Nasa draha a nezabudnutelna Slovenska Diva zostane vzdy v mojom srdci s je nadhernym coloraturnym slovenskym hlasom. Nech odpociva v pokoji s prektasnymi melodiami jej hlasu po celom svete. ❤️🇸🇰 Eva z Nice
The best Donna Anna ever. I had listened to many sopranos, live and on record, but in 2005 in Tokyo, during the Vienna Opera Japan tour that year, I could her live for the first time and I was so impressed, like never before by a singer. She was a great artist.
Sie war stark wie ein Fels in der Brandung, keine Unsicherheiten , keine Angst und nie hat sie Ihre Stimme forciert, so wenige haben diese Eigenschaften, nur so überlebt man in diesem wahnsinnig schwierigen Beruf , Ich verneige mich
A pesar de que los anios hayan causado estragos en su voz sigue siendo (para mi y muchos) una perfecta mozartiana. Por favor, aspirantes a cantantes (Netrebko, etc) escuchen esta sublime interpretacion!!!!! Y despues aprendan a cantar!!!!
Netrebko, please listen the divine Edita and learn how Donna Anna should be. Change your Repertoire....Mozart is not for you. Edita Gruberova is simply perfect and flawless as always...at 60 years old... bravo !
Crudele? Ah no, giammai mio ben! Troppo mi spiace allontanarti un ben che lungamente la nostr'alma desia... Ma il mondo, o Dio! Non sedur la costanza del sensibil mio core; ahbastanza per te mi parla amore Non mi dir, bell'idol mio, Che son io crudel con te. Tu ben sai quant'io t'amai, Tu conosci la mia fe'. Calma, calma il tuo tormento, Se di duol non vuoi ch'io mora. Forse un giorno il cielo ancora Sentirà pietà di me.
Bravo ROAR169!!!! Altro che Netrebko!!!! Gruberova is the real Donna Anna!! LA voce, le pause, il timbro...sublime!!!! Rispetto il lavoro della Netrebko ma e' lontana anni luce da avere una voce mozartiana. Un'altra Donna Anna da sogno e' stata Fleming al Met con Terfel, diretti da Levine, 2000...meravigliosa!!
ops! sorry for the typing error, I meant to say "in THE early 60's" Yes she was probably in her mid 30's when the recording was made. Makes me sad when I read the rave reviews of Gruberova, Interestingly it was Callas who said many years ago that Opera was a dying art, I think it's well and truly dead now at least when it comes to appreciation of what great singing is all about.
+cameronpaul Sutherland was a great Mozart singer. The legendary Bruno Walters came out of retirement to conduct her Donna Anna after he first heard her sing it.
Vette gaddia I think overall her voice was too big for Mozart but the role of Donna Anna suited her very well especially when she was young and the voice hadn't darkened as it did by the late 60's/early 70's.
cameronpaul Are you aware that far larger voices than Gruberova sing Mozart? Sutherland, Moser, Price. Gruberova has a small, pleasant sounding lyric soprano. She can never sing Verdi or Puccini because she is not a spinto as the three sopranos I named above. Anyone who thinks Gruberova has a large voice have not heard her in person.
Vette gaddia I think you misunderstood my meaning. I meant overall Sutherand's voice was too big for Mozart. Yes I agree Gruberova has a much smaller voice than the sopranos you mention. I don't actually find her voice very good at all but that is of course a personal opinion.
à 1.14 les attaques sont molles et fausses et ce n'est pas le seul passage (4.02) Elle prend les notes par en dessous. Je n'ai jamais compris l'engouement pour cette cantatrice qui pour moi est loin d'être la meilleure. Perso je n'adhère pas.
tut mit leid, das ist m.E. keine große Mozartstimme. Sie hat früher eine sehr gute Konstanze gesungen, Zerbinetta u.ä, auch. Donna Anna war, denke ich, nie so ihre Sache. Zuviel hörbare Anstrengung, keine schönen Farbe, auch musikalisch zu manieriert.
How painful and how laboured! Just listen to Joan Sutherland (YT) in her early 60's recording with Guilini conducting and you will hear how this aria should be sung. To think Gruberova gets an ovation at the end - just shows how the standard of singing has declined!
No thank you, I've listened enough to Sutherland, don't need more of that. Gruberova is way more exciting and sings with much more beauty and expression.
+Global Voice She sang the coloratura accurately but without passion. She did not sing it with the furocious precision that Sutherland did in her 1960 recording with Giulini.
Vette gaddia Unfortunately, it's not just passion. She sings not exactly. Execution is given to her with difficulty. Big problems with the voice and vocal technique seriously lame.
If you think this is dirty, I wonder what do you think is clear. I have listened to the "legendary" recording by Sutherland and she didn't sing it any clearer. I can't hear a note here which wouldn't be perfectly in tune or in time. And her voice is beautiful even in the highest notes, despite her age.
Sutherland perfectly performed the party of Donna Anna. How can you compare the lady Joan - one of the greatest singers of the 20th century with a pitiful Gruberova?!! Are you in your mind?!
Rest in peace, Edita. We will never forget you.
Nasa draha a nezabudnutelna Slovenska Diva zostane vzdy v mojom srdci s je nadhernym coloraturnym slovenskym hlasom. Nech odpociva v pokoji s prektasnymi melodiami jej hlasu po celom svete. ❤️🇸🇰 Eva z Nice
The best Donna Anna ever. I had listened to many sopranos, live and on record, but in 2005 in Tokyo, during the Vienna Opera Japan tour that year, I could her live for the first time and I was so impressed, like never before by a singer. She was a great artist.
So viele Liebe 💕 Danke vielmals für ewig.
Sie war stark wie ein Fels in der Brandung, keine Unsicherheiten , keine Angst und nie hat sie Ihre Stimme forciert, so wenige haben diese Eigenschaften, nur so überlebt man in diesem wahnsinnig schwierigen Beruf , Ich verneige mich
Sutherland spoils me for almost everyone...but I respect Miss Gruberova very much - especially at her age here.
Brava!
Edita has taken good care of her voice through the years
GOD has taken good care of her voice!
È difficile per me 😭😭😭😭
She just did 4 spectacular concerts in China for the first time
The lie detector has determined... that's a lie.
@@deadwalke9588 the joke detector detects that... you're the entire circus
59 años tenía en este concierto y la coloratura intacta!!
Vielen Dank, Edita... alles war sehr schön.
She is just perfect - perfect voice perfect acting,
And very beautiful too.
MAGNIFICA EDITA GRUBEROVA! E' LEI LA VERA DONNA ANNA! PASSIONE, TALENTO ED UNA VOCE QUI A 60 ANNI ANCORA STRABILIANTE, UNA FUORICLASSE SENZA PARI!
Do not write stupid things!
Opinions are like balls: everybody got his ones!
wonderful technique to sing with and study....
CHAPEAU!!!! ESTA SEÑORA ES MARAVILLOSA, BRAVOOOO!!!
Wunderschön
Maravillosa.
Se Mozart avesse conosciuto la Gruberova il titolo dell'opera sarebbe "Donna Anna" e non "Don Giovanni".
Bravissimo!!!!!!❤🌹👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
brava brava brava
Ruhe in Frieden Edita!!
Bist eine der ganz Großen.
A pesar de que los anios hayan causado estragos en su voz sigue siendo (para mi y muchos) una perfecta mozartiana. Por favor, aspirantes a cantantes (Netrebko, etc) escuchen esta sublime interpretacion!!!!! Y despues aprendan a cantar!!!!
Are you crazy or uneducated?! Gruberova never achieve world-class great Anna Netrebko!!!!!!!!!!!
Maravilhosa!! RIP,😢
maravillosa
Bravissima
Netrebko, please listen the divine Edita and learn how Donna Anna should be. Change your Repertoire....Mozart is not for you.
Edita Gruberova is simply perfect and flawless as always...at 60 years old... bravo !
she is even muscially super today.
Crudele?
Ah no, giammai mio ben!
Troppo mi spiace allontanarti
un ben che lungamente
la nostr'alma desia...
Ma il mondo, o Dio!
Non sedur la costanza
del sensibil mio core;
ahbastanza per te mi parla amore
Non mi dir, bell'idol mio,
Che son io crudel con te.
Tu ben sai quant'io t'amai,
Tu conosci la mia fe'.
Calma, calma il tuo tormento,
Se di duol non vuoi ch'io mora.
Forse un giorno il cielo ancora
Sentirà pietà di me.
Wow!!
I'm in love!
Qué bonito!
SUBLIME GRUBEROVA!!!!!!
The best!!!
I really don't like her but I have to admit that this is wonderful. A great surprise for me.
Listen to her La triviata so so wonderful no one better .
Bravo ROAR169!!!! Altro che Netrebko!!!!
Gruberova is the real Donna Anna!! LA voce, le pause, il timbro...sublime!!!!
Rispetto il lavoro della Netrebko ma e' lontana anni luce da avere una voce
mozartiana.
Un'altra Donna Anna da sogno e' stata Fleming al Met con Terfel, diretti da Levine, 2000...meravigliosa!!
cameronpaul Sutherland was certainly not in her sixties when she recorded that Donna Anna with Giulini.
ops! sorry for the typing error, I meant to say "in THE early 60's" Yes she was probably in her mid 30's when the recording was made. Makes me sad when I read the rave reviews of Gruberova, Interestingly it was Callas who said many years ago that Opera was a dying art, I think it's well and truly dead now at least when it comes to appreciation of what great singing is all about.
+cameronpaul Sutherland was a great Mozart singer. The legendary Bruno Walters came out of retirement to conduct her Donna Anna after he first heard her sing it.
Vette gaddia
I think overall her voice was too big for Mozart but the role of Donna Anna suited her very well especially when she was young and the voice hadn't darkened as it did by the late 60's/early 70's.
cameronpaul Are you aware that far larger voices than Gruberova sing Mozart? Sutherland, Moser, Price. Gruberova has a small, pleasant sounding lyric soprano. She can never sing Verdi or Puccini because she is not a spinto as the three sopranos I named above. Anyone who thinks Gruberova has a large voice have not heard her in person.
Vette gaddia
I think you misunderstood my meaning. I meant overall Sutherand's voice was too big for Mozart. Yes I agree Gruberova has a much smaller voice than the sopranos you mention. I don't actually find her voice very good at all but that is of course a personal opinion.
RIP
temp is too fast but she sang well
4:29-30 sth weird happened between Gruby and the violinist...
#Edita Gruberova
4:32
BRAVA~! Is it just me, or Gruberova not scoop as much if at all with Mozart? :P just sayin~.
à 1.14 les attaques sont molles et fausses et ce n'est pas le seul passage (4.02) Elle prend les notes par en dessous. Je n'ai jamais compris l'engouement pour cette cantatrice qui pour moi est loin d'être la meilleure. Perso je n'adhère pas.
questo si' che è cantare! Altro che la Netrebko....
tut mit leid, das ist m.E. keine große Mozartstimme. Sie hat früher eine sehr gute Konstanze gesungen, Zerbinetta u.ä, auch. Donna Anna war, denke ich, nie so ihre Sache. Zuviel hörbare Anstrengung, keine schönen Farbe, auch musikalisch zu manieriert.
+Mariano Cebelli Und wer ist eine?
How painful and how laboured! Just listen to Joan Sutherland (YT) in her early 60's recording with Guilini conducting and you will hear how this aria should be sung. To think Gruberova gets an ovation at the end - just shows how the standard of singing has declined!
No thank you, I've listened enough to Sutherland, don't need more of that. Gruberova is way more exciting and sings with much more beauty and expression.
@@Feisenbach ahahah, you funny, boo
@@Tkimba2 You aren't.
Very mediocre performance! It is evident that Gruberova sing hard, sometimes dirty!
+Global Voice She sang the coloratura accurately but without passion. She did not sing it with the furocious precision that Sutherland did in her 1960 recording with Giulini.
Vette gaddia Unfortunately, it's not just passion. She sings not exactly. Execution is given to her with difficulty. Big problems with the voice and vocal technique seriously lame.
If you think this is dirty, I wonder what do you think is clear. I have listened to the "legendary" recording by Sutherland and she didn't sing it any clearer. I can't hear a note here which wouldn't be perfectly in tune or in time. And her voice is beautiful even in the highest notes, despite her age.
Sutherland perfectly performed the party of Donna Anna. How can you compare the lady Joan - one of the greatest singers of the 20th century with a pitiful Gruberova?!! Are you in your mind?!
In order to talk about opera, you need to understand it. Why demonstrate your ignorance and stupidity?!