Yea idk y the koreans are addicted to creating manhwa that potrays bullying and alll the characters are handsome and beautiful and similar in look... I dont even find any expressions and character development much in there work... THIS IS MY OPINION can be different for others
I disagree with the expressions and charcter development compliant. But I would say that manwha has been being produced at a slow rate throughout its time relative to manga. So when you think of manwhas that have those expressions and character developments you can't list of that many because the amount of manwha isn't that large. But in manga there are a lot of examples because there's a larger pool to pull from. For the similar in look comment I would say when an artist is making characters they tend to have the same art style throughout the process so yeah but also manga tends to be more fictitious than manwha so they go more wacky with the charcter designs but like manwha have the same art style. For the bullying and all the characters looking handsame point I would say these are just elements that are used a lot and the same point could be made to manga like why do they always have a lot of isekai stories. These are just common tropes.
I agree, and the characters actually look Korean. Even when they have blonde hair, like Sangwoo, you can tell by the attention to facial details that he's still Asian. So it's assumed that his hair is simply dyed blonde. Compare this to how Japanese people draw Asians, and they make the eyes ridiculously big, as Koreans keep the eyes smaller, usually. The artstyles feel very different.
Manga prioritizes storytelling and work efficiency over color. Color is added when manga is animated. The relationship between manga and anime is very great. And the character designs are excellent and unique, making them well-suited for merchandising. On the other hand, manhwa's content is shallow and repetitive, resulting in quick forgetfulness. It is like junk food. The character designs are all similar and not catchy. Consequently, creating a masterpiece that remains beloved for many years would be very difficult for manhwa.
But sadly that is the world trend. Something short, shallow, less or no development but... Gives temporary but high amusement. Just like CZcams shorts.
@@stavrosboi I think there most likely won't be one that "Changes the Industry" as it is going on now and most likely their niche is these short shallow easy to pump out flash comics that could very much in the near future be entirely created using AI to generate the art and then someone adds speech bubbles to it.
Webtoons can be accepted as a new form, but manga has a far different depth of history, and it is too arrogant to say that it has surpassed it. Webtoons have the advantage of being easy to read because they are on smartphones, but because they are easy to read, they are mainly descriptive and have little dialogue, which makes it difficult to feel the depth of the story and the emotions of the characters.Even if a work becomes popular temporarily, it is unlikely to produce works that will be passed down to future generations as manga have been.
Call me weird, but i really have problems with colored mangas/manhwas whatever. I'm so used to bw, anything else just feels... wrong. Whenever i see the first page of a new manga being colored, i can't wait for it to turn bw... i mean, it's not so bad that i'd say i wouldn't read a manga that's colored although story and characters are top, but i reeeally prefer bw. And yes, i know that Manhwas used to be bw, i read the comments, don't worry, but that doesn't change the fact, that most Manhwas i started were colored and call me superficial, but the reason i stopped reading them was they being colored almost everytime
Opposite for me but it's probably a boomer/zoomer thing for color vs BW. It's probably the same dynamic with manga panels fit for physicals vs manhwas being fit for vertical scrolling on tablets.
I love this type of content, I've always been interested in professionals diving into The process of how different types of mediums are made. I also hope you write more manga some day.
One thing I would like foreign readers of manga not to misunderstand is that coloring in manga is also done in Japan😢 It's just hazy because many famous manga such as One Piece and jjk are in black and white.
The Reason i prefer Manga over Manhwa is because Manhwa is that most of the stories are Repetitive there is always this weak protagonist who looks scrawny and gets bullied and becomes stronger or there is always this guy who gets reincarnated in another world and is already op like most isekai manga Ln and anime's out there and most character's always looks handsome and beautiful and most of the side villains this ugly fat dude or this ugly gorilla dude and the protagonist will always be this handsome always saves the day dude and the villains are always like this handsome edgy dude that kinda gives that sasuke vibe and most Manhwa's are not unique and not just the story but the characters and the art too not gonna lie the art is great but the art is not unique its not the same the only manhwa art i find unique is The Boxer and in Manhwa Characters are very badly developed and like most of the development goes to the main character while there are some manhwa that try to avoid this such as Study Group which one of my favorite manhwa's by the way and most manhwa's story is very mid it's not unexpected and like most of the time you can probably what's gonna happen on the next page or the next chapters especially if you read many manhwa's Manga on the other hand Still does has some these flaws But in terms of Storytelling Characters and Development Manga always takes The Spot Manga art also starts to change over the course of time and not staying with the generic anime style art my most favorite art style in Manga is Berserk Vagabond and Jojo and The Crazy thing is Manga doesn't need Color to look good but if you put color in it especially if it's digital Manga will look 100x better than most Manhwa's if you don't believe then take a look at it online it's because of the detailing that makes them look good that make them feel more alive and not just Picture's That are drawn on each panel. There are also some Manga That doesn't work when it has color example of this is Berserk And Vagabond Berserk Always has this dark aura in it and because of that when you put color in it looking at it doesn't feel quite right that's why for me it doesn't work. Vagabond always has this Edo Period feeling that's because the story takes place in The Edo Period that's Vagabond with no Color works more becuz it keeps that feeling though im not saying that these manga's look bad when they have color it just takes away something important from them probably one of the reasons why even today Berserk still doesn't have a proper Anime adaptation
I have recently started reading manwa and yes you are 100% correct on your opinion and I agree that mangas are better but that just depends on the manga and manwa or the stereotype. I grew up watching anime so i also think mangas are better but that's just my biased opinion but your opinion is so researched based 😂
I tried honestly they are average or below average than manga so I quit those after some chapters. They couldn't attract me to read more like lair game, uzumaki, death note,Naruto, dragon ball, jujitsu kisen,tomiiee, and many more.so I think magans are best.@@JVision1
Personally i dont mind manwha though it seems to sacrifice story for "art", in some i have seen they will have just one or two large frames per page thus making one volume a single conversation where as manga tends to balance things out better. Abit annoyed by the jab at Isekai when most manwha fantasy titles are inherently Isekai while also have a 50% chance of being a korean version of an isekai manga that came out the year before. Also it did not surprise me when stated they asset flip images cause I'll be honest it seems all manwha share the exact same art style in my pov where as manga varies heavily in terms not only the artist but the theme, story, character and their context: example being one punch man can switch at a whim from looking poorly drawn to chibi then Hyper realistic. Not knocking on Manwha some are good, though there are alot of titles that are not.
Off topic, but I have something to say about Chinese Manhua For Taiwan (and Hong Kong): the Manhua is like manga where is Right to left. Meanwhile China: the manhua is like western comics and Korean Manhwa where it’s left to right. Just saying.
I’m currently reading 50+ active webtoons rn. Most of which are manhwa. The gems out of them that I get the most excited for are Teenage Mercenary, Jungle Juice, Omniscient reader, Return of the Blossoming blade, Lookism (which just had an anime adaptation announced),and The Ember Knight
most manhwa are like western cartoon and comic, it's really enjoyable but you get nothing but lose your time at the end of the day.all I get is "you need to be handsome and strong to beat the shit out of other people, don't love and care except yourself and your family"
In manhwa, there is no suffering at all after the main character gets out of the worst situation, and I get tired of it after a few months. In this respect, I can watch T.jun's works without getting tired of them.
My favorite manhwa is tower of god, sweet home My favorite manga (don't bully me bro) Kubo wont let me be invincible, chainsaw man, my dress up darling, and jujutsu kaisen
Keeping aside story, characters etc. Never been a fan of manhwa's vertical reading format, reason i love reading manga is that it doesn't feel like i'm reading just some comic, it feels more like a piece of literature with some philosophical takes by authors in their own way, also who wouldn't love to have a shelf full of manga collection..... Obviously a good story isn't entitled to it's medium, and in this digital era i understand why more and more authors are switching to web-comics/webtoons, i can't really explain but manga really has a different feel to it, those black n' white pages, traditional paneling just always works everytime for me......
I definitely feel that. That's why Some of the most cherished stories that I've written are in the manga format, But that's probably because I grew up reading more manga than webtoons😅
@@ajmorningstar6281stil manga detailing is better character are more realistic while manwah are cartoonish kids drawing with colors even my drawing is better
Man, it's true that most isekai are shit, but so are most shounen battle manga. A good writer can take a simple concept and make something amazing out of it. Some of my favorite series are isekai, like grimgar of fantasy and ash, ascendance of a bookworm and mushoku tensei.
think they are similar but the westen manhwa is different for me like every thing the style the story and it’s mostly the same story But Korean manhwa is very good I also grow up with manga and anime I love the both they are very amazing❤
ngl manga have the best artstyle for example: i've readed a manhwa that have torturing in there but it looks very bland for some reason meanwhile torture in manga looks 100x better manga is black and white thats why i like it meanwhile i feel like most of the manwha have the same artstyle idk, manga just hit different than manhwa
Is there a way if you can tell if the comic you’re making is more western manga or Manhwa? Back in the day my comic was pretty much just me working on it doing the line art the coloring the word bubbles, the stories and the character designs. But when I submitted my finished comic to my semi mentor Ben Dunn, which him and his brother founded Antarctic press, he said that my art style needed some more work but I was definitely in the right direction and he loved my story. So that prompted me to get an artist to do the line art and I do the rest like designing the characters doing the story plots, and design the page layouts. I ended up getting this really awesome artist from Thailand named Panu Leeluesai, which from what I know he has been working in the manga industry for at least 10 years definitely more than that. But with my comic I actually color it and of course do the word bubbles do the character designs and page mockups. My comic style I considered to be more western manga because it’s still in the page format but I color it. So the only difference that I have between my “western manga” style to the more Korean Manhwa is how it’s formatted. As you said the Korean style comics are formatted to be more like Websoon’s scrolling format with one panel over the other going downwards. But my comic is formatted more like a traditional western comic by pages and going left to right. So is coloring the pages making it more of a Manhwa style comic or can I still consider it “western manga“?
Manga made in Korea and China should not be called manhwa or manhua. Because the art style of those characters is almost the same as in Japan. Especially how to write those eyes, manpu(漫符), how to express scenes, and story composition. They should be called Korean manga, Chinese manga. In addition, color manga and vertical reading manga have been widely used in Japan for more than 10 years.
ok, folks, I'm sure there are people who disagree with my opinion. But especially look at the manpu and eye drawing, the manpu and eye drawing used in them all originated in manga.
Of course, I'm not saying much about all Korean manga and Chinese manga. Some of them have established original art styles. For example lookism, Viral Hit, Viral Hit. Solo leveling? No, it shouldn't be called manhwa. This is because the original is a light novel, and the Korean manga is drawn by Koreans, but the manga was originally drawn in Japan, and the way of drawing and expression is manga.
Favorites Manhwa : Solo Leveling , The Beginning After The End & Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint Favorite Manga : One Piece Awesome Video keep the good work up !
I don’t know about any of y’all, but my favorite current manhwa is World’s Apocalypse Online! I’m concurrently reading it along with the online novel series, and holy shit it is good. It’s a bit hard to watch the manhwa go through some writing style changes, like how we see how the main character died, before he goes back in time to stop the apocalypses, even though in the book we learn more as time passes about his past as he lives through it. Not to mention that his death is the most dramatic part of his back story that only reaches full impact once you’ve actually bonded with the character. So yeah, not a fan of that choice. In the book, the death scene felt almost magical for reasons I won’t spoil, but in the manhwa, it’s kinda shoved in there. I would recommend you read the book in my opinion, because I think leaving it up to the imagination in the first place is better, but I think that reading both is also a good idea.
i love how i never noticed the background music until he made a mistake and then the music stopped and then casually started playing after he finished correcting himself lol
Maybe I've been used to manga since kindergarten, then I enjoy it to this day, from stories intended for children to adults. The manga I've always liked the most are GTO, Aegis In the Dark, and Vinland Saga. I enjoy these manga starting from the physical comic form.
Webtoon has been gaining more favor from me lately the I read most of my comics on my phone so the format is way better than manga super string by boichi is amazing but for physical books there is no beating japanese manga for me I love the rough feeling of the pages and flipping the page to find the dumbest gag in gintama nothing better than reading a volume of gintama while eating a bagel with glass of strawberry milk
Linguistically speaking, Manga, Manhwa and Manhua are cognates (they have the same etymology). I don't know how Chinese and Koreans call Manga, but they probably call them respectively Manhua and Manhwa. Manhwa and Manhua are called Manga in Japan. They are all also called Comic in Japan. IOW, the Japanese don't use different words to separate the origin of the work. If they need to, they'll just say something like "Korean Manga".
Hi, I would like to know a few things; Firstly, which sect between the Manhwa industry and the Manga industry are more accommodating to foreigners and their work?( I'm an African ). Secondly, how do you chose the location of your story based on a place you have never been to and work it? Lastly, Based on your experience, are light novels more or less appealing to the fan base?
As far as Isekai go, I think the reason they flourish so well is because they target a different experience than good manga. The stories are kept simple and generic in order to be as easy as possible to read so that the reader can read 20 at a time while not paying attention and still understand whats going on. It also makes them easy to get into; one glance at the title and you can tell whether or not you will like the isekai. Whereas with a high effort manga, getting lost in a complicated plot, or not being as emotionally invested as the author intends can ruin the experience, and so requires a matching amount of attention from the reader. The cheap, mass produced quality of isekai give it some good traits as well.
Does anyone know if I should read the solo leveling light novel or manhwa first? I’d really like to see what it’s all about but it’s very u clear what most people enjoy
I've read both, there's not really much of a difference in my opinion but the story has a lot of characters, so I personally would reccomed comics first since they are a lot more easy to process, while solo leveling LNs are slightly more detailed in areas. So it's better for later context. Both are super fun to read though!
I read the manhwa first. It was the first material that i decided to try reading its other material as well. It was that good FOR ME. Despite already getting the gist of the story, the novel was interesting as well. Though the writing style was a bit of … i very much still enjoyed it. Lots of scenes were not covered by the manhwa sooo more stuff to discover.
My Korean romance manhwa recommendation -the fantasie of a stepmother(10/10) -the villainess reverses the hourglass(8/10) -your throne(9/10) -who made me a princess(9/10) -the taming of tyrant(10/10) -mother's contract marrage(9/10)
My favourite manhwa is there are no demon Death’s game I liked the drama more than the manhwa Rotten Actually I am new fan of manhwa lol 😅 Manga One piece Demon slayer One punch man Hunter x hunter Attack on titan Jojo Naruto
read tower of god if u like one piece u will like this too let me tell u this has a better world building than one piece unlike other show which have common classes like swordsmen , mage and healer tog has different battle class like fishermen, light bearer, spear bearer, scout and wave controller dose have its own power system shinshu which is unique on its own even different weapons like a fuckin fishing rod and a needle instead of a sword or katana and even inventories are used as a weapon and many more tog has a different setting it is a modern like ours but its more advance there are different races and each floor is like its own new world and from your manga list u must be a shonen fan i guess u watched the anime on the list u mention because all of them have gotten an adaptation and no way u read demon slayer before its anime came out it was on the verge of cancellation well it is a mid manga so ufotable saved it but u should read seinen too some like beserk ( highest rated manga on mal), vagabond , vinland saga ( u can watch the anime too it has 2 seasons each 24 ep), tokyo ghoul ( anime and manga are different anime followed a original path which made it worse), 20th century boys and monster( monster has an anime but its a bit long 74 ep but its all covered up it will be a slow pace since it covers every single thing from the manga) and finally chainsaw man
Hello Brandon! I am from India and I am looking for tips on how to get started as an author. I have been working on my story but it would mean nothing if it can't reach the audience. So could you give me a bit of guidance there...??
Welll this is my perspective but almost manhwa always have same artstyle and almost have the same story and development, almost manhwa always follow solo leveling, and i still doesn't understand why people more like solo leveling rather than omniscient reader or tower of god cuz in my opinion, these 2 manhwa have a better plot and story than solo leveling
From what I observed Most korean mc's have a bad personality, edgy a-holes who picks fights everywhere they go. Also why is bullying so prevalent on those comics, I'm scared to go to korea because of the juvenile delinquints portrayed on those highschool manhuas. So I'm more afraid than angry with how cruel it got so I'll cross korea of my travel-list While the japanese one are generic goody two-shoes with no backbone While the Chinese novel's, seriously almost everyone is on a powertrip that I can't even understand the story because I got lost with how they emphasize their moves and techniques than the plot like you literally could write a wholeass chapter for that one attack move like the heavenly demon crushing palm or something Oh and don't forget the iconic your courting death! Line everubody knows about.😂 But.. Doesn't mean I hate all of them, I still watch them regardless of their flaws, after all that what's make those mc's human. Also, I just hope they'll either they'll do it moderation or back it up with a good story Overall, I have a love and hate relationship with some of them, they're also most that I watch with guilty-pleasure. And I'm sorry of I sound like a jerk for only mentioning the flaws. Of course it has it's perfect moments. Regardless of the flaws I mentioned, I still love it.
Webtoon is rather anime-wannabe comics in essence than just comics. I don't think anime-wannabe comics is the future of comics. The reason why manga doesn't do/won't do as webtoon is doing is simply that manga doesn't need to become like anime.
Yea idk y the koreans are addicted to creating manhwa that potrays bullying and alll the characters are handsome and beautiful and similar in look... I dont even find any expressions and character development much in there work... THIS IS MY OPINION can be different for others
I disagree with the expressions and charcter development compliant. But I would say that manwha has been being produced at a slow rate throughout its time relative to manga. So when you think of manwhas that have those expressions and character developments you can't list of that many because the amount of manwha isn't that large. But in manga there are a lot of examples because there's a larger pool to pull from. For the similar in look comment I would say when an artist is making characters they tend to have the same art style throughout the process so yeah but also manga tends to be more fictitious than manwha so they go more wacky with the charcter designs but like manwha have the same art style. For the bullying and all the characters looking handsame point I would say these are just elements that are used a lot and the same point could be made to manga like why do they always have a lot of isekai stories. These are just common tropes.
I'm kinda sick of that too. That's why I don't bother reading them.
Read lookism💀
@@ProxieDaGoat he's right
I agree, and the characters actually look Korean. Even when they have blonde hair, like Sangwoo, you can tell by the attention to facial details that he's still Asian. So it's assumed that his hair is simply dyed blonde. Compare this to how Japanese people draw Asians, and they make the eyes ridiculously big, as Koreans keep the eyes smaller, usually. The artstyles feel very different.
韓国の漫画も好きですが、やはり日本の漫画の方が私は好みです。韓国の漫画は多くが、主人公がいじめられている、またはとても弱い、という状況から始まっている気がします。それに伏線や、ストーリーの意外性もあまり見受けられない。しかし絵はとても綺麗で、ソロレベリングはとても好きです。
私も、私もソロレベリングが大好きですが、他のいくつかの韓国のウェブトゥーンはより良いストーリーを持っています。
Manga prioritizes storytelling and work efficiency over color. Color is added when manga is animated. The relationship between manga and anime is very great. And the character designs are excellent and unique, making them well-suited for merchandising.
On the other hand, manhwa's content is shallow and repetitive, resulting in quick forgetfulness. It is like junk food. The character designs are all similar and not catchy. Consequently, creating a masterpiece that remains beloved for many years would be very difficult for manhwa.
But sadly that is the world trend. Something short, shallow, less or no development but...
Gives temporary but high amusement. Just like CZcams shorts.
@@KimDaniel1035 Why did Attack on Titan become a hit? Are shorter and shallow movies preferred?
People continue to seek deep stories.
There needs to be a dragon ball of manhwa, the manhwa that changes the industry and inspires other manhwa artists
@@stavrosboi I think there most likely won't be one that "Changes the Industry" as it is going on now and most likely their niche is these short shallow easy to pump out flash comics that could very much in the near future be entirely created using AI to generate the art and then someone adds speech bubbles to it.
Even the shallow and repetitive nature of Korean comics is copied from Japanese trend, narou-kei, amateuristic stuff.
Webtoons can be accepted as a new form, but manga has a far different depth of history, and it is too arrogant to say that it has surpassed it. Webtoons have the advantage of being easy to read because they are on smartphones, but because they are easy to read, they are mainly descriptive and have little dialogue, which makes it difficult to feel the depth of the story and the emotions of the characters.Even if a work becomes popular temporarily, it is unlikely to produce works that will be passed down to future generations as manga have been.
ベルセルクなしでは日本の漫画は語れません
Call me weird, but i really have problems with colored mangas/manhwas whatever. I'm so used to bw, anything else just feels... wrong. Whenever i see the first page of a new manga being colored, i can't wait for it to turn bw... i mean, it's not so bad that i'd say i wouldn't read a manga that's colored although story and characters are top, but i reeeally prefer bw. And yes, i know that Manhwas used to be bw, i read the comments, don't worry, but that doesn't change the fact, that most Manhwas i started were colored and call me superficial, but the reason i stopped reading them was they being colored almost everytime
I have this sort of problem with reading manhwa, not my type and I've sworn never to mess with reading them 😂😂
I have trouble identifying what’s happening in manga panels because everything is b&w. Manhwa is just so much easier to read.
The only manhwa I didn't have a problem while reading is solo leveling
Opposite for me but it's probably a boomer/zoomer thing for color vs BW. It's probably the same dynamic with manga panels fit for physicals vs manhwas being fit for vertical scrolling on tablets.
Yeah the only series that looks good with color is Jojo imo.
But some cover art looks good with color tho.
Manga is better
Preach 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
I love this type of content, I've always been interested in professionals diving into The process of how different types of mediums are made. I also hope you write more manga some day.
One thing I would like foreign readers of manga not to misunderstand is that coloring in manga is also done in Japan😢
It's just hazy because many famous manga such as One Piece and jjk are in black and white.
I still don't know how manhwa be drawn and colored that good in just a week, really want to see a behind the scenes of the artists
I like manga way more
I love Webtoon for sure.
I read manhwa a lot more than manga, but respectively, my favorites are “The Boxer” and “Spy x Family”
The Reason i prefer Manga over Manhwa is because Manhwa is that most of the stories are Repetitive there is always this weak protagonist who looks scrawny and gets bullied and becomes stronger or there is always this guy who gets reincarnated in another world and is already op like most isekai manga Ln and anime's out there and most character's always looks handsome and beautiful and most of the side villains this ugly fat dude or this ugly gorilla dude and the protagonist will always be this handsome always saves the day dude and the villains are always like this handsome edgy dude that kinda gives that sasuke vibe and most Manhwa's are not unique and not just the story but the characters and the art too not gonna lie the art is great but the art is not unique its not the same the only manhwa art i find unique is The Boxer and in Manhwa Characters are very badly developed and like most of the development goes to the main character while there are some manhwa that try to avoid this such as Study Group which one of my favorite manhwa's by the way and most manhwa's story is very mid it's not unexpected and like most of the time you can probably what's gonna happen on the next page or the next chapters especially if you read many manhwa's
Manga on the other hand
Still does has some these flaws
But in terms of Storytelling Characters and Development Manga always takes The Spot
Manga art also starts to change over the course of time and not staying with the generic anime style art my most favorite art style in Manga is Berserk Vagabond and Jojo and The Crazy thing is Manga doesn't need Color to look good but if you put color in it especially if it's digital Manga will look 100x better than most Manhwa's if you don't believe then take a look at it online it's because of the detailing that makes them look good that make them feel more alive and not just Picture's That are drawn on each panel. There are also some Manga That doesn't work when it has color example of this is Berserk And Vagabond Berserk Always has this dark aura in it and because of that when you put color in it looking at it doesn't feel quite right that's why for me it doesn't work. Vagabond always has this Edo Period feeling that's because the story takes place in The Edo Period that's Vagabond with no Color works more becuz it keeps that feeling though im not saying that these manga's look bad when they have color it just takes away something important from them probably one of the reasons why even today Berserk still doesn't have a proper Anime adaptation
I have recently started reading manwa and yes you are 100% correct on your opinion and I agree that mangas are better but that just depends on the manga and manwa or the stereotype. I grew up watching anime so i also think mangas are better but that's just my biased opinion but your opinion is so researched based 😂
Manhwa has more female readers, wonder why
@@ericsohn5084 it has more female protagonists. But ironically, I've seen more female manga readers than male manga readers.
Try the The Horizon, The Boxer, Like Mother Like Daughter, Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint and all Carnby Kim’s works
I tried honestly they are average or below average than manga so I quit those after some chapters. They couldn't attract me to read more like lair game, uzumaki, death note,Naruto, dragon ball, jujitsu kisen,tomiiee, and many more.so I think magans are best.@@JVision1
Personally i dont mind manwha though it seems to sacrifice story for "art", in some i have seen they will have just one or two large frames per page thus making one volume a single conversation where as manga tends to balance things out better.
Abit annoyed by the jab at Isekai when most manwha fantasy titles are inherently Isekai while also have a 50% chance of being a korean version of an isekai manga that came out the year before.
Also it did not surprise me when stated they asset flip images cause I'll be honest it seems all manwha share the exact same art style in my pov where as manga varies heavily in terms not only the artist but the theme, story, character and their context: example being one punch man can switch at a whim from looking poorly drawn to chibi then Hyper realistic.
Not knocking on Manwha some are good, though there are alot of titles that are not.
Off topic, but I have something to say about Chinese Manhua
For Taiwan (and Hong Kong): the Manhua is like manga where is Right to left.
Meanwhile China: the manhua is like western comics and Korean Manhwa where it’s left to right.
Just saying.
I’m currently reading 50+ active webtoons rn. Most of which are manhwa. The gems out of them that I get the most excited for are Teenage Mercenary, Jungle Juice, Omniscient reader, Return of the Blossoming blade, Lookism (which just had an anime adaptation announced),and The Ember Knight
Manga >>>>>>>>>>> Manhwa
Manga = OhTaku
Manhwa = mania
느금마
most manhwa are like western cartoon and comic, it's really enjoyable but you get nothing but lose your time at the end of the day.all I get is
"you need to be handsome and strong to beat the shit out of other people, don't love and care except yourself and your family"
Solo leveling 😜
Solo levelling overrated@@_Damian_5
talk about an exact opposite of the MC from Accel World
In manhwa, there is no suffering at all after the main character gets out of the worst situation, and I get tired of it after a few months.
In this respect, I can watch T.jun's works without getting tired of them.
Weak boy reincarnated as the strongest prince 😂
My favorite manhwa is tower of god, sweet home
My favorite manga (don't bully me bro) Kubo wont let me be invincible, chainsaw man, my dress up darling, and jujutsu kaisen
Keeping aside story, characters etc. Never been a fan of manhwa's vertical reading format, reason i love reading manga is that it doesn't feel like i'm reading just some comic, it feels more like a piece of literature with some philosophical takes by authors in their own way, also who wouldn't love to have a shelf full of manga collection.....
Obviously a good story isn't entitled to it's medium, and in this digital era i understand why more and more authors are switching to web-comics/webtoons, i can't really explain but manga really has a different feel to it, those black n' white pages, traditional paneling just always works everytime for me......
I definitely feel that. That's why Some of the most cherished stories that I've written are in the manga format, But that's probably because I grew up reading more manga than webtoons😅
I heavily disagree. But sure
Than what about the physical black and white manhwas?
im currently enjoying Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint which I believe is Manwha.
It is
Fav Manhwa- +99 Reinforced Wooden Stick, Yumi's Cells, Principal's Livestream, Eating Life
A manga written in ai called Cyberpunk Momotaro already came out last year or the year before. The pictures are chaotic and idiosyncratic.
Literally, NO ONE knows the word "Manhwa" and "Manhua" in Japan😂
It's disrespectful to Japan to talk about them in the same breath as plagiarized cartoons like that.
manga focus on writing ,
manhwa focus on drawing.
ye but some manhwa/webtoon has bad art like lookism and has good stories.
Solo Leveling
Tower of God
God of Highschool
These I recommend you should try out
@@ajmorningstar6281stil manga detailing is better character are more realistic while manwah are cartoonish kids drawing with colors even my drawing is better
@@Narshad568 so you don’t think manhwa has great stories and characters?
@@ajmorningstar6281 story weak boy become strongest i reincarnated as the strongest novel 😂😂 cheap isekai genre2
My favorite manhwa is "The Boxer"
Is it a Korean version of baki?
@Mr-pn2eh no, I suck at explaining, but first 9 chapters will define the rest of the story
Manga japan
Manhwa south korea
Manhua China
Truyen Tranh Vietnam
Comic book America
Komiks the Philippines
Can't believe even VN got recognition.
Philippines-Komiks
best comment
Man, it's true that most isekai are shit, but so are most shounen battle manga.
A good writer can take a simple concept and make something amazing out of it.
Some of my favorite series are isekai, like grimgar of fantasy and ash, ascendance of a bookworm and mushoku tensei.
Fav manhwa : Solo leveling, Omnipotent, The begging after the end
Fav manga : Naruto,Bleach,Blue lock
it has an anime
we now
I have a question: Would Korean Animation be called Saeng-Gi or just Korean Anime?
Webtoon
@@pokepork7747 Webtoons are digital manhwas. They’re not animated. As for the OP’s question it’s Korean animation or aeni
Thank you for this info Brandon :')
Thank you for the breakdown of the differences.
think they are similar but the westen manhwa is different for me like every thing the style the story and it’s mostly the same story
But Korean manhwa is very good
I also grow up with manga and anime I love the both they are very amazing❤
Manga >>>> manhaw
@@user-xx4me5yf7j 고아
@@Hamham-6 한국인이였냐 미안하다
ngl manga have the best artstyle for example: i've readed a manhwa that have torturing in there but it looks very bland for some reason meanwhile torture in manga looks 100x better manga is black and white thats why i like it meanwhile i feel like most of the manwha have the same artstyle idk, manga just hit different than manhwa
100% agreed the hatching shading and hitch hatch really shows the vibe
Is there a way if you can tell if the comic you’re making is more western manga or Manhwa? Back in the day my comic was pretty much just me working on it doing the line art the coloring the word bubbles, the stories and the character designs. But when I submitted my finished comic to my semi mentor Ben Dunn, which him and his brother founded Antarctic press, he said that my art style needed some more work but I was definitely in the right direction and he loved my story. So that prompted me to get an artist to do the line art and I do the rest like designing the characters doing the story plots, and design the page layouts. I ended up getting this really awesome artist from Thailand named Panu Leeluesai, which from what I know he has been working in the manga industry for at least 10 years definitely more than that. But with my comic I actually color it and of course do the word bubbles do the character designs and page mockups.
My comic style I considered to be more western manga because it’s still in the page format but I color it. So the only difference that I have between my “western manga” style to the more Korean Manhwa is how it’s formatted. As you said the Korean style comics are formatted to be more like Websoon’s scrolling format with one panel over the other going downwards. But my comic is formatted more like a traditional western comic by pages and going left to right. So is coloring the pages making it more of a Manhwa style comic or can I still consider it “western manga“?
comics, manga, manhwa
Me: i like them all
Favorite manga: killing stalking
I'm ready to get bashed
Bruh u mad
@@austux731 That’s a manhwa
@@JVision1 doesnt matter tbh
Manga made in Korea and China should not be called manhwa or manhua. Because the art style of those characters is almost the same as in Japan. Especially how to write those eyes, manpu(漫符), how to express scenes, and story composition. They should be called Korean manga, Chinese manga.
In addition, color manga and vertical reading manga have been widely used in Japan for more than 10 years.
ok, folks, I'm sure there are people who disagree with my opinion. But especially look at the manpu and eye drawing, the manpu and eye drawing used in them all originated in manga.
Of course, I'm not saying much about all Korean manga and Chinese manga. Some of them have established original art styles. For example lookism, Viral Hit, Viral Hit. Solo leveling? No, it shouldn't be called manhwa. This is because the original is a light novel, and the Korean manga is drawn by Koreans, but the manga was originally drawn in Japan, and the way of drawing and expression is manga.
For example, Italians would look down on me if I called spaghetti made in Indonesia "spageti".
@@notreally488 nobody cares what its called
you mean jpop should be called Japanese Kpop.
Favorites Manhwa : Solo Leveling , The Beginning After The End & Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint
Favorite Manga : One Piece
Awesome Video keep the good work up !
I have that mic. I had to check to make sure mine was still there. Lol. But good video man.
the loud music is kinda distracting, there are words I can't understood right away.
Favorite Manga: Steel Ball Run
Favorite Manhwa: The Boxer
Manga :1902s
Comic:1930s
Manhwa:1920s
Manhua:1928s
Can any of those beat berserk?
no
Pls, Berserk can't be even compared to others manga
Lol
bro even manga these days can't reach the choes of berserk vagabond and vinland saga
Absolutely
NOT!!!!!!!!!!!
Winner MANGA
I don’t know about any of y’all, but my favorite current manhwa is World’s Apocalypse Online! I’m concurrently reading it along with the online novel series, and holy shit it is good. It’s a bit hard to watch the manhwa go through some writing style changes, like how we see how the main character died, before he goes back in time to stop the apocalypses, even though in the book we learn more as time passes about his past as he lives through it. Not to mention that his death is the most dramatic part of his back story that only reaches full impact once you’ve actually bonded with the character. So yeah, not a fan of that choice. In the book, the death scene felt almost magical for reasons I won’t spoil, but in the manhwa, it’s kinda shoved in there. I would recommend you read the book in my opinion, because I think leaving it up to the imagination in the first place is better, but I think that reading both is also a good idea.
Man, the hate on isekai…
Deserved hate
Favorite Manga: Black Cat
Favorite Manhwa: Rise of the Sword King: Latna Saga
i love how i never noticed the background music until he made a mistake and then the music stopped and then casually started playing after he finished correcting himself lol
Maybe I've been used to manga since kindergarten, then I enjoy it to this day, from stories intended for children to adults. The manga I've always liked the most are GTO, Aegis In the Dark, and Vinland Saga. I enjoy these manga starting from the physical comic form.
I love the boy that got reborn as an OP vending machine. It hilarious. I'm living in the Vending machine capitol of the world, Japan.
2023 Manga beat Manhwa EASY
Webtoon has been gaining more favor from me lately the I read most of my comics on my phone so the format is way better than manga super string by boichi is amazing but for physical books there is no beating japanese manga for me I love the rough feeling of the pages and flipping the page to find the dumbest gag in gintama nothing better than reading a volume of gintama while eating a bagel with glass of strawberry milk
Manhwa needs a dragon ball, a manhwa that changes the industry and gives influence to future manhwa
Solo leveling
@@anda2736 it's not💀, solo leveling is just a power fantasy about a weak nerd who became strong suddenly, no training arcs and stale characters
@@stavrosboi that sounds suspiciously Isekai...
Dragon Ball, One Piece, and Naruto roared around the world because there was no Internet and little entertainment
@@stavrosboi What are you talking about? He does train
I'd say that the Gamer pioneered the system levelling style that Solo Leveling fits into.
Linguistically speaking, Manga, Manhwa and Manhua are cognates (they have the same etymology). I don't know how Chinese and Koreans call Manga, but they probably call them respectively Manhua and Manhwa. Manhwa and Manhua are called Manga in Japan. They are all also called Comic in Japan. IOW, the Japanese don't use different words to separate the origin of the work. If they need to, they'll just say something like "Korean Manga".
can we get a day in the life, like full vid?
Now we need the Difference between Japanese Anime and Korean Aeni!
Good video but bro what's wrong with the volume ? Is too high and stressful 😖
Favorite Manhwa: Eleceed, God of High School, Tower of God, Legend of the northern blade
Favorite Manga: Baki, OPM, JJK
Hi, I would like to know a few things;
Firstly, which sect between the Manhwa industry and the Manga industry are more accommodating to foreigners and their work?( I'm an African ).
Secondly, how do you chose the location of your story based on a place you have never been to and work it?
Lastly, Based on your experience, are light novels more or less appealing to the fan base?
this guy really said "theres a few gems in manga" and then listed some of the most mainstream series 😭
The difference is.... I'm not mid 😐
( haha. I'm just messing around ) 😅
Definitely korean manhwa is mid
@@zishiiff7246 Try the The Horizon, The Boxer, Like Mother Like Daughter, Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint and all Carnby Kim’s works
As far as Isekai go, I think the reason they flourish so well is because they target a different experience than good manga. The stories are kept simple and generic in order to be as easy as possible to read so that the reader can read 20 at a time while not paying attention and still understand whats going on. It also makes them easy to get into; one glance at the title and you can tell whether or not you will like the isekai. Whereas with a high effort manga, getting lost in a complicated plot, or not being as emotionally invested as the author intends can ruin the experience, and so requires a matching amount of attention from the reader. The cheap, mass produced quality of isekai give it some good traits as well.
Fav mangas:
Jjba
Sailor moon
Fav manwha:
True beauty
The fox club
Does anyone know if I should read the solo leveling light novel or manhwa first? I’d really like to see what it’s all about but it’s very u clear what most people enjoy
I've read both, there's not really much of a difference in my opinion but the story has a lot of characters, so I personally would reccomed comics first since they are a lot more easy to process, while solo leveling LNs are slightly more detailed in areas. So it's better for later context. Both are super fun to read though!
I read the manhwa first. It was the first material that i decided to try reading its other material as well. It was that good FOR ME. Despite already getting the gist of the story, the novel was interesting as well. Though the writing style was a bit of … i very much still enjoyed it. Lots of scenes were not covered by the manhwa sooo more stuff to discover.
@@intothedarkabyss8128 ooohhhh thank you!
Omniscient reader 🥰
How do I find a artist that wants to work with me
I like manhwa
way more
This is spitting fax about isekai anime, like I swear to God I have sean 10 iseakai that follow the same shit every time 😅😂😂
Hey bro how did you pay to your first artist
鋼の錬金術師、HUNTER×HUNTER、ジョジョ、ナルト、ワンピース、進撃の巨人、ドラゴンボール、チェンソーマン、デスノート、コナン、銀魂
日本の漫画は最高
あ、これ元々日本人の為に作られた作品だから自分の肌に合わなかったら無理して読まなくて良いよ
韓国のmanhwa？が好きな人はそっち読んでくれw
いちいち煽ると幼稚に見えるからそういうコメいらんよ。
大人になろう
@@user-lf2ou5ih8g
そういう君は他人の目気にして生きづらそうだねw
@@stzk2 i see so japanese people also fight like american anime/manga fans
ブォンジュール
My Korean romance manhwa recommendation
-the fantasie of a stepmother(10/10)
-the villainess reverses the hourglass(8/10)
-your throne(9/10)
-who made me a princess(9/10)
-the taming of tyrant(10/10)
-mother's contract marrage(9/10)
Can manhwa be black and white?
Yes, Manhwa was originally b/w similar to japanese manga. It is now more associated with the digital and vertical format because of webtoons
My favourite manhwa is there are no demon
Death’s game I liked the drama more than the manhwa
Rotten
Actually I am new fan of manhwa lol 😅
Manga
One piece
Demon slayer
One punch man
Hunter x hunter
Attack on titan
Jojo
Naruto
read tower of god if u like one piece u will like this too let me tell u this has a better world building than one piece unlike other show which have common classes like swordsmen , mage and healer tog has different battle class like fishermen, light bearer, spear bearer, scout and wave controller dose have its own power system shinshu which is unique on its own even different weapons like a fuckin fishing rod and a needle instead of a sword or katana and even inventories are used as a weapon and many more tog has a different setting it is a modern like ours but its more advance there are different races and each floor is like its own new world and from your manga list u must be a shonen fan i guess u watched the anime on the list u mention because all of them have gotten an adaptation and no way u read demon slayer before its anime came out it was on the verge of cancellation well it is a mid manga so ufotable saved it but u should read seinen too some like beserk ( highest rated manga on mal), vagabond , vinland saga ( u can watch the anime too it has 2 seasons each 24 ep), tokyo ghoul ( anime and manga are different anime followed a original path which made it worse), 20th century boys and monster( monster has an anime but its a bit long 74 ep but its all covered up it will be a slow pace since it covers every single thing from the manga) and finally chainsaw man
Hello Brandon! I am from India and I am looking for tips on how to get started as an author. I have been working on my story but it would mean nothing if it can't reach the audience. So could you give me a bit of guidance there...??
The Breaker
Blue lock baby
So many weebs here bruh 💀
@@sh-qz5oh weeb detected😭😭
Welll this is my perspective but almost manhwa always have same artstyle and almost have the same story and development, almost manhwa always follow solo leveling, and i still doesn't understand why people more like solo leveling rather than omniscient reader or tower of god cuz in my opinion, these 2 manhwa have a better plot and story than solo leveling
Manhwa, all the way. It started with Anime, branched into mangas, and then found manhwas.
Anyone know the title at 8:17 and 8:21?
For 8:21, it's A Returners Magic Should Be Special. It's really good.
For 8:17 it's "Reformation of the Dead Beat Noble"
Oh yeah... There's another title:
"The Lazy Lord Masters of the Sword"
Favorite manhwa: limit breaker
Favorite manga: One Punch man
From what I observed
Most korean mc's have a bad personality, edgy a-holes who picks fights everywhere they go.
Also why is bullying so prevalent on those comics, I'm scared to go to korea because of the juvenile delinquints portrayed on those highschool manhuas. So I'm more afraid than angry with how cruel it got so I'll cross korea of my travel-list
While the japanese one are generic goody two-shoes with no backbone
While the Chinese novel's, seriously almost everyone is on a powertrip that I can't even understand the story because I got lost with how they emphasize their moves and techniques than the plot like you literally could write a wholeass chapter for that one attack move like the heavenly demon crushing palm or something
Oh and don't forget the iconic your courting death! Line everubody knows about.😂
But..
Doesn't mean I hate all of them, I still watch them regardless of their flaws, after all that what's make those mc's human. Also, I just hope they'll either they'll do it moderation or back it up with a good story
Overall, I have a love and hate relationship with some of them, they're also most that I watch with guilty-pleasure. And I'm sorry of I sound like a jerk for only mentioning the flaws. Of course it has it's perfect moments. Regardless of the flaws I mentioned, I still love it.
Sweet.
You made GodGame!!! That's my favorite manga!!!!!
Logging 10000 Years into the Future (Apex Future Martial Arts) current favorite
it's a chinese manhua but yeah it's peak
you should try top tier providence cultivating for 10000 years or something like that
Vanbon always hearts
One Piece
Because they don't announce their attacks like lames
"That's a lot of men" #Men 🤤❤️
Ich mag beide manga und manhwa 🤩🥰🥳🙊🙃
hardcore leveling
Shadows house
Me likey
Me likey
The webtoon format is the future of the comics no matter it is japanese not Korean, we all be reading comics on the phone
In piracy...
@@TheBlueboy7777 absolutely
People read manga on their phone
I don't think the webtoon format will produce a masterpiece like the Japanese one.
Webtoon is rather anime-wannabe comics in essence than just comics.
I don't think anime-wannabe comics is the future of comics.
The reason why manga doesn't do/won't do as webtoon is doing is simply that manga doesn't need to become like anime.
i prefer chinese manhua
fire force manga is my fave and goh manhwa
Does unordinary count as manhwa because that's my fav but if not god of highschool is my fav manhwa
My fav manga is naruto