"Skid Steer Showdown: John Deere 317G vs. Kubota SVL 75!" + Lifting Demo
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 07. 2024
- In this video, we pit two heavyweights of the construction world against each other: the John Deere Skid Steer 317G and the Kubota SVL 75-2. Travis will provide you with an in-depth analysis of the machines features, specifications, and capabilities, helping you make an informed decision when purchasing a Skid Steer. Whether you're a construction professional or an equipment enthusiast, this showdown is sure to provide valuable insights and help you choose the right skid steer for your specific needs. Make sure to Like, Comment, and Subscribe to our Channel to see more comparison videos like this!
Chapters:
0:00-Intro
1:00-Specs
2:22- Lifting Demo
2:57- Kubota Lift
3:38-John Deere Lift
4:41- You Can't Get That on the Kubota
5:19-Maintenance Access
6:00- Fuel Tank
6:40-Hydraulic Hoses
7:19-Inside the Cab: John Deere
9:27- Inside the Cab: Kubota
12:40-Maintenance Checks
13:20- Transport Comparison
14:01-Quick tatch System
14:43- Auxiliary Covers
15:12- Speed
16:03- Everglades Equipment Group Has You Covered!
Both machines pick up a bunk of wood and osb but only one lets me get out of the cab when I have it a foot up in the air. That roll up door is worth its weight in gold
Great video but your a little late to the show. Kubota svl75-3 has lockable door, available counter weights , radiators on top now, fuel tank in rear , one piece cab, touch screen, bluetooth, keyless start , adjustable track response, higher lift capacity, air ride seat , quieter cab , new roll up sealed door, added vents , back lit switches, led lights , radio built into screen, windshield washer bottle now mounted in front , new ac , heat controls. So everything you talked about has been addressed plus more
The -3 does not have adjustable track response. Same pilot controls as the -2.
“Improved lifting capacity”? Bro its the same machine mechanically. It would need a heck of a bump in power to do what a 65 HP Deere will.
Why would you need counterweights if the machine is too weak to pick itself up anyway?
But then again, I’d expect that from a guy that doesn’t know the difference between your and you’re. Spelling is hard bro.
@@joshtarver6488 baked!
@@joshtarver6488t does have a control response speed adjustment. I am a cat guy but the new Kubota-3 is a nice machine.
SVL75-3 received closed center hydraulics and you can do multiple functions at the same time. Run a closed center machine and you won’t like an open center system.
I just traded my svl-75-4 in for my Deere 317G. Funny seeing this video after I traded. My kubota was a dog compared to the Deere. Like seriously no comparison. So, sorry to bust your bubble but I’ve owned both and yeah…no. My kubota never had a counterweight issue. It ran out of hydro power. I’ve learned that from kubota is that they “derate” their hydraulics so u can’t push the machine I guess. Idk but it’s stupid when the dealer sells shim kits to bump your hydro pressure up at the counter and is a “hot seller”. Only problem is it voids your warranty and it’s a pain in the butt to do. Even after doing the shin kit it didn’t compare to the Deere. Especially in pushing out a load of stone or dirt.
This video is dripping with bias. Makes me discount all the points since any product when compared to a competitor will have pros and cons. As a consumer I want to see fair comparisons. This video makes me think the kubota is actually better and a jd salesman is trying hard to prove his product is superior.
I mean, it looked to me like everything in the video was visible. I think there is bias too, but every point made in the video was visibly shown.
Everyone knows John Deere has not made tractors in years.
I think he was angry at the shirt his wife made him wear.
Its ok if you like cheap crappy machines...🤷♂️ the guy just showed you why deere was the better product. You get what you pay for.
I can pick up a 5500lbs jersey barrier with my Kubota SVL75-2. Guy does his best to put it down.. but kubota makes a great machine
And you can pick it up a foot and still get out of the cab. Fuck that swing out door
I can pick up 2 bundles of rebar no problem with my 75-2 is about 4,500 lbs their is bias that 75-3 will make u throw rocks at that 317. Tight cab no leg room and out swing door is for the birds 💩💩💩
That overhead door is the reason I put a Kubota at the top of my list of compact track loaders to purchase. as an owner operator it is a must have.
Really weird how you chose to being in the svl 75-2 instead of the 75-3. So much of the negatives youve claimed against it are resolved with the update.
He just made a new video with the newer model kubota... still a crappy machine and you'll see why.
Great points raise the boom. Up 2 feet and shut the machine off and get out. Ooooo can't do that on a Deere
Now I really want a Kubota. Not understanding why he didn’t get the SVL 75-3?
After doing some research on to SVL 75-3 I find you to be full of BS. When I run across a salesman like you I just turn around and walk away. Everything you talked about can be undone. Even the lifting.
He already did.. look for the video.
Another great video Travis!
Well I got to say the man definitely called Kubota out. Now he wasn’t comparing the latest model. Most of these issues have been addressed. Also I didn’t hear a $ comparison. He’s a JD dealer he should stand behind his product. If Kubota wants to shut him down then fire back. I love a good mud slinging head to head fight amongst brands. 👍
Thanks for sharing
Very good point regarding turning power of the two speed Kubota versus one speed Deere. Hard to stick a pile hard with 2nd gear on Kubota, so if your really hustling, one speed Deere easier to run especially for new operators. Great video!
Thank you so much!
Second gear on the kubota is only for long travel
Trying to say one speed is better? 😂
This would be great if the Kubota SVL75-2 was still being manufactured. Sounds like someone couldn’t get their hands on the newest model for this video.
Or they didn't want to.
He did not too long ago. kubota still crappy.
John Deere has priced themselves out of the market…by a lot!!…absolutely insane prices!
good video, comments on the door were weak. Got me looking at Deere again while shopping this round
It seems kind of weird he used the last gen of Kubota for comparison.
he couldnt get his hands on one or wanted to make the deere look superior. funny guy
I throw spears sometimes but I like this guy too.
Kubota got me 4 years ago on price. When I was using my equipment around my house it was a no brained but once I started my landscape company I learned very quick that kubota just doesn’t match up to other equipment brands. They are wildly under rated all the way around and absolutely basic. Yes I’m spoiled now as we own cat, ASV, and Deere was added this year in our equipment lineup but I couldn’t be happier leaving kubota last year. Sometimes you just don’t know till you know. Deere so far as taken the cake on all the features, capacities, and responsiveness. We’re certainly Deere fans for now
I would buy the Kubota for sure, Deere does not care about their customers at all ;;;;;;;;;;;
I guess it's obvious what franchise Everglades Equipment Group has. Is the SVL 75-2 being manufactured anymore?
Deere service is hands down best in class service and sales. I haven’t been to the dealership for a year because of I need something my sales guy brings it to me. If I need service they come pick it up so I can keep working. And when the dealer needed my machine to set up security codes, firmware update, and something else they brought a machine to my work site, traded out my machine with a loaner skiddy, took mine and brought it back and took the loaner with them. I mean seriously!!! Get that from anybody else.
Well, here I am, minding my own business, doing track loader research, and my damn face shows up on the screen. Strange feeling. Lol 11:25
Aren't both machines made in the same model year? Seems fair to me.
Dude! what is the weight of the load?
Need to compare to the SVL75-3...
There's a new kubota svl 75-3 that you could reavow
I prefer the deere myself, BUT, the electric attachment latch is way inferior to a hydraulic one. My son in law has a 333G and it doesn't have as much power as the hydraulic and moisture from water, snow, and mud burn it out frequently. It's too harsh of an environment for an electronic gizmo. Get manual or hydraulic latches.
Compare it to the SVL75-3? I think most of your complaints or comparisons are solved. Kubota uses a hydraulic over hydraulic joystick and closed center hydraulics. I like Deere and Kubota but do your own research don’t listen to a shady salesman. Especially a salesman that according to him Kubota has nothing better to offer than John Deere! Closed center hydraulics are far superior as are hydraulic over hydraulic joysticks! When companies compete we the consumer win with better product. Most people will not max out the lift capacity of either matching. If you are then get a bigger matching! Don’t give into the BS.
its funny that youre comparing Kubotas Discontinued model. The svl75-3 has a lot of improvements.
What a great video! Next we need the John Deere 317G vs. the Cat 259D3, now that would be a cool video to watch. I have always been a fan of the 317G and I ran one for years, very good and durable machine!
We have some upcoming Cat Vs. Deere content releasing very soon!
@@EvergladesTV great to hear! That makes me excited!
No question Deere would win that comparison as well.
Best way to gain credibility as a salesman is to admit the positives of your competitor. 100% bias and one sided is the typical used car salesman approach.
After watching this I am glad I bought a used 323E and not the Kubota.
We are glad you made that purchase too!
As I'm sure you already know the 75-3 fixes everyone of your beefs plus more room in the cab. I haven't operated a JD skid steer but I doubt its any smoother than the new 75-3. I'm good with my new 75-3. ( and don't forget never to open the door to your JD unless your machine is parked)
So what do they actually cost and why not compare a SVL 75-3 since thats the new Kubota model. Good video, just skipped the part that matters to the majority of people buying. $$$
What Year is The Kubota ? 80% What You Said is NOT True About a New Kubota!! I Have 75-3
I love these videos.Obviously pro Deere.But the new dash 3 Kubota's are again re-engineered better than the dash 2's.I think both machines are good machines,but Im bias,i love Kubota.I could care less about how much it will lift in a dead lift.I want resale,parts networking,fit and finish,and turn key on a job.I do believe Kubota has greater ground clearance on the deere?That matters.There's also a reason why every dealer compares there equipment to Kubota,it's the GOLD standard.Just say'in.Oh.yeah,those swinging doors vs overhead,you tell me?Also,is Deere pilot or EH?Pilot,way more economical for future issues of repair and downtime.The more bells and whistles,generally the more issues for the future.Keep it simple.
Pilot controls are not more serviceable. Leaks are a loss of fluid. Any of the EH controls are componentized, so easily replaced. which is why you find it on the "better" brands Cat Deere, JCB. All the accesses and survivability that an owner can do (as seen in the video) not to mention the lower cost of ownership from less often required service (filters and fluids) due to Kubota not being able to handle the heat generated, so it cooks the fluids and systems.
1) What is your price on the 317?
2) Will you deliver to Indiana?
Hi! We can help you out. Text us at 5617844000
I watched a ton of these videos ..and they seem to favor one make over another... So I don't believe that its a fair comparison !!!
Get the kubota, ktac insurance will cover ANYTHING you can do to it. Even intentional
The only problem is the more option you get the more future problems you will have.
How much is the Jhon deer
$93,000.00 with every basic option.
Great video. I’m definitely getting the Deere over the Kubota. Hands down. However there are a few available options on the Kubota that can be installed… You can get an air ride seat, keyless keypad start, and ride control. Again. The Deere is way better but I just wanted to note a few corrections for you.
Can you get out with the boom up lol
this is not a fair comparison because you are pro deer. And it is a biased review. there is a lot that you said negative about the Kubota and was simply not true. It has more vents than just one. I have a brother that has a Kubota and it is not bad unit at all. I do agree though deer is a better unit but you need to have an unbiased review and this ain’t it. Not everyone has that much more money to spend and if you only use it for residential use Kubota ain’t a bad u it. Both Great units overall.
My gosh! Why would anyone purchase a Kubota? Clearly their engineers should be jailed! I'm glad I found such a trustworthy source of information. It was like watching a Saturday Night Live skit. What joke. I'd rather just hear you promote why you think your unit is better rather than listen to you tear down your competitor.
plus old kubota model
Get stuck in the cab of a farm all once and you’ll go get a kubota !!
It's funny that Kubota is being called the budget option against JD in the tractor world. The JD tractors that are "higher price point" units are plastic junk. I'm not even a Kubota fan, but that's a bad take.
Too bad JD is one of the worst Corporations to exist! Constantly fighting against the consumers right to repair! FJD.
the loader cylinders are more exposed on the deer than the hydraulic quick attach on the kubota, you got some funny bias dude.
The Door is what suck on JD and CAT
Sodo u have any comparisons between the old iron ? Say like a bobcat? Or a Case 90 Xt ? Case 450 ,ASV ?
Come on man , you would like to sell a new design machine with trinkets like a cup holder and a radio ,but those things don't add to any of the performance of the machine .
Yes they are new and improved and very impressive, however they all rely on electronics now that are incorporated into all manufacturers.
But with the supply chain braking down and fears of Taiwan being invaded would mean that a new owner is dead in the water if something blows up.
So does John Deere make just a simple all mechanical skid steer ?
Kubota makes a great tractor. Other than that dont waste your money.
You are really selling that deer when you do comparisons you’re posted to just show the difference and let the people choose and four a machine that’s built and manufactured in the US it sure is expensive so are you really taken care of of the people I don’t think so
This guy is trying very hard to make jd look better then they really are it's sad to watch
Typical John Deere salesman, doesn’t know a lick about Kubota. The SVL75-3 runs circles around the JD machines. It’s the number 1 selling machine in the US for a reason. Superior engine and maintenance compared to the JD. Make that SVL75-3 video please 😂
What a biased review. @0K and the fuel cap is tethered ! What a joke ov a review !
This guy just embarrasses himself. These aren't reviews he's more a used car salesman
The only reason you would have to pick a Kubota out of all manufacturers to pick on is because they out sell and perform. Another thing 10 months ago the svl75-3 was out so use it for your comparison. I’ve never felt bashing another to make you feel good about your machine is a good tactic. Rather than telling me how bad the Kubota is tell me the good things that would make me wanna buy a Deere. Terrible video
Stop making videos. The point with the chain use a different hook genius.