Not gonna lie, Avi I think is better served as a solo artist. His talent is unquestionable, but his personality & artistry are better suited to a more niche fandom. Now he has a better grip on his career trajectory, and he can showcase all of his abilities in ways he couldn’t with the group. Matt is quite literally A PERFECT FIT with PTX. His addition seemed like the missing puzzle piece, and with him in the lineup they have reached new heights and expanded their skill set & repertoire, in both creative and performative aspects. In my opinion, this was the best case scenario for everyone.
Me too. I agree with every word. In addition, I believe that Avi is SO much happier now! Not that there was any problem between him and Pentatonix, but the nonstop touring and always being in cities didn't fit with our nature-craving Avi. His tours now are only a few weeks at a time, then a rest period, and plenty of time to spend in the woods and mountains. On the PTX side, Matt has brought in so much joy and energy! He was the perfect choice. And we still have Avi--both his exhilarating solo work and the 8 years of albums and videos with Pentatonix. Win/Win/Win.
There is only one Avi, but I love Matt’s buttery, soulful voice. He jumped into some big shoes with a joyful abundance! I enjoy the details you point out and your reactions - thank you!
Understand Avid wanted to.do.some single things and that the travel kept him from family..He of course can't be replaced just a different kind of bass. Matt has such a smooth base a great addition
In my opinion, you have had the “perfect” introduction to Pentatonix! Hallelujah, for its sheer majesty…Daft Punk, to show their versatility…and The Sound of Silence, to introduce Matt! Great job…another reactor has praised them for their ability to “get out of each other’s way”. Which is exactly what you are saying…when it comes time for each individual to sing, the other 4 are doing their dead level best to make that person shine, and shine they do!!! That’s what makes PTX PTX…
they covered 'mad world', which is a dark song but i love how they did it. would be interested in your opinion. they also cover 'imagine', which isn't dark, but is really good.
Avi left (apparently amicably) after PTX's 2016-17 tour. The others did some recordings with only four people while auditioning basses and added Matt Sallee on a trial basis for their 2017 Christmas season. Avi and Matt both have music degrees (and both did a capella in college), but it seems that Avi trained to develop his deeper range while Matt trained more to develop his baritone. Avi has said he loved his time with Pentatonix but the constant touring was a strain and he is now doing his own music and appears much happier.
Agree with your assessment. I would like to say that I think that in the early days for Matt, he was more in his baritone range, only because as you point out that is more what he originally trained for. As the years have progessed, he has worked hard on his lower range, and in their newest music he is killing his bass parts. Ben Bram indicated that when Matt came on board, they had to learn to arrange to his voice compared to Avi's voice, which meant that they had to do some thing differently. It's been 5 years now, and I think that Matt is exactly what PTX needed for the direction that they have taken their music.
@@elizabethfelet4743 Yes. Matt can't go as low as Avi did, not with the same power at least, but he can go higher with ease. I'd dare say his and Scott's range are almost identical, but the tonal quality, which part of their respective voices they're using (chest, head, falsetto, etc.), differs. I've haven't heard the current lineup live, I do wonder how they'd make their older songs fit with Matt.
@@xheralt I saw a version of Bohemian Rhapsody live that popped up in my feed, from the current era (so I know it exists, and I’ll have to find it again soon), and Matt’s high end on his verse in Hallelujah live is amazing, when he hits a very high falsetto so perfectly. I could probably find both of those pretty easily, so I’ll assume you can as well. Happy hunting :) Just as a note, they aren’t on the official channels, of course, but probably just searching “Pentatonix Bohemian Rhapsody live” will pop up several options, including the one from a year or two ago. I think the Hallelujah one I saw was from their concert in LA, and it might be the same concert as the Rhapsody video I’m going to go find right now.
Try their mix of New Rules x Are you That Somebody, for a better idea of Matt's base. If you want to hear all five just singing, try their covers of Dreams or My Heart with You.
@@derrickcox7761 are you sure? The only video I found of that is a mash-up of two songs overlaid on each other and the lyrics don't work for either song : czcams.com/video/XypXi5KoEic/video.html
Great reaction. Thanks. Fun fact: Kirsten’s boyfriend was the director of this video. He films a lot of the behind the scenes video when they are on tour (which is how they met).
Yesss… that one always gets overlooked. It’s one of my favorites also. I don’t know how a lot of their originals didn’t make a bigger stamp than they did.
There is so much for you to enjoy! For their signature wall of sound, watch their upgrade of Imagine. 90s Dance Medley is fun, as is Come Along. For a 4-in-1, try their live performance at Popspring 2016, which includes 3 of their originals and the Evolution of Michael Jackson. Run To You, another original, is phenomenal.
Given you like simplistic videos I’d suggest their upgrade of Kiiara’s Gold next. Given how effects heavy the original is it should be impossible to do a capella right?
In this video you can actually see that Scott is performing the bass line while Matt is singing his solo. Scott did it with Avi in Hallelujah, but the camera never showed Scott during that timeframe in that video. Recommendations: Just for something fairly different from what you've already seen: Havana or Attention, Sing (original), Jolene (collab with Dolly Parton, their 3rd Grammy winner), Papaoutai or Radioactive or Over the River (all collabs with Lindsey Stirling, with Kevin cello-boxing).
I have heard that in the official video of Hallelujah, they added a track with Avi doing the bass line, so it is actually him singing both solo and bass line at the same time. This makes sense to me since, as terrific as Scott's lower range is, he still doesn't quite have that buttery smoothness we know from Avi's voice, and when I listen closely, it really does sound more like Avi doing those bass notes. It would also make sense not to show Scott during that verse if he isn't taking over from Avi, but just doing background and harmonies with the others. I know Scott picks up the bass line when they sing Hallelujah live, but I do believe they decided to use Avi for the official video.
It did show him doing it in the live Christmas performance of Hallelujah. When Avi starts singing his solo, look over his right shoulder at Scott and watch his hands... he telegraphs what he is doing.
@@gingerjohnson1095 For sure it's Scott in the live Christmas performance, and any other live performance. I'm just saying I heard that for the official video of Hallelujah, they were able to use Avi's voice for the bass line while he was singing his solo, so they did. Perhaps they did add more resonance to Scott's voice to give it that fuller timbre, but I wonder why they would bother, if they could easily slip Avi's voice in there. Just an opinion...
Thank you for distinguishing PTX"s performance of this song as their own beautiful interpretation of the story and the music. A number of other reactors have tried to compare them to Disturbed's version but, like you, I don't think a comparison can be drawn. Technically it's the same song but the voices, the production and the way they make you feel while you listen to the music are so different. One reactor even said that PTX"s version was "almost as good as the original by Disturbed." This guy was apparently unaware that the original was done by Simon and Garfunkel in the 1960's. I enjoyed your reaction very much and hope you will do more PTX. I think you would enjoy Bohemian Rhapsody, I know I would.
Angie Pangie I believe I may have listened to the same reactor who commented that while he really loved PTX's cover of "TSoS", it was Almost as good as the original by "Disturbed"; and of the 2 groups, he'd have to give a slight edge to "Disturbed." Hmm..🤔 I immediately thought, 'I could have Sworn Paul Simon wrote that song in '64, when I was only 6 yrs old, and he & Art Garfunkel were the creators of the "Original" SoS, lol!"😉 My next thought was, 'Man, I'm getting old!'😱😄 Growing up I loved "The Sound of Silence"; both message & music stirred my soul! And when I watched Disturbed's cover about a year ago, I was surprised to find that I really loved it! But there wasn't any real way to compare Simon & Garfunkel's original version with theirs~ both were Awesome in their own right & in their own ways. Same goes for PTX; tho' I have to say that if I Had to choose, I like Pentatonix' cover a little more than Disturbed, as much as I did really like theirs.
Ben Bram has been their arranger/producer from the beginning. He helps them arrange and record. Ed Boyer is their mixer, he is a genius. If you want to see them arrange/record they have a short film "recording of Evergreen". Then if you look at Jacob Restituto's YT channel....he has interviewed both of them - if you are into that technical kind of thing! Enjoy!
Yes Matt, the young man in the white jacket is the new bass. Scott, the bartitone who started the song, covers base when Matt sings in a higher octave. However, in the majority of their other newer songs (2018 going forward), Matt does the majority of the bass. His sound isn't as operatic as Avi's but it is very rich and deep.
Mad World is another song that is amazing from PTX. It would be cool if you watched the early songs from the Sing Off TV show in order. Kind of like a beginning of the group to see how they have developed kind of like Tool. Love your reactions.
Matt Sallee took over for Avi in 2017 when Avi left for family reasons. Matt is like hitting the bass button on a system and his bass runs are killer. Avi was like hitting Super Bass and causing internal damage from vibrations. Love them both.
I do love it when Scott goes off. And Kirstie & Mitch in the back ground with their aah-aaahh-ahh sounds almost like a siren. New sub, interested to watch you go down the PTX rabbithole. As for where to go next, we'll, there's many possibilities and I could really just list their entire discography lol. But how about for a start something a little different that has Kevin playing cello & beatboxing, "celloboxing" as he calls it, and Lindsey Stirling on violin... on an upgrade of Imagine Dragon's *Radioactive* . Or if you wanted to try something sit down with mics then Ciara's *Gold* or even 21 Pilot's *Ride* . They have two albums full of originals that many get overlooked, and they range greatly in vibe, a quick jump in is to watch *Popspring 2016* miniconcert where they perform originals (Cracked, Can't Sleep Love, and Water) as well as their Evolution of Michael Jackson. It's a little longer but people don't usually seem to mind. As an aside, I also highly recommend *Superfruit* , which is Mitch & Scott's channel "The Greatest Show on The Internet" as they dubbed it (sadly they haven't uploaded in 3 or so years but there's a whole lot of awesome musical (and other fun) content over there). My fave to see people react to is always *Hip Hop Goes Broadway* 1 & 2 and for a real treat *Feeling Myself* (always wait to see if there are bloopers after the subscribe message lol). Along with various medleys and evolutions, and an albums worth of incredible original music all of which except one have music vids (it's not a capella) Also, all except Matt have ventured into solo or other projects. Some examples: Avi - Change On A Rise (he has a new album and a an EP that's from a couple years ago of his solo stuff since leaving) ; Kevin has his KOvers - Down and Sign of The Times are both phenomenal; Scott has a various duets, my fave is Lost On You with Mario Josè (who's on Rise with Superfruit) and his solo stuff like Avicii's Wake Me Up; Mitch has some very different solo stuff from the older Graveyard to Billie Eilish's Your Power, to his recent Messer project (verrry different to the Mitch we know) Love Supply and Angel's Pray for example. Kirstie - Break A Little.
I don’t think enough people comment on Mitch and Kirstie’s aah-aaaah-ahh sounds. It’s my favorite part of the song and I feel like I’m the only one that hears it since no one else ever mentions it. So thank you!
Love your reactions. Very insightful. I’m a Pentaholic and honestly I love both Avi and Matt as bass in different ways. I subbed. They do a great video of Mad World during pandemic which seems appropriate . Thank you
He is a new member his name is Matt Sallee, yet another awesome singer. You really should react to Bohemian Rhapsody it will blow your mind, Queen themselves loved it! Amazing Grace. Havana and their own original Coffee in Bed, stunning every one of them oh and don't forget The Prayer, Mitch just melts your heart. So welcome to the Pentatonix rabbit hole. keep reacting and you'll get thousands of followers they are huge on you tube and very well deserved too!!
Really enjoyed your reaction. As others have said, Matt is showcased in the fun "You're a Mean One Mr. Grinch," and he evokes such emotion in "Mad World" (as they all do in that song).
I really enjoyed your reaction and review--thanks! I am a long time Pentaholic and Voice Player that appreciates a reactor that does not compare one group or member of a group negatively against the others--thank you for that! Many people were so heartbroken about Avi leaving in 2017 that they were never able to show the new bass singer, Matt, any love or respect for all he does. I am glad I subscribed and look foward to more of your reactions to all three of the acapella groups (main ones anyway but there are other lesser known that are good too).
Bought this album over 55 yrs ago and this song was always one of my favourites...the lyrics are stunning and raw. Hearing this version by Pentatonix, though, was the first time the hair on my arms stood straight up. Wow.
I love your reactions - they are honest and insightful. Thank you! Please react to Pentatonix's covers of " Bohemian Rhapsody ", " Come Along ", and "Havana".
Suggestions for more Pentatonix -- "Happy Now", "Sing", "Love Again" (all PTX originals), "New Rules x Are You That Somebody" (Dua Lipa x Aaliya mashup), "Gold" (Kiiara cover, recorded live),
The person who sang first is Scott Hoying, and he’s been there since the very beginning; part of the original trio of Scott, Mitch, & Kirstin. The third person to sing is Matt Sallee, the new bass (although not so new anymore, been since 2017), and he replaced Avi Kaplan. Mitch Grassi was the second singer. Kirstie Maldonado is the fourth singer. And of course you have the best beat boxer ever, Kevin Olusola
Avi Kaplan was in the original group (2011 Sing Off) and continued through early 2017. He had family health issues and could not tour. There may have been some creative issues also. When you hear his solo stuff, then you'll realize he was limiting himself some in PTX. Try his Change On The Rise. Matt Sallee did some summer 2017 shows and officially joined a little later. I think his first recordings show up in 2018.
Avi had planned to do solo projects while in Pentatonix but now he can focus more on that. Kevin's solo content is amazing and a totally different vibe and Kirstin has done Broadway. I love that the members take time for their personal projects.
The family health was contributing to Avi's burnout, but it wasn't the reason in and of itself. Avi's sister continued on as PTX's tour manager until she got pregnant in 2019. "Creative issues" were the same... not the issue, but another contribution to burnout. Also not like they were disagreeing, but Avi's heart wasn't in the PTX music lane which made it harder to stick out through the stress. Avi *could* tour and loved the group... but he was worn out by their pace and wanted more room in his life for other things. Matt joined for the 2017 Christmas tour, not summer, as a "featured artist". He became official in February 2018 when PTX renewed their contract with RCA.
@@perfectkismet As Avi said in his leaving announcement - he didn't want to hold the group back. He was finding the constant touring/rehearsing a strain. Add being the other side of the world and not able to see his ailing family it just got too much.
@@alan-freeman He didn't even mention his mom's cancer in the announcement. He wanted more time to do other things, as I said. Everyone loves putting so much emphasis on the illness and family, but the guy moved away from his family after quitting to better pursue his solo music. That just wasn't the point. He wanted more time - for family, yes, but also for his music and just to have downtime and breathe. The point is that in 2016 PTX was going so hard that they were dragging a portable recording studio behind their tour busses and working before and after concerts and even on their days off. Avi didn't find that pace sustainable.
To set Matt's entrance into the PTX timeline, the first video Matt did with PTX after joining the group is their cover of Havana by Camila Cabello. I believe the last one that Avi did with the group was their cover of Bohemian Rhapsody.
Ahhhhhhvi.😁 He left to spend time with family and he went solo. Matt took his place. He's awesome as well. now if you want to hear Kevin, listen to "Mary, Did You Know"
Hello Skultz, thanks for doing this one by PTX. This is Pure Pentatonix Perfection. The solos. The cresceondo. The PTX wall of sound. They are all perfection. Mitch's lower register, with the inflections is just perfect. Avi (pronounced Ah-vee) left in 1028 and was replaced by Matt as the bass. Scott sings baritone and covers the bass backing when Matt is singing, Kirstie is sharp with her belting. Kevin the master beat boxer is beyond compare with the vocal percussion, stomping and clapping. PTX have about 250 songs, several genres, 3 Grammys. There is so much more that you will enjoy. Suggestions for you - The Prayer, Amazing Grace, Can You Feel the Love Tonight, Come Along, Gold - for starters. Then they also have great originals. PTX videos are always intentional. Thanks for recognizing so many details. Great reaction!!!
Gotta also give some love to another fantastic Acapella group named Home Free. Start with Mayday....both groups are equally talented and so proud of PTX and Matt is Avi's replacement for awhile now. They just were awarded a star on the Hollywood walk of fame!! Thank You!💜
For more variety, Amazing Grace, Can’t Hold Us, Mad World, Gold, Can You Feel the Love Tonight?, Problem and their original Love Again or Coffee in Bed are mandatory.
Love your take on the group. Great reaction. If you want to hear Kevin sing with Pentatonix, listen to Mary did you know, Imagine and Amazing Grace. If you want to see him solo, look up KO’s covers of Down and Sign of the times. New sub!!
Another great reaction! I had the exact same response when I first saw Matt. Where did Avi go?! Then Matt opened his mouth, and I was like....OOOOOOOHHHHHH! Since you mentioned your curiosity about the mixing of the videos, I thought I'd point you to 2 good interviews with the guy that mixes many Pentatonix videos, as well as some for the other big a capella groups, that were posted by Jacob Restituto. He's also has a really great interview of Ben Bram, who is the 6th member of Pentatonix (arranges their stuff).
That was good. I normally pass on the PTX reactions. Not because I don't respect their abilities/talent...it's just not really my thing. But since I saw it was you reacting, I decided to check it out. I was pretty entertained by the performance, so glad I checked it out.
Scott (first singer - baritone and covers bass when Avi (originally bass) or Matt (new bass) started the group with Mitch (second singer - countertenor) and Kristen (mezzo soprano) in high school. Kevin (beatboxer and phenomenal cello player) and Avi were added when the group audition for Sing Off which they did win.
I’m an original pentaholic. Saw them on “The Sing Off” and never looked back. Love your reactions. I’m sure you’ve gotten a million requests from everyone. Anything by them is awesome. So…I’m going to suggest someone else. Guy Sebastian is an Australian singer and he has an Amazing voice. “Battle Scars” live from the home front really shows off his voice. Would love to hear your reaction. I’m new to your channel and look forward to exploring more.
You should listen to Pentatonix cover Imagine next so you can get a little taste of Kevin when he sings rather than just the beatboxing you've seen so far. It's another older one with Avi in it and they covered it beautifully...plus the video always makes me emotional.
So I like your reaction to this. Just like artists themselves sometimes the reactors can take it to levels that aren't neccesary lol well done! I really love this group so much. They're all extremely talented and when all together they make magic! With that being said I do have an extra soft spot for Mitch.... I've never heard a more beautiful voice. Recommending you react to Come Along, nothing dark or sad just pure fun and guaranteed to make you smile! Also recommend Blinding Lights, it's upbeat and fun...and maybe you can help us figure out why Scott chose succulents hahaha
Scott started off Hallelujah, too. Matt and Avi are both amazing. he is the new bass who took Avi’s place. Feels weird calling him new, because he’s been with the group for several years now. I saw PTX in concert and he also played drums at one point. Scott played piano and Kevin played cello. It was nice seeing their other talents. :) Try “Bohemian Rhapsody”, “Come Along”, “Mary Did You Know”, “Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy” (won a Grammy) and original song “Sing”
Thank you for the great reaction! I hope you'll dive deeper and deeper into the rabbit hole named PTX.. we'll be by your side! Matt's voice is absolutely perfect for the group and I love his smooth tone, you should check out "You're a mean one, Mr. Grinch" where he has the lead.. and please do their cover of "Mad World", it's so hauntingly beautiful.. I think you'll like it 😊
@0:40 Skullz: "I think I have finally all their names..." The rest of us: "You've plenty more Avi to see, but also well desereved welcome to Matt". :D ;) :p
Thanks for the reaction! A while ago a commenter on a reactor said the S&G version was the warning of what would happen, Disturbed's version is angry that we didn't listen, and PTX's version is showing there's still hope if we listen and act soon.
As much as I do really love PTX, Home Free and Voiceplay I am still a Queen fan first. Please consider Queen - Under Pressure ( live at Wembley). I really think you would enjoy it! Thanks
You should listen to Pentatonix's version of Bohemian Rhapsody. Mitch uses a prop at one point but it is JUST a prop, he doesn't use the prop when live.
I'm a Pentaholic at my core, but I'm also rapidly becoming a VoicePlayer, and I have to take exception to your "a capella videos should be minimalistic..." because when VoicePlay go crazy, it's a FABULOUS crazy. I'd like to invite you to review their "Hoist the Colors," or for maximum crazy, either "Dragonborn Comes" or "Enemy" for full-blown theatrics. Well, technically, for FULL-BORE THEATRICS, "The Oogie Boogie Song" goes all out. They also have plenty of "sit in a chair and sing" videos too, to suit your taste, but they love to pull out the costumes. Don't get me wrong, as far as I'm concerned, the Pentatonix videos are gorgeous, but even they go costume drama from time to time. And it always works. "Cheerleader," or "My Favorite Things" (which really only has the basic tune/lyrics in common with the Julie Andrews version) or best of all, "Making Christmas." And you've already seen "Daft Punk." For a similar (but very different) vibe, you might look at their original "Love Again." Steampunk. Oof. Pentatonix is going to keep you busy for a while as they have an enormous catalog, but the top three a capella groups, in my opinion, are PTX, VoicePlay and Home Free. And since I'm not a Country music fan, Home Free trails, but they have their rabid fan base. Whichever way you go, you're pretty much guaranteed an awesome result.
I just subscribed because I really enjoyed your PTX reactions - I appreciate your informed comments on everything from their sound to their look to the setting. Although I've seen the videos innumerable times, I like it when someone points out something I've missed! Looking forward to more. As many have said, they have a catalog of over 200 songs and a LOT of them have accompanying videos. Contrasting their style from the early days 2012-2014 to the last couple years, you'll definitely notice a difference in production and styling, however, their overall music is still stellar. With a little searching online you can find many live performances (there's a great one for Daft Punk & Hallelujah) as well as other concert recordings and you'll see their live performances are VERY similar to the studio productions. Fans will say they don't record anything they can't sing live, and though I haven't seen them yet, and all I've seen is concert videos, you can tell that the lives are pretty much the same. Scott often changes his riff or throws a little something in the live to "prove" it's different from the recording. I'll be following your journey.
I have to say that PTX is my favorite acapella group. That said, while I like this version, and of course they sing it beautifully, I ADORE the Disturbed one. It portrays the rage and urgency that I feel about the subject much better. When it comes to a perfect message from a cover vs an original, PTX's Imagine has the most profound message for me. Matt is the new bass and he's amazing in his own right. He is showcased in a great way by their cover of You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch. So much fun! Kirsten's voice is on point in her/their original Be My Eyes. Avi has gone on to a solo career and is wonderful too.
Try The Prayer if you have not seen that one yet - I think you would enjoy it - This Pentaholic is enjoying your reactions - (you too will become a Pentaholic the further you go down the rabbit hole)! LOL
I was 17 when Simon & Garfunkel came out with the original in 1964. It struck me like few songs had or would. I still tear up at 76 and feel the ache I did then with PTX's version...a fantastic cover.
I love your PTX reactions and I so appreciate that you have taken the time and care to learn their names. A lot of reactors are still calling them "the blond guy" or "the dude with the high voice" even many videos in to their PTX journeys. So many ways to continue! If you want something more upbeat, you can't go wrong with Cheerleader. I smile along with them every time. That one is older and features Avi. Rather Be, Say Something, and Shallow heavily feature Kirstie. For more gorgeous ballads try Amazing Grace or The Prayer. And Bohemian Rhapsody is brilliant and is always a hit! If you want to get into some live stuff I'd recommend starting with the Popspring medley -- that one has some original songs as well as a fun Michael Jackson medley. Thanks for your thoughtful reactions! Can't wait for more.
Matt and Avi are two different people. They have two different voices and two different styles. BUT Mat's voice blends perfectly with the group and you cannot tell me otherwise. The sound is different, of course it is, but that does not make it lesser or greater, only different. And I love Matt with them. From what I understand Avi even helped them choose Matt to a degree. I've heard it said that Simon & Garfunkle's version is a warning, Disturbed's version was anger that the warning was ignored, and Pentatonix's version is hopeful that it's not too late. Personally, I think it's the best version of the song since Simon and Garfunkle.
A couple of really good ones for Matt/Mitch are the party's over and mad world. Matt's tones in new rules/are you that somebody are killer. For another awesome Avi performance try silent Night. They're all fantastic.
Thanks for this reaction. I always look forward to your reactions because you have some knowledge about music and video production. With the exception of Bohemian Rhapsody, you have done the main "classic" Pentatonix that most reactors start out on. I would recommend Gold (Kiara cover), Shallow, Come Along, La La Latch, Favourite Things, Mad World (Tears for Fears cover) for your next choices.
I am not a musician...when I sing in the shower the audience leaves. But I appreciate music immensely, and I've done audio mixing. I absolutely LOVE watching your reactions. Far and away, you show your appreciation of the sheer talent of the musicians AND the team behind them more than any other reactor I've seen. Especially with PTX, i wonder how much you are working to hold back your emotions?!?!? PTX and Peter Hollens get me emotional because they make it seem SO effortless to sound SO great, yet I know it is most definitely NOT effortless. Thanks for doing these!
Mary did you know is an awesome one! Also aha live in Singapore! Amazing grace.. imagine.. lalalatch.. cant hold us.. somebody that i used to know! Were here for it!! Yes . please 🙏
If you're talking about the tall blonde guy, that's Scott. New member is the guy in the white jacket, his name is Matt.
Scott was the opener. He does base at times. He has an insane range. The new low bass is Matt who replaced Avi.
Not gonna lie, Avi I think is better served as a solo artist. His talent is unquestionable, but his personality & artistry are better suited to a more niche fandom. Now he has a better grip on his career trajectory, and he can showcase all of his abilities in ways he couldn’t with the group.
Matt is quite literally A PERFECT FIT with PTX. His addition seemed like the missing puzzle piece, and with him in the lineup they have reached new heights and expanded their skill set & repertoire, in both creative and performative aspects. In my opinion, this was the best case scenario for everyone.
Perfectly said!!!
100% agree. I think Matt is a much better fit with the group. And I’m loving Avi’s solo career.
Well said, and absolutely agree!!
Me too. I agree with every word. In addition, I believe that Avi is SO much happier now! Not that there was any problem between him and Pentatonix, but the nonstop touring and always being in cities didn't fit with our nature-craving Avi. His tours now are only a few weeks at a time, then a rest period, and plenty of time to spend in the woods and mountains. On the PTX side, Matt has brought in so much joy and energy! He was the perfect choice. And we still have Avi--both his exhilarating solo work and the 8 years of albums and videos with Pentatonix. Win/Win/Win.
Well said! Thank you!
Everyone breathed a sigh of relief when Matt made muster. It was probably stressful for him.
There is only one Avi, but I love Matt’s buttery, soulful voice. He jumped into some big shoes with a joyful abundance! I enjoy the details you point out and your reactions - thank you!
Well, I won't lie. I miss Avi, but he seems happier in the place he is now.
@@bsvenss2 Agreed; I feel the same way.
Understand Avid wanted to.do.some single things and that the travel kept him from family..He of course can't be replaced just a different kind of bass. Matt has such a smooth base a great addition
In my opinion, you have had the “perfect” introduction to Pentatonix! Hallelujah, for its sheer majesty…Daft Punk, to show their versatility…and The Sound of Silence, to introduce Matt! Great job…another reactor has praised them for their ability to “get out of each other’s way”. Which is exactly what you are saying…when it comes time for each individual to sing, the other 4 are doing their dead level best to make that person shine, and shine they do!!! That’s what makes PTX PTX…
I forgot to mention that Kevin is a tenor.
@@Acadian_Proud I was gonna say, Amazing Grace or Mary Did You Know? next for Kevin's gorgeous tenor! 💜
Scott the baritone is an original member and got the group together. He often sings bass when the bass (Matt...white jacket) is singing.
they covered 'mad world', which is a dark song but i love how they did it. would be interested in your opinion. they also cover 'imagine', which isn't dark, but is really good.
Avi left (apparently amicably) after PTX's 2016-17 tour. The others did some recordings with only four people while auditioning basses and added Matt Sallee on a trial basis for their 2017 Christmas season. Avi and Matt both have music degrees (and both did a capella in college), but it seems that Avi trained to develop his deeper range while Matt trained more to develop his baritone. Avi has said he loved his time with Pentatonix but the constant touring was a strain and he is now doing his own music and appears much happier.
Agree with your assessment. I would like to say that I think that in the early days for Matt, he was more in his baritone range, only because as you point out that is more what he originally trained for. As the years have progessed, he has worked hard on his lower range, and in their newest music he is killing his bass parts. Ben Bram indicated that when Matt came on board, they had to learn to arrange to his voice compared to Avi's voice, which meant that they had to do some thing differently. It's been 5 years now, and I think that Matt is exactly what PTX needed for the direction that they have taken their music.
@@elizabethfelet4743 Yes. Matt can't go as low as Avi did, not with the same power at least, but he can go higher with ease. I'd dare say his and Scott's range are almost identical, but the tonal quality, which part of their respective voices they're using (chest, head, falsetto, etc.), differs. I've haven't heard the current lineup live, I do wonder how they'd make their older songs fit with Matt.
@@xheralt I saw a version of Bohemian Rhapsody live that popped up in my feed, from the current era (so I know it exists, and I’ll have to find it again soon), and Matt’s high end on his verse in Hallelujah live is amazing, when he hits a very high falsetto so perfectly. I could probably find both of those pretty easily, so I’ll assume you can as well. Happy hunting :)
Just as a note, they aren’t on the official channels, of course, but probably just searching “Pentatonix Bohemian Rhapsody live” will pop up several options, including the one from a year or two ago. I think the Hallelujah one I saw was from their concert in LA, and it might be the same concert as the Rhapsody video I’m going to go find right now.
Avi left the group because his Mom had cancer and the travel schedule became too much.
Thanks for appreciating Matt and what he brings to PTX❤️
I think you will really like their cover of Bohemian Rhapsody. Staged with simplicity, but arranged with on point complexity.
Try their mix of New Rules x Are you That Somebody, for a better idea of Matt's base. If you want to hear all five just singing, try their covers of Dreams or My Heart with You.
I will add Mad World to the songs where all five are singing . The melodies and key changes are wonderful in that song.
@@Gwennedd also that Lennon song.
@@derrickcox7761 are you sure? The only video I found of that is a mash-up of two songs overlaid on each other and the lyrics don't work for either song : czcams.com/video/XypXi5KoEic/video.html
@@derrickcox7761 Avi was still with them for the Lennon song, this thread is kind of about bringing Matt forward,
@@xheralt oops, you are right. The Grinch is another great one for Matt.
Great reaction. Thanks. Fun fact: Kirsten’s boyfriend was the director of this video. He films a lot of the behind the scenes video when they are on tour (which is how they met).
You should try Love Again. It is one of their original songs and the visuals are as amazing as the daft punk video.
One of my favorites!
Yesss… that one always gets overlooked. It’s one of my favorites also. I don’t know how a lot of their originals didn’t make a bigger stamp than they did.
Agree! Its often overlooked by reactors
One of my very favorites
There is so much for you to enjoy! For their signature wall of sound, watch their upgrade of Imagine. 90s Dance Medley is fun, as is Come Along. For a 4-in-1, try their live performance at Popspring 2016, which includes 3 of their originals and the Evolution of Michael Jackson. Run To You, another original, is phenomenal.
Given you like simplistic videos I’d suggest their upgrade of Kiiara’s Gold next. Given how effects heavy the original is it should be impossible to do a capella right?
YesYesYES
listen to the original first so you better understand the immense upgrade from PTX. 😁😁😁
Great reaction to a great song and cover. May I suggest, their cover of Mad World.
In this video you can actually see that Scott is performing the bass line while Matt is singing his solo. Scott did it with Avi in Hallelujah, but the camera never showed Scott during that timeframe in that video.
Recommendations: Just for something fairly different from what you've already seen: Havana or Attention, Sing (original), Jolene (collab with Dolly Parton, their 3rd Grammy winner), Papaoutai or Radioactive or Over the River (all collabs with Lindsey Stirling, with Kevin cello-boxing).
I have heard that in the official video of Hallelujah, they added a track with Avi doing the bass line, so it is actually him singing both solo and bass line at the same time. This makes sense to me since, as terrific as Scott's lower range is, he still doesn't quite have that buttery smoothness we know from Avi's voice, and when I listen closely, it really does sound more like Avi doing those bass notes. It would also make sense not to show Scott during that verse if he isn't taking over from Avi, but just doing background and harmonies with the others. I know Scott picks up the bass line when they sing Hallelujah live, but I do believe they decided to use Avi for the official video.
It did show him doing it in the live Christmas performance of Hallelujah. When Avi starts singing his solo, look over his right shoulder at Scott and watch his hands... he telegraphs what he is doing.
It’s Scott. They may have given more resonance to it in post.
It’s Scott. They may have added some resonance in post production, you can tell in they way they pronounce the ‘bum, bum bum’s’.
@@gingerjohnson1095 For sure it's Scott in the live Christmas performance, and any other live performance. I'm just saying I heard that for the official video of Hallelujah, they were able to use Avi's voice for the bass line while he was singing his solo, so they did. Perhaps they did add more resonance to Scott's voice to give it that fuller timbre, but I wonder why they would bother, if they could easily slip Avi's voice in there. Just an opinion...
I adore the passion they put into this one.
Thank you for distinguishing PTX"s performance of this song as their own beautiful interpretation of the story and the music. A number of other reactors have tried to compare them to Disturbed's version but, like you, I don't think a comparison can be drawn. Technically it's the same song but the voices, the production and the way they make you feel while you listen to the music are so different. One reactor even said that PTX"s version was "almost as good as the original by Disturbed." This guy was apparently unaware that the original was done by Simon and Garfunkel in the 1960's. I enjoyed your reaction very much and hope you will do more PTX. I think you would enjoy Bohemian Rhapsody, I know I would.
I agree. I love PTX, Disturbed, and Simon and Garfunkel’s versions. They all are great on their own. No need for comparisons. :)
Angie Pangie I believe I may have listened to the same reactor who commented that while he really loved PTX's cover of "TSoS", it was Almost as good as the original by "Disturbed"; and of the 2 groups, he'd have to give a slight edge to "Disturbed." Hmm..🤔 I immediately thought, 'I could have Sworn Paul Simon wrote that song in '64, when I was only 6 yrs old, and he & Art Garfunkel were the creators of the "Original" SoS, lol!"😉 My next thought was, 'Man, I'm getting old!'😱😄 Growing up I loved "The Sound of Silence"; both message & music stirred my soul! And when I watched Disturbed's cover about a year ago, I was surprised to find that I really loved it! But there wasn't any real way to compare Simon & Garfunkel's original version with theirs~ both were Awesome in their own right & in their own ways. Same goes for PTX; tho' I have to say that if I Had to choose, I like Pentatonix' cover a little more than Disturbed, as much as I did really like theirs.
In case nobody has mentioned it before, Scott does the bass part when Avi and Matt have a solo part. They are so amazing!
Ben Bram has been their arranger/producer from the beginning. He helps them arrange and record. Ed Boyer is their mixer, he is a genius. If you want to see them arrange/record they have a short film "recording of Evergreen". Then if you look at Jacob Restituto's YT channel....he has interviewed both of them - if you are into that technical kind of thing! Enjoy!
Thanks Trish! Appreciate your mentioning Jacob’s interviews of Ed (twice) & Ben. They were SO good!
Yes Matt, the young man in the white jacket is the new bass. Scott, the bartitone who started the song, covers base when Matt sings in a higher octave. However, in the majority of their other newer songs (2018 going forward), Matt does the majority of the bass. His sound isn't as operatic as Avi's but it is very rich and deep.
Mad World is another song that is amazing from PTX. It would be cool if you watched the early songs from the Sing Off TV show in order. Kind of like a beginning of the group to see how they have developed kind of like Tool. Love your reactions.
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Remember, PTX doesn't do covers... They do upgrades!!!
" Their ability to get out of each other's way" Actually, I've always thought their motto must be "Leave the ego at the door."
Matt Sallee took over for Avi in 2017 when Avi left for family reasons. Matt is like hitting the bass button on a system and his bass runs are killer. Avi was like hitting Super Bass and causing internal damage from vibrations. Love them both.
I do love it when Scott goes off. And Kirstie & Mitch in the back ground with their aah-aaahh-ahh sounds almost like a siren. New sub, interested to watch you go down the PTX rabbithole.
As for where to go next, we'll, there's many possibilities and I could really just list their entire discography lol. But how about for a start something a little different that has Kevin playing cello & beatboxing, "celloboxing" as he calls it, and Lindsey Stirling on violin... on an upgrade of Imagine Dragon's *Radioactive* . Or if you wanted to try something sit down with mics then Ciara's *Gold* or even 21 Pilot's *Ride* .
They have two albums full of originals that many get overlooked, and they range greatly in vibe, a quick jump in is to watch *Popspring 2016* miniconcert where they perform originals (Cracked, Can't Sleep Love, and Water) as well as their Evolution of Michael Jackson. It's a little longer but people don't usually seem to mind.
As an aside, I also highly recommend *Superfruit* , which is Mitch & Scott's channel "The Greatest Show on The Internet" as they dubbed it (sadly they haven't uploaded in 3 or so years but there's a whole lot of awesome musical (and other fun) content over there). My fave to see people react to is always *Hip Hop Goes Broadway* 1 & 2 and for a real treat *Feeling Myself* (always wait to see if there are bloopers after the subscribe message lol). Along with various medleys and evolutions, and an albums worth of incredible original music all of which except one have music vids (it's not a capella)
Also, all except Matt have ventured into solo or other projects. Some examples:
Avi - Change On A Rise (he has a new album and a an EP that's from a couple years ago of his solo stuff since leaving) ;
Kevin has his KOvers - Down and Sign of The Times are both phenomenal;
Scott has a various duets, my fave is Lost On You with Mario Josè (who's on Rise with Superfruit) and his solo stuff like Avicii's Wake Me Up;
Mitch has some very different solo stuff from the older Graveyard to Billie Eilish's Your Power, to his recent Messer project (verrry different to the Mitch we know) Love Supply and Angel's Pray for example.
Kirstie - Break A Little.
I don’t think enough people comment on Mitch and Kirstie’s aah-aaaah-ahh sounds. It’s my favorite part of the song and I feel like I’m the only one that hears it since no one else ever mentions it. So thank you!
That's actually my favorite part❤️ I always get chills with that part🙂
Try PTX Be My Eyes
If you really want to get a Mitch beat-down, their version of Bohemian Rhapsody is one to watch
Oh my gosh, I hope you react to Bohemian Rhapsody! I think you might really enjoy it!!! They are so good!!!!
Love your reactions. Very insightful. I’m a Pentaholic and honestly I love both Avi and Matt as bass in different ways. I subbed. They do a great video of Mad World during pandemic which seems appropriate . Thank you
He is a new member his name is Matt Sallee, yet another awesome singer. You really should react to Bohemian Rhapsody it will blow your mind, Queen themselves loved it! Amazing Grace. Havana and their own original Coffee in Bed, stunning every one of them oh and don't forget The Prayer, Mitch just melts your heart. So welcome to the Pentatonix rabbit hole. keep reacting and you'll get thousands of followers they are huge on you tube and very well deserved too!!
They always know how to get out of each other's way.
Really enjoyed your reaction. As others have said, Matt is showcased in the fun "You're a Mean One Mr. Grinch," and he evokes such emotion in "Mad World" (as they all do in that song).
I really enjoyed your reaction and review--thanks! I am a long time Pentaholic and Voice Player that appreciates a reactor that does not compare one group or member of a group negatively against the others--thank you for that! Many people were so heartbroken about Avi leaving in 2017 that they were never able to show the new bass singer, Matt, any love or respect for all he does. I am glad I subscribed and look foward to more of your reactions to all three of the acapella groups (main ones anyway but there are other lesser known that are good too).
Thank you for this reaction!! Appreciate you not comparing Avi/Matt. I suggest Can You Feel The Love Tonight 🙂
Bought this album over 55 yrs ago and this song was always one of my favourites...the lyrics are stunning and raw. Hearing this version by Pentatonix, though, was the first time the hair on my arms stood straight up. Wow.
I love your reactions - they are honest and insightful. Thank you!
Please react to Pentatonix's covers of " Bohemian Rhapsody ",
" Come Along ", and "Havana".
Suggestions for more Pentatonix -- "Happy Now", "Sing", "Love Again" (all PTX originals), "New Rules x Are You That Somebody" (Dua Lipa x Aaliya mashup), "Gold" (Kiiara cover, recorded live),
excellent choices!
The person who sang first is Scott Hoying, and he’s been there since the very beginning; part of the original trio of Scott, Mitch, & Kirstin. The third person to sing is Matt Sallee, the new bass (although not so new anymore, been since 2017), and he replaced Avi Kaplan. Mitch Grassi was the second singer. Kirstie Maldonado is the fourth singer. And of course you have the best beat boxer ever, Kevin Olusola
The Prayer and Bohemian Rhapsody are INCREDIBLE from them.........thanks you for your reactions....I love them!
So. Much. Power. And so much control. They always impress.
Recommend their original, Happy Now.
Avi Kaplan was in the original group (2011 Sing Off) and continued through early 2017. He had family health issues and could not tour.
There may have been some creative issues also. When you hear his solo stuff, then you'll realize he was limiting himself some in PTX.
Try his Change On The Rise.
Matt Sallee did some summer 2017 shows and officially joined a little later. I think his first recordings show up in 2018.
Avi had planned to do solo projects while in Pentatonix but now he can focus more on that. Kevin's solo content is amazing and a totally different vibe and Kirstin has done Broadway. I love that the members take time for their personal projects.
The family health was contributing to Avi's burnout, but it wasn't the reason in and of itself. Avi's sister continued on as PTX's tour manager until she got pregnant in 2019. "Creative issues" were the same... not the issue, but another contribution to burnout. Also not like they were disagreeing, but Avi's heart wasn't in the PTX music lane which made it harder to stick out through the stress. Avi *could* tour and loved the group... but he was worn out by their pace and wanted more room in his life for other things.
Matt joined for the 2017 Christmas tour, not summer, as a "featured artist". He became official in February 2018 when PTX renewed their contract with RCA.
@@perfectkismet As Avi said in his leaving announcement - he didn't want to hold the group back. He was finding the constant touring/rehearsing a strain. Add being the other side of the world and not able to see his ailing family it just got too much.
@@alan-freeman He didn't even mention his mom's cancer in the announcement. He wanted more time to do other things, as I said. Everyone loves putting so much emphasis on the illness and family, but the guy moved away from his family after quitting to better pursue his solo music. That just wasn't the point. He wanted more time - for family, yes, but also for his music and just to have downtime and breathe. The point is that in 2016 PTX was going so hard that they were dragging a portable recording studio behind their tour busses and working before and after concerts and even on their days off. Avi didn't find that pace sustainable.
To set Matt's entrance into the PTX timeline, the first video Matt did with PTX after joining the group is their cover of Havana by Camila Cabello. I believe the last one that Avi did with the group was their cover of Bohemian Rhapsody.
Ahhhhhhvi.😁 He left to spend time with family and he went solo. Matt took his place. He's awesome as well.
now if you want to hear Kevin, listen to "Mary, Did You Know"
Rhis one us going to blow your mind. Enjoy yourself and check out their version of Can't Hold Us. They actually have bars and flow in their rap.
Hello Skultz, thanks for doing this one by PTX. This is Pure Pentatonix Perfection. The solos. The cresceondo. The PTX wall of sound. They are all perfection. Mitch's lower register, with the inflections is just perfect. Avi (pronounced Ah-vee) left in 1028 and was replaced by Matt as the bass. Scott sings baritone and covers the bass backing when Matt is singing, Kirstie is sharp with her belting. Kevin the master beat boxer is beyond compare with the vocal percussion, stomping and clapping. PTX have about 250 songs, several genres, 3 Grammys. There is so much more that you will enjoy. Suggestions for you - The Prayer, Amazing Grace, Can You Feel the Love Tonight, Come Along, Gold - for starters. Then they also have great originals. PTX videos are always intentional. Thanks for recognizing so many details. Great reaction!!!
Gotta also give some love to another fantastic Acapella group named Home Free. Start with Mayday....both groups are equally talented and so proud of PTX and Matt is Avi's replacement for awhile now. They just were awarded a star on the Hollywood walk of fame!! Thank You!💜
Thx S . Please consider their Bo Rhapsody . It’s really cool. 😃
For more variety, Amazing Grace, Can’t Hold Us, Mad World, Gold, Can You Feel the Love Tonight?, Problem and their original Love Again or Coffee in Bed are mandatory.
Love your take on the group. Great reaction. If you want to hear Kevin sing with Pentatonix, listen to Mary did you know, Imagine and Amazing Grace. If you want to see him solo, look up KO’s covers of Down and Sign of the times. New sub!!
Another great reaction! I had the exact same response when I first saw Matt. Where did Avi go?! Then Matt opened his mouth, and I was like....OOOOOOOHHHHHH! Since you mentioned your curiosity about the mixing of the videos, I thought I'd point you to 2 good interviews with the guy that mixes many Pentatonix videos, as well as some for the other big a capella groups, that were posted by Jacob Restituto. He's also has a really great interview of Ben Bram, who is the 6th member of Pentatonix (arranges their stuff).
That was good. I normally pass on the PTX reactions. Not because I don't respect their abilities/talent...it's just not really my thing. But since I saw it was you reacting, I decided to check it out. I was pretty entertained by the performance, so glad I checked it out.
You need to check out Can you feel the Love tonight. (Lion King). and the Prayer.
Scott (first singer - baritone and covers bass when Avi (originally bass) or Matt (new bass) started the group with Mitch (second singer - countertenor) and Kristen (mezzo soprano) in high school. Kevin (beatboxer and phenomenal cello player) and Avi were added when the group audition for Sing Off which they did win.
I’m an original pentaholic. Saw them on “The Sing Off” and never looked back. Love your reactions. I’m sure you’ve gotten a million requests from everyone. Anything by them is awesome. So…I’m going to suggest someone else. Guy Sebastian is an Australian singer and he has an Amazing voice. “Battle Scars” live from the home front really shows off his voice. Would love to hear your reaction. I’m new to your channel and look forward to exploring more.
Really enjoyed your reaction to my favorite group!
Pentatonix is so amazing 🤩 chills the harmonies so incredible ❤️🔥🎶
You should listen to Pentatonix cover Imagine next so you can get a little taste of Kevin when he sings rather than just the beatboxing you've seen so far. It's another older one with Avi in it and they covered it beautifully...plus the video always makes me emotional.
They are phenomenal. 'Mary did you know' is one of my favourites.
So I like your reaction to this. Just like artists themselves sometimes the reactors can take it to levels that aren't neccesary lol well done! I really love this group so much. They're all extremely talented and when all together they make magic! With that being said I do have an extra soft spot for Mitch.... I've never heard a more beautiful voice. Recommending you react to Come Along, nothing dark or sad just pure fun and guaranteed to make you smile! Also recommend Blinding Lights, it's upbeat and fun...and maybe you can help us figure out why Scott chose succulents hahaha
Another amazing reaction thanku so much lovely skullz always a pleasure absolutely love this ao incredible thanku so much love and God bless always x
I love PTX version. It's a little more uplifting than Simon and Garfunkle's original and not so dark as Disturbed's version. Just my opinion.
Scott started off Hallelujah, too. Matt and Avi are both amazing. he is the new bass who took Avi’s place. Feels weird calling him new, because he’s been with the group for several years now. I saw PTX in concert and he also played drums at one point. Scott played piano and Kevin played cello. It was nice seeing their other talents. :)
Try “Bohemian Rhapsody”, “Come Along”, “Mary Did You Know”, “Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy” (won a Grammy) and original song “Sing”
Thank you for the great reaction! I hope you'll dive deeper and deeper into the rabbit hole named PTX.. we'll be by your side! Matt's voice is absolutely perfect for the group and I love his smooth tone, you should check out "You're a mean one, Mr. Grinch" where he has the lead.. and please do their cover of "Mad World", it's so hauntingly beautiful.. I think you'll like it 😊
One of their original songs "Sing" is always a great video to check out.
@0:40 Skullz: "I think I have finally all their names..."
The rest of us: "You've plenty more Avi to see, but also well desereved welcome to Matt". :D ;) :p
Amazing Grace ~ You’ll be Mitch slapped again! 😎
If you want something that looks more complex (just for fun) check out "my favorite things." It's so much fun!
Thanks for the reaction! A while ago a commenter on a reactor said the S&G version was the warning of what would happen, Disturbed's version is angry that we didn't listen, and PTX's version is showing there's still hope if we listen and act soon.
As much as I do really love PTX, Home Free and Voiceplay I am still a Queen fan first. Please consider Queen - Under Pressure ( live at Wembley). I really think you would enjoy it! Thanks
You should listen to Pentatonix's version of Bohemian Rhapsody. Mitch uses a prop at one point but it is JUST a prop, he doesn't use the prop when live.
Simon & Garfunkel - a warning
Disturbed - Anger at the world ignoring the warning
Pentatonix - There is still hope!
Oh I like that 💯
I'm a Pentaholic at my core, but I'm also rapidly becoming a VoicePlayer, and I have to take exception to your "a capella videos should be minimalistic..." because when VoicePlay go crazy, it's a FABULOUS crazy. I'd like to invite you to review their "Hoist the Colors," or for maximum crazy, either "Dragonborn Comes" or "Enemy" for full-blown theatrics. Well, technically, for FULL-BORE THEATRICS, "The Oogie Boogie Song" goes all out. They also have plenty of "sit in a chair and sing" videos too, to suit your taste, but they love to pull out the costumes.
Don't get me wrong, as far as I'm concerned, the Pentatonix videos are gorgeous, but even they go costume drama from time to time. And it always works. "Cheerleader," or "My Favorite Things" (which really only has the basic tune/lyrics in common with the Julie Andrews version) or best of all, "Making Christmas." And you've already seen "Daft Punk." For a similar (but very different) vibe, you might look at their original "Love Again." Steampunk. Oof.
Pentatonix is going to keep you busy for a while as they have an enormous catalog, but the top three a capella groups, in my opinion, are PTX, VoicePlay and Home Free. And since I'm not a Country music fan, Home Free trails, but they have their rabid fan base. Whichever way you go, you're pretty much guaranteed an awesome result.
Oh no! He's gone to the trouble of learning their names and now he comes up with one with Matt.
🤦♂️ lol
PTX has such great music! I’m really enjoying your reactions. For something really different from them, I suggest Gold.
I just subscribed because I really enjoyed your PTX reactions - I appreciate your informed comments on everything from their sound to their look to the setting. Although I've seen the videos innumerable times, I like it when someone points out something I've missed! Looking forward to more. As many have said, they have a catalog of over 200 songs and a LOT of them have accompanying videos. Contrasting their style from the early days 2012-2014 to the last couple years, you'll definitely notice a difference in production and styling, however, their overall music is still stellar. With a little searching online you can find many live performances (there's a great one for Daft Punk & Hallelujah) as well as other concert recordings and you'll see their live performances are VERY similar to the studio productions. Fans will say they don't record anything they can't sing live, and though I haven't seen them yet, and all I've seen is concert videos, you can tell that the lives are pretty much the same. Scott often changes his riff or throws a little something in the live to "prove" it's different from the recording. I'll be following your journey.
Looking forward to more PTX reactions! 💕
Avi (ah-vee) was with them through 2016. Matt joined them and has been with them since :)
I have to say that PTX is my favorite acapella group. That said, while I like this version, and of course they sing it beautifully, I ADORE the Disturbed one. It portrays the rage and urgency that I feel about the subject much better. When it comes to a perfect message from a cover vs an original, PTX's Imagine has the most profound message for me. Matt is the new bass and he's amazing in his own right. He is showcased in a great way by their cover of You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch. So much fun! Kirsten's voice is on point in her/their original Be My Eyes. Avi has gone on to a solo career and is wonderful too.
Enjoyed your reaction. Please react to the evolution of MJ, Amazing Grace and The Prayer.
Thank you for another great PTX reaction! Very observant and thoughtful. Much appreciated. 👍🏻
You will note that Scott covers bass when when the bass-man is doing solo.
Looking forward to watching you do lots more Pentatonix reactions. There are so many to choose from!
Try The Prayer if you have not seen that one yet - I think you would enjoy it - This Pentaholic is enjoying your reactions - (you too will become a Pentaholic the further you go down the rabbit hole)! LOL
From the Avi era: Can't Hold Us, Love Again, Perfume Medley, Royals.
From the Matt era: Coffee In Bed, Come Along, Mr Grinch, 90s Dance Medley.
I was 17 when Simon & Garfunkel came out with the original in 1964. It struck me like few songs had or would. I still tear up at 76 and feel the ache I did then with PTX's version...a fantastic cover.
I love your PTX reactions and I so appreciate that you have taken the time and care to learn their names. A lot of reactors are still calling them "the blond guy" or "the dude with the high voice" even many videos in to their PTX journeys.
So many ways to continue! If you want something more upbeat, you can't go wrong with Cheerleader. I smile along with them every time. That one is older and features Avi. Rather Be, Say Something, and Shallow heavily feature Kirstie. For more gorgeous ballads try Amazing Grace or The Prayer. And Bohemian Rhapsody is brilliant and is always a hit! If you want to get into some live stuff I'd recommend starting with the Popspring medley -- that one has some original songs as well as a fun Michael Jackson medley.
Thanks for your thoughtful reactions! Can't wait for more.
You should listen to their version of Bohemian Rhapsody, Imagine, the Prayer, Amazing Grace, Coffee in Bed, Anchor,
Amazing Grace, Imagine, Bohemian Rhapsody. Good crosscut of their range.
Matt and Avi are two different people. They have two different voices and two different styles. BUT Mat's voice blends perfectly with the group and you cannot tell me otherwise. The sound is different, of course it is, but that does not make it lesser or greater, only different. And I love Matt with them. From what I understand Avi even helped them choose Matt to a degree. I've heard it said that Simon & Garfunkle's version is a warning, Disturbed's version was anger that the warning was ignored, and Pentatonix's version is hopeful that it's not too late. Personally, I think it's the best version of the song since Simon and Garfunkle.
A couple of really good ones for Matt/Mitch are the party's over and mad world. Matt's tones in new rules/are you that somebody are killer. For another awesome Avi performance try silent Night. They're all fantastic.
Thanks for this reaction. I always look forward to your reactions because you have some knowledge about music and video production. With the exception of Bohemian Rhapsody, you have done the main "classic" Pentatonix that most reactors start out on. I would recommend Gold (Kiara cover), Shallow, Come Along, La La Latch, Favourite Things, Mad World (Tears for Fears cover) for your next choices.
I am not a musician...when I sing in the shower the audience leaves. But I appreciate music immensely, and I've done audio mixing. I absolutely LOVE watching your reactions. Far and away, you show your appreciation of the sheer talent of the musicians AND the team behind them more than any other reactor I've seen. Especially with PTX, i wonder how much you are working to hold back your emotions?!?!? PTX and Peter Hollens get me emotional because they make it seem SO effortless to sound SO great, yet I know it is most definitely NOT effortless. Thanks for doing these!
Mary did you know is an awesome one! Also aha live in Singapore! Amazing grace.. imagine.. lalalatch.. cant hold us.. somebody that i used to know! Were here for it!! Yes . please 🙏
Even their elocution is tight and so precise!
Avi Left the group in 2017 and Matt Sallee took over as the bass.
Can I suggest you watch "The Beginners Guide to Pentatonix. It's a couple of years old now, but introduces the members and gives a brief history.
Oo the chills everytime I listen to ptx