Tossing Out A Tenor
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 02. 2021
- The plaintiff is an opera singer who says she rented a room in the defendant’s home but refused to let her practice her music and then kicked her out. She’s suing for her security deposit back. The defendant says the plaintiff sang at the top of her voice every morning for three hours and then moved out without notice.
Case 29-068 - Zábava
The defendant didn't want peace, she wanted power.
You read her well...perfect observation....she had an attitude of superiority. That poor woman is from another country...must be made to feel welcome when they are far from their homes and loved ones...and she was seriously working on her art. An hour or two a day is SO reasonable.
To kick her out haughtily and keep her deposit says a lot about her.
@@sudhakhristmukti1930 one word Karen
Yes
As a human being, there are limits, to how much noise you can cope with.
@@payableondeath9091 I don’t think you have any clue what a “Karen” actually is lol This woman doesn’t fit that description
I highly doubt the dependent was so calm when she asked her to stop singing that Sunday morning
Defendant. And yes, you know she wasn't gonna hear it (literally).
I don't blame her. It gets annoying after a while. There's a young man that is taking singing classes in my family. The screeching gets to me eventually. People should find places to practice that won't bother others.
@@kittyb275 Yeah I agree. Also a residential building should not be a concert hall. I want peace and quiet and I have a right (written on the lease) to it. Go rent a studio.
She’s a count, I wouldn’t ever want to deal with her
@@prairierider7569 Pay your own rent. She kind of acts like a Karen.
So, an opera singer and woman who meditates moves in together? That's sitcom gold!
true that!
I can't picture the defendant as an actual mediator. She said she just wanted to sleep in later. She doesn't have a creative bone in her body.
@@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083 meditator*
this would of made a good Bill Cosby show
What about the 3rd lady?
The defendant wants peace and silence but lives in New York. 😂😂😂
That is possible where live there's parking everyday .you just got to find it
This is exactly why I have always made sure that I am able to afford living by myself.
Some people's professions require them to be transient. Renting becomes a must.
Always lived by myself...even when I couldn't afford it. I'll struggle for peace 😁
except this woman didn’t come to the U.S. to live.
@@GiftedVisionary There is such thing as short-term rentals.
@@GiftedVisionary Air BnB
Proud of the plaintiff for standing up for herself in a foreign country.
Exactly what I was thinking fam
She seemed so sweet from what I could gauge in 10 minutes, and I am sure her feelings were hurt, therefore backfiring. At the end of the day it was an unfortunate lesson for everyone.
The defendant strikes me as a liar.
She strikes me as someone... extremely difficult to get along with!!
Yep...she had seller's remorse. She knew that the plaintiff was an opera singer and is now using that excuse to without her deposit 🤦♂️
The hair alone is beyond reason. Looks like some new junk food noodles from a Korean market.
@@davidperez5089 hey, that’s not nice okay? 🙂
@@ioh7908 am i lying? I'm trying to deter future dye-died jobs.
The landlord looks like she is difficult to live with
Yeah, she is trouble. Can't imagine trying to be her boyfriend.
Smuggly
@@citytrees1752 Not bad to look at, but I doubt the relationship would last more than 15 minutes
Guessing she is the type that feels she’s doing people a favour and rather than sharing a living space she’s allowing them to exist in her space
She needs the $. Not the tenant.
The landlord is clearly a nut. You feel like she practice outside but you can practice being a “dj” in the house. She dodged a bullet moving out sooner.
Exactly! She was clearly the aggressor in my opinion and EXTREMELY RUDE! Sadly she’s a realitor, she should KNOW BETTER!
she though her good looks would work for her
A DJ and an opera singer could've been a great Collab.
I was thinking the same lmaooo
That was my first thought!!! What an opportunity.
What's a Collab?
@@thebalder9634 collaboration.
@@thebalder9634 in short: work together
I have to agree with Judge Marilyn, it's so strange that neither of them could ever come down to a common ground in regards to the plaintiff's singing.
Same. It seems to have gotten petty at some point and that’s when communication shut down.
The tenant got tired of the nasty baby-ish attitude from the landlord and was probably happy to get out ASAP.
@@citytrees1752 🤣💯
Yeah Blondie seemed like the one who is responsible for that. Just saying 🤷🏼♀️
@@citytrees1752 +😬😤😉
I can’t believe the defendant is a Real Estate Agent. She knew that withholding the rent was unscrupulous, a direct violation of our code of ethics. Smdh
I wonder what other codes of ethics she breaks in real estate. I don't trust her.
Obviously she took advantage of the fact that the plaintiff is a foreigner and arrogantly thought that she would not pursue what was rightfully hers.
The plaintiff Nicola Mills is a very talented british soprano. Shame on the defendant who withhold her security deposit.
She wanted peace on her terms. When you rent to someone, that person has certain rights to be able to use that living space for their enjoyment to a reasonable degree. This lady is the perfect example of someone who should just be living alone and not have renters in her property
She can do her yoga on the roof🤷🏾♀️
👏👏👏
Yes!
It's the best spot for yoga 😭😂😭😂
Yeah wouldn't doing yoga in the early morning sun feed the soul of the average yoga hippie?
I would’ve !
An hour flies by so quickly she could've used headphones.
Not when you're trying to sleep. Getting awakened can affect your whole day.
@@mrmagoo3701 she was practicing after 10 AM as the defendant asked her to!
@@MyVanilly For one hour ONLY.
"I'll tell you what right you have.... ZERO!!!!!!!!!!"
God, I love this Judge! :-)
Yesss my fave part
Yes !! She said rent was due and JM said "well you picked a hell of a day to tell her to leave " 🤣🤣🤣
I loved it! She reminded me of Judge Judy when she did that
So, the defendant not only kicked the plaintiff out with 2 weeks' notice but was, also, going to keep her deposit as "rent" money. I am glad that the Plaintiff won.
If she pays rent yes she can sing for an hour. Maybe they could have worked out a specific time schedule. Might have been beneficial for both.
Her practice hour could've been the house alarm clock. All she needed to do was more complex exercises and I doubt anyone wouldve had a problem.
Pretty much. I had roommates that would let me know when they were going to practice . If you arent musical I guess it's a little more difficult?..
Could she still be allowed to invade her room area bedrooms with her singing?For some,it would be as detrimental as cigarette smoke,or smells.How would it work,against objections?Just interested.
Yes, but the plaintiff SHOULD HAVE TOLD THE DEFENDANT THAT SHE WAS AN OPERA SINGER in the beginning. That way she could have had a choice whether to rent to her or not, or come to some kind of agreement ahead of time. It was completely dubious of the plaintiff to withhold that information and then expect that it wouldn't be a problem.
No schedule would have met with the queen dj's approval.
I loved the way the plaintiff presented her case.
if adoreable were a person
I'm glad she got her security deposit back
The defendant has an attitude problem and is a liar. The exaggeration (1-3 hours of singing for 30 days), text messages conflicting testimony and knowledge of real estate laws weakened her credibility. She likely assumed that the plaintiff would not sue. Depending on the state laws, she could have doubled her damages.
The defendant is soooooo full of herself like omg.
wonder what, if any MEN who might have moved in with her, had to deal with, lol. Oh boy.......
The way she threw her head back while the plaintiff was speaking, WOW
Yeh, that defendant thinks she's cute, you can tell.
But honestly I'm kind of in her corner, the plaintiff knowing that she has to practice singing opera loudly every morning should disclose this up front.
She shouldn't assume people already know, or that it's not going to be a potential problem.
@@nishisalott1839 She was doing a back stretch. I'm sure of it but yes, I didn't breath during that scene.
The plaintiff is so full of herself
The defendant, in all her arrogance, thought that she would be able to manipulate the roommate situation, and take advantage of the plaintiff. As a roommate paying rent, one gets to “live” as long as it doesn’t put other tenets in harms way.
U have two people with 2 different lifestyles. The plaintiff should have told the landlord that she would b singing in apt and asked if that would be OK.
Lifestyles should've been discussed before a deal was made. It's one thing to compromise on things like that, another entirely for them both to not divulge their roommate disturbing hobbies and just wing it.
Sadly some roommates dont think that way. I lived with one who somehow thought he was the property management ..... you would be surprised
“It’s not belting”. Oh she was offended by that.
Lol!
I felt offended for her!
@@StarC2233 why, belting is an vocal technique singers use. its only a negative if someone does it poorly since it can damage your vocal cords. its not common to use it as a opera singer but far from something that should offend someone.
Opera s8ngers develop great lungs
I’m pretty sure that belting is a type of singing though that actually sounds really good
This judge is so rude and out of touch. It’s time for people’s court to get a new judge, she had her moment now it’s time for a new refreshing judge.
I was split until the end. You don't tell someone to move out "ASAP" and then keep their money.
Am English speaking it was nice to hear another English voice standing up for her rights well done you ❤
"I don't feel safe here" 😳 Oh please!!! I've lived in a few situations which were very unsafe, NONE of which were a result of a house mate SINGING! Just as well she never rented to a gangsta rapper. The defendant drips of entitlement, narcissism and greed.
I agree, i get so tired of the " i dont feel respected" statement. Waaaahhhhh
You said this perfectly💯
Y'all never heard of ear plugs? Noise cancelling headphones?
I doubt that would help. Professional opera singers are loud.
@@melosidhe779 actually not so much when practicing. and even if she was, being in another room, and wearing headphones/plugs would be fine.
That was my thought, I have a pair and they definitely do work.
I don't wear headphones or earphones, what would I do?
@@melosidhe779 Listen .. that help. I lived near a band practicing daily for hours ... and I used noise cancelling headphones .. I finished 2 research degrees living there for 6 years. it worked .. the only downside is when I needed to take them off to sleep .. because some nights they'll play after midnight .. I don't think they were worse .. my worse was the old factory siren that would go off every heavy rain because it is how it works .. it took me 2 years of complaining to council for them to figure out who own that abandon factory and how to get that alarm to stop. that was horrifying .. it is very loud old siren .. and it would go for an hour if the rain is heavy .. horrible thing.
This case was cut and dry. The defendant is dumb as rocks for letting an opera singer rent her space if she didn't want any noise during her meditating. I mean, come on. What the hell did you expect? 🤦♂️
I would not want to piss off the defendant though. She could tear anyone to pieces, ESPECIALLY MEN
She didn't know she was an opera singer.
@@johng669 she literally says she knew she was an opera singer.
What meditation was she doing? Turning up the dial on her music?
Not go sing on the roof 🤣🤣
If you want to be so controlling about your space, make enough money to afford to live alone!!! No one should have to walk on eggshells or bend to your every whim when they’re paying rent.
Blondie gives me Mega Karen vibes.
The Opera singer though... 👀 on the spot belt out and sounds beautiful without any warm-up..💓💓💓💓💓
That what I was thinking. She not nice. She made her self out to be a victim. Wow.
Even her speaking voice is beautiful. I 💕 opera.
The opera singer seems like such a kind and considerate woman. She didn't even want to sue in the first place. Blondie is a total Karen. I saw evil in those 90s purple shadowed eyes. She reminded me of a mid 90s chic. Lol
Passive Agreesive Pam
@@corazoncubano5372 I am English,so I know her accent is almost mid-Atlantic,from her visits to the US.It sounds quite strange.Also,she only sang scales,and it was quite off.
This is hilarious! Why would you rent to an opera singer if you meditate and light candles and shyt? Lol
I will certainly be sure never to use the blonde as a realtor!! She did not make herself look good...
If you "want alot of peace around you" dont rent to an Opera Singer
I once rented a room in a house and the landlord’s sister who was also living in the house and was the unofficial caretaker kept making remarks about me taking phone calls in the house. That the walls were thin and she could hear me from across the hall. She insinuated I should make or take calls outside. One time i was on the phone in my room basically whispering like a child sneaking a phone call and she passes my room on way to hers slams her door and says for goodness sakes loud enough for me to hear. The next day i gave my notice till end of the month and left. Day i was leaving she shamefacedly asked me she hoped I wasn’t leaving because of her 🙄. Some people just can’t live with other people but should not be renting out their home
good for you for leaving. A person should only put up with so much. Just like at my current job. My health and mental wellness are starting to suffer in this place. Just took another day off, which is becoming a bad habit for me, I am considered a STAR employee. But maybe just a WORK HORSE, capable of being USED. The time should come with every human being to move on. If something is bothering you, about a living situation, a job, a person, take the next step and move on to greater things. Hope you have found greater pastures, Kem.
Woooowwwww I'm really glad you moved, you probably avoided getting murdered or something. That's crazy!!
@@MrMaddox57 That suuuucks. The line between star employee and work horse gets blurred sometimes. It's true, sometimes you've just gotta ditch it if it's not working for you. Life's too short. Hope things work out for you.
@CoolKem C they probably went thru your things too if they were that nosey wow
Please tell me you gave her a stare back and never answered .. I would. Such people don't deserve the satisfaction of manipulation.
I bet the defendant finds fault with many roommates. God help her roomies.
Defendant was going to cheat her out of another month's rent if she stayed a day longer. She knew what she was doing!
That accent 😍 so lovely
🏴❤️🏴✊🏽💁🏽♀️💯
L💓ve it!!!
I've been distracted this whole time by her accent, trying to figure out where it's from. I thought I was getting good at that for UK accents but she has me stumped. Sounds northern, maybe?
@@ukbusiness8811 I hope you don't mind me asking but any chance you can place her accent? I'm dead curious.
@@sadeatthewhip1846 she sounds like she is from the north ok England, Manchester or Leeds.
I had roommates and it was a complete disaster. I got rid of them all and got a young couple to move in. They paid rent on time, gave me gifts, bought groceries and cooked. It was great until the fighting started. I sold that place, moved 70 miles south and bought a doublewide to live in while I looked for a better place. I'm still in that doublewide. There's alot of space and the lot rent is $600/mo. The neighbors are nice, and I'm in for the long haul. No roommates required.
The defendant presents herself as a very difficult person and flat out lied about the final argument
I'm not at the stage of my life to have roommates, but if I was, I would love to have an opera singer and a dj for roommates.
nah bruv you wouldnt
Nah bro I had a wanna be DJ roommate and he would be trying to dj at every party we had and everyone hated it. But he would be blaring his music at 2am
I wouldn't want them as neighbors. Sounds like hell.
Get your own apartment, it may be more expensive but it is worth the peace of mind...
@Brad James 😂😂😂😂 you naughty☺️
My nephew had to practice his clarinet and I couldn't concentrate on my grad school work.i got noise canceling headphones. Problem solved.
Right that's for your nephew, a relative you love, not a tenant you give no relationship with
You're dumb if you think that's a universally acceptable solution. Smfh
@@shaydaslays A tenant that pays rent, she only practiced for an hour and the woman knew she practiced opera she just wanted someone to rent the room and didn't think it through and ended up having buyers remorse.
Wow I am so triggered by the landlord’s behavior. The judge made a good call
There had to have been something else going on. Its way too petty to kick her out over her practicing. An hour a day and that's it?
It’s just buyers remorse
Morning person and night owl clashing personalities... landlady actually doesnt like sharing her space but needs the money or is a Karen in the making...
Petty describes the defendant perfectly.
Ego was going on. Landlord doesn’t understand the difference between being a queen vs being a landlord. The plaintiff didn’t show her enough deference so she made it about the singing.
God, I love Judge Marilyn. No-nonsense straight shooter. Marvelous.
I just can’t imagine being annoyed hearing opera lol I would feel like I’m a king
She's someone who should not have roommates. Some personalities need to be in control, which is fine... if you live alone.
I love the plaintiff's English accent.
Me too, and I love my godmother's English accent as well.
💯✊🏽💁🏽♀️ 🏴
@@NellieKAdaba ok but this was about the plaintiff
Naw, Scots for me 😍😂
its not accent,its their language.. the americans have accent.. got it..
The plaintiff is incredibly adorable 🤗🤗🤗
She looks like Sarah Ferguson.
That she is
I don't know what you're seeing because I'm not seeing it.
@@jeanstanley8513 you don’t have to see it.
I can see and hear it, love her accent
La la laaaaa laaa lalalalalala 🎶🎶omg I would die 😂
Same 😩😩😩😩
XD I would install sound cancelling walls ... Oh seriously I would die if I had to hear that EVERY, SINGLE, DAY!!!
I would love it. I will sing scales with her.
@@justjared2009 What if she doesn't want you to sing scales with her?
Not to generalize, but most Americans have a lack of appreciation for opera. Even Judge Milian's "gun finger in the head" zany reaction is typical, though may have been taken as offensive, along with the "belting" reference to which the plaintiff objected.
I found that to be disrespectful of the Judge to do that.
I think the judge was annoyed by the high pitched repetitive noise. She might not mind actual opera music. You are assuming.
Singing opera and practicies and warming up is two different things! 4 notes of "A" would drive me crazy. But I can hear she has a good voice. And the judges told her twice she had a beautiful voice.. Its Just the warm up and practecy every day that can be desturbing.
I enjoy opera. But to hear a scale and practice notes for over an hour would drive anyone crazy. Don't be an elitist.
The judge was referencing the repeated over and over practice of just notes. That could be monotonous and annoying. It wasn't opera singing. But, if course, the tenant had the right to practice an hour a day!
Having dealt with tenant the last few years, if them signing opera for one hour a day is the worst thing they did, I would purchase earplugs for this time, if neccesaey.
Just use earplugs, people. I live in a 17 story tower in concrete. I don't have one specific neighbor that is noisy, but there's always going to be someone using a drill. So I sleep with earplugs. When even that isn't enough, I put my earlplugs and my headphones with my music above that. Someone could be drilling in my living room, I'd be sleeping in my room.
Defendant shot herself in the foot! LOL
Agree! I think she (defendant) was a witch too!!
Defendant needs to just live alone
Crunchy hair is so gross , what's up with that home perm
Lmao! I was over here wondering if it’s a perm because I’ve learned that a perm for us means straight hair & the opposite for white people.
Ikr ! I had flashbacks of teenager days with lots of Aussie Scrunch gel in the purple bottle, the smell and everything, and could practically feel how it felt to scrunch the hair🤏 in my hands 🤌LMAO 🤣
Girl, that Yoga and Meditation aren't working, you're not doing the work on yourself. I wish a lot of sucess to the opera singer
I don't think she does yoga. She's got such a mean aura 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
@@ayyboii8108 LOL
And this the first time this dude was nice to both! Lol
plaintiff NEEDS! her own apartment!
Absolutely.
She was only in NY for 3 months tho. That would be hard to find
@@monikathomas4985 yep
She should have informed the defendant about her practices. However the defendant didn’t handle this problem well, especially with a real estate license.
Only if she are able to live in the U.S. for a long period of time 🤷🏾♀️ she clearly stated she was only here for 3 months for AUDITIONS
She could be my alarm clock.
For small claims court in England, check out Judge Rinder.
I love him
Thank you!
He is so adorable 🥰
Plaintiff wanted an “all American experience” boy did she get one😭😭🤣
Someone who herself is a DJ, rents to an opera singer and thinks she won't practice daily??? The fact the defendant stated she "I no longer feel safe here" is telling of her entitled attitude...
Plaintiff was precious! I'd love an opera singer roommate
5:27
What a nice lady! She didn't even want to speak ill of her after all this.
Her daughters really do sing. They're called the Schlesinger sisters.
Thanks for the info.
William G hey cutie 😘😘
I guess you won't be saying 🤷 ASAP any more.😅🤣
She learned dat ASAP 🤣👍🏽
Yey finally a UK lass and she won
🏴✊🏽❤️
How hard is it to come to an agreement about times that either the singing or the meditation and Olga happens? Like my God this should have been such an easy thing to manage. Shows how people can’t talk to each other anymore.
I used to live near Time's Square which is where all the theaters are. I had an opera singer neighbor. I could hear her through the wall. I rather enjoyed it.
Does anyone else see Pauly D little brother in the audience behind the plaintiff
It would be annoying to listen to that every day! They should have an agreement on what time was good for both.
Wouldn't be annoying for me. I've been an opera fan for over fifty years now. Sounds like Heaven.
when Harvey interviews the people watching on the sidewalk, seems like that last woman who he held the microphone to would be a MUCH kinder landlady!
I’m glad the plaintiff won the defendant has zero respect for her I’m glad the judge told the defendant like it is !
The moment the defendant walked in with a smirk on her face...a karen smirk
Bloody Karen! I immediately disliked her soon as I saw the smug look on her face.
every time someone tells me they're going to move in with a roommate (or, god forbid, multiple roommates), I advised them to spin up youtube and watch Judge Judy and The People's court episodes about roommate issues.
Very good judgement. Here is this singer barely practicing an hour for her art...and from another country..and then she kicks her out & keeps her deposit...how mean.
She can sing for an hour a day jeez🙄
Glad Milian stopped the plaintiff from stating that she left the day AFTER rent was due... She would end up having to pay the whole month..
No, she was saying she left the day before rent was due.
Good on Nicola. She's a beauty who is lovely, talented, gracious and polite, unlike the defendant who sells herself as immature and entitled.
Nicola deserves far better than this piece of work for a roomie. IMO
She gave her a 2 weeks notice and complained that she had to pay her rent…DONT EVICT HER
As if Doug is so naïve that he thinks England doesn't have Small Claims xD.
I love how the judge preps her tone and shouts ZERO!😂
As a lifelong patron of the Opera, if I owned a house she could live rent-free for a season discount, lol!
I’m glad the Plaintiff won
How sad to travel to the United States and wind up in court over a living situation. I wish both of these ladies well. And regarding the defendant, maybe it would be helpful going forward if she advertises for a roommate with a quiet lifestyle.
She wants a roomate with a quiet lifestyle but she herself does not have a quiet lifestyle since she wants to play her DJ music!
Did anybody else shout “zero” with the judge? 🤣 just me? She had some nerve kicking her out then trying to force her to pay rent. If you like peace, make more money so you can afford to live alone.
I can barely live with my own children 🤣
Lol you got teenagers too? I hear you girl.
I'd have loved having a visitor from England in my house and an opera singer to boot.
Pretty interesting case
Wish you the best in opera singing. Welcome to USA
My wife can get all the high notes, and sometimes she shows off, one day we were going down the road and listening to CDs and all of a sudden I hear this high shrill, and I slammed on the brakes and swerved off to the side of the road and I thought something had happened to her, and I get stopped and looked over and she was alright, and kind of smirking, then I told her not to do that when I'm driving, we'll have an accident! 🤣
New York must be packed full of people cause every case from New York is ppl renting rooms and basement wow
I hear! No pun intended,
I hear the shower makes a great sound booth.
And that is a perfect excuse.
Just say everybody sings in the shower and a shower can take about an hour. He he he.
The plaintiff is sooooo cute. I hope she was able to line up some work here.
She can sing.....😍😍😍😍😍
I love the plaintiff’s accent and the defendant is gorgeous 😍😍😍😍 but,I knew the plaintiff was going to win because she got wrongfully evicted 💯
From what I know, here in Canada, anytime you do more than chill in the house (run a home based business, have a dog, practice singing/playing an instrument, etc) you should mention your requirements while applying for the place, as you are asking someone to limit their freedoms to accomodate your choises.
It sounds aweful put that way, but it is about managing expectations... What if the plaintiff had tenitis? Should she have to suffer for 60 days because the defendant did not mention her singing needs?
Canada does not have one set of laws governing tenant rights. It varies by province/territory.
@@brendenvarty3266 true, but I have yet to find a tennant legality that allows "entering a contract under false pretenses" which is the legal action a landlord can claim such acts under. Learned that due to owning a dog.
Basically, the concept I was stating is that one should explain their uncommon or jargon based needs while applying for housing.
@@Maninawig In Toronto, the landlord cannot legally put a no pets clause in the lease. Any such clause is void, even if signed.
Condo boards are a different game
@@brendenvarty3266 true, but if your dog is a yappy bitch (legal term), they can refer to the fact that you did not warn them before hand as a reason for eviction. The dog is not the issue, but the issues your particular dog is causing, such as the yapping causing your neighbour to fear passing your door in the hallway to get to their appartment.
Earplugs, earplugs people! They work wonders and could have avoided this situation.