It was a fast one only on people who don't pay attention. She explicitly stated she wants peace once you reach the isle. Also, look at her, what could you possibly do to save her? She's a broken, fractured mess, almost a corpse by this point and your decision makes her give up on life and die. Luckily she has other fragments of hers so she can still dial back time for you to make another choice another playthrough.
He gives that dialogue even if you give her peace but choose to lie to him by saying you released her. Because if you don't give her peace, both options are a lie, that's why Manus sees through it. You clearly didn't "release" her as she dies an agonizing death moments after your arrival and you also didn't give her the peace she explicitly asked of you.
Sophia was a great climax for the story! But they shouldn't time pressure the player into a euthanasia decision. My gaming mind is used defeat the bad guys and save the princess. This one truly hit me hard... 💀💀💀
Increasing your humanity level. Every time you lie it shows on the screen that your puppet heart is reacting, when this message shows it means that your humanity level has increased. There are other actions hidden in the game that increase your humanity.
When i thought letting her live would get me the secret ending 😭
Go through the game again… It’s easy!
Damn, they pulled a fast one on us. You'd think that the dialogue option to let her live would actually save her and get you the good ending.....
It was a fast one only on people who don't pay attention. She explicitly stated she wants peace once you reach the isle. Also, look at her, what could you possibly do to save her? She's a broken, fractured mess, almost a corpse by this point and your decision makes her give up on life and die. Luckily she has other fragments of hers so she can still dial back time for you to make another choice another playthrough.
Now that you explain it, you make more sense there. @@Siddios
@@Siddios too bad for sophia i will aways chose let her live in every single playthrough
@@colorpg152 then you are true evil
@@colorpg152Why?
Devs really lost a good chance do put: 'I CAN FIX HER' option.
Wow I haven’t chosen to let her live so I haven’t gotten that Simon dialogue
He gives that dialogue even if you give her peace but choose to lie to him by saying you released her. Because if you don't give her peace, both options are a lie, that's why Manus sees through it. You clearly didn't "release" her as she dies an agonizing death moments after your arrival and you also didn't give her the peace she explicitly asked of you.
@@Siddios thank you. I guess I just chose the different dialogue the first couple of times playing I just ALSO always usually save her
Sophia was a great climax for the story!
But they shouldn't time pressure the player into a euthanasia decision. My gaming mind is used defeat the bad guys and save the princess. This one truly hit me hard... 💀💀💀
I got the real ending on my 3rd play thru and I never thought of letting her live 💀
My heart is POUNDING and i still didnt save her 😔
THANK YOU
That s it?! So you really CAN T save her 🥺
You can save her in the real ending
You can save her in the Rise of P ending. It's actually a surprisingly wholesome ending for a souls-like.
@rolfo728 how?
Increasing your humanity level.
Every time you lie it shows on the screen that your puppet heart is reacting, when this message shows it means that your humanity level has increased.
There are other actions hidden in the game that increase your humanity.
I finished the game in both ending. I don t really call the true ending « saving her ».