain Nd the Making of the Western World," "The Matter With Things," Our Brains and the Unmaking of the World," two volumes 1500 pages with notes books by Iian McGilchrist.
    "The Redbook" Libra Novus, C.J. Jung, Edited and with an Introduction by Sonu Shamdasani, 2009. Excellent discussions and encouraging books of wisdom and guidance.

  • @skipleft
    @skipleft Před měsícem

    At 16 went pheasant hunting for first time with dad,grandpa.Shot one and instantly said,"thank you"
    Was not raised in any type of religious household.
    Did everything not to cry in front of the alpha males....never hunted,again
    Have no idea what invoked such gratitude and 40 years later the experience remains

  • @lambsauce1468
    @lambsauce1468 Před rokem +3

    My gifts to the world are my children. They came through me. That's why I always drive them wherever they need to go.

    • @ronnronn55
      @ronnronn55 Před rokem +1

      Our children are the only thing we pass along to maintain the species. All our accomplishments are for naught if there is no one in the future to make use of them.

  • @carlpiazza1950
    @carlpiazza1950 Před rokem +2

    A question is, when did we start to think of ourselves in this regard?

    • @AFRoSHEENT3ARCMICHAEL69
      @AFRoSHEENT3ARCMICHAEL69 Před rokem

      When we realized the connection to the mind and the monochord. A tempered scale is like your tempered mind called Temperament or Temperamental. The circle of 5ths was discovered in 600 BC by the Greeks. Who also gave us the idea of death and resurrection.

  • @theubercaste
    @theubercaste Před 6 měsíci

    0:29 has a very Marty Staufer vibe to it.
    0:50-what you just described is myth, too

  • @Stereostupid
    @Stereostupid Před 3 měsíci +1

    Joseph Campbell is the embroidery the embryo of consciousness and awakening stitching all mythology across time and memorial, from beginning to present moment!

  • @bealreadyhappy
    @bealreadyhappy Před rokem +1

    2:40 that’s a myth too. We do not experience death! Lol

  • @bealreadyhappy
    @bealreadyhappy Před rokem +1

    26:53 change in one psychology just by saying THOU. Wow! Yes it works!

    • @brettpilkington9539
      @brettpilkington9539 Před 8 měsíci

      Yeah this is why I keep rewatching this, that's very powerful and I missed it on previous listens / watches

  • @GnartotheBone
    @GnartotheBone Před rokem

    This might be the most kino video series ever produced

  • @tomatenpaprika6323
    @tomatenpaprika6323 Před rokem

    22:20 are we having similar encounter of a bird from Ramayana ? "Have you seen Sita"? Jatayu was asked

  • @bwoutchannel6356
    @bwoutchannel6356 Před 8 měsíci

    Over lunch the deacon explained that he had studied at the University of Chicago under Campbell’s friend, the anthropologist Mircea Eliade. The deacon informed me that on his deathbed Joseph Campbell asked for a Catholic priest and was reconciled with the church of his childhood.

  • @opusnone1
    @opusnone1 Před 3 měsíci

    The artist function is the mythololzation of the world.

  • @Liberated_from_Religion
    @Liberated_from_Religion Před rokem +4

    Watching the Japanese torture that little bear was unbearable.

  • @floydbingo
    @floydbingo Před 7 měsíci

    1:02 Gee, wonder why they cut it before the head swivel... Peace

  • @wapacheed
    @wapacheed Před 6 měsíci

    50:40 Black Elk Speaks

  • @theresahutch168
    @theresahutch168 Před rokem +1

    Hilma af Klint is an amazing woman visionary artist that influenced Paul Klee.

  • @wumpascott
    @wumpascott Před rokem

    32:25 🙂

  • @inchworm9311
    @inchworm9311 Před 8 měsíci

    12:42

  • @tomrisyucemen4060
    @tomrisyucemen4060 Před 5 měsíci

    26:25

  • @wumpascott
    @wumpascott Před rokem

    40:30

  • @sallyreno6296
    @sallyreno6296 Před rokem +1

    knitting?

  • @aroura15elementanne32

    The circumpolar bear cult i thought it was like a part of history unknown 😳 a ancient religion that was around in cave man days it we from the mountain ⛰️ of Europe to the east all the way to Alaska.

  • @Tommyharty_
    @Tommyharty_ Před měsícem

    29:41, 30:02, 38:26

  • @Stereostupid
    @Stereostupid Před 6 měsíci

    A boy is his mothers son but becomes his father's son 👌

  • @chobin7982
    @chobin7982 Před rokem +1

    Lol this is the cave george lucas used for empire strikes back

  • @dusandragovic09srb
    @dusandragovic09srb Před 5 měsíci

    The World belongs to Serbs #SRB

  • @nycgweed
    @nycgweed Před rokem

    Cave a temple made by nature
    Church temple made by man
    Both are cruel

  • @mrzfunk
    @mrzfunk Před 2 měsíci

    So disappointing that he fell for the exposure effect bias when talking about crime. He thinks the amount of disturbing news in the newspaper means crime is out of control when the data is quite clear that violence trends down exponentially with civilization and technological progress.

  • @claricesilva2700
    @claricesilva2700 Před 4 měsíci

    He was a genius. I just don't think he really understood the bible,like most western people we were taught in university to hate the bible and everything that has to do with cristianity, like, because of the horrible things the Church did, that somewow has something to do with the thing itself, like it's not the people that were wrong, it's the book...Joseph Campbell would have leanerd a lot with Jordan Peterson.

  • @miriamceornea97
    @miriamceornea97 Před rokem

    yeah sorry but on that one I do have a different opinion as far as rituals go and that we have to keep them alive. How is the circumcision of a boy less barbarian than people in the western countries commiting crimes? That are rituals that are important and to know their symbology and use is to be rememberd in some way, because of the depth of their meaning. But I will disagree on the part of having to keep certain rites. One more thing, sure, a women become a women by nature but I'm by is by far not obligated to having to give physical birth, that is also a social expectation that is now falling away, which is, again in my opinion, a positive. I do not shame people that do want to have children obviously, it has nothing to do with that, but a women should not feel lees of a women because she might for one maybe not have menstruation or children, again it's consciousness, everyone is more then just their mare bodies and more then the rituals.

  • @sophianelson9382
    @sophianelson9382 Před 4 měsíci

    I love Joseph Campbell, but when he uses the word "Barbarian" I would expect him to understand it's orrigins which is from the Berber tribe of North Africa in Morocco and Ageria (really Sahara desert), That word is used as a racisr slurr. Jus as Savages was towards Native American among others from the white colonists. Once again, understanding that no one is perfect and to think for yourself and never take anoyone's perspetive as concrete.

    • @WisdomIce
      @WisdomIce Před 3 měsíci

      You're indoctrinated, the word comes from a PIE root.
      from PIE root *barbar- echoic of unintelligible speech of foreigners (compare Sanskrit barbara- "stammering," also "non-Aryan," Latin balbus "stammering," Czech blblati "to stammer").

  • @robert-wr9xt
    @robert-wr9xt Před rokem

    Joe always was an old car.
    Just like Mister Miyagi?

  • @robert-wr9xt
    @robert-wr9xt Před rokem +1

    The GOP has failed America.