Top 40 QB
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 06. 2024
- It’s the last day of school before summer break. Simms & Paul take questions from the homies to put a bow on the Top 40 QB Countdown. #NBCSports #NFL #ChrisSimmsUnbuttoned
(7:20) Is Josh Allen worthy of No. 1 even though his best moment came against a bad defense?
(9:45) Who is a better running threat: Allen or Cam Newton from the mid-2010s?
(12:00) Is Patrick Mahomes being graded overly harshly?
(18:40) Who had the better first two seasons of their career: Andrew Luck or Justin Herbert?
(22:40) Why Herbert over Joe Burrow?
(27:00) Does anyone carry their team more than Aaron Rodgers?
(32:20) A look at the MVP odds powered by PointsBet
(35:45) Did Chris have too much of a short-term memory when ranking Matthew Stafford at No. 6?
(38:45) Why Tom Brady likely won’t crack Simms’ top five ever again
(40:30) Who benefits more from a new scheme: Russell Wilson or Derek Carr?
(42:00) If Dak Prescott was on the Ravens and Lamar Jackson was on the Cowboys, who would be better off?
(47:30) If you wanted to win a Super Bowl, would you rather have Kyler Murray or Mac Jones?
(49:30) Has Simms given up on Kellen Mond?
(50:55) For one game and one game only, would you take Ryan Fitzpatrick over any of the QBs from 21-40?
(52:45) What was Simms’ favorite type of receiver to throw to?
(54:15) Chris and Paul get into the weeds about QB shotgun stances
(56:20) What are the similarities and differences between Josh McDaniels and Kyle Shanahan?
(1:00:10) Who is your favorite non-football athlete?
(1:05:00) If you could replay any game you've played in, what would it be?
(1:07:30) Liam's wife Tara loves to rip on Simms
» Subscribe to NBC Sports: czcams.com/users/nbcsports?sub...
» Watch Live Sports on NBCSports.com: www.nbcsports.com/live
NBC Sports Group serves sports fans 24/7 with premier live events, insightful studio shows, and compelling original programming. NBC Sports is an established leader in the sports media landscape with an unparalleled collection of sports properties that include the Olympics, NFL, Premier League, NHL, NASCAR, PGA TOUR, the Kentucky Derby, Tour de France, French Open, IndyCar and many more. Subscribe to our channel for the latest sporting news and highlights!
'Chris Simms Unbuttoned' features in-depth Xs and Os NFL analysis; one-on-one interviews with players, coaches, executives, and draft prospects; game recaps and previews; gambling segments; extensive player analysis leading into the NFL Draft; and much more.
Visit NBC Sports: www.nbcsports.com
Find NBC Sports on Facebook: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Twitter: / nbcsports
Follow NBC Sports on Instagram: / nbcsports
www.nbcsports.com/nfl/sunday-...
nbcsports.com/motors/nascar
nbcsports.com/soccer/premier-...
Top 40 QB #AskMeAnything: 'Here, take my incest chickens' | CHRIS SIMMS UNBUTTONED (Ep. 381 FULL)
/ nbcsports - Sport
Simms roasting his wife 🤣🤣🤣🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
You guys are the best! Have a great summer Chris and Paul!
Finally! Chris Simms, the best talent evaluator on TV is on CZcams. I always catch #unbottoned on Peacock but it's nice to have this additional option.
The only thing i don’t understand about what chris has said this off-season is he keeps repeating “Josh allen has played consistently better than Mahomes the past two years.” Yet after the afc championship game last season when Mahomes played flawlessly and Allen had a really bad game Chris said on PFT that “Allen is really awesome, but he’s not on mahomes’ level yet.” So now just cause Mahomes had a month stretch of some bad games in 2021 all the sudden Allen has been better for two years? Idk that logic dont make sense to me
Brendan good to see you again
Brendan is back
Another great point
@@blick5511 blick good to see ya again
Everyone should know by now that Simms takes are all about emotion. When he looks at film and discusses specifics, he provides good insight. Then he will turn around and make a broad statement in direct opposition to the evidence he just provided. He's always been like that.
I clicked for incest chickens. I stayed for football expertise.
Is that the new name of football players? 😄
@@hamydunn9183 the washington Incest chickens. Commanders just didn’t roll off the tongue like they wanted
Chris being a total stoner but also a really good analyst is awesome
would love to smoke a blunt with Simms and talk football for hours lol
Lol Liked this video just for the title. Simms is the GOAT much love.
As a fellow lefty, MAD RESPECT for Chris being a daredevil using that kind of a pen. AND wearing white sleeves. Im DEAD
Bro just mentioned Sammy Watkins as a Mahomes weapon…Sammy has been gone for 2 years
While simultaneously saying looking at the current year for what it is, not past stuff. Oh well... Mahomes is better people will continue to say he's not as a talking point. Bounced Allen last 2 years where Mahomes was up against a better defense than Allen was.
Vish Kumaran is a legend!
As Florio would say: a new Simms-ism!42:12
“Marketably worse” I think he means “Markedly worse”?🧐
The Bills played 9 of their 17 regular season games against backup or rookie QBs. Every team gets some easy games, but the Bills played against bad offenses literally over half the time. Meanwhile, they got dominated when they played the Chiefs, Bucs, Colts, Titans, etc. They were the #1 defense in stats only.
They weren't dominated by thr chiefs or the bucs lmfao. They were dominated by the colts but that was do to turnovers caused by the bills playing terribly. The beat the chiefs in the regular season. Quite literally dominated them and in the second game in the playoffs Allen was the better QB. Any analyst will tell you that. Even Nick Wright who is a Josh Allen hater admitted that and even said if that game was in buffalo the bills would have won. The game was lost by a bad defensive stint (Without their #1 corner) and a coin flip. And they weren't dominated by the bucs. They were dominated in the first half and then dominated in the second. And were robbed by the refs when they didn't call a blatant PI call when the corner tackled diggs before the ball was even close while in the endzone,, which would have won the game. Even the defender got up looking for the flag and was surprised. And in OT they got away with the same thing and then called a terrible PI call against the bills that was absolutely terrible because Mike evens pulled the corner into himself to get the flag on 3rd down. And the stats do matter man lmao. They lost their #1 corner and still had the best defense in the league and they've been top 5 for 4 out of the last five years. What, did they get a lucky brake every year?
@@tohsakamine yes, Josh Allen was the better QB in that divisional game with less passing yards, less rushing yards and rushing TD’s and more carries, worse QBR and completion % all against a significantly worse defense. Half of his passing TD’s (2) were against CB’s that literally just fell down. Story checks out.
@@darylthebarrel2316 DVOA accounts for weak opponents and still had Bills defense ranked #1 last season and had their performance against the Texans as one of the greatest defensive performances in NFL history. Some of those backup QBs had really good games against other playoff teams, like Mike White against the Bengals or Davis Mills against the Pats, or Taylor Heineke against the Bucs and Raiders, but were all dominated by the Bills. Were the Bills the only team in the last 20 years to play a soft schedule? Because that's how long it was since a team got 2 shutouts in the first 4 games?
It's amazing because nobody cared about strength of schedule in the 2020 season when Bills played over 1/2 of their games against top 10 passing defenses, more than Mahomes and Rodgers combined that season. Yet strength of schedule was irrelevant because they all get paid?? Fast Forward 1 season and it's the most important factor for evaluating teams and players?? Go back and watch pregame stuff from games at the end of the season both year for the Bills and KC. It's incredible the 180 everyone did on SOS in a year.
As far as that playoff game, just watch the game. Mahomes played out of his mind but Allen had the greatest playoff run for a QB in NFL playoff history. Allen is the highest rated post season QB in the NFL. Both before and after this most recent playoffs run, Allen averaged more yards per game and a better TD/Int ratio than Rodgers, Mahomes, and Brady. All 3 of those guys have multiple playoff games with more int than Allen has in his career in the playoffs. I understand they have played in a lot more playoff games, but especially with Mahomes, not enough to account for that kind of stat. Mahomes has played in 5 more post season games and has a total of 3 individual postseason games with more int than Allen has thrown in his post season career.
Allen is the only QB in the NFL that no other QB can make all the plays he makes and he accounts for the largest percentage of offensive production in the NFL. If Allen played with the exact same stats and team for a team like New England or Dallas, he would be the face of the NFL but he plays in Buffalo so he still has people, with a national audience, claiming Baker Mayfield is a better QB.
Chiefs defense had the 4th least sacks that defense is horrid.
lol he’s been so much better the past two years yet Mahomes has made it further and beat him both times in the postseason
Allen has played perfect in every playoff game but the chief one last year. And he still is great and hasn’t had a questionable season or moment since he broke out. At least mahomes has that weird start to the season. It’s not as outrageous as you think.
Like simms said, if Allen had talent like the mahomes has he would have beat him both times
@@adamsgaming6265 Bullshit, dont be blinded that team is stack as well, Our Wr was ranked 1 in dropped passes and our defense was 29th, we dont have more talent only person that has a name is Jones.
@@usuckatthegame7096 that's completely false
@@adamsgaming6265 "if" lol....if Mahomes had that defense it would've been a blowout. Bills fans and a bunch of the media thought the Bills had the better overall team the last 2 years....then after Mahomes wins it's back pedaling to the "well look at his weapons" argument lol
Herbert will win MVP this year ⚡
Maybe let him make the playoffs one time before we start the MVP talk.
Good call brother !!⚡️⚡️⚡️
Drinky drinky Smokey Smokey time 🫡🔥💯
cam newton is not even in his honorable mention.... but he put case keenum and colt mccoy in his honorable mention.
Because Scam Newton is a shit QB and the most overrated to ever play in the NFL!
Insane disrespect
Cam is horrible now so...
Henry at 50-to-1 odds, knowing he can own the field and has a QB who does NOT overshadow him. If you think Henry will be healthy, put twenty bucks on him and win a thousand. I'm in. I'll take a bag lunch tomorrow to pay for it.
Everyone wants to say buffalo doesnt have the talent kc does when saying allen is better than mahomes but when the conversation comes up who the better team is this year its the bills. After last year allen does deserve the top spot but this next year kc will look way different, should be interesting.
Annnd then I listened to the convo about being hesitant to replace Kirk Cousins with Larmar.... Come on dude
kirk is worse than lamar
Chris mentions Andrew Luck being more efficient than Justin Herbert. Question for the QB's (or others who know). Is NFL QB "efficiency" just the attempt to completion ratio? Or is it something more....?
Other factors that could be considered in efficiency are how many yards the ball travels per attempt. (A pass thrown for 40 yards is more efficient than a pass thrown for 3)
Idk, but I miss Andrew Luck. If he was still around, Mahomes wouldn’t have sniffed a SB. The Colts had finally gotten their act together on offense when he retired.
Wentz over Jimmy G??
I said in a comment b4 josh Allen is like another version of cam newton, but Cam newton was a beast out there way better Running QB
For the ones who reads this just know this is only the beginning keep pushing, grinding, and fighting. Whatever it is in life you want to do to go after it life is to short. Life is a marathon not a sprint so go out there and live it up I hope all is well and goes well for you peace and one love! 🙏🏽
Way too low on rodgers. Say he has to go out and win the game but herbert will go out and lose you the game.
All the top 15 QB should be spoken about with the glass half full standard candle.
Earned 60% fandom over 40% hatedom.
Espn and other national sports media pushes to much hatedom.
If your hobby brings you to more hatedom than fandom its not for you. Get a new hobby or Get a new job.
MVP, Carr +3000 with Waller, Adams, Renfrow, Jacobs... worth a shot?
I love the pod and I watch every year, but there is no way you can justify Herbert and Burrow over Rodgers. Herbert, Burrow, and even Stafford, they make a lot of “wow” throws. But they also often put their teams in BAD spots. Stafford straight up lost a few games for the Rams. Rodgers has just as much “wow,” with none of the bad. Having him lower than 3 is joke, especially considering the fact you could make a compelling argument for him being #1. Chris missed big time on his top 5.
Was Rodgers not putting his team in a bad spot when his offense only scored 10 points in a playoff loss this year, a game in which they punted on 6 out of 10 drives of which 5 were three and outs? He’s below those guys because his conservatism costs his team games
@@yvjlvyu They would’ve won the game had the special teams executed though. And alternatively, he could have given the game away had he pressed too hard, which is what these other guys are subject to do. If you want to put a grade on these guys, just about every Rodgers game will be an A, with him really only dipping to C+ about once or twice. Alternatively, you get these other guys that could really end up anywhere alone the spectrum any given week. I see the argument for Burrow and Herbert, but I think we’re dinging Rodgers too much and following too much hype on the other guys. Rodgers is far more consistent and intelligent, and even though he’s almost 39, not far off in the talent category.
@@papapeaches0149 What happened is the only thing that matters. What if's don't matter because they didn't happen. His team F'd up and he couldn't bail them out. Herbert's D let him down multiple times and he still nearly put them in the playoffs. Burrow was playing at an excellent level until the playoffs and still played okay. He damn near won it all if his O-line wasn't so trash (most sacked QB in the NFL). Rodgers is still super elite and my pick from the NFC to go to the super bowl but I understand why Simms put him there.
@@narddog2151 Well I mean back to back MVPs would be your compelling case. I don’t think I’d put him at 1, but I wouldn’t put him at 5. I think 3 is fair.
lamar carries his team alot more than rodgers
If Lamar is credited 10 based upon his rush of 7 td then why would Ryan tannehills back to back 7 rush td not be credited the same? You can run all over the field but the points and production is what matters. Its surprising to know maybe but ryans always had 4 to 7 rush td. He's so efficient he scores more on less yardage than the average in both passing and rushing.
lamar is the ravens rushing attack, tannehill is a product of henry. big difference
@@terrancehall9762their was no Henry for ten games last year. Wasn't any aj brown or julio for 4 of 5 of those ten either.
Just Ryan and some back ups 6-4 .
@@terrancehall9762pass Td and int is so dependant upon receivers its the least data point of all but rush td are all player created.
lamar is dynamic and fun but still Ryan has had 4-7 rush td all 8 starting seasons even in Miami.
Lamar for all his running he don't turn it into anymore rush td points than Ryan.
And obviously Lamar's pass yards being a thousand less than ryan every year of he's played makes the big separating data and production.
When defining what is elite like this Chris appears to base most of if on last season. Which means Wilson Lamar or watson is getting something that didn't earn by default they got hurt.
You can do single game elite.
Career elite. A set period of time eliteness.
As an accumulated recent years top 10 they still don't belong in top 10
@@dadsonworldwide3238 all 3 are elite
Chris did not exactly answer WHY he had Burrow over Herbert and why Herbert now is ranked higher. Wow plays? Is that the answer. Unsatisfying.
Wow...lot to talk about that list...die hard Chiefs fan....I won't argue your one and two..... Russ over Brady is a thing...Lamar continues to drop as a passer....never seen the Dak love
Bills vs kc was the worst defensive playoff performance this decade. Both was trying to jump routes and pick the other off and it lead to td after td cause neither one could take the ball away.
It was a dumb plan on both sides.
No one earned the Td in that game. They had no value .
Disagree Allen to Davis second touchdown was a laser
The defenses didn't challenge the offenses and make them earn it enough to give TD value. You and everyone else knew whoever had the ball was going to score like an nba game. Its hard to respect that or get excited about a Td when its so easy and anticipated.
It was good offenses. And the defenses could've made them earn it more but they both tried to jump routes for Int and got beat to often..
The Josh Allen argument is the same one as the Lamar Jackson take etc the argument is always they don’t have more weapons then Mahomes. If Mahomes had those DEFENSES he’s getting a ring every year. The bills are a better overall team than the chiefs but Mahomes went up against a better defense and Put up the same numbers idk where the argument is
Chris haircut make him look like he's about to be arrested at a pride parade in Idaho
His haircut is ridiculous, as much as I like him. But holy shit his hair is weird.
I bet Simms' rankings next year has Bridgewater, Mariota, Hurts, Fields... all higher. Darnold will fall out of the top 32. Lock & load.
Even with the NUMBER ONE Defense still couldn't beat CYBORG(15) yet again in the playoffs is somehow Ranked above the Best player on the planet who has taken his team to 4 straight AFC Championships & back to back Superbowls. It's amazing how a guy who has WON NOTHING in this League is getting forced feed to us by attention seekers like this looking for clicks as their Credibility flies out the window. 99% of the Sports Sites rightfully have Mahomes as the number one QB because they are not going to Risk their Credibility for clicks. And even outside all of the winning Patrick Mahomes plays the type of game that's in a different STRATOSPHERE.
Because if you swap Mahomes and give him that Bills NUMBER ONE DEFENSE along with Stefon Diggs who is your Traditional Receiver with ELITE hands that Mahomes NEVER had, Mahomes would have crushed the Chiefs, There would be no talk of 13 seconds because it would have been a BLOWOUT. This Bills team is STACKED, People keep forgetting that the season before Josh Allen took over, A Tyrod Taylor Took these Bills without a Stefon Diggs to the Playoffs.
Regular season stats for defenses mean absolutetly nothing. Rams was like the 15th besg scoring defense in regular season. Whi saw them in the playoffs - knows they was top 3
huh?
Mohomes out played josh Allen and heat Allen he a hater bra better record better numbers Mohomes is the guy clearly
Sick of Chris Simms’s uninformed takes. Herbert and Burrow over Russ is absurd!
Nah that is fine, he put em over the back to back mvp which is fkn crazy tho
You need to watch football all over again
Bills had number 1 defense kc got no run game ether or defense hater
Burrow will win MVP this year.
Simms really epitomizes what’s wrong with the sports world. “Wins arent a qb stat” “well look where playing like brees and rodgers has gotten them they havent won anything” 🤡. Right simms its brees fault the minneapolis miracle happened, its brees fault the rudolph OPI wasnt called, its brees fault the rams DPI wasnt called, its brees fault jared cook fumbled when they were up by 10 vs the bucs. Its rodgers fault bostick couldnt recover an onside kick, its rodgers fault that his defense let up 250 yards before contact to mostert, its rodgers fault his team let up a blocked punt. For being mr. Wins arent a qb stat when it fits your narrative you sure seem to care about wins when it helps your argument.
I can agree...QB's raise the opportunity to win, like no other position...but you do need a team...a RB...an O-Line...wrs...and defense....with these in tow...a QB CAN correlate to WinS.....Even Simms will admit, Goff doesn't WIN the games in the playoffs that Stafford did...the Super Bowl....vs SF...and I doubt he gets up on Tampa...then does that magic to avoid OT...vs the greatest....Hell, put another QB on Tampa...and they don't get close in that Rams game...unless of course it's Herbert, Allen, Mahomes, Russell...Watson
Simms is right about Rodgers. He plays conservative after he believes they can control the game. Brees just got old and couldn’t score as proficiently as before.
But noting that “Simms really epitomizes what’s wrong with the sports world." is a gross generalization and hyperbole that you failed to explain how an analyst with an opinion who isn’t actively playing the game, is what’s wrong with the sports world.
Mahomes is definitely number 1.
Lol you want to talk better end of year play? Mahomes beat Allen the playoffs AGAIN. Got farther in the playoffs AGAIN.
lmaoooooooo, stop it, i got mahomes at 4, after that melt down with a 21-3 lead in the afc chip game, he's 4th on my list, Allen is clearly the best Qb in the game, thats why his team is favorite to win the super bowl, it's because of him
ok well with that idiotic rational you must have burrow ahead of mahomes since he beat him week 17 and in the afc title game
@@onlyfacts9820 “i got Mahomes number 4 on my list.” Good thing nobody gives a shit about your list lol
what rule have they changed for him tho? Brady had one lolololol
lmaooooooooo, mahomes didn't beat Allen, tyrek hill beat the bills defense, Allen clearly outplayed mahomes, mahomes was throwing short passes and tyrek hill was turning them into 70 yard td's, which made his stats look good, Allen was doing everything for his team, mahomes then went to the afc chip game, where he was up 21-3 at halftime and wet the bed, only scored 3 points in the whole 2nd half, he costed his team the game, mahomes is the 4th best quarterback in the league, don't know how anybody with football sense can put him at number one with the Sb performance he had a couple of years ago and the afc chip game he just had, he's regression , Allen is trending up
#21, #22, #23, #24 will all be in the 30's or unranked next year.
SIMMS is delusional. dak is surrounded by weapons and has won nothing....dak doesn't even know the rules. lamar is better than dak. simms is a hater. you can he is pressed lamar called him out. he is a florio shill now. simms ignores the injuries, no weapons and g ro as oc