The ONLY Thing That Can SAVE STAR WARS!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
  • Episode 7 of The Acolyte feels an awful lot like the final nail in the coffin for Disney Star Wars, but there is ONE way SW can be saved.
    For more SnarkyJay...
    Consider subscribing to my Patreon!: bit.ly/3MUrd6h
    Catch me LIVE on Twitch Tuesdays & Thursdays 6-8pm EST: / snarkyjaycosplay
    Follow me on Instagram: bit.ly/3GTPNjY

Komentáře • 1,8K

  • @user-kz5gw7xe4o
    @user-kz5gw7xe4o Před měsícem +222

    "A good novel tells us the truth about its hero; but a bad novel tells us the truth about its author.” G. K. Chesterton
    Lucas's 'Star Wars' was about Luke Skywalker. Leslye Headlands' 'Star Wars' is about Leslye Headland (and she's said as much).

    • @NothinSpecial9828
      @NothinSpecial9828 Před měsícem +5

      Damn that’s beautiful. I love finding short punchy factual ways to tell a truth or help someone understand your view without mudding the message that you’d like them to consider.

    • @Christian-el2bz
      @Christian-el2bz Před měsícem +1

      Ufff! That is a great quote! And a great point!

    • @D3athW1ng
      @D3athW1ng Před měsícem

      Facts

    • @chriswolfe351
      @chriswolfe351 Před měsícem

      Funny enough, I had that very experience not too long ago. There was a book I read about a group of clones that were meant to be the crew of this colony ship that was slowly crossing the galaxy, and it was presented as a mystery as to what had gone wrong. Not only was it not a mystery, because they figure out what happened the first time they sit down and speculate about it, but it also told me far more about the author than I cared to know. Case in point, there were two characters that were irredeemable trash that I could tell the author liked and thought were sympathetic, and there were two more that were sympathetic, who it was clear the author did not agree.

  • @chance_ondriezek99
    @chance_ondriezek99 Před měsícem +751

    You’d swear The Acolyte was made literally to punish Star Wars fans.

    • @carlflaherty2215
      @carlflaherty2215 Před měsícem +48

      Not quite.
      More likely, it was made to end the franchise.

    • @TheMaskGamer2007
      @TheMaskGamer2007 Před měsícem +29

      It was made to make white men cry.

    • @cliffordfernandez3524
      @cliffordfernandez3524 Před měsícem +1

      @@TheMaskGamer2007yup that’s what the half breed said

    • @user-sh6nx8ty8q
      @user-sh6nx8ty8q Před měsícem +9

      I’m crying lol

    • @carlflaherty2215
      @carlflaherty2215 Před měsícem +20

      ​@TheMaskGamer2007 And, they have succeeded. Unfortunately, the price for this is the White Men have (largely) moved on - taken their money with them.

  • @bernieclark8458
    @bernieclark8458 Před měsícem +90

    The wife and myself have been rewatching Stargate franchise just so we can relove Sci-fi again.

    • @dohnuts6603
      @dohnuts6603 Před měsícem +7

      Jaffa, cree!

    • @nexus_of_a_crisis
      @nexus_of_a_crisis Před měsícem +1

      I loved 'Atlantis', but chose 'Gomorah' and 'Logan's Run'.to numb the pain.

    • @Wezwolf
      @Wezwolf Před měsícem

      It's even better to watch anything from the 60's to early 80's - just to get away from anything modern looking. Even just seeing something made with HD digital film, can arouse trauma and cause trembling, nausea etc.

    • @jonathanbaker4361
      @jonathanbaker4361 Před měsícem +4

      Babylon 5

    • @bernieclark8458
      @bernieclark8458 Před měsícem +4

      @@jonathanbaker4361 Done that too. 🙂

  • @jamesr.5085
    @jamesr.5085 Před měsícem +54

    "Walk in with a chip on your shoulder." Been saying this the whole time. They came in looking for a fight and guess what “Broke into the wrong goddamn rec room didn’t you, you bastard!?”

    • @Bastion83
      @Bastion83 Před měsícem +2

      Love the Tremors quote.

    • @justin1730
      @justin1730 Před měsícem

      I feel like such a nerd for knowing that was a Tremors quote.

  • @funnypicturescomics
    @funnypicturescomics Před měsícem +260

    I've never in my lifetime witnessed a company so purposefully destroy their fanbase like Disney has. They can not be doing this accidentally.

    • @oldgoat142
      @oldgoat142 Před měsícem +9

      These done the same thing to superheroes.

    • @nj7969
      @nj7969 Před měsícem +23

      You’d be surprised how self destructive and counter productive an unchecked ego can be.

    • @brianabalos4878
      @brianabalos4878 Před měsícem +10

      Electronic Arts done it first to be fair. The only difference is Disney on it longer than EA and still going strong lol (to destroy everything that is).

    • @dontgiveinfo
      @dontgiveinfo Před měsícem

      no they are not. IT's social engineering paid by the good ppl of black rock who wants those kids

    • @jonsnow9796
      @jonsnow9796 Před měsícem +8

      I hope 20 years from now we'll have more answers as to wtf is going on with Disney

  • @mahall85
    @mahall85 Před měsícem +63

    Disney doesn’t need to clean house… Disney needs to tear the house down to the studs, and start over. Iger, the board, Kennedy, D’Amaro (the parks chief)… their issues are baked into the fabric of the entire company. And it needs to go.

    • @troffle
      @troffle Před měsícem +2

      You must be kidding, "Disney needs to tear the house down"? DISNEY IS THE HOUSE. It needs fire, down to the foundations to bake the very salts out of the earth.

  • @JoseGomez721
    @JoseGomez721 Před měsícem +18

    Star Wars was made as a rebellion against Hollywood's studio system. George Lucas wanted to tell a story his way by innovating in modeling, special effects, visual effects, CGI in the prequels, and superb work in swordfighting. George Lucas did not want the studio executives injecting themselves in the film making and script writing process. He wanted to things his way and let his team figure out the creative process. That is what made the original trilogy so very special.
    I believe Disney needs to sell Star Wars. Star Wars doesn’t work in a traditional studio system. The OG trilogy was avant garde filmmaking that was on the bleeding edge. Star Wars needs to return to its experimental roots.
    Or if Disney keeps it, it must go to a separate experimental film studio with ZERO corporate interference whatsoever. George Lucas, Dave Filoni, Jon Favreau, Bryce Dallas Howard, & Rick Famuyiwa should head that new studio.
    But Kathleen Kennedy, Leslye Headland, and the entire staff of The Acolyte need to be permanently fired and banned from Star Wars. Especially that writers' room that wrote this abomination. The Acolyte should be considered non-canon and disregarded.
    Bring Star Wars full circle back to its experimental and avant garde filmmaking roots. No studio decision-making, exploring the cutting edge in filmmaking, and pushing the technology to the limits. Let the writers take their time to produce compelling characters and storylines. That's what is needed to save Star Wars.

  • @cryeredd7563
    @cryeredd7563 Před měsícem +7

    dayumn, she got those yams just squeeeeezed up in there

    • @danielwesterlund1905
      @danielwesterlund1905 Před 7 dny

      Booba Fett brings in the views. Kind of crazy how many nobodies are making a living off of saying that Disney are shit nowadays.

  • @dmontalvo1983
    @dmontalvo1983 Před měsícem +127

    Return Of The Jedi was released in 1983, the year I was born. Star Wars has been in my life since I can remember. Luke and Vader raised me! I’m just a simple vato loco from the barrio who’s only escape from reality was Star Wars. HOW DID WE GET HERE, GUYS?? This genuinely breaks my heart…

    • @oldgoat142
      @oldgoat142 Před měsícem +8

      I go back even further. I'm one of those people who saw A New Hope 4 times in a row when it came out. I fell in love with it. Bought the models, the books, the comics. What these people have done to this thing which I sank who knows how much money into makes me break out into a dark side rage which would make anything Vader does look like a Sunday school social.

    • @Spartan77
      @Spartan77 Před měsícem

      Hold on to your physical media and your memories. "Star Wars" is only dead if you allow the woke lunatics take that away from you. How did we get here? Complacency and underestimating the determination of the woke, marxist lunatics trying to destroy Western Civilization. That is how.

    • @m1a1hm
      @m1a1hm Před měsícem +4

      I don't know my friend how we got here but I know how you feel. When Star Wars came out in 1977 me and my brother saw A New Hope 15 times in the theater. Those were some of the best days of my life being poor kids in the south.

    • @oldgoat142
      @oldgoat142 Před měsícem +5

      @@m1a1hm That was the beauty of the experience we shared no matter where we were. That story and the ones which followed cut across the board no matter who we were. I had nerdy, and not so nerdy, friends of every kind who were totally enthralled. It brought us all together because, GASP, it told a story!! And we all bought into it!
      As for whatever this thing is masquerading as our beloved franchise, they took the finest food and drink we were accustomed to, ground up rotting filth, sprinkled it with garnish, and tried to pass it off as the same thing, and when we refused to choke it down, they had a hissy.

    • @brianquebmankellerwilliams9495
      @brianquebmankellerwilliams9495 Před měsícem +4

      I saw A New Hope 11 times when it first came out. It was magic. I’ve been tuned out for a while. I’d prefer they just bury Star Wars at this point. It’s so sad.

  • @VaniFoxOfficial
    @VaniFoxOfficial Před měsícem +345

    News flash: Star Wars is long dead and Disney is p*ssing on its corpse

    • @donavinrodriguez6288
      @donavinrodriguez6288 Před měsícem

      You say p*sing I say S*itting

    • @bkbland1626
      @bkbland1626 Před měsícem +5

      It never was very good. Good riddance.

    • @badlaamaurukehu
      @badlaamaurukehu Před měsícem

      Same people who tumblr fanfic peepee fiction.

    • @RRolon999
      @RRolon999 Před měsícem +7

      Disney finally buried the corpse 😅

    • @Tomax_Bren
      @Tomax_Bren Před měsícem +9

      Yeah I would say Disney killed Star Wars the day they removed the EU. I'm just happy people are starting to experience the loss of Star Wars that I've been enduring for the last 10 years... welcome to the club.

  • @TheDMan2003
    @TheDMan2003 Před měsícem +21

    1:20 Oh, wow… this just makes it sound like Anna/Elsa was the villain in Frozen, when neither were evil. Yes, Elsa lost control of her power, but when Anna told her about the eternal winter, she got upset because she knew it was her fault. She even righted the wrong she unintentionally committed!

    • @Kalamain
      @Kalamain Před měsícem +1

      Yes!
      The redemption arc!
      Love conquers all!
      It's almost as if good stories are.... Good!
      You almost couldn't make it up. >.>

  • @raymondpearson6850
    @raymondpearson6850 Před měsícem +5

    I saw the original when it hit the theaters in 1977...they lost me after Rogue One (I did like Rogue One, but bailed on the franchise when Leia sailed through space...) Snarky, you are our only hope...stay strong and keep on!

  • @QuadZillaGodZillasbrother
    @QuadZillaGodZillasbrother Před měsícem +200

    Snarky you’re famous now you were on the biggest Star Wars CZcamsr stream Congratulations. We’re so proud of you.

    • @user-sh6nx8ty8q
      @user-sh6nx8ty8q Před měsícem +8

      Hellz yea just keep speaking facts!!!!

    • @michaelfortenberry5735
      @michaelfortenberry5735 Před měsícem +6

      Theory's had her on before.

    • @Heyitsdgaa
      @Heyitsdgaa Před měsícem +1

      @@michaelfortenberry5735when???

    • @snarkyjay
      @snarkyjay  Před měsícem +61

      Not true lmao, yesterday was the first time I’d been on with him and it was a blast! Grateful for the opportunity.

    • @user-sh6nx8ty8q
      @user-sh6nx8ty8q Před měsícem +3

      @@snarkyjay it was awesome to see u both hope you guys do it again for the last episode!

  • @hawkmoon4107
    @hawkmoon4107 Před měsícem +31

    You believe Iger when he's just trying to reassure investors?
    Oh, you sweet summer child! 🙂

    • @DogSerious
      @DogSerious Před měsícem +1

      The fish rots from the head down!

  • @BobBoozle
    @BobBoozle Před měsícem +6

    Very cool to see Snarky Jay collaborating with Star Wars Theory yesterday on a live stream.

  • @nonplayerzealot4
    @nonplayerzealot4 Před měsícem +10

    Snarky, you in that dress is the REAL demonstration of the power of 2.

  • @Nerdzombiedisco
    @Nerdzombiedisco Před měsícem +27

    That Fett dress is already on 🔥fire🔥. 😅

  • @justaguy105
    @justaguy105 Před měsícem +23

    I personally think KK hired LH just so they could regale in their old stories of getting coffee for their bosses and griping about them

    • @nexus_of_a_crisis
      @nexus_of_a_crisis Před měsícem +1

      Throw in an actress somehow worse than Zegler, and turn legitimate criticism as 'Review bombing'. Who cares about what ‘The View’ or ‘Mary Sue’ say? ‘The Acolyte’ wasn’t for them, although maybe it was.

    • @loris-bismar
      @loris-bismar Před měsícem

      LH didn't just get coffee for her boss, she also found young girls for him and her to m*lest.

    • @loris-bismar
      @loris-bismar Před měsícem +1

      It's LH though, she didn't just get coffee for her boss 😂😂

    • @Haven6419
      @Haven6419 Před měsícem

      @@loris-bismarfr tho 🤣🤣🤣

  • @dsubversion
    @dsubversion Před měsícem +18

    Throw out the JJ Abram's and The High Republic ideas and reset all the nonsense, basically start a new. Bring in good writers and fans to rebuild trust for all the OT fans. Good video bro

    • @Wezwolf
      @Wezwolf Před měsícem

      Yes. I don't understand why all this crap is being pushed on us as "lore". Why can't Star Wars just be retold in different ways just as Superman for example? Star Wars has "Legendary" status. This means you could write alternate sequels to the original trilogy or even remake the originals with different actors and alternate scenes.
      (Not that I'd necessarily support that idea though) They planned to do this with an "Aliens" sequel, which would basically ignore Alien 3 and 4. - Why not?

    • @CanalTremocos
      @CanalTremocos Před měsícem

      How would they recognize good writers? There isn't one intellectually sound person in their whole corporate structure. Everything from the Cruise Line to ESPN is suffering a huge slump in quality. I'm not even sure they have enough remaining expertise to hire an external consulting firm to fix them.
      Reminds me of Yahoo. One day they just sucked at everything they did. Their fix was to sell off their core business to become a financial services company, then they rebuilt their internet services business from square one. Disney would be wise to do the same.

  • @p.a.u.l.555
    @p.a.u.l.555 Před měsícem +8

    I still got the prequels and OG trilogy on 4K, that's all I need 😊

    • @maxmazzotti6651
      @maxmazzotti6651 Před měsícem

      Same, as is the old expanded universe. KOTOR and the 2d clone wars are fantastic

  • @SirDawkster
    @SirDawkster Před měsícem +201

    I mean, we really shouldn't expect Harvey Weinstein's former personal assistant to write and direct a good show.

    • @user-xt8qv2tx3c
      @user-xt8qv2tx3c Před měsícem

      Ngl, Russian Dolls was surprisingly good.

    • @rudigerradtke4115
      @rudigerradtke4115 Před měsícem +10

      @SirDawkster: "write what you know" ---> she said !!! 😜

    • @gregstubbington1703
      @gregstubbington1703 Před měsícem

      She's dialing up the female empowerment to make up for all the horror she was part of perhaps. Guilty conscience

    • @mathieuguillet4036
      @mathieuguillet4036 Před měsícem +3

      "Personal assistant"...

    • @Wezwolf
      @Wezwolf Před měsícem +2

      She should have based it on Weinstein's life instead of her own. Then we might have at least got a good villain.

  • @RandomNPC001
    @RandomNPC001 Před měsícem +106

    So this is how an empire falls? With thunderous applause!

    • @Anna-fw7lm
      @Anna-fw7lm Před měsícem +8

      So this is how an empire falls? With -thunderous applause- retching sounds and laughs !

    • @badlaamaurukehu
      @badlaamaurukehu Před měsícem +1

      ​@@Anna-fw7lm*Whimpers and endless petty comlaints about society"
      Thus Lucasfilm and the women ruining it.

    • @kaveiros75
      @kaveiros75 Před měsícem

      Disney 's empire doesn't seem able (or willing) to strike back!
      Pride comes before fall.

    • @bewmdogg
      @bewmdogg Před měsícem

      With thundering mehs

    • @hylianglitchmobber7570
      @hylianglitchmobber7570 Před měsícem +1

      You butchered the quote & it doesn't even fit in the current situation. Disney Star Wars is going out with a whimper & a wet fart.

  • @diamonddavemctv
    @diamonddavemctv Před měsícem +2

    After watching the Acolyte, I'm starting to think that the colossal threat Darth Revan sensed in the Unknown Regions and tried to unite the galaxy against in KOTOR and KOTOR II was actually Disney...

  • @kentako8179
    @kentako8179 Před měsícem +1

    Thank you for the comment & props you made about original The Crow. They just don't make great movies like that anymore. My friend won a contest to have lunch with Brandon Lee when he was promoting the movie in SF. Brandon was a up and rising star and was trying to follow in his father's foot steps but his life was cut too early and unfortunately none of the safety protocol's existed onset as they do today. I took back my thumbs up from Sw theory as soon as he said he didn't even finish the movie, how sad.

  • @FandersonUfo
    @FandersonUfo Před měsícem +45

    RIP Star Wars

  • @stephenturner3180
    @stephenturner3180 Před měsícem +19

    I agree a hundred percent. Cleaning house is essential.

  • @danielgudzevich3768
    @danielgudzevich3768 Před měsícem +3

    Nice commentary Snarky! You worded this perfectly and showed 10 times the passion of anyone in Disney Star Wars. Couldn't have said it better.

  • @meditatedgold2861
    @meditatedgold2861 Před měsícem +1

    I personally believe that were are in for a continuation of this rocky road and while i generally keep quiet and appreciate when we get something good , its really nice to see some like yourself speak out about it properly and eloquently so thx for that im sure many a fan appreciates it keep it up

  • @xavierharris9949
    @xavierharris9949 Před měsícem +91

    If we want Star Wars to be saved. Disney must fire Kathleen Kennedy, Lesley, and anyone who is agreeing with their beliefs. Also, burning your boba fett clothing is way too relatable.

    • @haewymetal
      @haewymetal Před měsícem +10

      I like how you guys never mention Filoni when his wife is literally a "witch" and he approved of the acolyte, ahsoka etc.

    • @craigsewell8692
      @craigsewell8692 Před měsícem +4

      Don’t forget Bob Iger in that list. It all starts at the top.

    • @CaptDingDong
      @CaptDingDong Před měsícem +2

      SELL IT BACK TO LUCAS. That's the only way to save it.

    • @haewymetal
      @haewymetal Před měsícem +2

      @@CaptDingDong hes too old and he doesnt have the money

    • @victorcates9330
      @victorcates9330 Před měsícem +1

      They have to hire absolute top talent. If you had a living director with the skill of Kubrick, you'd challenge them to adhere to star wars style as a test of discipline and pay them a sickening amount of money. Disney got their paws on Star Wars and Indiana Jones, but can't appreciate that those were peak Lucas and Spielberg. As is, Disney's work is being picked apart on political grounds. But it's also being picked apart as incoherent. They bought STAR WARS. They have billions of dollars in future earnings riding on the success of the franchise and they hand 180 million to Leslie Headland. The most gentle criticism is they handed the biggest franchise in the world to someone who they regarded as promising. I'm not letting a promising student driver handle my porsche.

  • @dcbooker2020
    @dcbooker2020 Před měsícem +87

    More like RIP 1977-2012.😢

    • @TheMaskGamer2007
      @TheMaskGamer2007 Před měsícem +2

      Actually, they had Phineas and ferb Starwars, and that was released in 2014, and it was good. So, it died in 2015 when the Sequels were made.

    • @somepersonskywalking
      @somepersonskywalking Před měsícem +2

      Well the Mandalorian season 2 was probably the last and best Disney project regarding Star Wars. It’s a bit more complicated than that. But I get what you’re saying.

    • @original2k
      @original2k Před měsícem +2

      I thought putting -2024 on the grave stone was quite generous as well lol

    • @Snake-ms7sj
      @Snake-ms7sj Před měsícem +2

      3 of the biggest Sci Fi franchises have died. Star Wars, Star Trek & Dr. Who. All garbage now.

    • @MBStrat88
      @MBStrat88 Před měsícem

      Very True!

  • @VSMOKE1
    @VSMOKE1 Před měsícem +4

    I definitely didn't picture snarky taking off that dress and burning it definitely not😂😮

  • @PHIllip324
    @PHIllip324 Před měsícem +3

    The ONLY thing that can save Star Wars is to give it the Old Yeller treatment.

  • @Thee_Comic_Book_Guy
    @Thee_Comic_Book_Guy Před měsícem +11

    Remember not to be so much in a blind fit of rage that you forget to take the dress off, BEFORE you lite it on fire. 😅
    Great vid as always.

  • @dereklopez9060
    @dereklopez9060 Před měsícem +54

    At this point, Star Wars is beyond saving. As long as it's in the hands of these lunatics at Lucasfilm.

    • @nexus_of_a_crisis
      @nexus_of_a_crisis Před měsícem

      And George's caveat to the deal is that Kennedy cannot be fired. The only way she'd have to go is if 'Lucasfilm' was sold again, with the caveat that's she's fired on the spot.

  • @starshineraiser6729
    @starshineraiser6729 Před měsícem +1

    Gurl, that dress was on fire the moment you tried it on.
    I hope I’m not the 25th person to state this. Also, you’re right, they can’t tell us we’re wrong for our opinion. I’m technically a member of their identity umbrella and I can’t stand what they’re doing. People like you, Disparu, the Drinker, you’re all spot on.

  • @Vic-RR
    @Vic-RR Před měsícem +2

    Yesterday I talk with my friend about this same topic. We’re planning to do our own video giving our thoughts as well. We love Star Wars too but now it has been so complicated to be a fan now a days, we all want to give our opinions good or bad to the story but can’t without getting called our or bullied pretty much. I appreciate your thoughts and opinions on this topic because it’s something that needs to long said. Keep up the good work. Let’s enjoy the times again were we all had fun talking about Star Wars and creating impactful stories.

  • @rafaelarruda5472
    @rafaelarruda5472 Před měsícem +23

    This is a clear example of the concept of the "postmodern parasite," as explained by the Canadian theorist Jonathan Pageau. According to this theory, the postmodern parasite does not create anything new but instead replaces or destroy existing elements, using established characters and stories to convey ideological messages.

    • @kaveiros75
      @kaveiros75 Před měsícem

      The plague of sequels/prequels?

    • @indalot8315
      @indalot8315 Před měsícem +2

      "The Shadow that bred them can only mock, it cannot make: not real new things of its own. I don't think it gave life to the orcs, it only ruined them and twisted them"
      Sounds similar to Tolkien's line in Return of the King

    • @faustomadebr
      @faustomadebr Před měsícem

      Exactly. A lot of people still thinking it is only "woke stuff", but it is a cultural war and they want to destroy the west values.

  • @augustoamador7582
    @augustoamador7582 Před měsícem +18

    I vote that only Gilroy should be allowed to create Star Wars shows.

    • @temetnosce2099
      @temetnosce2099 Před měsícem

      I’m worried about Andor season 2. Is Disney going to get more involved and ruin that too?

  • @cheapaudioman
    @cheapaudioman Před měsícem +1

    One of the most positive things about the decline of modern Star Wars is the creators that have benefited from it. I love to see people succeed on CZcams and having voices like yours willing to be critical of truly subpar content is what will drive change. It's amazing to me to see the channels that are becoming powerful media outlets. At some point there has to be a tipping point and without your channel, Nerdrotic, Drinker, and many others it probably wouldn't change. Channels are making real money and Star Wars's spiral has been a watershed moment for so many. Keep being you. So happy to see your success.

  • @TheEudaimonya
    @TheEudaimonya Před měsícem +1

    Now Headland is talking about bringing back two "fan favorite Acolyte characters": Yord and Padawan Jecki. I wasn't aware Acolyte had fans 😂

  • @JohnnyFibe
    @JohnnyFibe Před měsícem +7

    The Acolyte feels like an inside joke i dont wanna know.

  • @TheGavinator2024
    @TheGavinator2024 Před měsícem +5

    Enjoyed watching you with Theory chat about all things Star Wars and Star Warts (Disney +). Keep up the great work!

  • @izzyarland5304
    @izzyarland5304 Před měsícem +1

    You're extremely accomplished and competent for someone who's been on this world for fewer years than I've been playing Half-Life 🥰

  • @nicklimberis9488
    @nicklimberis9488 Před měsícem +1

    Hi Snarky. Yes, I think it all makes sense. Story telling is key. Another tip is, to take more time crafting each story. Really let characters and their journey's incubate. Not so sure about the story group's effectiveness in all of this. Perhaps spend a year or so mapping out the Star Wars eras and connectimng key moments from the formation of the Sith and Jedi to today. Perhaps have a pretty complete history blueprint detailing key events, key characters and a geanology? Geonalagy? Family Tree thingy. I also think a solid "precepts and principles" platform is needed. Like a style guide for creators, detailing key values the work stands for. Ie - it stands for a few items, not least of which is good vs bad. Right vs Wrong. The power of second chances and redemption. The bond inherent in family etc etc. The Force needs tio be really clarified and understood too. Anyway, maybe I should make my own video. Good work. I do love watching and listening to your streams. I'm new. Oh btw - The dress is awesome..Don't burn it ;)

  • @rbrucerye
    @rbrucerye Před měsícem +6

    "So this is how quality dies ... with cult like applause."

  • @mrbill4206
    @mrbill4206 Před měsícem +3

    I think they could have saved Star Wars if at the end of the film where Luke dies, instead, they had had him show up physically and demolish the imperials.
    Then he would take Mary Sue as his padawan and carry on in sequels.
    Luke would sell millions of tickets .

  • @inquisitoradrianicus
    @inquisitoradrianicus Před měsícem +1

    I caught you on the Star Wars Theory stream with Drunk 3PO. You definitely have great insights and a sense of humour. I instantly subscribed and am enjoying your older videos. Keep up the great work and don't let the haters get you down.

  • @honkyvanwildebeest8926
    @honkyvanwildebeest8926 Před měsícem +1

    $180 million for Lesley Hedland to work out her personal issues using human sock-puppets and interpretive dance. Now this is a REAL vanity project!

  • @LWAC71
    @LWAC71 Před měsícem +13

    P.S. Nice look on Star Wars Theory yesterday. I agree, you should consider live streaming on YT once in a while. This space loves you...One!

  • @dennismoore1116
    @dennismoore1116 Před měsícem +3

    The thing about Iger, if the stories were just pretty good the quantity would have increased the profits. Quantity might be a bit much due to greed, but the issue actually has nothing to do with the way they've approached things being hostile to the fan base.

    • @nexus_of_a_crisis
      @nexus_of_a_crisis Před měsícem

      He's running out of time to blame everything on Chapek.

  • @matthewbaumgardner8922

    My first memory is seeing Star Wars in theaters with my Dad, I don't even recognize what it's become

  • @TheManInBlueFlames
    @TheManInBlueFlames Před měsícem +3

    Can someone PLEASE explain why some Star Wars channels like ‘Star Wars Explained’ are STILL defending this shit?! Alex from that channel, like Theory, is a ‘Star Wars Expert’ but is still defending the lore changes and bad storytelling. How?! At least Grace Randolph didn’t like the last episode. However, in my opinion, Disney should have never had the rights to it!

  • @alec7364
    @alec7364 Před měsícem +7

    I think any company can only make a limited number of mistakes before they loose all trust from their consumers, I think Disney has crossed over that threshold

  • @mattseman5682
    @mattseman5682 Před měsícem +4

    I've been a fan of Star Wars for the 30 years I've been alive. Comics, books, videogames - before the Disney buyout, and even some after I've come to enjoy. I was watching the OT as as toddler, and my mom still laughs about me wearing out the VHSes Acolyte has single-handedly made me want to turn my back on the ENTIRE franchise, not only because it's so horrible, but because of the response to true criticisms. I no longer know if I've angry, or just don't care anymore.
    I kinda hope Disney doesn't sell the franchise, because I want them to rot with the fact that they killed what used to be the largest franchise in pop culture. And even if they did sell, I don't think I'd get back into Star Wars.

    • @Mormegil452
      @Mormegil452 Před měsícem

      I turned my back on the franchise after the Last Jedi.

  • @AquariumStoreDepot
    @AquariumStoreDepot Před měsícem +1

    Making a series about Star Wars legends would save everything

  • @hexmachine8263
    @hexmachine8263 Před měsícem

    Yeah I'm an 80s kid grew up with star wars movie's, toys, comics, books the works. I love old star wars so much, but I can't take it anymore. Recently me, and my son have gotten into Gundam. It has a rich story that spans multiple shows, and movies, and since getting into it we like it so much we're building the model kits now instead of spending money on Disney star wars junk.

  • @NickNapoli
    @NickNapoli Před měsícem +46

    The only way Star Wars can be saved in my opinion is you fire everyone at Lucasfilm, someone or a group buys it off Disney, restores Cannon, opens up LucasArts again and leaves the franchise alone for 15 years.

    • @badlaamaurukehu
      @badlaamaurukehu Před měsícem +4

      And wait 25 years. It'll take at least a generation to draw back anyone with an actual attention span.

    • @DavidSmith-mt7tb
      @DavidSmith-mt7tb Před měsícem +1

      maybe it becomes so unprofitable Disney lets it die and then years after that after Iger is gone, someone offers a lot for it even though it's practically worthless now, and spends years working on a killer strategy to revive it right and makes that money back.

    • @petriew2018
      @petriew2018 Před měsícem

      @@badlaamaurukehu in fairness all it'll take is one legitimately good movie that gets the plot back on rails
      unfortunately this means basically memory holing everything Disney's released save maybe Rogue One/Andor, so the collective ego at Disney won't allow that to ever happen...

  • @MarcBossYT
    @MarcBossYT Před měsícem +3

    Guys I think we all need to band together and create fan films 😂

  • @kenmrock9334
    @kenmrock9334 Před měsícem

    Every word of yours is pure gold. I haven’t watched SW since the end of Ray SW. I don’t plan on watching it again.

  • @c1ph3rpunk
    @c1ph3rpunk Před měsícem

    Spaceballs 2: Revenge of the Helmet
    Please.
    I wish I had $200M to make a SW parody right now. Soooo much material to work from, it’d be epic I say. Epic!

  • @madhattersc4051
    @madhattersc4051 Před měsícem +35

    Dear Disney, please listen to this girl. Look past the eye candy and your immediate desire to dismiss her because of her appearance and actually listen to this young woman. She really has nailed it. She cannot be much more on the nose with her assessment. Just write good stories, stop worrying about platforms. It’s ok to provide opportunities for representation, but it shouldn’t be the primary goal.
    Story, Story, Story… then whatever else.

    • @dariusthegreat3097
      @dariusthegreat3097 Před měsícem +5

      "Look past the eye candy".........................It's so hard though........😔

    • @blast3613
      @blast3613 Před měsícem +4

      @@dariusthegreat3097 "It's so hard" Lol.

  • @AdamDust
    @AdamDust Před měsícem +4

    Going from remembering the Return of the Jedi hype to enduring the Star Wars drought to the excitement of the 97' rerelease and the prequels just to see it all crumble,this sucks

  • @davidsuriyakulpanich2193
    @davidsuriyakulpanich2193 Před měsícem

    "transforms it into something you don't recognize".... yep

  • @darthcheeseburger
    @darthcheeseburger Před měsícem +1

    Damn, this is honestly one of the most honest and truthful reviews of new SW. Right on Jay. Also that Boba dress....fuck sake!

  • @justafanofnerdculture7602
    @justafanofnerdculture7602 Před měsícem +5

    Unfortunately, we all knew that Disney wouldn't do right by Star Wars. 😔

    • @skepticalsmurf
      @skepticalsmurf Před měsícem +1

      when they acquired Marvel and Star Wars,I thought the worse that would happen was that some characters would break out into song...

  • @queelude9
    @queelude9 Před měsícem +4

    if they let someone competent do a Starkiller show with Sam Witwer I would come back.

  • @wr1483
    @wr1483 Před měsícem +2

    The best stories are now "Legends"...

  • @Myke...
    @Myke... Před měsícem

    We are seeing a lot of big companies doing such things to subscribers, fans, community etc. They get so big and forget why they are doing it, and pay attention to shareholders more. It set up to milk the cow...

  • @daveblackman816
    @daveblackman816 Před měsícem +6

    Idk if it’s true, but Disney can’t make as much money off the legacy characters so they have to create their own. I just don’t understand what they’re doing to ruin such an iconic brand:

    • @dereklopez9060
      @dereklopez9060 Před měsícem +1

      At this point, there's nothing to understand. They're just intentionally ruining the brand by sheer incompetence, horrible writing, character butchering, canon breaking, wasting every potential for anything special, and so on. And then, blaming the fans for their own failures. Isn't it funny how they claimed we're threatened by female leads and diverse cast, when Rogue One, Andor, House Of The Dragon, Cobra Kai had really high scores by the audience?
      And then they call us racist time and again, when they were the ones who shrunk Finn in the Chinese poster of TFA and they made his character into a bumbling joke.

  • @clonearmy77
    @clonearmy77 Před měsícem +6

    Disney cleaning house will probably mean anywhere from 90-95% of people in their "entertainment" crew..."let go"...and I just don't see that happening.

    • @monkeybusiness673
      @monkeybusiness673 Před měsícem

      Well, they often do a little "spring cleaning"...Mostly by firing their marketing departments. Because these guys are clearly at fault for something as atrocious as The Acolyte failing 🤣

    • @clonearmy77
      @clonearmy77 Před měsícem

      @@monkeybusiness673 Yeah, but with them talking about doing a season 2, it is showing that Disney SW is not worth holding onto anymore. They're going to keep doing what they're doing until they have no money left, or the shareholders get together to put a stop to this. Unless the shareholders are also ok with losing money?

    • @monkeybusiness673
      @monkeybusiness673 Před měsícem

      @@clonearmy77 I saw someone break down some numbers, but I can't for the life of me remember where. According to this, Disney made barely a quarter of their 4 billion dollar investment back in 12 years. Which is abysmal! And yet Disney Lucasfilm is a small portion of their entire brand, and so losing money does not seem to impact things much. I wouldn't hold my breath for shareholders stepping in anytime soon. Which is really the worst part, because why would you EVER be okay with losing any amount of money?! As you said: Star Wars is dead! And I am glad I own all the good stuff on DVD, so I can watch it at my leasure.

  • @user-cs3gh2vs7z
    @user-cs3gh2vs7z Před měsícem +1

    Snarky, you 100% nailed it!

  • @Darth_Mornabin
    @Darth_Mornabin Před měsícem

    One thing I believe many fans don‘t think much about: The audience outside the fandom is way bigger than the fandom itself.
    And these people are just watching the new Star Wars-show because … it has Star Wars in the title. But these people don‘t go online, they don‘t chat with other people about the shows, etc. They have no ideas about the discussions online.
    So even if Lucasfilm would be antagonizing some parts of the fandom … There is always a way bigger target group, which will probably always watch the mayor Star Wars-productions no matter what.

  • @TaxmanTV
    @TaxmanTV Před měsícem +5

    Just brilliant miss Jay. I could not fathom a more effective & well spoken speech that champions all the OG SW fans like you just did here. I salute you. There is no defeat.. only victory and revenge. We will get our salvation.. someday.

  • @AzraelStDumas1982
    @AzraelStDumas1982 Před měsícem +3

    Hiiii Jay!!! 👋 😄 enjoyed your stream with Theory and Drunk Jay great job!! The Snarkmeister moving up in YT world yaaaay!! 👍🤙

  • @justuswarren8965
    @justuswarren8965 Před měsícem +1

    Star Wars is not dead
    As long as there's originals, prequels, in fact all the good ones in the past that we love and enjoy, we'll live through those

  • @Jab-Cajun91
    @Jab-Cajun91 Před měsícem +1

    Marvel has been stacking some wins with X-Men ‘97 and Deadpool & Wolverine (presale ticket sales and early screening reviews). Pixar just restored the box office with Inside Out 2 making one $1.4B WW. Star Wars is the only one that needs to get their shit together badly.

  • @mjohnsen8606
    @mjohnsen8606 Před měsícem +3

    As drastic as it is, Star Wars needs a total reboot. There are too many timelines to keep track of right now, and for better or worse the main characters of the IP are Han, Luke, and Leia.

  • @dragonray9450
    @dragonray9450 Před měsícem +13

    I was 10 years old in 77' when I saw Star Wars and I have been a fan ever since, I have just given up on Star Wars and Disney as a company...why can't they write stories that entertain us oldheads as well as the youth of today? The formula that makes up Star Wars is timeless and transcends age.

    • @LaraA55
      @LaraA55 Před měsícem +3

      I was 9 years old. I completely agree with you🤗

    • @kenb2671
      @kenb2671 Před měsícem +2

      I was 7 and I agree with you wholeheartedly.👍🏾🇺🇸🇺🇸

    • @dragonray9450
      @dragonray9450 Před měsícem

      @@LaraA55 I wouldn't trade my youth for anything these young folks have today. ")

    • @LaraA55
      @LaraA55 Před měsícem +1

      @@dragonray9450 I am so with you 👍

  • @benzz4960
    @benzz4960 Před měsícem

    It took you a while, but you have finally grown up. Well done you

  • @helenconnell5195
    @helenconnell5195 Před měsícem

    The stories have already been written, a long time ago, at the time of the original series in the form of really wonderful books, full of imagination, optimism, beauty and a completely different direction to Disney's. And each book needed to fit into the story but add to it. Would be amazing if they could be brought to life as movies.

  • @dreadedotaku1860
    @dreadedotaku1860 Před měsícem +5

    Hey Jay loved the collab with Theory hoping for more in the future.

  • @thestarisalie
    @thestarisalie Před měsícem +4

    Its my favorite dress too.
    My gawd.

  • @patrickwhite4449
    @patrickwhite4449 Před měsícem

    On a Disney SEC form showing their plans for the future and stuff like that it says “you cannot ‘restore the magic’ if you do not understand the magic” how did they forget that so quick? And when are they gonna go back to understanding the materiel they are working with and the audiences it is made for?

  • @donkzy2406
    @donkzy2406 Před měsícem +1

    Yup they destroyed our IP. Wish they'd have made their own IP for the message, we would not have cared. We not racist, sexist, bigots. Just fan who used to love Star Wars. A crazy world we live in

  • @tonymarino8
    @tonymarino8 Před měsícem +4

    SnarkyJay is a goddess. Smart, funny, sassy, and a complete nerd. I don't care if you call me a simp, Jay is a diamond. Rare and priceless. If you dont agree, you're blind af. Js.

  • @davidlutz2242
    @davidlutz2242 Před měsícem +6

    Not for me, I'm afraid I've been pushed away and been told they don't want my money so often that now they'll never see a penny again.

  • @Alexcarter27
    @Alexcarter27 Před měsícem

    At this rate if I want my Star Wars fix, I just go back and play the old Star Wars games like OG Battlefront 1 and 2, Bounty Hunter, Republic Commando and the KOTOR games. Ironically it's these games as well as others that serve to remind us how much better things were back then before Disney took over. Another piece of Irony is that right now, Disney are the ones mostly supporting and helping to prop up the Playstation Plus Classics collection by releasing past games such as Star Wars Demolition, Episode 1 The Phantom Menace, and Attack of the Clones. if Disney really wants to Revive people's love for Star Wars they should look at how the aforementioned games helped to expand the existing lore and told interesting stories about existing and new characters.

  • @fakshen1973
    @fakshen1973 Před měsícem +2

    The OG Star Wars fanbase are over 50. The fans that followed in the 80's are, at best, not much younger. Star Wars covers 4 generations of fans. Disney doesn't serve any of them.

  • @afropunkx
    @afropunkx Před měsícem +6

    Acolyte is so bad we don’t get a walk up.

  • @jamisonjamisonx
    @jamisonjamisonx Před měsícem +6

    I used to feel like I had to at least watch everything star wars that was released...but now, it's easy to skip watching anything disney puts out and I don't feel like I'm missing anything.

  • @TeeVeesGreatest
    @TeeVeesGreatest Před měsícem

    I've been a 65 year old Star Wars fan since I first saw it in 1977 in the pouring rain here in NZ. I'm so upset by what Doseny- has done to one of the most important franchises in my life.
    I've been collecting SW Merch since 1978. But no more! I'm going to save SO much money now! I've been forced to pirate the OT and PT movies, so now I can get rid of Doseny- and save even more money, but sadly, I will place myself on the copyright FBI train.
    But that's ok; when I'm arrested, I can just say, "Disney made me do it!".
    George, why did you sell it? You didn't need the money, I think you did it to prove Hollywood stinks. But we all knew that. You must be laughing like hell, over there at Skywalker Ranch. But surely, very deep down, you must be so upset (like us) with what they did to your baby. We, the Star Wars fan base, all feel violated, cheated, and betrayed.
    But I guess that's the Woke agenda: to be negatively corporate, with liberal hegemony, that they see as wholly performative and helpful to overthrowing capitalism and instituting a more egalitarian society, destroying family, the church, and individualism, and bring about the swing to a Communist, evil, anti-norm, overly politically correct, and the destruction of free speech and creativity.
    Good on you, Doseny; you're doing your bit.

  • @Robert_H_Diver
    @Robert_H_Diver Před měsícem

    You’re 100% correct, although I think Iger is a part of the problem. He could have cleaned house already but hasn’t.

  • @shaynecameron6781
    @shaynecameron6781 Před měsícem +11

    Declare all Disney Star Wars previous to be an alternate universe, recast the original roles, and make movies from the Thrawn Trilogy by Timothy Zahn.

    • @davidstewart5896
      @davidstewart5896 Před měsícem

      Save Clone Wars Season 7, Episode 9 - 12. Actually go and make those 4 episodes into a movie and release to theater.

    • @gregwasserman2635
      @gregwasserman2635 Před měsícem

      Um...no!!! No, no, no! Tim Zahn is a hack!!!

    • @Osprey850
      @Osprey850 Před měsícem +1

      I recently read the Thrawn trilogy and had the very same thought, that it could be the way to save Star Wars. Re-casting the roles would be controversial, but I think that fans are so tired of the direction that SW is going in and would warm up to the chance to see new adventures with their favorite characters in their primes again and finally get the sequel trilogy that they've always wanted. Then, afterwards, they could get another 25 years out of those actors playing those roles. That said, current Disney would totally screw such a rebuild up, but, hypothetically, with the right people overseeing Star Wars, it could work, I think.

  • @GiratinasRisingRenegades
    @GiratinasRisingRenegades Před měsícem +4

    My suggestion is to get rid of Blackrock, Vanguard, CIA (or just those who are enabling the ego machine) along with Apple and the regimes over at Disney an WBD.

  • @neuro.weaver
    @neuro.weaver Před měsícem

    Your Boba Fett dress is already on fire!

  • @4Xscalper
    @4Xscalper Před měsícem

    I've watched Rogue One twice and Andor again since ditching the acolyte. That has kept me sane.

  • @ericdanner8799
    @ericdanner8799 Před měsícem +3

    What Star Wars needs is it's equivalent to what Deadpool has with Ryan Reynolds, someone who actually knows and loves the IP. It's too bad Ryan isn't much of a Star Wars fan. “[Star Wars] would be a real hard thing to say no to,” he added, “but honestly - I’m not making this up - it’s not something I’ve ever thought of.”

  • @artfuldp1669
    @artfuldp1669 Před měsícem +4

    Unfortunately my anger has turned to apathy by now, the worst fate any show can suffer. Unless they put you in charge then I'll give it another chance 🤟😎

  • @mudbutton2
    @mudbutton2 Před měsícem

    Glad I was a kid in the Golden Age of SW in the 70's and 70's. Got my original Luke Skywalker watching me type this. :)

  • @SkydivingKiwi
    @SkydivingKiwi Před měsícem

    Jay, it's super cool to see your analysis from a psychology perspective. Reviewing episodes of shows everybody know is shit is boring. Distilling the crap like this is awesome. Keep it up 🤘