FIRST TIME WATCHING * Dune: Part Two * MOVIE REACTION!!
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
- THIS MOVIE MADE ME TAKE MY SHIRT OFF.!! Honestly from minute one I had goosebumps, one of the greatest movies ever made!!
Hope you guys enjoy our Movie Reaction to DUNE PART 2!!
#reaction #movie #review
Directed by : Denis Villeneuve
Stars : Timothée Chalamet , Rebecca Ferguson , Zendaya , Josh Brolin , Javier Bardem , Austin Butler , Florence Pugh
Watch THE FULL REACTION ON PATREON : / justtrustash
HANNAH’S NEW CHANNEL : / @donttrusthannah
Join The DISCORD ASHOLE ARMY : / discord
Add me on Instagram: @ashkanjavdani / @hannahlaresasmith
BUSINESS EMAIL : ASHKANJAVDANI@YAHOO.COM
Original Video : Dune: Part two (2024)
ABOUT MY CHANNEL:
YES MATE! I'm Ashkan Javdani , a fellow film nerd, Anime Fan, Netflix Addict who's probably gonna save you lot of time, money and arguments by finding you the right movies and shows. Trust me I GOT YOU. I also React to Some of the Most people shows, Trailer and try my hardest to Entertain you guys by ACTUALLY reacting and hopefully entertaining you guys…I love you and ENJOY!!!!
FAIR USE:
• Images used in this video are under fair use and are copyright material of their respective owners.
• Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use - Krátké a kreslené filmy
"He sounds like an evil Elvis" ASH HE PLAYED ELVIS LMFAO!
Austin Butler has even addressed the difficulty he's had shaking the accent after working on it for so long.
He worked with a voice coach to make him sound like stellar skarsgard
The symbolism!!
No, he sounds like...The Batman.
Elvis Presley after one week in Eastern Europe
😶MFW I realise theres people in this world who experience the dune movies through a single airpod.
ikr..
i would recomend them to buy each rather than split in to half.
Watchin film with half of it, just feels like something is missing..
Or the reactors that watch on a laptop...
I just wish they would shut the f up and pay attention.
I think they do that so it's easier to hear each other
They need full on headphones for this movie.
Hannah calling Christopher Walken 'Christopher Nolan' had me creasing
Florence Poo 😂
lol she corrected it to Christoph Waltz. still not quite there haha. Florence Poo is spot on however.
And then called him Christoph Waltz
Stilgar: Don't EVER listen to the Gin
Hannah: I say that to myself a lot but I don't think we're talking about the same Gin...
😂😂🤣
Djinn sounds exactly like Gin... For all the little weird things the English language can do for phonetic disambiguation, alas, it falls short at the right moment for some laughs. Hannah really did make that joke shine!
There's a difference in "Jin" and "Gin" :D
@@saiien2
No there isn’t. They are phonetically the same.
@@roems6396Depends who’s saying it, really.
@@fosterbennington6405
No it doesn’t. They are pronounced the same. The D is silent.
you are not getting the full effect of the Voice wearing a single AirPod, in theater the voice was unreal
I thought the single AirPod is just for the mic and then speakers on the tv?
@@chrisherber1635 They have a big ass microphone in from of them.
"We have all the moisture we need in that girl right now, if they were to drain her now, they'd fill the whole lake up". Shout out to Hannah for the quote of the year 24:52 😅😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Absolute champion.
As it is written
"He sounds like evil Elvis." The guy literally played Elvis looool
Is there a good Elvis?
@@traydevon his stillborn twin brother
33:05
"I wrote the Dune series because I had this idea that charismatic leaders ought to come with a warning label on their forehead: "May be dangerous to your health." (Frank Herbert, author of "Dune")
In other words, Frank Herbert is the Emperor.
@@TheGavrael More a God-Emporer!
@@TheGavrael Definitely way more than his son, Brian Herbert, LOL.
It's impressive how that early into oil interventionism, Herbert absolutely nailed the commentary in a way that gets more relevant and poignant every year.
Much more effective than Lucas' attempt to lampoon the Vietnam War.
in reality he stole most of the book from the book the Sabres of Paradise. sometimes even word for word
My favorite actors, Christopher Nolan and Florence Poo.
😂😂😂
Lmfao 😂
Austin Butler’s portrayal as Feyd is the best yet
He gave Feyd Rhauta a very personal touch: it was his idea to speak like Baron Vladimir, since his character had been raised by his uncle and the second kiss between them had not been scripted.
100% in agreement. Was shocked by Mr. Butler acting. The young man has a great future in front of him.
Excellent movie.
In Masters of the Air he was phenomenal too ;)
Far better than Sting
That third guy Atriedes that fought against Feyd wasn't just an average soldier, he was "Lieutenand Lanville" the one Duncan called to after getting off his ship in Dune 1, and the one that said "Shields!" to all the Atreides soldiers when they were about to step foot on Dune off the ship, and the one that warned that they needed to shield the doors because the sun was rising too much. But..... he was also the fight and stunt co-ordinator on the crew. Dude is a real badass and I love that he got a role in the movies.
His name is Roger Yuan; he's worked on a number of films including Skyfall, Batman Begins and John Wick 3, and he's had cameos in a bunch of the films he also did fight choreography or stunts on.
He dreamed that Chani killed him but really it was just "symbolism" for himself dying and being reborn as one of them.
it could be taken as symbolism but Paul "predicting" the future is hardly magic. Its like mentat but whole new level. He's calculating everything and so he can "predict" what's going to happen. That's why it was said that he needs to see the past to see the future. You need X and Y to know what's going to happen in Z.
It's one of the possibilities he was seeing at that moment when he doesn't have X and only have Y. This also avoid the most common used BS in time-travelling movies. Paul doesnt know the future, his brain is calculating possibilities and everytime he meets a new person or encounter an unexpected something the calculus changes.
For example, If paul an jessica were able to fully walk on the desert without attracting the worm Jamis would've believe in him and he would still be alive.
To be fair, Paul is doing all this for survival (the visions have showed him there is only one way out of there situation as victors and alive) Imagine you have lived a thousand lives, that's what Paul basically went through. He loves Chani but if he stays, its game over for everyone he loves. Chani's POV and anger is totally valid, but there is no other choice.
its not valid at all, its incredibly selfish. shes only thinking of herself and nothing else.
@parlyramyar Paul's word: "she will come to understand... i have seen it" meaning its a shock for her right now but maybe later she will get it, as the consequences unfold. But let's not forget she has great wisdom and her anger is probably foreshadowing something big. ;)
She will understand
@@skullbm8827In the book she understood immediately. In Fremen culture it's normal for leaders to have many wives; and Paul tells her straightup "You're my woman--she's just a contract" and Chani's like "let's go to war"
when paul drank the water of life he gained access to the other memories of all his ancestors back to the begining of time itself, so billions of lifetimes
Ash cumming in his pants about a story that is a cautionary take about absolute power is so on brand for him. Him slapping his chest and saying he'd be ready to go to war is literally what Frank Herbert warned us about! Terrifying really.
I watched this in the cinema and I was being drawn to Paul's charisma, I saw myself fighting for him and I had to remind myself that it's a cautionary tale, lol... However, I also realized that the throne was either going to Paul or to Feyd Rautha and in this situation, who are we supposed to choose?... People say that we should be cautious of Paul, but the alternative is way worse.
Have you seen his other videos? HE'S always like that 🤣
It’s his Iranian coming out. 😂 But in all seriousness, it’s not that deep lmao - at this point it’s ambiguous what the full panoply of possible futures is, so we’re just reacting to Paul seizing the mantle with emphasis. It’s not some elaborate value judgment…
@@AngkatanNamwaran it's an interesting question you pose because that alternative is never really discussed in the books. You say it would be worse? I'm not so sure. The harkonnens would certainly brutally subjugate arrakis and revel in the power of God emperor's of the known universe... But would they go as far as Paul and his children do? Paul's legacy is basically ethnic and religious cleansing, on a universal scale by fundamentalist lunatics. We will never know the harkonnens outcome. But the fact that it takes an entire star system over 10 thousand years to recover from Paul says a lot.
@@Hagg-o-tron However, Paul was burdened with knowledge, he could see the future and he took the path that the thought was necessary to ensure the survival of humanity. He didn't just kill for sport. For me, it's just a very complicated situation.
I get mad when reactors talk over the movie but you guys are actually funny and understood the movie very well. More reactors like you guys is what we need. The guy is very hyped (dude literally made me get hyped too even tho i already watched the movie lol)
I love theem...samurai shamplo
If this is your first reaction to them bro u needa watch the jack ass ones 😂. Or just go down the line with horror he's always like that
@@sensaiuriah5440 Will do later 😂
The moment dude took his shirt off and went "Les Lac du Connemara" with it.
This dude is ready to give his Life for Lisan-al-gaib
No good guy is ALL good. No Bad Guy is ALL bad. That's just one of the things that makes this story one of the most amazing ever written. Take away all the fantastic sci-fi, and you have an incredible human-piece that is more honest about the beauty and ugliness of humanity than almost any other story.
Imagine giving aliens these dune movies and they think it's real like a galaxy quest type scenario 😂. I wonder what they'll ask or do .
And this is why Dune will continue to resonate with people decades, generations, from now. Frank Herbert wrote the book integrating every "ecological" aspects of Humanity and these, religion, fanatism, politics, culture, economics, etc., are never all black or all white. It's infintely more true to reality than other popular tropes.
the reason Paul asked for the princess was because he can be legitimised as a ruler through marriage he loves Chani, but he has to marry the princess to bring stability and to keep his promises.
Yup and in the book chani is totally with Paul and on his side.
@@kevinmatthew1050 the books go in far deeper, we also don't really get much of the spacing guild, the Fremen technology, I must admit Chani is very different I hope it is to emphasise the point of being wary of "saviours' and "leaders" and not just girl boss because.
@@kevinmatthew1050 yeah in the movie shew portrayed as selfish and only thinks about her own happiness
@@parlyramyar yea exactly. That didn't bother me that much though to be honest..movie to me was still incredible.
@@parlyramyarshe didn’t seem very selfish it’s pretty realistic she’d feel heartbreak and seeing Paul change but she still accepted it
Mom is NOT evil. Remember when Leto in part I asked her to protect Paul and he told her he was not asking his mom, he was asking the Bene Gesserit?. Jessica is literally keeping her promise to Leto. By doing what she is doing, she is protecting Paul in a way she would have not been able to as just a mother.
It’s more nuanced than that. She’s not just protecting him I mean let’s be real she wanted him to be the kwisarz haderach. Also regardless if your motivations the way you go about something still matters and causing a war that will results in the deaths of billions across space is obviously inexcusable.
@@samrogers5090 i mean, thats what mothers do, no? anyone except their kids
@@samrogers5090 It is more nuanced than that. You are laying out a more simplified version of my comment.
@@zackfozzy7506 Exactly. Mothers know no bounds on what they would do to protect their kids.
@@di3486 the nuance is that she’s a complicated character she’s not necessarily evil but she’s not “just being a good mother”. I think it’s fairly reductive to excuse the crazy shit she does. If you were actually looking at this as legit history you would anaglyze her actions differently. She helps put a war into gear that kills billions. And not unknowingly.
There's only 1 path forward for victory. Some might say a "Golden Path".
Not even for victory, just for survival.
39:30 when they talk about Jessica's voice being "cringey" is so ironic. Watching the movie in theaters with acoustics is an entirely different experience than watching with 1 earpod in. The voice is perfect. The bass on it vibrates your whole body (in a theater).
the voice is one of the coolest things. so that makes me sad.
Ash is a little bit cringe so it’s okay
I agree with them that the Voice should change every time based on the context. The "old crone" voice is overused and out of place in a lot of scenes; it should be tailored differently for every person
I think what he meant was that jessica's voice is a bit cronky, others have a bit deep and impactful voice, her voice is kinda higher in pitch
100%
Hannah, you have the patience of a saint.
Ash would join a cult so easily 😂 the baby took on centuries of knowledge same as the mom.
I much prefer movie Chani to book Chani
I prefer book Chani
@@ReallyGoodandKind dude how? She isn’t even a character from what I recall she barely even speaks in the second book she’s not even a character she’s a plot device
@@ReallyGoodandKind Book Chani was just a yes-woman... She never questioned Paul's decisions.
@@AngkatanNamwaran She's not a yes woman, in fact it's the complete opposite. Paul is a yes man, he helps the Fremen/Chani/Liet Kynes achieve their life long dream of terraforming Arrakis into a paradise and expelling Landsraad occupation forever from their planet. People seem to conveniently ignore that. Chani knows Paul is the only chance their people have in order to terraform Arrakis. But Villeneuve changed her to love Arrakis the way it is, a desert planet where people constantly recycle and kill each other over water, in constant guerilla warfare with the Landsraad. Exploitation was mutual, there is a point in the book where Paul realizes it doesn't even matter if he dies because he's done his job and the Jihad will happen no matter what, Chani is there to make sure he fulfills the prophecy and be his support.
@@samrogers5090 It's not about how much she talks, she is a beautiful character who is the daughter of Liet Kynes, if Jessica failed and died during water of life ceremony she would take Jessica's place as Sayyadina. Just because she's not vocal doesn't mean she's not important, she plays a massive role in both her people's lives and Pauls lives, she's a humble servant to both. And somehow people seem to have an issue with that. Movie Chani is an alien among her own people, in fact she's part of the status quo and doesn't want there to be change, is highly emotional and incapable of grasping the bigger picture... the ending is testament to that because she's literally alone. NOw seems she is set up to be Paul's enemy in Messiah which is absolutely ridiculous and will break the entire story going forward.
When Paul tells Jessica he sees a narrow way through, there is a brief flash of him holding the knife in Feyd-Rautha. He knows he has to let Feyd stab him in order to win. He knows more or less exactly what he has to do at all times. That's why tells Gurney it is his burden - he knows precisely what he has to do, even if those things are morally horrible (like instigating a holy war), or physically painful for him, and failure to do those things has great consequences.
54:08 that's exactly what happens in the book, which was the only way he could become emperor, with Chani becoming his concubine, but she's still the one he loves, and she didn't run off, she stayed
They had to "feminist" it up, I guess. It makes sense what he chose to do, though. There are bigger things at play than simple romance.
@@ams914oh stop it. The whole dune series was anti religious anti dictatorship did you even read the books? It’s a total leftist series.
@@ams914nah I disagree I think it’s a good change because it makes it clearer to the audience that Paul is following the wrong path with the choices he’s making and they make this point with the I’ll be with you as long as you never change and in the end of course he changes so she leaves. It also makes sense that the fremen who rejects Paul as their messiah is the one who’s closest to them. There are movies to make that criticism for but when you do it for one as banging as this it makes the criticism lose its meaning. You’d be surprised how many reactions think Paul is still the hero far past when they should. Granted it’s clearer when you read the book but still.
@@ams914 that is not true. The reason they made it so was to cement the idea that charismatic leaders aren't all good and roses. And it worked.
@@samrogers5090 No one said it was wrong...But it's 100% had a feminist viewpoint inserted into it. Which is a shame really.
I’m convinced Ash is high on ⛷️ ❄️ because he was on 10 the entire reaction, didn’t stop talking or yelping. He is so extra and hyperactive like a toddler. 😂 My gawd how Hannah doesn’t have a headache I don’t understand.
Facts! Lol. Like damn, just watch the movie
Ngl I've been watching for yeaaaaars and I've never seen bro just hype for long periods like that 😂. His ahh popped a molly
@@sensaiuriah5440 I think its the rebound effect of adhd medication. When you have taken your last dose off the day and it wears off in the evening, you get hyper. it is a good idea to watch an exciting movie or do some yoga until you feel calm enough to go to bed.
Hannah's ready to call up the Harkonnen HR department.
"Don't listen to the gin." Words to live by.
Great reactions, guys. Ash became a fanatic for the Lisan-al-gaib, while Hannah saw through all the B.S. like Chani! Now go see it in the big screen! Saw it with my son in 4DX. When the grandfather worm appeared the theater started shaking like an earthquake was happening. When Paul rode the worm, my seat was bucking like a bronco trying to throw me off. It was smashing into my back. I needed a seatbelt. I reached for my son fearing for his safety. He was screaming with joy! We both let go of our seat, raised our arms and raised our feet off the floor. We rode the worm with Paul! The soundtrack was deafening beyond belief. The whole theater was shaking like it was going to tear itself apart. It was an unbelievable, exhilarating experience!
“Saw through bs like Chani”.
Tell me you never read the books without telling me
@@VDViktor based on how Villeneuve portrayed the characters.
You literally just made me want to watch it in a theater
@VDViktor it's not Hannah's fault that Denis changed the context of their relationship from the novel. I understand he wanted a cliffhanger, but I don't like it either.
@@VDViktor to be honest, Villeneuve made Chani's character a favor by making her a bit more interesting and deep than what she is in the book.
Ashkan going nuts from when Paul woke up from the water of life till the end of the movie was incredible. I felt like jumping out of my seat with him and screaming "Lisan Al-Gaib!" about 15 times.
The disrespect to this movie with only sound in one ear :(
Sharing AirPods is not the way
They will appreciate it a lot more when they sit down and actually watch parts one and two together. They've missed so much. It's a reaction you have to talk, but it's such a shame for them. The movies were amazing in IMAX.
@JackCarnes Real IMAX is definitely the way to see this.
Dude, seeing it in the theater was fuckin amazing. One of if not the best movies I've seen at the theater. Immediately wanted to go back and see it again after leaving.
I watched it on my home theather system (the TV is small but the sound system packs some serious punch) and was afraid my neighbours would object. Quite some subwoofer action in it.
Timothée Chalamet will DEFINITELY win an Oscar for that scene. Just watch. That scene is pure insanity.
This movie is going to sweep the Oscars. Best Lead, supporting, director, musical score, fucking on set janitor.
@JackCarnes considering the first movie got 6, I'm not expecting anything different this year 🤷♂️
He did well but no he didn't deserve an Oscar for it
Majority of the best scenes in this movie are his, he's so very good here. He and Denis gave me a movie experience I can't forget. The speech scene was insane I truly believed. Definitely deserve an Oscar for that, but they're not gonna give it to him. When it comes to male actors, the Oscars love to make them wait. If you're female though they'll give it to you early.
@@rkdwjddnr90 yeaaah you're probably right unfortunately :( the movie itself will probably get a few I just wish our boy Tim got one for himself because he truly is a special actor.
The speech scene, along with "LONG LIVE THE FIGHTERS" got me so hyped I was ready to go on a holy war for him
Remember his conversation with Jessica: 'Our enemies are all around us... I see a narrow path' This is the way
When you watch the movie, pay attention to his visions in that moment. He saw exactly how the fight had to go.
Thank you for mentioning Ash’s over the top theatrics.
"I'm giving you sacred spit!" Is a phrase ONLY ASH could come up with lmaooo. Even funnier.....that would probably be lore accurate!
The reason every one used bladed weapons is the shields. Bullets cannot pass through them because they move to fast, and lasers cause a nuclear reaction .
The Fremen though actually do use both bullet during guns and lasers because you should never wear or use a shield in the desert as they attract the Sandworms.
I saw Ash's comments on his community post a few weeks ago when they recorded the review to Dune2 and oh boy oh boy, apparently our boy Ash completely lost it, cant wait to witness it!
The thing you guys don't seem to be getting is that, Paul isn't going after the power of being Emperor because he wants it or is power-hungry. It's because, in order to achieve the capabilities needed to terraform Arrakis/Dune and turn it into the Green Paradise that the Fremen have been promised for so long, he needs to be Emperor to do so. The Holy War is basically just a stepping stone to get through to achieve that final goal.
I'm glad at least Hannah understands that Paul starting a Holy War is a bad thing.
It's a bad thing, but for an eventually good cause, no?
Like, thousands of years of pain and suffering, trillions dead, but at the end of it humanity will be better off. That's why Paul is doing it in the first place, it's the golden path. Paved with blood and bones.
But It's kind of the least bad option.Imagine if the Harkonnens had undercut the emperor like they planned! Or a bad man became Kwisatz Haderach. Even the Bene Geaserit who view humanty like a dog show breedee tryong to get a Pit-Doodle-triever-hua
@@SlowSlowSlothI've seen people reiterating that Paul started the holy war for the golden path and it's a good thing.
But there's a catch that people with similar opinions are forgetting. Paul DIDN'T go through with the golden path. He couldn't bring himself to do it. That's why someone else had to do it because Paul threw away all those lives just for revenge. He did see the path but he strayed from it.
Yeah way too many people get caught up in their love of Paul and miss the message of the story. Which is super ironic cause that was the point of it!
@@Tochi68 I think it's still the lesser evil compared to just letting the Harkonnens take over
"A bit of power." Hannah, he's the Emperor of the Known Universe now.
Anyway, fun video. If you haven't, check out "No Country for Old Men" starring Josh Brolin (Gurney) and Javier Bardem (Stilgar), and "ELVIS" starring Austin Butler (Feyd-Rautha).
I'd also like to recommend "Cloud Atlas," on a whim.
😂 Hannah, lovely, you deserve a fricking medal for how much you managed to pay attention with Ash going booloo next to you 😂 😂 just goes to show you're crazy sharp hun xx
Ash and Hannah are my two brain cells during the part with Paul becoming the Lisan al Gaib. One brain cell is telling me "Wow this is bad, he's becoming a bit of a tyrant, which is..." but it's drowned out by the second brain cell being absolutely in awe at the epicness of Paul, and singing along to the incredible music
Remember, Paul warned chani why he didn't want to go south.
But once he does go south. It's an unstoppable force.
It's also why he said he'll always love her. Right before he says he'll marry the princess.
Which is a strategic alliance. Chani is still his true love.
It's amazing to me how so few people pick up that this is the bad ending. The music literally tells you! It might just be me hearing the Harkonnen arena riff in the music later, but even if that riff isn't there, that is not 'yay, our heroes have gathered and it is now time to win this for the good guys' music. That is villain introduction music.
There is no good ending, every eventuality will lead to mass suffering. This isnt the bad ending, it is in fact the only way the human race can survive as it allows paul to have a son, Leto II. Humanity is about to embark on the golden path
And people say Americans are loud 😭😭😭
Funny that Ash keeps praising the director because has done Sicario aswell. Denis Villeneuve is an absolute genius filmmaker!
Friends we have witnessed history. Ash‘s bare-chested delirium is gonna down as an all-time classic in the reaction genre.
I laughed for a full minute when that happened :D
Yuck
If you listen to what he says after the monster energy drink, "I see a narrow clear path for our survival", he didn't do it for power, he took power to survive.
Denis Villeneuve the director said him and the composer Hanz Zimmer were both huge fans of the books and you can tell poured so much love into it. They did an awesome job staying true to Frank Herbert's themes in the novel. BEST MOVIE I'VE SEEN IN A LONG TIME!!!
I love your reactions Ash, but why you gotta bully Hannah so much to the point of pissing her off.
Cause he dim af
"Whoever this director is, you are a movie fan, you know, you love movies and you loves fans."
That would be Denis Villeneuve, and Dune is his favorite sci-fi book. Star Wars was inspired by Dune.
Plus the fact this is his 4th movie they have watched on this channel 🤦🏻♂️
Nah this is the funniest, most chaotic dune reaction so far
I actually love to watch people go through this story and change or dance around the perspective of Paul being the „good guy” during this journey. Wait till you learn what happened during Holy War…
I just want everyone to remember that our beloved Hannah is an incredible actress in her own right. Go watch her movies and support her career. If you think she’s a blast on these reaction videos, both with Ash, and on her own, you should see how incredible she is When she is performing a role in a film.
What are her films
IMDB….. she is listed. She is great.
@@YHShinVH Here's a direct answer to your question so you dont have to go on a scavenger hunt to find one of her movies like OP is suggesting. This is a trailer for one of her movies: czcams.com/video/A6dx1HslKNw/video.html
@@montysmegma4649
Just looking up "Hannah" on IMDB doesn't work.
whats her full name
For Hannah... Don't be mad. It wasn't FOR POWER. It was for the long term survival of the Fremen and far later down the road, humanity. Remember, this was the only path Paul could take to save both the Fremen AND Chani. He had to show the entire Imperial court that he was wanting to take Princess Irulan's hand to take control of the Imperium. And what makes this movie one of the greatest TRAGEDIES ever made was the sacrifice Paul had to make so that his loves (the Fremen and Chani) would survive. That's why he told Chani: "I will love you as long as I breathe." He knew the path and how it would affect her. BTW, this is different than the book. In the book, Chani understands that this is a show marriage.
For Ash... Embrace your Fremen nature. Ya-hya zhou hada!!!! Long Live The Fighters!!!
When ... WHEN ... they have Dune 2 in IMAX re-release, go see it in IMAX. Every time you see it in IMAX, it just gets better.
yes its onIy poIitics
I actually really enjoy the differences with Chani’s character - I haven’t read the books since high school but I remember her as someone who holds herself as a Fremen more than anything else. In the movies (so far), I feel like she’s presented as someone who obviously wants to aggrandize her people, but she is also a young woman going through the throes of love and devotion for the first time. You really see the juxtaposition of her decisions in the movies. Like, even if she knows why Paul is doing these things, she sees a darkness in it and in the way he makes her feel
I'm pretty sure she understands it in this also but this showed more her immediate visceral reaction to the reality of it. It's one thing to know something but quite another to experience it.
@@fxzero666 No, Hannah gave no indication that she understood it beyond what I said. You are making stuff up that you think she thought. She was still seething about how that whole scene went down after the movie credits rolled and you could tell it bothered her.
So I have no idea where you got that 'she understands it'. Hannah even says in the analysis: "you go against all this for power", "your girl, you did all this for a bit of power". So no, she didn't understand it.
I cannot tell you how much I love your intelligence, the both of you, and the purity and intensity of your emotions, and your dynamic together.
Best wishes for your happiness and success.
Watching Just Trust Ash reactions is one thing but watching Hannah reacting to Ash is whole layer of entertainment in these videos lmao... love it
60:00 I love you guys and you're always entertaining to watch, but if you had paid attention to what was said throughout the movie, you'd know that this is what Paul meant when he said he was afraid he'd lose her. This is the "narrow way through" he spoke of - the only way they all can survive. He is marrying the daughter of the emperor in order to gain the throne and eventually give Dune its green paradise. By *not* choosing his love, he is saving all of the Fremen, and giving *them* a better future. Meaning he is choosing the greater good over his own personal feelings, he is not going after power for a 'bad' reason. This is also what he meant when he said that "she'll come to understand". He declared his love for her before making this choice to make her further understand that she is the one he actually loves and he has no choice. FURTHERMORE he didn't want to go south and if you remember it was actually Chani who eventually talked him into doing just that.
Dune Messiah was precisely made for people like ash and hannah 😂
One hundred percent
I think Hannah gets it in a way. Ash is basically a fundamentalist lost to the cause, and very quickly. He'd be a high ranking Nazi in the 1940's...
This isn't Dune Messiah, this is just the second half of the first Dune book. Buckle up for the Dune Messiah though
@zls_89 we are aware we were merely making a comment on how dune messiah was written specifically for people who believed that Paul was the good guy in Dune.
@@zls_89 I know this isn’t.
53:15 - "I will take the hand of your daughter"
A note from the books, about this point: it is stated, more than once, that the marriage of Paul and Irulan, the emperor's daughter, is purely a political move. Jessica herself explains this to Chani, adding that Paul will never provide any affection for Irulan, and that there will be no intimacy between them (not even to consumate the marriage), and that Chani is and will remain Paul's wife and companion for ever.
A similar situation, described in the book in several different ways, and at different points of the story, is the one between Jessica and Leto. The two of them had not been married. Jessica's social position was that of being the concubine of Leto, and their marriage had been arranged (partially by the Atreides household, and partially by the Bene Gesserit, who had trained Jessica). However, the two of them had fallen deeply in love, and they were a married couple in all but name. Officially, howerver, it was necessary for Leto to be single and available to marry, in the case that he needed to make political marriage of convenience to another Noble house.
(spoilers ahead...)
In the following book of the series ("Dune's Children"), set a dozen years into the future, there is the continuation of this plotline: Paul and Irulan have contracted a political marriage, but Paul stays with Chani, who he considers his true spouse. In one of the court meetings, Irulan complains about this, but Paul matter-of-fact reminds her of the political necessity of their marriage and ends the discussion. However, he is not harsh about it, and even openly suggests for Irulan to take a lover, is she feels lonely (though he warns her to be discreet about it).
I think the reason Jessica didn't mention she was pregnant is because the current Reverend Mother would have died before the baby was born, and she needs to be alive for the transfer to work.
The only thing Jessica would gain by asking them to wait would be her own death after delivering the child. The Fremen would then be left without a Reverend Mother and have a new mouth to feed on top of that.
Instead she gambled on being able to transmute the poison before it affected the baby. Had she failed, at least she would still be alive to ensure Paul's survival and keep things moving in the direction of the prophecy.
Dune Part 2 is a monumental achievement and milestone in filmmaking. Respect that Ash got the callback from Paul vs Gurney in the first film.
Raban calls the Fremen rats, Paul becomes Muaddib in honor of the rat and the most dangerous name in the galaxy, symbolism!
The Dune Saga is now officially Ash's greatest wet dream; if Denis manages to make Ash take out his pants and underwear in Dune Messiah (which itself is already an impossible feat due to the 2nd novel's lack of action scenes), then he has accomplished his mission.🤣
17:10 The whole sequence🤣 Poor girl's trying to be wholesome. And Brah's here:
*"They should spit in each other's mouth!!!"*
Ash is so goddamned obnoxious, he's like an adult toddler
Poor Hannah.
He was doing better lately but i almost couldn't finish this one
@@meganmichaels9510 Are you lot yanks or something? Ash is brilliant, even when he's OTT. Natural entertainer
I love your little snappy arguments and sassy dynamics XD
As to whether the girl becomes evil, she comes to be known as "Saint Alia of the Knife," so there's that.
They are in “black and white” because they have a “black” sun. It doesn’t emit the same light properties that allow the same light spectrum. This was my favorite little detail of the movie
30:00 This scene isnt in black and white; and they didnt film it in black and white either. The scene is to show the lighting of the black light from the Harkonnen Sun.
They actually got the effect using infrared lighting and a modified Arri Alexa (the industry standard camera for movies); with modified filters to capture more light in the infrared spectrum.
My favorite book since I was 10 years old. One of the biggest influences on Sci Fi films for over 50 years.
You guys are my absolute favorites. Right when I thought I’ve seen all the dune reactions and getting tired of them a bit, yall come along and just bring so much joy into it again. Cheers from Texas!
My brother 👊🏽❤️
every time the daddy chill guy comes up i laugh . i just cant hold back .
"Hello. Nice to meet you. Have you lived here long?"
"When I was 9 I shit in a urinal"
I don't where he gets the confidence when he has nothing to be confident about.
Hannah is very smart. Even though she hasn't read the books she get's the point of Dune. That there are no heroes and Paul is not a hero. That is what the author of the books was trying to get across.
Frank Herbert intended his novel "Dune" as a study in power.
And an hommage to Lawrence of Arabia.
Much more than that actually. He shows his passion for Ecology and the potential of the human mind.
I love your reaction to this cinematic masterpiece! This has become my favorite movie of all time and Ash’s reaction to everything was very similar to mine.
Everything is just so epic and it does such an awesome job of making the viewers feel it, as if you were there. The music via Zimmer plays a big part in that!
As bitter sweet as the ending was, it follows the books pretty well, besides a few changes and liberties. In the books, Chani understands the politics of Paul’s marriage and remains his concubine because Paul truly does love her and not the Princess. In this, Chani is much more reluctant to follow Paul or even remain his lover but we’ll see how the handle this in the next movie, Messiah.
I could be wrong, but I think Ash enjoyed this.
Jessica’s unborn child is already a Reverend Mother because of the water of life
Sad that people don't get it. The power is already in his hands because he can see all futures. He knows what has to be done to win the war FOR THE FREMEN, for Stilgar's and the believers' green paradise, for his love for Chani. He has to lose her and even his friendships with the fremen who become war-hungry zealots.
This story is a tragedy, not a road for a sociopathic power hungry unidimensional character. A lot of reactors do not seem to get it but I guess it is just so much easier if you've read the books.
I mean, I am literally in the first 15 minutes of the audiobook. I already knew that Paul isn’t the hero and this is not a happy story just by actually paying attention to the first two movies. As an American, I thought maybe it was just an American this but I guess not.
It's funny to see how she understand perfectly the movie and pay attention to the details and implications about what is happening and the guy just becomes the exact thing what the story critic is about. Watching this dude scream and shout just because looks cool like a blind fanatic is funny, but annoying as well. Great reaction!!
17:00 - Related to what both of you will say in the next minute...:
According to the book, in Fremen Culture, if a Fremen (man or woman) provides water to the comunal water bassin (seen at 12:30). he is given a set of rings, called "Water Rings", which account for that water quantity. And, related to that, the act of a man entrusting his Water Rings to a woman is seen as a gesture of courtship.
In the book, Paul and Jessica do give they reserve water (a few liters, that they had in a bottle) to the communal freemen pool. It is Chani herself that measures it, and gives Paul a set of Water Rings corresponding to that quantity of water. Upon receiving the rings, Paul immediately asks Chani to keep them safe. Jessica senses a change in the mood of the people around them, and correctly concludes that Paul, instinctively, is starting to court Chani.
I really appreciate Hannah understanding the consequences and how scary Paul's change in appearance is once he's awoken from taking the Water of Life. It's not a good thing to celebrate that he's a chosen one, it's reluctantly horrifying.
Ash… Star Wars stole from Dune and the creator of Star Wars has yet to acknowledge the books. That’s why it feels similar to Star Wars 💯💯💯
Paul is the Kwisatz Haderach. He just came one generation earlier than the Bene Gesserit expected due to Jessica having a son instead of a daughter. If Jessica had a girl, the girl was then supposed to breed with Feyd-Rautha and their child would become the Kwisatz Haderach.
Paul became the Kwisatz Haderach when he drank the Water of Life. That is what Jessica means when she says: “The Kwisatz Haderach will be born in the south”.
Also, Paul didn’t become the way he became for power. He became that way because he could see that only one future was available where the Fremen and his family prevails, and he chooses to go through with that and to not try to avoid it. That is also why he says about Chani coming around to him again: “She’ll come to understand, I’ve seen it”. He knows she will come back to him at some point.
“THINGS ARE GOING TO HAPPEN “ Hannah just used the voice 😂😂😂😂 53:31
Hannah is too good catching up with stuff and foreshadowing damn
Watching this reaction made me realize why Herbert was so explicit with Messiah, the message of the movie really flies over so many people's heads.
Also, they don't show it in the movie, but Fremen Stietches have factories in them where they manufacture Stillsuits, Thumpers and all the other equipment they utilize. They're not a primitive people, they have advanced technology just like the rest of the universe.
Herbert couldn't portray the message properly because of his own faults as a writer. Paul isn't to blame, the Bene Gesserit are Fremen fanatics are. The "message" simply says that good people can make bad or negative decisions, nothing about the in-depth philosophy that Herbert claims to have pressed
Ofc there's the 🤓 dumass "preaching" about the same ish in every video lmao
@@niamhmaloney8750 bro goes around watching dune reactions to talk shit on frank herbert 💀
Not really. Books are always way more detailed. More proof book readers are obnoxious. With how these movies are it just seems like an innocent heir seeking revenge for others offing his entire family. It's not until later in this one do people realize "hey he might be...not so good"
@@templesleeper27 Talking shit about Heretics, Chapterhouse and the rest of Frank's fuckups is required to be a Dune fan. Fans are meant to praise whats good and criticise whats bad, otherwise you're just a fanboy with your head up your ass.
Like you
The only channel on YT where the intro story deserves applause…every reaction. 👏 Thank you
I just realized Paul is the product of the love of two cousins 😂
Omg yall neeeed to watch Jennifer’s body (2009) I think Hannah would love itttttt 😂😂😂😂😂
In the book, seen in the 1984 movie and mini series, Jamis had a wife and two sons. Paul adopts Jamis’ family. Harkonnens can use guns against the Fremens as they don’t use personal shields. Riding the worm, if you pry open a segment of the skin, the worm will try to keep it away from the sand. This will keep the worm from diving into the sand. Major difference from the book, If I remember correctly taking the water of life caused Jessica to give birth prematurely. The baby Alia was born fully mature in mind and power, considered an abomination. One of the scariest characters in sci-fi, not introduced here, being saved for the next film. The only one scarier than Alia is Hannah. Her understanding of this film qualifies her as a Bene Gesserit Witch.
I like Alia in Messiah; she's a militant murder-goblin on teenage hormones with the personality of a sassy grandma.
Though I'm not sure about Anya as her actor; I would've gone for someone like a young Rachel Weisz type of energy, someone who can motor-mouth about personal gripes while knifing the shit outta people at the same time.
35:05 “I just think it’s really intelligent” HELL YES!! That’s why this movie hit so hard, great action and cinematography with a gripping and thought provoking plot. Recipe for a banger
You've gotta see the next one in IMAX. Denis Villeneuve is the same director who made Prisoners, Sicario, Arrival, Blade Runner 2049, and a dope Jake Gyllenhaal mind bender called Enemy.
Hannah is dead on! The whole point is not to trust Paul (or any charismatic leader). He's actually the bad guy. The line "The Holy War has begun" gives me chills because now he's about to cause the deaths of billions. Billions across the galaxy.
Billions that were ok with the emperor killing his dad and house. Billions that were ok with treachery & tyranny.
@@orphanedhanyou I totally get where you're coming from. I'm talking about the common people. Not the great houses. Fuck them. But all those people who die of starvation because his war. And Paul knows he's causing that.
I think if Paul had actually blown up a spice field to back them off and then ruled Arrakis with Chani (making new trade deals with the CHOAM), he'd have battles to fight but wouldn't cause near the amount of deaths.
Seriously appreciate your comment though because the ruling class doesn't deserve to be saved. I think that's part of the nuance.
This ending with Chani always breaks my heart....
This is possibly the best reaction I've ever seen on CZcams... and I've seen a lot. You two bring so much life and energy to your reactions. Love your content.
I really like your older reactions Ash. But now most of the time it feels like you are trying to hard to find the next joke or "symbolism", instead of just enjoying the movie and showing your honest and true emotions or point of view. But maybe thats what most of your viewers are here for and i am the only one feeling like that.
Same, now he just plays the character of a dirty, 9yo on uppers or something. Barely watchable. Would not like to see him intoxicated.
Yep
You guys have the best CZcams reaction videos
In the book, the time frame of the story is that from the fall of House Atreides and Paul and Jessica's escape, two years pass before Paul triumphs over the Emperor. During that time, Alia is born. She has the full knowledge and abilities of a Reverend Mother. Alia is a terrifying figure being a two-year-old who can (and does) kill, uses the Voice, and acts like an adult. She will be extremely important in the next Dune film based on the novel Dune Messiah.
In the book, Chani never stands against Paul. She believes in Paul, accepts the prophecy, and is one of the most loyal to Paul. In fact, there's a heartbreaking part of their story not covered in this film or the 1984 version directed by David Lynch. I won't say what, because it is horrific, and happens during the final battle. When Paul takes Irulan as his bride, it is strictly so he can ascend the throne and become Emperor. Jessica even consoles Chani about this. "“Think on it, Chani: that princess will have the name, yet she’ll live as less than a concubine-never to know a moment of tenderness from the man to whom she’s bound. While we, Chani, we who carry the name of concubine-history will call us wives.”
“This is how monster energy drinks are made”
Had me in freaking tears !
Good one Ash!!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ash, I don't remember them talking about shaving in the books. 🤣
I watched this for the third time yesterday in the theater. It's great to see you guys reacting to it today.
This might be my favorite film of all time. It's an absolute masterpiece.
But the freman have spice orgies in the book...
Actually, they don't really bathe at all. The book talks about the smell of the seitch.