SubhanAllah....the way I see it is that even though scholars thought it was an extra word or couldn't make any sense of it, they continued to copy as is. This is way before printing press.
Assalamualaikum. Thank you so much for this. I understand your discomfort for not being given the appropriate justification. I can imagine our young men and women seeking knowledge in higher institutions being cloned and brainwashed in a similar manner and not wanting to even ask for fear of standing out like a sore thumb. May Allah guide us to the truth.
I don't have much knowledge of the Quran and Arabic is not my native language but it always hurts me when Islamic scholars say: "this word in Quran does not have meaning" or "there is a missing word in this ayat". How a scholar can dought Allah (swt) word??? I love listening to your lectures because you do not add or dismiss words, you are trying to understand what Allah wants to tell us, not what we want to hear. Thank you for sharing your works with us, I really learn a lot from you.
Everything is open to interpretation as long as there is evidence and thorough understanding even if someone doesnt agree to ur conclusion we cannot say its right or wrong and Allah knows best.
Salaamun alaikum, such a pleasure to visit these segments after awhile. I remember how shocked I was when i listened to it for the first time. The evidence is so glaring. And it is no surprise that the opponents cant seem to find their words in the light of this evidence.
Watching the segment after a long time, I remember a debate with an Imam of local mosque regarding this issue, where at last he gave an explanation from what he have been taught , and it plainly said it was an extra word ! And that was a heavy realization.........
Subhanallaah, I was telling you about similar experience in a comment in one of your recent videos and I am just watching this video for the first time. This notion used to disturb me a lot during my attendance of the halaqat when I was a teenager, one of the instances that still haunt me and I hope you will help decipher it is 42:11 (ليس كمثله شيء) that my teacher used to disregard the ك because it carried similar meaning of مثل. I assume you get the point and what he is avoiding and his reasoning made sense to me at the time but I kept asking why would Allaah use it in the first place and I still struggle with it to this day. Jazakallahu Kheyr.
Having an unconditional belief that Quran is the word of Allah and it is flawless is the key to success... If something doesn't make sense in Quran means it is a sign telling us to stop and search till it makes sense ...
As an Arab, this is the explanation. The story is being told by Allah who is well aware of the intentions of Musa. The first "An" refers to "the decision" of Musa that he decided to do an action. The second "An" refers to his action itself. If you are writing a story in classical formal Arabic, it is a style of writing. It is not something that is unusual or out of context but it is rare and only shows the highest level of literature.
This is incorrect my friend. I challenge you to provide one single example from Arabic literature that shows "an" before "Araada". I challenge you! This is a unique Quranic style, and yet many Tafseer and Arabic linguists decided this "An" before "Araada" is extraneous!
I truly believe Rabilallameen is opening up knowledge for people who are sincere and genuinely seeking true guidance. Allah gives us miracles DAILY subhA. I don't really care what the mainstream think anymore. They are truly lost in my view and reading some of the comments on Dr Hany'd videos confirms my view that many are unable to step outside their preconceptions to actually learn about the real Deen. They view the so called scholars of past and present like infallible oracles of knowledge, which some of us clearly know, they most certainly are not.
Thank you Dr Hany, for sharing this with all of us. It is useful to take notes, as I am doing upon my second (or third) view. I have never been so close to the ayaat of Allah before I came upon your channel earlier this year. Alhamdulillah. Glad to be here with you & MQ for this life-giving ilm 🙏
Yes, this was very useful to me. And that those "purposeless conjunctions" are still there, proofs the integrity of the Qur'an and that Allah swt is indeed taking care of His word. Thanks for your efforts and may Allah give you the reward.
What's the difference between in Surah Qasas 28:31 "...أن يموسي..." and Surah Ta-Ha 20:11 "...يموسي..." (no أن)? Both are talking about the same moment but one has "أن" and the other one doesn't?? Please explain to me what I'm missing here.
Excellent question! Masha Allahh! The Quran teaches us about its own style, in several ways and in several repeated scenes. This is one of the many reasons for repeating scenes in different places in the Quran.. In Surah Taha 20:11-12, it shows us that "نودي" does NOT have to be followed by "أن". In other words, it is what the traditional Arabic allows and expects. In Surah Al-Qassas 28:30, it shows us that the call was not direct, but through an indirect agent... And that way, by showing us the 2 ways to the exact same event, the Quran is teaching us its own style of expressions which is different than traditional Arabic. If the Quran followed the traditional Arabic style, 28:30 would have necessarily needed to follow that style too. Instead, it is telling us that the Quran is not limited to that style! Regards
My Egyptologist friend says N is the creative sound of God. She is not Muslim. So I quoted Kun Fa yakun to her. She was surprised. In your examples of AN, the Alif also brings out the creative Noon. You see direct intervention of God. Like God is saying , Himself. Perhaps worth looking at. I haven't thought of AN, will look now as I go along, reading the Quran. So take mine with a bit of salt. I obviously can't prove the concept of The Creative Sound. Perhaps others know more. Still it so fitted Kun Fa yakun.
Dear brother Hany, thank you so much for your drawing attention to the Arabic word أن an. I found an explanation for أن an in the book إعراب القرآن الكريم written by Muhyi ad-Deen ad-Darweesh, saying that "أن an" in sura 28:19 is pointing to a different quickness in acting of Musa concerning the first and the second aggression. In Arabic it reads as follows: أن : زائدة، وتطرد زيادتها بعد لما، وقبل لو، مسبوقة بقسم، كقول الشاعر: فأقسم أن لو التقينا وأنتم لكان لكم يوم من الشر مظلم وإنما زاد "أن" للإشعار بأن موسى لم تكن مسارعته إلى قتل الثاني، كما كانت مسارعته إلى قتل الأول، بل كان عنده إبطاء في بسط يده إليه فعبر القرآن عن دلك الإبطاء بزيادة أن I would kindly ask you for your opinion on that explanation. Regards Gunnar
@ GUNNAR When you apply his explanation to other ayats where the same "An" was used, it does not work. Sometimes these grammarians come up with their own explanations based on Arab poetry, or just guessing, while not taking in consideration how the Quran intended it. See for example 27:8 Notice that he referred to it as "Za'idah" Regards
Subhanallah at last someone answering all the dilemmas of majority Muslims. By the way, Prof Atchan, how about the Arabic 3 letter word / 2 letter word at beginning of the Surah - what does it mean?
Going back to this one. Did you consider any other possible meanings before concluding in "(indirectly)"? How did you figure it out? Also I'm wondering if there was a specific reason it was placed twice in 28:19.
Brilliant! the mainstream scholars brushed it aside saying it’s just extraneous and people accepted their concepts BUT there would be those that understood many such things yet could not put it forward because the rulers/powers were backing the mainstream. They would easily stifle such voices.
There are messengers whose stories We have told you already and others We have not. And to Moses Allah spoke directly. Yeah this one is going to be very tough, unless taklima means also something else.
More I see Dr Hany’s videos more I think was there a conscious attempt to hide Quran and is this still going on in big Islamic institutes as well as at individual level. Allah huwal Alam
@ Crazy Streamer Do you really expect them to say "O Yes! We have been neglecting the Quran and chasing human narrations that have no authoritativeness!" ? or "O Yes! We have been doing exactly what Allahh warned not to do in the Quran!" ?
Asalāmu’alaikim Sir , “ALLAH“ is knower of the thirst of SOULS for right knowledge has arisen now, in the 21st century, when people are more exposed to science and education and availability of extraordinary abundances with no clear sense of belief, yet living with the religious community/ families . Is not making sense and no questions are answered by the so called Ulemas / preachers . Hence God made seekers of truth,take a leap into the ocean of knowledge in search of the path of the true believers to the “CREATOR” of the WORLDS . So “ALMIGHTY LORD” is opening the ways to seekers and YOU are the chosen one among few others (righteous people). I pray to “ALLAH” to give you best of health and understandings to teach the correct translation of “The QURAN KAREEM” and what “ALLAH” meant for us all, through Prophets’ teachings. Amen 🙏🏻
It would seem that after baby suckles from its mom, it would refuse to feed from anyone else. These are some pretty wild stories that you’ve concocted. Have you ever sat down with any of the major scholars from Saudi Arabia and explained these stories??? Does any major scholar agree with what you’ve discovered???
@Mr Stranger And you don't think it's wild to claim that the Quran has extraneous words and expressions??? And you prefer to think that Moses heard Allahh's voice??? Amazing amount of denial
@@MarvelousQuran Could it be possible that these words you call extraneous are relevant but you don’t understand how??? I find it strange that Musa grew another hand 🤚 and no one from the scholars or the children of Israel ever knew about it. In addition it’s strange that the messenger of Allah (saw) never mentioned it. There’s a Hadith or is it Quran about the rock running away with Musa’s clothes while he was bathing and his entire body was exposed and they found him to be perfect in his anatomy. Allah (swt) also spoke to Muhammad (saw) above the heavens when he gave him the salah. So speaking Musa is what the Quran says right??? Anyway this locution system you’ve come with is gonna shake a lot people up.
@Mr Stranger The quran clearly said that Bani Issrail hid a lot of their knowledge There is no evidence to confirm that we received everything the Prophet SAWS or his companions knew. As a matter of fact, in later videos (which I am sure you have not seen yet) we prove the opposite. About the Hadeeth about the rock running away!!!!!!!!!! Suit yourself brother!
@@MarvelousQuran "There is no evidence to confirm that we received everything the Prophet SAWS or his companions knew" I need to research into that more and I might not know what u mean by saying that exactly but I dont want us to fall into saying our religion is not complete when the Quran says our religion is complete.
Takleem indicates multiple times. Many scholars have already determined this, such as Az-Zamakhshari Mussa was addressed by Allahh, just like Allahh addressed several other prophets and messengers in the Quran: Indirectly To learn more, please see this video czcams.com/video/Hi-agtNQaQA/video.html
I answered you because I understood your question. Mussa was addressed by Allahh, just like Allahh addressed several other prophets and messengers in the Quran: Indirectly Watch the video plz
@@MarvelousQuran Dr. Hany, I watched the video 2 times before I raise this question I shouldn't go in debates, you are much higher than me in knowledge and wisdom, this makes me feel some how embarrassed. But please excuse my eagerness and let me rephrase my question Why this verse was said especially only for prophet Mussa, and it was not said the same for the other prophets? Although you had mentioned he was spoken to, the same way (indirectly) like the other prophets Do you mean that ALLAHH used other sound instruments like wind as an example, rather than angels to make the semi-direct communication happens? Especially Sorat Taha, contains a lot of the conversations that happened between ALLAHH and Mussa you will find it without "أن"
No worries my brother! Your original comment asked for the meaning of 1 aya. I provided it. Now you are asking a follow up questions. That's fine! Your questions: 1. Why this verse only mentions Moussa? 2. How (exactly) did Allahh deliver the communication to Moussa? 3. Why in some cases without "أن"? Here are the answers: 1. See Aya 42:51. It tells us that all messengers and prophets (and even all human beings) received "takleem". Those behind "hijab" are not messengers or prophets, but the rejecters described in Aya 17:45 2. How? We don't really know for sure, but angels talk to us all the time. Most of us don't even want to recognize that they do 3. Having mentioned "أن" is sufficient in a few cases to confirm that Allahh did not talk directly, but through delivery agents such as angels Regards
He speaks to everyone of us all the time, but Not directly. Aya 42:51 clearly identifies the 2 forms of communication: - Enjoinments (i.e., instructions, or commands that we sense inside of us... We call them "drive", "gut feelings", or "instinctive reactions"), or - Through messengers (sometimes humans, and sometimes angels) Hijab (in Aya 42:51) is an obstacle, not a filter. In other words, this refers to those of us to whom Allahh is talking, but they refuse to listen or to heed. They raised an obstacle between themselves and Allahh that prevents them from recognizing the divine communication.
@@MarvelousQuran Salaam Brother Hany, can you please explain sura 4:164. I am trying to learn how to apply your method (Abrahamic Locution) and when I read this Ayat it does not have the (alif-noon) An. But Scholars say this is direct talk from Allah to Musa. Please help me.
This man is from those who deny Hadiths. That's why he is finding new meanings to the Holy Quran. The issue of the word UN is nothing but a twist he is trying to create in the minds of ignorant people. In an Hadith our Beloved Prophet ﷺ cautioned us of such men at the end times who will curse the earlier generations of Muslims as he is doing i.e. all scholars before him were ignorant of the Holy Quran and its meanings. عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، قَالَتْ: أَمَا إِنِّي سَمِعْتُ نَبِيَّكُمْ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يَقُولُ: «لَا تَفْنَى هَذِهِ الْأُمَّةُ حَتَّى يَلْعَنَ آخِرُهَا أَوَّلَهَا»
We never cursed anyone. I challenge you to find anywhere we Dr Hany cursed anyone! We, as Muslims, including yourself, have the obligation, in accordance with the instructions from the Quran, to question people's interpretations of Allahh's words. That's what we did. We never accused any one specifically of bad intention!!! Please do NOT Exaggerate and do NOT misquote what Dr Hany said. Regarding Hadeeth: Are you aware of our clear position on Hadeeth in this video czcams.com/video/rXdzcgiBxQU/video.html, and in this video czcams.com/video/noBa4w76O58/video.html We actually defended a Hadeeth that NONE OF THE HADEETH SCHOLARS WOULD TOUCH!!! Not enough for you??? Please watch the above videos carefully before you judge unfairly. You owe it to yourself to judge fairly lest you earn bad deeds unintentionally.
@@MarvelousQuran may Allah reward you with this effort, I know there will be people who may disagree with you but hopefully they will be respect your view.. I am watching all your videos..
Also, Adam AS, many people have misconception that Adam AS and Eve RA was in Heaven when they did the Sin.. which I do not agree as how the Satan can enter the paradise if Adam AS was in the heaven..
That makes no sense that Musa(as) was part of a gang! And if so why would he kill his own member??? The story is about two different races of people not gangs.
Baarak Allah feek Dr.Hany you really showed that every letter every word of Qur'an is perfect in its place, we are not perfect to get the meaning
You too Akhi
SubhanAllah....the way I see it is that even though scholars thought it was an extra word or couldn't make any sense of it, they continued to copy as is. This is way before printing press.
Assalamualaikum. Thank you so much for this. I understand your discomfort for not being given the appropriate justification. I can imagine our young men and women seeking knowledge in higher institutions being cloned and brainwashed in a similar manner and not wanting to even ask for fear of standing out like a sore thumb. May Allah guide us to the truth.
I don't have much knowledge of the Quran and Arabic is not my native language but it always hurts me when Islamic scholars say: "this word in Quran does not have meaning" or "there is a missing word in this ayat". How a scholar can dought Allah (swt) word??? I love listening to your lectures because you do not add or dismiss words, you are trying to understand what Allah wants to tell us, not what we want to hear. Thank you for sharing your works with us, I really learn a lot from you.
Alhamdulillah
🤝🏾
Thank you for all your hard work
Everything is open to interpretation as long as there is evidence and thorough understanding even if someone doesnt agree to ur conclusion we cannot say its right or wrong and Allah knows best.
OK. As you wish
Salaamun alaikum, such a pleasure to visit these segments after awhile. I remember how shocked I was when i listened to it for the first time. The evidence is so glaring. And it is no surprise that the opponents cant seem to find their words in the light of this evidence.
Watching the segment after a long time, I remember a debate with an Imam of local mosque regarding this issue, where at last he gave an explanation from what he have been taught , and it plainly said it was an extra word !
And that was a heavy realization.........
Masa Allah. Excellent and increasing our iman and encourages to read Quran often. May Allah help our ummah to more engagement with Quran.
Alhamdulillah
Very true , if you learn by heart Allah helps you and opens the doors of understanding...
Jazakallah o khair Sir.
Subhanallaah, I was telling you about similar experience in a comment in one of your recent videos and I am just watching this video for the first time. This notion used to disturb me a lot during my attendance of the halaqat when I was a teenager, one of the instances that still haunt me and I hope you will help decipher it is 42:11 (ليس كمثله شيء) that my teacher used to disregard the ك because it carried similar meaning of مثل. I assume you get the point and what he is avoiding and his reasoning made sense to me at the time but I kept asking why would Allaah use it in the first place and I still struggle with it to this day. Jazakallahu Kheyr.
Having an unconditional belief that Quran is the word of Allah and it is flawless is the key to success...
If something doesn't make sense in Quran means it is a sign telling us to stop and search till it makes sense ...
Alhamdulillah thank you Dr Hanu
As an Arab, this is the explanation. The story is being told by Allah who is well aware of the intentions of Musa. The first "An" refers to "the decision" of Musa that he decided to do an action. The second "An" refers to his action itself. If you are writing a story in classical formal Arabic, it is a style of writing. It is not something that is unusual or out of context but it is rare and only shows the highest level of literature.
This is incorrect my friend. I challenge you to provide one single example from Arabic literature that shows "an" before "Araada". I challenge you!
This is a unique Quranic style, and yet many Tafseer and Arabic linguists decided this "An" before "Araada" is extraneous!
Alhamdulillah, nothing is extraneous in the words of Allah.
I truly believe Rabilallameen is opening up knowledge for people who are sincere and genuinely seeking true guidance. Allah gives us miracles DAILY subhA. I don't really care what the mainstream think anymore. They are truly lost in my view and reading some of the comments on Dr Hany'd videos confirms my view that many are unable to step outside their preconceptions to actually learn about the real Deen. They view the so called scholars of past and present like infallible oracles of knowledge, which some of us clearly know, they most certainly are not.
Alhamdulillah
Really Marvelous explanation.
Alhumdulilah, Salaamum Alaykum, May Allah guide us to a self-correcting methodology.
Thank you Dr Hany, for sharing this with all of us. It is useful to take notes, as I am doing upon my second (or third) view. I have never been so close to the ayaat of Allah before I came upon your channel earlier this year. Alhamdulillah. Glad to be here with you & MQ for this life-giving ilm 🙏
Yes, this was very useful to me.
And that those "purposeless conjunctions" are still there, proofs the integrity of the Qur'an and that Allah swt is indeed taking care of His word.
Thanks for your efforts and may Allah give you the reward.
Asalam aleykum warahmatullah wabarakatu. Jazakallahu kheir Dr Hany
How did you come up with this conclusion
Wow Dr. Hany you solved one of the biggest questions that I had regarding Quranic interpretation. That is from Surah 28:30. Thanks a lot.
Alhamdulillah. More big questions resolved in many other videos insha Allahh
JAZAKALLAH khair brother
Alhamdulillah. Thank you Dr Hany.
What's the difference between in Surah Qasas 28:31 "...أن يموسي..." and Surah Ta-Ha 20:11 "...يموسي..." (no أن)? Both are talking about the same moment but one has "أن" and the other one doesn't?? Please explain to me what I'm missing here.
Excellent question! Masha Allahh!
The Quran teaches us about its own style, in several ways and in several repeated scenes. This is one of the many reasons for repeating scenes in different places in the Quran..
In Surah Taha 20:11-12, it shows us that "نودي" does NOT have to be followed by "أن". In other words, it is what the traditional Arabic allows and expects.
In Surah Al-Qassas 28:30, it shows us that the call was not direct, but through an indirect agent...
And that way, by showing us the 2 ways to the exact same event, the Quran is teaching us its own style of expressions which is different than traditional Arabic. If the Quran followed the traditional Arabic style, 28:30 would have necessarily needed to follow that style too. Instead, it is telling us that the Quran is not limited to that style!
Regards
That explains it. Thanks a lot.
My Egyptologist friend says N is the creative sound of God. She is not Muslim. So I quoted Kun Fa yakun to her. She was surprised.
In your examples of AN, the Alif also brings out the creative Noon. You see direct intervention of God. Like God is saying , Himself. Perhaps worth looking at.
I haven't thought of AN, will look now as I go along, reading the Quran. So take mine with a bit of salt.
I obviously can't prove the concept of The Creative Sound. Perhaps others know more. Still it so fitted Kun Fa yakun.
Alhamdulillah
Dear brother Hany,
thank you so much for your drawing attention to the Arabic word أن an.
I found an explanation for أن an in the book إعراب القرآن الكريم written by Muhyi ad-Deen ad-Darweesh, saying that "أن an" in sura 28:19 is pointing to a different quickness in acting of Musa concerning the first and the second aggression. In Arabic it reads as follows:
أن : زائدة، وتطرد زيادتها بعد لما، وقبل لو، مسبوقة بقسم، كقول الشاعر:
فأقسم أن لو التقينا وأنتم لكان لكم يوم من الشر مظلم
وإنما زاد "أن" للإشعار بأن موسى لم تكن مسارعته إلى قتل الثاني، كما كانت مسارعته إلى قتل الأول، بل كان عنده إبطاء في بسط يده إليه فعبر القرآن عن دلك الإبطاء بزيادة أن
I would kindly ask you for your opinion on that explanation.
Regards
Gunnar
@ GUNNAR
When you apply his explanation to other ayats where the same "An" was used, it does not work.
Sometimes these grammarians come up with their own explanations based on Arab poetry, or just guessing, while not taking in consideration how the Quran intended it. See for example 27:8
Notice that he referred to it as "Za'idah"
Regards
Alhamdulillah. Tq MQ.
Subhanallah at last someone answering all the dilemmas of majority Muslims. By the way, Prof Atchan, how about the Arabic 3 letter word / 2 letter word at beginning of the Surah - what does it mean?
Some knowledge has been divulged, and we remain silent on what we don't know
Going back to this one. Did you consider any other possible meanings before concluding in "(indirectly)"? How did you figure it out? Also I'm wondering if there was a specific reason it was placed twice in 28:19.
When you gather all the occurrences, a pattern develops, especially after understanding the story in Surah 28.
Thank you Sir, respects from India 🇮🇳
What is shajara's meaning in the 28:30?
In the traditional translation they translate as "tree".
Mashallah
Brilliant! the mainstream scholars brushed it aside saying it’s just extraneous and people accepted their concepts BUT there would be those that understood many such things yet could not put it forward because the rulers/powers were backing the mainstream.
They would easily stifle such voices.
Masyaallah! its true that jibrael was and is the mediator
Alhamdulillah..
Dr how do you explain this, (4:164) "And Allah spoke to Moses with [direct] speech"
Wrong translation: It does not say he talked to him directly
Dr, how do you explain this, in Surah An-Nisa verse164, "And Allah spoke to Moses with [direct] speech"
The word " ان " in the study of Nahwu Sorof means Harf Masdariah and Harf Tafseer
What about the "أن' in 28:19, and in 12:96 ?
The Mufassiroon said it was extraneous (زائدة), did they not?
My fav Brother,plz make a video on yahweh. Inshallah you will make. 🌺
There is no Yahweh in the Quran
ASSALAMUN Alaikum:- Brother-:- When-people-DONT-UNDERSTAND-OR-Then-they-DONT-WANT-To-UNDERSTAND-THey-WILL-OPPOSE-you-BEYOND-LIMIT-IS-EASY-FOR-THem.!!-??? FeeAmaanALLAH KAREEEEM
Doctor, can you explain Surah 4 verse 164 where it states that Allah spoke to Musa(AS) directly
Masha Allahh. Very good question. Please keep watching. Answers are forthcoming soon. Regards
@@MarvelousQuran please give me link for 4:164 as someone asked you earlier.
Thank you
There are messengers whose stories We have told you already and others We have not. And to Moses Allah spoke directly.
Yeah this one is going to be very tough, unless taklima means also something else.
More I see Dr Hany’s videos more I think was there a conscious attempt to hide Quran and is this still going on in big Islamic institutes as well as at individual level. Allah huwal Alam
If we have question in your videos how can we ask to make ourselves clear. JazakaAllah kair.
Ask away. Questions that are related to the video are welcome here. Alternatively, you could connect via email marvelousquran@gmail.com
Dr Hani when i dicussed ,some of my fellows ahle hadeeth said that i m affected of munkireen e hadeeth rasool
@ Crazy Streamer
Do you really expect them to say "O Yes! We have been neglecting the Quran and chasing human narrations that have no authoritativeness!" ?
or
"O Yes! We have been doing exactly what Allahh warned not to do in the Quran!" ?
@@MarvelousQuran my brother dr Hani ,u r genius ,i appreciate your hard work ,what do u say about verse no 26 of aale Imran ,please let me know
We addressed this aya in the video on Allahhumma
كلم الله موسى تكليما
How would you explain this being an indirect conversation??
Your recording volume is so low that it is difficult to focus. Pls correct it!
Insha Allahh
Asalāmu’alaikim Sir ,
“ALLAH“ is knower of the thirst of SOULS for right knowledge has arisen now, in the 21st century, when people are more exposed to science and education and availability of extraordinary abundances with no clear sense of belief, yet living with the religious community/ families . Is not making sense and no questions are answered by the so called Ulemas / preachers .
Hence God made seekers of truth,take a leap into the ocean of knowledge in search of the path of the true believers to the “CREATOR” of the WORLDS .
So “ALMIGHTY LORD” is opening the ways to seekers and YOU are the chosen one among few others (righteous people).
I pray to “ALLAH” to give you best of health and understandings to teach the correct translation of “The QURAN KAREEM” and what “ALLAH” meant for us all, through Prophets’ teachings. Amen 🙏🏻
alhamdulillah
AAAmeen
,🙆🤷🙅🤦 Everything is literally changing.....!!!!!!
Subhan Allah
It would seem that after baby suckles from its mom, it would refuse to feed from anyone else. These are some pretty wild stories that you’ve concocted. Have you ever sat down with any of the major scholars from Saudi Arabia and explained these stories??? Does any major scholar agree with what you’ve discovered???
@Mr Stranger
And you don't think it's wild to claim that the Quran has extraneous words and expressions???
And you prefer to think that Moses heard Allahh's voice???
Amazing amount of denial
@@MarvelousQuran Could it be possible that these words you call extraneous are relevant but you don’t understand how??? I find it strange that Musa grew another hand 🤚 and no one from the scholars or the children of Israel ever knew about it. In addition it’s strange that the messenger of Allah (saw) never mentioned it. There’s a Hadith or is it Quran about the rock running away with Musa’s clothes while he was bathing and his entire body was exposed and they found him to be perfect in his anatomy. Allah (swt) also spoke to Muhammad (saw) above the heavens when he gave him the salah. So speaking Musa is what the Quran says right??? Anyway this locution system you’ve come with is gonna shake a lot people up.
@Mr Stranger The quran clearly said that Bani Issrail hid a lot of their knowledge
There is no evidence to confirm that we received everything the Prophet SAWS or his companions knew. As a matter of fact, in later videos (which I am sure you have not seen yet) we prove the opposite.
About the Hadeeth about the rock running away!!!!!!!!!! Suit yourself brother!
@@MarvelousQuran Ok my brother, Inshallah I will check out the rest of your videos before I say another word. May Allah forgive and guide us Ameen!
@@MarvelousQuran "There is no evidence to confirm that we received everything the Prophet SAWS or his companions knew" I need to research into that more and I might not know what u mean by saying that exactly but I dont want us to fall into saying our religion is not complete when the Quran says our religion is complete.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Alhamdullilah
I will write the verses in Arabic so as not to burden the mis-translation
So what is the meaning of: "كلم الله موسى تكليما"؟
Takleem indicates multiple times. Many scholars have already determined this, such as Az-Zamakhshari
Mussa was addressed by Allahh, just like Allahh addressed several other prophets and messengers in the Quran: Indirectly
To learn more, please see this video czcams.com/video/Hi-agtNQaQA/video.html
@@MarvelousQuran
بارك الله فيك
أنا أقصد بأن الله قال "كلم الله موسى تكليما"
اليس هذا دليل بأنه كلم سيدنا موسى بشكل مباشر؟
I answered you because I understood your question.
Mussa was addressed by Allahh, just like Allahh addressed several other prophets and messengers in the Quran: Indirectly
Watch the video plz
@@MarvelousQuran
Dr. Hany, I watched the video 2 times before I raise this question
I shouldn't go in debates, you are much higher than me in knowledge and wisdom, this makes me feel some how embarrassed.
But please excuse my eagerness and let me rephrase my question
Why this verse was said especially only for prophet Mussa, and it was not said the same for the other prophets?
Although you had mentioned he was spoken to, the same way (indirectly) like the other prophets
Do you mean that ALLAHH used other sound instruments like wind as an example, rather than angels to make the semi-direct communication happens?
Especially Sorat Taha, contains a lot of the conversations that happened between ALLAHH and Mussa you will find it without "أن"
No worries my brother!
Your original comment asked for the meaning of 1 aya. I provided it.
Now you are asking a follow up questions. That's fine!
Your questions:
1. Why this verse only mentions Moussa?
2. How (exactly) did Allahh deliver the communication to Moussa?
3. Why in some cases without "أن"?
Here are the answers:
1. See Aya 42:51. It tells us that all messengers and prophets (and even all human beings) received "takleem". Those behind "hijab" are not messengers or prophets, but the rejecters described in Aya 17:45
2. How? We don't really know for sure, but angels talk to us all the time. Most of us don't even want to recognize that they do
3. Having mentioned "أن" is sufficient in a few cases to confirm that Allahh did not talk directly, but through delivery agents such as angels
Regards
Love u so much
Love you too brother
Brother Haney, according to the Quran did Allah swt ever speaking directly to any of His swt prophets?
He speaks to everyone of us all the time, but Not directly. Aya 42:51 clearly identifies the 2 forms of communication:
- Enjoinments (i.e., instructions, or commands that we sense inside of us... We call them "drive", "gut feelings", or "instinctive reactions"), or
- Through messengers (sometimes humans, and sometimes angels)
Hijab (in Aya 42:51) is an obstacle, not a filter. In other words, this refers to those of us to whom Allahh is talking, but they refuse to listen or to heed. They raised an obstacle between themselves and Allahh that prevents them from recognizing the divine communication.
@@MarvelousQuran Salaam Brother Hany, can you please explain sura 4:164. I am trying to learn how to apply your method (Abrahamic Locution) and when I read this Ayat it does not have the (alif-noon) An. But Scholars say this is direct talk from Allah to Musa. Please help me.
4:164 "Takleem" simply means multiple times. And several Tafseer scholars have confirmed this. This is not even controversial.
This man is from those who deny Hadiths. That's why he is finding new meanings to the Holy Quran. The issue of the word UN is nothing but a twist he is trying to create in the minds of ignorant people. In an Hadith our Beloved Prophet ﷺ cautioned us of such men at the end times who will curse the earlier generations of Muslims as he is doing i.e. all scholars before him were ignorant of the Holy Quran and its meanings. عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، قَالَتْ: أَمَا إِنِّي سَمِعْتُ نَبِيَّكُمْ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يَقُولُ: «لَا تَفْنَى هَذِهِ الْأُمَّةُ حَتَّى يَلْعَنَ آخِرُهَا أَوَّلَهَا»
We never cursed anyone. I challenge you to find anywhere we Dr Hany cursed anyone!
We, as Muslims, including yourself, have the obligation, in accordance with the instructions from the Quran, to question people's interpretations of Allahh's words. That's what we did. We never accused any one specifically of bad intention!!!
Please do NOT Exaggerate and do NOT misquote what Dr Hany said.
Regarding Hadeeth: Are you aware of our clear position on Hadeeth in this video czcams.com/video/rXdzcgiBxQU/video.html, and in this video czcams.com/video/noBa4w76O58/video.html
We actually defended a Hadeeth that NONE OF THE HADEETH SCHOLARS WOULD TOUCH!!!
Not enough for you???
Please watch the above videos carefully before you judge unfairly. You owe it to yourself to judge fairly lest you earn bad deeds unintentionally.
Doctor can you please do ISA AS too in the Quran, does Quran say Isa AS will return??
Coming shortly Insha Allahh
@@MarvelousQuran may Allah reward you with this effort, I know there will be people who may disagree with you but hopefully they will be respect your view..
I am watching all your videos..
Also, Adam AS, many people have misconception that Adam AS and Eve RA was in Heaven when they did the Sin.. which I do not agree as how the Satan can enter the paradise if Adam AS was in the heaven..
Keep reflecting and discovering my bro (sis). Regards
@@jaweedpatel I do not agree as Quran is quite in this matter.. if coming if the jesus PBUH was such a big event then why Quran is quite about it?
That makes no sense that Musa(as) was part of a gang! And if so why would he kill his own member??? The story is about two different races of people not gangs.
Read Surah 28.
..... poor أَنْ ..... 🤭 👌
May Allah protect the muslims from you and your deviant interpretations and your misguided methodology, Allaahumma ameen.
Allahumma