I know Jason uses lethal force but he isn't about to shoot Dick. Dick has more combat expertise and skill imo. And even if Jason used his guns there have been a plethora of times he's relied on them too much and it's bit him in the booty, leaving him with a ton of "oh shit" moments when he's either out of ammo, his guns are removed from the fight or they just don't help in a certain situation.
Nightwing is the most skilled of the Robins. He's the closest to being Batman or even surpassing him. He's literally the one capable of being Batman. However, if any of the Robin's stood a chance, it would be Jason because he could've been the most skillful if he wasn't so impulsive and emotional.
As a Red Hood fan I agree Nightwing wins because Jason is more of a "Punisher" type which involves a lot of shooting while Nightwing is more of the "Batman" type which involves more tactics and skills plus more intelligence plus he doesn't let emotions get in the way.
In Batman and Robin Eternal: "Mother" storyline, Orphan (Cassandra Cain) "said" once, Red Hood (Jason Todd) is the Brawn, Red Robin or Drake (Tim Drake) is the Brain, and Nightwing (Dick Grayson) is the Heart.
Why is this a debate? It's a no brainer, Nightwing is the best fighter Bruce has ever trained, he even beat Batman in hand to hand from time to time. Unfortunately, the animated movies hate Nightwing and make him get his arm broken in EVERY MOVIE. They don't do him justice at all, especially in that fight against Batman.
At the start of their lives Nightwing was training his body towards the peak of acrobat perfection. He was able to perform the quadruple flip at a young age. Red Hood on the other hand was learning street smarts( parkour brawling enviormental awareness). Training they both trained under Batman. Red Hood trained under a older and slightly more experienced batman however Nightwing continued to learn from Batman every once in a while after he became nightwing. Nightwing has also fought Cassandra Cain and Deathstroke to a standstill (Deathstroke usually wins). He also has been able to withstand telepathic attacks by shear willpower. Speaking of willpower this is an area Red Hood wins in. Red Hood was resurrected in a lazurus pit and then went on to train under some very evil people. All this was done while having a lot of anger and vengenace pent up inside him. He then went to Gotham and confronted batman (the man who failed him) all without falling into the murder happy state that Batman would if he ever let himself kill. All this is more impressive since the Lazurus pit is known to cause mental instability. All that being said Nightwing has been fighting people with guns and lethal tactics his whole career. Nightwing's age, experience, and acrobatic skill would win this fight 95% of the time.
Love the beatdowns, could we ever see a batman vs Deathstroke in the vein of Ben Affleck’s idea. Would be awesome to see since we never got it and there’s no other live action fight on CZcams like it. Your amazing team is just right to bring us the batfleck deathstroke match up we never got! Keep up the great work
I know Jason uses lethal force but he isn't about to shoot Dick. Dick has more combat expertise and skill imo. And even if Jason used his guns there have been a plethora of times he's relied on them too much and it's bit him in the booty, leaving him with a ton of "oh shit" moments when he's either out of ammo, his guns are removed from the fight or they just don't help in a certain situation.
Nightwing is the most skilled of the Robins. He's the closest to being Batman or even surpassing him. He's literally the one capable of being Batman. However, if any of the Robin's stood a chance, it would be Jason because he could've been the most skillful if he wasn't so impulsive and emotional.
Nightwing for sure. Trained with Batman longer than anyone
I think nightwing is a better strategist in my opinion because if you are a defensive fighter you probably gonna use your pieces more carefully.
Does Jason Todd's enhanced strength and healing, post his resurrection, give him the edge over Grayson?
Nightwing, hands down.
Nightwing. How is this even a thing? We DO remember that red hood is Jason Todd, right? Nightwing is just better.
Nightwing hands down. Redhood is predictable and irrational. Nightwing is so much more put together.
Nightwing hands down.
Nightwing. Whenever Jason gets around the bat family, he gets too emotional. Dick would capitalize on one Jason's mistakes and subdue him.
I'd like to see Captain America and Winter Soldier vs Nightwing and Red Hood
These are the videos we need during these times. Love to see more of these.
I would have to go with Nightwing.
Nightwing is a casual bullet timer lol...been dodging bullets since early teens...
I love both these super heroes but Nightwing was the original Robin but Jason died and became redhood. But I think Nightwing will win
As a Red Hood fan I agree Nightwing wins because Jason is more of a "Punisher" type which involves a lot of shooting while Nightwing is more of the "Batman" type which involves more tactics and skills plus more intelligence plus he doesn't let emotions get in the way.
In Batman and Robin Eternal: "Mother" storyline, Orphan (Cassandra Cain) "said" once, Red Hood (Jason Todd) is the Brawn, Red Robin or Drake (Tim Drake) is the Brain, and Nightwing (Dick Grayson) is the Heart.
Why is this a debate? It's a no brainer, Nightwing is the best fighter Bruce has ever trained, he even beat Batman in hand to hand from time to time. Unfortunately, the animated movies hate Nightwing and make him get his arm broken in EVERY MOVIE. They don't do him justice at all, especially in that fight against Batman.
At the start of their lives Nightwing was training his body towards the peak of acrobat perfection. He was able to perform the quadruple flip at a young age. Red Hood on the other hand was learning street smarts( parkour brawling enviormental awareness). Training they both trained under Batman. Red Hood trained under a older and slightly more experienced batman however Nightwing continued to learn from Batman every once in a while after he became nightwing. Nightwing has also fought Cassandra Cain and Deathstroke to a standstill (Deathstroke usually wins). He also has been able to withstand telepathic attacks by shear willpower. Speaking of willpower this is an area Red Hood wins in. Red Hood was resurrected in a lazurus pit and then went on to train under some very evil people. All this was done while having a lot of anger and vengenace pent up inside him. He then went to Gotham and confronted batman (the man who failed him) all without falling into the murder happy state that Batman would if he ever let himself kill. All this is more impressive since the Lazurus pit is known to cause mental instability. All that being said Nightwing has been fighting people with guns and lethal tactics his whole career. Nightwing's age, experience, and acrobatic skill would win this fight 95% of the time.
Love the beatdowns, could we ever see a batman vs Deathstroke in the vein of Ben Affleck’s idea. Would be awesome to see since we never got it and there’s no other live action fight on CZcams like it. Your amazing team is just right to bring us the batfleck deathstroke match up we never got! Keep up the great work